Jack: Is the... jar of dirt going to help?A character is handed (or idly picks up, or discovers in his possession) a seemingly useless item of junk. This can happen fairly early in the story — in The Hero's Journey, it's one of the first steps. The item in question later becomes important to resolving some major or minor obstacle moving the characters forward. Or the character thinks it will, anyway. Or the character, if handed it, cherishes it as a gift. (Or the character is a pack rat.) Items of this sort are a certain form of Chekhov's Gun. Especially common in Adventure Games from the '90s, from whence the name was derived. A Plot Tailored to the Party involving items instead of personality or skillset typically revolves around these. This is similar to when a character learns a seemingly useless skill or fact that will be needed later on, see: Someday This Will Come in Handy. If an item is elevated to Plot Coupon status, it is because You Will Know What to Do. Popular items include paperclips and the like, as well as jewelry, perhaps because of its nominal resale value. It could be magic beans, a piece of moldy cheese, etc. If an item is conspicuously clickable, compare Notice This. See also Orphan's Plot Trinket. If your entire starting kit consists of these items, you may be asked to defeat evil With This Herring. Common enough that subversions are notable when the item will in fact turn out to be useless junk. Or immediately useful. A savvy character may fob off an otherwise useless Clingy MacGuffin (or just get the hero to take out the trash) by uttering the words "Take this... it may help you on your quest." On the other end, it may lead them to grab everything they can so as to be ready for every conceivable challenge or obstacle. An unusual variant is when the giving character says, "You'll need this more than I do." — common amongst elders who have advanced beyond the need for an item. Compare Grail in the Garbage. Not to be confused with Vendor Trash, which is only valuable in large quantities. If the item turns out to have sentimental value, it is a Memento MacGuffin. When the character's whole objective is to obtain or deliver an item, it is a Plot Coupon. See also Plot Coupon That Does Something, Starter Equipment, Sword of Plot Advancement, Useful Book.
Tia Dalma: If you don't want it, give it back.
Jack: [tentatively] No...
Tia Dalma: Then it helps.
Tia Dalma: If you don't want it, give it back.
Jack: [tentatively] No...
Tia Dalma: Then it helps.
It's dangerous to go alone! Take these tropes!
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Definitely Inuyasha. The main character's battle-happy brother Sesshomaru receives a sword that resurrects people. He begrudgingly carries it around and eventually resurrects Rin as a test to see if the sword works. The sword has a catch: it can only resurrect a person once so it can't save the people Sesshoumaru actually wants to save. Rin and Kohaku have died once before so he can't save them and Kagura's death dissolves her body, so he can't save her either. It turns out that he needed Tenseiga and the lessons Tenseiga forced him to learn to be able to finally achieve his desire (a combat sword of his very own that could match his vast power, the idea being that only a compassionate heart should wield great power otherwise that power would be grossly misused).
- In the penultimate episode of Mazinkaiser Boss gives Kouji a resistance bar. Kouji uses it immediately to smack an Iron Mask Soldier. Then in final episode Mazinkaiser's control stick breaks and Kouji uses the bar to replace the broken part, letting him pilot Mazinkaiser again.
- The Orihalcon Statue in the first arc (both novels, anime, and manga), which holds a powerful, magic-enhancing stone fragment. Lina happened to stumble across it on a treasure hunt, but the priest Rezo seeks it to cure his blind eyes. The end result is the resurrection of Shabranigdo, a demonic being that was split into pieces, and Lina and company have to defeat him.
- Later on in the novels, there's the Blast Sword. Because he loses the Sword of Light for good in this version, Gourry needs a new one. He and Lina find a rusty old sword, and during the battle with Dynast Grausherra, it reveals itself as the Blast Sword, which is even more capable of fighting demonic beings than the Sword of Light.
- In Yu-Gi-Oh! Kaiba gives Yugi his copy of Fiend's Sanctuary before the Final Battle with Marik in Battle City, knowing it's an effective weapon against the Winged Dragon of Ra but leaves it up to him to figure out how to use it; fortunately, he does.
- An example occurs in the two-part episode of Yu-Gi-Oh! GX where Judai duels Asuka (who is Brainwashed and Crazy due to the Society of Light). Both Fubuki and Manjyome give him cards before the duel starts, thinking that they might help him get through to her. When he first uses them, however, neither works at all. However, he is later able to use both to bypass Asuka's lockdown strategy and summon a monster that lets him destroy the White Veil card (a vital factor in the cult's hold over her) so the two cards do end up being useful... Just not in the way they were originally intended.
- In Astérix in Britain, before setting out on the journey to Britain, Asterix takes some herbs from the Druid Getafix who says "Take some if you like." These herbs are eventually found out to be tea, which works as a Magic Feather for the British village they were out to save in their battle with the Romans.
- Not long after Final Crisis, it's revealed that Darkseid cloned Batman several times. When the clones went crazy, they were all killed, except for one, just in the off chance that Darkseid ever needed a spare Batman corpse. Which he later used to fool the world into thinking Batman was dead.
- In Star Wars: Legacy, Cade Skywalker is handed R2-D2. He is not impressed.
- The beans from Jack and the Beanstalk. He traded a cow for them, though.
