These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Sonic Colors
Here are the various subjective tropes used in, and in response to, Sonic Colors.
In the years since its release, the Broken Base has increased due to a bit of Hype Backlash factor. Now fans can't stop arguing whether Unleashed or Colors was the game that saved the series' reputation, or which one is much better designed.
Casting Gag: Not voice casting, but writer casting. At one point, Sonic says "Nobody said there'd be math", which was a Running Gag in MadWorld. Guess which writing team they brought on to make Colours?
Everything in this game is gonna embed itself into your brain. It isSonic after all.
Eight Point Five: IGN's score on Colors. Complaints rose, of course, mainly due to the fact the major flaw cited was certain difficult spikes, and difficulty is mostly a subjective concept. On the other hand, considering the scores IGN has handed out to other3DSonicgames, 8.5 is amazing.
Epic Riff: Just about every song in the game has these, but most notably Planet Wisp and its Piano line.
Filler: Each zone has only one or two stages that are expansive, have alternate paths, are in 3D, and are generally 2-4 minutes long. Everything else are just minute-long stages that rely on gimmicks to pad them out, especially in regards to the switch-activated moving platform stages.
Also, SA-55 Orbot (the robot nicknamed "Ergo" by fans), in the final cutscene that had Eggman in Sonic Unleashed, suggested that Eggman simply begin his plans anew. Bringing planets together is basically the opposite of what Eggman did in Sonic Unleashed by cracking the Earth into pieces, so maybe Eggman decided to use the same plan but backwards... and in space?
Some people are calling bull on Sonic not being able to outrun the black hole in Terminal Velocity Act 2. However, it should be noted that nothing — not even light — escapes a black hole when sucked in. Thus, not even the fastest thing alive, who can only break the sound barrier, would be able to resist its pull.
A lot of people might think that the disclaimer "Now with FISH!" referring to a sushi restaurant was a joke about Eggman's terrible restaurant planning. But "sushi" actually refers to a type of vinegared rice, which is SOMETIMES served with raw fish among other ingredients. So a sushi restaurant without fish actually makes perfect sense.
Game Breaker: The Wii version has Super Sonic. He makes the powerups useless, since he can basically do everything they can (and when he can't, the levels actually change to help him out). It may seem like a Bragging Rights Reward once you realize that you have to collect all the Red Rings in all the levels, but it makes getting 100% Completion by getting S Rank in some of the levels easier, since it even gives you a bonus every few seconds just for being Super Sonic.
Hype Backlash: The game has gotten quite a bit of Sonic fans calling it overrated due to it getting much more critical acclaim than a lot of the other previous 3D Sonic games, noticably about where most people say it was "the game that saved Sonic's reputation". This caused yet another Broken Base where, despite the better much ratings compared to 06 and Unleashed, fans still question on whether it's a good game on its own or not, or how it compares to the likes of Sonic Adventure 2 (which is also suffering Hype Backlash now for similar and different reasons).
It's Short, so It Sucks : Well, not that it sucks, but Nintendo Power gave the DS version a lower score simply because it's over too fast. They did say that it was great while it lasted, though.
The Purple and Violet Wisps themselves. They were once regular Wisps, but they were abducted by Eggman, forced to do his bidding, and transformed into violent, Slasher Smile-wearing, eyeless creatures that look like this◊ and this.◊ And then there's their motives for helping Sonic. Are they still good-natured Wisps, trying to use their new powers to aid Sonic, or did Eggman's tinkerings cause a permanent Face-Heel Turn and they're simply using Sonic to get back at Eggman? Will they even be able to return to their original forms? (The answer: Yes.) Just thinking about it is so terrifying, it's depressing.
Oh, and the drowning music returns, this time fully orchestrated, albeit a bit less scary in the "Whoa, I'm scared" sense, and more scary in the "I'm gonna lose a life here and have to start this section over" sense.
Even scarier: making Sonic stand still when the countdown begins will actually show him struggling for air this time.
Scrappy Mechanic: Swinging on lollipops in Sweet Mountain, as it can be hard to tell when it's a good time to jump off and get to the next platform.
That One Level: Planet Wisp, Act 3. Seems simple enough, but it is FAR too easy to just BARELY miss those TINY platforms that you have to cross and plummet to your death... The Cube power-up also has an annoying tendency to run out when you're standing on the blue blocks, which revert to rings, and — you guessed it — cause you to plummet to your death.
The levels with the yellow moving springs can also give grief, as you have to both keep up with the spring and not overpace it, as well as having to stomp on it to gain more height, which is very finicky and sometimes likes to not bounce you high enough to reach platforms. Best not let it tempt you to your death with its hard to reach rings. Asteroid Coaster Act 3 makes it even harder with pushy things that instantly kill you if you don't stomp on the spring at just the right moment.
That One Side Quest: The DS version brings us Mission 2 in Sweet Mountain. Now, normally, rescuing the 25 Wisps isn't so hard if all you're trying to do is simply pass it or collect the mission's red rings; however, it becomes a total nightmare when trying to S rank the mission, mostly due to the fact that when you get to the robot that tosses you up into the air and you have to float down while trying to dodge bomb balloons and land on the hot dog it's holding and then go into its mouth, the problem is that you move at a very sluggish pace when floating down and have no way to land on the hot dog and into the robot's mouth faster, so that section of the mission winds up wasting a lot of your time, and since it's a rescue the Wisps mission, that means there are no extra time capsules to pick up to give you extra time on the mission's countdown timer. By the time you're past the giant robot with the hot dog part, you probably won't have enough time left to earn an S rank for the mission.
Even worse is Mission 3 in Asteroid Coaster. Merely completing this level is utterly hellish, as you have to complete the entirety of Asteroid Coaster Act 2 — by far the most difficult level in the game — in a single life under a very unforgiving time limit. Getting an S rank for this mission requires absolute perfection. Do not attempt unless you have a lot of time to waste and a very tight grip on your sanity.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: A mind-controlled Tails would have made an awesome boss for this game, especially considering that Tails had been becoming a Non-Action Guy lately. Unfortunately, Eggman's mind-control ray ran out of power.