"It was just a joke! We didn't know Mrs. McNulty was allergic to weasels!"Pulling Practical Jokes on others is all well and good in a comedy — it's part and parcel of the laugh department, and we love watching some pompous ass get taken down a peg or two in some clever and humorous fashion. But in a drama, mystery or horror movie, a practical joke, if it's not played with cruel and malicious intent by cruel and malicious people, has a very high chance of going horribly wrong and ending with somebody getting seriously hurt or even killed as a result of the prank, such as the old guy you meant to give a harmless scare turning out to have a heart condition, or someone cracking their skull after slipping on a Banana Peel, or any number of other horrible unforeseen consequences. If you're in a drama, you will most likely have to deal with the fallout, emotional and otherwise, of what you've done, with plenty of Anvilicious Can't Get Away with Nuthin' overtones. And god help you if this happens in a horror movie, as chances are excellent that your victim or one of their loved ones will come after your sorry hide for some very bloody vengeance, even if they have to rise up from the grave to do it. Some deadly pranks are meant to end in the other person getting hurt or killed, like the variety of the Prank Date that ends in the victim getting robbed, raped or killed, and such pranks signify that their perpetrators are utter scum who get their amusement from making other people suffer. Contrast Massive Multiplayer Scam. Also contrast Youth Is Wasted on the Dumb. For nonlethal instances, see Prank Injuries.
— Roy, The Order of the Stick
open/close all folders
- An advertisement for an Argentinean print production company (which went viral by removing the part where the company ad appears and saying that it happened for real in Russia, as explained by Snopes here) showcases a fictional Candid Camera-style prank with a person inside a mailbox (that pushes people's mail back out) which ends (Record Needle Scratch and all) when one of the people using the mailbox pulls out a gun and casually shoots the prankster.
Anime and Manga
- In Rosario + Vampire, Mizore pranks Kurumu into thinking Gin took her virginity. It becomes this trope when it's revealed that hurting a succubus's heart too much can be fatal.
- More than one case in Detective Conan can have its roots and motivations traced to one of these, with someone related to the people fatally pranked seeking punishment for those who came up with the whole bad joke. The most notorious is the Naniwa Murder Case: Five Osakanites get their very strict driving instructor drunk after graduating from their driving school. Instructor crashes his car and gets killed. Death is filed under accident and the five Osakanites get scott free. 20 years pass. Son of the dead instructor is a cop and chases a Serial Killer, who turns out to be one of the Osakanites. Serial Killer has a Villainous Breakdown as he finds out who is pursuing him and spills out the truth. Son of the dead instructor starts chasing and killing the other Osakanites left as revenge for their Deadly Prank.
- In episode 6 of Nobunagun, some researchers at a remote lab in Alaska haze a new recruit by telling him he's eating meat from a dead alien. He goes nuts and kills them all. Even worse, he thinks eating the meat caused him to become an alien himself and he tries to side with them against humanity, calling them his real family. An alien kills him right after he frees it from containment.
- Bobby in Hack/Slash is victimized by one of these when a couple of guys put him in a gas chamber and start to turn it on. Unfortunately, the gas actually deploys and they can't turn it off. He comes back as a slasher.
- This is how The Joker sees many of his murders: Simply as pranks. Part of the Jokers warped world view is that life itself is just a cruel joke, so he sees no difference between a classic pie in the face, or a poison pie full of acid. Occasionally, he'll pull a completely harmless joke just because the victim is clearly pissing himself in fear and expecting the worst.
- One standalone issue of ElfQuest features a couple of human boys who decide to play a prank on the "spirits" (elves). It all goes disastrously wrong, with two elves dying and one of the boys being executed by the human tribe's elders.
- In "Last Laugh!" in Tales from the Crypt #38, the main character dresses several pounds of bloody horse meat in boy's clothing, dumps it on the railroad tracks and then screams right after a train goes by as a "prank" on several local boys playing nearby. This results in a chain reaction which gets the town doctor's wife and two sons killed. Naturally, this being EC Comics, said doctor plays a rather improbable revenge "prank."
- Plop! #4 likewise has a story called "The Last Laugh!" in which a Traveling Salesman for a practical joke company comes across a beautiful Farmer's Daughter. Only problem is, she's a psychopath with a really sick sense of humor; after she and her family enjoy his pranks all day, he comes to see her that night, whereupon she cuts his head off with a hatchet as her own "prank".
- The Bridge: During Nightmare Night, a Changeling shape-shifts into Slendermane to jump out and scare anypony who passes by its lair. Unfortunately for it, the last pony it tries to scare is Destroyah, who simply blasts it. It survives, but loses its horn in the process.
- A near miss occurs in Mouse of Konoha when Anko tells a six year old Naruto to meet her at Training Grounds 44 (aka The Forest of Death) then heads to a bar instead because his bright jumpsuit distracted her and nearly made her run into a tree. When Naruto's various Chuunin friends/clients arrive, Naruto was in the middle of facing off against a bear. Despite everyone's attempts, Sarutobi finds out and slaps a massive fine on Anko while making her Naruto's tutor for the next several months. He notes that the only reason Anko is getting off so lightly is that Naruto was unhurt.
