Big things are happening on TV Tropes! New admins, new designs, fewer ads, mobile versions, beta testing opportunities, thematic discovery engine, fun trope tools and toys, and much more - Learn how to help here and discuss here.
Tetsuya Tsurugi from Mazinger Z and Great Mazinger is serious, grim-looking and moody, and he seldom smiles. So when he grins, everyone freaks out and dons Oh, Crap stares. Mainly Warrior Monsters, since it usually means they are about to die horribly and painfully.
Mark Ibaraki from 7 Seeds is usually very upbeat, friendly and goofy, with a constant smile on his face. When that smile disappears off his face? You know things are looking really, really bad.
Inverted with Death — if he starts acting in character, you know you're in some serious shit. He does occasionally put on his old scary voice just to scare his staff into paying attention, and is even more likely to treat the most dire of circumstances (Asura's resurrection, Kid's abduction) casually, even jokingly.
Also played straight: if Black☆Star is not yelling and Death The Kid is not OCD'ing over symmetry, prepare for an asskicking. Kid's an interesting example because the occasions he faces disorder and doesn't have a fit over it tend to be when he instead fixes on another inherent characteristic, that of him being a Shinigami (e.g Mosquito, minor point in his second fight with Black☆Star).
A weird two-in-one example; Crona's OOCness has different meanings depending on what side they're on. When evil, if Crona stops rambling like a lunatic then it's time to run. When good, Crona dropping their usual gloominess means that they're about to kick some serious butt. A possible third in the penultimate chapter of the manga. There, Crona calmly considers what has happened, what 'fear' is and what they can do about it and Asura. No fighting, no evil influence from Medusa. Just Crona. And it is awesome.
Shunsui (or Syunsui) Kyoraku never loses his temper, and his general demeanor never really elevates beyond "mildly concerned"—even when fighting his mentor who is implied to be thousands of years older than he is. However, when his Heterosexual Life Partner Ukitake appeared to have been killed, he lost it. For extra emphasis, even in the context of that story arc, his reaction was pretty extreme.
Chizuru Honshou is the local Genki Girl and Plucky Comic Relief. She has only cried twice in canon,: the first happened when she and others were subjected to Body Horror and forced to attack Tatsuki and Orihime thanks to Numb Chandelier, and the other was during her Heroic BSOD when Aizen was chasing her, Tatsuki, Keigo, Mizuiro and Mahana through Karakura Town.
When Ichigo decides to murder Tsukishima (despite never having killed anything other than hollows at this point) on the off chance it will reverse his Fullbring's effect on his friends and family, you know he's pissed.
The usually cool-headed Byakuya completely loses his composure when As Nodt steals his bankai, therefore proving how utterly screwed the Shinigami are.
This is more because of his enemy's fear power.
Much earlier on, on June 16, Ichigo begins acting oddly friendly to his classmates, and Orihime immediately picks up on the change, impressing her best friend and Ichigo's long-time friend Tatsuki, who took three years to figure it out. It's because it's the day before the anniversary of Ichigo's mother's death, which he blames himself for.
In an episode of Samurai Pizza Cats, space-cadet Emperor Fred (who normally communicates by saying "Fuh-red!" and scat-singing) catches a nasty cold, and apparently upgrades from The Unintelligible to Talkative Loon ("This is to certify that kung pao chicken containing MSG may cause your BMW to have a headache...") This leads Al Dente to conclude that the emperor is very sick.
Pippin, the Gentle Giant of the Band of the Hawks in Berserk, never speaks and is never seen with eyes open. He only opens his eyes and speaks for the first (and last) time when the world goes to hell around him during the Eclipse.
One episode of the Ranma ½ anime has Happōsai, the resident Dirty Old Man, acting extremely despondantly and unlike himself. It culminates when Female!Ranma is forced by the fathers to put on a swimsuit and give the Old Master a show in order to raise his spirits... and he just tells her to Please Put Some Clothes On. At this point, everybody know there's something very wrong with Happōsai.
Trigun. Vash's reaction to Monev the Gale's wholesale slaughter of a small town in the anime is a definite example of this. Vash is usually a goofball and kind to the point of preferring to be injured himself rather than hurt anyone else, even when people are actively trying to kill him, but after seeing what happened to the town he puts a gun to Monev's head gets this close to just blowing his head off.
In One Piece, as a result of massive Despair Event Horizon, Luffy becomes so depressed that he admits his own weakness and renounces his worthiness for the title of the Pirate King.
Played for Laughs in an earlier moment, when Nami gave treasure to Lola. Luffy and Usopp were shocked, and actually shouted "A STORM IS COMING !" !
Arguably any time that Luffy stops joking around and being a total moron it's clear that shit is about to go down.
It is actually applied for every member of the Straw Hat AND the Straw Hat crew as a whole. They are usually very goofy and would get into fighting with each other for very silly reasons. But if you manage to make them stop fooling around, you know a lot of shits are coming down on you.
At one point in the Alabasta arc, Vivi says three words to Crocodile: "I'll Kill You!". Mind you, this is coming from a young princess who is such a Nice Girl that she can't stand the idea of a single person dying in a war.
Luffy actually uses this on purpose to relay a secret message to his crew after they've been separated to meet up in Sabaody after two years.
Corazon is thought to be mute by everyone, including his own brother. Which makes it so surprising when he finally talks to tell Law that he needs to get away from Doflamingo.
When Luffy points out the very harsh, but necessary truth that it's naïve to hope that all people involved in a war will survive, Nami gets angry at Luffy for being so blunt and not considering Vivi's feelings. It's extremely telling that Sanji is the one to tell Nami to shut up and not cut off Luffy. Usually, he would never show agreement with his male crewmates if he can please his female crewmates instead, but in this situation he apparently agreed with Luffy so much that he forgot his principles.
In Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle, it's clear that Fay's mental state has taken a turn for the worse not because he grows his hair out after losing his eye and takes on a generally more gloomy disposition, but it's because he drops the cutesy nicknames and actually calls Kurogane by his name. Later on when he starts using them again it's a huge relief to everyone since it indicates that he's getting better.
In Bakuman。, Hiramaru, infuriated over the reasoning behind putting Detective Trap on hiatus until Mashiro graduates, storms off to work on his manga.
Eiji Nizuma is a manga enthusiast who reads everything in Jump, especially the main characters' work, since they're his rivals. When he says he isn't reading Tanto, it's proof of how strongly he believes that it's inferior to their work and they are not living up to their potential by working on it.
Shinryaku! Ika Musume: Similar to the Bleach and Negima examples — when Chizuru opens her eyes, you're screwed.
Except for the one time she was trying to be friendly instead of intimidating. And it was adorable.
There is just ONE time in which Goku from Dragon Ball refused a meal. When he sensed that his best friend Krillin was in danger and rushed to help him. It was too late: Krillin was already dead.
As for Dragon Ball Z, Vegeta was the Big Bad of the series during the first story arc; one arc later, he breaks down, reveals his dark past, and cries during the Frieza Saga just as Goku arrives to fight Frieza.
Another Vegeta example involves him blowing himself up in order to destroy Majin Buu and save the world, while expressing his love for his wife and son.
Rounding out the trifecta, one of Vegeta's most recognizable character traits is his overwhelming arrogance; even against people who vastly outclass him, and he's aware of it, he tends to enjoy the challenge and trash talk them like none other. Therefore it is a major shock in two of the movies when Vegeta is so terrified of his opponent that he cannot muster the will to fight (against Broly and Beerus), and a sign that these characters are seriously bad news.
The few times Shouma does not attempt to solve problems via words, things have got really bad. Specially the last one.
Similarly, his penguin #2, a Big EaterExtreme Omnivore, only once decided to share his meal with his "sister" #3. She refused it and left him all dejected — a foreshadowing of her and Himari leaving the Takakura family home.
This is a general (but important) plot point in Darker Than Black. Contractors are completely emotionless and self-serving, so when some of them aren't, people always make note of it. Likewise, Dolls are so completely empty that they won't even eat without proper programming. At one point, one uses her specter to call for help, which is about the same as your cell phone calling to tell your friend you're getting mugged.
In the season 1 finale of Code Geass, the typically whimsical Lloyd freaks out when he notices Nina ready to detonate a homemade nuclear bomb. The Black Knights' chief engineer Rakshata immediately calls for a ceasefire because she was college classmates with Lloyd and realizes that if he's scared enough to act serious, it's definitely something to be afraid of.
In Katekyo Hitman Reborn!, Reborn always pushes Tsuna to succeed in any given situation and never gives him a break because he knows that Tsuna has the potential to pull it off. So it's a huge shock to Tsuna when Reborn tells him that he has no chance of defeating the strongest member of the Vindice.
Once in Axis Powers Hetalia, Germany joined Japan on a diet and gave up beer. This leaves various Germans completely stunned and his older brother Prussia is nearly brought to tears out of fear. Of course, this being Hetalia, it's all presented as hilarious.
Random German Guy: ZE VORLD IS COMING TO AN END!!!!
Kyoya Otori is a very cold, calculating, selfish man who never does anything that he can't gain from (at least, nothing that he'll admit to.) So when he blows up in Yuzuru Suou's face near the end of the manga and delivers an angry Reason You Suck Speech to him for forcibly wresting control of the Suou family businesses from Grandmother Suou and dashing Tamaki's hopes of someday reconciling his entire family in the process, despite there being nothing to gain and everything to lose from it, it comes off as a serious Crowning Moment of Awesome for him.
In Sangatsu no Lion, the normally meek Rei eventually becomes irritated over Nikaidou's taped lecture over his MHK Cup loss and is vocal about it as he shouts back at the screen. Someji and Momo's reactions play it off like a joke as they look in amazement and surprise over Rei actually getting angry. However, Hina, in a slightly more serious moment, is happy to see a side of Rei that she never gets to see.
In Bakemonogatari, in Hanekawa's arc, when told that she knows everything, she responds "I don't know everything, I don't know anything." By comparison, her catch phrase is "I don't know everything, I just know what I know."
Played for Laughs in Nisemonogatari. Araragi is so freaked out by seeing his tomboyish little sister Karen wear a skirt that he assumes she was bullied into it.
In the first arc, Rena and Mion or so we're lead to believe act... oddly, prompting Keiichi to become defensive, ignore them outright, and to even carry a weapon around. This in itself triggers a very serious reaction from Mion and Rena, who believe what's happening to him is what happened to Satoshi a year prior- just before he vanished.
When Satoko (aka the Master of Traps) doesn't respond well (or at all) to her friends' playful jokes, it means it's her turn tobreak.
If Rena is serious, it has two possible meanings: she's snapped from Hate Plague and is about to kill (or has already killed) someone, or one of her friends is in serious danger.
If Mion's genkiness goes away for a while, she's either acting more girly (read: impersonating her twin sister) to get closer to Keiichi, or if it's played for horror, it's not her at all; it's Shion instead. And, like Rena above, she becomes very serious when her friends' lives are in danger, or when attending family meetings.
Throughout the Endless Eight arc, Yuki is frequently seen looking mildly bored or sad, which is pretty much the equivalent of a Heroic BSOD for her from being trapped in a "Groundhog Day" Loop for almost 600 years.
In the story "Snow Mountain Syndrome," when the Brigade gets lost on a mountain and finds a mysterious mansion, Yuki is even more listless and detached than normal, not saying a single word to anyone and barely nibbling her food. When pressed, we find out her link to the Data Overmind has been cut, and she has no idea how. So this is her freaking out.
Later during Snow Mountain Syndrome, Yuki actually faints, which shocks Kyon, Koizumi, and Mikuru so much they can't even move to catch her when she falls. Thankfully, Haruhi (who is unaware that Yuki is a Physical God in all but name) isn't quite so stunned, and is there to grab her before she hits the ground.
One good way to check the seriousness of a situation is to check whether or not Koizumi is smiling. There have been two major times his perpetual smile has broken: when Mikuru accidentally began firing actual lasers from her eyes (nearly taking off his head with them), and when Kyon nearly strikes Haruhi in anger when she seriously crosses the line, which Koizumi fortunately steps in to stop.
In the anime, the last one involves two other OOC moments: the usually deadpan Kyon being angry enough to go from snark to physical violence (which he lampshades) and the cheerful and selfish Haruhi being brought to tears.
Mako is typically coolheaded at her most energetic and lethargic and lazy at worst. When she hears about her grandmother collapsing, she becomes especially determined to reach the hospital as soon as possible, even considering swimming an impossible distance if necessary.
Mako, who detests having to get up early and is often shown napping, is said to be losing sleep over her grandmother's condition, since the previously mentioned collapse is not the first one.
Mako typically snarks at Sodoko, calls her by her nickname against her wishes, and displays a calm and stoic personality. When Sodoko deletes all of Mako's tardinesses and absences, ensuring that she will be able to graduate on time Mako lets out a whoop and glomps her.
Katyusha is quite arrogant, and enjoys sitting on the shoulders of Nonna to seem taller than everyone else because of her short height. When she's defeated by Oarai, she gets off Nonna's shoulders and shakes Miho's hand, something she had refused to do earlier, to congratulate them.
In the Little Army prequel manga, Miho, upset by Maho's aloof behavior after admitting to having shot an enemy flag tank when it went to rescue one of hers, questions her mother on whether it was necessary, despite her timidity and unwillingness to call her own mother out. Her mother shrugs this off, but Maho makes note of this and later comes to speak with Miho privately to apologize and tell her to pursue her own style of tankery.
Momo typically alternates between being relatively calm and getting comically angry over things like missing or being called "Momo-chan". On some occasions, though, she seems genuinely upset, such as when the team doesn't care whether or believe they can win, especially considering the school will be shut down if they don't win the tournament.
Miho is generally a polite girl who can't find it in her to say anything bad about other people, even the Jerkasses. When Emi begins saying she hates Miho's sister despite never having gotten to know her, Miho loses her temper and, in her anger, declares she hates Emi. Miho's friends are shocked at how Miho got angry, and Sakuyo notes that it's rare for Miho to get angry.
Anzu is typically a Perpetual Smiler, generally loses the smile under similar circumstances as Momo's own OOC Is Serious Business behavior.
Anzu: (not smiling) Losing is not an option for us...
Yukari: (thinks) The president became serious for once.
After Saunders loses to Oarai, Kay, typically a cheerful Large Ham who likes competition, walks up to Arisa, whose unsportsmanlike intercepting radio transmissions backfired and cost them the match, and tells her in a calm, yet stern tone of voice that they will be discussing what happened, prompting an Oh, Crap reaction from Arisa.
During Urusei Yatsura, Ataru usually has either a goofy look or a perverted look on his face. When he's caught looking serious, things just got real. It's even pointed-out during the Anime itself.
Ling Yao of Fullmetal Alchemist typically has his Eyes Always Shut. When he does open his eyes, it's either because he means business or after about the halfway point, Greed is currently in control of his body.
Related to the above, Eren, is a guy who swore to exterminate every single Titan on the planet because they killed his mother and destroyed his home town, and generally has a world view bordering on Black and White Insanity. Upon learining his friend Annie is a traitor responsible for the deaths of a large number of people including some of his teammates, first reacts with denial. Even after he gathers the resolve to use his special ability, he still shows her a surprising amount of compassion, and seems willing to hear her out. In other words, he simply cannot bring himself to completely dehumanize her like he does any of his other enemies.
×××HOLiC: If Yuuko is wearing something she's has ever worn before, things are getting serious. note And yes, CLAMP designed that many outfits for Yuuko.
In the second season of A Certain Scientific Railgun, after first discovering the Sisters, Mikoto is sufficently rattled that the next morning she fails to punch Kuroko for groping her and pays for something from the evil vending machine instead of kicking or electrocuting it. Kuroko becomes concerned that she may have been replaced by an impostor.
When Mikoto is suffering from a Level 6 Shift attempt, and is destructively mutating into an angel, the extreme Cloudcuckoolander and Idiot Hero Gunha Sogiita starts talking clearly and calmly, and defers to Touma to come up with a plan, since the situation is that serious.
At the end of episode 12 of Servant × Service, the perpetually slacking Yutaka Hasebe comes into the office on Monday and... settles in to work with barely a word. His colleagues are massively creeped out to the point of staging an intervention to find out what's going on with him. Turns out there is some serious business afoot - he's just recently learned that his own father is the civil servant who approved Lucy's Overly Long Name, i.e. the person that the girl he's in love with wants revenge on. And worse, his father's justification for approving such a ridiculous name is that he was distracted because Yutaka was ill with a fever at the time, making Lucy's situation indirectly his fault.
In Saki, Mihoko keeps her right eye constantly shut, since it's a different color from her left one, and she's sensitive about it. When she becomes surprised, she sometimes opens that eye, such as when she played Hisa for the first time three years ago.
In the quarterfinals, an interesting case happens when Hisa's teammates notice that she's not herself. Saki becomes worried when Hisa isn't trying for her "hell waits"- Hisa has a strategy for choosing waits that are unlikely to work, knowing that she's only likely to win with them- while Nodoka, who plays more logically, is happy that Hisa is not playing that way. Mako notices that Hisa was less than confident going into the match, and wonders if she really is alright after seeing her with a suddenly renewed confidence.
In Saki Shinohayu -dawn of age-, Kanna is a short-tempered and fairly abrasive girl. As such, when she declines Kyouka's offer to hang out together with a smile and an apology, Kyouka knows something is amiss; Hayari had hoped to apologize to her friends for upsetting them, but none of them showed up, leading her to think she had driven them away.
