You said we were chosen for a reason. That is not chosen! That’s killed! - Ava
Sam: We're looking for iron, silver, salt—any kind of weapon.
Jake: Salt is a weapon?
Sam: It's a brave new world.
Written by Sera Gamble.Directed by Robert Singer.Airdate: May 10, 2007.Sam is transported to Cold Oak, South Dakota, by the Yellow-Eyed Demon. Dean is desperate to find his brother.The Road So Far starts with Bobby Singer saying, "The storm’s coming, and you boys, – you are smack in the middle of it." The first beats of Boston's "Foreplay/Long Time" are heard as Mary Winchester burns on the ceiling, infant Sam cries in his crib, and John tries to shield himself from the flames in his son's nursery. The Yellow-Eyed Demon asks John, "You know the truth, right? About Sammy? And the other children?" We see Andy Gallagher and Ava Wilson. Andy says, "I didn't hurt anybody". Sam replies, "Yeah, not yet". Sam says to Max, "Max, your abilities, they started 7 months ago right?". When Max asks, "How'd you know that?", Sam replies, "The same thing killed our mothers". We see Max using his mental powers to point a kitchen knife at his stepmother. Mary Winchester sees a figure beside Sam's crib before burning on the ceiling. John reacts in horror before grabbing Sam out of the crib. Sam tells Max, "You and I were chosen." Max asks, "For what?" and Sam says, "I don't know." Sam has a premonition of a murder. Sam holds a gun to Gordon Walker's head. Jonah Greely tries to stab Dean. Sam is in an explosion. The Impala swerves on to a road racing to the hospital. Greely's ghost is blasted with rock salt. Ava shows Sam the article describing how Scott Carey was stabbed to death in a parking lot. Ava says "I saw this guy die days before it happened" as Scott is stabbed and Ava wakes up in bed next to her fiancé. Sam asks Andy, "You can make people do things, can't you? You can tell them what to think." We see Dr. Jennings shoot the man at the store. Andy says, "This is a cherry ride. Can I have it?" A smiling Dean says, "Sure, man". Dean watches Andy drive off in the Impala. Ansem Weber convinces Tracey to leap from a bridge in Sam's premonition. Sam tells Ava, "You must be one of us. One of the Psychics." Ava answers, "Screw you, buddy. Okay? Because I'm a secretary from Peoria and I'm not part of anything!" Gordon says, "This demon tells me there are soldiers to fight in this coming war. Psychics, fighting on hell's side." The Winchester home bursts into flame. We sees the wall of yellow eyes in Scott's closet as Scott says, "The yellow-eyed man. He tells me to do things, awful things." Ansem says, "He told me he's got big plans for me." Sam says, "Yeah, maybe this is his plan, maybe we're all supposed to be —". Dean interrupts, "What killers? Give me a break." We see the missing person poster for Ava, and Sam says, "No one's heard anything about Ava, she just . . . into thin air, you know?" Sam and Dean find Ava's fiancé with his throat cut. Her engagement ring is left behind, and there is sulfur on the window sill. Ellen says, "Now, something big and bad's coming and it's coming fast, and their side holds all the cards." As a bound Dean cowers to avoid the brunt of a large explosion Sam says, "We can't run from this, and you can't protect me." A frustrated Dean replies, "Damn it, Sam, this whole thing is spinning out of control."NOW, Dean and Sam pull up to Sunnyside Diner in Iowa inside the Impala at night in the rain. Dean gives Sam some cash and asks for extra onions and pie. An annoyed Sam goes into the diner while Dean waits in the car. Static interrupts Boston's "Long Time" playing on the car radio, and then the song cuts out. Dean notices the diner looks empty and follows Sam into the diner. Dean sees a balding gray haired man collapsed forward on the table with his trucker cap next to his half drunk cup of coffee, roast beef club sandwich with potato wedges on a plate, and condiments including a salt shaker. His face lies in a pool of blood which drips down the side of the table. As the country song "Wrapped Around Your Finger" by Martyn Laight plays in the diner, Dean calls out for Sam and takes out his Colt. He walks around the counter and finds the cook and the waitress lying dead on the floor with their throats cut while the grill still sizzles. Dean opens the back door of the diner and finds sulfur on the window sill. Dean then leaves the diner calling for his brother.Sam wakes up outside during the daytime. He finds himself surrounded by abandoned buildings including an old windmill. He pulls out his cell phone, but there is no reception.The Teaser ends with a metal chomping sound, and the Title Sequence plays in a burst of flames.Sam starts to explore the western town, which appears to have been abandoned in the later half of the 19th century. He hears a creaking noise and picks up a wooden plank as Andy Gallagher walks around the corner. Andy says he was doing a bong hit when he smelled sulfur and woke up in this ghost town. They hear a woman screaming and find a locked shed. Sam smashes the lock with a rock to release an upset Ava Wilson, who embraces Sam and asks him what is going on. They hear voices and find Jake Talley, a soldier who was fighting in Afghanistan, and Lily Baker, a woman from San Diego, who also have no idea how they got here. Sam explains that they all have special powers that developed in the last year and that he has visions. Ava admits she also has visions. Andy describes his ability to compel people to do what he wants and goes on to explain that he is now able to beam images into other people's minds. Lily says she would kill for powers like that and reveals that she kills people when she touches them. When Andy asks who brought them here, Sam replies it is less of a who and more of a what. When he explains it was a demon, the others look at him