- Following the My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic episode "28 Pranks Later", many Fix Fics abound on the zombie pony prank becoming this as a result of Rainbow Dash overreacting.
- In Harry Potter, love potions are seen as an annoyance and a good way to have a laugh at somebody's expense. In King of Serpents: Game of Shadows, absolutely no one is amused when Artemis drinks a love potion-laced eggnogg and enters into cardiac shock because he's allergic to one component of the potion.
- Legends Of The Fourth Of July Coreline provides a rash of these as a background note: a toy and practical joke company created "Fakehuggers" (robotic duplicates of the Facehugger that were built and programmed to be completely indistinguishable from the real thing at first sight other than lacking the "chestbuster" embryo), who were used on pranks throughout the land... many of which ended with people scared straight into fatal heart attacks or Driven to Suicide (because they believed that they had a chestburster inside them and they felt it was the less painful option of dying). Unsurprisingly, the toy company was driven into bankruptcy with the barrage of lawsuits that followed.
- The '80s slasher film Terror Train, starring Jamie Lee Curtis (of course) and David Copperfield (what?), has this as the killer's motivation. A group of sadistic med-school frat boys lead a socially-awkward student where he is told a girl is waiting to have sex with him. Of course, once he pulls off the bed sheet, the "girl" turns out to a dismembered corpse. Naturally, he freaks out and ends up in a mental asylum. Of course, this almost gets them kicked out of school, but surprise-surprise, three years later during a graduation train ride, the frat boys (as well as a wrong place, wrong time David Copperfield) start getting knocked off...
- This is the origin of Troma's The Toxic Avenger. Geek Melvin is set on a Prank Date with the The Ditz / The Vamp. After some events that involve a ballet tutu and a sheep, he's laughed out of the gym locker room by what seems like the entire town, and takes a running jump out of the window and into a vat of radioactive waste. Yeah...
- Urban Legend's villain was set off by the death of her boyfriend, who was killed in a car accident, the result of the other characters scaring him by putting their flashers on and chasing him, in imitation of an urban legend.
- The high school film Jawbreaker features the main characters staging a kidnapping for their friend's birthday. Unfortunately, this goes horribly wrong when the intended victim chokes on the jawbreaker they were using to gag her.
- In The Orphanage, Tomas died as a result of this combined with his own refusal to be seen without his mask. However, the standard horror-movie revenge thing is enormously subverted, as yes, his mother did kill all the kids responsible, but no, the disappearance of the protagonist's kid has almost nothing to do with the entire business.
- A similar prank-deranges-and-deforms-victim premise drives the film Slaughter High.
- Provides the motivation for the killer in the early 80s slasher film The Burning. It tells the story of a cruel, alcoholic caretaker at a summer camp (nicknamed Cropsy, after the huge garden shears he carries) who falls victim to a prank that went out of control and leaves him horribly burned and disfigured. Following his release from hospital, he returns to his old stomping ground and begins a murder spree. Naturally.
- In The Butterfly Effect, Evan and his friend put a stick of dynamite in someone's mailbox to blow it up. A woman carrying a baby happens to come to check for mail at the worst possible moment, and they're both killed when it detonates.
- In the movie The House on Sorority Row sorority girls play a prank on their house mother, but it goes wrong and she ends up shot and killed. They hide her body in the pool. Later someone starts killing them. It turns out to be her mentally disabled son she kept in the attic who saw his mother get shot and wanted revenge.
- Sorority Row released in October 2009 is a remake of The House on Sorority Row but with a slightly different plot. The Sorority sisters have one of the sisters pretend to die in order to prank a boy. At an abandoned coal mine shaft they pretend they have to look for something to dismember the body. The boy thrusts an object through her body, killing her (he thought she was already dead). They hide the body in the coal mine shaft, but later they get messages on their cell phones from someone saying they know and threaten to report them to the police and then someone starts killing them.
- Penn & Teller Get Killed features Penn & Teller one-upping each other with pranks, to the point that when a murderous stalker fan starts trying to kill Penn, he believes that it's just another of Teller's tricks. It turns out that the fan is Penn's prank on Teller, but Teller gets so freaked out that he purchases a gun unbeknownst to Penn and accidentally shoots him just when he's revealing the prank. Teller and everyone else related to the prank kill themselves in grief, and then random people who stumble upon the scene begin shooting themselves in horror as the credits roll.
- The Catacombs features a young woman visiting her sister in Paris. The sister invites her to a secret underground rave in the Parisian Catacombs, where the sister's friends get the protagonist drunk on absinthe. Then, the sister is apparently murdered by a psychopath, and the police raid the rave, causing everyone to disperse before the protagonist can get help. The psycho continues to stalk the protagonist, who suffers some injuries, but eventually manages to dispatch the killer with a pickax. She then runs into her sister and the friends. It was all a joke... they just pumped her full of alcohol and put her through Hell for a lark. Then they realize the protagonist (in a failing mental state) killed the "psycho". They start yelling at her... and she's still holding the pickax...