Skip Beat! has spent a lot of time developing Ren's (psychotic) Hidden Depths, but mostly from the reader's perspective. In chapter 194 we have a literal out-of-character be Serious Business when he freaks out at Kyoko for a personal matter while they're supposed to be the Heel siblings, and Kyoko is more astonished that he's breaking character while acting than that he's going full-on Bastard Boyfriendpsycho on her. Even though they're alone in a hotel room. And they are not a couple.
His breaking character as 'Tsuruga Ren' and letting suppressed emotions and behaviors like rage appear was used this way at first, but it became enough the norm that it's gone to the next level. Earlier in the course of being Cain Heel he actually lost his temper while rehearsing a fight scene as a psychotic murderer and enjoyed the attempt to kill his co-star much more visibly than the character would, but luckily at that point he was about four cover identities deep, so no one was able to accurately interpret what had just happened. Though some came close, even working with false information.
In a story arc near the end of Anatolia Story, when Urhi fakes holding Nakia hostage to keep everyone from learning about her involvement of the previous king's assassination, he whispers to her that he wishes they could start over where they first met. This initially just seems like him expressing sorrow at missed opportunities, but Nakia is confused over the uncharacteristic sentimentality Urhi is showing. She realizes that it's a hint from him to go back to the pool where they first met. He hid Yuri's present-day clothing there, which she can use to magic Yuri to a different time period.
While Tohru Honda is normally sweet and upbeat to the point of silliness, there are a handful of times when she truly breaks down and shows despair. The first is when she admits to Kyo that she secretly thinks her father was a "bad man", even though she knows he loved her and her mother and took good care of them. A later one would be when Kyo rejects her, causing her to run from the house in sorrow and run into an insane Akito. This is lampshaded at one point by her friend, who says that "hell would freeze over" if Tohru became overcome by sadness and stopped smiling.
Also, alongside sweet and upbeat, Tohru herself is incredibly polite and well-mannered. The moment she pushes someone away from another person with her own hands is incredibly out of character for her. And it wasn't out of the blue, it happened when a very uncomfortable-looking Yuki was passive-aggressively harrassed by someone Tohru had never been before until then — Akito.
In Naruto, Asuma is almost always seen smoking, except for a few occasions. One instance is around the time his father, the Third Hokage, died. Another is when two Akatsuki members kill his friend Chiriku, and the rest of the members of his temple.
Shikamaru: It's been two days since your last cigarette. When a chain smoker like you lays off, something's always up.
Asuma: Sharp eyes, Shikamaru. If the likes of you can read my heart, then I'm still a rank amateur.
Kakashi usually acts like a total flake, but when Guy tells him he taught Lee the Hidden Lotus Kakashi is almost too mad to speak.
Alucard from Hellsing is incredibly hammy, especially while fighting. The one time he acts completely solemn during a fight is when he begs Anderson not to become a monster like him.
Played for Laughs during the Hot Springs Episode of Sayonara, Zetsubou-Sensei. When the class and Nozomu learn about a hot springs' detoxifying qualities, Nozomu goes on a rant about the dangers of recklessly detoxing. Cue the students coming out of the spring without any of their character flaws, like the lawsuit-happy Ms. Fanservice tripping and revealing a wetsuit underneath her towel, while just asking for a band-aid instead of threatening to sue, and the Stalker with a Crush respecting Nozomu's personal space and staying away from him. Nozomu, being Nozomu, is horrified by all of this.
In Death Note, Near figures out Light's otherwise brilliant plan because Light's Dragon, Teru Mikami, otherwise an obsessive Creature of Habit, goes to the bank two days in a row, when he would normally only go once a month.
In Full Metal Panic! (major spoilers ahead) Kaname begins acting completely differently after visiting the ruined lab at Yamsk 11, including pulling a voluntary Face-Heel Turn in which she sides with Leonard Testarossa (who up to this point she utterly despised) as well as beating up Leonard's sister Tessa and apparently killing Sousuke, to whom she'd confessed her love the last time they saw each other. It turns out she's doing this because it's not Kaname — Sophia, the psychic test subject from Yamsk 11, had taken over her body and is using it for her own ends, while the real Kaname is trapped in her own mind and fighting back (such as making Sophia think she killed Sousuke so he wouldn't be considered a threat anymore).
Skalman from Bamse, a Swedish comic series, almost never showed emotion, and always obeyed a strict schedule. When he stopped obeying that schedule for a bit, or snapped at his friends, you knew it was serious.
In the recent comic book adaptation of Darkwing Duck, the Liquidator, who has the Verbal Tic of speaking in ad slogans and bogus claims, suddenly drops it just long enough to warn someone about Quackerjack's Berserk Button. Which turned out to be Serious Business indeed.
Death Of The Family: Joker has always used Joker Venom, which kills a person and leaves them with the creepiest grin on their face. But this time, his venom kills a person, and leaves them with a frown on their face. Something is wrong...
The Joker has always had a fondness for jokes, tricks, and gags in his various schemes and murders, but in A Death in the Family he forgoes his usual methods and simply opts to beat Robin (Jason Todd) half to death with a crowbar and let a bomb finish the job.
While Dick Grayson was the sole Batman in the DCU, he let security cameras record him beating up thugs, so that criminals would know that Batman was back in town. However, Two-Face sees him smiling in one of these recordings, and this tips him off that the Batman he's watching is not the Batman, as Batman does not smile.
Similarly, during Knightfall, Joker takes one look at Azbats and realizes it's not the real Batman, walking away from the fight.
Some writers claim that part of the reason Spidey quips mid-battle is because his enhanced nerve conduction velocity (reflexes and spider-sense) actually allows him to think at superhuman speeds... which means that to him, the world is moving in slow motion during a fight, and he fills in the extra time by making jokes. If he's not making them, not only is it frightening that he's strong and angry, it's frightening that he's dedicating 100% of his genius intellect and enhanced processing power to deciding how he's going to hurt you in the most personally satisfying manner possible.
A theory put forward by Stan Lee himself is that Spidey is making jokes to cover up that he actually is terrified, so the bigger the danger, the lamer the jokes. So when he stops it usually means that no matter how terrifying and dangerous you are, he is not buying it anymore. Now all he feels is that he really wants to beat you unconscious.
Rorschach of Watchmen is gruff, insulting, and arrogant most of the time, and also doesn't usually use pronouns or proper names. When he says, "Daniel, I apologize. I know it's difficult being my friend," you know he's being dead serious.
When Dan/Nite Owl finds out that his friend and mentor, Hollis Mason/the original Nite Owl was beaten to death by members of a gang, he starts beating the ever-living crap out of a gang member, to get information about the murder. Even though Nite Owl has no aversion to violence, the raw viciousness makes Rorschach of all people stop him. (Although his rationale is to tell Dan, "Not in front of the public.")
Any time that the Pre CrisisLex Luthor, the version who used to be Superboy's friend and a pretty nice guy, would have a Pet the Dog moment, it represented his earlier decent nature showing through, and (rightly or wrongly), it gave Supes hope that someday he might come back to the side of the angels. One of the very last Pre Crisis stories, "The Ghost of Superman Future,'' indicates that in at least one possible future, Lex did eventually reform and they became friends again in their old age. It was by Elliot S! Maggin, who was very fond of Luthor. He later wrote a short story along similar lines called "Luthor's Gift."
Then there's Superman himself. When Supes gets pissed, which is rare, beware, because the Boy Scout is about to test his Thou Shalt Not Kill credo.
Wonder Woman has her own version. When she puts aside her lasso and other tools meant to disable, and actually takes up a sword or axe, it means she has declared war and someone's going down- or possibly somearmy. It doesn't really apply to the Nu52 version who's, well, sword armed almost all the time, but it used to be a big deal for the champion of peace to take up a weapon meant to kill.
In the 3rd book of Bone, while the world slowly crumbles due to the Rat Creatures and Thorn learning she is a princess, Grandma Ben, whose eyes are always closed, opens them for a split-second when she finds out that she has partially doomed the Valley by not telling Thorn that she is a princess.
Deadpool, the fourth-wall breakingWild Card to end all wild cards, has his speech bubbles and thought rectangles shaded yellow, to show that he's the one guy in the entire comicverse who knows he's in the comicverse and is perfectly okay with it. On the rare occasions where his speech bubbles go to the normal white shading, meaning he's taking things seriously, you know it's significant. The plot of Deadpool Kills the Marvel Universe involves the yellow and white voices getting somehow killed... and the red voice replacing it. Let's just say it doesn't go well for the world.
In the Marvel vs. DC crossover, there comes a moment when the universe genuinely looks like it's going to end. The sky is bleeding. Spider-Man turns to J. Jonah Jameson, and says,
Spider-Man: You gonna take one last shot at me before the lights go out?
Jonah: ...For what it's worth, I'm sorry.
In the Ultimate Universe, JJ snaps at young Parker and fires him after Parker calls him on his BS. But he shows up later on and apologizes to Peter for his behavior and goes on to explain calmly and sensibly what his problems are with Spider-Man.
Scootaloo turning down an offer to hang out with Rainbow Dash is so upsetting that RD has to tell her friends about it. (Whether she's worried for Scoot, is just nursing her bruised ego, or both is uncertain.)
The Caged Demonwolf in Empowered drops his alliteration and wordiness at one point for a genuinely touching discussion with a character about how he'll always remember her. After five or six volumes of "Bah!" it's an attention-getting moment.
During the finale between Sonic and Robotnik in Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog, Sonic is so pissed off about Robotnik seemingly killing Sally that he doesn't quip any jokes and even refers to Robotnik by his real name. The comic itself lampshades this.
The fourth issue of The Tick comic book, "The Night Of A Million Zillion Ninjas" seems much like the previous chapters, until The Tick's friend and partner Oedipus gets stabbed by two ninjas, seriously enough that she falls unconscious and starts losing blood. At this, the wheels come off - rather than his usual bombast and style, The Tick quickly, silently, and violently dispatches the two ninjas, and all he can say as he carries Oedipus is "This isn't supposed to happen." He barely registers the paramedics who come to help Oedipus, and is later seen with paranoid delusions of the various buildings taunting him over his failures. Unlike most Cloudcuckoolanders, he doesn't suddenly become sane... he just stops being the "fun" kind of insane.
In the Fantastic Four arc "True Story", when Reed and Sue Richards' daughter Valeria (who loves bedtime stories) loudly declares that she doesn't want a story before bed, Sue is convinced that this is the work of an enemy. The Fantastic Four soon discover that recurring Doctor Strange villain Nightmare has been attacking the Lands of Fiction, causing people to lose interest in stories.
In the recent story arc "The Fall and Rise of the Fantastic Four", Sue goes to retrieve Valeria from Doctor Doom after Valeria pulled a Screw This, I'm Outta Here! following learning why her family went on a time-traveling family trip. When Valeria refuses, noting that Doom is starting to actually reform and she wants to finish it, Sue flips out and when Doom steps in, she tears him a new one. Doom ends up sensing the entity Malice within Sue, but she ignores him. It's when Valeria throws herself between the two and outright states that she's scared of Sue that Sue ends up backing down.
Nooby: Nooby knows how it feels to not be accepted. Noob... I know what it feels like to be the odd pygmy out.
Ooga: He's making sense?!?!
In the third issue of IDW's Ghostbusters: Mass Hysteria (issue 15 of the 2013/2014 series), Peter takes a phone call for help while discussing the current problem with Walter Peck and immediately leaves via motorcycle without a word, much to Peck's surprise. Considering the caller was Dana Barrett, it's understandable.
Walter Peck: Ms. Melnitz, after taking that phone call, Peter Venkman ran out of here without a single smart-assed remark. That kind of character inconsistency is, in my experience, the reddest of red flags.
In response to a then-recent nuclear accident in the 1970's, Alfred E. Neuman of MAD went into a full-scale panic. His Catch Phrase, "What, me worry?" was replaced with, "Yes! Me worried!"
In Calvin and Hobbes, as Calvin is lying sick in bed, his mom tells him she's going to call the doctor. She also adds that it's Saturday, so he won't miss school, and he responds with a weak "I know." Since Calvin is a kid who usually is overjoyed at the thought of not going to school, his mother is convinced this is serious and races for the phone.
In the final week of dailies of U.S. Acres, Lovable Coward Wade achieves peace with the world... sending Orson, Roy, and Booker away screaming in terror.
In chapter 10 of Once More with Feeling, Asuka admits that she had screwed up in front of Rei, and Rei apologized for Asuka. And Shinji, who was staring at shock and whose jaw almost hit the floor, wondered why nobody had informed him that Earth started rotating from West to East overnight.
In Undocumented Features, Azalynn, who's been shown to be extremely forgiving, finds herself holding a grudge against Liza for calling the Psi Corps on Devlin, even when everyone else has forgiven her. She is extremely shocked when she realizes how spiritually off-balance she is.
Exaggerated in I Cannot Tell a Lie when England is unable to properly insult France at a meeting (it was because of a spell). Almost all the characters reacted to this by passing out, going catatonic, or panicking and screaming (their theories for this OoC moment include the apocalypse and an alien invasion). Oddly, the only person to remain calm is America, who just thinks England's sick.
In Out of Time, when Kenshin is mystified by the burnt soup Kaoru made and says it tastes bad, Yahiko asks him, "Who are you?", stating that Kenshin would never insult her cooking (and is also probably thinking that her legendarily bad cooking shouldn't be news to anyone).
Sano: Wow, guys, check it out; the Weasel's gone speechless...
Megumi: Please don't say that. I think I read somewhere that that's a sign of the impending Apocalypse.
When Nepeta drops her cat puns and other typing quirks in Herding Cats, that means she's really upset.
In From Shizunes Perspective, midway through the fic, Shizune notes that Misha is chewing her lip like she does during tests she expects to fail, and is not snarking at her like she usually does. Misha claims that it's out of sensitivity toward Shizune, who is upset over Emi not responding to her text messages, but the truth is that Misha and Hisao have a Secret Relationship, and are worried about how Shizune will react.
In Things We Don't Tell Humans, Prowl has a loud, public, and surprisingly violent breakdown when he finds out who died in Transformers. And we learn to pay very close attention to out-of-character moments from Megatron (both in the present and in the flashback arcs) and from Mikaela.
While he's generally a goofball, Cruise Control turns dead serious for a few seconds to tell Apple Bloom that older siblings always care for their younger siblings. It's later revealed that that side of him is his real personality, his doofus side being an act.
Trixie drops her Third-Person Person act a few times, perplexing Twilight. When she finally gets around calling Trixie out on it, she discovers black psyche-locks on her; in other words, she's hiding a great secret and sorrow, and she's not even consciously aware of it.
My Little Avengers: You know Rainbow Dash has become a Thor fangirl when she's so excited about attending a party in his honor that she forgets the Wonderbolts are going to be there too. Pinkie and Big Mac are left rather stunned.
Hivefled: Equius had been rapidly losing his respect for Gamzee as Gamzee slipped further into his rages, to the point that he was willing to insult him to his face and strife without letting him win. When their conflict indirectly leads to Nepeta dumping Equius and he screams at Gamzee that he intends to "wring your scrawny neck", he's over the edge.
For someone who isn't afraid to swear, Valkron appears to be limited to "hell", "arse(hole)", "damn" and "bloody". This is because he only does a Precision F-Strike when he is seriously angry.
Insufferable Genius Samaroh drops his entire pompous smarter-than-thou attitude for a more gentle and softspoken bedside manner when caring for the injured. The biggest Deadpan Snarker of the story is surprised at this.
Combined with Precision F-Strike in The Next Frontier. If Bill Kerman uses a real swearword, the situation is serious. The first time he does it in the fic, the normally unflappable Jeb is appreciably freaked out.
In the Megamind fanfic, Rain On The Just, Megamind has been working hard to say "hello" at least closer to correct way. So when he comes to rescue Roxanne from the Beetle-Bomber/Fire Bug/Owen and says "Ollo," she knows that her boyfriend is serious ticked off.
Occurs in the first two chapters of the xxxHolic fic Transitions when one of the main characters switches universes without realizing it at first.
Doumeki wonders if he should get a doctor for Watanuki, because after spending several minutes in his presence, he wasn't insulting or yelling at him. He really begins to freak out when Watanuki starts holding his hand.
Meanwhile in the neighboring universe, Watanuki gets weirded out when Doumeki is smiling and acting affectionate.
In both chapters, the alternate universe versions start panicking when they realize the other is suddenly on a Last Name Basis.
In the MLP Fanfic What Have You Done, Twilight Velvet, Twilight's mother goes to talk to Twilight, who was kicked out of her brother's wedding. She gets very worried when she can't find Twilight in any of the libraries or bookstores in town, which is where Twilight goes when she is upset. When Velvet learns about her fight with the Mane 6, and the fact that they don't know where she is, she starts panicking.
In Alpha and Omega, Joker becomes extremely worried when EDI starts drinking, using contractions, and violating regulations frequently. This turns out to be caused by EDEN's hacking of EDI having scrambled their programming together.
In the sequel, Misato surrenders much easier than most of the Wunder crew expected. That's because she's been replaced by EDEN.
