Royce Boss Hogg Lumpkin: Look, maybe I did abandon my daughter and steal her songs, but I'm still the most honorable record producer y'all have ever worked with!Recording an album wasn't easy. You and your plucky underdog band had to either get signed to a record label or raise funds to pay for studio time. Then you had to choose a record producer, hope nobody ended up at somebody else's throats by the end of the sessions and prepare to be dicked around by the label. Of course, improvements in recording technology now give you the option to say bollocks to all that and just record stuff at home in GarageBand or something (as The KLF predicted in The Manual). However, these improvements haven't overshadowed traditional studios yet. A record producer wears many hats. These include: controlling the recording sessions, coaching and guiding the musicians, organizing and scheduling production budget and resources, and supervising the recording, mixing and mastering processes. The last responsibility shouldn't be confused with the studio engineer, who actually does the recording/mixing/mastering. As The Director is to movies, The Producer is to music. In other words, they are an important part of the recording process. Coincidentally, there are a few archetypes in this case.
Natalie Maines: Well, he's got us there. But in human terms, he's deplorable!
Natalie Maines: Well, he's got us there. But in human terms, he's deplorable!
open/close all folders
The Producer from Hell
You're not going anywhere, Dee Dee.The Producer From Hell comes in many forms: Cloudcuckoolander, one who does not suffer idiots kindly, or a man with a Berserk Button or flat-out Hair-Trigger Temper. He is distinguished by a domineering attitude that sometimes crosses over into bullying the band he's assigned. Band members will often be so marked by the whole thing that they will hate him and swear to never work with him again. Coincidentally, some bands produce critically acclaimed work thanks to a producer from hell. In short, the musical version of the Prima Donna Director.
- Phil Spector, the inventor of the Wall of Sound and the man behind the board of some of the best known singles and albums of the '60s and '70s. Ignoring his personal life (showing his wife a coffin and threatening to kill her if she left) and that little murder conviction, he is famous being a genius of a producer, but this coupled (and often negated) by his temperamental personality and gunplay in the studio. He threatened Leonard Cohen with a loaded gun, stole tapes for the John Lennon album Rock 'n Roll at gunpoint, and put the Ramones through hell. He was last employed in 2003 by the alternative band Starsailor to produce their second album, but they fired him after two tracks.
- Joe Meek. He was the inventor of many modern bits of studio equipment which are still used today in almost their original forms, and is widely considered an electronic music pioneer. He was also completely insane, and ended his life killing himself after shooting his landlady.
- Martin Hannett, Factory Records' in-house producer. Various stories circulate about his bizarre Cloudcuckoolander behaviour towards Joy Division, his obsession with drum sounds in particular manifesting itself in freaky tormenting for drummer Stephen Morris. The following acts are attributed to Hannett: forcing Morris to dismantle his kit and re-assemble it with extra toilet parts, setting up his kit on a fire escape, making him continue playing for an hour after everybody else finished recording, staying on a hill for an hour to record "silence", and insisting that Morris play every drum separately to prevent leakage.
- Kevin Shields, who exhibited obssessive studio perfectionism, erratic behaviour and use of 13 separate studios and engineers to record Loveless, who ended up mostly bringing him coffee - only Anjali Dutt and Alan Moulder made any actual contributions to the process.
- Guy Stevens, the producer of The Clash's Crowning Music of Awesome London Calling. Now, the band don't complain much since they got along with him very well and rightfully credit his production as a key ingredient of that album's success, but one can only imagine how pleasant it is to work with a producer who swings ladders and throws chairs around to keep everybody on edge and pours wine into piano cases for some reason. Well, hey, at least he ain't Phil Spector.
- Subverted in that while he did things like this to keep an edge he also did things that were the polar opposite. He for example brought out the band each day to play football with each other among other activities he did to encourage a team spirit.
- Fictional example: The Bruce Dickinson. Not that one.
- Bruce Dickinson is a real person, but he didn't produce any Blue Öyster Cult albums (he's actually a mid-level executive at BOC's label who oversaw the remastering of the band's catalog in the mid-90's).
The Acrimony Producer
Rundgren had sarcasm down to an extremely cruel art.some bands produce critically acclaimed work under his supervision.
- Todd Rundgren. Famous for being both a musician and a producer, he did not get along with XTC during the production of Skylarking and Andy Partridge claimed he was often sarcastic towards them. Skylarking is XTC's most critically acclaimed album, coincidentally. When he produced a Bad Religion album, he didn't exactly like them, either, which left the band's singer Greg Graffin disappointed as he was a fan of Rundgren's music. Meat Loaf and Jim Steinman have both stated that their attitude in 1977 was that Rundgren was responsible for "ruining" several songs on Bat Out of Hell by reducing their lengths. However, they have also said that these changes were ultimately for the best (Jim Steinman has even gone so far as to say that Rundgren is one of the few people he considers a genius).
- Bob Rock. Metallica's favourite pastime during the recording of the The Black Album was to find various ways of tormenting him - James at one point plastered the studio room with pictures of gay porn due to Rock's surprised reaction to such earlier. It's insinuated on the A Year And A Half In The Life of Metallica film that this is mostly due to Rock's having the balls to challenge James Hetfield and suggest he change certain riffs or write new lyrics (the case with "Enter Sandman"), something former producers Jon Zazula or Flemming Rassmussen had apparently never done.
- Yoshiki Hayashi, who once bought Bob Rock's studio. Dir en grey liked/likes him as a person, but working with/for him is another matter entirely.
- According to former MC5 members, Jon Landau was overbearing and rude while recording Back in the USA, trying to impose a certain sound on the band.
- Nick McCabe, The Verve's guitarist, has admitted in an interview that he found working with John Leckie on A Storm in Heaven difficult, disagreeing over what the sound of the album should be like. According to him, the final result is a compromise between the two.
- Dream Theater fought constantly with David Prater during the Images and Words session. Mike Portnoy hated the electronic snare he was made to use, and the band were very upset when he cut their Epic Rocking masterpiece "A Change of Seasons" from the album for being "too long" (which is Completely Missing the Point - Dream Theater are all about the Epic Rocking). The band was also frustrated with how Prater's mix failed to bring out certain sections of the songs the way they desired and the overly polished final mix toned down their aggressiveness, making them sound more like Queensr˙che than a Progressive Metal band.
- When they finally got around to recording "A Change of Seasons" as an EP three years later, it was with great difficulty that they decided to hire Prater to produce once again, reasoning that since "A Change of Seasons" was an Images and Words outtake it made the most sense to have him handle it. There were less fights this time around, and Prater wasn't around long enough to start clashing with the band again since the rest of the EP was filled by a series of covers recorded at one of the band's concerts. However, the most infamous incident during these sessions was when Prater asked James La Brie to sing the whole 20 minute song of "A Change Of Seasons" when he had to record multiple takes. However, Prater stopped when James La Brie absolutely went off on him.
- Soundgarden didn't outright fight with Michael Beinhorn while recording Superunknown, but Chris Cornell mentioned that he did contribute to the recording process being slower and more frustrating:
Michael Beinhorn was so into sounds. He was so, almost, anal about it, that it took the piss out of us a lot of the time...By the time you get the sounds that you want to record the song, you're sick and tired of playing it.
- The band specifically chose to self-produce their next album Down on the Upside to avoid the slow, one-song-at-a-time, prolonged recording of Superunknown.
- Hole hated working with Beinhorn on Celebrity Skin, with drummer Patty Schemel accusing Beinhorn of forcing her out of the band because he wanted to work with a studio drummer instead (which is what happened; Schemel's replacement Samantha Maloney joined the band after the album was done but before touring), and Courtney Love calling him "a Nazi" in a retrospective documentary about the album's making.
- Trevor Horn - Previously the singer for The Buggles (and later a member of Yes and Art of Noise), Horn has a reputation for playing to his artist's strengths and adapting appropriately; hence how he can produce slickly produced and expansive pop/rock in the vein of Frankie Goes to Hollywood's Two Tribes, Yes' mainstream breakthrough 90125 or Robbie Williams' Reality Killed The Video Star, or alternately experimental and edgy like Grace Jones' Slave To The Rhythm and the Art Of Noise's... well, the Art Of Noise's early material. Horn is often cited as being the best producer in Britain, and the man deserves the accolade. That being said, his perfectionism at all costs (often quite literal costs) has been known to get artists' backs up from time to time, with Frankie Goes to Hollywood eventually taking him to court. It's widely known that Frankie's song "Relax" was reworked so much that, like the album it sat on, only Holly Johnson's voice is an original element of the song. Pet Shop Boys acknowledged that Horn promised a finished production job on "Left to my own devices" within a week, only for the song to come back six months later, well over budget.