disbelievingly.Dean meets Bobby Singer on the side of US Route 65 in front of a motel and next to a river, and they stare at an interstate map spread out over the hood of the Impala. Bobby explains that their has been no demonic activity, even low level exorcisms, in the last month, and Dean realizes this means that they have no trail for tracking Sam. Dean's cell phone rings, and it is Ash calling from the Harvelle Roadhouse in Nebraska. Ash says it is a "big negatory" on locating Sam, but he found something really big. He is unwilling to discuss what he has found over the phone, but says it will not only help find Sam but is "huge". Bobby and Dean get into the Impala and head off to the Roadhouse.Sam is trying to explain the existence of demons to the others in the ghost town, but they do not believe him. Jake says he is better off alone and walks away. Jake sees a young blonde girl in the window of the schoolroom, but when Jake enters the room is empty. He hears a childish giggle and then the squeak of chalk on the chalkboard. The chalkboard is now filled with “I will not kill” written over and over again. When he turns around the little girl is there giggling, but her fingers extend into claws and her face becomes monstrous with clouded gray eyes and fangs. Before she can attack Jake, Sam enters, grabs a poker from beside the stove, and swings the poker at the monstrous little girl. She dissolves into black smoke as Lily, Ava, and Andy, arrive at the door of the schoolroom. Sam explains that this was an Acheri demon, a type of demon that disguises itself as a little girl. As they walk out of the schoolhouse, they notice a bell, and Sam recognizes the symbol of an oak tree on the side of the bell. He realizes they are in Cold Oak, South Dakota, a town so haunted, every single resident fled. Lily says they need to leave, but Sam and Jake point out that they are surrounded by miles of woods with no idea of how many demons are out there. Lily still does not want to work with the others and explains that she accidentally killed her girlfriend when she touched her. Sam explains that he has lost people as well, but they have to work together. Sam, Ava, Andy, and Jake, head off looking for things they can use to defend themselves, but Lily hangs back and then walks into the woods.Bobby and Dean pull up to the Roadhouse and find the bar has burnt to the ground. They search the debris and find Ash's badly burnt remains, which they identify by his unusual wristwatch. They do not find Ellen Harvelle among the dead bodies.Lily is walking through the woods alone, when something quickly brushes by the tree branches unseen. Then she hears a young girl's giggle. Meanwhile, Sam searches through a trunk in one of the abandoned houses and finds a Bowie knife. Sam notices that Ava is holding her head, and he asks her if she is okay. She says she is dizzy from not eating, and is fine except for their situation. Andy calls out that he has found something. He enters the house laughing with two bags of rock salt above his head. Sam notes Lily is not with Andy, and then they hear the childish giggle. They run outside, and when they look up, they see Lily hanging from the windmill, limp and pale with a noose around her neck. Ava tearfully insists that they have to leave, but Jake and Sam both agree that they need to stay and prepare for the next attack from the demon. Jake goes to cut Lily down, while the others walk back to the abandoned house. Sam and Andy pause on the porch as Sam says he wishes Dean was with them. Andy says he may be able to mentally contact Dean if Sam has something Dean has touched. Sam gives Andy a gas receipt.Among the ruins of the Roadhouse, Bobby and Dean remain overwhelmed by the destruction. With no idea of what Ash was going to tell them, they have no way to track Sam. Dean suddenly grabs his head and supports himself against the Impala. There is a white flash followed by the image of the bell engraved with the oak tree. Bobby asks Dean what happened and Dean says it was a headache. When Bobby asks Dean if it could be a vision, Dean replies that he is not a psychic. At this point Dean is overwhelmed by a second vision which brings him to his knees. He sees the bell again, and this time also sees Sam. Dean describes the vision to Bobby, who recognizes the bell and says,"I know where Sam is."As night falls, Sam is trying to break the spokes off of a steel tractor wheel with the fireplace poker. Jake grabs the spoke with his bare hand and easily pulls it of the wheel. Jake reveals that he started getting headaches while in Afghanistan, and then he found he could lift vehicles and bench press 800 pounds.Later, Ava and Sam covers the thresholds of the door and windows of a room with rock salt to create a safe room. Ava mentions that she wishes she was watching television with her fiancé, Brady. Sam looks around nervously, and then tells her that when the demon abducted her, Brady was killed. Sam hugs Ava as she sobs.Now it is completely dark outside, and Sam, Ava, Jake, and Andy, are all in the salt lined room lit by candles. Jake watches the door holding the steel tractor wheel spoke. Andy sleeps with his head on the table. Ava sits at the table, seeming to still be disturbed by her fiancé's death. Sam sits in the corner, struggling to stay awake. Sam sees the Yellow-Eyed Demon standing behind Jake, but when Jake does not react, Sam realizes he is dreaming. The Yellow-Eyed Demon asks him to go for a walk and as they walk through the ghost town the Yellow-Eyed Demon explains that only one of them is going to leave Cold Oak, and that instead of raising an army of psychics to fight in the Apocalypse, he is just looking for one leader among the psychics to lead his army of demons. The Yellow-Eyed Demon says he is rooting for Sam, and Sam replies that he killed everyone Sam has