- Mean Creek's entire plot focuses around this trope. A shy boy named Sam is getting bullied by a bigger kid at school named George. In retaliation, Sam, his older brother and his two friends and Sam's girlfriend invite George on a canoe ride up a creek, where they intend to steal his pants, push him into the water and make him walk home. They are surprised that the bully actually tries to fit in and be friendly to them, revealing he doesn't have many friends. George's crude behavior though, and his vulgar and violent reaction when he finds out what they intended to do to him, leads to a confrontation where George is knocked into the stream, hits his head on a rock and drowns.
- In Zombieland, Bill Murray in Zombie makeup decides to play a prank on Columbus and Little Rock by dressing up as a zombie and trying to scare them. This leads to a very surprised Columbus delivering a blast of buckshot through his chest. Not the smartest prank to pull in a world infested by zombies, but the character involved was high on pot at the time.
- There's also kind of a potentially Deadly Scam, if you will, when Columbus and Tallahassee are told that Little Rock is infected and that they have to shoot her. Not the best scam to pull on complete strangers who have obviously seen a lot of action and are probably willing to pull the trigger.
- Trick 'r Treat plays with this. A group of kids play a prank on the "idiot savant" kid, when they dress as zombies and scare her. She, terrified, falls into a ravine and cracks her head on a big rock. After one of the pranksters, horrified, asks "Is she dead?" she turns out not to be; just badly hurt and still panicking. Then the actual zombies show up and eat the pranksters, the savant pointedly doing nothing to save them.
- The Graveyard uses this trope. Lesson being? Don't play pranks in graveyards.
- A Deadly Prank is ultimately the cause of Katie Marcum's murder in Mystic River.
- Inverted in Doctor X, in which an Explosive Cigar saves the protagonist's life by scaring off his would-be attacker.
- The main drive behind When Good Ghouls Go Bad.
- Not quite deadly, but the prank in the prologue of Black Sheep (2007) combined the the subsequent news of his father's death causes Henry to develop extreme ovinophobia.
- Heathers. J.D. and Veronica try to prank Heather Chandler by breaking into her house and concocting a drink made up of orange juice and milk and convincing her to drink it. J.D. pours a glass of drain cleaner as well, and Veronica accidentally switches it. J.D. notices, but decides not to tell her, and Heather Chandler promptly dies when she ingests it. Veronica and J.D. are shocked, and make it look like a suicide. Subverted in the sense that J.D. later reveals that he completely intended this outcome, and tries to kill more teenagers by claiming to Veronica that they're "pranks".
- Forget Me Not: The main character and her friends pulled one resulting in a ghost on a Roaring Rampage of Revenge.
- No humans actually die, but in Animal House, a prank goes too far when the Deltas bring Neidermeyer's horse into his office and tell their new members to shoot it; the gun is only loaded with blanks, but the poor horse has a heart attack and dies anyway.
- Funny Man: The Funny Man's modus operandi is entirely composed of inflicting lethal pranks on people, the next crazier than the last. Naturally, given his Villainous Harlequin trickster nature.
- In Stephen King's Carrie, not only did the malicious prank at the prom trigger the title character's deadly telekinetic rampage, it also resulted in the death of Carrie's date Tommy Ross as the bucket of pig's blood hit him upside his head and killed him.
- In Stephen King's Needful Things, the main villain is a store owner, who sells everybody what they wish the most for very low prices, but the customers also have to do a prank on someone. Little do they know that those pranks worsen existing grudges between people, and eventually lead to murderous encounters.
- This makes up the whole of the plot of the novel Killing Mr Griffin and its derivative movie. Mr. Griffin has a heart condition and dies without his medication.
- Used in Harry Potter when a sixteen-year-old Sirius Black tricks Snape into going down a tunnel with Lupin in werewolf form at the end. (Snape survives due to the intervention of James Potter). Disturbingly, both Sirius and Lupin refer to it as a practical joke more than thirteen years after the event, and Sirius doesn't seem to receive any punishment for it.
- In Labyrinths of Echo by Max Frei, the protagonist was informed that now he's able to spit instant-kill magical poison, he will do it if very enraged or afraid, and as such got a status of more or less a human Grim Reaper. He contemplated spitting at one dirty-mouthed guy while in normal mood, but realized such a joke might cause heart failure. So later he spat at an approaching insane cannibal, who in his opinion looked inadequate as a threat, just to scare. And learned that "really afraid" part was optional after all.
- In Rex Stout's The League of Frightened Men (1935), the second Nero Wolfe book, the titular league permanently disabled an unpopular fellow college student many years ago in a hazing incident. (They're frightened now because after years of patronizing him, they're panicking at the idea that some sudden deaths among them may be due to his having murdered them, and they can't prove it.)
- In Private, after Thomas humiliates Reed in front of the entire Easton Academy campus, Noelle and the rest of the Billings Girls group decide to punish him by kidnapping him as part of a prank. They get him drunk, strip him, shave his head, drive him to a remote area and tie him to the trunk of a tree and leave him there. They intend to drive back after a couple of hours and free him but things do not go to plan when Thomas is then found murdered. This leads to a five book story arc with Reed trying to discover the identity of the killer and clear her current boyfriend's name.
