I'm actually in favor of option 3. I don't like softsplitting trope pages unless there's only two or three different ways to use something.
Analogy time: I think that the page smiling
should be a disambiguation/supertrope/index/thingy for the ways you can use the Body Language
of a smile to emote. The individual things
you can emote with a specific part of the body are the actual tropes, organizing by body part seems chairsy because it's pure organizational, rather than having any specific meaning.
Replace "smiling" with Finger Twiddling
and you have why I think we should Trope Transplant
this trope down one level. I think we may also want to look into building some subindexes of Body Language
built around the body part used, as that's the easiest way to sort (to me anyway). We should also build a similar one around what
the body language is telling us. I feel that both have options.
We may also need a larger supertrope for simply Hand Gestures
I believe Finger Drumming
and Steepled Finger Drumming
would work under such a trope as well.
edited 2nd Mar '12 1:18:19 PM by Deboss