What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Quotes/MyImmortal

ReikoKazama
topic
02:28:16 AM Dec 21st 2010
Can I... put them back? Please?
94.6.91.77
topic
09:04:42 AM Apr 2nd 2010
edited by 94.6.91.77
(ignore)
90.217.54.50
topic
12:26:21 PM Mar 5th 2010
To borrow from earlier discussions, we don't need a "List Of Quotes From Other Series Describing A Character's Horrified Reaction But With A Noun Replaced By The Name 'Tara'". I found none of this particularly witty, not even for a cheap laugh. Wouldn't it make more sense to include quotes in or about the fucking work?
94.8.141.31
04:38:10 PM Mar 21st 2010
edited by 94.8.141.31
But for "posterity", here you go:

I'm sorry...I tried. My brain...

Death to My Immortal!

"You read this fic, you might want to die. You read this fic, you know you're going to suffer. Once you've read this fic, you might be wondering this. Where is he? Where is God? How could he let this... this thing happen? And the answer is: Tara has him bondage."

Loki-Chan
07:52:13 PM Mar 21st 2010
Thank you so very much second poster. I'm asking you, people, is it really necessary to have My Immortal listed on this site if we are not even able to laugh at it. That's the freaking point of having it here.
johnnye
05:57:50 PM Mar 26th 2010
^What he said. It's not like we need a serious educational resource on a crappy fanfic that was probably trollspawn in the first place, the whole article may as well be Just For Fun.
94.6.91.77
09:05:51 AM Apr 2nd 2010
edited by 94.6.91.77
You guys do realise, the second person deleted it in the first place.
94.6.91.77
09:11:52 AM Apr 2nd 2010
If anything, those stupidly painful quotes defiled all those works just as much as My Immortal defiled Harry Potter canon. It's dumb, but actual lines from the work can presumably show it far better than "We've entered an endless spiel of goffik" or "You DARE bring Goffs to my lair? YOU MUST DIE!!!" or "OH MY GOD, THIS IS THE WORST FANFIC I'VE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE!".

Also, TV Tropes educational? Really? None of the pages, apart from MAYBE the Useful Notes apply.
maxwellelvis
08:26:42 PM Apr 16th 2010
edited by maxwellelvis
If you actually thought we were going to destroy innocent reader's sanity by actually quoting that story, may I suggest you step away from your computer, go out, get some fresh air, see a movie, I don't care, just GET HELP!
94.2.212.203
06:52:14 PM May 1st 2010
The variants of others' quotes still sucks though.
cg12345
07:36:16 PM May 15th 2010
I don't care. I thought these were hysterical. Thank you for preserving them, even if you personally didn't like 'em.
AlirozTheConfused
09:22:19 AM Jun 8th 2010
It was one of my favorite pages on Tv Tropes. Besides, nothing we could come up with could possibly be worse than my immortal. Nothing at all.
ChristoTF2
05:24:49 AM Aug 7th 2010
And that's it, I'm afraid. There's no more from you on the Fanfic comments page, that's the last I've got. I don't know what stopped you talking but I can guess. They're coming. The Goffs are coming for you, but listen—your life could depend on this— blink. Just blink. Blink and you're sane. They are crap, crapper than you could believe. Turn your back,look away, and blink. [beat] Good luck.
74.168.26.130
08:55:22 PM Aug 7th 2010
Removing this from the quotes page is a crime against humanity - especially because apparently only one anonymous person removed it while there are multiple people here who think its funny.
205.244.126.49
07:27:12 AM Aug 31st 2010
Uh, I don't find them funny. How are they funny? They're just sentences from other things changed to make it look like they're talking about My Immortal or Tara.

My Immortal is not some monster out to take your life, burn your hopes and eat your soul. It is just fanfic. A god awful fanfic mind you, but still just a fanfic. It will not kill anyone to read some quotes from the story

We don't need a bunch of misquotes from other works to help support the fact that it's god awful.

I'm sorry that I can't find them funny. But I do wish we could at least not have so many of them.

24.231.250.203
05:59:54 PM Sep 11th 2010
The quotes are essentially beating a dead horse now. You can take a quote about X Horrible Thing, replace key words with "My Immortal", "fanfic", "Tara", etc. and that's okay on its own. However, when there are over fifty quotes doing the same thing, it loses the effect it would have had with just one, simple quote. (Plus, they lead to the misconception that My Immortal is soul-crushingly awful instead of a hilarious probable-trollfic.)
Raxis
08:20:05 PM Oct 4th 2010
The last one from Myst earns a Crowning Moment Of Awesome for whoever did it XD
RhymeBeat
05:53:22 PM Oct 5th 2010
I'm putting the MY Immortal version of Hellfire in. It actually does tell you something about the fic other than it's terrible.
Meshakhad
10:06:24 PM Oct 11th 2010
I personally find the quotes quite hilarious. I understand that some don't but that's not a reason to delete them. We have a selection of quotes from the fic to start it off, then we get into the silliness.
Prfnoff
03:46:05 PM Oct 17th 2010
It's not "silliness," it's just a lot of bile and hate. That's not what this wiki is for, so I took it out. Pages have been locked and wiped for much less.
ProgenyExMachina
05:40:40 PM Oct 17th 2010
edited by ProgenyExMachina
*saves the Portal song, but stays out of the argument*
Meshakhad
01:38:28 PM Nov 22nd 2010
Well, for posterity, here's what the earlier poster didn't include:

And tore me to pieces
And threw every piece into a fire
Her writing just was that bad

For the people who are still alive.

Maybe you’ll find some much better fanfic
Try reading Twilight
When I look out there it makes me sad I’m not you
I’ve a noose to be hung
On the people who are still alive

And believe me I am still alive
I read the whole thing but I’m still alive
When you read it I’ll be still alive
Still alive
Oh, hurry, or I may be dead!

back to Quotes/MyImmortal

This wiki is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
Privacy Policy