In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Shrek, God of Ogres (Love, Life), as an Intermediate God under Fantastic Races (House of Otherness).
- Donkey, God of Second-Rate Equines as an Demigod under Ungulates (House of Beast).
- Lord Farquaad, The God Who's Compensating for Something as a Quasideity under Body Images (House of Personal Appearance).
- Princess Fiona, The Goddess Who Proves That True Love Is Exceptional as a Lesser Goddess under Romance (House of Love).
- Puss in Boots, God of Beguiling Stares as a Lesser God under Eye Abilities (House of Personal Appearance).
- The Fairy Godmother, Goddess of Evil Fairy Godmothers (Dama Fortuna) as an Intermediate Goddess under Fairies (House of Otherness).