Video Game / Alan Wake II

This page assumes that you've played Alan Wake, Alan Wake's American Nightmare and Control. Spoilers for all related games will be left unmarked. You have been warned.

I follow you into the dark...

"We all come to a story with hopes and expectations, looking for an answer. Sometimes it would be better to live with that hope — without ever knowing the full story. In a horror story, there are only victims and monsters, and the trick is not to end up as either. But trapped by the genre, we are all ripped to pieces along the way. This is not the story I hoped it would be. This is not the ending I wanted. This story will eat us alive. This story is a monster. And monsters wear many faces..."

— Alan Wake

Alan Wake II is a Survival Horror video game and the sequel to Alan Wake, developed by Remedy Entertainment and published by Epic Games for the PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and Microsoft Windows, released on October 27, 2023.

Thirteen years after the mysterious events that rocked the sleepy Washington town of Bright Falls, two FBI agents — Alex Casey and Saga Anderson — arrive in town to investigate the ritual murder of special agent Robert Nightingale, who went missing along with famous author Alan Wake back in 2010. What initially seems like a relatively simple case involving the esoteric Cult of the Tree quickly spirals into the darkness of a supernatural horror story — one laid out with eerie accuracy by mysterious manuscript pages that seem to be written by Wake himself.

Thirteen years after defeating the Dark Presence and sacrificing himself to save his wife, Alan Wake remains trapped in the Dark Place beneath Cauldron Lake, trying to write a story that will set him free and keep the Dark Presence locked away. Unfortunately, years of isolation have taken their toll on his mind, and the Dark Presence has found a way to exploit that and write a story of its own: Initiation. To prevent the world-ending horror story from coming true, Alan must dive deeper into his nightmare, following the trail of his Evil Doppelgänger, Mr. Scratch.

As these two story threads intersect with each other, Alan and Saga will be forced to contend with unimaginable dangers, which threaten not just their lives, but their very realities...

The game is slated to have two story-based DLCs, "Night Springs" and "The Lake House", both of which come with the Digital Deluxe Edition at no extra charge; the former is set for release in Spring 2024. Free post-release content adding "The Final Draft" and Nightmare mode was released on December 11, 2023.

Previews: Announcement Trailer, Gameplay Reveal, Dark Place Trailer Launch Trailer

---

Alan Wake II contains examples of the following tropes:

• 108:
  • Saga petting all twelve taxidermized deer unlocks Room 108 in the Elderwood Lodge.
  • The climax of the draft of Initiation set in the Oceanview Hotel is in room 108.
• Abandoned Hospital: The Valhalla Nursing Home's Wellness Center, which is a small private practice for the residents of the main manor of the estate. It is ominous, quiet, and other than the raving Tor, completely abandoned of staff and patients by the time Saga arrives. On top of this, the first of the Taken Divers lurk the building.
• Aborted Arc: Nightingale possibly being a new vessel for the Dark Presence, as implied at the end of the first game, is never addressed — even In-Universe, the Cult of the Tree got him before he could be a real Humanoid Abomination threat.
• Achievement Mockery: One of the hidden achievements is to shoot a Mr. Drippy cutout in Coffee World. While any of the cutouts will do, given a scripted jumpscare occurs when Saga rounds a corner of the amusement park, and is startled by its Evil Laugh, a player will likely get the achievement as a "reward" for instinctively trying to blast away the threat and wasting ammo on a harmless cutout.
• Action Girl: Saga, one of the protagonists and a FBI criminal profiler, is shown fending off against the Taken with different firearms. Her ally Agent Estevez also leads her people from the frontline.
• Actionized Sequel: Inverted, because of the shift into Survival Horror. Combat encounters are fewer, slower, and more methodical, but Taken are much tougher despite being fewer in numbers. There is much more puzzle solving too; especially in Alan's chapters.
• Action Mom: Saga has a daughter back home in Virginia named Logan, along with her husband, David.
• Advancing Boss of Doom: At the end of the first two Murder Scenes, Alan is confronted by a manifestation of the Dark Presence itself; a massive ball of shrieking darkness. He is forced to flee to the nearest Safe Room to escape it.
• Always Over the Shoulder: The game is a Third-Person Shooter which sports a tight, constant over the shoulder view of the player characters. Especially notable in contrast to the first game, which had its camera far further back than the standard, allowing a wide field of vision.
• Alien Geometries: It quickly becomes apparent the Dark Place doesn't conform to normal geography, in some places Alan will be going in circles until he finds the right way, in others he might end up somewhere else like going down a stairwell to a basement door and coming out on a rooftop.
• Ambiguously Related:
  • According to the first game, the Clicker belonged to Alan's father; in this game, we find out that it came off of a lamp once owned by Thomas Zane. Muddying the waters is the fact that Zane and Alan are both played by the same actor; did Zane write Alan into existence and give him the Clicker through Rewriting Reality, or is this a case of Generation Xerox helped along by a Timey-Wimey Ball making them appear to be the same age?
• All Elections Are Serious Business: The Mayor of Bright Falls, Mayor Setter, is up for re-election, and a competing candidate, Jim Figamore, announces his candidacy by claiming that Mayor Setter kills cats. You can meet the Mayor as early as Saga's Chapter 5... Mayor Setter is a dog.
• Amusement Park of Doom: One of the town of Watery's attractions is an amusement park called Coffee World, the most caffeinated place on earth. Following the conventions of the genre, it is unsurprisingly creepy, abandoned and swarming with Taken thanks to being the site of an Overlap between the real world and the Dark Place.