ever loved. The Yellow-Eyed Demon explains that Jessica had to die so that Sam would quit trying to be normal and go back to training as a hunter. When Sam asks why his mother had to die, the Yellow-Eyed Demon says that was "bad luck", and it really was about Sam. The Yellow-Eyed Demon then snaps his finger, and Sam and Dean are in Sam's nursery on the night of Sam's 6th month birthday. A figure is standing by baby Sam's crib, and adult Sam lunges at the figure, but the Yellow-Eyed Demon tells Sam to relax and that this is just a replay with which they can not interfere. Mary comes into the room and can not hear the adult Sam yelling to her. Mary assumes that the figure beside the crib is John and leaves. The figure uses his thumbnail to slice his wrist and starts to drip his blood into baby Sam's mouth. Mary returns, and the figure turns revealing glowing yellow eyes. Mary says, "It's you". The Yellow-Eyed Demon of the past uses telekinesis to slam Mary against the wall and raise her to the ceiling. The Yellow-Eyed Demon of the present then says, "I don’t think you wanna see the rest of this," and he snaps his fingers.Sam wakes up to Jake saying that Ava is missing. Sam and Jake rush outside, and Jake goes to search the barn and hotel while Sam goes to search the houses for Ava. They agree to meet back at the safe room in 10 minutes. Ava is seen sneaking back in the direction of the safe room. Andy stares outside the door of the room lined with salt. Ava appears behind him and draws her finger through the line of salt on one of the window sills. Andy turns around and is surprised to see Ava. Ava places her hands on her temples and concentrates. Black smoke pours through the broken line of salt on the windowsill and takes the monstrous child form of the Acheri demon. The demon attacks Andy, tearing open his stomach. Ava smiles down at Andy's body, and then screams. Sam hears the scream and runs back to the safe room. Ava says she just found Andy's body like this. But, Sam sees the broken line of salt on the windowsill and works out that Ava is using the Acheri demon to kill for her. When Ava realizes that Sam has figured this out, she wipes away the false tears on her cheeks and starts to gloat about how she has killed so many others, always arriving in groups of 3 or 4, and remains the champion. Once she stopped fighting it, her powers expanded and she began to have fun. She then puts her hands to her temples and says, "Yeah, I’m sorry, Sam. But, it’s over." The back smoke starts to pour through the broken line of salt on the windowsill, but before the Acheri demon can take form, Jake returns and snaps Ava's neck.The Impala pulls to the end of a road ending in forest, and Booby says, "Well, it looks like the rest of the way’s on foot." Both Booby and Dean take a flashlight and a sawed off shotgun from the trunk of the Impala, and start walking into the woods.Sam tells Jake that he thinks they can make it out of Cold Oak, now that Ava is no longer controlling the Acheri demon. Jake says he is sorry, but the Yellow-Eyed Demon spoke to him and he knows that only one of them will make it out. Sam says they can not listen to the Yellow-Eyed Demon and that Jake can trust him. Sam puts his knife on the ground. Jake puts his steel spoke on the ground, but as he stands up, he punches Sam across the field and through a fence. Jake goes to kick Sam in the side, but Sam manages to kick Jake and get up. They exchange blows, and Jake fractures Sam's right shoulder. Sam ducks one of Jake's blows, and Jake gets his fist stuck in a wooden trough. Sam is able to get the steel spoke and knocks Jake out. Sam lifts the spoke again preparing to strike the still Jake, but then drops the spoke. He hears Dean calling his name, and walks toward Dean and Bobby. Dean yells "Sam, look out!" as Jake stabs Sam through the back with the Bowie knife. Dean catches Sam as he collpses, and Bobby takes off after Jake. Dean tries to tell Sam it is not that bad, as Sam's eyes close and he slumps forward. A crying Dean continues to hold his little brother.
For this episode = At least 10 humans, including the death of Sam Winchester, which is the first death of either of the Winchester brothers in the series, but the third death of a Winchester family member. 4 of the humans who died were Special Children. At least 2 of the humans who died were hunters. The number of deaths may be higher because the total number of casualties at the Harvelle Roadhouse is unknown.For the series so far = At least 199 humans, 15 ghosts, 5 vampires, 2 shapeshifters, 2 werewolves, 1 demon, 1 djinn, 1 god, 1 rakshasa, 1 rawhead, 1 shtriga, 1 wendigo, and 1 zombie.
Barehanded Bar Bending: Sam tries to loosen one of the spokes from the steel tractor wheels by repeatedly banging on it with the fireplace poker from the schoolroom. Jake simply grabs the spoke with his bare hand and pulls it off the wheel.
Blood Magic: The Yellow-Eyed Demon's blood transformed the Special Children when he fed it to them as infants. It also appears that when a demon takes a vessel, the vessel's blood takes on the demon's magical properties, as the Yellow-Eyed Demon is shown cutting his vessel's wrist to feed baby Sam.
Borrowed Catchphrase: Sam usurps Dean's line when Sam says "You son of a bitch." to the Yellow-Eyed Demon,
Broken Masquerade: The Special Children learn about demons and the source of their powers.
Anndy: Give me a minute. I'm still working through "demons are real".
Bury Your Gays: Lily is the first of the Special Children to die in this episode. She also killed her girlfriend.
The lines the Yellow-Eyed Demon and Sam exchange about the whereabouts of Dean are almost the same as the ones Sam exchanged with the Shapeshifter in "Skin" (S01, E06).
Sam: Where’s my brother?
Yellow-Eyed Demon: Quit worrying about Dean. I'd worry more about yourself.