- In the Heralds of Valdemar titles, Herald-trainee Talia is nearly killed when some young nobles throw her into an icy river "as a joke" — too bad they added a Pre-Mortem One-Liner to Talia before they threw her in. (It had been foreshadowed that these students might make an attempt on her life on the off-chance one of them would be named heir to the throne.)
- The Ninth Circle of the Tour of the Merrimack series begins with a youth dying in a hazing ritual gone wrong.
- Penny swaps Hessa's medication in Edenborn with laxatives. Turns out one missed dose is all Black Ep needs to kill her in quick order. Worse, Hessa's father increases the meds of his other children to address the mysterious outbreak, upsetting the delicate balance between the disease and the treatment and sending them into death spirals.
- Pretty Little Liars sees our eponymous foursome planning to hit someone else with a stink bomb; Jenna gets blinded in the process.
- In My Sister Jodie by Jacqueline Wilson, Jodie scares the small children at her boarding school with a horror story about the school's tower being haunted by a woman's ghost. At Halloween, she pulls a prank by dressing up as a ghost and climbing the tower; but she ends up falling off, and is killed.
- In The Machineries of Empire, back when Jedao was in the Shuos academy, there was a game contest. Jedao's submission was a game revolving around breaking the rules. One of his friends played it and ended up being caught by a Doctrine official, while another claimed to be the author of the game. Both were grievously punished.
- The short story The Real Thing by Robert Specht tells the tale of Charlie the town half-wit and Tad the town prankster. Charlie rooms at the local funeral home, and Tad tells him that the young lady lying in state in the front was killed by a vampire and will soon rise as one. Tad gets his fiancee to dress up and pretend to be a vampire rising from the coffin to scare Charlie, while Tad and his friends watch and laugh from the window. Everything goes as planned... until Charlie pulls out a stake and mallet.
- Psych has this as the murder in Scary Sherry: Bianca's Toast. The sorority sisters intended to scare off a pledge. However, the casement window she was startled into was unlocked and she fell to her death.
- Supernatural has two kids inadvertently summon a real monster while playing a prank in "Hell House." In a later season, childish pranks turn deadly in a small town, with a joy buzzer somehow electrocuting its victim, and a teenage girl scratching a hole through her skull after someone put itching powder on her comb. As it turns out, a little boy in town is developing Reality Warper powers without realizing it, and the joke items are becoming dangerous because he believes they're dangerous.
- Then there's the trickster, who does this on purpose (well, more like not caring if he permanently scars or kills someone and will keep doing it). Made worse by the fact that he's actually an angel under "witness protection" and technically, The Powers That Be allow him and even encourage him into killing people to prove he's "Loki".
- Saturday Night Live uses this trope in its "Pranksters" sketch. The eponymous show presents hidden-camera pranks that start off as harmless. Then Christopher Walken's character shows the video of his prank, summed up best with the quote "I pranked him to death with a tire-iron!" Hilarity Ensues.
- A parody of this is played up in Scare Tactics, where the scare victims are tricked into going onto a fake reality TV show called "Fear Antics", where they're put under the impression that they're going to pull a huge fright-based prank on someone for the cameras. However, the other participants always rig the stunt so that it looks like it goes horribly wrong, causing the victim to think they've inadvertently seriously injured/killed/got in some other deep trouble the person they were supposed to scare.
- Backfires in one episode, when the prank-victim, confronted by the prankster "killer," grabbed a knife and nearly tore into the prankster.
"OH FUCK, NO NO NO, YOU'RE ON SCARE TACTICS, IT'S A TV SHOW, IT'S A JOKE, YOUR FRIEND SET YOU UP JESUS CHRIST FUCK."
- In one episode, the prank-victim was fooled into thinking he was trapped in a Gas Chamber, and he broke a hole in the wall.
- Backfires in one episode, when the prank-victim, confronted by the prankster "killer," grabbed a knife and nearly tore into the prankster.
- In Boardwalk Empire Willie Thompson gets revenge on an obnoxious college bully by spiking his drink with milk of magnesia to give him diarrhea. It works at first, and Willie gets to laugh at his humiliation... but the dose proves fatal, with the bully dying in the bathroom.
- B.J. and Winchester set Sgt. Zale up for one of these in a later episode of Mash after Zale plays a prank on B.J. involving a fake grenade.
- The Masters of Horror episode "We All Scream for Ice Cream" starts with a childhood prank gone deadly wrong.
- In the Tales from the Crypt episode "Abra Cadaver" a doctor pulls a prank on his brother, scaring him into a stroke and ruining his medical career. The brother never forgets and gets revenge with another prank years later... killing his brother twice.
- Happens in another episode, "This'll Kill Ya", when an asshole doctor thinks he's been poisoned by one of his colleagues. It turns out that his colleague had tricked him to teach him a lesson, but this isn't revealed until after the doctor kills him as "revenge".
- Degrassi: The Next Generation: "Time Stands Still Part 1" in which Rick is painted and feathered after winning at a game show contest. He goes home and starts looking at a gun in a box...
- To make matters worse, the prankster pinned the blame on another student who Rick then attacked, resulting in Rick getting killed and the other student severely injured. The prankster was remorseful and guilty over his actions, but it still wasn't enough to keep from getting expelled when he confessed to the principal.
- Alfred Hitchcock Presents:
- "Beta Delta Gamma" has a group of frat brothers heavily sedate one of their passed-out-drunk brothers and make the other passed-out-drunk brother think he killed him in an alcoholic blackout. Too bad he decided to bury the "dead guy" on the beach and the high tide washed away footprints and other traces...
- "The Night the World Ended" has a guy use a fake newspaper to trick a homeless man into think the world will end that night. The homeless guy finds out and kills the prankster at the exact time the world was supposed to end.
- In the Alfred Hitchcock Hour episode "The Cadaver" a college student arranges for another student to go on a date with a woman and wake up with a similar-looking cadaver, to scare him from drinking so much. And, of course, the prank victim finds out and kills him, putting his body in with the other cadavers.
- In one episode of CSI, a woman sneaks a large block of dry ice into a guy's room, so that the CO2 fumes would make him sick. He and a woman that he sleeps with in the room die. She protests that she carefully calculated the amount of CO2 be non-lethal. She didn't anticipate that they'd be sleeping on the floor. Since the fumes are heavier than air, the concentration near the floor was high enough to be lethal.
- And in another, a juror dies in the jury room. Turns out that he was honking off the rest of the jurors with his attitude, and had happened to mention his peanut allergy (loudly and repeatedly). One of the others then decided to lace his chili with peanut butter to bring him down a peg or two, not appreciating the potential consequences of his allergic reaction. She tried to back out of it at the last second, Mind you, a bee - one of his other allergies - beat her to it.
- In the episode "Pledging Mr Johnson", a pledge is murdered under the cover of a fraternity hazing gone wrong.
- A different episode featured a crusty old poker star who drops dead at the poker table. A number of factors contributed to his death, one of which is that the waitress for the table - annoyed at his extended refusal to tip - put eyedrops into his drink, hoping to give him diarrhea. The eye drops reacted with the large amount of lead he'd had in his system after years of eating pounds of chocolate a day made with cocoa grown in lead heavy soil.
- Anything more than a few drops of many eyedrops formulas, including Visine, will cause death by shutting down the nervous system. Nothing more is necessary. See the Visine example below in the Real Life section.
- Likewise, there's the time a guy who's still alive, just fully paralyzed, ends up on Doc Robbins' table. He was a used car salesman whose colleagues kept playing pranks on one another to unnerve them/take them away from the sales floor. One of them put snake venom in his coffee, which normally would've just given a really upset stomach... if not for the bleeding ulcer.
- Supposedly, the prank Hannah West played on the Alpha Bitch was just meant to annoy her and scare her out of the shower and this started a chain of events that led to her death. Except... not really; her brother killed the victim.
- In an episode of iCarly, Carly, Freddie and Sam decide to prank Loubert by giving him an exploding muffin basket. They didn't realize it would explode quite so much, dealing serious damage to Loubert, who spends the rest of the episode being tended to by Freddie's mom, which shifts the focus onto a potential romance between the two. By the end, the prank is forgotten and none of the kids receive retribution.
- On Cheers the most elaborate prank between Gary and Sam involved Gary getting most of the city of Boston including everyone at Cheers to convince Sam that Gary had been killed by a hologram machine.
- Played for Laughs in the second season Green Wing. Joanna gets sick of Statham being happy so, under the advice of Sue, decides to knock him down to his partly miserable old self by scaring him. Since Statham is frightfully scared of gobins, Joanna asks her dwarf cousin to hide under his desk, his face covered in green make-up. and shout "boo!" when he comes in. Unfortunately when he does this, Statham beats him to death with a stuffed heron.
- On How I Met Your Mother Barney spends a month perfecting an exploding meatball sandwich. It took so long because it had the nasty side effect of decapitating the test dummies.
- There was a Candid Camera-esque show of two guys about to prank a barber. The first guy put a bag of fake blood under his wig, planning to make the barber think he cut too deep. When the fake blood was released and the first guy acted in much pain, the barber apparently went into such shock that it triggered his heart condition. To make matters worse, his friend ran away, and the barber's daughter called the police immediately to the scene. However, it's all revealed that the REAL prank is on the first guy, by the second guy, the barber, his daughter and the policeman.
- An unusual example where the prank is deadly for the prankster in Defiance - a young man is persuaded to fire a paintball gun at the incumbent mayor during a mayoral debate, not knowing that an anonymous tip has been made of a plan to assassinate the mayor.
- Two Twisted episode Finding Frank has a security guard's colleague disappear and calls out desperatly over the walkie-talkies. When the guard goes to find him it turns out to be a surprise retirement party but goes terribly wrong when the nervous guard over reacts firing his gun when the lights come on, killing his wife but as the guard is being led away he drops a a bit of paper that his colleague picks up. It's an invitation to the party with the exact time, location, everything showing that the guard knew all along and used the party to kill his wife framing it as accident. It's even better when you know the actor who plays the guard played a set-upon Extreme Doormat in his most famous role.
- Averted on Doc Martin, but as Martin pointed out, it did keep him from attending to patients that actually needed his help.
- In The Big Bang Theory, in revenge for an earlier prank, Sheldon shakes Howard's hand with an electrical buzzer, causing Howard to collapse due to a heart condition. Howard was faking, and uses the opportunity to scare Sheldon a second time.
- Played with in the Inside No. 9 episode "Nana's Party", based around a man playing a prank by hiding inside a papier-mache cake at his mother-in-law's birthday party. The audience is led to expect disaster with the cake, but it never happens ... until the trope comes into play when the elderly mother-in-law starts choking on a trick ice cube (although she survives.)
- Chicago Med once had an episode surrounding a shooting at a movie theater. It later turned out that the "shooter" was an internet prankster with a leaf blower. Unfortunately, the panicked movie-goers trample a woman to death and a movie-goer with a gun shoots the prankster. The prankster ends up surviving after receiving a liver transplant from the trampled woman, oddly enough. Also, the man who shot him jumps in front of a moving car and later dies.
- Alan on Freaks and Geeks snuck peanuts into Bill's sandwich because he thought that Bill was kidding about being allergic to them. He wasn't kidding and spent most of the episode at death's door. He lives, though.
- In the April Fools' Day episode of Kenan & Kel, Kenan played pranks on all his friends and family (i.e making Chris think he won the lottery, ordering a hundred pizzas for Sharla, putting a piece of meat in Mark's bag to get dogs chasing him, etc). Each prank resulted in his friends getting thrown in jail.
- A variation appeared in The Outer Limits (1995) episode "Nightmare". A spaceship crew transporting a planet-destroying device are captured by enemy forces and tortured and interrogated. It turns out that they were actually on Earth All Along and that they were being put through an experiment by their general to test their snap threshold. Unfortunately, the experiment went awry when one of soldiers was pushed to his breaking point and led to believe that another had betrayed the crew, causing him to stab him in the stomach. Even worse, The Stoic scientist who had helped design the explosive device had completely broken down and set the device to blow in a Taking You with Me attempt. Definitely one of the biggest Cruel Twist Endings out there.
- Death in Paradise: A deadly prank 40 years earlier provides the motive for the murder in "A Personal Murder". A group of boys threw a younger boy's hat into the river. In trying to retrieve it, he slipped into the river and hit his head on a rock. The others buried his body and swore never to tell anyone what had happened. Decades later, one of the conspirators decided to come clean, and one of the others silenced him before he could talk.
- In Spartacus: Blood and Sand, Lucretia and Licinia trick Ilithyia into having sex with her and her husband's mortal enemy Spartacus, by having them both wear masks during the act. (Licinia out of pure mischief, Lucretia because Ilithyia had wanted to have sex with another gladiator who Lucretia wanted to keep for herself.) When the truth is revealed, Spartacus nearly strangles Ilithyia to death before being dragged away, and Ilithyia's reaction is to beat Licinia's brains out (literally) on the stone floor.
- In The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, Will's girlfriend Lisa sets him up for a prank intended to scare and humiliate him, having been asked to do so by her sorority sisters as payback for Will's skeevy behavior towards women. Will breaks loose and intends to just ditch Lisa, but ends up going back when he sees her crying and feels bad about his occasionally Jerk Ass behavior. They reconcile and simply fake the prank being successful to make Lisa look good. However, Will decides to get back at Carlton (who helped set up the prank) by telling him that Will killed Lisa in misguided self-defence. This causes Carlton to have a massive Freak Out! and leads to one of the funniest moments on the show where Carlton runs screaming and blubbering through the various show sets, backstage and even through the studio audience.
- The Umgah of Star Control are like this. Their idea of "pranks" include pretending to be another race's gods and ordering them to attack their neighbors, "accidentally" garbling a message to the Ur-Quan so the cowardly Spathi volunteered for front-line combat duty, dropping an asteroid in another race's ocean, etc. It's heavily suggested that the Umgah are simply insane and don't realize the enormity of what they're doing.
- This happens in Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney: Justice for All in case 3, when Regina puts pepper on Bat's scarf. This causes a lion to sneeze while Bat's head is in its mouth, which puts him in a coma. As a result, his brother Acro tries to kill Regina as revenge.
- Katawa Shoujo: In one route, Kenji comes up behind Hisao and greets him by slapping him hard on the back. The problem? Hisao has cardiac arrhythmia, and a sudden shock to the chest is a very bad thing for him. Fortunately, he's fine this time, but he angrily snaps at Kenji to never do that again, because it could actually kill him (Kenji was unaware of Hisao's condition, and apologizes with uncharacteristic sincerity).
- In Five Nights at Freddy's 4, The game's protagonist gets his head stuffed into the face of the Fredbear animatronic by his Big Brother Bully... and then Fredbear bites down, much to the horror of the boy's brother and his brother's friends. Rather this is the infamous "Bite of '87", or not is unknown.
