Follow TV Tropes

Ask The Tropers

Go To

Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help. It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here.

Ask the Tropers:

Trope Related Question:

Make Private (For security bugs or stuff only for moderators)

3rd Apr, 2020 07:11:07 AM

If you change it back, it won't count as an Edit War just yet, since that would be the second edit in the chain and at least three conflicting edits are needed for a war.

But it is good to alert the other troper of what they did wrong, so they don't just do it again. Did you send them a message?

3rd Apr, 2020 07:47:40 AM

I don't really know how to PM and say "You did this wrong" without coming off rude.

3rd Apr, 2020 08:14:23 AM

So far there's no official Administrivia topic on localizations and the issue helper database is maxed out and can't have new notifiers added for ignored localization rules.

^ - I'd just raise the matter in the English Localization Cleanup thread to get consensus for a revert, revert with posting a link to the cleanup thread, and then message the troper with a link to the cleanup thread and tell them their edit has been reverted for breaking the mod ruling calling for English localizations (if they're available for a work).

Maybe at some point, the English localization rule should be added to Administrivia and the issue helper database can be expanded one day to include a custom issue helper for reverting work translations improperly (the helper system is maxed out at last check, so one would have to send a regular PM for the time being).

3rd Apr, 2020 08:59:38 AM

I brought "Aeris" / "Aerith" up once in the Localization thread. I was told that "Aeris" is correct when referring specifically to the original FFVII and to only use "Aerith" when referring to other material.

I guess she changed her name before FFVII, then changed it back after she died.

Obviously it should be "Aerith" since literally everything calls her "Aerith" now, but whatever.

3rd Apr, 2020 12:21:35 PM

Hypothetically, we could use the manual for the Steam release if we need a source for "Aerith" in FFVII proper.

(This would require us to treat the manual as part of the work, which is a bit iffy, but it's the best we have.)

4th Apr, 2020 03:12:07 PM

I reverted the edits and linked back to this discussion.

4th Apr, 2020 04:58:12 PM

Is this over the remake of the game? If so, which name does it use?

4th Apr, 2020 05:01:33 PM

^ Final Fantasy VII Remake uses Aerith; however, it is irrelevant to VII proper.

4th Apr, 2020 05:32:41 PM

Ah. Didn't realize they had separate pages

24th Jun, 2020 11:13:55 AM

They just changed it back to Aeris again. It's now an Edit War.

24th Jun, 2020 11:17:03 AM

At that point yeah its an edit war.

I know in most cases we use the localization name, but Aeris was admitted by the team to be a mistranslation so I think using Aerith is correct to use for it. I know I went through to clear some of those up on other pages but going forward I will defer to what is decided here first.

24th Jun, 2020 11:17:26 AM

... aren't they... right though? Based on this thread it sounds like on a page specifically about the Playstation 1 game (which this is) it's correct to use Aeris.

Still unabashedly edit-warring, but it sounds like he's actually correct.

Edited by Larkmarn
24th Jun, 2020 12:09:20 PM

Honestly, since at this point even the people who made the game have stated that Aeris is a mistranslation, I honestly think we should just only use Aerith, even when talking about the original game. It also makes it a lot more consistent with the rest of the site.

To be frank, I don't know why we give Aeris so much leeway. No one refers to Peach as Toadstool anymore. Nor do I see people calling Ganon Gannon, or calling Sailor Moon Serena.

24th Jun, 2020 12:38:45 PM

Peers at our Wiki page, which does indeed call Sailor Moon Serena

24th Jun, 2020 12:51:16 PM

I would like a link Ghilz.

24th Jun, 2020 12:54:14 PM

Sailor Moon Usagi Tsukino

Literally on the top banner. (I didn't say it exclusively calls her that, but we do list it as one of the character's names)

Edited by Ghilz
24th Jun, 2020 01:04:40 PM

Plus Sailor Moon uses them pretty much interchangeably, though with more uses of Usagi.

That said, it's pretty much apples to oranges between an intentional Dub Name Change and a translation error.

24th Jun, 2020 01:09:00 PM

I think the policy should be something to the effect of: "Localized names are used except in situations where Word of God clarifies otherwise". For example, the Dragon Ball dubs use Krillin consistently, but if one day they had started saying Krillen (just an example), and then later said it was a mistake or switched to Krillin, then Krillin should be the name we use.

Its been acknowledged by the devs that Aerith is the correct name and that Aeris was a mistranslation.

24th Jun, 2020 05:12:43 PM

So in the case of Word of God vs videogame content, wouldn't both be appropriate? So long as no one feels the need to swap one name variant for another, couldn't we just let the troper's decide which they want to use? For instance, I personally would post a ff7 trope about the character as Aries whereas I would use Aerith for any other work but I wouldn't change another troper's name choice to match my own. As such would posting a trope under the name Aries now have someone swap it for Aerith or would it be left alone (and thus to the troper's discretion)?

24th Jun, 2020 05:56:56 PM

^ Leaving it to tropers just leads to Fan Myopia of fans believing they know better than the creators. Even though Square-Enix rereleased the original Playstation version of Final Fantasy VII without updating the game much other than fixing a few bugs, they refer to that character as Aerith in all subsequent material of Final Fantasy VII and even the remake calls the character Aerith.

The English Localization thread on the forums had already decided to continue to use Aerith due to Aeris being a mistranslation and Square-Enix using Aerith for all subsequent new releases (despite not being updated for the rereleases of the Playstation Final Fantasy VII).

Fan opinions cannot trump what the creators officially use, but we can note Aerith's original name as trivia and we already do so. We don't need to plaster "Aeris" everywhere.

24th Jun, 2020 05:58:41 PM

Also (and keep in mind I have zero stake in this), we just want the wiki to be consistent. While things like American/Commonwealth spellings aren't a big deal, character names can be, and we want to be professional enough to not just let any name variation be used. It's confusing and we have standards.

24th Jun, 2020 06:02:26 PM

@neiberger: Also, that would result in a massive amount of edit warring, which is what we're in right now.

Edited by Arctimon
24th Jun, 2020 09:28:43 PM

Aha, I see—so for the sake of consistency it should utilize only one name and as such it would make sense that the true name is used (true being Word of God approved) for all content on the page. I guess it would make sense and it would definitely make things consistent. As for edit warring, I recently found out first hand how easily it is to be caught up in it (even/especially being ignorant of what that is) so for the sake of us still learning the ropes, I can say I now agree that "Aries" has had her day and should remain in the Trivia section. THE AYE'S HAVE IT~

25th Jun, 2020 09:42:05 PM

I would like to get a mod's opinion on this befote acting further.

29th Jun, 2020 04:48:48 PM

Given that all other pages go with "Aerith", the dedicated thread on the matter decided that was the right call, and the troper is edit warring I'd say that's grounds to get a mod to revert the edit. Is there a specific place to request a mod revert a page?

29th Jun, 2020 05:18:05 PM

Generally, this is the place to make such requests.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report