Jinx in The Measure Of A Titan can't even imagine how bad things must be for Starfire to rip through about a foot of solid metal and explicitly threaten the Hive Five with death. Answer: Robin got shot in the chest.
In xLilyStarkx's Avengers fanfiction "Chained", Tony manages to make Loki cry. Everyone who sees Loki in this state reacts with this trope.
In Gensokyo 20 XX, we have two instances of this. One instance goes where Yukari leaves without telling (20XXIII) and, when she does, it is made note of how worrying that is because usually unlike her to do so, as she would usually be sticking around to suffer with them and or for them and, that if she did leave, she will have told someone and, if she had wandered off, being so mentally unstable, they would have found her. Naturally, their prompt assumption is that she left to die so she would be one less mouth to feed when food is so scarce. In 20XXV, we have an arguable example with Reimu stabbing Yume Ni with a pair of scissors in a fit of rage, after the latter kicked her in the face. Apparently, she felt the pain and... responded to it with rage.
Later, in chapter 93, Marisa did note that Reimu typically didn't talk much and not once swore (specifically, she said "ass" to them) at Ran and Ren and neither did she go against them and hold her ground, instead of submitting, be that reluctantly, as seen in earlier chapters. Eight chapters later, she says something shocking, during which she challenges Baka to kill her.
Steve realizes that he's done something bizarre or wrong after breaking some robots in The Joke when even Agent Coulson is gaping at him.
In The Many Doors of Níu Heimar Steve draws a caricature that Loki finds so funny he bursts out laughing. Everyone else, particularly Thor, stares at him in concern.
In Marching Orders, Xander makes a nurse and doctor understand just how serious the situation is when he explains that as Sunnydale residents, they have an idea of what goes on at night. He and his friends dealt with it everyday for years and they're leaving Sunnydale immediately.
Played for laughs in Monsters In Paradise. Marisa, the setting's local Kleptomaniac Hero who never returns the things she "borrows", admits to returning a book and entering the Mansion through the front door. In response, Patchouli and Sakuya both decide who will inherit their belongings in the event of their deaths, while Koakuma tearfully denounces her prank-loving lifestyle. Since the situation wasn't all that serious, their comments annoy Marisa and nothing more.
The Fifth Act: Angeal cherishes his honour and takes pride that he will do the right thing. That goes out the window when he slowly starts to die of degeneration. When he deliberately tricks Cloud and sells him out to Hollander in search for a cure.
Silver: You heard the boy! Get this blasted heap turned 'round!
In An Extremely Goofy Movie, Max is convinced that he wants to transfer schools after being defeated by his own dad at his best event, because there's "only room for one Goof." PJ is devastated at the news—temporarily relapsing to the insecure and worrisome personality he'd just broken out of— and Beret Girl tells Max that he can't admit defeat, but nothing helps... until Bobby, the Plucky Comic Relief, in a dead-serious, emotionally-charged tone, gives Max a Rousing Speech.
Frozen: The difference between Anna, the Plucky Girl and Anna, the Princess. Notice her commanding tone when she demands her horse be brought to her after Elsa runs away; it shows just how important finding and helping her sister is to her.
Olaf also displays this when he lights fire to keep a freezing Anna alive; he drops his position as comic relief (very briefly) to assure her that he knows full well what will happen to him, but that it's worth it for her.
In Transformers: The Movie, Kup has Seen It All and uses any situation as an excuse to mention some previous adventure of his. When the Autobots see Unicron standing astride the entire planet of Cybertron, Hot Rod asks if this reminds him of yet another one of his war-stories. Kup's only response is a quiet "Nope... Never seen anything like this before."
Films — Live-Action
When Silent Bob speaks, you listen. Though this tendency begins to annoy Jay after a while. This tradition is itself subverted in Clerks II, when Bob's cue to speak arrives and he can't think of anything to say...
Lampshaded in Chasing Amy by Jay, who comments that Bob stays silent so often in order to make people pay attention whenever he does speak, and to make whatever he says sounds deeper because of that.
Towards the end of the first movie when Jack shoots Barbossa and Barbossa thinks that Jack wasted his shot. Clever viewers can tell from Jack's cold, steely glare that this is not the case; it's the one time in the entire movie that he's not doing something eccentric.
Speaking of Jack acting OOC; it can be hard to tell what is and isn't out of character for a guy whose methods are so mercurial. The only certainty is that anything he does is (virtually) always with the ultimate goal of furthering his own interests.
Elizabeth: "Whose side is Jack on?"
Will: "At the moment?"
Jack gets one at the climax of At World's End when Jones stabs Will through the heart and Jack, who has has his self-serving objective literally in the palm of his hand, goes from cruelly gloating over his imminent victory to looking mind-screwed by despair, almost Heroic BSOD ing. It's brief, but is big enough to make his sacrifice afterward make perfect sense without hefty foreshadowing.
In a deleted scene Jack shows that even he has standards when he solemnly tells Beckett, who is asking about when Jack worked for the East India Trading Company but got on their bad side when he refused to transport slaves, that "People aren't cargo mate" with none of his usual wackiness.
Jack's refusal to turn the ship around to go back for his hat early in Dead Man's Chest is a sign that he's very afraid of the Kraken. When he tells them to leave it behind, his crew looks at him as though he's grown a second head.
In the final scene of Penn & Teller Get Killed, Teller (who has never spoken to this point), finally breaks his silence to ask what the hell is going on.
In Galaxy Quest, Classically Trained Extra Alexander Dane hates being known as a character from a sci-fi series, and hates his Catch Phrase even more, spending most of the movie trying to get out of saying it, or saying it in monotone. However, when a Thermian who's always looked up to Alex's character is shot and mortally wounded, Alexander says, sincerely, "Quellek... by Grabthar's hammer... by the Sons of Warvan... you shall be... avenged" before opening a can of whoop-ass on the bad aliens.
This might make it an inversion, since here IC Is Serious Business.
Running Scared (1986)
A humorous version can be found when the two main characters call for backup. They come out of the building without their pants (having had to give them to the Big Bad of the film), only to find that a huge number of cops — including the SWAT units — have shown up to help.
There's another: When Danny Costanzo (Billy Crystal) soon-to-be-ex gets kidnapped by the Big Bad, Danny (who up until this point has not slowed down the wisecracks for a second) gets a call from the crook letting him know his girl's in trouble:
Danny Costanzo:(in a dangerous, low tone) You hurt her, you'll never be dead enough.
In the film of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Harry is running around looking for the diadem. Luna is trying to tell him he needs to ask a ghost, but Harry won't listen. Luna, usually the gentle Cloudcuckoolander, shouts "HARRY POTTER! YOU LISTEN TO ME RIGHT NOW!" Harry, suitably shocked, turns around and listens.
In the fifth movie, when Hermione observes that it's kind of exciting breaking the rules, Ron demands "Who are you and what have you done with Hermione Granger?"
In Sudden Impact, Harry is tipped off to a robbery in the coffee shop that is his usual haunt by the waitress breaking a years-long routine and dumping a large amount of sugar into his coffee.
Marianne is shown to never swear. She constantly uses euphemisms like "rhymes-with-witch", and other gosh-dang-it-to-heck-isms. But when she hears the rumor that Olive gave Marianne's boyfriend Micah chlamydia, Marianne completely loses it, and yells, even screams "That... that BITCH!"
Also, Marianne is shown to be a bit snide, condescending, and utterly dedicated to attempting to correct other's supposed sins, but she does it without being out-and-out confrontational. But after she snaps, she full on slaps Olive across the face. Which is most decidedly not a typical Christian value.
In Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, Watson deduces that something serious is going on from the fact that Mycroft is missing an appointment at the Diogenes Club, especially since his favorite dish, potted shrimp, is on the menu that night.
Holmes stops his wisecracking during his first meeting with Moriarty once the latter reveals he killed Irene Adler and plans to do the same to Watson and Mary.
Unforgiven: When William Munny, who'd been sober for many years, starts downing that bottle of whiskey before going after Bill Daggett, you know things are about to get serious as a heart attack.
In Serenity when the crew land on Haven and find that it's been razed, Mal loses it. After telling his crew to strap bodies to the front of the ship, threatening to kill any of his crew that gets in his way and shooting dead an Alliance soldier trying to surrender, the crew know that it's all just hit the fan.
Earlier in the film Mal invokes this to prove to his crew that a call from Mal's love-hate-love interest is actually her being coerced by the villain to lure them in to a trap.
Mal: Y'all were watching, I take it? (Everyone sort of admits it) Did you see us fight?
Manderlay (the sequel to Lars Von Trier's Dogville) features a double-dose of this towards the end. After the freed slaves celebrate their first harvest, they discover that the money they worked so hard to get has been stolen- and it could have only been done with the help of one of the ex-slaves. Following a massive off-screen riot that gets two people killed, Grace finally arrives on the scene to ask questions: Wilhelm, the man usually relied upon to explain things, is too shell-shocked to speak of what happened. This leaves Mark holding the exsposition ball; for once, he doesn't bother dithering around with longwinded tangents, and provides a straightforward explanation.
A small, but powerful moment in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country. After apparently firing on a Klingon battlecruiser carrying the Klingon Chancellor on a diplomatic mission, the battlecruiser recovers, rights itself, and prepares to retaliate on the unshielded Enterprise. Kirk watches this for a full ten seconds in silent, slacked-jawed horror. He doesn't raise shields, or order evasive maneuvers, or any of the other things that fans expect him to do; he just watches. . .and then he surrenders. This is the first time in the history of Star Trek that Kirk is ever seen to falter in the command chair, and it's terrifying.
Another one in the same movie by Spock, the paragon of emotionless logic and reason, who very angrily smacks a phaser from the hand of his protegé, Valeris, who had just been exposed as a conspirator in Gorkon's assassination. He later uses the Vulcan Mind Meld to try and pry the identities and plans of the conspirators, which ends up becoming, based on the reaction of the receiving party, dangerously close to Mind Rape.
Some fans consider the events of Star Trek VI to be the in-canon chronological first evidence of Section 31, a Base BreakerGovernment Conspiracy accused of being OOC for the entire future society depicted by the franchise.
In Star Trek Into Darkness, when Scotty resigns in protest of their mission to Qo'noS (pronounced "Kronos"), he makes a last desperate appeal for Kirk to reconsider and calls him "Jim" instead of Captain.
Also Spock's reaction when Scotty calls him down to the reactor room. He doesn't even know what happened, only that something terrible has happened to Kirk. He rushes out of the bridge, forgetting to give the legally required order that someone takes command. And as he runs through the halls, there is sheer panic on his face.
Mac The Bartender is also The Quiet One. The seriousness of any particular book is proportional to the number of words that he says. A complete sentence or two is enough to scare Dresden. In Changes he goes on for a good sized paragraph.
Also, in Blood Rites, Lieutenant Murphy meets Harry's mentor, Ebenezer McCoy. As they are on a hunt for vampires in Chicago, Murphy tells him (rudely) to get out of the driver's seat. Harry tells him to do it, slipping in the word "sir". Murphy drops everything she's carrying, mainly because hearing the anti-authority Dresden using the word "sir" is something that you only hear once. Also justified, as Ebenezer is the only one to whom Harry will apply an honorific. Being Harry's Obi Wan has its perks.
In Dead Beat, Harry asks Bob about Kemmler, the author of a book that the visiting group of Necromancers are all hot and bothered about. Bob has a minor freak-out, and tells Harry that Kemmler was straight up, capital-E Evil. This immediately catches Harry's attention, mainly because Bob's view on morality is... sketchyat best.
Toot-toot the dewdrop faerie is normally fearless and a ravenous junk-food addict. When Toot tells Harry to run, it's serious; when he tells Harry to forget the doughnut and run, it's dreadfully-so.
The one time in his life that Morgan calls Harry by his first name is when he tells Harry to stand down and let the Wardens arrest Morgan for murder, rather than get himself killed defending a man he knows to be innocent.
Two incidents related to Harry himself and mental magic:
In Small Favor, Harry spends most of the book getting into sticky situations full of monsters and notincinerating them out of hand. This is because Queen Mab removed his memory of how to do so (and took away his blasting rod for good measure), ostensibly for his own good.
To Kill a Mockingbird is full of these: Scout notes the only time she ever heard Atticus raise his voice (when he's defending his parenting style to Aunt Alexandra) and the only time she ever heard him call something a sin (to kill a mockingbird). Jem decides to follow Atticus the night the mob threatens him outside the jail because Atticus took his car instead of walking as usual. Scout and Jem are shocked at Tom Robinson's trial when Atticus takes off his jacket and loosens his tie, because they've never seen him do that during the day. Scout knows that Aunt Alexandra is seriously shaken when the children have been attacked at the end, because she brings Scout her overalls to put on, after spending the entire book trying to get her to stop wearing them. And, of course, there's Boo Radley leaving his house for the only time in living memory in order to protect them from Bob Ewell.
In the earlier books, moments when Hermione was in favor of breaking the rules were this.
Most notable was when Harry and Ron save Hermione from a cave troll. She saves them from getting into trouble by lying and saying she thought of going after the troll and they were only rescuing her (when really, the troll found her by chance and Harry and Ron broke the rules and went after it, instead of going to their dormitories). Not only did Hermione lie to a teacher to cover for Harry and Ron's rulebreaking (something which she refused to go along with earlier), but she used a cover story that made her out to be the rulebreaker. Harry compares the situation to Snape giving out candy.
In Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione slaps Malfoy across the face for insulting Hagrid. It scares Malfoy enough to shut him up and get him to leave.
A rather terrifying example happens at the end of the first book. when Harry finds p-p-poor s-stuttering Professor Quirrell in front of the Mirror of Erised - and he isn't stuttering...
In Prisoner of Azkaban, Dumbledore loses his temper for the first time in the series when a pack of Dementors nearly kill Harry. Hermione mentions that it was absolutely terrifying.
And again when confronting the fake Moody in The Goblet of Fire - Harry realizes just how much of a threat Dumbledore is to the Death Eaters, as he sees for the first time that Dumbledore isn't just a harmless old man, but is a powerful and dangerous wizard capable of magic that Harry can't even pronounce.
Sweet, motherly Molly Weasley reacts rather badly when Bellatrix tries to kill Ginny.
Molly:NOT MY DAUGHTER, YOU BITCH!
The Weasleys in general are a fun, happy family, but they generally share a Berserk Button of hearing someone insult one another. In The Order of the Phoenix, Fred and George (who had previously gotten revenge via subtle trickery) began punching Malfoy in front of the school after a Quidditch match, because he was insulting their parents. Meanwhile, one of the things that truly breaks Ron out of his snarky, laid-back personality is hearing someone insult his family, Harry, or Hermione.
A rather frightening example happens in Deathly Hallows, where it turns out that the corrupting power of Horcruxes can cause this sort of thing to happen. Between a combination of low self-esteem and his wearing the locket, Ron sinks into a suspicious, depressed state which in turn dampens the hope of Harry and Hermione.
Another one in Deathly Hallows is when Lupin, who is usually the calm voice of reason, starts shouting about how he should never have married Tonks, how guilty he feels about potentially passing on his condition to his unborn child, and how his new family will be much better off without a father and husband they should be ashamed of. Fortunately, a What the Hell, Hero? from Harry sets him back on track, but it's quite jarring to see just how low an opinion of himself Lupin has, especially since he's one of Harry's few remaining parental figures and looked up to by a great number of other characters.
In The Chronicles of Narnia series, this happens in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. When the ship is attacked by a giant sea serpent, Reepicheep yells at everyone to push the serpent off the boat rather than fight it. Since Reepicheep usually leaps at any opportunity for glory in battle (at one point earlier in the book he had to be restrained from challenging a dragon to single combat), this is unusual enough to startle the rest of the ship's crew into helping him.
In Roadkill, the last book of the Cal Leandros series, Robin Godfellow, aka lust incarnate, becomes monogamous. All of his friends instantly assume he must be seriously ill.
Rincewind is an inept coward who would much rather run away from most problems rather than face them head-on. In Sourcery, Rincewind challenges the most powerful source of magic on the disc with a half brick in a sock, and then holds off a swarm of eldritch abominations long enough to escape, armed with only a sock full of sand.Holy shit.
Conversed by Twoflower in The Light Fantastic, when he reasons that Rincewind's uncharacteristic lack of fear about the Red Star implies that it's not the world-ending threat most people assume it to be.
He does it again in Interesting Times, when faced with the horrors of the Agatean Empire, Rincewind concludes that there are times you have to stop running, even if it's because there's nowhere left to run to.
Death almost never ends his sentences with an exclamation mark, so you know he's pissed off when he shouts at the New Death for setting himself up as a ruler over mortals, in Reaper Man.
This is also invoked for Death when he speaks emphatically of the Auditors' hatred for humanity in Hogfather (represented as italics), shocking Susan.
Lets not forget Death's first major role in Mort, where he is throughout the book made to be The Stoic, and is even explained to lack the physical capability for feelings, but in the climax of the book he expresses extremely human rage, unlike ever before or after, and when Mort is at his mercy, he does a mocking, cruel Evil Laugh, which also is a completely unique expression of negative emotion — right before revealing that he decided to spare Mort and his friends after all.
Vetinari takes pride in his ability to play Sam Vimes like a fiddle and get him to do the best job imaginable... all by keeping him suitably pissed off. Vimes even tends to punch the wall outside Vetinari's office as he leaves, sometimes hard enough to require repair. Until one day Vimes departs, and Vetinari doesn't hear the telltale thump, and realizes that he might have gone too far.