• And I Must Scream: It's established that it has been thirteen years since the events of the first game with Alan trapped in the Dark Place the whole time, and it has done nothing good for his mental health.
• And Now for Someone Completely Different: In addition to controlling Alan Wake, the protagonist of the first game, players also control FBI Agent Saga Anderson who is trained in both investigations and firearms as opposed to Action Survivor Alan. There are even sections in Saga's campaign where you play as Alan.
• And Then John Was a Zombie: This game being what it is several characters get turned into Taken, the Achievements spoil boss fights with Agent Nightingale, Cynthia Weaver and deputies Mulligan and Thornton.
• Animal Motifs: Both Alan and Saga are represented by a stuffed animal in their respective Mind Places. Alan is an owl and Saga is a deer (though interestingly a male deer given the antlers). This comes up more with Saga, as she comes across multiple stuffed deer heads throughout the game that she sympathizes with, and when she is stuck in her Mind Place after getting pulled into the Dark Place, she at one point has a vision of a bright white deer that begins to give her hope to escape. For Alan, it mainly comes up when him and Saga are referred to by their respective animals in the Dark Poem 2, a transcript page that can be found, though in one of his more insane rant videos, Alan can be seen crouched on his desk waving his arms like a bird.
• Another Side, Another Story: Rather than solely controlling the titular protagonist, the player can choose between playing as Alan in his exploits within the Dark World and newcomer Saga Anderson during her investigation throughout Bright Falls, Watery, and the surrounding woods.
• Anti-Frustration Features:
  • Only consumables and ammo take up space in your inventory; story-important items (like keys and puzzle components) are in their own separate storage that lets you keep as many things as you need to.
  • If you encounter an item that you can't pick up because your inventory is full, it will be marked on the map for as long as you're in the area. The same is true for locked containers.
  • On Story and Normal difficulties, enemies will drop batteries if Saga or Alan are running low. On those difficulties, they will also drop ammo from time to time.
  • Near the end of the game, if you go meet Mayor Setter in Watery, you get a charm that will reveal all items and interactable objects around Saga. This is very useful for mopping up the rest of the lunchboxes, rhyme puzzles, and even some of the cult stashes (if the chest needs a key, the charm will reveal it), some of which can be hard to find in the dark. Additionally, while strictly following the story won't take you back to Watery, it will take you past by a campaign sign saying that you can meet Setter in Watery, which Saga comments on, to nudge you in the right direction without forcing you to go. The charm is especially handy for hunting since by the time you can get it, the entire area is going to be dark.
  • There's usually a janitor's bucket at the beginning, end, or both of a chapter in both campaigns to make it easier to play the game with a Two Lines, No Waiting plot.
  • During the brief No-Gear Level in Return 4, there is a darkness barrier blocking progression that can only be destroyed with either three flashlight boosts or some other darkness-burning implement, such as a propane tank, flashbang, or flare. The player only has a single flashlight battery, and if the player runs out of flashlight boosts before they're able to destroy this barrier, the flashlight will automatically recharge itself, like how the flashlight worked in the first game, preventing a softlock.
• Arc Number: 665, the "Neighbor of the Beast", shows up a few different times in the Dark Place, being a code that Alan needs to enter, being featured on some graffiti, being Thomas Zane's room number in the Oceanview, and being the number of days that Doctor Darling has spent in the Dark Place.
• Arc Symbol: Things connected to the Dark Place are often marked with a spiral symbol. Especially true for otherwise normal-looking doors that have a spiral on them.
• Arc Words: "This is the ritual to lead you on/Your friends will meet him when you're gone".
• Armor-Piercing Attack: An upgrade for the Hunting Rifle allows it to ignore the Taken's darkness shields.
• Ascended Fridge Horror: The first game mostly avoided the topic of people the Dark Presence had Taken and how Alan had used them as characters in Departure. Here, frequent disappearances near Cauldron Lake have given Bright Falls a bad reputation, leading to much of its tourism leaving, and Saga is furious with Alan for using Logan and possibly killing her as backstory tragedy. The Cult of the Tree is even a desperate attempt to keep people safe by only killing Taken and deliberately cultivating its image to scare people out of the forest. They view Alan as a monster, thinking he's the source of the Taken, and believe that killing him will make them stop coming.
• Attack Its Weak Point: Most Taken now have a glowing red "Source Point" somewhere on their bodies after burning away their darkness shield. Shooting it will make it explode, dealing massive damage to the Taken. If they survive, or it's somewhere too hard to hit (such as on the Taken's back), then the head will suffice as a secondary weak point just like in most other shooters.
• Back for the Dead: Agent Nightingale, Cynthia Weaver and deputies Mulligan and Thornton.
• Bad "Bad Acting": Ilmo and Jaakko cover both sides of this in their commercials. Ilmo is overly-eager and hammy, while Jaakko is incredibly monotone and makes no attempt at emotion. Jaakko at least admits he's only there for the free beer. This is somewhat changed for the final commercial, due to Ilmo being alone — he tries to remain over eager and hammy, but without Jaakko to bounce off of due to his death at the hands of Scratch, there are points where he clearly is missing his brother.
  • At the cinema in the Dark Place, Alan finds the Yötön Yö actor who looks like Casey tied to a chair, who repeatedly and stiltedly begs Alan not to sacrifice him using a nearby knife, as he repeatedly jerks his head towards said knife, with Alan awkwardly repeating what he is saying. Alan's internal dialogue notes how stilted and awkward the entire exchange is, like the first draft of a scene that could really use a few more passes.