The scene of Mary seeing someone beside Sam's crib and thinking it is John, followed by her realizing it is not her husband and returning in fear is replicated from the pilot. But this time, we see that Mary recognized the Yellow-Eyed Demon when he turned around and she saw his eyes. We again see the silhouette of a man with his jacket collar turned up beside the crib. The yellow moon nightlight, crib, and baseball mobile seem to be the same in both episodes, but some of the other details are different. The dialogue is almost the same between the two episodes, except for Sam's unheard interruptions, Mary says "okay" instead of "all right", and the addition of Mary's "It's you!".
When Sam wakes up in Cold Oak, he gasps, sits up, and then looks around confused.
When Sam wakes up from the dream with the Yellow-Eyed Demon, his head snaps up and his eyes are wide.
Cat Scare: As Sam explores the abandoned town, he hears a creaking noise. Sam picks up a wooden plank and starts to swing as someone walks around the corner. Sam halts his swing as he realizes the person is Andy, who ducks, terrified.
Andy introduces himself to Ava as "Andy. Also freaking out."
Sam points out that they were all brought together by the Yellow-Eyed Demon and have special abilities, and, whether they like it or not, they are going to have to work together.
Sam: But I know one thing. I know what the three of us have in common.
Later Sam points out that Lily is not the only one who has lost someone and that they are "all in bad shape".
Consummate Liar: Ava brushes off a concerned Sam by pretending to be dizzy from not having eaten, and gets a smile from him when she jokes about their situation. However, she really had been holding her head because she summoned the Acheri demon to kill Lily.
Sam: Are you sure it’s not some kind of—
Ava: What? Some kind of freaky vision thing? No, more like I'd kill for a sandwich. I haven't eaten since...well, who knows? No, don't worry. I'm fine. Except for every single thing that's happening.
Cowboy: Ash is disturbed when a man wearing a cowboy hat with the brim covering his eyes and a jacket with a shearling collar walks by as Ash is talking to Dean on the phone. Later, we see this charred cowboy hat among the ruins of the Roadhouse.
Cower Power: When they find Lily's body, Ava covers her mouth as if she is going to be sick, and Andy hugs his arms around himself. They both have trouble looking at the body, while Jake and Sam are unflinching and seem to stand taller.
Creator Provincialism: When trying to search for Sam, Bobby and Dean look at an interstate map of the United States and bemoan the lack of any demonic activity. Evidently, they did not consider looking for demonic activity in other countries or consider that a demon from Hell may take Sam over national borders. Also, unless the Yellow-Eyed Demon is performing separate trials in other nations, it seems that all of the Special Children are Americans.
Dean:[to Ash] Oh, come on, man! You've gotta give us something. We're looking at a three-thousand-mile haystack here.
Creepy Child: The Acheri demon preying on the Special Children. It appears as a little girl, but when it's about to attack, its face changes, its teeth and nails grow long and sharp, and its eyes turn demonic. It never talks, but can be heard giggling in some scenes.
Crocodile Tears: Ava pretends to break down into hysterical sobbing to fool the others and keep them from knowing that she's the killer among them. After Sam wises up, Ava gets eerily calm, wipes away her fake tears, and starts talking about how she'd had him going for a 9while there.
Ava: Who we are, Sam. If you'd just quit your hand-wringing and open yourself up, you have no idea what you can do. The learning curve is so fast, it's crazy, the switches that just flip in your brain. [laughs] I can't believe I started out just having dreams. Do you know what I can do now?
Dead Guy on Display: After sneaking away from the rest of the group, Lily is found hanging dead from a windmill. Jake climbs up and gets her down off-screen.
Diner Brawl: Sam is kidnapped in the diner after the customer and staff are murdered.
Dirt Forcefield: Initially averted, when Sam stands up from lying on the ground and has dirt smudges and dried grass stuck to the back of his tan jacket. Later it is Played Straight, when Sam's jacket is perfectly clean (the dirt and grass stains having disappeared) throughout the rest of the episode. These stains are later replaced by a large blood stain when Jake stabs Sam in the back. This jacket has already recovered remarkably from the blood stains that covered it in "Devil's Trap" (S01, E22) and "In My Time Of Dying" (S02, E01).
Dramatic Thunder: Thunder rumbles overhead when Jake leaves the other Special Children and walks by the schoolroom. There is another rumble when they find the bell with an engraving of a tree on its side.
Dull Surprise: After Sam chases off the demon in the schoolhouse, the other Special Children stand quietly with their eyes wide and their mouths open. Jake adds some hyperventilation to his panicked expression.
Erudite Stoner: Both Ash and Andy have mellow, laid-back attitudes, but Ash uncovered information on the Yellow-Eyed Demon, and Andy developed his abilities enough to send telepathic images.
Everything's Better with Monkeys: When the scene of Ash calling from the Roadhouse opens, the camera scans over a chipped figurine of an Organ Grinder monkey, who has a creepy smile, sitting next to the salt and pepper shakers. The monkey is seen among the debris after the Roadhouse is consumed by fire.
Evil Mentor/Stealth Mentor: The Yellow-Eyed Demon has been manipulating the lives of the Special Children since they were infants to make them strong enough to serve his purpose.
Expy: Lily, with her black leather jacket, long hair, and brooding attitude, has many similarities with Rogue, which go beyond their power to kill with a touch. Although according to Sera Gamble, the character motivation is Allison Reynolds from The Breakfast Club.
Eye Colour Change: The Acheri demon's eyes change to a clouded gray when she reveals her demonic form.
Fainting Seer: When Dean gets the first vision, he grabs his head and leans against the car. When the second, stronger, vision occurs he holds his head and collapses to his knees.