The Librarian hates to be called a monkey (orangutans are apes), and will apply a great deal of physical violence to remind people when they forget this. That's why, when the Senior Wrangler calls him one in The Last Continent and gets away with his head still screwed on, the other wizards become quite concerned. There's another occasion when someone calls him a monkey, and he pats their hand comfortingly.
Although that latter one is because the character in question was so mad that they might have literally out-murdered the Librarian if the Librarian had tried to "correct" him.
In A Hat Full of Sky, Rob Anybody is so worried about the hiver going after Tiffany that he starts to lose interest in hunting, fighting, and other activities typical of the Nac Mac Feegle. When he refuses a drink of Special Sheep Liniment, the other Feegles are briefly convinced he's dead.
In The Fifth Elephant, while searching for Angua, Carrot not only raises his voice when Gaspode tells him a wolf has been caught in a nearby village, but actually uses deception to acquire the animal so it can help them locate her. For straight-laced, inscrutable Carrot, that's tantamount to any other man having a full-on nervous breakdown when his girl goes missing.
In Night Watch, when a young Corporal asks Sgt. Colon where he, Vimes and Nobby (and we find out later, Reg Shoe) are going and why they were all wearing sprigs of lilac. The usually jolly Colon rounds on the youngster and tells him that anyone who had the right to ask that already knew and was headed in the same direction. Vimes has to lead him away to calm him down.
In Good Omens Aziraphale the angel may no longer be completely uncorrupted by humanity, but he's still angelic enough that he's the undisputed master of Gosh Dang It to Heck!. Then, he swears. And shit just got serious.
Daur is considered the most straitlaced and disciplined of the lot. In Only In Death, he nearly hits Rawne, which is taken as a sign of the insidious effects of Hinzerhaus. In Blood Pact, when he is caught helping out in one of Rawne's scams, Hark thinks that the regiment's discipline and morale has hit a new low.
Only In Death has some more of these. Normally unflappable Mkoll gets spooked, chatty Maggs is unusually silent...
E.E. Smith's Skylark Series: The reason Dick Seaton knows the scientific knowledge he needs to save the Earth exists is because of independently-evolved legends from two worlds of a large and complex star cluster, which describe their gods stunning mortals who attack them. This is despite ten thousand years of strike-to-kill conditioning in both races. Ergo the legends must contain a grain of truth to have lasted for that long without "stunned" being changed to "killed", and the "gods" must be the Sufficiently Advanced Aliens he's looking for. He turns out to be right.
In Larry Niven's short story "Flatlander", our hero Beowulf Shaeffer has just finished doing some scans outside the spaceship. He turns to his companion:
Beowulf: Elephant, have you noticed a tendency in me to use profanity for emphasis?
Elephant: No, not really.
Beowulf: Well, it's goddamned radioactive out there.
In second Black Company book when Goblin doesn't way to play tricks with One-Eye as he usually does and instead of smiling and humilating his rival he actually gets provoked by him, worse, attacks him with his bare hands, everybody knows there is something wrong.
In the first chapter of World War Z, Dr. Kwang Jing-shu says he knew that something very bad was happening through a combination of this trope, Meaningful Echo, and Out-of-Character Alert. An old army comrade renowned for seeing the worst in any given situation, Dr. Gu Wen Kuei, once had a rare non-curmudgeonly moment when they were performing extremely difficult surgery in the middle of a dangerous border clash in Russia, and said to the nearly-disembowelled patient, "Don't worry, everything's going to be all right." Years later, when Jing-shu calls him about a small outbreak of unusual symptoms, Kuei, who knows what's going on, repeats the familiar reassurance, and that's when Jing-shu realizes that the outbreak is not isolated and the situation is much worse than he thought.
Marco is known for being such a fountain of snark that whenever he's serious, it's safe to assume that something pretty upsetting is going on. At one point, during a mission that involved his mother, when he was understandably preoccupied, Jake had to take him aside and tell him to start cracking stupid jokes because he was scaring the others.
Jake did the same thing to Rachel in another book when she was acting too cautious.
Commented on when Ax starts screaming at everyone to book it during an infiltration attempt:
Ax never yells. So when he does, it's usually a good idea to pay attention.
This was how the kids realized that Jake had been made a Controller in book 6: When Ax touches Jake’s cheek, the Yeerk in Jake’s head can’t handle it and screams, “Get your hands off me, Andalite filth!”, thus blowing his cover. He immediately tries to play it off as stress, but the others aren’t having it, and Rachel lampshades it.
The sole time one of the Chee fight, Rachel is later seen crying. This more than anything convinces Marco how horrific the slaughter was.
In the Dark Nest Trilogy, Luke Skywalker (whose job it is to exemplify tranquility and serenity) drops the GFFA equivalent of the F-bomb.
In Warrior Cats, Jayfeather invokes this by saying he's glad that the cranky elder Mousefur isn't acting all sweet and kind because that would mean she was getting heat stroke from the recent hot weather. Later when she starts acting mopey because of Longtail's death, Jayfeather gets really worried about her well-being.
In the Dale Brown novel Sky Masters, normally composed Jon Masters lets the pressure get to him, up to the point of Rant Inducing Slight, something his chief assistant notices immediately.
In the final novel of the Codex Alera, Tavi is rather shocked when his lover Kitai becomes furious with him for carrying on a relationship with her without marrying or courting her. Note that Kitai has never given a damn about Aleran laws or customs (or really ever noticed them, except to snark about them) and her own people's view on this sort of thing is rather more... relaxed. So why is she so bent out of shape? She's actually pregnant with her and Tavi's child, and while perfectly happy to flout Aleran rules herself, Kitai does not want her child to have to deal with the major social stigma Alerans place on illegitimacy.
Vivenna from Warbreaker believes that women should dress modestly with high-necked dresses, with skirts that come down to the calf at least. However, when she decides to become more of an Action Girl, she dons a man's trousers and shirt.
Ham from Mistborn spends the better part of three books mired in interminable ponderings, dilemmas, and hypotheticals. Finally he answers a question with "No", and is believed out of the shock value.
Honor Harrington is generally portrayed as a military professional: killing is an unfortunate consequence of her career, she takes no pleasure in it, and she can be courteous to former military opponents who tried to kill herbecause that was their job. Those who have known her long enough instantly recognize (and are scared shitless by) her change in bearing when she really, truly wants someone to die.
Mostly because she becomes a cold-blooded psychopath. When she discovered that an enemy had not just permitted, but ordered the rape and murder of her subordinates, she turned right around and tried to shoot him. Her friends had to physically hold her down to keep her from killing a prisoner. Later, she legally executed the men who had her lover assassinated in the most painful way she could manage.
Most recently, she learned who was responsible for killing most of her extended family, one of her closest friends, and millions of innocent people on her homeworld. While she hasn't yet had the opportunity to discuss this with them, it promises to be... unpleasant.
When the very anti-killing Campion informs a mook who helped kidnap one of his friends that if she was hurt, he'd "break his rule" and kill him.
In Artemis Fowl, Julius Root apologizing after referring to another fairy as 'human-blooded' is used to convey just how serious an insult 'human-blooded' is amongst fairies. In the second book, the LEP realise just how screwed they are when the usually gung-ho Captain Kelp orders a retreat.
At one point, Artemis (usually very serious and very articulate) calls Butler and simply shouts "Lollipops!" This makes Butler even more worried than he already is.
Kitty Norville is a chatterbox by nature who prefers to avoid violence and tries to get any fellow lycanthropes she meets to let the human aspects of their psyches call the shots as much as possible. So when she (in human form, mind you) lunges at an unarmed normal man on sight and does nothing but literally snarl when bodily restrained, the first question out of the mouth of someone that has known her for a couple of days is "What did you do to her?"
In A Series of Unfortunate Events Aunt Josephine is extremely obsessed with grammar. When the Baudelaires find her apparent suicide note Klaus begins to analyze the grammatical errors, but Violet disgustedly asks who would care about grammar in their situation. Klaus points out that Aunt Josephine would and realizes the mistakes are actually a coded message.
In the Paladin of Shadows book A Deeper Blue, Mother Lenka laughing heartily is recalled with horror.
In The Elenium Talen is found to have followed the knights on their mission to Zemoch. When questioned, he stammers and stutters, eventually giving an incredibly unbelievable story about why he followed them. Since Talen has never once been shown to be at a loss for words and has proven the ability to make up believable lies on the spot, this clues the knights in that Aphrael, the Child Goddess, is influencing Talen, since She had wanted him on the mission in the first place and is known to be a horrible liar.
This trope is the clue to Sparhawk that someone is using magic to influence the various kings of Eosia into confining the Pandion knights, as they are believing outlandish claims without any evidence and have turned aggressive towards their allies. It is revealed to be a spell that induces belief being cast by Annias, which is another example because as a church man, he is not permitted to learn magic.
Also in the sequel saga, The Tamuli: whenever Sparhawk stops being his short-tempered self and goes eerily calm, you know shit is gonna go down. The first time it's humorous, when he doesn't yell at Elhana for making it so she'll go to the Tamul Empire - which is currently at the gates of a civil war, although this time it was because Kalten took Sparhawk to a crypt and made him yell and wave his arms there so he'd have a clear head to confront his wife. The second time, less so, since it was caused by the kidnapping of his wife.
At one point in Galaxy of Fear Lando Calrissian, teaching Zak about playing cards, tells him "A good rule to follow is that if the other guy is acting normal under unusual circumstances, you can bet he's bluffing".
Army of Terror has The StoicPapa Wolf Uncle Hoole, confronted with the Kivan wraiths menacing him and his charges, just... stop fighting completely, take a Pose of Supplication, and wait for death. When someone else drives them away, he who is so good at Dissonant Serenity is profoundly shaken. He is The Atoner and blames himself for their deaths, just as they blame him.
In Spore, well, here's a quote.
Hoole touched the gash delicately. "I will live." The stern Shi'ido tried to look as light hearted as his stony face could manage. "It was not my best landing, but all things considered, I would say it wasn't my worst."
Tash grimaced. Hoole never joked. The fact that he was trying to probably meant he felt worse than he looked.
In LIES, Caine Soren is visibly disturbed by the fact that his girlfriend Diana Ladris A) isn't beautiful anymore and B) Isn't being snarky and sarcastic. He notes that this is a sign that she's finally lost her will to live. Serious business, indeed.
In the same installment of the series, Lana seems to lose hope when she notices Caine isn't being a cocky, arrogant sociopath, actually seeming quite insecure and timid, and remarks; "You gotta give he guy some credit; he has a genius for doing the wrong thing. We actually need him to be the bad guy, and now he's mr. meek and mild."
Devout Catholic Astrid loses her faith in God... And Promptly decides thats a good excuse to throw her brother out a window.
The first sign Alys gets that something is wrong in Terra Mirum Chronicles is that the sheriff arrives at the restaurant she works at an hour ahead of his usual time. It turns out he was at her best friend Charlie's house where Charlie committed suicide the night before.
This is the only way to detect Changed Ones in Hometown. Sometimes the symptoms are subtle, but when the local Big Friendly Dog starts acting more like a rabid wolverine, you know something's wrong.
In Across the Universe, Amy only knows Elder as a sweet, somewhat awkward teenage boy trying to do his best to lead Godspeed. Therefore, when she suspects he snapped and murdered Luther, in the second book, she is severely shaken at the thought.
Kopaka has a few such moments in the BIONICLE books. First, when believing Pohatu to have died in a cave-in, turns sappy and offers the mask they've been trying to find to Pohatu's people. In a later book, after being beaten by the bad guys, robbed of his mask and tools and attacked by a bunch of innocent villagers mistaking his team for villains, he breaks down and attempts to kill the villagers without hesitation.
When You Reach Me: Wheelie is the school secretary who knows all of the students, what class they are in, and even who is absent. But when the police come looking for Marcus, Miranda realizes just how bad the situation is when Wheelie asks them to repeat his name and ask what grade he is in.
Caves of Ice: When Ciaphas Cain note Hero Of The Imperium!!! realizes that his squad just found a Necron tomb and is giving orders to seal it, he knows that his "everything's under control" mask slipped big time. This actually reinforces his orders to the troopers.
(Grifen) no doubt thought that anything bad enough to leave a hero of the Imperium in need of clean undergarments was something she didn't want to meet.
In Murderess, Déaspor and ‘Hat Lad’, who usually have a rather smug and somewhat condescending yet benign attitude, become very angry when Lu or Hallwad and Aucasis refuse to take on their mission.
Since returning to Starling City, Oliver Queen (the titular Arrow) has staked his name on his decision to never wield a gun. The previews for the upcoming third season show him using one with expert precision, explaining "I never said I didn't know how to use a gun."
If the mild-mannered Clark Kent started speaking and acting rough and is sexually aggressive, you could bet your lucky stars that he is on red kryptonite. On the other hand, seeing him being overly cheerful and completely without Wangst is not a good sign either (Hypnotic)... Oh, and whenever he is not crazy over Lana, something is definitely wrong.
If Chloe Sullivan wears black, run away as fast as you could. She had donned a black outfit on three occasions - in Rush when a parasite makes her do all sorts of crazy things, in Exodus when she betrays Clark, and in Identity when she renders the bad guy of the week catatonic in a truly terrifying scene. Also, if she does anything to hurt Clark in any possible way, something is very, very wrong.
There's an episode where Michael sends Sam to escort Madeleine to safety. Madeleine isn't hearing of it, offers Sam a beer. Sam refuses the beer, at which point Madeleine starts taking him seriously.
In another episode, one of Sam's old "buddies" comes to him for help. Madeleine can tell something's wrong because Sam stops drinking for the duration of the episode. And in a DVD special feature, Bruce Campbell states that you can tell something is serious when Sam isn't drinking. Though he can be seen drinking during the planning stages of a mission, he almost never does it during an actual operation. So, since it's another (and not infrequently invoked) character trait for him, it might not exactly qualify as out of character.
In LOST when Locke and Ben are discussing moving the island after Alex's death, the normally well-mannered Ben warns Locke off his destiny searching path with the warning "Because destiny, John... is a fickle bitch"
The Ninth Doctor is cheerful, silly, happy, and above all, calm. Nothing fazes him. Then in a secret lab, he sees a heavily damaged, barely-alive Dalek (in the episode by the same name) — and immediately loses his shit in a big way. In the old show, and in public consciousness even more so, Daleks were often played for laughs. This signals very effectively that on the new Doctor Who, Daleks ain't funny — as everyone else learns quickly enough.
By a similar token, the Tenth Doctor is very decidedly anti-gun, turning one down repeatedly when Wilfred tells him to take one and kill whatever it is that has been predicted to kill him in "The End of Time". The mere mention of the possibility of the Time Lords returning causes him to pick up the gun without a second thought. It's how we know shit just got serious.
He picked up the gun before that in The Doctor's Daughter when Jenny is killed.
Ten is also known to allow terrible things to happen because they represent a "fixed point in time", i.e. something with far reaching consequences that needs to happen lest history be royally screwed. He even destroyed the city of Pompeii himself, and let (nearly) everyone die because it had to happen. But in "The Waters of Mars" he's finally had his fill, declares himself the "Time Lord Victorious", and proceeds to screw up a major historical event. It's rather frightening, and the consequences for him are indeed dire.
"Forest of the Dead": As she's about to make her Heroic Sacrifice, River Song remembers her last meeting with the Doctor — how he turned up on her door with a haircut and a new suit, and left her his sonic screwdriver — meaning that the Doctor had known River was going to die.
When the Doctor allowed Solomon to die in "Dinosaurs on a Spaceship", it was an immediate sign to Amy (and the fans) that something was wrong and cemented the theme that the Doctor shouldn't travel alone.
If it's Carly or Freddie that starts to suggest breaking and entering, vandalism or general mayhem, and not Sam, then the situation has definitely got out of hand.
Sam acting considerate and helpful worries Carly and Freddie, and they start to believe Sam is in love with their new intern.
In one episode of Clarissa Explains It All, Clarissa senses something is wrong when she sees her brother Ferguson acting nice, missing some of his favorite possessions, and unable to properly insult her.
Yes, Minister: Jim Hacker is dead set on a course of action that won't do anyone any favours, and won't be swayed. It's serious enough that Sir Humphrey even drops his incredibly elaborate Sesquipedalian Loquaciousness and tells him "If you're going to do this damn silly thing, don't do it in this damn silly way." This stops Hacker in his tracks.
Loomer: Dude, you haven't said anything since we've known you.
Buzz: Everything's been fine up until now.
In the first season and earlier second season of Dollhouse, anything Topher is against on moral grounds goes well beyond just being wrong. This is lessened with time as Topher develops more of a conscience.
Wacky stoner Alan Tudyk suddenly and wordlessly carving someone's face up in Alpha's signature style.
In the second season of Teen Wolf, while the main cast tries to keep a Brainwashed and Crazy Jackson contained by keeping him locked in, Stiles (who's on guarding duty) sends a text from Jackson's phone to his parents so that they don't worry when he doesn't get home. The thing is, as Allison tells Stiles when he informs her what he did, Jackson hasn't told his parents he loved them since he was a little child, from the moment they told him he was adopted, and Stiles included an 'I love you' at the end of his text.
Sure enough, minutes later, we're shown Jackson's father arriving to the police station to tell the Sheriff he's terribly concerned about Jackson because of this very reason and the police start immediately looking for Jackson.
Mayor Wilkins:(to Angel) Yeah, well I'd get set for a world of weeping! I'd get set for a world of pain! Misery loves company, young man, and I'm more than willing to share that with you and your whore!
Similarly, any time that meek, submissive (in early seasons) Willow loses her temper and begins to basically force her bickering team mates to cooperate by chewing them out, typically opening up with a shout of HEYYYYY!
And in the second season premiere of Buffy, Buffy's attitude problem causes her to get baited easily by the vamps, leaving her friends unprotected so that Willow, Cordelia, Giles, and Miss Calendar get kidnapped by the vampires working for the Anointed One. Xander, normally Buffy's biggest fan, lays it out for her:
In the season 5 finale of Buffy, Giles is trying, as gently as possible, to explain to Buffy that it may be necessary to kill Dawn to save not only the world but all of reality. Buffy point-blank says she's not discussing the matter until Giles jumps to his feet and shouts, "YES WE BLOODY WELL ARE!"
In Season 6 of Buffy, when Anya doesn't open the magic box for a long time after Xander left her, he is genuinely scared.
While in early seasons of Buffy Giles often chided the Scoobies for their immature behavior, he did have a certain respect for their talents and tried to speak to them like rational adults. When he eventually calls Willow out on her magic by referring to her as a "rank amateur" and an idiot, you know that the line has been crossed.
Heck, Giles in general could be a poster-boy for this. While most of the series showed him as a bookish, nerdy Watcher, some of his most terrifying moments come when he taps back into his days as a hardcore magic-user named Ripper and wipes the floor with his opponents.
If Buffy ever willingly kills or attempts to kill another human being, you know things are getting bad.
If Angel does this it's usually a sign of Angelus returning. It can also be a sign of Tranquil Fury, as Wesley finds out.
Lorne's the smiling, happy, carefree member of the team. When he begins to crack in Season 5 of Angel, it's a sign that everything's about to fall apart. He never really recovers.
In an episode, Shawn and Gus find a missing camp counselor's bloodstained pajamas. Later, when Shawn explains how he knew her disappearance had been staged, he mentions how Gus didn't freak out like he usually does when he saw the "blood," meaning he must have been in on the secret.
The first episode involving the Yin-Yang serial killer (who kidnaps Shawn's mother) involves this trope as well. Shawn has to get serious to deal with the dangerous case so he asks Gus to pick up the slack on the wacky jokes and bizarre antics for two reasons: 1) to keep anyone from noticing Shawn himself is taking this deadly serious (OoC for him), and 2) because Shawn needs those hijinks or else he'll crack under the pressure of a case this serious. What's completely in character however, is that Shawn gets Gus to agree to not tell anyone why he's acting like an idiot during a life and death struggle, earning him some confused and angry looks from other characters as it continues.
In season 7 when Henry gets shot, Shawn lets his emotions get in the way rather than acting rationally. When he investigates the suspect's home, instead of discreetly sneaking in and analyzing the evidence like he usually does, he breaks a window to get inside and trashes the place to vent his anger and frustration.
The framing device of Mystery Science Theater 3000 is that mad scientists Prof. Forrester and Frank are showing the Satellite of Love crew bad movies as part of a twisted experiment. One movie, "Manos" The Hands of Fate, was SO bad that the villains broke character, apologised to the crew, and tried to cheer them up to get them through the movie. It doesn't really work, as the bots are reduced to blubbering pools of tears and Joel has to take on the persona of Carol Channing to buffer himself against the pain.
In the same episode, at one point the normally laid-back Joel shouts "DO SOMETHING! GOD!" It's a telling indicator of how trying the movie is.
We get a similar moment in the Wild World of Batwoman where during the final pointless dance scene Tom Servo starts screaming "END! END! END!" Tom is not as laid back as Joel but he rarely screams like that.
He screams again during Mitchell when the title character descends to a child's level to have a prolonged argument.
Leverage: One of Eliot's catchphrases is "I don't like guns," usually said while reflexively unloading one after taking it off someone else. When he shoots someone (instead of killing him hand-to-hand) in The Big Bang Job it's a fairly good indicator of how seriously he takes this particular mark.
The writers of Mad Men do this on a meta level in Season 4 (which begins a few months after Don Draper's divorce). Don had previously established himself as a moderate drinker who never got more than just a bit lubricated; when Season 4 starts, he's seen stumbling home from bars, being drunk on duty, and being called an alcoholic by at least two other characters. Furthermore, he had previously been a Chivalrous Pervert who would never hit on or be creepy toward any of the women in the office, let alone have an affair or even a one-night stand with one; Season 4 brings on the occasional pass and finally an ill-advised affair with his secretary Allison. Things only start getting better for him when he finds a relationship (first with statistician Faye, and then with his secretary Megannote A relationship that had started platonically when he needed a babysitter to supervise his kids when he took them to California.). However, by this point, everyone — and particularly the audience—has gotten the message: Don's marriage was really important to him despite his seemingly cavalier attitude, and despite his womanizing, he needs a girlfriend/wife to keep him on level.
In the episode "Prototype", the team stumbles upon Khalek, a seemingly-innocent, newborn clone of Anubis, and Technical Pacifist scientist Daniel Jackson flat-out says that they should kill him. Not imprison him, not study him, not try to reason with him. Kill him. Kill him before his Goa'uld genetic memory kicks in and he remembers who he is. His reaction is understandable given the circumstances: Khalek is physiologically closer to an Ancient than an ordinary Human, with all the superpowers that entails, and furthermore he will soon be able to Ascend — and it took nothing short of a Divine Intervention to stop Anubis the first time. Daniel even lampshades this in dialogue: if he, of all people, says this is the only option, then it must be. And yes, Daniel is the one who ends up shooting him, while Khalek is busy deflecting Mitchell's shots.
In the episode "Shades of Gray", O'Neill and Hammond's unusual actions at the beginning of the episode are really the only way to tell that there's more going on than meets the eye.
In the How I Met Your Mother episode "Do I Know You?", Barney, who has recently fallen in love with Robin, takes her out to dinner on Lily's advice to make a good impression so that Robin will take him seriously and not dismiss him as the sleazy, womanizing idiot he usually is. His attempt at being chivalrous and tasteful is so impressive (he doesn't even bat an eye when the buxom waitress practically dangles her breasts under his nose) it completely weirds Robin out and she tries to make Barney act like himself again:
Barney: Insurance gonna cover that? Sometimes they don't.
Robin: That's it?
Robin: Okay... Well, um, today, I was at the dentist, that guy drilled me. All day long.
Robin: He drilled me hard.
Robin: He filled all of my cavities... Come on, man!
Barney: Well your teeth look fantastic.
Robin: Who ARE you?!
Also, Barney burning the Playbook in season eight was treated by the rest of the gang as a sign that he was serious about being in a relationship with Patrice. It's later revealed he burned the book as part of his "The Robin" play, but it's no less shocking because he genuinely meant it since "[he doesn't] need it anymore".
Adrian Monk has severe OCD and a host of other phobias, such that he frequently needs sanitary wipes. During a garbage strike in San Fancisco, he was so disturbed by the trash bags piled around that he was unable to function as a detective. By the climax of the story, he's driving a garbage truck around, picking up the garbage himself, and fingering Alice Cooper for the crime in a summation that's more implausible than usual. His friends get him to a clean room, and he gets back to normal. Relatively speaking.
There's one episode where a radio host is a suspect in a crime, and Monk appears on his show to interview him. The story of Trudy's death comes up, and one of the hosts offers his condolences. The suspect, who's a serious Jerkass, starts making tasteless jokes. You know Monk is pissed when the normally mild-mannered detective who abstains from physical contact jumps across the table to tackle the man.
And Natalie is not immune either in "Mr. Monk Gets Lotto Fever." Normally, she's very accepting of Monk's OCD behaviors and has a bubbly personality, but when she becomes a lottery hostess, Monk observes her becoming a full-tilt diva. For example, in one scene, she gets incredibly pissed when she trips over some sound wires, getting into a heated argument with the sound engineer, which culminates in the station manager being involved, and said engineer being fired because he's got a hot streak. Monk even says he's observed it when he talks to Dr. Bell:
Dr. Neven Bell: But I see your point about the monkey.
Adrian Monk: All I'm trying to say is... it's not the same Natalie! If you knew her you wouldn't know her! Last night after the show, she got somebody fired!
Dr. Neven Bell: Really?
Adrian Monk: One of the crew, sound guy! There were some wires on the floor, and she was just like [leans back in his chairs and snarls like a raptor] you know, complaining.
Subverted in "The Concert", during The Middle's third season. After an early exit from a spelling bee, an event he had gone all the way to the regionals in the previous season, Brick, usually cool and unflappably optimistic, is angry and then depressed, remaining in his room the next day and vowing never to return to school. His parents are actually happy because it's an emotionally appropriate response from a child not known for them.
In one of the DVD Commentaries for Firefly, Joss Whedon points out that Alan Tudyk has a great ability to sell the gravity of situations just by looking upset.
In an episode of Red Dwarf: When Rimmer seems against filming women in the showers, Holly remarks "Alright, who are you, and what have you done with our Rimmer?"
In Season Six finale "Out of Time", the Starbug crew is facing what appears to be certain death in a fight with their morally-repugnant but technologically-superior future selves. When asked whether to capitulate or fight, Rimmer's response? "We Fight! Better dead than smeg!"
In The A-Team, when "Howlin' Mad" Murdock drops his psychosis of the week and takes a turn for the serious, you know something big is going down.
Penny pinching patriarch Jim Royle of The Royle Family never misses an opportunity to complain at his mother-in-law or save money. So what does he say to his wife Barbara at her Nana's funeral? "I'd give all the money in the world to have one last drink with her."
And when he wins £100 on a scratch card he hides the fact from Barbara and seems to spend a little too much money out drinking it looks to us and Barbara that Jim is being a selfish miser again. But come Christmas Day, just after Barbara shouts at him for hiding the money in front of the whole family, she finds that Jim had bought her a new wedding ring to replace the one she lost a few months back.
This is Jim in a nutshell. He's usually lazy, abrasive, selfish, tactless and sometimes outright verbally abusive, but when his family really need him to step up, he does the right thing.
Dr. Cox of Scrubs is The Nicknamer to the rest of the cast and never lets any of them in emotionally. But once in a blue moon, he'll drop the nicknames and talk from the heart. Though he rarely ever calls JD by his name (and even then, it's always by his last name), one episode has him address him as JD, while thanking him for helping him out of his Heroic BSOD.
Another example would be when, furious at J.D for ditching his interns, he yells "Where the hell is Dorian!". Yelling isn't OOC, but calling him Dorian definitely is.
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: "Improbable Cause": after three years and an entire episode full of blatantcheerfulobfuscation, when the crew realises the Romulans are trying to assassinate him, Sisko asks Garak why they'd want to. Garak responds with a simple "I don't know" and the entire room falls silent in shock as they realise he's telling the truth. It emphasises how ominous the situation actually is: as the show's resident Magnificent Bastard and Knowledge Broker, Garak either knows everything or can guess what he doesn't know. To see him so stumped that he's actually cooperating with the truth is as stunning for the audience as it is for the crew.
Quark's chilling line in "The Siege of AR-558" regarding how even the nicest humans can turn into bloodthirsty killers if they are deprived of their normal comforts and placed in danger over a long period of time. This after spending 6+ seasons mainly as a comic relief character.
The Star Trek: The Next Generation episode Q Who? features Starfleet's first encounter with the Borg, thanks to Q's machinations. When he is blamed for the deaths of 18 crew members in a confrontation, he drops all pretenses of being a Trickster GodJerkass and utters a chilling, "Oh please." With those 2 words, the audience (and the crew) realize that Q's amiable persona is simply one aspect of his being, which he can discard at will.
For example, in The Most Toys, that Data failed to transmit a bit of shuttle flight information to Enterprise is the first bit of evidence LaForge finds that Data's shuttle accident was staged. The transmission was so trivial that any other pilot might have just skipped it without arousing suspicion, but Data never takes shortcuts.
Another, more dramatic example from The Most Toys: Data has a fundamental respect for life, especially sentient life. So if a character is evil and dangerous enough to drive him to attempt cold-blooded murder...
More commonly, if Data uses a contraction, it's usually either a sign that Lore is around, or that you're stuck in an illusion.
In the Top Gear Bolivia special, there's a scene where Jeremy Clarkson tells his fellow hosts to stick together as they cross the Andes while suffering from altitude sickness (not surprising as they are traveling at 17000 feet, well above the altitude where supplemental oxygen/pressurized cabins are required for aircraft). Considering that this is pretty much the complete inverse of how they usually behave, it drives home exactly how dangerous the situation with the high altitude is.
Also in the above, the trio a traversing a dangerously narrow mountain road with no railings, and James 'Captain Slow' May tells the others not to ram him as they usually would. Normally he would take such taunts on the nose. This time, though, he gets out of his car, goes over to Jeremy's, leans in the window, and proceeds to threaten Jeremy with a machete.
Another example from that same situation. Normally, if one of them fall behind due to the car malfunctioning in some way, the others leave him to spite him. On the death road, the headlights on James' car stop working and he asks Richard to not abandon him. Richard listens.
The first overseas special in the US has two instances of this: First Instance The trio drive through Alabama with offensive slogans scrawled on their cars. This stunt almost gets them attacked by, to put it bluntly, rednecks. The gravity of the situation is driven home by Clarkson being unflinchingly polite to the gathering mob in a desperate attempt to defuse the situation.Second Instance When the trio arrive in New Orleans, which was ravaged by Hurricane Katrina a scant year before and still hadn't shown any sign of recovery, they immediately stop the joking and decide to quit the last part of their challenge in favour of donating their cars to needy families for free
In the Syria special, when James suffers a serious head injury that requires medical attention, they immediately rush over to help him.
In Dinosaurs, Baby always hits Earl over the head and calls him "Not-The-Mama" instead of "Daddy". When he becomes seriously ill, he starts calling Earl "Daddy" and tells him he loves him. The family freaks out and get him cured as quickly as possible. Everyone is relieved when Baby hits Earl and calls him "Not-The-Mama" after he is cured.
In the final season of 24, Jack Bauer snaps after Renee Walker is killed and goes on a Roaring Rampage of Revenge in an attempt to kill all responsible after the President betrays him by covering it up. Realizing that he isn't in his right mind at the moment, Chloe refuses to go along with him and says that he needs to be brought in, causing Jack to actually threaten her. Chloe lampshades it herself later on that he's never done that before.
Many uncharacteristic moments of affection by Sherlock towards others (especially towards John, Mrs Hudson or Molly Hooper) are listed in the Crowning Moment of Heartwarming page but one notable example is when Sherlock meets Irene Adler. When she says "Brainy's the new sexy" his normally perfect enunciation fails for a second and he mumbles his next sentence. John's expression shows how big a deal this is. Benedict Cumberbatch indicates that Sherlock's verbal keyboard mash happened in response to John's obvious interest in Irene Adler's flirting.
There is reason to suspect that Sherlock's embarrassed fumbling speech was an artifice to keep Miss Adler off balance seeing how he used knowledge gained during that initial encounter to coldly manipulate her emotionally throughout the rest of the story.
Sherlock offering to do the groceries or making coffee should have tipped John off that something was wrong.
In The Hounds of Baskerville, it's a huge deal to see Sherlock and, to a slightly lesser extent, John, experiencing and expressing devastating levels of fear:
Sherlock: (clutching a glass of whiskey and shaking badly) Look at me, John. I'm afraid.
With one line Sherlock lets the audience know how bad things are in The Reichenbach Fall.
Sherlock: You were right. I'm not okay.
For the entirety of Blackadder's first season, the only line not screamed, bellowed or roared by Richard IV is the one where he softly says to his son, "If you cross me now...or ever... I shall do to you what God did unto the Sodomites." In the whole dark, bitingly cynical world of the series, it's possibly the one time when one of the buffoonishly over the top characters ever qualifies as being genuinely scary.
You could make a case for any character played by BRIAN BLESSED to be especially worrisome when they start talking softly.
In the finale of the last episode of the fourth series set in the trenches of The First World War, George, who has been all full of bravado and impatience to "go over the top" for the entire series, admits that he's scared now that they really are going over the top and doesn't want to die. And later on in the scene, Blackadder, who has continually insulted and ridiculed his comrades, especially Baldrick, says, in response to Baldrick's last ditch "cunning plan" that we never get to hear: "Well, whatever it was I'm sure it was better than my plan to get out of this by pretending to be mad, I mean who would have noticed another madman round here? (sincerely) Good luck everyone."
Richard Castle is normally a charming, witty, up-beat, mystery novelist who spends most of each episode geeking out about something. When his daughter Alexis is kidnapped he asks very quietly to be left alone in a room with one of the people involved, who has repeatedly refused to give the police any information. After some of the scariest things Castle has ever said are said, the next thing anyone outside the room hears is a long, high-pitched scream. Castle got the information he wanted.
In the Game of Thrones episode "The Rains of Castamere", the normally stoic and to-the-point Lord Roose Bolton is acting increasingly festive and merry during a wedding, even though he refuses alcoholic drinks throughout. The wedding is going to end in a massacre, and Bolton is part of the conspiracy. He finds the happiness of the wedding guests who are about to die incredibly amusing. Catelyn notices, but by the time she puts it together and realizes he's wearing chainmail under his robes it's already too late.
