What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/ImpliedLoveInterest

 

Wyldchyld
topic
02:50:18 PM Sep 23rd 2013
edited by 2.100.114.143
I have removed the InuYasha example to here as it's turning into an Edit War and PMs, while completely calm and polite, aren't resolving it either because edits are being made as the PMs take place. This is the proper place to discuss the example.

The example that was changed was this:

This was originally considered a suitable fix for the monstrous Word Cruft that existed previously. A Wonk problem occurred recently and, as per Ask The Tropers, was reverted back to the above example. Unfortunately, over the past few days, the example keeps getting edited to bring Word Cruft creeping back in. I agreed in PMs that the Sesshoumaru sentence might be considered zero context, so suggested an edit of this (to keep it consistent with the Kagura sentence):

  • InuYasha: Sesshoumaru and Kagura. Rin's observations and Kagura's thoughts imply Kagura's in love with Sesshoumaru. Mouryoumaru and Toutousai's comments and Sesshoumaru's thoughts confirm Sesshoumaru had feelings for Kagura but Takahashi leaves their exact nature open to interpretation.

However, the example continues to be edited to keep pushing detail into the Sesshoumaru example. Since detailed examples are not being used for the Kagura side, I don't see the point of pushing detailed examples into the Sesshoumaru sentence. That's just starting the creep back to unwieldy and pointless Word Cruft.
fantasoda22
08:12:08 PM Sep 23rd 2013
how's this then:

InuYasha: Sesshoumaru and Kagura. Rin's observations and Kagura's thoughts imply Kagura's in love with Sesshoumaru. Tenseiga being reforged into a fighting weapon because of his feeling for her confirm Sesshoumaru had feelings for Kagura but Takahashi leaves their exact nature open to interpretation.
DonaldthePotholer
topic
12:04:27 PM Jul 14th 2013
Removed the following. The reason should be obvious:

  • Roy and Riza are pretty much considered to be the Beta Couple in Fullmetal Alchemist. It's very clear they care very deeply for each other but it was never confirmed if they were in a relationship.
    • It's been confirmed through supplementary material that if they weren't both in the army, they would be dating.
      • Not just dating. If it weren't for the anti-fraternization law in the military, they would be married.

Wyldchyld
topic
02:21:26 PM Feb 5th 2012
edited by Wyldchyld
The original intent of the Inu Yasha entry was to make an entry that limited the subjectiveness as much as possible which is why not all incidents from the manga were put in. This was in the interest of posting something that would not trigger a ship war.

I had been hoping it could remain entirely in that spirit and an Edit War over the additions of entirely interpretational incidents that had been deliberately left out (on those grounds) is not something I would like to get involved in.

As a result, I will leave the example as it currently stands and will not be revisiting or editing this any further. Please can further edits be avoided if all it's for is to squash further examples or expand on examples already given? The entry is comprehensive enough as it stands. It doesn't matter if not everything in the manga has been included.
fantasoda22
04:15:07 AM Sep 19th 2013
I don't want to leave it like this: * InuYasha: Sesshoumaru and Kagura. Rin's observations and Kagura's thoughts imply Kagura's in love with Sesshoumaru. Sesshoumaru's confirmed to have feelings for Kagura, but Takahashi leaves their exact nature open to interpretation.

Because that doesn't tell you about what actually happened in the manga between them. So can we please leave it like this: * InuYasha: Sesshoumaru and Kagura. Rin's observations and Kagura's thoughts imply Kagura's in love with Sesshoumaru. Sesshoumaru's confirmed to have feelings for Kagura, most notably with the breaking of Tokijin defending her and of Tenseiga transforming into a fighting weapon because of his feelings for Kagura and him vowing over the sword to avenge her but Takahashi leaves their exact nature open to interpretation.

So that it tells people about what actually happened between them, i.e. HOW Sesshomaru was confirmed to have feelings for Kagura?
back to Main/ImpliedLoveInterest

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy