Literature / Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
This trio of books is probably one of the most controversial series to hit American bookshelves. "Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark" is a trilogy of children's books written by Alvin Schwartz, made up of stories based on urban legends and local myths. These are the three volumes:
- Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark (1981)
- More Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark (1984)
- Scary Stories 3: More Tales to Chill Your Bones (1991)
The series is geared towards extremely young audiences (not that this stops the stories from being surprisingly violent), and while the stories may be scary for an eight-year old, older audiences will find them more cheesy than anything. Instead, what makes the books so scary (and controversial
) are the illustrations that accompany them. Using little more than black ink and water, Stephen Gammell has given us some of the most notoriously terrifying pictures you'll ever see in a book. So much so that the Scary Stories are on the American Library Association's list of most challenged books (ie, Moral Guardians
demanding they be pulled from library shelves), being the number one most challenged book for over a decade.
Likely because of this controversy, Harper-Collins released Scary Stories
and More Scary Stories
in new editions with considerably less unnerving artwork by Brett Helquist (best known for his work on A Series of Unfortunate Events
). There was a price spike (a high one!) when older editions were pulled from store shelves, but Scholastic Press, who released the books originally, still sells them with the original art. Hooray!
The stories were also collected and turned into a series of audiobooks with the same names. While they didn't contain any of the scary pictures from the books, the sometimes over-the-top telling of the stories could be a great replacement.
Soon to be a feature length movie
from CBS Films and the writers of the Saw
These books provide examples of:
- All of the Other Reindeer: The nursing school in "The Dead Man's Hand." Apparently at this school, being and nice and friendly and not having bad habits is a bad thing.
- Adoring the Pests: Subverted in "Sam's New Pet." After the family found out what it really was, it's unlikely they kept it.
- Alas, Poor Villain: Addie Finch in "Such Things Happen." Even though she tried to ruin the protagonist's life with her spells, she was still at heart a lonely and grieving old woman who dearly loved her cat. The amount of agony she's put through is so much even the farmer starts to feel sorry for her.
- And I Must Scream: "The Bride", in which the titular bride accidentally traps herself in a trunk and dies inside.
- And Then John Was a Zombie: The ending of "The Thing".
- Asshole Victim: Several examples, namely the husband in "Just Delicious".
- The woman in "A New Horse", who puts innocent farmhands through the painful experience of being transformed into a horse and ridden at high speeds around the countryside. While her comeuppance - being transformed into a horse, having horseshoes nailed into her hands and feet, and transforming back into a human, with the horseshoes still on - is quite painful and freaky, we don't feel too bad for her when it happens.
- Addie Fitch from "Such Things Happen." See Disproportionate Retribution below for details.
- Baleful Polymorph: "A New Horse", Throwing a magic bridle on someone transforms them into a horse. Fortunately for them, removing it changes them back.
- Be Careful What You Wish For: "What Do You Come For?". A lonesome old woman wishes for some company. She gets a living corpse that comes down the chimney and (most likely) kills her.
- Body Horror: "The Red Spot". An itchy spot turns out to have spiders pouring out of it. You're welcome.
- Bowdlerise: The new Brett Helquist illustrations are far tamer than Gammell's. This blog article compares some of them.
- Breaking and Bloodsucking: In "the Window", a girl sees a monster lurking out her window and she's too frightened to do anything. She unfortunately gives it the time to smash its way in, grab her, and bite into her throat. Her screams allow her brothers to save her and chase it off. The police pass it off as an escaped lunatic who thinks he's a vampire. Months later, the vampire comes clawing at her window again, but she screams at the sight of it and her brothers are able to track and kill it.
- The Cake Is a Lie: "The Drum"
- The Calls Are Coming from Inside the House: The Babysitter
- Cat Girl: "The Cat's Paw" has a truly macabre example.
- Cruel Twist Ending: "Bess".
