It's complicated, but it's less of a retcon than the idea that the Doctor has had incarnations before the First Doctor; the existence of the War Doctor was enough of a retcon for the Doctor's known timeline.
- That would also explain why Ruth's TARDIS was a police box when the First Doctor's (William Hartnell's) TARDIS didn't become a police box until the first episode.
- Adding on a "Fractured" Doctor; Possibly either a Doctor from the Season 6B Theory, or even a Valeyard type situation?
- Seemingly Jossed by Chris Chibnall.
- Doubt it, as why would the screwdriver register them both as Doctors? And then she would know why this Doctor can't remember her.
Now, the Six-Seven regeneration is noted for being a case of Dropped a Bridge on Him. What if that's because it was actually a forced regeneration, done so the Doctor wouldn't know he'd had another incarnation between them?
As for why this would've been done, given that the Timeless Child is apparently a huge secret, that would explain going to such lengths: the Time Lords (the most likely perpetrators) wanted to make absolutely certain that the Doctor would never know what they'd discovered while they were Ruth, thus going to the lengths of even topping up the Doctor's regeneration energy so they wouldn't know they'd regenerated once more than they actually had.
- How would that be even possible when Six was actually seen transforming into Seven onscreen? It's not like the case with Eight, who was never shown physically changing into his successor (initially thought by everyone to be Nine), and thus left a narrative gap for Moffat to place the War Doctor between them.
- Memory wipes and amnesia? The point being that this is the only other regeneration besides 2 to 3, judging by events, where another incarnation could plausibly be slipped in. And hey, this could even be a metatextual explanation for why Sylvester McCoy had to play Six briefly since Colin Baker refused to return for the scene because he'd been fired.
- In order for this to be true, then the Sixth Doctor's regeneration as seen by the viewers, would have to be fake (either through Time Lord trickery or the scene being shown from the perspective of someone who believed Six turned directly into Seven), since as mentioned, Six was physically shown transforming into Seven. I find this fairly unlikely, since the show is usually objective about showing what actually happens on screen being what truly happened.
- As of "The Timeless Children", most likely [Jossed: She's actually a pre-Hartnell incarnation. The Doctor actually does not have a regeneration limit, and has had many past lives forcibly erased from their memories in order to keep this from them.
- Jossed: Chibnall confirmed that Ruth is not from an alternative universe, and that she is really an incarnation of the Doctor.
Season 6b is going to be made canon and Gat is the Doctor's handler in CIA, this would explain Ruth's line about her job that she did not apply for and cannot leave.
- I was actually going to theorize that she came between 2 and 3 because not only is it the only regeneration where we don't actually see the change, but in existing Canon the Time Lords did mess with the Doctor's mind, erasing his ability to fly the TARDIS, so, it is possible that the Doctor escaped after regenerating and when they recaptured her they erased her memories of Ruth and gave her an extra regeneration to hide Ruth's presence in the Doctor's past.
- They may not even have had to give the Doctor an extra regeneration. The Time Lords only said they were going to change the Doctor's appearance, not that they were forcing him to Regenerate. Of course the term hadn't been invented yet, but in-universe it gives us a nice out!
- It may also explain why Ruth's TARDIS has the Classic Control Room, and Police Box exterior, too, since that is the TARDIS look used up until the Middle of the Third Doctor's Era.
- A few other points of note; she does not recognise the Sonic Screwdriver, which puts her before the Third Doctor, the first incarnation to use it, and her TARDIS being a Police Box has to put her after the First. She also specifically calls the TARDIS a "ship", which is something more associated with the early incarnations. Finally, Gat responds to the idea of a multi-incarnation event as an "abomination", which suggests at that point in her timeline, Gallifrey has yet to start plucking past incarnations of the Doctor out of time and forcing them to work together, as often happened in the classic series, and started with the Third Doctor.
- The Second Doctor had the sonic screwdriver, it first appeared in Fury from the Deep
- At the time it appears to have only been used as a screwdriver; the Doctor had not yet begun modifying and expanding its uses. The modern sonic probably looks as much like a regular sonic screwdriver as a Swiss army knife does a bread knife, or a cell phone does a 1950s land line phone. Ruth hasn't seen Thirteen use the sonic on any screws, so she'd have no reason to connect it to the simple tool the Second Doctor had until Thirteen names it, and even then she looks skeptical.
- While the Second Doctor had a sonic screwdriver, not all of the later ones used one. Five didn't bother to replace his after "The Visitation" and neither Six or Seven used one despite the fact it's fairly easy for a Time Lord to make one. Also Ruth knows what a sonic screwdriver is so perhaps she just didn't recognise Thirteen's self-made one.
- The Second Doctor had the sonic screwdriver, it first appeared in Fury from the Deep
- As of "The Timeless Children", probably Jossed: She's actually a pre-Hartnell incarnation. The Doctor actually does not have a regeneration limit, and has had many past lives forcibly erased from their memories in order to keep this from them.
- Confirmed.
- The Doctor didn't waste that regeneration — he was dying before he regenerated, and he was alive and well afterwards, exactly what a regeneration is supposed to do, except that he forced the regeneration to only heal him in his current form, and not change his body into a new one. (Side-WMG: If they could find a way to fine-tune this so that the extra Regeneration Energy wasn't lost to the Time Lord in question, then a Time Lord might be able to regenerate many more times than the normal limit of twelve!)
- Actually, the Doctor doesn't have a regeneration limit. However, they have had their memories periodically erased for a truly insane span of time because the Time Lords didn't want them to figure this out.
- If you imagine that the Doctor regenerated a certain amount of time after escaping from Gallifrey, that would make her the second, Hartnell the third, and so on.
- Somehow, the Doctor did not have a regeneration limit before Trenzalore. Presumably, the regeneration energy that the Time Lords give him, was only to trigger a regeneration that was already going to happen. This was likely done so that the Doctor wouldn’t become suspicious, as to whatever circumstances explain this.
- You'd need a reason why the TARDIS is shaped like a police box, since they expressed surprise in "An Unearthly Child" that the exterior hadn't changed.
- That's simple; The TARDIS is sentient, and has decided on one of their previous visits to Earth(specifically London) that she likes the police box look. Additionally, the TARDIS might have changed from its classic cylindrical shape to police box when she recognized a later version of "her thief" standing next to another, and made herself look recognizable, so the Doctor gets the point of Ruth being the Doctor ASAP.
- Regarding why Ruth doesn't seem surprised when she sees this design, the TARDIS probably made itself a police box in a weird place at least once before (and then went back to working again). Maybe..the chameleon circuit was never broken, it's just been a such a long time since the TARDIS disguised itself properly, no version of the Doctor suspected anything beyond a malfunction. The idea Donna comes up with, in "Journey' End" is really just how to coerce the TARDIS to behave.
- That's simple; The TARDIS is sentient, and has decided on one of their previous visits to Earth(specifically London) that she likes the police box look. Additionally, the TARDIS might have changed from its classic cylindrical shape to police box when she recognized a later version of "her thief" standing next to another, and made herself look recognizable, so the Doctor gets the point of Ruth being the Doctor ASAP.
- Jossed; she's actually one of the Doctor's many, many pre-Hartnell incarnations who they were given Laser-Guided Amnesia of.
- It likely does count as a regeneration. It's just that the Doctor, unlike other Time Lords and unbeknownst to them, does not actually have a limit to how many regenerations they have.
- The Valeyard was described as coming "between the Doctor's twelfth and final regenerations." At the time, everyone assumed there was only one time that could refer to, because no one got more than thirteen lives. Now, it's basically just any time between the second Tennant incarnation and whatever ends up being the last incarnation the Doctor has, whenever that ends up being.
- Except if the Doctor had a past regeneration cycle, then maybe "the twelfth incarnation" was part of that cycle.
- Jossed.
- Or go to the dawn of the Mondasians and convert the first Mondasian.
- As of "The Timeless Children", Jossed. The Lone Cyberman's plan is to retrieve the Cyberium sent into Earth's past, then use it to wipe out the last traces of humanity.
- From "The Timeless Children", Jossed and also partially confirmed: it doesn't seem likely that Ruth found out something the Time Lords didn't want her to know, but she was erased from the Doctor's memories because of the Timeless Child: the Doctor is the Timeless Child, and as a result is both much older than they know and is able to regenerate an infinite number of times. The Time Lords regularly erased their memory to keep them from finding this out.
- The long-standing opposing idea is that the other faces seen in that episode were previous faces of Morbius, not the Doctor.
- Per "The Timeless Children", Confirmed: The Doctor is not and never has been subject to a regeneration limit. Over the eons, the Time Lords periodically wiped their memories of their past lives to keep them under their control and believing they were an ordinary Time Lord. Ruth and the "Morbius" faces are all past lives that the Doctor was made to forget this way.
The question now becomes, where does she fit in the timeline? And what caused her to hide with a Chameleon Arc in the first place?
- I find this fake limit a bit pushing it. Wouldn't the Master have found out? How could you keep that under wraps?
- As another theory further up the page suggests, perhaps only the Doctor specifically doesn't have a regeneration limit, for some as-yet-unknown reason, and the High Council is trying to prevent them from realizing this. Other Time Lords, such as the Master, do have such a limit.
- A limit clearly exists. The Decayed Master (played by Pratt and Beevers) was the result of the Master trying to extend his life past the natural end of the last incarnation in his original cycle, and Azmael, the Doctor's mentor, died after inducing a regeneration whilst in his thirteenth incarnation in The Twin Dilemma. The only reason these examples occurred is because of the presence of a limit.
- The limit might be artificial rather than fake. This would fit with Rassilon having "the secret of perpetual regeneration" in "The Five Doctors", not to mention the Minyans being able to regenerate an unlimited number of times in "Underworld". Though given that the Time Lords are able to hand out extra sets of regenerations willy-nilly (both "The Five Doctors" and "The Day of the Doctor"), it seems more like thirteenth regenerations require medical assistance rather than being impossible — so renegades like the Doctor, the Master, and the Rani had to be careful, while Time Lords in good standing like Borusa could regenerate pretty casually until Gallifrey's destruction.