- Found in a Norwegian folktale about a princess who always had to have the last word. Three brothers are off to try their hand at winning the princess; the youngest is mocked for carrying around every piece of junk he finds. Youngest brother manages to stun the princess into silence by using the junk as props ([brother holds out goat horn] "I've never seen the like!" [brother gets out other goat horn] "Here you see the like, Princess.") and they live happily ever after.
- In Mercer Mayer's version of East of the Sun and West of the Moon, the heroine meets a Plant Person of the forest, a Giant Fish of the ocean, and the North Wind, each of whom gives them a gift which she needs to use in order to defeat the Troll Princess: a bow and arrow from the king of the forest, a fish scale, and a tinderbox. In the last case, she needs to free her prince from a block of ice. The tinderbox burns the drapes, melting the ice, which douses the flames.
- Mario and Sonic: Heroes Unite!
- Before storming Bowser's Castle, Mario receives an Item Bag. His comeback was from the last item in said Item Bag.
- Sonic receives a Power Star just before going back to his world. That same Power Star is used to power the Star Fighter the heroes use as transportation.
- From the Pirates of the Caribbean example, a Stupid Statement Dance Mix:
Jack: I've got a jar of dirt!
- From Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality: Dumbledore with great ceremony gives Harry... his father's rock and tells him to keep it with him at all times. It's just a big rock which is not special at all. The fact that it actually does come in useful, and the circumstances where it does, are seen as so suspicious in-universe that it completely changes the state of political alliances by bringing the Malfoys in under Harry's personal banner.
Films — Animation
- Miss Spink and Miss Forcible know exactly what Coraline needs... a piece of rock with a hole in it. It helps. Well, they are good for bad things. Or is it lost things...? They were just savvy enough to recognize the utility of a Self-bored Stone.
- Galadriel's little phial (see literature below), moreso in the animated The Return of the King, where the phial just shows up in Sam's pocket — due to rights issues preventing them from telling anything set up in the first two books, which Ralph Bakshi had the rights to.
Sam: What's this? a vial. And what magic is in it to make it glow so? Handy, this thing...
Films — Live-Action
- Pirates of the Caribbean:
Tia Dalma: Land is where you are safe, Jack Sparrow. And so you will carry land wit' you.
- In Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest, Tia Dalma gives Jack a jar of dirt. This isn't surprising, since the Pirates films seem to be influenced by LucasArts' Adventure Game series Monkey Island, which plays this trope.note
Jack: ...this is a jar of dirt.
Tia Dalma: Yes...
Jack: Is the... jar of dirt going to help?
Tia Dalma: If you don't want it, give it back.
Jack: No!Tia Dalma: Then it helps.
Pintel: "Those are nine pieces of junk!"
- The Nine Pieces of Eight in At World's End. The Pirate Lords were, to a man, skint broke.
- Bootstrap's grungy knife as well. It seems an odd gift, but Bootstrap gives it to Will as if he knows he will need it and may never see him again. Will assumes he needs it to stab the heart. Ironic in hindsight.
- The everyday items in Paycheck. Rare film example of a plot setup involving the character collecting otherwise useless everyday items, justified in that the character knew exactly what was going to happen in the future and when. Although why such a security conscious company would allow him, with their knowledge, to take a key card with him is anybody's guess.
- In the short story it's based on, its revealed that the machine wasn't just a viewer, it allowed one to extend a mechanical grasping arm through time to obtain objects. The protagonist uses it to grab the final MacGuffin out of the villain's hand at the climax, then his future-self pulls it out of his pocket.
- In the Ewok Adventure TV movie, Mace is given a seemingly useless rock by Chief Chirpa. He discards it, but Wicket picks it up and gives it back to him, to Mace's dismay. Later when the group is trying to find the entrance to the Gorax's cave, Mace tries to use his blaster to make an opening, but it fails to destroy the rock. However, when he breaks open the little innocuous rock given to him by Chief Chirpa, a little arrowhead falls out and zips under a nearby boulder, which is revealed to be a secret entrance to the cave.
- Almost every James Bond movie has Q give 007 a stack of gadgets, which he would use once each in the course of the film. These would usually be unveiled in descending order of firepower and perceived uselessness, with the latter always proving to be the most essential, presumably because his captors wouldn't think to take it from him. Much more advanced and bizarre technology in Q's lab would be pooh-poohed as not ready for prime time.
- Done rather poorly in Troll 2, when Grandpa Seth hands Joshua a double-decker baloney sandwich, saying "take this, and only use it when you really need it". The last 5 minutes of the film may not be a good time to introduce a vital Chekhov's Gun.
- Another iffy example happens in Van Helsing, when the monk-inventor sidekick introduces the hero to a seemingly vulgar stone that can produce a sudden burst of solar-like light. The monk-inventor insists he doesn't know why it could be helpful, despite knowing that they are going to travel to Transylvania to fight vampires who are vulnerable to day light, then says he is going to take it anyway. Three guesses about what specific item they use to escape a palace filled with vampires at night later on.
