There is something unique about Undine as a magical girl
Not necessarily in a The Chosen One
sense, but little things stand out. For example, when the girls talked about their Dreams Undine seemed the only one to consider it a positive experience. She retains memory of the Girl in the Dream, even if only within the dream itself, something the Girl seemed surprised by. She's also the one actively targeted by the Purple One and who's had the Girl on the Dream step in to alleviate her nightmares.
Something about Undine is different from the average magical girl and it's put her at the center of everything going on in the story.
Anemone and the Woman in White
The Woman in White is some sort of Magical Girl goddess, who grants powers. She sacrificed herself to create magical girls against the monsters. Anemone was there when the magical girl system started, or somehow knew the Woman in White previously. She became a magical girl, and now observes the system that her friend(?) created.
The Woman in White is the Founder that some people worship.
Vedika describes a group of "Founder Worshippers" who believe the Founder speaks to Magical Girls in the Dream that gives them their powers. In the one dream we see, Undine indeed meets someone, the Woman in White, who remarks that it's rare to see the same girl twice and expects, even encourages Undine to forget about her when she wakes up. During the discussion of their Dreams, every
girl has a part they can not clearly remember.
- This is further supported by the very familiar-looking statue seen here, with the plaque reading "To our guardians."
He has advanced gear, stays at the fringes and is unfamiliar with the norms of the 'locals'. Perhaps they had to fend for themselves after the loss of all Magical Girls.
- unfortunately, the use of time travel has been jossed.
Alternatively, Mark is from outside of the dome.
This seems to be the most likely conclusion from what we see of his notes, not to mention the fact he says "Jesus", even though Christianity doesn't seem to be practiced or even remembered. This, in turn, indicates that civilization still exists outside of the City (perhaps surviving through technological means like his grenades, rather than relying on Magical Girls?), and that the local government may be keeping this fact from the populace for unknown reasons.
Goops McGee is one of Heartful Punch's friends
Undine, despite the torment, has never been called by Goops or encountered anywhere except while out doing magical girl things. Heartful Punch, however, gets a call to her personal room, meaning that Goops must know her phone number somehow. Additionally, Goops knowing personal information about HP like her last name and what happened to her mom, when HP is pretty unhappy with people even knowing or calling her by her first name. This would require a lot of research, or simply already being close to her, perhaps both.
- Also, one of her friends, Vedika, has speech bubbles that are the inverse colors of Goops'
- Vedika also has been confirmed to stay inside when the monsters are active. The interstitial between chapters 4 and 5 states that with enough time and effort, a monster or even a Magical Girl can break the weaker barrier between the houses and the streets. If she is lying about her powers, she could be planning to break the barriers and let monsters in. If her powers are non-combative and she's telling the truth, she still could have the ability to control/make monsters, and she could summon a monster strong enough to break the barrier.
- A challenger emerges! Gabby seems to think Cassidy can't be trusted, and it should be noted, she does have a purple headbow and the same bang style as Goops. Perhaps Goops can disguise herself. (Of course, this is presuming Gabby was talking about Cassidy, she didn't name names so it could be Vedika or Harley or Bud she was referring to.)
- It turns out in this pageCassidy in her magical girl form Flash Cut was spying on Undine and Kokoro while they were training. In the later pages, the hamburger monsters have orange eyes, which is Cassidy's signature color.
- Furthermore, Flash Cut's main power is the ability to split herself in two. Sound familiar?
- Should be noted: this is what the Wikitionary defines a flash cut as. Make of those definitions what you will.
- Of course, this all could be a giant Red Herring specifically to get us guessing.
The reason Undine was able to utilize the water jet cutter move, was because of the power she inherited from Tessa
One of the unknown women is the announcer.
The voice is specifically called a lady's in Chapter 1 - Page 6, so it's likely either Anemone, or a recording of the woman in white.
- The speakers the announcements come out of are shaped like anemone flowers, much like Anemone's name and parasol. It's probably Anemone.
- The text colors don't seem to match up, though.