- David Tickle. According to the members of Split Enz, Tickle became increasingly arrogant after producing True Colours, their global breakout album. With the follow-up album Waiata, they were dismayed at Tickle's refusal to give them any input into the final sound of the album. Later on, Department S and Crowded House had similar creative tensions.
- Robert John "Mutt" Lange has a reputation for being a perfectionist in the studio. Def Leppard's Phil Collen reputedly described him as the "nicest dictator in the studio". And during the production of the Foreigner album '4', guitarist Mick Jones frequently "locked horns" with Lange.
- The Red Hot Chili Peppers had two different examples in their career: first with their debut album, when they fought harshly with Andy Gill - producer and guitarist for one of the band's influences, Gang of Four - because he wanted their sound to be more radio-friendly. They disliked him so much that Flea reportedly gave Gill a pizza box filled with poop. Then many years later during the Mother's Milk sessions, when John Frusciante frequently fought with producer Michael Beinhorn over guitar tone and layering, because Beinhorn wanted Frusciante to play in an almost heavy-metal style. Beinhorn's idea eventually prevailed, which explains the peculiar sound of the album.
- Squeeze were initially excited to be working with John Cale of The Velvet Underground as producer for their first album (they had actually chosen their band name from a VU album), but their enthusiasm rather quickly evaporated when Cale forced them to throw out all the songs they had already written, made them write songs on the spot in the studio, outright terrorised the band during sessions and pursued his pet theme of having the album be named A Bunch of Gay Guys (thus explaining the album's cover). And after that was all done, the record company then made them put "Bang Bang" and "Take Me I'm Yours" on the album, so they could have singles to sell. The result has since been received comparatively negatively.
- Corey Taylor has made it clear that he was not at all happy with his experiences working with Rick Rubin on Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses). According to Taylor, Rubin charged them an incredible amount of money while barely ever showing up to recording sessions; on the rare occasions when he did arrive, it was for around forty-five minutes, and he apparently did nothing other than lay down on a couch while listening to the preproduction tracks a few times, not even bothering to provide constructive criticism or basic guidance. He apparently would also regularly bring in horrific-smelling food of indeterminate origin and would haphazardly bolt it down (and apparently got it all over himself on a regular basis); other than that, he was completely absent and was largely just an invisible (and enormous) expense. Taylor made it clear that he respected what Rubin had accomplished to get him to the level he was at, but also that he felt that Rubin was a shadow of his former self who coasted by on his reputation and used it to justify charging jawdropping amounts of money, and furthermore vowed to never work with him on anything ever again.
The Invisible Producer
It always offended me when I was in the studio and the engineer or the assumed producer for the session would start bossing the band around. That always seemed like a horrible insult to me. [...] So, I made up my mind when I started engineering professionally that I wasn't going to behave like that.
Steve AlbiniThe Invisible Producer is very minimally involved in the recording process. He just sets up the microphones, pushes "record" and sits back. Sometimes he may give suggestions, but generally takes a backseat to the band.
- Steve Albini prefers to be this by default, even to the point of refusing to accept royalties from records he works on (most famously during the production of Surfer Rosa by The Pixies and In Utero by Nirvana), considering the act to be insulting to the band he worked with. Apparently because he favours "live" recording over the layers of multi-tracking that most producers prefer, Albini has to spend an age setting up the microphones just so, but other than that, the description is fairly accurate. He also tries to have his name left off the album credits if possible, and if not, he absolutely refuses to allow himself to be listed as a "producer", instead preferring the title of "engineer" or saying the album was "engineered/recorded by". Also, he despises digital audio formats and recording systems with a passion, to the point of referring to CD's as "the rich man's eight-track tape" and refusing to use the Pro Tools installed in his studio.
- Mick Jones for the Libertines.
- Glyn Johns
- Andy Johns (Glyn's younger brother)
- Ethan Johns (Glyn's son.)
- Bob Johnston. With all of Dylan's late 60s albums and Johnny Cash at Folsom Prison on his resume, you certainly can't argue with his approach. He once wrote that if Cash had wanted to record a live album on the Moon, he would've gotten everything set up.
- Eddie Kramer
- Rodger Bain on Black Sabbath's first three albums. It should be noted, however, that this was due primarily to the rush job they did on said albums, which was a common practice in that era.
- Nick Mason, drummer for Pink Floyd has done several production jobs for artists like The Damned, Gong and Robert Wyatt. People who he has worked with confirm that he is brilliant at organisation (getting the studios booked, keeping it on budget) but that his influence on the actual music is minimal.
- Andy Warhol for Velvet Underground's debut The Velvet Underground & Nico. Although credited as producer, his influence primarily seems to have been just to pay for the recording, the actual production work was done by Tom Wilson and the band themselves. Lou Reed acknowledged that Andy's pedigree allowed them to get away with a lot for their debut that might've otherwise been lost in Executive Meddling.
- Speaking of Wilson, he also produced Bob Dylan's Bringing It All Back Home, Velvet Underground's White Light/White Heat, Frank Zappa's Freak Out, "The Sound of Silence", and other masterpieces. Many of the artists who worked with him have noted that he basically just signed off on whatever they wanted to do because he trusted their instincts. He did, however, contribute massively to the popularity of Folk Rock (Dylan had already recorded "Like a Rolling Stone", which Wilson also produced) by overdubbing electric guitars, bass, and drums to the original acoustic version of "The Sound of Silence", which became an immediate hit and served as Trope Codifier for the genre. Zappa praised Wilson throughout his career for the fact that he "stuck his neck out for us" and deflected Executive Meddling to allow the Mothers of Invention practically free reign on Freak Out!, and letting their debut be an unprecedented double album.
The George Martin
The George Martin is the Long Runner of production, faithfully sticking with the same band for an incredible amount of time and albums. Of course, this exposes the band to the danger of getting stale, but it's not like they wouldn't get there anyway. Or alternatively, the band loses their way when they ditch the producer.
- The Trope Namer and Trope Maker, George Martin, who produced every Beatles album, except Let It Be, which was produced by Phil Spector.
- Brown Bannister, who has produced or co-produced all of Amy Grant's Christian albums.
- Bill Maxwell produced all of Keith Green's Christian recordings.
- Nigel Godrich, who has been with Radiohead since the My Iron Lung EP (1994), although he was not actually the main producer of one of their albums until OK Computer three years later.
- Rick Rubin, who had been with the Red Hot Chili Peppers since 1991's Blood Sugar Sex Magik, but the band has since moved on from him after 2011's I'm With You. He has also produced all of System of a Down's albums. In addition to his work with those bands, he's also incredibly eclectic, working with artists from Jay-Z to Johnny Cash, all with his signature stripped down production style.
- Bob Rock for Metallica between 1991-2003. They finally ditched him after St. Anger made them realize they were digging themselves into a hole.
- Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois in various degrees for U2 since The Unforgettable Fire, only absent on 1997's Pop.
- Ted Templeman, on Van Halen's first 6 albums. He left with David Lee Roth (although returning for For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge). Templeman stuck around longer with the Doobie Brothers and Michael McDonald.
- Bill Ham, producing every ZZ Top album from 1969 until 2003.
- Terry Brown, who produced every Rush album between Fly By Night and Signals.
- Rob Cavallo, with Green Day since 1994; the only exceptions being 2000's Warning (produced by the band with Cavallo serving as executive producer, i.e. providing the money) and 2009's 21st Century Breakdown (produced by the band and Butch Vig).
- Pierre Marchand, with Sarah McLachlan since 1994.
- Frank Peterson, the Martin for Sarah Brightman.
- Dick Knubbler in Metalocalypse.
- Notable for doing a double Heel–Face Turn- from producer (sent by the record company for quality control) and spy, to trusted confidant of the band and the only person aside from Offdensen they'll actually listen to. If they can hear him...