• The Bad Guys Are Cops: Early on Casey jokes that Sheriff Tim Breaker is the cult's Grand Wizard, becomes oddly prophetic when later we encounter cultists that are clearly wearing Bright Falls sheriff deputy uniforms and again when we fight Taken deputies Mulligan and Thornton.
• Bait-and-Switch:
  • Players might hear the name "Sheriff Breaker" in the early game and expect a return of Sarah from the first game; instead, we have Sheriff Tim Breaker, Sarah's cousin, played by Shawn Ashmore.
  • At the Valhalla Nursing Center, one of the designated safe zones where Saga puts her guns away, she stumbles across Cynthia Weaver from the first game. Her outfit is haggard and she is blankly staring at the setting sun, which may lead players to think she is losing her faculties like Pat and to an extent, the Anderson Brothers. Instead, trying to talk to her has her spout a creepy line and teleport away in the flash of a Jumpscare, revealing the poor woman was Taken before Saga even arrived.
• The Big Rotten Apple: Invoked; Alan's memories of his home in New York City have caused his sector of the Dark Place to mimic it — and given his less-than-cheerful disposition of being trapped there and him writing a horror story into reality, it's a vision of the city at its gloomiest, being full of rain, ambient neon-lighting, and signs and graffiti that seem to be actively mocking Alan.
• Bittersweet Ending: Alan realizes that Mr. Scratch will escape with him if he gets out of the Dark Place, and moreover, if he gets out, then Saga will be trapped where he was. Wanting neither of those things, he guides Saga into shooting him with the Bullet of Light, affixing him into a Stable Time Loop where he is trapped, but Saga and the world live on, and he discovers that Alice apparently killing herself was a deliberate lie devised by her after she re-entered the Dark Place, with Alice explaining that the only proper way out of it is "ascension"; Alan then excitedly exclaims that "It's not a loop, it's a spiral", implying that he may escape someday with enough minor variations in the loop. Additionally, the game never makes it clear if Logan is alive still. The last we see of Saga is her calling her daughter, but we get a Smash to Black before seeing whether Logan picks up or not.
• Bland-Name Product: Ahma beer is a reference to the real-life Finnish beer Karhu. Both beers are named after an animal in Finnish, and reference that animal in their branding- Karhu uses a bear, and Ahma uses a wolverine. Also seen is "Compton"-brand spray paint, which has a similar oval-shaped red logo with colored dots in a circle to the real-life American spray paint brand Krylon, and a knockoff version of a United States Postal Service Ground shipping label.
• Blasting It Out of Their Hands: When the Cult of the Tree comes after Wake at the Elderwood Lodge, one of the cultists corners him with a knife, preparing to bring it down. Saga shows up just in time to shoot it out of their hand, also knocking off their mask and revealing Ilmo Koskela.
• Blinded by the Light: A manuscript page Saga finds in Nightingale's body says that Taken aren't capable of seeing people in bright light, this soon becomes useful when Nightingale gets up and starts rampaging through the morgue, forcing Saga to use the lights to hide.
• Bloodier and Gorier: Fighting the Taken in the real world is a much more visceral experience now, with each bullet taking chunks out of them. Of course, it adds to the horror when they just keep coming even as their body is a bloody mess...
• Bloody Horror: Using the "Devil" plot point at scenes in the Oceanview Hotel causes them to be covered in blood and bodies, often spilling outside the usual confines of the scene.
• Bookends: The first and last thing Alan says in the game are the same line, "Back to the beginning." Given how he is cut off the second time, and the spiral nature of the game, it is all but said this is technically him literally travelling back to the beginning to restart the events of the game from his perspective.
  • Not to mention that the first shot we see of Alan is of him with a light spot on his forehead. The ending shows that this is where he was shot with the Bullet of Light by Saga.
• Bread, Eggs, Breaded Eggs: An ad read by Pat at the Bright Falls radio station gleefully announces that a local brand of beef jerky now comes in three new flavors: hickory smoked, teriyaki, and hickory teriyaki.
• Brick Joke: Saga immediately knows something's up when she hears about the Cult of the Tree, because, "What kind of cult calls themselves a cult?" When Ilmo's describing how he developed it as a way to keep people wary in the dark, he says he picked the name more for how it sounded scary than because it made any sort of sense. As he says, "What kind of cult calls themselves a cult?"
• Broken Bridge: There's literally one of these in Watery, swept away by flooding, necessitating Saga going around the long way to get to Coffee World. It gets repaired with wooden boards by the time she retrieves the Clicker, with Saga lampshading how fast they finished work.
• Call-Back:
  • Like in Alan Wake's DLC, Saga is trapped in the Dark Place and faced with a duplicate of herself who has completely given up hope and constantly chastising herself for her failures.
  • A few of the manuscript pages Saga can find are direct translations of the Hotline messages Jesse received from Wake back in Control.
• The Cameo: In the Oceanview Hotel, Dr. Casper Darling appears on some televisions, and subtitles indicate that Jesse Faden is trying to call out to Alan and Zane, possibly implying that she's experiencing the events of the AWE expansion at the time.
• Combo Platter Powers: The Dark Presence appears to be capable of mixing and matching Taken powers, including ones Mr. Scratch gave them in American Nightmare. One Gameplay video has Saga run into a Taken with a darkness shield, teleflanker and splitter powers all at once.
• Comical Coffee Cup: Saga has one that says "Not the Worst Mom". It was a present from Logan that she found Actually Pretty Funny, and now is a permanent fixture in her Mind Place. We never see her drink out of it though, presumably because the real one is all the way back in Virginia.