- Per "The Timeless Children", Partially confirmed: the regeneration limit is real. The Doctor, however, is not and has never been bound to it.
Points against this idea are the fact that Ruth's TARDIS is police box-shaped and no mention of Susan (yet?).
- As of "The Timeless Children", this appears quite likely, although it is not explicitly confirmed..
All the previous regenerations of the Doctors are canon; nothing about the timeline has changed. So then what is Ruth? Simple; another Doctor. This connects to the Timeless Child myth because the knowledge of the Child keeps the existence of the fact that other versions of a Time Lord have splintered all around space and time. So, in keeping with this theory, there are always going to be several Time Lord doppelgangers or clone like entities around space and time; the Gallifreyan Founding Fathers just used the Timeless Child to keep the many other versions of the same Time Lord secret from their people.
- We've already seen something like this with Tom Baker's appearance as The Curator in the Fiftieth Anniversary. Plus, the Master brought up the events of "Logopolis" in "Spyfall"; maybe Ruth is a splinter regeneration of Four.
- Jossed.
- Given that there's some kind of secret tied to the Timeless Child that drove the Master (more) insane, Thirteen may have voluntarily removed part of her own memory in order to forget.
- As of "The Timeless Children", it's implied she's a past Doctor, but it is not explicitly stated to be so.
- The Master will be the one doing the changes.
- Jossed.
- Jossed that she's from a different timeline by Chris Chibnall.
- Jossed, as Chris Chibnall has stated she's not from an alternate universe.
- Jossed.
- As of "The Timeless Children", partially confirmed: as it turns out, the Doctor started as a little girl a very long time ago, but there's no indication that Missy was aware of this at the time.
- Jossed.
- This is already covered above, mostly in the sixth WMG down.
- Per "The Timeless Children", Jossed the Doctor has never actually been given extra regenerations because they are not actually bound by the twelve-regeneration limit, and never have been.
- At the very least, it would explain Ruth's more apparently ruthless behavior as a remnant of the War Doctor's characterization.
- Jossed.
- Technically speaking, that would make Ruth the "real" fourteenth Doctor.
- Jossed.
Firstly, Jack and Ruth appearing in the same episode in two separate subplots implies that there is some sort of connection (albeit this one is clutching at straws a bit). Could it be that what the Lone Cyberman wants is an audience with the Trickster, and that Ruth is somehow involved with that? It could be that the Lone Cyberman asks for the Trickster to make the Doctor on the run from the Time Lords or be involved in events other than the Cybermen, leading to a different set of regenerations and the Cybermen empire triumphing in this scenario. We know that the Trickster is capable of this as he wipes Sarah Jane from existence in his home series, though only when he comes to people who are absolutely desperate (and the Lone Cyberman, by its muddy appearance in the trailers and the state that Jack says the Cyberman empire is). And besides, Chibnall himself has said that Ruth IS the Doctor and not from a parallel universe and why would he make the potentially very controversial move of inserting another new incarnation between Doctors (even the War Doctor was fairly polarising)? The only other explanation would be someone editing the Doctor’s home timeline, and the Trickster has the power to do that.
As for how this ties in with the Timeless Child, it’s either the Trickster himself (as the final episode is called the Timeless Children, which may refer to the entire Pantheon of Discord if this is the case, plus the Trickster may exist outside of normal time due to his power to edit it) or a dirty job the Time Lords had him do plus the Cyberman Empire he creates (fits in with the Timeless Children thing again as the Children could be all the new, different lives and Cybermen this act creates, as they wouldn’t exist in the unedited timeline). Further evidence for the Trickster being the Timeless Child is that K9 describes the location him, the Doctor, Luke, Rani and Clyde are sent to in "The Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith" as “nowhere, NOWHEN”, implying that it is a timeless location!
Though it’s unlikely that the Trickster will return, we have seen characters from the spinoffs return in a significant way before, such as Luke, Gwen and Ianto in "The Stolen Earth", Luke in "The End of Time" and the Star Whales in "The Beast Below", so there is the slightest chance that this could happen (though it’s still unlikely).
- And now we have further evidence courtesy of "The Haunting of Villa Diodati". The Doctor notes that none of the stuff is going on should be happening and that SOMEONE sent back the Cyberium to mess with the past. The dilemma between giving the Lone Cyberman what it wants and letting Percy back is also a particularly tricky one to solve, and the Trickster could have made this scenario deliberately to make it difficult for the Doctor to get away without changing history. Sadly, this josses the Trickster being who the Lone Cyberman wants, but the Cyberium could have records of a way to contact him.
- Jossed.
- As of "Ascension of the Cybermen", Jossed: The Cyberman is after a powerful AI that contains the entire history of the Cybermen, and the Doctor is forced to give it up after a Sadistic Choice involving the death of an important historical figure and the potential destruction of the Earth.