- Cryptic Background Reference: The creepy woman from "The Dream" saying that the house with the carpet shaped like trapdoors and the windows nailed shut is an evil place. We never learn why, and it appears to be part of a larger story that the protagonist is not meant to be part of. She leaves before we learn anything more.
- Darker and Edgier: Scary Stories 3.
- Dark Is Not Evil: The strange woman in "The Dream" as well as (presumably) the creature from "Is Something Wrong?". Not that they're any less terrifying because of it, though.
- The Dead Can Dance: "Aaron Kelly's Bones".
- Death by Despair: "Cold as Clay".
- Dem Bones: Skeletons make many appearances: "The Thing", "Aaron Kelly's Bones", "The Bad News", "Is Something Wrong", "What Do You Come For", whatever the hell that thing is in the sky in the illustration for "Oh Susannah" etc.
- Disproportionate Retribution: "Such Things Happen". As a poster on YouTube put it, "Accidentally running over someone's cat is one thing. It's another thing entirely to kill a defenseless dog out of spite."
- Domestic Abuser: George Flint from "Just Delicious" is heavily implied to be abusive towards his wife, Mina. He's flat out stated to be "a bully."
- Doomed New Clothes: The White Satin Evening Gown, although much more extreme than the trope normally calls for.
- Downer Ending: Quite a few stories.
- Elevator Failure: The ending of "Room For One More."
- Face Full of Alien Wing-Wong: "The Red Spot". Well, it's really "Face Full Of Spider Wing Wong", but it still applies.
- Family-Unfriendly Violence: For a children's book, the stories delve into the gore field quite frequently, one key example being "Wonderful Sausage".
- Faux Affably Evil: Samuel Blunt of Wonderful Sausage is described as a "fat and jolly butcher". Said "fat and jolly butcher" kills people and grinds them into sausage to serve to his customers.
- From Nobody to Nightmare: "Harold". Boy howdy.
- Government Conspiracy: More like a local government conspiracy, but this is what happens in "Maybe You Will Remember..."
- Grotesque Gallery: Every picture in the series counts, but "The Haunted House" and "The Dream" especially.
- Hero with Bad Publicity: The ghost in "The Dream" may well be cringe-inducing to look at, but to be fair, she did save the girl in the story from some unknown gruesome fate, so...
- The truck driver in "High Beams" is a straight example.
- Hoist by His Own Petard: In "A New Horse" the witch's method of turning men into horses backfires gruesomely.
- Though never shown or stated, the ending to "Wonderful Sausage" heavily implies that vengeful townsfolk grind up Samuel Blunt after discovering the secret behind how the title objects were being made.
- I'm a Humanitarian: "Wonderful Sausage".
- Jump Scare: In the film version of "Clinkety Clink" it SEEMS like that story would end with the old woman's ghost being unable to find her two silver dollars. But then... fade to black... two second pause... "YOU'VE GOT IT!" (scream)
- It's invoked in the book version - it's meant to be read out loud, and requires the reader to do the same to the audience, complete with grabbing someone.
- Inverted in "The Attic". The reader has to scream as loud as they can at the end, and end the story there. At least someone in the audience will ask why they screamed - the reader then explains you'd scream at the top of your lungs, too, if you stepped on a nail.
- Lighter and Softer: The last story is always a lighter version of the first story. The second book's end portion had a comedic collection of the supernatural.
- Mama Bear: Addie Fitch must've really loved her cat. Of course, it may have been more than just a cat to her.
- Maybe Magic, Maybe Mundane: Part of the setting for "Such Things Happen."
- MegaNeko: In "Wait 'till Martin comes", there are three black cats, one normal sized, another cat the size of a wolf, and still another the size of a tiger. None of those cats are Martin, leading to the suspicion that "Martin" is the size of an elephant
- Mind Screw: "A Man Who Lived in Leeds". The film version does this as well, in a VERY messed up way.
- Mr. Gammell somehow manages to pull off a few in the illustrations. Stare at "The White Satin Evening Gown", "The Black Dog", "The Ghost in the Mirror" and "The Trouble", and especially "Oh Suzannah" for a good five minutes.