- Pat Dillett, who produced all of They Might Be Giants' releases since Factory Showroom.
- Jimmy Miller, who produced the most highly-regarded series of albums by The Rolling Stones - Beggars Banquet, Let It Bleed, Sticky Fingers and Exile on Main St.. He was thrown out after Goats Head Soup because his drug use was affecting his production skills.
- Though he's always credited as co-producing with the band themselves, David Fridmann for The Flaming Lips; He first worked with them in 1990 (when critics and fans seem to generally agree that the band started Growing the Beard), and with the exception of Transmissions From The Satellite Heart, he's co-produced every album since.
- He has also had a hand in producing every album by Mercury Rev (for whom he used to play bass), continuing even after he left the band in 2004. As above, he's always credited along with at least one other band member, but has received top billing since 1998's Deserter's Songs.
- Gil Norton, with The Pixies between Doolittle and Trompe le Monde.
- Iron Maiden had two: Martin Birch, that produced all between Killers and Fear of the Dark (then retired), and Kevin Shirley, for all since Brave New World.
- Tony Brown, who was a pianist for Elvis Presley, then a member of Emmylou Harris' and Rodney Crowell's road bands, turned to production in the late 80s and it has been his calling ever since. He produced all of Vince Gill's albums from 1989-2000, and all of George Strait's albums between the Pure Country soundtrack in 1992 and Love Is Everything 20 years later.
- Dwight Yoakam worked with producer/guitarist Pete Anderson from his 1986 debut Guitars, Cadillacs, Etc. Etc. until Population Me in 2003. Anderson also played lead guitar on all of those albums.
- With a career spanning from 1989 to the present, Alan Jackson has worked with producer Keith Stegall on all but one album (his 2006 New Sound Album Like Red on a Rose). Scott Hendricks co-produced the first two and one song on the third, while 2013's The Bluegrass Album features his nephew Adam Wright as a co-producer.
- Patty Loveless has been produced by her husband, Emory Gordy Jr., for all but two albums. He and Tony Brown co-produced the first two, then Brown produced her third and fourth by himself, before Gordy returned permanently (with assistance from Justin Niebank on 2005's Dreaming My Dreams) Gordy also plays bass guitar on most of her albums, and in her road band.
- All of Five Iron Frenzy's albums (eight of them, over the course of eight years) were produced by Masaki Liu. In the liner notes of their final album, FIF called him and label-runner Frank Tate the 9th and 10th members of the band.
- Tony Clarke, who produced The Moody Blues' "classic seven" albums of the late '60s and early '70s, as well as the not-quite-as-classic-but-still-pretty-damn-good Octave from 1978. He's often referred to as "The Sixth Moody" by fans.
- Paul Rothchild produced almost every album by The Doors. He split with the band after Morrison Hotel, dismissing their new material as "cocktail music", so the band instead promoted engineer Bruce Botnick (who had engineered all of their albums) to the position for L.A. Woman.
- All of The Cure's albums between The Top and Wish were co-produced by David M. Allen.
- All of Steely Dan's albums were engineered and co-produced by Roger Nichols. All of their albums between Can't Buy A Thrill and Gaucho were produced by Gary Katz.
- All of Tim McGraw's material to date has been produced by Byron Gallimore except for his little-known debut single "What Room was the Holiday In", which was produced by Doug Johnson instead. James Stroud co-produced with Gallimore for the rest of McGraw's self-titled debut through Set This Circus Down in 2001; Darran Smith (Tim's guitarist) took over the co-production role from Tim McGraw and the Dancehall Doctors (2002) until Emotional Traffic (2012), Tim's last album for Curb Records. Following his move to Big Machine Records immediately after the latter, Smith departed as co-producer, leaving just McGraw and Gallimore for everything since.
- McGraw and Gallimore also produced for labelmate Jo Dee Messina from 1996 through 2006, except for her 2002 album A Joyful Noise, which was produced by Brent Maher (best known for producing The Judds). Also, the McGraw/Gallimore team only produced three tracks on 2005's Delicious Surprise, while Messina produced the rest of the album (something she hadn't done previously) with Gallimore on some tracks, and Mark Bright on others.
- Buddy Cannon has produced for Kenny Chesney since I Will Stand in 1997. Between then and All I Want for Christmas Is a Real Good Tan (2003), Cannon's frequent co-production partner Norro Wilson helped.
- All of Garth Brooks' albums except for three have been produced by Allen Reynolds. The first one was the In The Life Of Chris Gaines album, produced by Don Was. After Reynolds retired in the mid-2000s, Brooks' next two releases (the six-disc Blame It All on My Roots: Five Decades of Influences, entirely composed of covers, and 2014's Man Against Machine) were produced by his longtime engineer Mark Miller (not the same person as the lead singer of Sawyer Brown).
- Keith Urban worked with Dann Huff from 2002's Golden Road until 2013's Fuse, which included a different producer on nearly every track (including Huff on the single "Somewhere in My Car" plus a bonus track).
- Mary Chapin Carpenter co-produced all of her albums with John Jennings from her little-known 1987 debut Hometown Girl through Time* Sex* Love* in 2001. The former included one track co-produced by Steve Buckingham instead, while the latter had Blake Chancey as a third producer.
- Brad Paisley worked with producer Frank Rogers from his 1999 debut to 2012. Paisley notably refused to co-produce (something that many artists do), although he still abandoned Rogers in favor of self-production on 2012's Wheelhouse, and co-production with Luke Wooten on 2014's Moonshine in the Trunk.
- From 1996 to 2013, all of Gary Allan's material was produced by Mark Wright, albeit with at least one helping hand on the first four discs (songwriter Byron Hill on the first three, then Tony Brown on his third and fourth). Allan co-produced with Wright on his fifth through seventh albums, and Mark Droman (an engineer who frequently co-produces with Wright) joined on his eighth, Get Off on the Pain. 2013's Set You Free broke from the pack, with Jay Joyce on five tracks, Droman on four, and Wright on only three.
- With a handful of exceptions, Felton Jarvis produced or co-produced most of Elvis Presley's late 60s material, and in 1970 he was officially hired as Elvis's exclusive producer, a job he held until Elvis died.
- With a career spanning from the late 1970s to The New Tens, Randy Travis was produced by Kyle Lehning for all but four albums: his little-known 1978 debut under his real name of Randy Traywick (produced by Joe Stampley); Wind in the Wire, a 1992 album done as a side project for a TV series (produced by Steve Gibson); and his first two albums after switching from Warner Bros. to DreamWorks Records in 1998: You and You Alone and A Man Ain't Made of Stone (produced by Byron Gallimore and James Stroud).
- He's also had a couple stray tracks by different producers: his Warner Bros. debut "On the Other Hand" was co-produced by Keith Stegall, who declined any further production roles at the time as he wanted to focus on his own singing career (which imploded, thus leading to Stegall's long-running role as Alan Jackson's producer), and a cover of Brook Benton's "It's Just a Matter of Time", which was produced by Richard Perry for a compilation called Rock, Rhythm & Blues and included on one of Randy's albums because he liked how it sounded.
- The Oak Ridge Boys were produced by Ron Chancey for most of their hit-making years, spanning from the late 70s to the mid-late 80s.
- All of John Conlee's material dating back to his Breakthrough Hit "Rose Colored Glasses" in 1978 has been produced by Bud Logan.
- Jason Aldean has only ever been produced by Michael Knox. Before Aldean's debut single in 2005, Knox had only one other production credit way back in 1998.
- From his third album onward, Cledus T. Judd was produced by his frequent co-writer, Chris Clark, although 2013's Parodyziac!! had a couple tracks co-produced by Rex Paul Schnelle instead.
- Carrie Underwood has been produced by Mark Bright from 2004-2014, all except her American Idol coronation single "Inside Your Heaven", a few tracks on her debut album that were produced by Dann Huff instead, and a handful of guest appearances.
- The Judds had only one producer, Brent Maher, in a career spanning 1984-1991. After Wynonna Judd broke from the duo, Maher also produced most of her fourth studio album, 1997's The Other Side, as well as all of her releases since her 2006 Christmas album.