Goops McGee is Mitsuki
Their hair looks similar and given that her mother died with ice similar to her color scheme it is possible that something like Goops is the result of the nightmare corruption on a former magical girl who lost her power.
- Why would Mitsuki hate Undine though?
Anemone was on the receiving end of a power transfer from The Woman In White, which inadvertently rendered her immortal one way or another.
Between Anemone's power apparently being some form of omnipotence or foresight (which, as far as non-combatant powers go, sounds incredibly convenient, perhaps even overpowered) her apparent mourning over the Woman in White, the implication that she's Older Than She Looks in the Crimmus Interstitial, and the fact that weve only ever seen the Woman in White in dreams and therefore dont know her actual appearance or full color scheme
Additional possible evidence:
- The Woman in White is shown, however briefly, to have had a physical form at some point, as evidenced by the fact that Anemone still has a painting of her hanging around.
- Such a reveal would loop right back around to Chapter 2, A.K.A the catalyst for the rest of the comic's plot, and effectively introduce Anemone as a major character/a possible foil to Undine.
- Power transfers are all but outright stated to be incredibly dangerous, and it's not unreasonable to assume that in the earliest and most unpredictable forms of magical girl powers, Ascended to a Higher Plane of Existence could be a possible side effect. "Rendering receiver immortal," however, is a bit more outlandish.
- Vedika also mentions a Founder figure that is the subject of worship for many people, which ties back into the theory of the Woman in White and the Founder being one in the same.
Undine is a reincarnation of, if not the Founder herself, then some aspect of her.
That's why she got a rare second dream, and remembered the Woman in White, and why Goops is targeting her.
Heartful Punch is one of the only magical girls who's never met The Woman in White.
Unlike other magical girls who seem to do so during their dreams, since the source of H.P's powers are different from other girls means that she's "cut off" so to speak from her. Further evidenced by her closed off behaviour when the others' are talking about the dreams they've had, Heartful Punch has never had one.
Rue being unregistered will be a plot point.
There's going to be some sort of situation - probably a life or death one - and Tessa will have to either watch another friend get injured or die or turn her in to the M.G.S.I., betraying Rue's trust.
- Something else to consider: Rue seems to be getting closer to Will than Tessa is (seems to be inadvertently since Rue asked why Tessa hasn't asked him out yet), so jealousy might be another motivator.
Goops McGee isn't a magical girl at all......but a monster.
TL;DR: Word of God confirms that the monsters are based off of various phobias. One of Sleepless Domain's major recurring themes is dreams, so following that thread, let's say the monsters actually manifest from the fears or nightmares of the city's residents. Taking Goops' strange and nightmarish nature into account, it's very much a possibility that she was never human to begin with, and is instead a fear herself - more specifically, the fear of magical girls, thus explaining her hatred for Undine and sapience uncharacteristic of monsters.
- Alternate idea: She's basically the hatred and fear of the Woman in White, purged from her and taken corporeal form.
Specifically, once where the story ends badly
and the town SD takes place in is the only human refuge left.
Rue's not actually a magical girl.
That's why she's not registered with the M.G.S.I. She's actually a normal civilian that's probably using the same bombs Mark had to fight monsters with. I mean, to be fair... her eyes don't really look green, and that hair just could be a stylistic choice like normal!Tessa having mauve hair in some lights.
- I have never been so glad to have gotten Jossed. Chapter 13 shows Rue's transformation sequence.
Goops was supposed to be Tessa's twin and died before she could be born.
A likely answer is that she was absorbed by Tessa in the womb (possibly before Tessa's mother even knew about the pregnancy), and didn't gain a corporeal form until Tessa's powers as Alchemical Aether awakened, which had the side effect of 'awakening' Goops's powers. (Personally, I feel that had she been born she would have been Alchemical Umbra, as one person
theorized.) She resents Tessa for living the life she should have lived, and attacked Team Alchemical to hurt her, and out of jealousy at the others. She continues to target Undine only because she senses Tessa's powers in her, and thinks that if she can absorb Tessa's powers, she can become 'real'.
This comic should
have been a showdown between Tessa and Goops, which brings me to the next WMG.