- The Man Who Would Be King: In the glory days of the British Raj in India, ex-soldier Peachey Carnehan (Michael Caine) steals a pocket watch from a well-dressed white man (Christopher Plummer as Rudyard Kipling) at a train station. Peachey sees the watch fob is a Masonic emblem and, being a Mason himself, "has" to return the watch, hopefully without giving away his thievery. He does (or thinks so) and thus meets Kipling. Later Peachey and Daniel Dravot (Sean Connery), also an ex-soldier and Peachey's fellow "gentleman-of-fortune", meet with Kipling and tell him of a grand adventure they are about to embark on. Later still, as they leave for this adventure, in an impulsive gesture Kipling gives the watch fob to Dravot. It later saves their lives.
- That innocent little cookie that the Oracle offers to Neo in The Matrix might not have been so innocuous. If a piece of cake causes great excitement in a young woman in the Merovingian's club in ''The Matrix Reloaded'', then the Oracle can bake a little programming for Neo into her own batch. What are cookies known for in computer jargon, huh?
- Parodied in The Wrong Guy, where Nelson is given two tea bags and a sheet of wax paper and told that you can kill a man with them. When Nelson is attacked by the villain, he ineffectually waves the items around, as he has no idea how to use them.
- Most of the Fighting Fantasy and Lone Wolf books qualify. Lone Wolf and the Fighting Fantasy series Sorcery!, being multi-part series rather than one-offs, are the most worrying with this — certain items might not come in handy for three books. Fighting Fantasy at least usually has no rules on how much you can carry. Lone Wolf is not so lenient. To make things worse, Lone Wolf sometimes subverts this with items that look like they fit this trope but which serve no purpose at all, or even a few that are actively harmful. And because it's a gamebook with branching paths, sometimes you'll just miss the path where an item is supposed to be used, carrying it around for dozens of later books with no payoff.
- Quite frequent in GrailQuest, though the items are often rather bizarre. Especially notable in book 3, The Gateway of Doom, which adds a Critical Encumbrance Failure aspect, and has Merlin lampshades the trope in the text:
Pip: Why should I want a gold braid, a joke book or a xylophone?
Merlin: Why should you want a hammer or a saw?
Pip: Because they might come in handy.
Merlin: So might a gold braid, a joke book and a xylophone. Anything might come in handy in an adventure like this.
- In "Northern Lights" by Phillip Pullman the alethiometer (a divination device called the golden compass in the American edition of the book's title) is a very obvious instance of this trope. So are the titular Subtle Knife and Amber Spyglass of the other two books in the trilogy.
- In C.S. Lewis's "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe" the four main characters are each given a special object by none other than Father Christmas.
- Harry Potter
- The Time Turner in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban.
- In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, each child gets a pleasant but seemingly useless gift (a Snitch, his Put-Outer, and a book of fairy tales) from Dumbledore by his estate's executor with cryptic hints. Each proves critical to their quest. Justified because Dumbledore is dead and since the executor takes anything he deems "suspicious" he can't outright tell them. For a similar scenario on film, see Paycheck.
- Galadriel's gifts in The Lord of the Rings.
- Her gift to Sam? A Box of Dirt with a seed in it. Galadriel specifically says it won't help Sam on his quest, but when he gets home. Given his vision in the Mirror, she has a fair idea of how it will be used.
- Galadriel's little phial, too. The movie version implies that Galadriel knows it will be useful against Shelob, but the book, less so.
- The Hobbit: Bilbo finds the One Ring by complete accident.
He crawled along for a good way, till suddenly his hand met what felt like a tiny ring of cold metal lying on the floor of the tunnel. It was a turning point in his career, but he did not know it. He put the ring in his pocket almost without thinking: "Certainly it did not seem of any particular use at the moment."
- In Percy Jackson and the Olympians, the eponymous character is given a pen and told only to use it times of great need. It helps. Given that it's a pen that can turn into a sword... He then proceeds to whip it out at any possible time whatsoever, probably because he's a teenage boy who owns a pen that turns into a sword.
- In the book Key to Rondo, Mimi's pendant and her lemon candy prove to be what the bad guys want, and the decoy.
- As she leaves for a boat trip, Martine of Dolphin Song is given a plant by the old woman who's been teaching her about bush magic. Everyone teases her about it, until it proves to be the cure (the only cure on hand) for Man o' War stings. The best part is, the woman told her later that she just wanted it out of her garden.
- In The Phantom Tollbooth, Milo is given gifts by many of the people he meets, and they all come in handy when he is facing the demons who live in the Mountains of Ignorance.
- The Sirens of Titan features an interesting twist. The main character's son picks up a random piece of scrap metal during a factory tour on Mars. It becomes his lucky piece and he carries it with him everywhere for the rest of the book until they arrive on Titan itself. Turns out, this little piece of scrap is the replacement part the alien observer has been sitting around waiting for since before the dawn of humanity. It seems all of human history was guided (and perhaps even BEGUN) by his species remotely just to bring him this small piece of metal so he could continue his mission (which it turns out is just to say "Hi" to whoever lives on the far side of the universe). It's a bit of a downer realization, until one considers that with this delivery/quest complete, perhaps humanity will be free to pursue its own destiny.