• Continue Your Mission, Dammit!: A subtle example occurs at the end of "We Sing": if you're slow to use the Writer's Board to end the song, Alan will keep repeating the line "Gotta figure it out, to bring this song to its end".
• Continuity Nod:
  • Alan takes to wearing a blue plaid jacket in the real world and posters are visible for Night Springs throughout the Dark Place. Both the outfit and show were featured prominently throughout Alan Wake's American Nightmare. Mr. Door likewise alludes to the events of American Nightmare, calling them a "nice distraction".
  • The small town of Watery neighboring Bright Falls is a major location in Saga's campaign; the town was mentioned as being nearby to Bright Falls in Episode 5 of the original game.
  • In Chapter 2, Saga can find a monitoring station run by the Federal Bureau of Control; the technician repairing it claims it's there to monitor volcanic activity in the area. Later in the chapter, she can find evidence of the FBC running their own experiments on Cauldron Lake, trying to exploit its apparent power to turn fiction into reality. A FBC contingent shows up in person to apprehend Wake later on, responding to the AWE with Agent Estevez as its lead agent, as the titular expansion's ending showed.
  • Ahti appears at several points in both the real world and the Dark Place, often providing helpful advice and guidance to Alan just like he did with Jesse. Alan even notes that Ahti is a friendly face, just like Jesse did.
    • After the musical sequence in Initiation 4, Ahti is shown cleaning the auditorium and humming along with the song. In Control, Ahti is shown to be an Old Gods of Asgard fan, but he gave away his Walkman to Jesse to help her through the Ashtray Maze. It may have been his first chance to hear them since.
  • Alan can find a book by Dr. Casper Darling in Mr. Door's dressing room. Said book is about the theory of many worlds, and Dylan Faden previously said that Mr. Door exists in all worlds.
  • The Clicker is referred to as an OOP (Object Of Power) in an email sent by the Koskela brothers, and as a potential OOP by some FBC documents that they had stolen.
  • The Oceanview Hotel is the same one from Control, just with a different layout; you can find every symbol from the motel, except the spiral that leads to the Dark Place, in the hotel, but none of them can be opened. Its address is 3 Cord St., referencing the need to pull a lightswitch cord three times to enter it.
  • The promotional standee of Alan holding "the Sudden Stop" which Barry lugged around throughout Chapter 4 of the first game shows up, safely among Rose's Stalker Shrine to Alan at the Valhalla Nursing Home. A nearly identical standee, featuring Alan's new appearance in the same pose, shows up in Scratch's world, holding a copy of Return.
  • Saga can find the journal of someone who has been having dreams of a specific dodecahedron-typed shape, and provides diagrams of their visions. Fans of Control will recognize this as the Hedron device, the device used by the FBC to contain and protect Polaris, Jesse Faden's protective paranatural ally.
  • Agent Estevez will note that FBC Headquarters has "gone dark," referring to the events of Control where the Oldest House had to be sealed to stop The Hiss getting out.
  • This House of Dreams, an ARG released at the same time as American Nightmare, had numerous pages of Tom Zane's poetry posted to it. Throughout the game, these poems are quoted both by the Filmmaker "Zane" in his final scene and by the lyrics of "Dark, Twisted, and Cruel".
  • Before Saga heads into the Wellness Center for the first time, Rose briefly drops her overly-sunny demeanor and ominously warns her to be careful. "You can hurt yourself in the dark." The exact same thing Cynthia Weaver said to Alan at the beginning of the first game before his first encounter with Barbara Jagger.
• Contrived Coincidence: Near the end of the game when Alan has been both removed from the Dark Place and had the Dark Presence excised out of him at the cost of Saga being pulled in to the Dark Place and Casey getting possessed in Alan's place, Agent Estevez gives Alan what she says are the only remaining weapons they have left so he can make his way back to Bright Falls. Those weapons just happen to be exactly the weapons Alan used inside the Dark Place, despite Saga's loadout being completely different. Probably justified if Alan wrote them specifically into the story so they'd be weapons he's used to using.
• Controllable Helplessness: You begin the game controlling a naked man who walks through the woods at night. The man in question already has a limp, and sprinting doesn't make him much faster. Plus, there's a Jump Scare or two taking place on his mind. He doesn't get far before the Cult of the Tree finds him, puts him on an altar, and cuts out his heart.
• Cosmic Retcon: It's heavily implied that Alan, Thomas Zane, and Scratch each made numerous changes to the history of Bright Falls, besides the obvious ones that Alan did involving Saga's backstory - Zane is now, and has definitely always been an auteur filmmaker, and one of the residents of Valhalla Nursing Home claims to have no memory of Zane's house before he moved into it.
• Crappy Carnival: Coffee World was in a state of severe disrepair before the Taken got to it. To start with, it's in the middle of a swamp prone to flooding, all of the bathrooms are out of order, most of the attractions are made out of poorly-painted plywood, and the park's mascot, Mocha the Moose, died of a caffeine overdose. That's not even getting into Ilmo Koskela's obsession with puzzles meaning that employees have to jump through hoops for something as simple as the safe combination. Saga can find notes from a visitor who was writing a very negative review — positive features of the carnival include a very reluctant acknowledgement that all the coffee-related puns in the park were "mildly amusing," the mascots were "trying their best" and the much-hyped coffee was OK. Two out of five stars.