It should have been Tessa at the center of this. It's openly been stated that Tessa was the strongest of Team Alchemical. There's also the two comics where the Woman in White tries to visit her after she lost her powers, showing that she has some sort of interest in her. Therefore, I propose that Tessa was The Chosen One
. Undine only ended up being the center of the plot because Tessa's powers transferred to her
, leaving the Woman in White with no choice but to use Undine instead. (And yes, I am
suggesting that Undine was supposed to die with the others.)
And now for the contrarian theory: Tessa was never supposed to be a magical girl.
This is supposing that Undine indeed was The Chosen One
. The only reason Tessa, and indeed the rest of Team Alchemical, gained powers was because Undine unconsciously wished it so her friends could be with her. (Remember, canonically she was the first one to awaken.) Tessa was shown to be not too happy about Undine awakening. I suspect that while Undine was Resigned to the Call
, Tessa just wants to be special.
Which brings me to the next WMG.
Goops is the manifestation of Tessa's anger, resentment, and jealousy.
Sally was right: Tessa really does think she was better than the others. And when Tessa sat out that fateful night, her resentment and anger at being questioned as leader manifested itself...as Goops. Who proceeded to attack the other girls to 'teach them a lesson'. She continues to attack Undine because Tessa is jealous that Undine kept her powers while Tessa lost them, and now that she did so she is practically ignored by everyone except Rue.
Seems Tessa regrets giving up her powers and is starting to crack from how her life's turning out. Makes prime material for her to become a Dark Magical Girl
, right? And Goops could give her means to get new powers if she makes killing Undine a condition of it, which Tessa might do if she thinks it would get her
what she wants. And Goops has some
sort of interest in Tessa, she's briefly heard at the cemetery, and according to Anemone has been lurking outside her window.
- Seen from this perspective, it's possible that everything Goops has done up to this point has been done with the goal of hurting and isolating Tessa, to get her depressed enough to accept this deal. She starts by waiting for Tessa to leave the team before killing them - targeting all Tessa friends, but not Tessa herself. This is complicated by Undine surviving, so she doubles down on her efforts to kill Undine (and Kokoro once they start helping each other), so that Tessa will have nobody left. Tessa now seems to have shut out Undine anyway, which may be why several weeks have passed (seemingly) uneventfully for Undine and Kokoro - she's no longer helping Tessa get better, so there's no longer any need to target them. Rue, however, is still trying to help Tessa, which is why she was Goops' most recent target (as of 11/25/19). All with the goal of getting a powerful MG like Tessa on her side somehow, either as a Dark Magical Girl or some sort of physical host for Goops herself, to become a much more effective method of breaking through the barrier than the monsters could ever be.
- Alternate idea: the deal is to revive Team Alchemical, with Goops in Undine's place. It'd torture her to see her teammates again, possibly as zombies/monsters, and Tessa crazed, and Goops taunting her all the while.
At some point, Heartful Punch will be able to tap into her mother's abilities.
My guess, she'll be able to summon javelins (they're spears!) to pull off some sort of long range attack.
A character will be revealed to be a magical girl whose color is black
A character having colored speech text indicates to the reader that she is a magical girl, while plain black text indicates that a character is non-magical, so black text could also be a way to hide a magical girl whose color is
She came off as a Rich Bitch
thanks to being a money-grubbing snob, but then we learned that she had a good reason to be Only in It for the Money
: she was in charge of her family's finances and earned all the money for them after something happened to put her mother out of work (possibly illness or injury). It could be that the Skylarks used to have more money than they now do, hence the way she acted and the connections she had to snag a good manager and hire a camera crew.
The Woman in White, Anemone, and the Purple One were all once members of the same Magical Girl Team
Perhaps even the original
Magical Girl Team, which first defended the City whenever... whatever happened happened. The Woman in White sacrificed herself to power the barrier and/or empower more Magical Girls to carry on the fight. Anemone got stuck watching over the whole thing. The Purple One somehow got corrupted by the monsters, to the point that her former teammate doesn't even recognize her. Goops also had some kind of bad history with the team's Water user, explaining her obsession with Undine, who she either misidentifies or regards as the reincarnation of her enemy.