- "The Church", both in the book and the film version. Hands up, who expected sheep?
- Mood Whiplash: "Faster and Faster." It starts with two young boys having fun in the woods, and then the supernatural stuff rears its ugly head.
- The books themselves - all of the volumes have a collection of humorous stories near the end, ranging from terrible puns, black comedy, or hilarious subversions of the usual endings.
- Nightmare Face: Oh yeah. Made even worse by the Nightmare Fuel-rific illustrating style depicting them.
- No Ending: The story about the severed hand in the closet. See fuller discussion in the No Ending page.
- Nothing Is Scarier: What "The Voice" turns out to be, and "Footsteps" as well. "Sounds" might count, although it's subverted toward the end.
- "The Curse" might also count. We never do find out exactly what happened to the boys who went into the house.
- In "The Dream" we never find out the identity of the mysterious woman or why the place is supposedly evil.
- Parental Abandonment: "The Drum" gives us one of the worst possible examples of this at the end.
- Reptiles Are Abhorrent: "Alligators" (with the added twist that the titular 'gators are actually the protagonist's transformed husband and sons), and "Bess" (in which the protagonist is fatally bitten by a snake.)
- Rise of Zitboy: "The Red Spot" mostly consists of the protagonist complaining about the disgusting, itching, hurting and growing spider bite - which is basically a zit - on her cheek. However, it turns out to be much worse than just a zit...
- Rodents of Unusual Size: "Sam's New Pet". Apparently it was the size of a dog.
- Scary Scarecrows: The eponymous "Harold", also provides the page image.
- Shaggy Dog Story: In "The Baby Sitter", when the girl learns that the calls are coming from upstairs, she simply calls the police and leaves and the man is arrested. The end.
- Shown Their Work: Most definitely. Each book ends with a comprehensive collection of sources, references, times, dates and locations. Of course, there are plenty of mistakes in those lists. See the YMMV page for details.
- Swamps Are Evil: "The Dead Hand"
- Tempting Fate: In "The Bride," the eponymous bride cleverly whispers to herself "They'll never find me there." Turns out she was right.
- "Bess" starts with horse raiser John Nicholas going to a fortune teller who tells him that his favorite horse will be the reason behind his death. John is unconvinced and laughs the idea off. At the ending, said favorite horse has been put down and reduced to bone. John gets fatally bitten by a rattlesnake who had living inside the horse's skull.
- The Grim Reaper: Appears as a character in 'The Appointment.' Nobody really bats an eyelash at him unless he beckons to them, but he seems a pretty cool guy.
- Tomato in the Mirror: "Something Was Wrong"
- Unusually Uninteresting Sight: "Aaron Kelly's Bones". Features a widow's husband rising from the grave because he doesn't feel dead enough to die. In whatever universe this story takes place in, the rising dead are apparently nothing special, with the characters more annoyed than anything that this corpse insists on living. How that dead man danced...
- Also 'The Appointment', where the Grim Reaper just kind of... hangs around the town and people seem more annoyed by him than anything else.
- Voluntary Shapeshifting: "Alligators"
- Wendigo: Well, "The Wendigo", even though in the Sources section in the back, Alvin Scwartz makes it sound more like a Greek mythological Siren than an evil spirit of cannibalism. This is because the story is an altered version of Algernon Blackwood's 1910 short story "The Wendigo", which doesn't much resemble the original folklore either.
- Wild Child: "The Wolf Girl".
- The Wild Hunt: "Faster and Faster".
- You Can't Fight Fate: "Bess" and "The Appointment".
- This trope is somewhat in effect in "The Dream". After the eponymous nightmare, the girl in the story can't bring herself to visit the town she originally intended, so she visits an alternate village instead. Guess who she meets in this new town? That's right, that bloody pale woman.
- Youtube Poop: Is becoming an increasingly popular source; search for "Tom's Terrifying Tales From the Toaster".