• Crapsaccharine World: Near the end of the game Alan gets a preview of what the world will look like once Mr. Scratch's ending of the story comes true and the Dark Presence is set free: a bright, sunny, never-ending Deerfest celebration where everyone is a Loony Fan of Alan's work - or, depending on how you look at it, Scratch's - and wearing the cult's deer masks, which will gradually spread across the entire Earth unless Alan and Saga stop it. To say Alan is surprised by this, instead of what the Dark Place is to him, is an understatement.
  Alan: This is... not what I expected.
• Creator Cameo: Sam Lake appears both As Himself during the second and third Mr. Door talk show segments, and as the model for FBI Agent Alex Casey.
• Creepy Changing Painting: The signage equivalent: In the entrance to the Dark Place's subway system, a sign initially offers directions to the D-O-N-T lines to Sleep Street and Again Avenue, but when Alan uses the Angel Light to turn on the power, it instead directs to the S-T-O-P lines to Writing Boulevard and Wake Street.
• Critical Status Buff: The Mr. Drippy Charm increases the damage Saga does when her health is critical.
• Cult:
  • A major enemy group in Saga's campaign are members of the Cult of the Tree alluded to in Control, adorning themselves in antler-like branches and are related to the ritualistic murders that Agent Anderson is investigating. The Dark Presence certainly finds them useful, as Saga has to fight them as Taken. But "cult" is only part of their name. Far from being a religious group, they're closer to a sort of hardcore neighborhood watch, dedicated to keeping Taken away from Bright Falls; all of the people they murdered came out of Cauldron Lake and were at risk of becoming Taken.
  • Alan's campaign has the Cult of the Word in the stories he experiences in the Dark Place. They're much more hazy than the Cult of the Tree, serving more as a spooky antagonistic force for him to use as he tweaks plot points and scenes, and technically don't exist, not even in the Dark Place.
• Darker and Edgier: As fully admitted by Alan in the intro sequence, this isn't the ending or story he wanted, and he sincerely regrets the amount of hell his manuscript is going to put everyone through — the Dark Place's influence makes "monsters and victims", not heroes, and from the start, with Nightingale being murdered by the Cult of the Tree from the player's perspective, it's clear that for all of Alan's power over the Dark Place, he and Saga are actually in a more helpless and violent situation. This is specifically justified in-universe in a recording of Alan in the Dark Place. He notes that with the Dark Presence's power growing greater and greater, it is basically forcing his hand to make a darker and darker story to stay consistent with what it is pushing him to do. Alan describes it as an "arm's race", one he has to win soon or else the Dark Presence will be too powerful to stop.
• Darkness Equals Death: In the morgue fight scene, you have to stay in the lights to avoid being attacked. Wandering in the dark will let the enemy find you quicker.
• Difficulty Levels: The game released with three levels of difficulty (Story, Normal, and Hard) to choose from, with Nightmare mode being added as free downloadable content.
• Dirty Cop: :Thornton and Mulligan, two of Bright Falls's deputies, are part of the Cult of the Tree and imply that the only reason that Saga went easy on a black couple at the start of the game is because they're the 'same kind'. Granted, the Cult of the Tree is ultimately heroic in their intentions, but Thornton and Mulligan still covered up their Accidental Murder of an innocent woman.
  • The Dark Place versions of Thornton and Mulligan are NYPD officers who are so desperate to join the Cult of the Word that they eagerly help the Cult commit their crimes, including disposing of corpses for the Cult. The Cult is not particularly grateful, and kills the two cops after promising to finally induct them.
• Do Not Taunt Cthulhu: Jaakko Koskela ends up murdered by Mr. Scratch after the former insults the latter thinking it's Alan, for extra irony it later turns out he knew the Dark Presence exists but not that it has an avatar like Scratch.
• Don't Go Into the Woods: The Taken prowl the woods surrounding Bright Falls and Watery, but stay out of the towns themselves. This leads to many local rumors starting of monsters in the woods, made worse by fears of the Cult of the Tree stalking the woods at night as well. This turns out to be invoked by the Cult of the Tree; by making the woods seem as obviously dangerous as possible, they keep people away from the Dark Presence and the danger of the Taken, keeping them safe in a roundabout manner.
• Double-Meaning Title: One of Saga's chapters is "Local Girl". It's where she learns more about her role in Alan's story, including her supposed history in Watery, making her a local. But it also refers to when she reaches her trailer and finds a newspaper article with the title, "Tragedy in Watery: Local Girl Drowns".
• Dying Town:
  • Alan's manuscript describes the town of Watery as slowly dying out, as the lumber mill that served as its main economic driver closed down years ago, and the fishing yields from the nearby lake are starting to decline. Coffee World has managed to stave off total collapse, but Alan states it has merely delayed the inevitable.
  • Bright Falls isn't faring much better, with businesses failing left and right and the younger townspeople desperate to leave due to Bright Falls picking up a reputation as a "haunted town" thanks to a string of mysterious disappearances in 2010. A late-game article notes that the FBC sealing off Cauldron Lake utterly destroyed their tourism industry.
• Dynamic Entry: In the abandoned general store, Saga approaches a doorway leading to Nightingale's heart from the other room... only for an ax-bearing cultist to come crashing through the wall and attack Saga in the first proper combat encounter.
• Earn Your Happy Ending: The Final Draft's ultimate outcome: Logan is confirmed to survive, with her death reduced to nothing more than a bad dream. Alan also survives, the Bullet of Light having both banished Scratch from his head and allowing him to retain the memory of the prior loops. If Alan's ending monologue is any indication, Alan is more than ready to fight his way out of the Dark Place, with Saga and Casey at his side. Granted, it's not a happy ending yet, but with the way that Alan declares "it's not a loop, it's a spiral" with excitement in his voice, it seems that for as bad as things are, there's a chance they're going to get a victory.