- In Jim Butcher's Spider-Man novel The Darkest Hours, Spider-Man asked Doctor Strange for his assistance in dealing with the Ancients, three malevolent beings related to Morlun (from the J. Michael Straczynski run). Strange refused, stating that doing so would undo the cosmic balance. He did arrange for his manservant Wong to prepare Spider-Man a sack lunch... which contained, along with a ham sandwich, three small stones which could be used to transport someone to an uninhabited dimension. After Spider-Man defeated the Ancients, Strange asked Wong what had happened to the stones, pretending not to know anything about their use.
- Subverted most effectively in Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn trilogy - Vin's earring, her only memento of her mother which she has been wearing since the start of the first book, turns out to be the way the Big Bad has been influencing her all along.
- Subverted in Katherine MacLean's Missing Man, where a guru gives George (the protagonist) a quarter, saying "I can see into the future a little. In two weeks if you don't have a quarter you'll probably die," and "Tape it to your skin and forget you have it." In fact, the quarter does become (hypothetically) useful... except that George, as instructed, forgets that he has it, and so never uses it.
- In Whispering Nickel Idols, Garrett brings a bucket of kittens to Belinda's mob party, thinking he can get rid of a few by giving them away. (Morley lampshades how unlikely this is to work, but Garrett really doesn't want a bunch of cats in his house.) As it happens, the "kittens" are actually the Luck of A-Lat, whose presence soothes emotions and prevents a bloodbath at the gathering.
- The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Ford Prefect's penchant for towels. He insists to Arthur that they are useful in all kinds of situations.
- Common in live-action adventure games from the Dream Park series. Kevin's gift of a soot-covered rag in The Barsoom Project is a good example.
- In Night Watch, Anton is savvy enough to know that any amulet Geser gives him will most likely be useful in the near future. Even a low-level Other is able to view his own probability lines. An old and powerful Great Other like Geser can do it a lot better. Why would you need an enchanted SIM card in Uzbekistan? Well, to block GPS tracking on your phone, of course, in case someone decides to cause an avalanche at your location. Why would battle mages like Anton and Alisher need rings that protect against fire, ice, poison, and vacuum when they can just use the Mage's Shield spell? Because those will happen to be the spells that their enemy will use, and the battle mages will have The Load to protect.
- Emperor Mollusk versus The Sinister Brain by A. Lee Martinez. Mollusk keeps finding superfluous components in cybernetically-controlled organisms sent by the Brain to destroy him. The unusual thing is, all the components are based on his designs. The components eventually assemble into a device that plugs into a machine that shuts down the Brain and his cohorts, as part of a Batman Gambit arranged by Mollusk's future self, who's being held prisoner by the Brain.
- The toolkit Rainbow Dash gets from the rest of the Mane Six for her quest to obtain the Half-Gilded Horseshoe in Rainbow Dash and the Daring Do Double Dare.
- Sara combines this trope with Note to Self in the Relativity story "Sinkhole" when she arranges for a comic book and a newspaper headline to be delivered to herself several weeks in the future.
- Subverted in Why We Took the Car: A man gives Maik and Tschick a bottle filled with a strange liquid, saying it will save their lives one day. They throw it out of the car once they're out of sight.
- Estate of Panic: The most successful contestant in the second of three rooms usually received an item that might have helped them in the third. For example, in the first episode a contestant was given a screwdriver, but had to figure out where to use it (on the A/C vents) to earn the extra money.
- Game of Thrones: The iron coin Jaqen H'ghar gives to Arya. She uses it to barter passage across the narrow sea in "The Children."
- Parodied on Garth Marenghis Darkplace, when ghostly Scots invade Darkplace Hospital: "What's this?" "Something that might come in handy."
- Rather cruelly inverted in an episode of House, where they spend an entire episode looking for a cause for a young boy's ailment, only to discover that a piece of scrap metal used as a fob on his keychain was highly radioactive. Previously unrevealed to the audience, it had been randomly picked up by his father, a scrap dealer, and given to him as a Memento MacGuffin to remind him of his roots.
- Played fairly straight in Merlin, episode "The Eye of the Phoenix", when the Fisher King hands Merlin the waterglobe and says "When all seems lost, this will show you the way."
- Power Rangers Zeo: When Adam Park dreams about Mondo taking over, Rita and Zedd told him about a sorcerer that could vanquish Mondo's forces but needed items Adam needed to pick up along the way.
- Happens on Tracker when Mel finds both her grandmother's diary and the strange triangular object. She finds it a bit odd but dismisses it and nails it up as a decoration, and it's only later that the writing on it is ID'd as Vardian and they learn that it's the key to the underground vault, and that the diary's poetry was another key clue.
- In the first episode of MythQuest, Alex (as Theseus) is given a ball of string to help him navigate the labyrinth of the Minotaur.
- The Twilight Zone (1959): The episode "What You Need" has a peddler whose entire case is filled with items that seem useless at the time, but turn out to be exactly what the person will need in the near future. The peddler himself is benign, even charitable, but when a gambler tries to abuse this ability he gives him what he needs: A way to get rid of the gambler.
- At one point in The Beatles' "Revolution #9", a voice says "Take this, brother, may it serve you well."