False Innocence Trick: Ava pretends to have found herself in a padlocked shed 30 minutes ago with no more idea of what is going on then the others. She even makes a show of screaming and banging on the door of the shed to get the others to rescue her.
Jake: Now, I can get out of here. I get close to the demon, I can kill the bastard.
Five-Man Band: The five Special Children at Cold Oak fall into these roles rather neatly.
The Hero/The Leader: Sam. He's The Hero of the group, the most heroic as well as the only many-episode character in a muddle of one- and two-off characters. As the member of the group with the most experience and knowledge of the supernatural world by far, he also falls into the role of The Leader, trying to keep them everybody safe, informed, and relatively calm. His job is not easy.
The Lancer: Jake assumes this role, first by acting as the voice of dissent against Sam (when nobody believes Sam about demons) and then by becoming his unofficial Number Two.
The Smart Guy: Andy is actually the least combat-capable of the psychics and is by and large used for comedic relief. He's also pretty smart (as was previously implied in his other episode) and ends up being the one who figures out a way to contact Dean.
The Big Guy: Sam and Jake. Sam is the most combat-capable of the psychics against the Acheri, having been trained a hunter. Jake is a US soldier, making him almost on par with Sam in terms of fighting ability and vastly superior to all the rest of the psychics in terms of pure strength; while he isn't stupid, he is quieter than the others.
The Heart/The Chick: Sam and Ava. Sam works to keep them together and connects with each of them emotionally. Helping him is that he has preestablished relationships (or at least acquaintances) with two of the other psychics. Ava is perhaps most emotionally connected to him (which is why her betrayal came as such a shock) and is the most emotional in general of the group.
The Sixth Ranger: Unlike Andy and Ava, Sam didn't meet Jake and Lily in a previous episode and so they are complete strangers to him and the viewers.
When it comes to Ash's death, Dean reacts with anger born of loss saying "Oh, Ash, damn it!" when he finds Ash's wristwatch.
When Sam dies, Dean initially seems to be in denial telling him it is not that bad, and then dissolves in depressed tears.
Dean: Hey, look at me. It's not even that bad. It's not even that bad, all right? Sammy? Sam! Hey, listen to me. We're gonna patch you up, okay? You'll be good as new. Huh? I'm gonna take care of you. I'm gonna take you care of you. I've got you. That's my job, right? Watch out for my pain-in-the-ass little brother? Sam? Sam! Sam! Sammy!
Flyaway Shot: The camera rises above Sam and Dean as Dean holds Sam's body.
Sam: I think I know where we are now—Cold Oak, South Dakota. A town so haunted, every single resident fled.
Ava: Swell. Good to know we're somewhere so historical.
Forced to Watch: Subverted Trope. Before Mary bursts into flames the Yellow-Eyed Demon says, "I don’t think you wanna see the rest of this." He then snaps his fingers, and Sam wakes up.
For Want of a Nail: If you really think about it, Jake killing Sam caused the rest of Supernatural to happen.
Freeze-Frame Bonus: Postcards, business cards, and a guest check are stuck on the post next to the phone in the Roadhouse. These include a business card for Expresso Land, Broken Toys, who provides towing and scrap removal, and Angela James. There is also a postcard from Oakland and another postcard showing a painting by Sharon Quirke.
Giggling Villain: The Acheri demon never speaks but has an innocent child-like giggle.
Gondor Calls for Aid: The Winchester brothers seek out other allies when they find themselves separated. Dean first seeks out Bobby for help, and when this fails he calls Ash. Sam tries to convince the Special Children to work together.
Gory Discretion Shot: The blood splatter on the window and Andy's face as the Acheri demon attacks Andy.
Goth: Lily is dressed in a black jacket, boots, and dark make-up.
Gratuitous French: The cook at the diner lay dead with his arm resting on Kirkland Signature Towel Essuie-tout.
Greasy Spoon: The Sunnyside Diner, which offers "all-day breakfast, lunch, & dinner". The menu includes omelet, cereal, scone, muffin, burger, hot dog, regular and large fries, juice, ice cream cone, fresh lemonade, and a wide selection of pies.
Hair Trigger Explosive: Averted Trope. The gas pump and gas tank surrounded by barrels is untouched despite being only about 100 feet from the completely burnt-down Roadhouse.
Hates Being Touched: Lily. Justified, obviously. It's not so much that she would mind a little physical contact with somebody (since she was up for touching her girlfriend), it's just that she doesn't want to anybody else to die because they touched her. Lily tends to hang back from the others and keeps her arms crossed against her body with her sleeves pulled down over her hands.
Jake Talley's last name may be an allusion to the Talley family from the play Fifth of July, which deals with the difficulties Vietnam veterans faced on returning from war.
Jake has a unit patch which reads 27 IN crossed by a yellow lightning bolt. This may be a tribute to the 27th Infantry Regiment, the Wolfhounds, of the United States Army, who were featured in the film Three Stripes In The Sun. This regiment was repeatedly deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan in the recent wars, but has a distinct insignia featuring a wolfhound instead of a lightning bolt.
Hope Spot: Sam knocks out Jake, Dean and Bobby show up to save Sam...
Idiot Ball: While they were gathering supplies, it seems stupid that they would not have collected water from the well and stored it in the safe room. It also would have made sense to have some sort of accommodation in the safe room for those who need to relieve themselves.
Ava: Had you going, though, didn't I? [wiping away tears] Yeah. I've been here a long time. And not alone, either. People just keep showing up. Children, like us. Batches of three or four at a time.