- Or maybe Goops was the original Water user, and her reaction to Undine is self-hatred. If she's able to manifest ice, that would explain how she knows how HP's mother died — because she's the one who killed her.
The prototypes shown in the first printed volume will be retconned into being preincarnations of Kokoro, Undine, the Golden One, and Goops.
I mean, it seems awfully
coincidental that the other two people in the prototype team had yellow and purple as their color schemes...perhaps they were the FIRST magical girl team, but something happened that caused the Purple One to feel betrayed and now seeks revenge against her former teammates, even to the point of reincarnation.
Undine is being kept alive by Tessa's magic
As in constantly. When Tessa revived Undine, she didn't stop being a magic girl. All her magic is just concentrated in keeping Undine alive or at least animated. Goops Mcgee even commented that she isn't interested in killing Undine anymore cause "she's already dead".
There is no Team Flash, or if there is Cassidy isn't actually a member.
Seems pretty odd we haven't even seen one of them once, and Cassidy is spending all her time in school around HP. If the above theory that Cassidy is Goops is true, this might be a cover story.
Cassidy is not Goops. Rather, Goops has an army of magical girl double agents. Why? Goops's powers is to make monsters based off of magical girls' powers.
Following the hamburger monster and Cassidy connection that I mentioned above. It is likely that Goops has a bunch of magical girls on her side to help her create monsters.
Those with grey/white color schemes have some tie to Anemone.
I just find it awfully
coincidental that both Bud and Zoe have grey and white as their color scheme and Flower Motifs
. Anemone has grey hair and a Flower Motif
as well (notice the bow in her hair.) There's gotta be some sort of connection.
Zoe and Bud are supposed to be a thematic duo
changed the records so no one catches that.
The fight between Undine and Cassidy will end when Vedika gets between them.
And it accidentally triggers a power of Vedika's...to share memories. Cassidy and Vedika will see through Undine's eyes exactly what happened in Chapter 2.
It's not exactly hard
to get a crush on HP after all, and when it comes to, at the least, HP's attraction to Undine, Everyone Can See It
. If Cassidy is interested in HP romantically, then she'd see Undine as a threat.
- Well Bud thinks that's what's going on.
Unless something happens to change Cassidy's mind about Undine, she'll probably leave the club when the rest of the girls take Undine's side. (It's also possible they'll kick her out
of the club.) A perfect target for Goops to sway her over to get her revenge (And if the above WMG is true, HP's love.) Hell, why CAN'T Goops make the Psycho Rangers
Friends arguing seems to be a trigger for Undine (and considering the circumstances that led to Team Alchemical's deaths, who can blame her?), so she'll snap and lose control of her powers while yelling for everyone to stop fighting. It's going to take a Cooldown Hug
from HP to calm her again. Unfortunately, Cassidy will just think she's been proven right.
Much like Undine, Tessa has also inherited all or part of her powers from someone else.
Magical girls have the same color for their eyes and their hair. The only exceptions so far are HP, whose eyes are solid blue due to her mother's powers, and Undine, who got pink pupils after Tessa saved her from dying. And back when she was a magical girl, Tessa's eyes also weren't a solid color, instead being pink with golden pupils - so she was probably at the receiving end of a power transfer as well. She probably blames herself for it as well, if we go by her words "Any one of you deserves to live more than I do" back in chapter 2.
Goops will go after Cassidy next.
Goops tends go after those with connections to what happened on that night, and Cassidy's trying to find out. Also on the title page for chapter 15, Cassidy is in the dark purple tea.
Cassidy's gonna go murderous and try to kill Undine that way.
There is nothing 'special' about Undine that makes Goops target her, it's just Goops' own pettiness
Goops is just trying to kill as many magical girls as she can.
The reason Goops is taunting Undine and Tessa
is simple: she survived Goops' attempt to kill her
, and now Goops wants to finish the job. Now that Rue and Zoe have survived a similar attempt, Goops may react the same way
- or, given the fallout of this failure
, Goops may have recognized that her petty 'revenge' is getting her nowhere and switch tactics.