- Subverted in Starbomb's Zelda rap:
Old Man: You'll need a magic weapon that will never, ever miss
It's dangerous to go alone, take this!
Link: Oh thanks Old Man, that's really, really nice
I can always count on you for some friendly advice
Though I've never seen a sword quite that shape or size...
Oh God, that's not a sword, it's your dick in disguise!
- From an episode of The Goon Show:
Grytpype-Thynne: Now, here's a screwdriver, a blindfold and a cucumber.
Neddie Seagoon: Cucumber?
Grytpype-Thynne: You've got to eat, haven't you?
[it's actually a bomb]
- Many adventure and RPG games condition pack-ratting behavior as an inventory management pressure, especially if there are inventory limitations and/or economic necessities. Not all games give clues whether the items are useful for problem-solving, or at least for uncovering Easter Eggs, or just Vendor Trash or completely dead weight. Recently the games have gotten easier by simply making the "Handy" things undroppable/unsaleable, rather than more intuitive in their problem-solving application.
- Standard policy for adventure games is that if it's not nailed down, take it, you'll need it. If it IS nailed down, find a way to remove the nails and take it. And take the nails too. Many, many early adventure games punished people for following this advice before realizing that it was a bad idea. For example, in Uninvited, picking up a certain seemingly important gem results in being demonically possessed about three turns later. Whoops.
- All the old LucasArts adventure games have this. If you can pick it up, no matter how random and useless it seems, you will at some point need it. Unless it's a Red Herring. And sometimes even then, as The Secret of Monkey Island has proven.
- An interesting case occurs in Escape from Monkey Island in the Swamp O' Time. Guybrush meets himself in the future, who gives the present-Guybrush several items and holds a conversation with him. Shortly after, present-Guybrush ends up on the other side of the encounter and must follow the exact same routine as before in order to avoid a Temporal Paradox and restart the area. One of the items is a pistol, which makes Guybrush excited to finally get one, only to have to give it away soon after. The items themselves are a part of an Ontological Time Loop, as they have never been created.
- Monkey Island plays with this one. At one point in the first game, you can pick up a staple remover, which Guybrush remarks will probably come in handy. Like almost everything else you find, it is seemingly useless, until:
- One may use it immediately against a yak with wax lips.
- Not to mention a Rhinoceros' toenails; probably the same Quarrelsome Rhinoceros you hypnotized earlier.
- The staple remover can also be combined with the flint to blow up the dam on Monkey Island. Since this puzzle can be solved with the spyglass and the sun, it makes at least one set of items (or resulting scenery) useless.
- "A rubber chicken with a pulley in the middle... what possible use could that have?"
- Not really useless in value, but the wedding ring in Tales of Monkey Island is given to you in Episode 2 and proceeds to uselessly sit in your inventory. It ends up being the solution to the final puzzle of Episode 5.
- "That thing your aunt gave you which you don't know what it is," from The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy the Text Adventure game. The thing in question is a Clingy MacGuffin which doubles as a Bag of Holding. You can't get rid of it permanently, no matter how hard you try, and you can store things in it as well. It's very useful, but these miraculous properties are never hinted at in the game itself — you have to discover them for yourself.
- Worse, the game can't be completed successfully if the player hasn't collected every single one of the small objects in the game, beginning with ransacking the room at the game's start. The game's final challenge is to present a random one of those objects, but the game will always choose an object that the player hasn't collected if there are any.
- In OneShot, there are a few of these. Specifically, the amulet Silver gives you, and the feather Calamus and Alula give you. They glow yellow because it turns out they have special yellow phosphor in them, very important later in the game.
- Every Infocom game includes at least one of these. The best is the piece of braided black string in Zork 2, which seems completely useless at first, but turns out to be the fuse necessary to make sure you can get away before the plastic explosive to blast open the locked box goes off, without which setting off the plastic explosive kills you automatically.
- The two Discworld games, where there really are totally useless things to collect, albeit not many, making them more Red Herrings.
- There are items like this all over the place in Alone in the Dark (1992), e.g. an Indian cover, a heavy statuette and others whose use isn't quite obvious at the beginning.
- In Brain Dead 13, both times while trying to get away from the witches, Lance picks up an eyeball hanging on a rack for no discernible reason whatsoever. At the end of the game, he gets the idea to tie the two eyeballs together like a bola in order to stop a boss, but that still doesn't answer the question of why he picked up the eyeballs in the first place.
- Every Sierra game has one of these. At least. Actually, it seems like an Adventure Game trope.
(later) "HEEEEEEY! DON'T FORGET YOUR FISH!"
- Every King's Quest game has at least one Wizard Gift. The guide even says "If it's not nailed down, take it. If it is nailed down, check for loose nails."
- The moldy cheese you need the fishhook to retrieve in King's Quest V: Absence Makes the Heart Go Yonder!. What sort of monster goes around collecting moldy cheese?