In season 4 of Warehouse 13 Mrs. Fredrick arrives to help solve a problem, but seems somewhat confused. Artie and Steve aren't particularly concerned until she starts walking away instead of her usual Offscreen Teleportation.
Steve: She didn't just disappear, she walked away. Walked!
When Morgan calls Devon by his real name, rather than Awesome, it clues him in immediately that something is out of sorts.
Chuck under the influence of Laudenol. Even when he's using the Intersect to kick ass and take names Chuck is still his generally affable self, while the drug turns him ice cold. Even without knowing why, you'd realize something was very wrong seeing him in such a state.
Subtly used in "Chuck Versus the A-Team" with the two Intersected Gretas, Captains Dunwoody and Noble (Stacy Keibler and Isaiah Mustafa, respectively). Both are noticeably more arrogant and cold when in possession of the Intersect than in their previous appearances. Immediately after the Intersect's removal, they revert to their more affable original personalities.
When Decker attempts to interrupt Chuck's unauthorized mission to approach Volkoff about a cure for the Norseman weapons system, Casey turns white when he recognizes the voice. Chuck immediately points out that Casey doesn't react that way.
Morgan forgetting pop-cultural references like Indiana Jones and Star Wars is the first clue that something is very wrong with the version of the Intersect he uploaded.
Throughout the first half to the series finale, Chuck notices small details that show something is wrong with Sarah. He dismisses them initially, but it ultimately leads to the reveal (to the cast, the audience having already been made aware of this in the preceding episode) that she has been mind-wiped by the Intersect.
Agents Of Shield: Phil Coulson, Team Dad who's Seen It All, is very rarely rattled by anything and hardly ever has cause to even raise his voice. When he does, you know something has gone very wrong. When he straight-up yells at you, then you know you really screwed up.
This is used to heartbreaking effect in ''The Magical Place'' when Coulson starts crying when Raina tells him how upset his cellist girlfriend was by his "death", and then is seen begging to be allowed to die during the operation on his brain to rewrite his post-death memories.
Another heartbreaking example is in Yes Men, when he breaks down when telling Skye the truth behind the drug that saved both their lives. He then says that he's chucking out the rule book in order to go after the people responsible for everything that was done to him and Skye, something quite at odds with his very lawful nature during the movies.
Melinda May gets this in "T.A.H.I.T.I." when she beats the ever-loving crap out of Ian Quinn while he's in SHIELD custody for shooting Skye. She is normally The Stoic, so her intense display of emotion is a sign that the situation is deadly serious.
Use for comedic value in "I Will Face My Enemy" when May is undercover as a cheerful, flighty, laughing wife. Hearing her laugh and talk so much freaks Coulson's team out.
On Hells Kitchen, Gordon Ramsay is usually the definition of Mean Brit; not because he's a bad person, but because seeing people squander their talents or potential is his Berserk Button. So the few times when he's polite or complimentary to a contestant, it's 100% whole-hearted, and generally produces a heartwarming moment.
In Season 6 of the US version, Gordon refers to contestant Robert as "Bobby", which greatly upsets the normally jovial man. During a private meeting later, Robert explains that Bobby was the name of his abusive father, who always told him he'd never amount to anything. Gordon apologizes for unintentionally bringing up painful memories and promises never to use that name again.
Margaret: You don't usually say, "Hey there, Margaret."
Toby: (giggles) What do I usually say?
Margaret: You usually growl something inaudible.
Toby: Not today.
Margaret: I see.
Toby: You, on the other hand, should turn that frown upside down.
Margaret: I'm sorry.
Toby: Let a smile be your umbrella, Margaret.
Margaret: Okay, now you're scaring the crap out of me, Toby.
In episode 3 of The Musketeers, the normally calm and stoic Athos simply shut down after discovering his wife Milady whom he had executed was actually alive. When he dazedly tried to explain to D'Artagnan and became more and more frantic, D'Artagnan was noticeably alarmed and frightened.
This is invoked by Philip on The Americans when he approaches Arkady in a bookstore. Philip is a highly trained, highly competent KGB sleeper agent and Arkady is the embassy's KGB resident. The FBI knows who Arkady is and regularly has him followed. For Philip to approach Arkady in a public place, where they can be easily spotted by the FBI, is a gross violation of operational security and risks destroying decades of espionage work. A spy with Philip's experience would never do it under normal circumstances. Philip does this deliberately to send a clear message to his bosses in Moscow about how extremely upset he is about their plan to recruit Philip's daughter as a spy. If Philip is willing to risk exposure merely to send a warning, there is no telling what he would do if the KGB actually tries to go forward with the plan.
Happens again during the season 9 finale when the depths of the Mark of Cain's effects on Dean are illustrated when he leaves his cheeseburger entirely untouched, again saying he isn't hungry.
Punky Brewster's friend Cherie is normally sweet and effervescent, but in "The Anniversary," she suddenly becomes introverted and quiet. Punky finds out the day marks when Cherie parents were killed in a traffic accident. Punky persuades Cherie to visit the graves at the cemetery, and there Cherie has a cathartic heart-to-heart with her departed parents that even moves Punky to tears.
Mr. Young: At the end of "Mr. Space", Adam realizes he has changed Finnegan for the better when Derby and Slab, who ordinarily can barely spell their own names, start spouting off science trivia.
Also in another episode, both Derby and Ivy are visibly disturbed when the latter compliments the former.
When Delenn first sees a Soul Hunter in the first season, she grabs a gun and tries to kill him. Sinclair is taken aback and notes that he'd never seen this in the time they've known each other.
In the fourth season, Londo and Vir are on Centauri Prime discussing the need to remove Cartagia from the throne. Vir is hoping they can do it without resorting to bloodshed but then they meet Cartagia, just up from personally torturing G'Kar and watering plants in the garden with his blood. Vir decodes right then and there he needs to die.
Two seasons before, Earth and the Minbar lodge protests over the use of mass drivers by the Centauri against the Narn homeworld, but the fact that the Vorlons also lodge one shows just how bad this is.
Kim Kardashian and her mother Kris are well-known (and mocked) for their performances as zany, melodramatic and dim-witted socialites in the Keeping up with the Kardashians reality show and spinoffs. In a recent episode, Kim and Kris visited Vienna, where a blackface performer pretending to be Kanye West was at an event they attended. Both of them, especially Kim, dropped their "act", stopped smiling and made it very clear that the situation was in no way funny.
In the Two and a Half Men episode titled "That Pistol-Packin' Hermaphrodite", Charlie tells Rose (his stalker) he's getting married. Rose visibly forces a very calm response and, for the first time in the series, leaves the house using the front door.
Jesus: It is written: "My house shall be a place of prayer." But you are turning it into a den of thieves.
If you read the account carefully, you'll note that this wasn't a hot-blooded moment of rage. No, Jesus "made a whip out of cords" (John 2:15), which takes a good bit of time. Tranquil Fury with extreme deliberation.
Not as OOC as one might think. Jesus' one true Berserk Button is hypocrisy, in any form.
Another example would be when Jesus curses the fig tree, causing it to wither and die. This is the only time that He is shown to use His gifts/talents/powers in a way that does not cause life and healing for the recipient (certain Apocrypha notwithstanding).
There is even a saying about Buddha, the poster boy for patience, serenity, that goes like this : "Even the Buddha will get angry if slapped thrice in the face" for The Stoic finally snapping. Basically, the threshold is high, but if you are stupid enough to repeatedly annoy them, even a Saint is going to snap at you, and it's going to be Serious Business.
Since wrestling announcers are supposed to be loud and talking all the time, it was always a pretty safe bet that when they went completely silent, it was a sign that someone was legitimately hurt (instead of when they kept talking, which showed it was part of the show). However, that's not quite as accurate now, since the people behind the scenes have caught on to this, and have started to use dead air when trying to sell a Kayfabe injury.
While announcers do use the "Owen Voice" as it is known by internet fans, they will make it very clear when a real injury or accident happens, by repeatedly dropping all pretenses of kayfabe and telling the audience that it is not part of the show. This was most recently seen during Jerry Lawler's heart attack during the show. He got drowsy, passed out, started snoring, then there was a silence for a while. While he was being attended to by EMTs, the crowd reacted to it, and Michael Cole tried to carry on commentary for a few minutes while the match went on. Then he went completely silent for the rest of the match. When they came back from commerical, he (in tears) related to the home audience that Jerry Lawler had a heart attack while at the desk and that it was not part of the show. All updates through out the rest of the show were prefaces with "this is not part of the show". Being pro wrestling, it eventually became part of the show when he returned after 10 weeks and top heels CM Punk and Paul Heyman made fun of it by having Paul fake a heart attack in the ring. This was followed up by every heel on commentary making some kind of joke about his heart attack.
John Cena is almost always above everything, just laughing off anything resembling a threat. Until The Wyatt Family came after him. Thus far the Wyatts have proven to be the only thing that can make Cena show actual fear.
Kermit: You never miss the chance to shoot yourself out a cannon, is something wrong?
A number of character-driven RPGs give characters compulsions to act in certain ways and require expending resources to ignore them, effectively making Out-of-Character a form of Heroic BSOD. For example, Exalted calls it "Limit Break"note No relation to the trope and forces the Solars to either take their greatest Virtue to extremes or invert it, Lunars to act animalistic and Sidereals to stubbornly force Fate into a path dependant on their caste.
Similarly, Scion has Virtues (such as Loyalty, Duty, or Courage); every pantheon reveres four of them, and their Scions are expected to uphold them. If a Scion resists his or her Virtues too hard, they can explode into Virtue Extremities, causing the Scion to burst into extreme behavior; a Loyal Scion will throw herself into the line of fire for her friends even if they beg her not to, a Courageous Scion goes into an Unstoppable Rage, an Expressive Scion will quite literally bleed for his art, and so on.
Speaking of Tyranids, when the vast eternally hungry Hive Mind leaves a certain light-years wide area of space alone, it's probably for a good reason.
On Mighty Thews: characters have what is called a "D20 trait", since each skill is assigned a dice value. By acting in concert with your D20 character trait, you earn a reroll token in a scene; but if you act opposite to it, you can roll a D20 for one skill roll, which means quite a bit when D12 is the largest available die.
In Disgaea: Hour of Darkness, Etna's final episode preview does not focus on her and is actually an accurate portrayal of the final chapter. The other characters promptly freak out.
A more serious example shows up in his side-quest. Jan is approached by his cousin and the two chat merrily about the family and said cousin's life at the circus. Then said cousin mentions that Lissa is living in the Jansen home at the moment. Jan immediately drops his regular persona and states "did he hurt her". The ensuing quest, which is fairly dark by Baldur's Gate standards already, contains Jan making absolutely zero jokes and several death treats towards Lissa's abusive husband.
There's another one when the resident Boisterous Bruiser ranger Minsc, who will otherwise go Leeroy Jenkins on anything he sees as evil, advises the player character to "come back later with a bigger sword" when confronted by the red dragon. Even the most novel player should get the hint that dragons are Bonus Bosses which you don't fight until you are very, very sure of your abilities and equipment.
In Final Fantasy X-2, whenever Rikku and Brother agree on something, the general reaction is "take cover."
There are several scenes where Squall, normally keeping himself completely under tight emotional control, will suddenly flip out with little warning when something happens that deeply upsets him. Early on it is after he's told Seifer was killed and he starts wondering what others would think about him if he died. Later on, he flips out when NORG tells him that Garden and the SeeDs were nothing but expendable troops, and he finally starts jumping violently at anything that threatens Rinoa after he admits his feelings for her.
It's generally a bad sign whenever a member or former member of the Omega Team in Last Scenario changes expressions. Helios really takes the cake, though—no matter what you do to him, he never stops smirking, right up until the sequence in which he sacrifices his life to let Castor escape.
In the Shivering Isles add-on for The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, your biggest clue that things are about to go bad is when Sheogorath tells you you're out of time with an explaination of the concept of time, which is a bit too orderly and lucid for the usually chaotic and wacky Sheogorath, indicating that he's about to become Jyggalag and begin the destruction of the titular isles.
Although, in the previous quest, it's pointed out that Jyggalag has resorted to subterfuge due to the player's involvement, which actually gives Sheogorath some hope.
The Motor Mouth salarian doctor Mordin Solus never uses personal pronouns. It is part of his general personality, which focuses on conveying the most information possible in the shortest amount of time, but is also his way of depersonalizing what he is talking about to deal with the guilt of the things he has done. Except once, in the third game, if, when trying to talk him out of curing the genophage, you point out he was the one who previously helped strengthen it.
Mordin: I MADE A MISTAKE!
This is a double OoC moment, as Mordin normally never shouts. Makes the moment all the more poignant. On a lesser scale, he says "My mistake" on his loyalty mission when he finds out that Maelon was not kidnapped and instead was voluntarily helping to cure the genophage. The key word in both of these examples is "mistake." Mordin is never insensitive to the consequences of his actions, but his tremendous intelligence and pride make it difficult for him to acknowledge when he's made a bad decision, which means he'll defend the genophage modification as distasteful but necessary every time you confront him about it up until you reach the Shroud.
He does also use a personal pronoun on at least two other occasions, one time being a callback to the previous time
Mordin: Had to be me, someone else might have gotten it wrong.
In the second game, he gets a line if you're romancing someone where he talks quickly about the medical consequences of a one-night stand, such as suggesting biotic suppressors for a romance with Jack or cautioning that oral contact with Thane could cause hallucinations. These are usually lighthearted and semi-comedic, unless you're romancing Tali, who is of a species with an extremely weak immune system and has to spend most of her time in an environment suit, in which case he sounds a lot more sober because, well, if she lets you into her suit without extreme preparation, she could die.
Shepard themself has one after the fall of Thessia. Normally, when Shepard responds to someone saying something inappropriate, they will have at least one option to say something that's at worst, mildly chiding, or ignoring it. After Joker makes a very unfunny crack, Shepard's Paragon response is snapping at him, indicating just how near the Despair Event Horizon s/he's come. An earlier Shepard moment occurred in the Project Overlord DLC. You know Shepard's pissed off when the usually noble Paragon interrupt is to pistol-whip someone. In the same vein, Zaeed's loyalty mission involves him setting a refinery on fire while there are still innocents inside it, at which point Paragon Shepard punches him in the face and yells at him.
There's a popular saying that goes, "You will only see a turian's back when he's dead," which makes their retreat from Palaven near the end of the game show just how serious and hopeless the situation against the Reapers is.
The usually calm, if eager for a fight, Wrex will snap completely if you sabotage the genophage cure in the third game. It's actually scary seeing him shouting at the top of his lungs and firing a shotgun at Shepard - but then again, his unborn son just died as a result of you stabbing him in the back.
Female!Shepard gets one herself near the end of the if you romanced Garrus. When saying their goodbyes before the final push, the conversation starts out light-hearted enough, but near the end, Shepard, yes, the same Shepard who kept her cool as she sacrificed a teammate on Virmire, ran a suicide run on the Collector base, and watched helplessly as Earth fell to the Reapers, actually begins to break down into tears. Bonus points to the fact that this isn't just Shepard's reaction; Jennifer Hale stated that this line was one the most emotional moments for her in the game. It really helps to drive the point home about just how much pressure is mounting on Shepard and her team, not to mention the fact that she knows that she's likely not going to come out of this alive.
In Sabres Of Infinity Elson, a friendly Perpetual Smiler, gets EXTREMELY angry at you if you break the rules of engagement, particularly if you disobeyed his direct orders in order to do so.
Elson: I shall write to Grenadier Square of this. Next time, if there is a next time, you will follow orders, or I will see your sword broken, your career in tatters and what's left of you on a ship southwards so that you may live the rest of your life in infamy. Am I understood?
In Tales of the Abyss, Jade says, after weighing the possible benefits of Luke sacrificing himself, tells Luke that "as (his) friend" he feels compelled to stop him, prompting Luke to point out that he never called him his friend before. Jade then apologizes, something that's equally uncharacteristic of him. Much earlier in the game, Jade gets visibly angry when he realizes that the villains are using fomicry.
Kyrie Florian is a flirty, coy, and playful character with a manipulative streak who doesn't seem to take things too seriously... unless if something she really cares about is brought up, such as her dying planet or her dying father-creator, then that personality drops, showing The UnfetteredDeterminator underneath.
Levi the Slasher acts like a hyperactive Cheerful Child practically all the time, save for near the climax of the game when she decides to join Stern in her Suicide Mission to stop the growth of the Unbreakable Darkness. Here, she expresses a rare moment of seriousness and thoughtfulness that surprises Stern and ultimately convinces her to allow her fellow Material to help her with her plan.
Given the tragic ending of Super Metroid, this appears to have been the intended trope for Samus Aran throughout much of Metroid: Other M. However, no previous personality had been properly established for her outside of an obscure manga, so most people interpreted it as the norm for her, and were not pleased. She does display some Not So Stoic moments in the game though.
In StarCraft Brood War, protoss campaign, when Razhagal orders the extermination of a dissenting group of Aiur survivors, Zeratul remarks that she would never act so malevolently, and was able to figure out that she was under the sway of Kerrigan.