- The plot of Until Dawn rests on one of these. During a house party hosted by the Washington siblings at their family's mountain lodge, Hannah Washington is pranked by some of the guests as retribution for her obvious crush on Mike (who already has a girlfriend). Feeling humiliated, she runs outside into a snowstorm, and when her sister goes to look for her, they both get lost on the mountains and are presumed dead by the time the rest of the game takes place one year later. Their brother Josh decides to get revenge by pranking the others in turn, but everything goes to hell when actual monsters appear. It's noted that while no one intended the prank to have such terrible consequences, their motives were still malicious; the player also has the choice to have characters either deeply regret the prank, or believe that Hannah over-reacted to it.
- A very young Princess Azura once was the target of a prank that went almost fatally wrong in Fire Emblem Fates, at the hands of some of the concubine kids in the Nohrian Deadly Decadent Court, and barely survived to it. As a consequence she gets a pretty ugly scar on her body (which is a plot point in her supports with Saizo) and was emotionaly devastated.
- An episode of Pucca has the Vagabond Ninjas prank Sooga Village by releasing termites that eat all the chopsticks, and it all goes downhill from there.
- In I Killed Pom-Pom!, Strong Bad tricks Homestar into thinking he killed Pom-Pom. Unfortunately, he decides to "Fight murder with murder"...
- The Gmod Idiot Box: This is the entire point of Harmless Shenanigans(?) with Chuckles the Cheat. Literally every prank Chuckles pulls leads to someone dying. Except that one time where his victim dies from something else.
- The incident in The Order of the Stick with the weasel that provides the page quote.
- A flashback from Something*Positive where Davan's father (when he was a boy) played a joke on a complete jerkass bully in hospital. Turns out the boy had a weak heart, and died from shock.
- In a standalone comic by Ian Samson, a novice witch turns her more experienced sister into a dress and wears her for a day, not realizing that the spell she used has no way to preserve her mind, which fades until ultimately dying in the wash, leaving her crying over an ordinary dress.
- The short film Spider.
- Roommate Alien Prank Goes Bad: Two guys repeatedly scare their roommate Chad with alien sunglasses and hands because Chad hates aliens. Then a real alien shows up.
- Everyman HYBRID was started as a parody of Marble Hornets, disguised by having the health/exercise regimen appear to be what is being hijacked by Slender Man; in reality, the in-universe characters are using a prop Slendy placed in rather obvious places. Then the real Slender Man finds out about it, and it seems he is not happy in the slightest. After recent events, the characters are starting to wonder if he would have showed up at some point anyway.
- In the Furry Basketball Association, a prank on a player who is addicted to cocaine results in him snorting caffeine instead; the pranksters had no idea it would result in the addict screaming in pain. This trope is ultimately inverted as the player is sent to the hospital, where he's convinced to enter rehab.
- A version of sorts happens in Chowder. After already playing a prank that ruins Mung's catering business, Ms. Endive plays another prank on him, dropping a huge pie on top of him, which turns out to crush him flat. She becomes desperate to keep the accident a secret and eventually decides to leave the country. Turns out that it was all just a prank by Mung to get back at her for all the pranks she did to him.
- In the Halloween Episode of Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends, Bloo pulls the old snake-in-a-can gag on Mr. Herriman. Herriman has a heart attack and dies, and Bloo hastily buries him in the yard. Herriman then comes back from the dead and unleashes a Zombie Apocalypse. No, really! Well, not really. In the end, it all turns out to be a prank pulled on Bloo by the whole house, only it backfires when Bloo unleashes a berserk Mac (hopped up on candy) upon them.
- Not quite deadly, but Hey Arnold! has an episode where Arnold accidentally seriously blinds Helga when he takes revenge on her for some pranks she pulled. She gets better, but the rest of the episode is a bizarre Cycle of Revenge. Leads to a funny conversation (taken from memory, so probably not exact):
Arnold: I didn't think it would blind her!Grampa: Well, what did you think I meant by "it'll release a blinding light"?
- Used in the Halloween Episode where Arnold and Gerald prank the boardinghouse by imitating the infamous War of the Worlds broadcast. Unfortunately, it gets out of hand when the radio show is picked up by an Orson Welles expy reporter who blows the situation out of proportion and sends the entire city into hysteria. Even worse is that Arnold's friends were dressed like aliens for Halloween and ended up getting chased by mobs, culminating in Helga nearly getting strangled by her alien schizophrenic father.
- On The Simpsons Bart pranked Homer on April Fools Day with an extremely shaken can of beer. It sent him to the hospital, and while he was moderately fine, Homer ended up in a coma when his attempts to get at a candy bar resulted in the vending machine falling on him. Even worse, because of the prank, we had to suffer through a Clip Show.
- South Park: as a joke two Sea Park employees make the boys think that the killer whale is really Willzyx and needs to return to its family in space. It's all fun and games - ending with a big shootout, one of the employees dead ("I still say it was funny!") and the whale dying on the moon, having been shot there by the Mexican Space Agency.