• Eldritch Location:
  • The Dark Place as a whole, but the Oceanview Hotel especially; it loops Alan back out the front door when he tries to enter it, necessitating him going underground to the Mirror Peak bar... which spits him out on a rooftop that eventually leads him to a side entrance. Once you actually get inside, you frequently find hallways and rooms that connect together impossibly. The stairway to the second floor is boarded up, so you get further up by going through a bathroom that exists on both the first and second floors.
  • The Overlaps are exactly what they sound like: places where reality overlaps with the Dark Place. All of them are Unnaturally Looping Locations that Saga has to break through in order to fight a very powerful Taken. The Coffee World Overlap both loops unnaturally, and has multiple loops where Saga climbs down into a well and follows a flat underground tunnel to a door, which leads out to a lakeshore at ground level.
• Elemental Motifs: The Dark Presence has a strong connection to water.
  • In Saga's story, areas under the influence of the Dark Presence are flooded, and each of the first three bosses you fight have some connection to water; Agent Nightingale came out of Cauldron Lake, the Deputies dumped a body down an old well, and Cynthia Weaver was drowned in a bathtub. Clearing out the Overlaps cause the floods to recede and opens up new areas for exploration.
  • In Alan's story, he likens projecting himself into the Dark Place as being a 'deep-sea diver' (much like Thomas Zane, whose hotel room/studio is full of photographs of him in a diving suit like the one he had in the first Alan Wake), and in the Dark Place's version of New York, it's constantly raining. One of the major areas you can explore is the Oceanview Hotel, and there are plenty of signs for bars (or 'watering holes') in the Dark Place.
• Emergency Weapon: If Alan and Saga are desperate for some space in a fight, or even worse, plum out of bullets, their last hope beyond running to a Break Room is to use their melee attack. The resulting Pistol Whip is pathetically weak compared to any other weapon, and leaves them open to reprisal by the Taken, but never runs out and can be spammed fairly quickly.
• Epic Rocking: Granted, it sort of depends on how quickly you make your way through the section, but, in grand Remedy fashion, the game contains an incredibly elaborate musical number by Poets of the Fall as the Old Gods of Asgard, in the form of "Herald of Darkness", a song that manages to completely shift genres at times from hard metal to showtune. In-game, its length depends on how long you take to get through Alan Wake: The Musical, as Mr. Door puts it, which can take around twenty minutes. The version you get on the radio in the Writer's Room, however? Fourteen. Minutes. Long. A "complete edit" version was later released, which is over double the length at thirty minutes.
  • There is also a second musical number by the Old Gods which, like the original musical section from the original game, has Saga protecting them from the hordes of Taken while they attempt to summon Alan Wake back through the song "Dark Ocean Summoning". While not as long as "Herald of Darkness", "Dark Ocean Summoning" is still nearly seven minutes long.
• Equipment Upgrade: Once a weapon is discovered by Saga, a magazine for it is added to her Mind Place. With Manuscript fragments she can find in the hidden Alex Casey lunchboxes, she choose from three upgrades each for the weapons, which range from magazines holding more bullets to attacks growing stronger with consecutive hits. Each upgrade comes with a bit of narration from Alan, unique to every single upgrade, describing Saga spontaneously discovering that her weapon works better now, showing that the fragments are helping Alan help her.
• Escape Sequence: Three times throughout Initiation, Alan is forced to flee from his life from the unstoppable Dark Presence. The first two times are the climax of both the Caldera Station and Oceanview Hotel murder scenes, where it is a giant shrieking ball of Darkness, and finally in Scratch's distorted reality, where he chases Alan in Casey's body.
• Evil Old Folks: One of Saga's chapters sees her spending a lot of time in the Valhalla Nursing Home, where most of the residents are pleasant enough. But she has to descend into an Overlap to fight Cynthia Weaver, whose advanced age and overall exhaustion allowed the Dark Presence to capture her and turn her into a Taken.
• Evil Sounds Raspy: Throughout Alan's campaign, the raspy chanting of the cultists can be heard heralding the return of Alan's Doppelgänger, the second half of which quotes what Zane said about Scratch in his first appearance.
  Cultists: This is the ritual to lead you on... Your friends will meet him when you're gone!
• Exploding Barrels: Saga can find bright red propane tanks scattered throughout Bright Falls and Watery. As they are portable, she can pick them up, throw them at Taken hordes, and shoot it to blow up the whole group.
• False Memories: Most of the residents of Watery that Saga meets have memories of her living in their town, despite her never having set foot in it before the investigation, which she says is "the story affecting them". Saga can play along in order to get information out of them. This is a side effect of her being Immune to Fate; Mr. Scratch wants her to be a Tragic Hero returning to the site of her worst moment, but since Saga is an Anderson, she causes the story to bug out — she isn't even aware of her role, let alone remembers what the townsfolk do.
• Foreshadowing:
  • Saga can open a Cult cache with a note mentioning that members "M" and "T" have gone missing while on patrol. This clues the player in that Deputies Mulligan and Thornton are members of the Cult.
  • Some of the dolls you collect for the nursery rhymes resemble characters; the "Hero" doll resembles Saga, the "Child" her daughter Logan, and "Mother" seems to be Freya, Saga's mother. The "Father" doll, the last one you find, resembles Mr. Door, revealing that he's Saga's father.