In World of Warcraft, Thrall's teacher Drek'thar has been gradually becoming senile, so whenever he becomes lucid, it's a sign that he feels strongly about something. He does so in The Shattering Prelude to Cataclysm when he hears about Cairne Bloodhoof dying, demanding to know how he could have been killed. He does so again in a quest in which the player asks him to help the Forsaken war effort; since he is a repentant Old Horde war criminal who is haunted by the memories of the atrocities he committed, he is horrified that the Forsaken could commit similar atrocities without feeling anything.
In Warcraft III, Medivh is perpetually calm while trying to subtly unite the mortal races against the Burning Legion. The sole exception is when Jaina calls him mad for suggesting she ally with the Horde, at which point Medivh angrily yells, "Have you heard nothing I've said!?"
In Borderlands, Angel never cracks a joke, remains somewhat aloof, and is constantly flattering the Vault Hunters. In Borderlands 2, she takes a much snarkier, more conversational tact. This is because Handsome Jack was feeding her lines in the first game, while she's speaking naturally in the second. In fact, when she goes back to talking like she did in the first game during the battle with Wilhelm, it's a sign that Handsome Jack is ordering her to deceive the Vault Hunters.
In Baten Kaitos Origins, Milly and Guillo are constantly Volleying Insults, even after they become friends. At the end of the game, Milly starts a fairly serious conversation with Guillo about her feelings for Sagi. Guillo quickly picks up that something's wrong, and it's right - she's about to make a Heroic Sacrifice. It also counts as one for Guillo, who is completely at a loss for words.
In Resident Evil 6 Sherry spends all of her first chapter with Jake being calm, collected, and Adorkable. So when Ustanak shows up and she looses her nerve and screams "RUN!!!" you know he's a serious threat.
In Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines you meet Nines Rodriguez, a Brujah who leads the Anarchs in Los Angeles and is as tough and fearless as someone can manage to be. Close to the end of the game, both of you meet a certain type of creature that anyone who has any previous knowledge about the setting will fear. Those who don't know the setting will learn to fear it when your character asks "Are you afraid?" and Nines answers "Yes. Yes, I am afraid".
Star Control II: there is one thing that will break the Ur-Quan's demeanor of self-assured superiority and authority: telling them that a fully sentient Dnyarri has emerged. If you know their backstory, you know exactly why this makes the Ur-Quan practically soil themselves with apprehension and fear. This is also the only way in the game to talk to an Ur-Quan and avoid battle with them afterwards: as thanks for informing them of the threat, they will let you go free.
In Fire Emblem Awakening, Owain, one of the game's Kids from the Future, is a boisterous, loud, Large Ham of a character, parodying a number of anime and JRPG tropes and generally being hard to take seriously. In his support conversations with his father, he breaks down crying when it's revealed that in the Bad Future, his father died protecting him from an enemy ambush when a similar event happens in the present. This happens again in the Harvest Scramble DLC map, when Owain suddenly and very seriously asks Inigo how many people he's killed, with both revealing how horrible they felt killing for the first time. Being a Turn-Based Strategy game, the player will almost certainly have cut down innumerable foes by this point with no consequence, making the conversation incredibly jarring.
Inigo: Wha—?! Owain! What kind of a question is that? If this is more of your usual fun and games, it hardly seems appropriate.
In the Future Past 2 DLC, an alternate version of Owain speaks normally almost the entire time, when he, Inigo, Yarne, and Brady are faced with a life-or-death crisis. He only goes back to his usual, boistrous self at the end of the mission if everyone made it out safely.
Persona 4's protagonist, Yu Narukami, is normally calm and very level-headed...but in late November, when the rest of the Investigation Team is discussing tossing alleged TV murder perpetrator Namatame into the TV, he gets so irritated by the team's anger-clouded judgement that, in his only fit of anger in the game, he tells everyone to "Calm the hell down!"
Jurassic Park The Game: John Hammond in the films is a kindly old man, who deeply respects the dinosaurs and desires for them to be able to live and flourish in the world he gave them. Which means you know he's not joking around when he says that the Troodon are far too dangerous to be kept at the Park and orders them euthanised. To add an additional comparison, the Velociraptors were considered too intelligent and dangerous to be public park attractions and yet despite Muldoon's insistence, he kept them alive.
Phoenix is always flustered or worried about his cases in some way. But sometimes, he stands perfectly still and and speaks calmly and with absolute confidence. When this happens, not only will he find the killer, but they'll probably be convicted of half a dozen other crimes too. The first time is in game one case four. After Phoenix clears his client of one murder, they admit to another. Naturally, he doesn't believe they did it. In the ensuing recess, Maya freaks out and then asks Phoenix why he's looking at a photograph. Phoenix's response? "I'm preparing our case."
At one point in 2-4 he actually manages to intimidate the judge, something usually reserved for the prosecution or certain witnesses.
In Case 1-3, Edgeworth starts to morph from being a jerkass to a Jerk with a Heart of Gold when he helps prevent Dee Vasquez from escaping the court by demanding she testify about after finding the body (which Phoenix hadn't thought to ask her). The only reason Phoenix can think of for why he did this was because he agreed that the evidence was compelling enough that Vasquez was the real murderer, but this was the first time that he put finding the true criminal above maintaining his perfect trial record, which had been shattered in the previous case.
In Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney, Klavier is typically laid-back in court, even when Apollo pokes holes in his arguments, and enjoys using Gratuitous German. When Vera Misham's testimony indicates that she was responsible for forging the page out of Magnifi's diary, which Klavier uncovered on a tip from his brother and got Phoenix disbarred, Klavier is visibly shocked, and calls her "Ms. Misham" rather than "Fraulein" or other variants thereof.
Later, when Kristoph is on the stand, Klavier becomes much more hardcore in his prosecuting, blocking most of Apollo's arguments. Trucy speculates that he wants to impress his big brother.
In general, most of the witnesses will have a breakdown point where, if they're pretending to be sweet, naive, innocent, or any other personality type, they'll drop the act altogether. In the case of characters like April May or Dahlia Hawthorne, it can be pretty scary. In the case of Yanni Yogi, who completely drops the braindead routine he'd been using for the entire case, Maya even comments that he seems to be a different person entirely.
After she and Edgeworth almost get shot by Callisto Yew, Franziska's confident front fades and she is visibly frightened.
Similarly, the single time when Kenji calms down enough to speak reasonably and offer Hisao emotional support, you know it's gonna bring up a Tear Jerker.
In Emi's route, when Emi and Hisao meet after she throws Hisao out of her house, Rin becomes surprisingly direct and to-the-point.
Rin: Hisao is kind of worried about you, Emi. I don't think he can decide, or maybe I don't believe him, but I think I'm going to go somewhere less awkward now.
Hisao Narrates: I'm so surprised by Rin's being so suddenly forward about well, anything at all, that I merely watch her head through the door.
Hanako exploding at Hisao in her bad ending. She also tells him to "...Go away" when he tries to check on her in Lilly's route, surprising him.
In Lilly's route, Shizune, a typically blunt girl who has a rivalry with Lilly, responds to Hisao telling her that he's going out with Lilly by saying that it's his business who he dates, and she hopes they go well together, which Hisao implies is her not saying what's on her mind. She then is about to say something more, but has Misha not translate her signing, which makes Hisao wonder why Shizune would pull a punch or speak without forethought.
In Fate/stay night, in the Heaven's Feel route, it is the first cue for the player who went through Unlimited Blade Works and witnessed firsthand the insane determination Archer puts into accomplishing his goal, killing his younger unwitting self Shirou, that some VERY SERIOUS shit is about to hit the fan when Archer witnesses the damage done, and at the drop of a hat, postpones his personal vendetta with Shirou, to switch back into full Counter Guardian mode, and deal with the more pressing, in the end literally world-threatening, issue of the Shadow.
Dr. Bartholomew Oobleck, prior to his role upgrade in Volume 2, was known as a coffee-guzzling, fast talking, and overall strange history teacher at Beacon Academy, focused on the idea that history is, and always will be, important to the events of today. But when he explains to Ruby why history is important, he does so with a gentle voice, and a clear explanation without taking a single gulp of caffeine.
The trolls all have a characteristic quirk or two when it comes to communicating through their messaging system. When Gamzee's changed from "hOnK" to "honk HONK", signifying that he's now sober and completely Ax-Crazy, Karkat freaked out. (Along with the rest of the readers.)
CG: OH MY GOD
CG: NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
Feferi and Eridan typically have very distinctive typing styles, but drop their quirks briefly to have a serious conversation about Feferi being Eridan's Morality Chain.
As of Act 6, you know something's up when Terezi, who is normally the resident Handicapped Badass and The Chessmaster who is obsessed with smelling and tasting everything as replacement for her missing eyesight, suddenly starts hiding her eyes behind her dragon hood and acts more withdrawn. It would seem that meeting the pre-scratch version of her ancestor made her feel more self-conscious, and some of her behavior could also be caused what is revealed sometime later that she and Gamzee are filling a black quadrant together, and at some point she had Aranea fix her eyes.
Later in Act 6, when Gamzee is staring with a blank expression at something, you know it's weird.
Dave again . . .
DAVE: jade this is STUPID DAVE: my quest is a STUPID PIECE OF GARBAGE QUEST for LAME SHITTY LOSER FUCKHEADS WHO SUCK BALLS WHILE CRAPPING THEIR PANTS JADE: omg JADE: youve really spent way too much time alone with karkat havent you DAVE: ... DAVE: i need help :(
When Torg starts to actually think (or simply stops acting silly), you know business has just got serious. Often coupled with Let's Get Dangerous.
In "Oceans Unmoving", Honest Stu always tells the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth — no matter how awkward or dangerous the occasion or rhetorical the question. The one time he actually lies, and just for the fun of it too, is when he is dying, very nearly with his last words.
Belkar again after Malack kills Durkon and turns him into a vampire spawn. Roy is so furious and disbelieving at Belkar's account of the events he threatens to kill him. But after he tells them about Durkon asking Malack to spare the rest of the Order, Haley believes him because she doesn't believe the canonically Chaotic Evil Belkar is capable of making something like that up.
In Questionable Content, the normally-calm-and-passive Marten is furious after Dora flips out on him and Faye for thinking they were fooling aroundnote actually Marten calming Faye down from a panic attack, which startles Faye.
In Schlock Mercenary, Captain Tagon is being briefed on an AI that was found in the massive space station where their mission is taking place. After Tagon is told the AI's name is translated to "Broken Wind", he asks if Ennebsy made a "fart joke" before diving into the computer to fight the AI. When told he did not, Captain Tagon says, "We '''are''' in trouble".
In Gunnerkrigg Court, Ysengrin is a Yes-Man who is wholly devoted to Coyote. When he learns that Coyote knew all along that the Court tricked Reynardine and imprisoned him and did nothing to help him he immediately calls him out on it, asking him how he could leave Reynardine trapped there. Especially notable since previous interactions between Ysengrin and Reynardine indicated that they were not particularly fond of each other.
In Slice of Life, when Pumpkin Cake passes up the chance to make mischief, her parents (and Pinkie Pie) can tell she's really upset.
Vixen of the DesuDesBrigade is very relaxed, informal and happy in most of her reviews, even in a lot of the shows that squick her out. Then came her Film Fox review of The Twilight Saga: New Moon, where she's in complete distress with no escape throughout and screams more than once.
She never apologizes. So when she tells Nella that she's sorry for not including her in a review, you can see the manipulation coming a mile off.
More seriously, The Christmas Shoes was so awful about having the kid (whose mother was dying) being taught the values of earning money that she — a self-admitted Child Hater — ended up screaming at the adults for how monstrous they were acting.
He starts his review of Caligula out of character claiming that it's his favorite movie and that it's going to be hard to "Snob" it.
During the film Elves, the main character's stepmother kills her cat. Brad (a well-known Kindhearted Cat Lover) snarls, "I'd kill her. I'd fucking kill her!" — without any of the Snob's usual tone.
At the end of his review of Goldengirl, Brad Jones went so far as to take off his glasses and unslick his hair before telling his viewers to seek out the film, just to make it clear he was serious.
The review of Gross Out starts with Brad almost begging his viewers not to watch the review. To put it in perspective, he didn't do this before the review of Pink Flamingos.
On a similar note: the moment when the protagonist of Rock: It's Your Decision reveals decidedly homophobic tendencies. Brad's previous cheery mockery vanishes instantly, as he coldly, calmly states: "Kid...go fuck yourself."
Burt from We're Alive usually can't resist an opportunity to quote from his favorite movies. But in chapter 23, he and Angel are trapped in a hospital room with zombies at the door and their only escape, a Bedsheet Ladder, broken. Burt yells for the other two characters, who got out, to leave them and run for the helicopter on the roof of the hospital by saying "Get to the chopper!" Angel asks if that was a quote from Predator. When Burt "What?...Oh, no, it was just a coincidence." Angel goes into Oh, Crap mode.
Spoony gives off one in the middle of his Ultima IX review. His normal vitriol and hot-bloodedness fades away during the scene as he simply reminisces quietly to the audience on his history with the Ultima series and the value it had to him growing up... before throwing the cases of those individual games against a wall. The entire scene serves to illustrate not only how far the game itself had broken him, but arguably also the state of mind of Noah himself at the time.
After Church rages at the crew in Episode 18, Caboose leaves Epsilon-Church despite his prior Undying Loyalty, driving home just how crushed the Blood Gulch Crew is at that point. That said, he does get over it quickly enough, so it's probably more that he was upset that Epsilon-Church was alienating his friends than anything else.
In the same episode, who is the first to leave? Lazy Grif, who typically just goes along with whatever crazy scheme everyone else comes up with because it's too much work to disagree with them.
After Caboose, Simmons, Grif and Tucker escape from the canyon in Season 11, being forced to leave Sarge, Donut, Lopez and Wash at the mercy of their enemies, Tucker, well known for his behaviour, doesn't try and woo Vanessa Kimball, the leader of the New Republic.
In episode six of season twleve, when Kimball has talk with Tucker, she ends their conversation by telling him he can drop by her office at any time. The thought of making a joke and/or hitting on her doesn't even seem to cross his mind. Instead he goes straight to Grif, Simmons and Caboose and tells them they're leaving because he doesn't want her, or anyone else, getting hurt on their personal mission.
Noob has the well-established fact that Arthéon is afraid of Game Masters. He does quite a few uncharacteristic things after reaching his Rage Breaking Point, but the act that ended up having most of his soon to be former guildmates as an audience was him asking for a Game Master.
Achievement Hunter's Gavin Free is a certified troll, doing things to screw over his fellow AH players for shits and giggles, but trying his damnedest not to out and out cheat. When Caleb was caught cheating and it's Gavin calling him out, you know that you dun goofed.
Mark Kermode is a avid hater of films in 3D and is more than willing to rip apart the technology, finding extremely gimmicky and is nothing more than a ploy for studios to make more money. Then Gravity came along and on his blog, he posted a video announcing that "Gravity is worth seeing in 3D". He then face palmed for saying those words.
The SCP Foundation very rarely actively attempts to kill supernatural entities, as they don't know what effect it might have. So SCP-682 must be a serious threat to warrant a file that begins with "SCP-682 must be destroyed as soon as possible."
The Foundation members are usually portrayed as Determinators who will go to any length to find a way to insure that any entities that could pose a danger are safely contained. Except for SCP-2317, who they have explicitly given up on containing and what procedures they do have are merely to keep up morale.
SCP-682 ends up on the other end of this trope several times. It's an Omnicidal Maniac that tries to kill pretty much anything that gets left out in front of it. So something must be seriously, intrinsically wrong with SCP-173 (which it is too scared of to attack), SCP-053 (the only being it has ever acted legitimately friendly towards), and Dr. Alto Clef (whom it doesn't attack for some unknown reason).
In Danny Phantom, the only time Sam acts really cheerful is around Christmas, even though she's Jewish. One of the kids at her school was so freaked he thought it was A SIGN OF THE APOCALYPSE!
Happens a few times in Teen Titans, such as when Perpetual FrownerRaven acts cheerful for whatever reason, like in "The End Part I" (when this was just an act) and "The End Part III" (when it was genuine). Also when the Hot-BloodedRobin doesn’t yell at his team to insist he’s fine after he breaks his arm and instead decides to give up and watch television in the episode “Fractured”, much to the shock of his friends.
"Lake Laogai": Longshotspeaks just once as Jet is dying... and it stuns everyone who hears him because it's so rare. It stunned the fandom just as much; up until that point, nearly everyone thought he was a mute!
The eponymous Avatar is usually a very happy-go-lucky kid. He's very peaceful and spiritual, and has stated repeatedly that he doesn't eat meat. Then in "The Desert", his best friend and pet since he was a kid, Appa, is stolen by Sandbenders. The normally cheerful Aang spends the entire episode being cranky, aggressive, and angry. He even kills a wasp-buzzard that tried to take one of his other friends even after the threat it posed was gone. When they run into the Sandbenders who stole Appa, you know they're infor a worldof hurt.
Katara absolutely despised the fact that she learned bloodbending, even breaking down when it sinks in that she learned it and used it. When she uses it again in "The Southern Raiders", it shows that she is letting her rage drive her more than her morality and how serious she is about possibly killing in cold blood the man who killed her mother.