- Diamond Rio has been produced by Michael Clute since their third album, 1994's Love a Little Stronger. From the next album onward, they began co-producing.
- Except for a few instances, all of Girls Aloud's albums have been written and produced by Xenomania, a team headed up by producer Brian Higgins, lyricist Miranda Cooper, and their various helpers. Higgins is also one of the producers behind Cher's legendary comeback song "Believe".
- In combination with being the DIY Producer (q.v.), Jimmy Page was responsible for all nine Led Zeppelin albums.
- All of Rodney Atkins' material except for his very little known 1997 debut "In a Heartbeat" has been produced by songwriter Ted Hewitt, who has almost never produced for anyone else.
- Eric Church has never had any producer except for Jay Joyce, who is best known for his work with Cage the Elephant.
The Helping Hand Producer
After that, I think we finally figured out that Guy [Bidmead] just wasn't Vic Maile. [...] He was too nice! Vic knew when to tell us to shut the fuck up!The Helping Hand Producer is a slightly subjective trope, and one whose existence is rather hard to determine until after the fact. It refers to the belief that one producer is a great match for a band because he knows their strengths and helps them produce excellent albums. A great sign of this trope is when the band split with said producer and release albums that don't have the same reception. As said, it's easier to discern after a split occured.
Lemmy, about working on Nö Sleep At All
- Vic Maile for Motörhead, to the point that even Lemmy admitted it (see above).
- Stephen Street for the Cranberries. After they switched to Bruce Fairbairn in 1996, To the Faithful Departed got a massive panning.
- A review of The Stone Roses' debut album, The Stone Roses reissue which includes demos pointed out that John Leckie played an important part in making the band sound great.
- The Tori Amos albums that Eric Rosse produced (Little Earthquakes, Under the Pink) are among her most critically acclaimed.
- Tony Visconti for Music/David Bowie. The albums he recorded with David Bowie, Low, Heroes, Lodger and Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) are among the most critically acclaimed of Bowie's career. Following his split with Visconti in the '80s, Bowie produced Let's Dance (his biggest commercial hit, but considered by many to be too 'polished' to be a proper Bowie album) and the derided Tonight, Never Let Me Down and Tin Machine albums. Their renewed association in the 21st century produced, among other things, 2013's well-regarded The Next Day.
- Joy Division started as a generic punk band. Then they hooked up with Martin Hannett, and the rest is history.
- Elvis Costello admitted that he took up production duties on The Pogues' Rum, Sodomy & the Lash because he felt he could help them achieve Three Chords and the Truth-hood:
I saw my task... was to capture them in their delapidated glory before some more professional producer fucked them up.
- For added hilarity points, The Pogues hooked up with professional producer Steve Lillywhite for If I Should Fall from Grace with God and scored one of their most successful albums.
- Rush have this sort of relationship with Nick Raskulinecz, the producer of Snakes and Arrows and Clockwork Angels. The band were initially taken aback by how readily and enthusiastically he would tell Neil Peart to change a drum part, but he won their respect by not letting the band coast through the recording process.
- Alabama seemed to lose focus after ditching original producer Harold Shedd in 1988. Larry Michael Lee and Josh Leo were able to carry them for a few more years with a more mainstream sound, but their fate continued to slide once he was replaced with Garth Fundis for two tracks off a Greatest Hits Album, Emory Gordy Jr. for one album (1994's In Pictures), then Don Cook for everything afterward.
- Going the opposite way, Brooks & Dunn's fortunes were failing with their 1999 dud Tight Rope. It was their last album with original producer Don Cook, and their only album with Byron Gallimore (who produced all three singles from it). Their two most-acclaimed albums, 2001's Steers & Stripes (which included their biggest hit, "Ain't Nothing 'bout You") and 2003's Red Dirt Road, were praised for the more energetic and muscular production of Mark Wright. They switched again to Tony Brown on Hillbilly Deluxe (2005), who moved them more or less back to where they were on the early Cook-produced albums.
- Little Big Town acknowledged on a Great American Country special that they did not find their sound until they began working with Wayne Kirkpatrick, who gave them a sound not unlike a grittier, more countrified Fleetwood Mac. Interestingly, they abandoned him in favor of the eclectic Jay Joyce starting with 2012's Tornado.
- Rodney Atkins originally worked with producer Chuck Howard, who cast him as a mustachioed cowboy singing in a Roy Orbison-esque voice. Dissatisfied with this image, Atkins asked the head of his label for a change in producers, and he ended up under the production of otherwise completely unknown Ted Hewitt. After a false start with Honesty, which pretty much had him as an expy of then-labelmade Tim McGraw, Hewitt later helped find Atkins' strength as a baseball cap-wearing everyman who sings positive songs that often centralize on the family starting with If You're Going Through Hell.
- John Simon produced The Band's first two albums; coincidentally or not, those are also their two most popular and acclaimed releases by a large measure.
- When The Monkees won the right to control their own music they brought in former Modern Folk Quartet member Chip Douglas as producer. His laid-back, patient style was perfect for a group who was basically learning on the job. Everyone agrees that the two albums he produced (Headquarters; Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn and Jones Ltd.) are their best.
- Jake Owen's most commercially successful are the two on which Joey Moi (best known for his work with Nickelback) produced: Barefoot Blue Jean Night (2011) and Days of Gold (2013).
The DIY occurs when a band gets Genre Savvy toward Real Life and decides to produce their albums themselves to avoid interference. Either that, or they have a creative vision that they couldn't express properly before.
- Electronic music, due to its basis in sound generated from scratch, has each musician working as their own producer. In the pop landscape of the 2000s, many electronic musicians are even asked to produce for other artists. See DIY.
- The Beach Boys' Brian Wilson, at least in their most commercially and critically successful years.
- Although the nominal producer on their earliest records was Nick Venet, by most accounts his role was limited to telling the engineer to do whatever Brian Wilson wanted.
- The Beach Boys' early '60s surf-pop rivals, Jan and Dean, also had a DIY producer/arranger in Jan Berry.
- Yoshiki Hayashi for almost every X Japan single or album, although Jade was co-produced with an American producer.
- Jimmy Page, who produced every Led Zeppelin album.
- It is worth noting Jimmy was an experienced producer by the time Led Zeppelin started. He even admitted he switched around engineers for every album to make it clear to everybody that he was the architect of the band's sound.
- Ron and Russell Mael of Sparks have produced and recorded all their albums since 1988's Interior Design by themselves.
- Trent Reznor, the only permanent member of Nine Inch Nails.
- Al Jourgensen, for Ministry.
- RZA for the Wu-Tang Clan.
- Geoff Barrow, for Portishead.
- George Clinton, for Parliament-Funkadelic.
- Jack Dangers, the only permanent member of Meat Beat Manifesto.
- My Bloody Valentine were credited as producers for every album/EP except Loveless, which credits bandmembers Kevin Shields and Colm O Ciosoig (the latter purely for the interlude "Touched").
- The Velvet Underground started self-producing with 1969's eponymous album, The Velvet Underground, after one album (allegedly) produced by Andy Warhol (The Velvet Underground & Nico) and one with Tom Wilson (White Light/White Heat).
- Queen, alone (1976-1977) or in collaboration with three other producers: Roy Thomas Baker (1973-1975, 1978), Mack (1980-1984) and David Richards (1986-1995).
- Paul McCartney. alone or in collaboration, for most of his solo career. Anything of his recorded after the break-up and before 1998 has his touch.
- Steve Harris has produced or co-produced a lot of albums and videos for his band, Iron Maiden.
- Steven Wilson self-produces Porcupine Tree records, and has produced other bands such as Opeth.
- The Rolling Stones' "Glimmer Twins" (Mick Jagger and Keith Richards) have either produced their albums themselves or in collaboration with others (Steve Lillywhite, Don Was, The Dust Brothers) since It's Only Rock 'N' Roll.
- Sonic Youth have had a co-production credit on almost every record since around Bad Moon Rising.
- Big Black, considering their guitarist was Steve Albini, who produced their album Songs About Fucking.
- After Tori Amos' boyfriend/producer broke up with her, she thought it would be appropriate to produce her next album Boys for Pele. Now Tori produces all of her albums.
- Kate Bush.
- The Tea Party.
- Most recent Rush albums give the band, or at least guitarist Alex Lifeson, a producer co-credit.