  • "Herald of Darkness" practically spells out that Mr. Scratch is Alan. Besides mostly being about Alan in spite of its title, the chorus goes, "Show me the champion of light / I'll show you the Herald of Darkness." Also, if you don't head up the stairs straight away, when you finally get up there you'll notice that the Alan on the screen is wearing Mr. Scratch's signature Slasher Smile — but it quickly flickers back to his regular face once you get closer.
  • During Alice's videos, a lamp behind her frequently flickers like lights do when the Dark Presence is near, but nothing happens. Because as The Stinger reveals, she's already in the Dark Place.
  • Watching the entirety of Tom Zane's movie in the movie theater has the movie ending with the words "It's not a loop, it's a spiral." These words are echoed in the mid credit stinger by Alan himself.
  • The Old Gods of Asgard's presence on the "In Between With Mr. Door" talk show wouldn't make sense at first since they are not pulled into the Dark Presence like Tim Breaker and are not part of the story like Detective Alex Casey. It turns out Odin and Tor willingly enter the lake to rescue Saga and time works differently in the Dark Place.
  • The Alex Casey in the Dark Place believes that Scratch and Thomas Zane are simply aliases for Alan Wake to commit murders. Late in the game, it is revealed that Scratch and Alan are one and the same. In addition, Zane also greatly resembles Alan.
  • It's occasionally pointed out how strange it is for The Cult of The Tree to call themselves a cult. They're not really a cult. They wanted people to think there was a dangerous cult in the woods so that no one would go in there and run afoul of the real danger.
  • The combination to the safe in Coffee World is hidden in a puzzle similar to the ones that lock cult stashes because the two groups are run by the same person.
  • When Alan first wakes up in the talk show green room, he touches his forehead, as if he was expecting something to be there. The "something" turns out to be the bullet hole he receives courtesy of himself at the end of each loop.
  • After Alan washes up on the shore of Cauldron Lake, the alarms on the FBC monitoring station start constantly blaring. Sure enough, the FBC themselves show up later to investigate the problem and arrest Alan.
  • In the cutscene that concludes Initiation 6, Alan's attempt to alter the manuscript of Return is interrupted by Scratch barging into the Writer's Room and shooting him. Except Scratch Doesn't Like Guns; he said so himself in American Nightmare. Indeed, that wasn't Scratch, that was Alan himself from a later point in the spiral, who thought he was shooting Scratch. After doing so, he suddenly remembers being on the other side of that encounter and realizes he just screwed himself.
  • The Cult of the Tree uses the same light-sensitive paint to mark their stashes as Cynthia Weaver used to mark hers because they used to be the Torchbearers, who were either directly founded by her, or were merely inspired by her and followed her example. Their goals remain the same, they've just rebranded under Ilmo's leadership.
• Freeze-Frame Bonus: During Alan and Alex's second confrontation in the Dark Place, for a single moment as Alan shoots Alex, his face briefly flashes to the Slasher Smile of Scratch, confirming he was briefly possessed instead of instinctively pulling the trigger.
• Full-Frontal Assault: Nightingale's corpse is not wearing any clothes and he is completely uncensored^note Unless a specific nudity censor is toggled by the player. When this corpse is made into a Taken and attacks Saga, this fact remains true. Thankfully, by the time of his proper boss fight, he has distorted and bloated out enough nothing is visible.
• Game-Breaking Bug: It's possible to softlock at numerous points in Alan's segments when he rewrites reality; if you're playing on a lower-powered machine, not all of the scenery, models and geometry load in at once, so if you rush through an area without everything loading in, you could potentially find yourself stuck in an area that you can't escape from.
• Gameplay and Story Integration:
  • The map that Saga can access at any time is in her Mind Place, so essentially she memorizes any map she sees and is recalling it as needed. So whenever you control Alan in the real world, he is unable to access the map, as he never actually saw them. This is most relevant at the end of the game when he has to make his way from the shore of Cauldron Lake all the way back to Saga's car.
  • The Mind Place and Writer's Room are mental constructs for their users, so they don't pause time when you access them. Alan and Saga essentially get extreme tunnel vision and zone out, which leaves them vulnerable if enemies are nearby.
  • The entire conceit of the plot is that Alan is stuck in a loop, unable to resolve his story in a satisfactory manner and losing his memory of the loops so he does it again. The way to achive the best ending is to accomplish exactly that as the player - defeating the New Game Plus with the foreknowledge and equipment collected from one's first playthrough.
• Genre Savvy: The Dark Presence works this way. Alan's story works in a way of a horror genre, with all its tropes and clichés, and trying to write it any other way will not work the way the writers want. This is invoked by Alan and Saga in the ending. Since a horror story usually has no happy ending for the hero, one of them has to pay the ultimate price to ensure the others do get their happy ending.
• Golden Ending: Discussed and defied in the ending; Alan, having to write a new ending for "Return" in order to stop Mr. Scratch, struggles to try to write one where Everybody Lives. Once Saga pitches in, however, the author realizes that, as a horror story, the hero of "Return" must pay a price for everything that is saved; the more that is preserved, the greater the cost, and thus he forces a No Ending situation by having Saga shoot him, possessed by Mr. Scratch, with the Bullet of Light, separating her from the manuscript's story and thus bearing the burden of the "debt" himself. "The Final Draft" ultimately has this ending come to pass.
• Government Agency of Fiction: The Federal Bureau Of Control has a presence around Cauldron Lake, where they've set up a monitoring station and have cordoned off part of the area. They've also set up puzzles involving nursery rhymes and dolls that Saga can solve to get charms for her bracelet, in an attempt to exploit Cauldron Lake's ability to bring fiction to life. A squad of FBC personnel, led by Agent Estevez, shows up to try to contain both the Cult of the Tree and Alan in Return 4.