The sequel series The Legend of Korra has Tenzin very surprised by Korra's refusal to join the anti-Amon task force. While he was glad she didn't, he recognised that her unwillingness to charge her enemy head-on was very uncharacteristic, and (correctly) guessed that Korra was truly afraid for the first time in her life.
Varrick is an eccentric, amoral businessman who is perfectly happy to start a war with False Flag Operations if he thinks it'll make him a profit, and who loves experimentation and invention For Science!. In Book Four, however, he immediately attempts to shut down his spirit vine energy project when he witnesses the true destructive power stored within those vines, considering it too dangerous. That should say something.
In the last story arc of the first season of Transformers Prime, Megatron almost kills Rafael when he attacks Bumblebee with a blast of Dark Energon. Optimus Prime declares, in no uncertain terms, that he intends to KILL Megatron for what he's done. Few characters in fiction adhere as strictly as Optimus does to Technical Pacifism, and seeing him actually show a vengeful streak shocked even his fellow Autobots. He actually sticks to this policy later — while he and Megatron are forced to ally against Unicron, Optimus shows he is still going to terminate Megatron if he gets the chance now — fortunately Dreadwing intervened.
Another example, and once again with Optimus: when Starscream uses his Red Energon speed serum to steal all the Omega Keys at once Optimus actually loses his cool and shouts in impotent frustration. Ratchet and Bulkhead are actually visually distressed at watching Optimus break like that.
The series Big Bad Megatron had a rather poignant moment when he vehemently refused to resume leadership of the Decepticons at the end of "Predacons Rising" film, this came as such a shock that even Starscream was weirded out.
Similarly, Shockwave almost never freaks out over anything at all, with Tranquil Fury being the most emotive he usually gets. However, when Unicron arrives and begins resurrecting several Predacon skeletons to use as his undead army during "Predacons Rising", Shockwave has a clearly horrified, if relatively subdued, reaction.
Shockwave: It is... not logical.
In Scooby-Doo and the Alien Invaders , Scooby and Shaggy each fall in love. When asked what they want to eat, the normally bottomless pits say they aren't hungry. Cue Ironic Echo and the rest of the gang looking at each other in shock.
On Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated, Velma goes through this as the series concludes. She usually counts on rationale, logic and facts to guide her and the gang through their mysteries, but when the Curse of Crystal Cove sends them through a nightmare realm where those that have been associated with the search for the cursed treasure remain, Velma feels that logic and reason have failed her. As a result, she breaks down crying.
Wade Duck of the U.S. Acres portion of Garfield and Friends, while not literally afraid of everything, is afraid of so many things that most people wouldn't even consider (e.g., he is canonically afraid of caraway seeds) that the other farm inhabitants seem to think it the case. So when Wade, having his cowardice suppressed via hypnosis, passes by performing a stunt on a bicycle...
Booker: It looked like Wade, but it didn't tremble like Wade...
In the Ed, Edd n Eddy episode "Little Ed Blue", Ed, who is normally the resident Perpetual Smiler, spends the episode angry, bitter, and has a huge need for isolation from everyone else, including his own friends Edd and Eddy. Edd is concerned, and Eddy is too impatient to deal with it, and because of Eddy's impatience, Ed goes on a rampage, until Jonny and Plank show up and everyone finds out that Ed has a pebble in his shoe. It's very telling that Sarah, who will willingly jump on and beat the crap out of anybody up to and including Rolf (physically the strongest among the kids except for Ed), looked at Ed much as the Eds look at her when she's mad and told everyone to back off the instant she realized Ed wasn't backing down.
The episode "Going Native" has Butters become hostile towards the other characters.
In "Cartoon Wars Part 1", Cartman seemed to be genuinely concerned about Family Guy offending Muslims with their portrayal of The Prophet Muhammad. It isn't until long after Kyle joined his cause that Cartman reveals he just wanted to take Family Guy off the air entirely.
In "Fat Camp", this is what tips Stan and Kyle off that the "silm" Cartman is an imposter when he actually is nice and doesn't insult the two.
In "Tonsil Trouble", Cartman is actually so upset about getting HIV that he turns down free ice cream.
Cutie Mark Failure Insanity Syndrome shows up for each character in the mane cast, with that character's personality changing dramatically in response to outside stress, especially stress related to that character's talent. Seeing the showoff Rainbow Dash suffering from stage fright in "Sonic Rainboom" or the usually steadfast and honest Applejack lying to her friends in "The Last Roundup" is mindboggling. The issue goes to outright terrifying with Pinkie Pie's lapse into depression in "Party of One", Fluttershy's lapse into Yandere at the climax of "The Best Night Ever", and Twilight Sparkle's complete psychotic break in "Lesson Zero".
In "Lesson Zero", Princess Celestia flies over to Ponyville right after she fulfills her sun-related duties, fixes Twilight's mess, and sternly reprimands her. This is the first time in the series that Princess Celestia has shown any disappointment in Twilight, let alone the outright anger she expresses upon first realizing what has happened.
Fluttershy does this all the time. She is normally extremely fearful, but when her friends are in trouble, she'll stand up to a manticore, a cockatrice, or a giant firebreathing dragon. And if there isn't a threat around, it means trouble for her friends (see "Putting Your Hoof Down" for an example).
Big Macintosh, who is normally calm, collected, and quiet, chewed out the Cutie Mark Crusaders for printing embarrassing details about him and Applejack in "Ponyville Confidential". You know you really screwed up when you got him mad enough to say more than a few words.
Even more, when Big Mac is talking, Applejack, who was just as mad, became The Quiet One, resorting to the same "eyup"s and "nope"s Big Mac was famous for.
In "Keep Calm and Flutter On" when Celestia brings Discord to Ponyville in an attempt to reform him, the mane six are furious that she would bring the worst villain they've ever faced anywhere near them, even Twilight - who is usually intensely reverent of Celestia and terrified of disappointing her - outright yelling at her.
In episode "The Uncertainty Principle", Jameson spends the first half of the episode being very quiet and subdued as his son, an astronaut, encounters problems that could get him and his crew killed. Once he's safely back on the ground, though, Jameson only takes a moment of serene thankfulness before instantly reverting to his usual No Indoor Voice/Motor Mouth bossiness as he orders everybody to throw together an issue praising his son's success.
He also does this when he heard the victim of the heart attack was Peter's aunt, going from wanting it on the first page, to wanting to tell Peter himself.
When pre-Flanderization Ned Flanders snaps in "Hurricane Ned", it very much has this effect, since the usually mild-mannered and nice-to-a-fault Ned absolutely rips into everyone in Springfield, and all he says to Homer is that he's the worst person he's ever met. It's not especially surprising when Ned checks himself into a mental hospital immediately after.
If there is ever a moment where Bart is studying or behaving, expect a reaction from everybody.
In your average episode, Phineas is almost spookily optimistic and cheerful. It makes sense that a few of the specials ("Summer Belongs to You" and "Christmas Vacation") and the movie have moments in which he's sad or angry just to let the audience know that these aren't normal episodes. One line in particular became Memetic Mutation, even though it would have been no big deal if someone else had said it:
Phineas:GET ON THE TRIKE!
This had led to a Broken Base as of "Mission Marvel" where he was under a lot of stress and took it out on Candace. It's probably the only thing contentious about that crossover, and for a crossover with comic book character, that's saying something. Phineas actually holding a grudge for a small amount of time just feels that uncharacteristic.
"The Lizard Whisperer": Ferb must really love Steve the chameleon, because when Steve goes missing and Phineas and Isabella are on the verge of giving up the search, he delivers a long and epic speech to urge them on.
In "Lawn Gnome Beach Party of Terror", Linda becomes very concerned when she doesn't receive a call from Candace about the boys' latest activity.
Lampshaded in "Phineas and Ferb Save Summer".
Buford: This must be a special episode. He's yelling at his sister again.
In Justice League Unlimited, a season finale sees Lex Luthor divide the League, make the public hate and fear them, and he tops it off by merging with Brainiac to be a limitless technological god-being who defeats the primary League members singlehandedly, leaving only the Flash left to kill. The normally happy-go-lucky Flash runs away... and returns having circumnavigated the globe in seconds to build up the speed to hit Luthor/Brainiac hard enough to hurt him. Appearing deadly serious, Flash does this nearly a dozen times becoming a literal bolt of lightning pummeling Luthor into dust. Until this episode, nobody realized that the most powerful member of the team was not Superman.
There's one episode, in all the DCAU, where Batman laughs, and it's one of the darkest:
Harley Quinn: I've never heard you laugh before...I don't think I like it...
Superman wants to kill Darkseid. It's not a "I Did What I Had to Do" situation, if left alone Clark will go so far as to sacrifice his own life to ensure that Darkseid dies. It's not a case of Superman being dark, it's a case of Darkseid being just that evil.
So anyone who's seen Gargoyles knows that, in battle, Goliath is a force to be reckoned with. Off the battlefield, he's thoughtful, considerate, even downright philosophical at times. He's not afraid to pull out all the stops in the heat of combat, yet repeatedly chastises others for going overboard when it's unnecessary. But push him too far and he will get pissed. In "Hunter's Moon", the second season finale, his daughter Angela is beaten almost to death by the Hunters... at which point the noble, level-headed clan leader growls, his eyes glowing, and in a scene that's drawn like he's looking out from the very gates of Hell intones the following:
In the Kim Possible Episode 53, "Emotion Sickness", both Kim and Shego are victim of "Moodulator" chips and are subject to drastic mood swings, scaring Ron and Draken, respectively. It should be noted that both men are way more unsettled when Kim and Shego are acting very amorous toward them as opposed to angry.
In The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius episode "I Dream of Jimmy", Jimmy goes into Carl's dream and tries to wake him up. All his attempts to convince him he's in a dream fail... until Jimmy kisses his rival Cindy.
Carl: Jimmy kissing Cindy? Oh, that couldn't happen in a million years! I must be dreaming...
In an episode of Littlest Pet Shop (2012), Mrs. Twombly (normally a very kind and sweet woman) was so enraged at Fisher Biskit for outbidding her on a doorknob that even the mention of his name angered her. After she hears about the open house he's having where he will be showing off his art collection, she slams her fist into the counter, causing Blythe to scream and shout "So out of character!"
In Dastardly and Muttley in Their Flying Machines, The Vulture Squadron's card-carrying coward Zilly becomes brave to gung-ho levels in the episode "Zilly's A Dilly," thanks to hypnotism. However, his devil-may-care bravery becomes more of a hinderance to the squadron than when he was a coward.
In the Moral Orel episode "Sundays", Reverend Putty has to do a sermon on "Hope." The morning after a terrible night for him and Florence (which affects her roommate, her ex-husband and their daughter by extension), none of them are in the best mood. He looks around and sees many of the townspeople (Doughy, Bloberta, Censordoll, etc) also disheartened by similar tragic situations in their lives, until he remembers Orel Puppington! The Cheerful ChildKeet protagonist! But no, Orel's just as upset as everyone else. Not being able to find a Hope Spot from Orel leads Putty and the episode on a Downer Ending.
In the Batman: The Animated Series episode "The Clock King", Temple Fugate announces his secretary, Ms. Perkins, that he would take his coffe break out of office. Ms. Perkins' shocked gesture shows us that this is something Fugate just doesn't do.
In Star Wars: The Clone Wars Duchess Satine of Mandalore is an Actual Pacifist, who could not bring herself to shoot a man, who was threatening to blow up a starship, full of innocent people. Yet, when in the episode "Corruption", children got food-poisoning from toxic tea, bought by corrupt officals on the black market, she went into such a rage, she completely abandoned her pacifist views. She even threatened a suspect with physical violence if he didn't start talking!
Ben 10: Ultimate Alien: Near the end of Season 1, Kevin absorbs Ben's Ultimatrix energy in a last-ditch effort to stop Aggregor, and promptly goesAx-Crazy again. After failing to stop him several times, Ben, known for his Chronic Hero Syndrome and No One Gets Left Behind tendencies, decides outright that Kevin is too far gone to be saved and must be put down. Grandpa Max even remarks that things must be really bad for Ben to go that far.
King of the Hill: Peggy Hill is normally the self-proclaimed smartest woman in the state, completely unaware of her own flaws, and a genuinely good housekeeper. So, in the episode "Death and Taxes", wherein a prison convinct manages to dupe Peggy into smuggling him cocaine by playing to her ego (threatening to turn her in if she refuses to continue the supply... or whenever he feels like it), Hank realizes something is seriously wrong when she manages to screw up creating a rather simple dinner, and responds by asking aloud, "How could I be so freaking stupid?!"
In a plot akin to the Ed, Edd 'n' Eddy example, the Uncle Grandpa episode "Bad Morning" shows that the usually friendly and upbeat Uncle Grandpa becomes a grouchy, violent old man that constantly shouts 'bad morning' whenever he gets up on the wrong side of the bed, caused by Pizza Steve joyriding in his racecar bed and parking it in the wrong spot.
In the first episode of the series, Mac realizes that Terrence must be working with someone to get rid of Bloo because he was far too stupid to come up with a plan like the one he used on his own.
Wilt is normally kind and helpful to everyone he meets. But in the episode, "Room With a Feud", when a basketball-themed room becomes available to anyone who wants it, he becomes cocky and selfish and competes against Eduardo, Coco, and Bloo for it. note It is also revealed in that episode, that in all the years he's lived at Foster's, he's never had his own room.
At the end of the first part of Batman Beyond episode "The Call", when it appears that Superman is trying to kill the Justice League, Bruce shows Terry his secret weapon against this threat should it ever have arisen again: kryptonite. Technical Pacifist Bruce Wayne then tells Terry to do whatever it takes to stop him.
Sir Topham Hatt is very fond of his Top Hat. However, in the special, "Misty Island Rescue", he is so overjoyed at having found Thomas, he throws it into the air, not caring the least when it disappears into the mist.
The Troublesome Trucks take delight in causing mischief to the other engines on Sodor. However, in the episode, "Missing Gator", when they roll down the hill into an Abandoned Mine, they are glad when Percy finds them, and even ask him to help them out of the mine, as they don't like being left there alone.
Toad the Brake Van is normally very polite and doesn't get mad at anything the engine pulling him (most commonly Oliver) is doing. However, in the episode, "Toad's Bright Idea", while he still retains his polite speech, he gets angry with Gator when the latter refuses to relight his faulty lamp in the dark.
A soldier in World War II managed to invoke this trope unintentionally; he was well known for having a very poor grasp of punctuation, and once joked with his wife that if he ever sent her a perfectly punctuated letter, she should underline the first word of every sentence and it would reveal a coded message. When he was captured by the Nazis and put into a labour camp, he remembered the joke, and sent his wife a coded message hidden inside a well punctuated one. It worked, and his wife, with the help of the British government, managed to smuggle various items to him which he used to escape the camp.
Speaking more broadly, a sudden change in behavior can be a sign of mental illness. Or in some cases, a regular illness.
It may also be a sign of neurological or even vascular issues as well. A sudden unexplained personality change in a close friend or family member should be treated as serious and indicative of a possible medical emergency.
A sudden uptick in someone's mood after a long depression may be a sign that they're happy that their problems will soon be over. Because they're about to kill themselves.
Parents often become concerned if their teenager son or daughter, who has been extremely rebellious and unruly for many years, suddenly becomes very nice, mindful and polite to everybody. Sometimes this may be justified, as it may be a sign that he or she has secretly joined a cult or other clandestine organization. Or that he or she is on drugs.
Before Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans, the local National Weather Service office issued a bulletin. This is standard, but sentences like "PERSONS...PETS...AND LIVESTOCK EXPOSED TO THE WINDS WILL FACE CERTAIN DEATH IF STRUCK" and "WATER SHORTAGES WILL MAKE HUMAN SUFFERING INCREDIBLE BY MODERN STANDARDS" are decidedly not. After the hurricane, authorities credited the bulletin with saving thousands of lives.
Governor Chris Christie showed how seriously he took Hurricane Sandy when he praised Democrat Barack Obama and snubbed fellow Republican Mitt Romney (for whom he was a high-level spokesman) days before the election. He also later beat up on Republicans in Congress for declining to pass a pork-filled relief bill.
Usually, Walt Disney ended his meetings with his staff with "See you later." During his final meeting with Marc Davis, in the middle of a terminal illness that would claim his life before the month was even halfway out, Disney left with these words: "Goodbye, Marc." That sent a signal to Marc that Disney didn't have very long to live.
At a Congressional Hearing in 1985, Dee Snider spoke out against the censorship of music, including his. While he was in his normal outfit, sleeveless shirt and denim trouser, but he didn't have his usual makeup on. This footage shows how he had to be taken serious.
Early 20th century American William Ellsworth Robinson took his stage persona of Chinese magician Chung Ling Soo to the point of never speaking English on stage and even talking to the press through an "interpreter". In 1918, the gun he used in his trademark bullet catch trick malfunctioned and Robinson was shot for real. He said in English "Oh my God. Something's happened. Lower the curtain", and died in a hospital the next day.
US President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who was a paraplegic, usually refused to let the full extent of his disability be known to the public. While the citizens were vaguely aware that he had polio, they were encouraged to think he was recovering from it, as he didn't use his wheelchair outside of the White House, wore leg braces, and made all his speeches while standing and leaning on the podium. But in March 1, 1945, he consented to be wheeled into the House chamber to address a joint session of Congress, and even referred to his leg braces at the start of the speech. Needless to say, his audience was shocked, and six weeks later he was dead.