- Recent Hot Hot Heat albums are recorded in a studio Steve Bays owns and mostly self-produced.
- Disturbed from Indestructible onward. The primary production seat is held by guitarist Dan Donegan.
- Mike Shinoda has produced everything Linkin Park-related aside from their first two albums and Dead by Sunrise's debut.
- The Smiths co-produced all their albums, usually with either John Porter or Stephen Street. Morrissey and Johnny Marr received the main credits, but Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce were allowed to make decisions about how to mix their own instruments.
- The Cure or Robert Smith have been credited as co-producers on every album since Seventeen Seconds.
- The Band, beginning with their third album.
- Toby Keith's first two albums and a Christmas album were produced by Nelson Larkin and Harold Shedd. After Shedd left Mercury, Keith began co-producing everything he put out: first with Larkin for one album, then with James Stroud (from 1997's Dream Walkin' through 2005's Honkytonk University, his last album for DreamWorks Records before it closed). He has been mostly DIY ever since, with the occasional helping hand.
- Garbage (though Bleed Like Me has an extra producer as they started it really burned out).
- Kanye West is the Trope Maker of this for hip-hop, as he was a producer before he became a rapper and so produces all of his songs, which lends his albums a sense of coherence and vision that most hip-hop albums lack.
- Kanye opened a door for "producer/rappers" and made them appealing to record-labels (less production costs), and as a result there are now the likes of J Cole and Big K.R.I.T. in or on the outskirts of the mainstream.
- Before Kanye, someone taught Eminem how to produce, and as a result, Shady co-produced the vast majority of The Eminem Show.
- Dr Dre is not really an example, simply because Dre didn't write any of his raps, and was first and foremost a record producer. A number of well-known rappers have written raps for Dre, including Eminem, Snoop Dogg, Royce da 5'9', Kendrick Lamar and Jay-Z (famously on "Still D.R.E.").
- Electric Light Orchestra's albums are either produced or co-produced by Jeff Lynne.
- As mentioned above, Brad Paisley abandoned Frank Rogers, who'd produced him since 1999, in favor of self-production on 2013's Wheelhouse. That album has a far more bombastic style than before, which has been met with mixed results. What makes this more interesting is that, unlike most artists, Paisley refused to co-produce.
- Clint Black was produced by James Stroud for the entire first decade of his career. Mark Wright co-produced the first album, and Clint co-produced from his third album onward. Starting with D'Lectrified in 1999, he abandoned Stroud and produced everything by himself. He also produced Nashville Star winner Buddy Jewell's debut.
- The Yardbirds' bassist, Paul Samwell-Smith, produced some of their '60s sessions (most notably their Roger The Engineer album). After the group's breakup he went on to become a successful producer for such artists as Cat Stevens, Jethro Tull, and Carly Simon.
- Manny Charlton helmed the releases of Nazareth between Hair of the Dog and No Mean City. Charlton also co-produced the album Rampant, which came right before Hair of the Dog, with Roger Glover.
- Cat Stevens was the producer of his 1973 album Foreigner and helmed every release from there to his final album as Cat Stevens, Back to Earth, both collectively with others (Paul Samwell-Smith on Buddha and the Chocolate Box and Back to Earth and Dave Kershenbaum on Izitso) and individually (the only other release as such being Numbers).
- Nick Jameson produced two albums for Foghat, Rock and Roll Outlaws and Fool for the City. He played bass as an actual member of Foghat on the songs from the latter, including "Slow Ride."
- Roger Boyd of Head East produced the group's debut album, Flat as a Pancake.
- Sleigh Bells has Derek E. Miller who plays all instruments, writes all the songs, and produces the albums himself (the only other member is Alexis Krauss, who only sings).
The One or More Trick Pony
The One Or More Trick Pony has one or more distinctive styles that, consciously or not, he imposes on the bands who work with him.
- Nigel Godrich - ethereal space-rock (Radiohead, Pavement, R.E.M., Beck etc.).
- Mark Ronson - more trumpets (Lily Allen, Amy Winehouse, etc.).
- Jackknife Lee - fuzzy ballad rock (U2, Kasabian, Bloc Party, etc.).
- Bill Laswell - Neoclassical Punk Zydeco Rockabilly fusion with a recurring Production Posse of session musicians. His production work on Herbie Hancock albums is often derided as "Bill Laswell featuring Herbie Hancock".
- John Leckie - Sixties influenced psychedelic rock (The Stone Roses, XTC, The Verve, Radiohead).
- Steve Albini - aggressive, lo-fi Grunge/Alternative Rock (The Pixies, The Breeders, Nirvana, PJ Harvey). Although he did do a fantastic job recording folk singer/songwriter/harpist Joanna Newsom and Post-Rock ensemble Godspeed You! Black Emperor with an almost absurd degree of clarity, and Mono's Hymn To The Immortal Wind with an orchestra and thirteen minute instrumental tracks. But he's still stereotypically associated with lo-fi recording methods and big-name Alternative Rock bands.
- Robert John "Mutt" Lange - formerly gritty Hard Rock (AC/DC's Highway to Hell, Back in Black), now over-produced pop-rock (Def Leppard's Pyromania and Hysteria, The Cars' "Heartbeat City", Bryan Adams' Waking Up the Neighbours, Nickelback's Dark Horse) and pop-country (ex-wife Shania Twain).
- Nick Lowe developed a clean, unpretentious pop sound ("bash it out, we'll tart it up later") in the late '70s which helped launch the careers of, among others, Elvis Costello and the Pretenders.
- Butch Vig - clearly recorded but still aggressive grunge/alternative rock (Nirvana, L7, The Smashing Pumpkins) or industrial rock (Garbage).
- Tony Visconti - trippy glam rock (T. Rex), grinding proto-industrial rock (David Bowie's Berlin Trilogy and Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)), and various other styles (Mary Hopkin, Moody Blues, etc.)
- Larry Klein has produced exclusively albums by female singer-songwriters. He got his start on Wild Things Run Fast by Joni Mitchell, whom he eventually married, though it didn't last.
- The same thing happened to Eric Rosse, whose production credit on Little Earthquakes and Under the Pink led to him being hired quite frequently by female singer-songwriters (Lisa Marie Presley, Anna Nalick, Sara Bareilles, etc).
- Jim Steinman - a grandiose, bombastic sound that is equal parts Bruce Springsteen and Richard Wagner. He perfected this style with Meat Loaf and Bonnie Tyler, and it's very much in evidence on a variety of one-shot singles he's done with other artists (Air Supply's "Making Love Out of Nothing at All", Céline Dion's "It's All Coming Back to Me Now").
- Marty Munsch - known as "The Phil Spector of punk rock" for his aggressive, massive sound and his work with various industrial Ministry, KMFDM, My Life With the Thrill Kill Kult, Nine Inch Nails, Revolting Cocks, Young Gods, Front Line Assembly) and electronic bands (Meat Beat Manifesto, The KLF).
- Phil Spector - inventor of "The Wall of Sound".
- Rick Rubin - his scaled down sound marked by minimal use of effects like reverb, trying to keep most of the instrumentation live and a focus on performance and precision. He's known for the sheer eclecticism of the bands he's worked with and his seemingly uncanny ability to bring out the best in the people he works with. His credits include: Beastie Boys (Licensed to Ill), Run-D.M.C., LL Cool J (Radio famously had the credit "reduced by Rick Rubin"), Jay-Z, Slayer (Reign in Blood, South of Heaven, Seasons in the Abyss and more), Johnny Cash (the American Recordings series), Red Hot Chili Peppers (all of their albums since Blood Sugar Sex Magik), Danzig, Metallica (Death Magnetic), System of a Down (all their albums), AC/DC (Ballbreaker), Neil Diamond (12 Songs), Justin Timberlake and Weezer. On a more negative note, he is also notorious for Loudness Warring his recent releases to an egregious extent.
- Bob Ezrin - alternately grandiose and arty (Pink Floyd's The Wall, Lou Reed's Berlin, Peter Gabriel's first album) or simple and direct (Aerosmith's Get Your Wings, KISS' Destroyer), but always pretty slammin' rock.