Sam: You killed them? All of them?
Ava: I'm the undefeated heavyweight champ.
Kick Them While They Are Down: Played Straight when Jake quite literally kicks Sam in the side while he is lying on the ground. Subverted when Sam knocks Jake out—Sam raises his arm to strike Jake again, but then lowers his arm and throws the piece of iron away.
Kung-Foley: The cracks and whacks accompanying Sam and Jake's fight.
Left the Background Music On: Boston's "Long Time" plays as the Winchesters pull up to the diner. As Dean waits for Sam, static interrupts the music. Dean fiddles with the radio dial, but the song cuts out.
Let's Split Up, Gang: When Ava disappears, Jake goes to search the barn and hotel, Sam goes to search the houses, and Andy remains in the salt-lined room.
Mind over Matter: The Yellow-Eyed Demon slams Mary against the wall and then pulls her to the ceiling with telekinesis.
Mind Rape: Andy admits to beaming sexually-explicit images into another guy's brain at all hours of the day because he thought the guy was a dick. This is played for comedy as the images consist of gay porn.
Played Straight. When Sam disappears it is around dinner time and is dark outside in Iowa. When he wakes up in the neighboring state of South Dakota, it is daylight.
Subverted Trope. Ava acts as if she does not realize that five months have passed. She says that she just saw Sam two days ago, but is lying to deflect suspicion. She spent those five months training her abilities and learning to kill under the sway of the Yellow-Eyed Demon.
Sam: Ava, have you been here this whole time?
Ava: What whole time? I just woke up in there, like, a half an hour ago.
Sam: Well, you've been gone for five months. My brother and I have been looking for you everywhere.
Ava: Okay, that's impossible, because I saw you two days ago.
Mood Dissonance: We go from a smiling Andy holding the bags of salt over his head, where you think things might just work out, to finding Lily's body hanging from the windmill. Then we have a Hasselhoff joke.
Sam tries to get the others ready to fight the demon by pretending things will be all right if they work together, but he has his own doubts. Jake realizes this.
Jake: It doesn't matter if we believe it. Only matters that they do.
The Yellow-Eyed Demon says he didn't come out and say that he only intended to select one of the Special Children and the others would be killed because he "had to let everyone think they had a fighting chance".
Mr. Exposition: Sam explains the basics of demons and where they are to the other Special Children.
Never Split the Party: Sam tries hard to keep them all together, bless him, or at least make sure everybody has one person with them as back-up, but they're not used to running on horror-movie rules. Lily sneaks away and tries to escape through the woods, only to get killed. Then Ava vanishes...
Never Work with Children or Animals: According to Robert Singer, the director, getting blood into the baby's mouth was the most difficult special effect in the whole episode. The baby was evidently having a bad day and started crying even before they started trying to drip fake demon blood into the baby's mouth. Eric Kripke and Robert Singer discuss this on the DVD Commentary:
Eric Kripke: It's so funny. We have a job and it's like, "Okay, now we're going to drip all this fake blood in a baby's mouth..." Like, "Dammit it, the baby won't do it!" It's hilarious to me that that's an obstacle.
Robert Singer: And before you even get there you have to go through, "Well, it's a baby..What can we actually put in there? What sort of liquid is okay that looks like blood?" It's endless. Getting her up the wall was a lot easier than getting blood in the baby's mouth.
New Powers as the Plot Demands: This is a Justified Trope, as the Special Children develop their powers with training and use. Andy has developed the ability to project images into another person's mind. Ava has learned to control demons.
Not a Zombie: When Jake sees the blonde little girl all alone in the ghost town, he initially tries to help her, thinking she is lost and telling her not to be afraid. She lures him into the schoolroom and transforms into a demonic form with claws and fangs.
The Nth Doctor: We first see the Yellow-Eyed Demon in the vessel of the janitor from the hospital in "In My Time Of Dying" (S02, E01), played by Fredric Lehne. However, in the dream where they see what happened in Sam's nursery, the Yellow-Eyed Demon is in a different vessel who has a mole under his right eye and another mole on his left cheek.
Nuclear Candle: Most of the later scenes have only one light source. There is the kerosene lamp in the tractor barn, a group of three candles in the salt-lined room, and a very bright moon.
Offscreen Teleportation: Ava goes missing from the salt-lined room with three other people in it with no one noticing. Considering everyone was at least half asleep, that one could be excusable. However, we then see her sneaking from behind a building, and she just appears in the salt-lined room without Andy, who is standing in the doorway, noticing.
The Oner: When Jake enters the schoolroom, the camera pans across the empty chalkboard and then pans around the schoolroom in a circle until the chalkboard is seen again, but now the chalkboard is covered with the sentence "I will not kill" written over and over again. This is all one shot with no cuts.
Open Says Me: Sam picks up a rock and uses this to smash the padlock on the shed to release Ava.
Ash is wearing a Nixon Super Hero II SS Tide Watch. Who knew Ash was a surfer? Perhaps even stranger than Ash wearing a watch that has tide information programmed for your local beach in Nebraska, Ash seems to be wearing the watch in dual time mode, and, assuming he is using Central Standard Time for his primary time, his second time of 1:09 a.m. (17 hours ahead of his first time of 8:09 a.m.) puts him in the UTC +11 time zone, which includes Vladivostok, the Solomon Islands, and part of Southeast Australia during Daylight Savings Time.
