In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Timothy "Timmy" Tiberius Turner, God of Dangerous Wishing and Loser Protagonists (Twerp, Cleft the Boy Chin Wonder, Gah!) as a Demigod in the Halls of Protagonists (House of Characterization) and Plot Points (House of Narrative)
- Cosmo Julius Cosma and Wanda Venus Fairwinkle-Cosma, Co-Deities Of Matching Eye And Hair Colors (Clefto, Super Not-Cosmo, Cosmoron, Tiny Cosmo, Mr Fairyman (Cosmo), Wanda Woman, Nagules, Ace, Mrs Fairyman (Wanda)) as Intermediate Gods in the Hall of Personal Appearance: Other (House of Personal Appearance)
- Jorgen Von Strangle, God of 80s Action Star Parodies as a Greater God in the Hall of Real and Legendary Pastiches (House of Derivatives)
- Denzel Quincy Crocker, Unholy Granter of Impossibly Low Grades (Mr. Crocker, Dr. Crockpot, Dr. Crocktopus, Psycho Crocker) as a Demigod in the Hall of Subjects (House of School)
- Vicky, The Infernal Babysitter (Icky Vicky, Icky with a V, The meanest teen in the toon, The Baby Shredder, Vicky Whats-Her-Name) as a Demigoddess in the Hall of Social and Recreational Work (House of Jobs and Profession)
- Head Pixie, God of Corrupt Bureaucracy (H.P) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Tainted Law (House of Law and Justice)
- The Crimson Chin, God of In-Universe Fourth Wall Breaks (The Chin, Chuck, real name: Charles Hampton Indigo) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Metafiction (House of Narrative)
- Chippington "Chip" Skylark III, God of Perfectly Pearly Teeth as a Demigod in the Hall of Mouths (House of Personal Appearance)