- Scott Burns very nearly invented the sound of 90's death metal, producing Cannibal Corpse's first five albums, five by Deicide, four by Obituary, three by Death, three by Malevolent Creation, and many more. His retirement from producing was largely due to death metal exhaustion, having never been a big fan of the music, just very good at making it sound right.
- Gil Norton - spacey, aggressive Alternative Rock (The Pixies, James, Belly, Catherine Wheel, Foo Fighters) or whiny Post-Grungey indie rock (Dashboard Confessional, Jimmy Eat World).
- Stock Aitken Waterman - high-energy pop-dance (Dead or Alive, Rick Astley, Kylie Minogue). Probably the most hated of the bunch.
- Conny Plank - Krautrock. Yes, it is a bit circular since Krautrock is basically "sounding like Conny Plank", but his tendencies (expressed through Kraftwerk and Neu!) are clear: lots of synth, lots of echo, clear clean drums and liberal use of abstract noise as an instrument.
- Timbaland - dance-pop music with heavy drums
- David Foster - Bombastic piano and orchestral-driven power ballads.
- The Neptunes - dance-pop/rap music with emphasis on bass & drums
- Trevor Horn - crystal-clear sound quality, eighties reverb, lush arrangements, heavy use of samplers and new recording technology, the presence of Anne Dudley and J.J. Jeczalik.
- Erik Rutan - Mostly death metal, though he does other genres from time to time. Especially known for great guitar tone and an approach that can be anal and perfectionist at some times and laissez-faire at others, though he also has major Loudness War issues.
- Giorgio Moroder - a pioneer of the 'computer disco' sound in the 1970s, like with Donna Summer's I Remember Yesterday (1977) and Bad Girls (1979) and subsequently producing many New Wave, hi-NRG and rock artists in the 1980s. Heavy emphasis on analogue synthesisers and four-on-the-floor drum machine rhythms.
- Bruce Fairbairn - overly bombastic, occasionally horn- and synth-laden rock (Aerosmith, Yes, AC/DC, Bon Jovi, Loverboy).
- Red One - booming drums, grungey sawtooth synth bass overlaid with sweet-sounding synth melodies.
- Dann Huff Slick, often bombastic mainstream country-pop with loads of electric guitar, making him a particularly effective producer for the rock-styled guitar work of Keith Urban. (Not surprisingly, Huff is also a session guitarist, and often plays on whatever he produces.)
- One of his favorite tricks with Rascal Flatts, whom he produced from 2005 to 2013, is to make the song start off really soft with just piano, then keep building and building until the song is almost ridiculously loud on the final chorus, before cooling back off to just piano again. This power balladry often forced lead singer Gary LeVox, who already has an extremely nasal tenor voice, to resort to really whiny, warbly histrionics just to be heard over the noise.
- Some of his production on The Band Perry's Pioneer is noticeably more organic than Huff usually is, particularly "Better Dig Two".
- Huff made a rare excursion outside country-pop when he produced Megadeth's Cryptic Writings and Risk, but he still brought a slicker, more mainstream-friendly sound to those albums compared to Megadeth's previous output. Mustaine later admitted that he made a mistake in allowing Huff and his manager Bud Prager more creative control over Risk, blaming them for its terrible reception.
- Kelly Clarkson's "Don't Rush" is also a major exception, with none of Huff's usual bombast. It's a very laid-back song that sounds like an early 80s country-pop tune.
- Jay Joyce uses lots of funky acoustic guitar riffs, usually in really low tunings like Drop C, and heavy electric guitar. He also loves using drum loops and nonstandard instrumentation (for instance, "Homeboy" by Eric Church has harps on it), and loves vocal filters (e.g. Church's "Creepin'" or Little Big Town's "Pontoon"), and his production has a very "raw", unpolished feel throughout. However, he does know when to tone it down, such as Thomas Rhett's "Beer with Jesus" or Church's "Like Jesus Does".
- As mentioned above, Keith Stegall has worked with Alan Jackson on all but one album. While Jackson is known for his meat-and-potatoes, everyman simplicity, that same sound can be heard in a lot of Stegall's other productions. Most notably, Stegall's knack for simplicity brings out the harmonies and nylon-string guitar/fiddle/keyboard interplay of the Zac Brown Band. However, Stegall often let his bombastic pop side out of the bag in the early 2000s when producing for Mark Wills and Jamie O'Neal.
- Frank Rogers also has a generally light touch with crisp vocals and a prominent bass line, making him most effective for the deep-voiced, traditional-sounding Josh Turner and other strong vocalists such as Darryl Worley, Darius Rucker, and Scotty McCreery (although unusually for him, some of Rucker's work falls under Loudness War). On the other hand, his production for Brad Paisley usually tended to be a little heavier and more guitar-driven (a logical choice, since Paisley is a guitarist).
- Paul Worley (no relation to Darryl) also wears many hats. He started off with a meaty, guitar-heavy sound (unsurprisingly, he's also a session guitarist like Dann Huff) that wasn't too polished, and kept this into the late 1990s. By the early 2000s, he used ultra-slick pop sheen on Martina McBride, nearly Meat Loaf levels of pure rock loudness on Big & Rich's albums, and returned to ultra-slick pop sheen later in the decade for Lady Antebellum. One of Worley's trademarks is using a very large number of instruments that come and go throughout the song.
- Michael Knox seems to excel in a raw, overdriven, Southern rock-influenced sound that's less brickwalled than most, but isn't as "quirky" as Jay Joyce. This is most evident on his production for Jason Aldean, but it also helped return Montgomery Gentry to their signature sound on Rebels on the Run.
- Dr Luke - self-consciously low-fi, video-gamey synths, arrangements that sound sparse but take ridiculous amounts of multitracking to do, and very sparkly, ultra-sampled guitar. His biggest success is Katy Perry, but his sound is so distinctive that a number of people confused Jessie J for Perry on first hearing simply because they both work with him.
- Nathan Chapman (Taylor Swift) has an affinity for more acoustic-driven arrangements. If any electric guitar is used at all, it's usually clean. The only exceptions are the pop mixes of Swift's songs, which are given heavy back beats, and the heavy electric guitar on the pop mix of The Band Perry's "If I Die Young". However, as of about 2012, he's developed a much more layered, overdub-heavy style with lots of polish, as seen on the tracks he produced on Keith Urban's Fuse, as well as Lady Antebellum's output from "Compass" onward.
- Frank Liddell seems to have two modes: "reasonable" and "brick-walled into total noise". It's hard to believe that Miranda Lambert's "The House That Built Me" (nothing but vocals and acoustic guitar) and "Only Prettier" (very loud and brickwalled) had the same man behind the boards. One of his favorite tricks is making the guitars super-loud but hyper-compressing them into a loud, trebly, tinny mess (good example: "Let It Rain" by David Nail).
- Some of it also comes from his occasional production partner Mike Wrucke, who does the same thing to albums by the Eli Young Band — one track sounds good, another is obscenely brick-walled.
- Billy Sherrill: sophisticated, dramatic music mixing traditional country instruments with strings and other embellishments, fronted by a distinctively-voiced singer (Tammy Wynette, George Jones, Charlie Rich).
- James William Guercio: horn-dominated hybrids of jazz and rock (Chicago's first 11 albums; Blood, Sweat & Tears; The Buckinghams).
- Mark Bright: Slick country-pop, dating back to his work with Blackhawk in the mid-late 90s. It carried Rascal Flatts for their first few albums, and is now seen on Carrie Underwood's work. Basically "Dann Huff if he backed off on the guitars a little".
- Buddy Cannon seems to have two modes. The first is neotraditionalist fiddle-and-steel country, a style that he's kept since the early 90s when he worked with the likes of Sammy Kershaw and George Jones, and on through the likes of Chris Young and Ashton Shepherd. The other is "Kenny Chesney style", which has evolved from the same neotraditionalism, to a snare drum and guitar-heavy arena rock sound (e.g. "Big Star", "Young"), to a combination of tropical influences ("Everybody Wants to Go to Heaven") and somber, spare, acoustic numbers with little more than acoustic guitar and organ ("You and Tequila", "El Cerrito Place").
- Andy Sneap specializes in heavy metal, and has a known penchant for a very specific guitar sound that heavily pushes low-mids.