- On Regular Show, Muscle Man plans to prank Mordecai by taping his bed to the ceiling. Then the bed falls on Pops, seriously injuring him. Muscle Man then swears off pranking, which unfortunately leaves the park vulnerable during an epic prank war with another park; the prank war being just as bad as the Muscle Man's prank.
- Sym-Bionic Titan: In "The Ballad of Scary Mary," fifty years ago, a nerdy high school student named Mary is never seen again after a group of classmates lure her into the woods to tar and feather her. The Monster of the Week, a shapeshifting ghost, ends up taking advantage of the Urban Legend party for it. However, the trope is subverted at the end of the episode, when it's revealed that Mary hadn't died, but instead hit it off with a cute biker boy she met in the woods and ran off with him.
- Squidward did this in Spongebob Squarepants because he wanted quiet from all the pranking due to April Fools Day. However, the prank was so cruel and harmful that it caused Spongebob to cry and the citizens to call him out on this. And Squidward looks around to see the damage and realizes that he went too far. But it winds up subverted: SpongeBob had planned a Gambit Roulette that specifically required he get that injured, and when Squidward finally apologized, it turned out everyone in the town was in on it.
- In the Steven Universe episode "Joking Victim," Steven and Sadie decide to get back at Lars by putting magical fire salt on his food. Between putting too much and it getting stuck in his throat, he actually starts breathing fire and runs screaming through town. It's more Played for Drama than it sounds (though not entirely).
- In one episode of King of the Hill, Hank and the guys take Bobby and his friends on a Snipe Hunt. Unfortunately, they land into trouble when Bobby apparently kills a rare whooping crane.
- While not exactly lethal, in one episode of Garfield and Friends, Jon, Odie, and Nermal decide to teach Garfield a lesson with his penchant for trying to mail Nermal to Abu Dhabi by substituting Nermal with a stuffed cat doll in the package and making Garfield's favorite meal but saying they can't eat without Nermal. Unfortunately, they underestimated the lengths Garfield would go for food as he chased after the package all the way to the central post office. When Garfield learned of the trick, he decided to turn the tables by using the stuffed cat (after painting its tail to look like his own) to make them think he mailed himself to Abu Dhabi.
- In one episode of Ed, Edd n Eddy, Eddy plays a prank on Ed by having a reluctant Double-D pretend to be a monster. It results in Ed smashing Double-D and Jimmy with a tree.
- In My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic episode "28 Pranks Later", during her pranking spree, Rainbow Dash switched out some Filly Scout cookies for gag cookies that would turn one's mouth rainbow colored. The cookies end up turning everyone in Ponyville into cookie-craving zombies. It's then revealed that it was all just a prank the whole town was in on to teach Dash a lesson about her excessive pranking.
- In The Angry Beavers episode "Omega Beaver", when Daggett falls for a conspiracy con about creatures called Howler Leeches, Norbert and their friends decide to play a trick on him by pretending to be Howler Leeches. Unfortunately, the paranoid Daggett sets a leech-killing canine on their friends which not only mauls them, but they also get frozen in the snow. Despite the gag being his idea, Norbert blames Daggett for them being frozen.
- In The Amazing World of Gumball episode "The Prank", Richard has a Bucket Booby-Trap full of what-might-be-water. Gumball and Darwin, feeling guilty after the mutual prank war led to Richard needing the paramedics to pull a bucket off of his head, decide to humor their dad by "falling for" the obvious prank. The bucket falls... and gets lodged in the floor. It turns out that Richard had left wet concrete in the bucket and assumed it would stay wet.
- Combine this trope with Teens Are Monsters and Bury Your Gays, and you have the story of Tyler Clementi. Tyler's roommate filmed Tyler and another man having a sexual encounter and posted it on Facebook. Tyler got so much negative reaction that he killed himself.
- This story about a man who got drunk and passed out, and his friends stuck a 20-inch live eel in his anus. The eel proceeded to eat his insides, resulting in his death.
- During the Troubled Production of Titanic (1997), disgruntled crew members put PCP in the crew's soup. The main target, James Cameron, vomited upon ingestion, while over 50 others were hospitalized.
- Two Australian DJs made a prank call to the hospital Kate Middleton, Duchess of Cambridge, was staying in with morning sickness. The receptionist who answered the call fell for the prank and divulged confidential information. Two days later, the receptionist was found dead in her home after committing suicide.
- There have been numerous cases of people putting Visine in drinks, thinking that it's a harmless diuretic. It's actually a poison that can kill and induce comas. For this reason, this and any other kind of Laxative Prank has been outlawed in many US states.
- Thirteen members of the Florida A&M University Marching Band are facing various criminal charges up to and including manslaughter in the death of their drum major, Robert Champion, after a prank on a school bus went horribly wrong. (In Florida, the hazing itself is a third-degree felony, whether Champion had died or not.)
- Most likely apocryphal, but the pagan harvest festival that would be commercialized into Halloween was Serious Business. Failure to provide hospitality when you had the means to do so could result in legally fatal pranks.