Dork Age: Anime and Manga

  • Anime series in general tend to hit Dork Ages when the anime overtakes the manga and, as a result, goes into a filler arc.
  • Astro Boy might be a classic, but not even it is immune to dork ages. In the sixties, Tezuka had Astro Boy go through a Face-Heel Turn, and wrote a story where a construction error turned Astro Boy evil. Instead of being a champion of justice who never wanted to hurt a human being, the evil Astro didn't care a bit about human lives anymore. Tezuka didn't actually like the idea of Astro Boy turning evil, but his editor insisted that an Astro Boy who killed people and destroyed buildings would be more interesting. Though Tezuka was fully aware that violent anti-heroes were the latest trend in manga, he didn't feel that it was the way to go for Astro Boy. Still, the editor made Tezuka change Astro. Tezuka himself was convinced that the readers preferred Astro to be a good-hearted robot, and was proven right when the readers turned out to have zero interest in reading about an evil Astro Boy. Tezuka changed him back, but it took a lot of time and effort to get the series' popularity back.
  • Once Reiko Yoshida left the Tokyo Mew Mew project, Mia Ikumi tried to write a sequel incorporating the retcons made in the TV show and replacing Ichigo with a new character named Berii. Ichigo herself lost her powers except as a living accessory to the new heroine, her origins and family life were completely ignored in favor of sending her to Europe, and she became a washed-up hero. It's no surprise Tokyo Mew Mew a la mode has a high degree of Fanon Discontinuity amongst fans who also really dislike Berii. Berii herself has been Mis-blamed, though; the real blame lies in the publishers, who, among other things, restricted the series to just two volumes when commissioning the sequel.
  • For some portion of the fanbase, Magical Record Lyrical Nanoha FORCE has become this for the main continuity of the franchise. The series became Darker and Edgier, but the method of doing so was introducing an Anti-Magic virus into a magical setting. This led the new villains to become a Villain Sue gang that beat beloved favorites almost insultingly easily while being insufferable, hypocritical jerkasses, the heroes have to combat them with Flawed Prototype weapons that barely even work and the new main character is, unusually, a heterosexual male that has so far not done anything beneficial for the heroes. Even worse, it has undergone a massive Schedule Slip, releasing only 30 chapters in the four years of its publishing. Perhaps due to all of these reasons, it is currently on (a most likely permanent) hiatus.
  • A sizeable portion of the fanbase felt that Bleach went into a Dork Age with the Fullbringer Arc. The arc focused on new characters with totally new powers instead of the established characters and featured a plot that seemed almost completely unrelated to any part of the Myth Arc. To be fair, with Ichigo depowered and Aizen alive but imprisoned, there weren't many plot threads that could be carried over directly from the previous arc and at least nothing involved Aizen.
    • There are also fans who consider the four year long Arrancar Arc a Dork Age. In general, the writing became a lot more divisive after the Soul Society arc, and the series' sales and ratings dropped to the point where the anime was cancelled as soon as the Fullbringer Arc wrapped up.
  • Lupin III has Lupin III (Pink Jacket), which consists of the third anime series and the Legend Of The Gold Of Babylon film. Both the series and the movie had Lupin wearing a pink jacket, most of the adult themes downplayed and the slapstick brought Up to Eleven (as well as a bizarre design for Fujiko). Today, it is widely ignored by both the anime producers at TMS Entertainment and most fans in general in favour of Lupin III (Red Jacket) and the yearly specials it inspired.
  • Anime and Manga in general in The New Tens seems to have hit this for a lot of Western fans due to the increasingly diverging tastes of Japanese and Western fans.

    While Moe series have fans in the West, they also attract a loud and vocal Hatedom who see them as nothing more than Otaku bait. Of course, Moe is EXTREMELY popular among Japanese otaku, who buy most of the figures, DVDs, and such. As a result, series that focus on four high-school girls (popularized by the works of Kyo Ani, especially K-On!) took over the airwaves, while more unique series that would better appeal to Western tastes have become much rarer.
  • While still held in extremely high regard by the western anime/manga community for its incredibly masterful art and nuanced characterization, some fans feel that Berserk entered a bit of a Dork Age in comparison to the Golden Age arc, since Guts' new companions have joined (especially Isidro and Schierke), introducing things like elemental powers and more slapstick between Evarella and Puck, which have somewhat softened what is still an incredibly grim and violent story.
    • This is one of the rare series generally believed to have started with a Dork Age. Many fans aren't very fond of the first three volumes, which consist largely of Guts being not very sympathetic as he ruthlessly and amorally hunts down apostles in an attempt at reaching the Godhand. It's overall just not considered as strong as the rest of the series in terms of both character handling and art.
  • VS Knight Lamune & 40 Fresh, a sequel to VS Knight Lamune & 40 Fire, breaks the concept of the original series of light hearted and comedic Super Robot fantasy adventure genre into a dark military story with girls showing off her breasts. It didn't go well, considering every previous show before it was made for children.
  • Saint Seiya hit the dorkiest of all ages with Saint Seiya Omega. It's not Kurumada canon, it changed the super-suit from metal armor to spandex, it added a superhero school, the eponymous character is rarely in the spotlight(!), and so on. It seems that the writers eventually understood why it was so hated, and gave it a second season that thoroughly reverted all changes.
    • On the other hand, this has caused a broken base, with people that liked the first season of Omega (including some fans who didn't like the original SS) being unhappy that they reverted things, and declaring season 2 a Dork Age.
  • Among certain fans, the Pretty Cure franchise has been in one since the end of Heart Catch Pretty Cure (which admittedly was a Darker and Edgier Tough Act to Follow and is almost universally considered the franchise's highpoint).
  • Light Novels are stated by many to be in a Dork Age, with the popularity of OreImo. The growing amount of generic Visual Novel-inspired stories with the same trappings as the genre, as well as overly-long and uncreative titles that just describe the plot, has made people view the Light Novel genre as little more than a place where hentai artists can go to as an easy way to go pro.
    • The less said about the imoutoTranslation  genre, the better.
    • Ironically this trope may become inverted in America. A bunch of Japanese light novels were translated and released overseas in 2014 and 2015 - something no-one ever thought would happen. Time will tell if the Dork Age in Japan will be mirrored by a Golden Age in the US...
  • Many manga readers feel that the shoujo demographic is in one, as many new series are generic slice-of-life Kimi ni Todoke knockoffs. There's also the common accusation that most of them focus more on cliché romance scenes and less on trying to tell an actual story. It's no surprise that very few of them have gotten anime adaptions in recent years, with most of those being flops.
    • The shoujo magazine Nakayoshi is considered to be going through one, as most of their series in the last 5 or so years are either otaku-bait or a cheap attempt to be Hotter and Sexier.
  • Gundam AGE is simply condemned a mediocre and a mixed bag inconsistent attempt with a multi-generational plot. Some fans criticize it for looking too childish, others says it rips off everything the previous Gundams had, others notice that the series digs deeper and deeper into having needless deaths, violence and stupidities. The 2nd arc is considered better, but the 3rd arc pushes the series into rock bottom.
  • As The New Tens move on, Shonen itself seems to be in a Dork Age. Of The Big Three that dominated the Noughties, only One Piece has come out relatively unscathed.