- Mark Wright, a Country Music producer, is known for really "heavy" instrumentation with lots of up-front guitar and drums. His production style helped re-energize Brooks & Dunn on their 2001 comeback album Steers & Stripes. Since about 2000, he's also favored a huge amount of instrumentation with big walls of backing vocals and often odd instrument choices, such as a mandolin distorted through an amplifier. (Lee Ann Womack specifically sought out Wright on her first albums for his "fat" production.) Wright is also a fan of vocal processing: he used lots of Auto-Tune on Joe Nichols' Old Things New and has repeatedly used filters on Gary Allan's voice.
The Multiple Producers is, well, when a band works with more than one producer for an album. This can be for various reasons - either they worked with one at first then moved on to the other and both batches of songs ended up on the album, they consciously set out to do so, they found a few who bring out different parts of their sound, etc. The advantage here is that you get more people you can bounce ideas off of, and may provide a degree of diversity to your album. The pitfall is that Too Many Cooks Spoil the Soup, and you might just end up with an inconsistent, disorganised and schizophrenic mess.
- Almost every Hip-Hop album since sometime in the mid-nineties. There are lots of reviewers who point out that this basically loses the coherence and sonic/conceptual unity that rap albums had in the past when the entire production would be handled by one guy/team.
- Whereas previous Pink Floyd albums were either credited to Norman Smith (1967-1970) or the band alone (1971-1977), The Wall's production credit reads: Bob Ezrin, David Gilmour, James Guthrie, Roger Waters. The Final Cut is slightly less unwieldy, being reduced to Waters, Guthrie and Michael Kamen - but that's partly because Gilmour had his name removed from the production credits over disagreements with Waters over the direction of the album.
- All of U2's albums since 1984 have been produced by Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois, but in The '90s they expanded production credits by having The Edge take occasional credits, bringing in Steve Lillywhite for Achtung Baby, Mark "Flood" Ellis for Zooropa and Howie B and Steve Osborne for Pop. How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb bears their longest list of producers, numbering: Steve Lillywhite, Chris Thomas, Jacknife Lee, Nellee Hooper, Flood, Daniel Lanois, Brian Eno and Carl Glanville.
- The production duo of Clive Langer and Alan Winstanley produced just about every Madness studio album (with the exception of their covers album, The Dangermen Sessions, Vol. 1), as well as Too-Rye-Aye for Dexys Midnight Runners and a couple of albums for They Might Be Giants and Elvis Costello.
- Most of Jars of Clay's self-titled debut was self-produced, but Flood and "Liquid" (two of their first hit singles) were produced by Adrian Belew.
- Primus specifically drafted in more producers and guest musicians for Antipop to try and do something different. Said producers included: Tom Morello, Tom Waits, Stewart Copeland, Matt Stone and Fred Durst.
- The B-52s' Cosmic Thing. Half the tracks are produced by Nile Rodgers, and half by Don Was. The tracks produced by Rodgers are more commercial sounding and happy, whereas the Was tracks are more experimental and jungly. Not really surprising, considering both Rodgers' and Was' backgrounds as performers, with Rodgers serving as lead guitarist for the mainstream disco pop band, Chic, and Was serving as bassist for the more eclectic rock group, Was (Not Was).
- Country Music producers Buddy Cannon and Norro Wilson frequently co-produced in The '90s, most notably for Kenny Chesney. From about 2003 onward, Wilson has been largely retired, while Cannon has focused almost all of his production efforts on Chesney.
- Jason Aldean's road band (which consists of Tully Kennedy, Kurt Allison, David Fanning, and Rich Redmond) produces for labelmates Thompson Square, James Wesley, and Parmalee under the name New Voice Entertainment. Fanning also records on the same label as a solo artist.
- Keith Urban's 2013 album Fuse features eleven producers, including himself, longtime co-producer Dann Huff, and a few from far outside the realm of country (e.g., Benny Blanco and Stargate). The album has been fairly well-received for the resulting mix of sounds.
The Man in the Middle
What's my job as a producer? To produce an album. I'm not getting paid to be Layne Staley's friend.The Man in the Middle is the exact opposite of the Acrimony Producer: this time around, the band members are too busy fighting amongst ''themselves'' and the producer by default ends up trying to keep the whole thing going, even if it means being the only one around to tell the band to chill out and get back to, y'know, recording.
— Dave Jerden, about working with Alice in Chains.
- Richard Dashut and Ken Caillat, Fleetwood Mac's producers from 1977's Rumours to 1987's Tango in the Night. Ken recalled that during the Rumours sessions the band members would, when not recording, get into fights with one another and snort whatever they had handy, and he repeatedly found cocaine lying on the mixing desk.
- George Martin himself in his final sessions with The Beatles. After the ordeal that was recording Let It Be, with George Martin mostly absent, Glyn Johns being more in charge of the whole thing than anyone, and fights erupting left and right, Paul asked George Martin if he was willing to do one more album with the band. George replied "Yes, if I am really allowed to produce it". Although the boys didn't hate each other much less than in the previous sessions, they were willing to let George Martin reign supreme and the ensuing album, Abbey Road, is not only much more consistent and cohesive than The Beatles ("The White Album") and Let It Be, it's also one of the best albums by anybody, period.
- Dave Jerden had the misfortune of being pretty much the only sober man around while Alice in Chains were recording Dirt, inevitably clashing with the band over their destructive habits.
- By some accounts, Trevor Horn was forced to attempt this on Yes' Big Generator. It didn't work.
- Although Pink Floyd were credited as Producers or Co-Producers on all their albums up until Roger Waters left (either as 'Pink Floyd' or David Gilmour & Roger Waters), various producers such as Chris Thomas (The Dark Side of the Moon) and Bob Ezrin (The Wall) were brought in to mediate between Gilmour and Waters' different visions of the music. Thomas largely accomplished this goal by skillfully reaching a sonic middleground that satisfied both Gilmour and Waters, while co-producer James Guthrie described Ezrin as being more forceful in bridging the gap between the two, who at that point had a soured relationship after Waters' I Am the Band trip starting with Wish You Were Here.
- Gary Usher produced three albums for The Byrds and found himself in this role for the chaotic The Notorious Byrd Brothers sessions, during which David Crosby and Michael Clarke were fired and ex-member Gene Clark rejoined the group but abruptly quit after a few weeks. A bonus track on a later CD reissue of the album captures a vicious in-studio argument between Crosby and Clarke with Usher trying to act as peacemaker. To his credit, it's usually considered their best album.
Artist as Producer and vice versa
Artist as Producer/Producer as Artist. Two sides of the same coin. Sometimes, an established artist will be sought out by up-and-coming artists hoping that whatever magic made the established artist a star will rub off to them. This can have varying results (the less said about Keith Moon's attempts to produce Peter Cook the better) but sometimes it will lead to a secondary career for the established artist which may prove invaluable when the hits dry up and when touring becomes more of a pain. In the second category, there are those who start off with 'Producer' as their day job and seeing the adulation for the acts they work with, at some point think "I gotta get me a bit of that"
Examples in the first category include;
- Munetaka Higuchi.
- Yoshiki Hayashi. See "Acrimony Producer" above.
- Todd Rundgren. See "Acrimony Producer" above.
- Paul Samwell-Smith, following the breakup of The Yardbirds. See "DIY Producer" above.
- Brian Eno. Starting as a synthesizer player with Roxy Music, he then released a number of acclaimed solo albums. This led to production jobs with the likes of Talking Heads, Devo, David Bowie, U2 and James.
- David Bowie. Used his star power to resurrect the careers of early influences such as Mott the Hoople, Iggy Pop (The Idiot, Lust for Life) and Lou Reed (Transformer).
- Elvis Costello: For The Pogues, Squeeze and The Specials. Costello was at one point considered to produce They Might Be Giants' breakthrough Flood, but the Johns hired his former producers Clive Langer and Alan Winstanley instead.
- Edwyn Collins: Having had hits with the group Orange Juice and a succesful solo career, he went on to produce for Terrorvision, The Proclaimers and The Cribs
- As mentioned above, Tim McGraw produced most of Jo Dee Messina's albums with Byron Gallimore; the two also produced The Clark Family Experience, Lori McKenna, and Halfway to Hazard. The former was on Curb as well, while the latter two were on StyleSonic, a label that McGraw and Gallimore own as a side project.