- King's Quest I: Quest For The Crown: pebbles, a carrot and that silly bowl you find in the middle of nowhere
- King's Quest II: Romancing The Throne: a wooden stake and a random piece of cloth
- King's Quest III: To Heir Is Human: oh so many potion ingredients; virtually everything you can pick up is required to brew a magic spell
- King's Quest IV: The Perils Of Rosella: a book of Shakespeare quotes and a peacock feather
- King's Quest V: a stick, an old boot, a pie, let's face it, over half of the inventory items here qualify due to Guide Dang It! puzzle design
- King's Quest VI: Heir Today, Gone Tomorrow: an empty bottle that turns out not to be empty, a shred of paper, and a rabbit foot
- King's Quest VII: The Princeless Bride: A rubber chicken, an ear of corn, and a hair comb (Valanice) An old sock, a severed foot, and a sweet-smelling flower. (Rosella)
- Space Quest 1: a plant, a rock and an undefined "gadget"
- Space Quest 2: a silly puzzle and, again, a rock
- Space Quest 3: the orat-on-a-stick, and a cereal decoder ring
- Space Quest 4: an energizer bunny
- Space Quest 5: a banana and a packet of space monkeys
- Space Quest 6: "Also, you look like you could use this fish."
Roger: I finally got rid of that fish!
- This happens repeatedly throughout that game. Guess it's a good thing that the fish kills the Final Boss.
- There's a piece of moldy cheese you had to pick up in the Blade Runner adventure game, too. You have to Pixel Hunt to get it. Semi-justified in that cheese was an illegal substance in the story. (Yes, they made a Blade Runner Adventure Game. It has 13 alternate endings.)
- The Legend of Zelda:
- The trend in the series, since at least the second game, is that you will always get what you need to complete the next dungeon either in that dungeon, or right before it. This can become egregious at some points, like the trope picture. How lucky is it that you found that item right before flipping over blocks and pots from a short distance away became a vitality important ability? It's sometimes justified by the dungeons being carefully laid out trials, but just as often it isn't brought up. Did whoever designed the fire-temple in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time know that the switches would become rusted over, and that's why they left a hammer capable of pressing them for you to find, or was it just a coincidence?
- "It's dangerous to go alone! Take this!" Sure is handy that some old geezer who is giving away the game's most essential item for free lives right where Link happened to begin his quest. Although the rest of The Legend of Zelda is much less conveniently arranged.
- At another point, you, again, get an item that immediately helps out in the trial afterwards. This time however, it seems to be that Link just decided to be smart after killing an enemy wielding a ball and chain and thinking "hey, this could probably break all that ice I can't get past". Doesn't explain why no other enemy in the game wields a ball and chain.
- Silent Hill
- When replaying Silent Hill, you find a device in the 7-11 lookalike that is of no use unless you're at certain locations (e.g. the rooftop of the oxidised Midwich Elementary) through which you get the Alien ending and a raygun for the next replay.
- During the main story, Harry comes across the elderly witch Dahlia Gillespie, who assumes The Mentor role and gives Harry two items: a rather sensible key to a locked drawbridge, and a more bewildering puzzle-box device, along with the cryptic explanation that "these will help you". It later turns out that she's deliberately being vague because she's setting Harry up as an Unwitting Pawn).
- Silent Hill 4: The Room subverts this trope with the "Shabby Doll", kindly offered to you by Walter Sullivan halfway through the game. Not only can you not use it, nor does it help you out in any way, but stashing it away in your inventory results in life-sucking, weeping baby heads sprouting from the walls. Players aware of this simply refuse the 'Shabby Doll', but those who aren't will accept it, because there is no reason to not take it.
- A very minor example occurs in Mass Effect if you choose all the paragon interactions with the Asari Consort. She gives you a seemingly worthless trinket that you can later use on another planet, to discover a recording made by the protheans of early humanity (with some Experience Points and Credits of course).
- In Asteka II: Templo del Sol (a.k.a. Tombs and Treasure), you get the lighter from the first room in the game, and it can't be used for anything until the last room in the game, where it's necessary to complete the game.
- Final Fantasy:
- Final Fantasy I: You're given a Lute by Princess Sarah after you defeat Garland. This item does absolutely nothing until the final dungeon, where you play it to break a seal and move on. Remakes show your lead character playing it. The song? The Prelude.
- In Final Fantasy IV, if you talk to Yang's wife at a certain point, she will give you a spoon. This turns out to be a thrown weapon, and the only weapon that does max damage against the final boss.
- Earlier in the game, you get the FRYING PAN OF LOVE, no mere spoon, which is also a ridiculously strong throwing weapon. You're supposed to use the frying pan on Yang, and she'll give you the Spoon, which is an even better throwing weapon (the spoon is in later versions replaced with a knife).
- At the start of Final Fantasy XII, the main character Vaan breaks into the Palace of Rabanastre to 'liberate' the treasure within from the imperials. However, thanks to well-times distractions, he only manages to steal a shiny rock. This turns out to be the Dusk Shard, which falls into enemy hands when Vaan is captured. In a subversion, it's the villain who nearly wins because of it — he attempts to use it to power a giant airship.
- In Final Fantasy VIII, if Squall talks to Cid just before leaving for his first SeeD mission, Cid presents him with an old lamp which he says is a cursed item but might come in handy. The lamp has the Guardian Force Diablos sealed inside it.