Ava puts her hands to her temples after Sam finds the knife. Sam is concerned she is having a vision, but she says she is just hungry. Later, when she is alone with Andy and when Sam confronts her, she does the same thing.
Dean grabs the sides of his head, first with his right hand but then with both hands, when he gets the visions. They do come with a wicked headache, though, and Dean originally denies visions as a possibility.
Quieter Than Silence: After the radio cuts out, we hear the rain hitting the windshield of the Impala. A Scare Chord plays as Dean notices that he no longer sees the waitress through the window of the diner.
Quip to Black: The way scene one ends before the commercial break.
Sam:[holding an iron poker] Just so you know. That was a demon.
Ragnarok-Proofing: While there are a few missing roof shingles and a broken fence, most of Cold Oak seems intact, despite being abandoned for over 100 years. The glass panes are unbroken in the windows which are covered by lace curtains. The painted wood signs are perfectly legible.
Reaction Shot: When Jake says he went to sleep in Afghanistan, Ava raises her eyebrows. She does this again when Sam says it was a demon that brought them to the ghost town. Both Ava and Lily look disturbed when Andy describes beaming gay porn into another man's mind.
The Reveal: Sam has demon blood in him and Mary knew the Yellow-Eyed Demon.
Running Gag: Dean once again does not get the pie. There is a menu on the wall of the Sunnyside Diner listing Janice's pies which include banana cream, Boston cream, coconut cream, lemon meringue, and apple. A slice of pie costs $1.65 and you can get it à la Mode for 50 cents. Dean was too distressed to think about pie after Sam's disappearance. Previously in "Scarecrow" (S01, E11), the sheriff made Dean leave town before he had a piece of the apple pie he ordered.
Dean: Hey, see if they've got any pie. [Sam slams the car door] Bring me some pie! I love me some pie.
Sadist: Ava seems to take pleasure in watching Andy suffer and die.
Sawed-Off Shotgun: Bobby carries a sawed-off Remington Model 870. Dean carries a sawed-off Zabala 12-gauge side-by-side shotgun.
Scenery Gorn: The destroyed Roadhouse. We see the charred monkey figurine, destroyed shotguns, and burnt clothes in the debris. We also see at least three badly burnt bodies, including a close-up on one leg wearing an intact work boot and an arm with the skin peeling off.
Andy and Sam hear a scream and find Ava locked in a building. Later, Ava screams right after she has the Acheri demon kill Andy.
Mary screams as she is pulled up to the ceiling.
Screw This, I'm Outta Here!: Lily thinks "the only sane thing to do here is get the hell out of Dodge". When Sam reminds her that they are surrounded by miles of woods, she says it "beats hanging out with demons".
Shotguns Are Just Better: There are two charred Winchester Model 1873 shotguns among the ruins of the Roadhouse, attesting to its popularity among hunters. The two ruined Winchesters could also be foreshadowing.
Ava says, "If not for bad luck, we'd have no luck at all." This may be reference to Ray Charles's song "If It Wasn't For Bad Luck", but it could also be an allusion to the often covered song by Albert King, "Born Under a Bad Sign", as these lyrics are repeated in the chorus.
The Yellow-Eyed Demon says "Welcome to the Miss America pageant", comparing the competition among the Special Children to a Beauty Contest.
Show, Don't Tell: Initially when Dean has the vision, he was going to say, "I'm not a freakin' psychic." But they decided to change this line to "Come on, I'm not some psychic", as it seemed like Dean was being harsh on his brother. Instead, Dean's facial expression and voice tells the audience that Dean is not comfortable with the idea that he may be a freak.
Ava has one tear run down her right cheek after they find Lily's body.
The episode ends with Dean holding Sam while a single perfect tear runs down Dean's left cheek.
Slashed Throat: The waiter, cook, and customer at the diner all had their throats cut.
Sleeves Are for Wimps: Ash wears a sleeveless flannel shirt over a sleeveless T-shirt with a mug of beer on the front, revealing his tattoo on his right shoulder.
Special Effects Evolution: In later seasons, most of the solid-color eyes we see on demons are CGI, but actors portraying the Yellow-Eyed Demon wore colored contacts that made them nearly blind. Despite this, Fredric Lehne does a great job hitting his marks in the scene with Sam.
Spreading Disaster Map Graphic: Inverted Trope when Bobby shows Dean an interstate map of the United States with no notes or marks and says this represents all demonic signs and omens in the last month. Dean and Bobby realize that the absence of any demonic activity, including low-level activity like exorcisms, cannot be a good sign and leaves them with no way to track Sam.
Stealth Hi/Bye: The Acheri demon disappears when Jake sees her through the window of the schoolhouse.
Stoners Are Funny: Andy, who was doing his fourth bong load when abducted, provides comic relief.
Sam: It's a brave new world.
Andy: Well, hopefully there's food in your world, because I'm frickin' starving.
A Storm Is Coming: The rain when Sam and Dean arrive at Sunnyside Diner in the teaser. It has rained so much that the diner almost seems to be surrounded by a shallow moat.
Summon Magic: Ava Wilson learns how to summon and control the Acheri demon using her psychic abilities.
Superhuman Transfusion: The Yellow-Eyed Demon cuts open his wrist and drips his blood into infant Sam's mouth.
Super Smoke: The Acheri demon dissolves into black smoke when Sam swings the poker. When Ava breaks the line of salt, the black smoke pours through this break in the line on the windowsill and reforms into the monstrous form of the little girl. After Sam confronts Ava, the black smoke again starts to pour through the broken line of salt, but disappears when Jake snaps Ava's neck.