- As mentioned above, Tony Brown was a prolific piano/keyboard player for several artists before becoming a producer at the end of The '80s.
- Dann Huff was a member of the Christian rock band White Heart, and later the rock band Giant. He spent most of the late 1980s through mid-1990s as a session guitarist, primarily in country music. By the end of the 1990s, he started working as a producer, starting with a few small country acts before getting his big production break on Faith Hill's Faith album. Ever since, Huff has focused more on production, and generally plays guitar only on albums that he produced.
- Ronnie Dunn of Brooks & Dunn co-produced Wade Hayes' 2001 album Highways & Heartaches. Another producer on this album was Terry McBride, formerly Lead Bassist of McBride & the Ride and a then-member of Brooks & Dunn's road band.
- Garth Brooks produced Highways & Dance Halls, the third album by his friend (and former guitarist) Ty England.
- Singer-songwriter Paul Overstreetnote made his production debut in 2012, collaborating with Tony Brown on songs by Kristen Kelly.
- The Reverend Horton Heat had three different albums produced by people primarily known as musicians: The Full-Custom Gospel Sounds of the Reverend Horton Heat was produced by Butthole Surfers vocalist Gibby Haynes, Spend A Night In The Box was produced by Butthole Surfers guitarist Paul Leary, and Liquor In The Front was produced by Ministry's Al Jourgensen.
- Electric Light Orchestra's Jeff Lynne has found a secondary career of producing other musicians' albums as a result of his work with ELO and The Traveling Wilburys. He produced his Wilburys bandmate Tom Petty's Full Moon Fever (Petty credits him for being the main reason "Free Fallin'" was written, as he had brought the sequence of three chords into the studio and encouraged Petty to work it into a song), and became a Promoted Fanboy by working on The Beatles' "Free as a Bird" and "Real Love" from The Beatles Anthology, having been chosen specifically because of the combination of his production expertise and the fact that he was a great fan of the Beatles.
- Brett James is an interesting version, as his career path changed many times. He started out with an album on Arista Records in 1995, then put his career on hold to start a family and attend college. In the early 2000s, he turned down an invitation to join the band Sixwire and started writing songs for others. These cuts' success led to him re-signing with Arista and charting with two singles that never made it onto an album. Although the second phase of his singing career didn't pan out, songwriting was his bread and butter for many years. But after the hits stopped coming, he turned to producing for the likes of Mark Wills, Josh Gracin, Jessica Simpson, and Kip Moore.
- Byron Gallimore was originally a singer who won a contest at a song festival. When his singing career didn't pan out, another producer (James Stroud) encouraged him to start producing as well. Gallimore went on to produce all of Tim McGraw's albums, with other notable production credits including Faith Hill (Tim's wife), Jessica Andrews, and Sugarland. He also collaborated with Stroud on several occasions.
- Besides his work with The Beach Boys, Brian Wilson produced a number of singles for outside artists during the '60s, although none of them enjoyed anything close to the commercial success the Beach Boys did. In 2003 Ace Records in the UK issued a compilation CD of these, cleverly titled Pet Projects.
- Ever wondered how, exactly, Neil Diamond managed to get onstage with all those rock legends in The Last Waltz? The fact that The Band's Robbie Robertson had produced Diamond's Beautiful Noise album earlier that year might just possibly have had something to do with it.
- This is common rap, examples include Kanye West, Jay-Z, and Timbaland, among others.
- In the last twenty years of pop music, electronic music producers (themselves artists, as they producer their own songs) have increasingly been tapped to produce songs for mainstream pop acts. Some examples include William Orbit for Madonna, Zedd for Lady Gaga, and Calvin Harris for a number of artists including Rihanna and Ellie Goulding.
- Frank Zappa founded his own labels, "Bizarre", "Straight", "Barking Pumpkin",... to help musicians that wouldn't get a chance for release elsewhere. This included producing Outsider Music like Wild Man Fischer and Captain Beefheart's Trout Mask Replica and Alice Cooper's debut album. He also produced an album for Grand Funk Railroad, despite the band being extremely popular at the time.
- John Zorn's independent label Tzadik distributes his own music, but also produces countless experimental musicians, among which Boredoms are the most famous.
- Jay DeMarcus, bassist and keyboardist of Rascal Flatts, has produced albums by James Otto (his brother-in-law), Chicago, and Kix Brooks among others.
- Roger Glover of Deep Purple took the reins of three Nazareth albums, Razamanaz, Loud 'n' Proud, and Rampant. Glover produced the last of these with Nazareth guitarist Manny Charlton.
- The aforementioned Norro Wilson was originally a singer for Smash Records before becoming a producer.
- As mentioned above, Jason Aldean's road band is also the production team New Voice Entertainment. One of the members, David Fanning, has also released singles on Broken Bow, the same label to which Aldean has signed.
- Shane McAnally was originally a recording artist for Curb Records in 1999, for which he recorded one album and three singles. When this didn't pan out, he disappeared for a while, and scored a few songwriting credits. These then paved the way for an equally fruitful career as a producer for Kacey Musgraves, Sam Hunt, Jake Owen, and Old Dominion.
- Mac McAnally (no relation), a prolific songwriter, on and off singer ("Down the Road", "Back Where I Come From"), and member of Jimmy Buffett's Coral Reefer band, has also produced for Buffett, Sawyer Brown, Restless Heart, and others.
- In The '80s, Jeff Stevens fronted the band Jeff Stevens and the Bullets, which had a couple minor chart entries. He later turned to songwriting, and made his production debut on Jerry Kilgore's Love Trip. He returned to production on Luke Bryan's 2007 debut "All My Friends Say", and has held his role as Bryan's producer ever since. His son Jody, formerly one-half of the duo Fast Ryde, produced (and played every instrument on) Cole Swindell's debut single "Chillin' It", and co-produced with his father on Bryan's 2015 album Kill the Lights.
Examples in the second category include:
- Ian Broudie. Starting out as a producer for the likes of Echo and the Bunnymen, The Icicle Works and Terry Hall before forming his own group The Lighting Seeds. Broudie admitted that he was very uncertain about beginning a career as a musician, and played all the instruments on the Lightning Seeds' first album - only after it was successful did he assemble a real band.
- Garbage. All of the members apart from singer Shirley Manson were experienced producers and remixers before forming the band.
- Timbaland: Was a producer for three years before releasing his first solo album.
- Alan Parsons: Probably the definitive example of this trope, Parsons had already engineered and produced for the likes of Pink Floyd, Cockney Rebel, Pilot and Al Stewart before starting his solo career (or, to be technical, joint solo career with manager/songwriter Eric Woolfson).
- Daniel Lanois was already a big name producer when he released the album Acadie in 1989. It was critically acclaimed and sold well enough to make the Billboard album charts. Since then he's released several more albums and also did some film soundtrack work alongside his production duties.
- Jon Astley (no relation to Rick). In the middle of his prolific production career (most notably with The Who and Eric Clapton) he released two albums in the late 1980s and scored a couple minor hits ("Jane's Getting Serious", "Put This Love To The Test".)
- Norman Smith engineered all The Beatles recording sessions through Rubber Soul, then produced three of Pink Floyd's first four albums. Then in the early 1970s he adopted the stage name Hurricane Smith and managed to have Top 10 hits in the UK and US.
- Kanye West started out producing for various acts in Chicago before breaking it big with Jay-Z in the early 2000s. He still continues to produce for other artists after his career took off.
A possibly unique example of both:
- Keith Stegall. He was a solo singer-songwriter in the 80s and had a few cuts by other artists, most notably Dr. Hook's "Sexy Eyes" and Mickey Gilley's "Lonely Nights". Although he scored a Top 10 hit on his own with "Pretty Lady" in 1985, his singing career was never very successful. His first production credit was two tracks on Randy Travis' 1986 album Old 8×10, and by 1990, he largely stopped recording in favor of production, having had his breakout as Alan Jackson's producer. In 1996, Stegall made a one-time return to the other side of the mic as a side project for Mercury Records Nashville (where he was also head of A&R) before returning mainly to production, although he still had the occasional songwriting gig and owned the short-lived label Bigger Picture Music Group.