- In Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction, The Plumber hands Ratchet a 3 3/4 Centicubit Hexagonal Washer saying "you never know when you'll need it." This item is utterly worthless throughout the game. As it turns out, it's used at the end to repair the Dimensionator and prevent it from destroying the galaxy.
- In Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete, you have Alex's ocarina from the beginning. You won't really need it until the very end, when you have to save Luna from her self-imposed Heroic Sacrifice.
- Kingdom of Loathing
- The "Wand of Nagamar" in has no combat or utility value (though the combat messages could be entertaining). However it's required on the final Council Quest to provide an absurdly unlikely finale to The Naughty Sorceress.
- The game has a considerable (and sporadically growing) number of such items, varying in degree of apparent uselessness, and has slowly begun to add skills of this type (such as the Disco Bandit skill "Gothy Handwave", which is Exactly What It Says on the Tin — and unlike other dance skills, does exactly what it does in real life).
- Very few examples are actually handed to the player with the accompanying dialog, the rest of them Randomly Drops without drawing attention to their significance. The Amulet of Plot Significance which drops on the Penultimate Fantasy Airship is one subversion, but the Cid-like Captain Ersatz on the same ship gives you two items critical to completing that quest and The Very Definitely Final Dungeon.
- After the Level 10 quest revamp, the Amulet of Plot Significance does help you on your quest, as it can be used to unlock the second level of the Giant's Castle.
- Every game of Indiana Jones and His Desktop Adventures (an adventure game where the world and puzzles are randomly generated each time) should begin with Marcus giving you a briefing and giving you "something to get you going" — usually a priceless ancient artifact which inevitably turns out to be just the thing a NPC needs.
- In the first Mata Nui Online Game, after the Po-Koro event, as a reward for helping the town, you are given an item, the "Po-Koro chisel" which seems to have absolutely no use, surprising in a game where every single item serves at least some purpose in one way or another. Flash-forward to the ending cutscenes of the game where Takua is fleeing from the newly-awakened Bohrok, and he discovers a device with an indentation that bears a staggering resemblance to the chisel. If you can't guess what happens next, you haven't been paying much attention.
- Maniac Mansion:
- One game that averted this was the original, which, due to having multiple characters and multiple endings, has many items that were worthless if you have the wrong party. It also has items that are completely worthless no matter what, such as the chainsaw, which has no fuel.
- Interestingly, the sequel Day of the Tentacle goes back to the traditional tactic of not only having every single item be used at least once, but if the item is small enough to be passed through time, it will be needed in another time.
- The only item that's never used is the hubcap....and you can not pick it up.
- Played with a bit in Starcraft II 's first campaign, which has protagonists Jim Raynor and Tychus Findlay (along with their army) gathering seemingly benign Xel'naga artifacts for the Moebius Foundation early on in the plot. While the fanatic Tel'darim put up quite a fight for it, and the Hyperion's resident scientist Egan Stettman detects some weird readings from them, none of them suspected that the artifacts were actually the pieces of a Lost Superweapon
- Everything about Marle's pendant in Chrono Trigger. It starts out as a macguffin, but once you go to Zeal, it's very important.
- The Dynamix adventure game Rise of the Dragon has one character give you the following items all at once:
- A shiny rock, for luck. Useless.
- A tome of "Ancient Wisdom." Every page reads "Don't Worry, Be Happy"
- A fortune cookie with gibberish on it. Contains the solution to a game of Simon in the last part of the game.
- And, "in case all else fails, some body armor."
- In Spellcasting 101, there is a book that is so good you can't put it down. Literally. Once it's in your inventory, you can't drop it. In the penultimate puzzle, you give it to the Big Bad, and since he can't put the book down, he can't activate the MacGuffin, as the activation buttons are on opposite sides of it, requiring the use of two free hands.
- In The Orion Conspiracy, LaPaz will give Devlin keys to open the cupboard in Danny's room. Also, Ward will give you a rotten biscuit to spite you later on. In both cases, the items are immediately useful in some way.
- Green Moon is full of items which seem initially useless but turn out to be necessary for spells or potions.
- Parodied in Pokémon Black and White: the post game begins with Looker coming to your home to ask for help apprehending Team Plasma's 7 Sages. He then gives you a Super Rod (a fishing rod), and the player character's mother asks what help a fishing rod would be. After thinking for a minute he admits that it would be no help whatsoever.
- Also seems to show up in Pokémon Gold and Silver and the remakes. The player's mother saves some of the money they earn and randomly buys items. She'll always say "I'm sure you'll find it useful" or something like that when she calls to tell you.
- In Radiant Historia, the main character, Stocke, is given a seemingly useless book by his boss at the beginning of a mission.It ends up saving his life, and kickstarts the plot from there, by giving him the ability to travel to specific points in time.
- In Casper: A Haunting 3D Challenge you collect fool's gold coins throughout the game. They appear useless until the final boss, where ghost Carrigan chases you around a maze and you can drop coins to distract her.
- In the cancelled Warcraft Adventures: Lord of the Clans, Thrall has to chase vultures off of a wolf's corpse so he can grab the bladder and stash it in his pocket. Of course, you end up needing it later on, but one has to wonder what compelled him to pick up a (still full) bladder in the first place...