Super Strength: Jake's power is that he can lift vehicles and bench-press 800 pounds.
Sympathetic Magic: Andy says he needs something of Dean's or something Dean has touched in order to be able to send Dean a mental image note But considering Andy's disappointment when Sam said his brother wasn't with him and Andy's admission that he is quite well-versed in gay porn, it may be that he just wanted an item of Dean's.
Talking in Your Dreams: In Sam's dream, the Yellow-Eyed Demon has a conversation with him in which he tries to explain to Sam why he killed Jessica and Mary. It is implied that the Yellow-Eyed Demon also visited all or almost all of the Special Children in Cold Oak this way to encourage them to kill each other to survive.
Sam: Jake! Behind you! [Jake does not react]
Yellow-Eyed Demon:[stepping around Jake] Howdy, Sam.
Sam: I'm dreaming.
Yellow-Eyed Demon: What do you say you and I take a little walk?
There Can Only Be One: The Yellow-Eyed Demon wants his Special Children to kill each other until only one remains. The victor will go on to lead an army from Hell and presumably start the end of the world.
They Died Because of You: The Yellow-Eyed Demon confirms that he did not want to kill Mary, and that the only reason he killed her was because she interrupted him while he was feeding Sam his demon blood.
Sam: What about my mom?
Yellow-Eyed Demon: That was bad luck.
Sam: Bad luck?
Yellow-Eyed Demon: She walked in on us. Wrong place, wrong time.
Sam: What does that mean?
Yellow-Eyed Demon: It wasn't about her. It was about you. It's always been about you.
Took a Level in Badass: Ava, who in the five months she was missing, kills other psychics and develops the power to control demons. Andy, to a lesser extent.
Touch of Death: Lily's power causes people to have heart attacks if she touches them.
Trash the Set: The Roadhouse is completely destroyed. Part of the storefront remains, including part of the burnt-out neon sign showing only the letters "ROA", but behind this is only charred wood and other debris. The nearby phone booth, windmill, gas tank, and RV covered by a blue tarp did survive the fire.
Traveling at the Speed of Plot: In one day Dean and Bobby travel from Iowa to Nebraska, and then arrive in Cold Oak, South Dakota, just in time to watch Sam get stabbed in the back.
According to the DVD Commentary, Dudley Town, an abandoned settlement in Connecticut, was an inspiration for Cold Oak. Originally, there were references to Dudley Town in the script, which ended up being cut. According to local legend, Dudley Town was founded by a cursed family, who went insane, reporting seeing demons before killing themselves.
Vagueness Is Coming: Sam says he is not sure if he believes they are going to make it and says, "I mean, the size of what's coming–-it's bigger than anyone has ever seen. I mean, it's gonna get bad." But Sam doesn't really flesh this out further.
Yellow-Eyed Demon: That's why I'm here, Sam. I wanna give you the inside track. You're tough. You're smart. You're well-trained, thanks to your daddy. Sam—Sammy—you're my favorite.
Sam: You ruined my life. You killed everyone I love.
Yellow-Eyed Demon: The cost of doing business, I'm afraid.
Wakeup Makeup: Even though Mary just woke up and went to check on Sam, she is wearing eye shadow and lipstick. Her hair is also perfectly styled and curled.
Waking Up Elsewhere: Sam and the other Special Children wake up in Cold Oak with no explanation. Before waking up, Sam was in a diner in Iowa. Andy was in Guthrie, Oklahoma. Ava was in Peoria, Illinois. Lily was in San Diego, California. Jake was in Afghanistan.
Andy: I just woke up in freaking Frontierland!
Sam: What's the last thing you remember?
Andy: Honestly? My fourth bong load.
Wall of Weapons: Before Bobby and Dean set off on foot, they open the weapons locker in the Impala's trunk and take out ammo, flashlights, and sawed-off shotguns. Inside the locker we see a grenade launcher, flashlights, an ax, a tank of gasoline, a can of salt, and various types of ammunition shells. We also seen a sawed-off Ithaca 37.
Weirder Than Usual: Jake says that learning about his super powers while serving in Afghanistan was "just too crazy". Sam replies, "Crazy is relative." Jake, realizing they are in a ghost town preparing to fight a demon, says, "I'm starting to get that."
White Shirt of Death: The white button- up shirt of the waitress and the white apron and white T-shirt of the cook at the diner make a striking contrast with the pools of blood spreading from their throats.
The Wild West: Cold Oak has a saloon, dry goods store, white steepled church, single-room schoolhouse, and a windmill. Sam looks through the window of a cobbler's shop which promises "Expert Repairs" next to a picture of a boot. We also see a wagon wheel leaning against a porch, tipped-over bucket, and hitching posts.
Wipe: The scene of Lily alone in the forest transitions to Sam finding the knife in the trunk with a horizontal wipe.
Worst Aid: Dean does nothing to try to stabilize Sam. Given Jake's strength, it is possible that the knife went right through the spine and severed the thoracic aorta, where Sam would have likely bled out very quickly. But Jake seemed to angle the blade upward and Sam may be unconscious due to a puncture of the chest wall resulting in an open pneumothorax, where applying a plastic dressing sealed on three sides may help to keep air from continuing to enter the wound. It would have made sense for Dean to at least apply pressure to the wound and try CPR if Sam loses his pulse.