    Naruto and Bleach, while still technically popular, have both suffered massive backlashes due to pacing issues and controversial plot developments, with even hardcore fans often having laundry lists of things about the series that they hate. Even beyond their own individual problems, these two series are sometimes seen as emblematic of common Shonen problems (such as a poorly balanced cast of characters, shocking plot twists that fans feel don't make sense, fights being won through Ass Pulls or brute strength instead of clever strategy, certain arcs or even the whole series going on for much longer than needed, and certain characters being so powerful that they completely wreck the plot).
    • Fairy Tail has a large fanbase, and its focus on wizards give it an identity comparable to other popular series.note  However, many longtime anime fans consider it average at best, and its anime was put on hiatus due to sluggish ratings and middling DVD sales. So far, it shows no sign of becoming as popular as its predecessors. Toriko was for a time considered to be the replacement for Bleach, and was given a massive marketing push. However, its sales do just barely better than Bleach, and its anime was cancelled after only three seasons. In fact, when Bleach and Toriko were cancelled, they weren't replaced by new series, but by instalments of some of Shonen's more enduring cash cows – Bleach was replaced with Rock Lee's Springtime of Youth, and Toriko was replaced by the Buu Saga of Dragon Ball Kai (itself only made due to Kai's popularity in the West).
    • One of the most common complaints across all Shonen series (even One Piece to some extent) is that they're cliché storms, with most series falling back on the same character archetypes and plot progression while doing little to innovate or improve on the flaws of their inspirations. With Naruto and Bleach officially in their final arcs as of 2014, it remains to be seen whether any new series will be able to properly replace them and reclaim the popularity they once held, or if Shonen will continue to be perceived as a stagnated genre populated by series long past their prime... and One Piece.
    • Not even One Piece has remained unscratched. After Marineford, which is the climax of thr first part of One Piece came Fishman Island and then Punk Hazard. Fishman Island was poorly received by fans, who cite the very slow pacing and weak villains as the reasons for disliking the season. Punk Hazard was better received, but not by much. Punk Hazard's problem, according to most, is that most of it was running.
  • Happened to Yu-Gi-Oh! once it hit filler. Arcs tended to give Kaiba's backstory or company more prominence, and each arc had its own kind of sin for the fans: the Virtual World interrupted Battle City, and was incredibly weird and nonsensical to many people. Waking the Dragons/Doma had irrational characterization for both Yami and Mai, and screwed with the history of the Shadow Games, and the KC Tournament arc was perceived as just a long breather episode that did little even to expand on Kaiba's character, who the Big Bad of that arc was targeting. And that isn't even mentioning the oddness that is Capsule Monsters.
  • From 1990 to 1998 anime got through a really big one in the Netherlands, most likely due to the amount of quality live-action that was there back then, which was so good that anime was not really needed there. Thus many perceived anime back then under the term "manga-movies" which was used to describe films and series that had only violence and sex in them. This negative image combined with limited export drove the anime underground there and the little fans of anime that there were during that time had to rely on imports from the United States. The reason that it stopped in 1998 is because that was the year that international bestsellers such as Spirited Away and Pokémon started appearing in that market and broke with the traditional held ideas, organizations were created to fight against the negative image of anime in the Netherlands, the very first Dutch anime conventions and the release of the first Dutch anime magazine: Ani Way. Averted in Belgium, where anime would not have any real lasting popularity until the airing of Bakugan Battle Brawlers in 2011 on VIER Kids.
  • The second season of the Black Butler anime is seen as this by nearly all of the fandom. The shotacon fanservice was cranked up to intolerably squicky levels, the new characters were poorly written and completely unlikable (and the returning ones were derailed or flanderized), and the plot was a near-complete mess that had nothing to do with the manga and had a Gainax Ending. It took years for another season to be made, and it unsurprisingly ignores everything that happened in this.

Previous

Index

Next