- Downplayed in Undertale. In the end of Ruins you recieve Butterscotch-cinnamon pie, which is already Too Awesome to Use since it always heals you fully. However, if you decide to keep it through the Neutral or Pacifist Run, it reduces Asgore's ATK and DEF, or causes both Asgore and Toriel remember you as Lost Souls.
- In Okage: Shadow King, main character Ari receives the music box his dad gave his mom when he was younger. It isn't used until Ari encounters Princess Marlene, where he gives it to her (regardless of what choice you pick), and wouldn't come into play until Ari disappears from the world, as the box is how Marlene is able to remember Ari due to his status being the only one not affected by Beiloune's Classification
- Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits has the mother of the main human character, Kharg, giving him an item called the Wind Stone, which was owned by his father which he split with his mother. It turns out the Wind Stone is one of the five Great Spirit Stones, and his twin brother, Darc, has the other half.
- Parodied in Icewind Dale II: Early in the game, you can pick up a dead cat item after completing a quest. Much later in the game, if you've held onto this useless item for all this time, you can get a dialogue option to offer it to another character. The character asks why on earth you would have a dead cat, to which you can guiltily admit that you thought it might solve some problem in the future and help you learn something from the experience.
- Parodied in the Dragon Tails RPG arc, in the same strip as But Thou Must!, nonetheless. Uncle Sparky, the dragons' slobbish uncle, offers the heroes some help.
Uncle Sparky: I shall give you a half empty pizza box and a bag of garbage to take to the curb. May they be of aid to you on your journey.
- Gunnerkrigg Court: Annie got a "beacon" from Eglamore way back in chapter 20 (November 2008). It was finally used in chapter 39 (August 2012), and it did indeed prove useful.
- The Order of the Stick:
- Celia gives Roy a magical talisman that, when broken, would summon her to save Roy if he was in danger. Subverted, as he dies because he cannot break it. Celia had no idea humans couldn't shoot lightning from their hands.
- Also, during an early adventure, Elan picked up a magic belt that can turn the wearer into the opposite gender. Some time later, Roy needed a way to sneak past the enemies without his weapon and Elan showed him the belt.
- The above example later leads to a subversion of this trope, when we learn that at the time Roy had in his possession two potions, Shillelagh Oil and Delay Poison, which were exactly what he would have needed to escape the situation without having to done the belt of gender change, but he didn't think of it.
- Problem Sleuth carries his precious cargo through the whole comic/game: four pieces of candy corn.
- Wicked Awesome Adventure:
- Stick Man Stick Man plays with this when Tina gets a screwdriver: see strips 862, 877, 886.
- The kids in MS Paint Adventures spend a lot of their time "alchemizing" various things. A few of them are useful, but most of the time, they just seem to be goofing around making things that are never referenced again.
- At the end of Episode 9 of The Mercury Men, Jack Yaeger gives Edward Borman his ray gun, implying he'll need it later.
- Tends to happen a lot in The Questport Chronicles. During Year Two, the heroes find a bunch of junk, including an old spell, while searching for a different Plot Coupon; the spell becomes vitally important to retrieving the next Plot Coupon.
- Subverted in an episode of Family Guy. After Quagmire has an affair with Cleveland's wife, Cleveland's swears revenge. Quagmire hires Mayor Adam West as a guard, but after failing to keep still, West decides to leave while giving Quagmire a banana and telling him "When the time comes, you'll know what to do." Later, when Cleveland is chasing him, Quagmire throws the banana... and it does nothing. The scene is set up to invoke the classic banana peel gag to viewers, but Quagmire forgot to ''peel'' the banana before throwing it.
- One episode of Darkwing Duck is made up of a long string of characters literally saying "This could come in handy some day." It's an aged Darkwing telling his supposed origin story, and everything from his gas gun to his martial arts skills is given to him with this note from the repeated giver. And damned if they don't all get used in sequence in the course of about a minute.
- As a parody or tribute to James Bond, Totally Spies! uses the exact same "three gadgets that each get used once" shtick.
- Freakazoid!: "The Wrath of Guitierrez" had the eponymous hero needing a MacGuffin to detach himself from a device on time to avoid deletion after an enemy sucked him into an Adventure Game. He needed certain items to help through his quest, and lampshades the usual pixel-hunting with things like a soup bowl he finds behind a suit of armor ("I found a bowl, good for me!"). He also lacks the usual invisible inventory, and towards the end of the game is carrying a huge armload of stuff.
- At the beginning of each episode of the James Bond Jr. animated series, the Gadgeteer Genius would give Bond three very use-specific items. Almost always he would use those three items in the same order they were given...
- In one episode of ReBoot, Season Three, AndrAIa and Matrix are training a small team of citizens from a rundown system to play Games and win. The game in question is modeled after typical RPG fantasy quest games, and the character who reboots as a wizard finds a feather on the path. He sticks it in his pouch. One other character sarcastically remarks "Great. If we meet the user, you can tickle him to deletion." Later, the feather proves instrumental in getting the team inside the castle, as it allowed the wizard to give himself wings.
- On Dungeons & Dragons, Presto's magic hat had a habit of never producing what Presto wanted, but instead producing something that was only useful with a bit of lateral thinking.