• Grid Inventory: The inventory used for consumables and weaponry works like this, with bigger weapons using up to four spaces on the grid. The Inventory Management Puzzle usually brought on by this is more simplified than most examples, as all weaponry must be stored horizontally and all supplies except the bigger guns and first aid kits only being a single inventory slot.
• Guardian of the Multiverse: Warlin Door... maybe. Control had Dylan Faden claim that Door was a being that knew about the multiverse and existed throughout it, and he seemingly saves Tim Breaker... by pulling him into the Dark Place. He also, in his own way, warns Alan about the existence of Initiation, and there seems to be no point to We Sing other than to try to pep Alan up. In their last meeting, Door also chastises Alan, warning that their next meeting would take place in "very different" circumstances, and that the author would do well to "play [his] part", or "stay out of [Door's] way".
• Guide Dang It!:
  • In the "Return 6: Scratch" segment Saga has to return power to the police station by finding a fuse. Many players get completely stuck trying to find the fuse because it's nowhere to be found, and will spend literally hours trying to search every nook and cranny of the station and outside, with no success. Turns out that in order to get the fuse you have to talk to Alex Casey several times, after which he gives you the fuse. Problem is that, for an inexplicable reason, you don't get the usual prompt to talk to him when you get close, as with most situations where an NPC has something to say, so there's no indication you can even talk to him, much less that you need to do it repeatedly until he gives you the fuse.
• Hell Hotel: One of the locations Alan visits in the Dark Place is the Oceanview Hotel where the cult is staging a play about a ritual murder, Alan will have to use the plot board to reenact the play to progress while dealing with the Taken.
• Help Yourself in the Future: Late in the Initiation campaign, Alan gets a phone call from himself an unknown amount of time in the future with some vital information. Playable Alan is incredulous he is serving as his own Deus ex Machina, but Future Alan hangs up before he can reveal anything else of use.
  Alan: I'm never getting out of here, am I?
  Alan: Yes, you are, and no, you're not. I'm sorry for what you'll have to go through.
• Heroic Sacrifice: Alan guides Saga into shooting him with the Bullet of Light in order to keep Mr. Scratch from escaping the Dark Place, which ensures Saga and the world can continue to exist as they are but affixes Alan himself to a Stable Time Loop, at least for the time being.
• History Repeats Itself:
  • It's implied that like Thomas Zane before him, Alan has used the power of the Dark Presence to try and escape by drawing someone to Bright Falls who can help.
  • This turns out to be the reason Mulligan and Thornton got turned into Taken, they committed an Accidental Murder and dumped the body down a well where a pair of local serial killers did the same, which the Dark Presence took advantage of.
• Hoist by His Own Petard: Dr. Campbell, who's organized the Nursery Rhyme puzzles in the game, tries to get Saga dragged into the dark place; he ends up getting consumed instead.
• Hold the Line: The climatic ritual at Cauldron Lake plays out like this. Saga needs to fight off the approaching Taken on the shore until Tor and Odin finish their song to return Wake to reality. Saga's allies will provide cover fire, ammo, and brief respite with flares as the fight goes on, while a convenient lightning strike will clean up any Taken when they try to switch targets to the Anderson Brothers.
• Imperfect Ritual: It's revealed that Nightingale's Ritual Murder was incomplete. He was meant to have the Clicker inserted into his chest after his heart was cut out, with the implication that the failure to do that allowed him to become Taken.
• Inspector Javert: The Dark Place Alex Casey (a distinct entity from the "real" one accompanying Saga) appears to play this role throughout Alan's campaign, with his own personal narration revealing he's more or less convinced Alan is behind the Cult of the Word.
• Insurmountable Waist-High Fence: Several of the barriers stopping Saga from progressing without the bolt cutters are fences that could be climbed over.
• Interface Spoiler: A somewhat common bug can cause a collectible icon for Alice's photos to appear on the talk show studio map as early as the very first time Alan visits the basement during the first chapter of his plotline, spoiling the involvement of an important character whose state isn't even known at that point. After that first time, the player doesn't even get to access that particular area or know that item exists until nearly the end of Alan's story.
• Intro-Only Point of View: In the prologue you briefly play as Robert Nightingale before he's ambushed by the Cult of the Tree and sacrificed.
• It Can Think: In the original Alan Wake, the Taken were essentially mindless puppets of the Dark Presence, spewing out random nonsense phrases; several of the Taken in this game seem to be able to retain their intelligence.
• Justified Save Point: Every proper save point in the game is located within special "Break Rooms" and have Alan or Saga stop for a cup of coffee.
• Kick Them While They Are Down: The conclusion of the Dark Ocean Summoning plays out like this. Saga is down for the count but has the Clicker and Wake safe... until Scratch, having possessed Casey, stomps her hand, takes the Clicker, beats her down and throws her into Cauldron Lake before making his getaway.
• Kitschy Local Commercial: One of the collectibles of Saga's campaign is the Koskela Bros. commercials for various businesses around Watery, they're all So Bad, It's Good.
• Leaning on the Fourth Wall: In "The Final Draft" DLC, Dr. Darling finds a frequency of Alan narrating the events that are happening to him and he points out that it sounds an awful lot like his own voice, a nod to the fact that the actor playing Dr. Darling (Matthew Porretta) is also Alan Wake's voice actor. While Darling is clearly excited by the discovery, he also looks concerned by the comparison. A later TV has Darling and Zane (played by Ilkka Villi, who provides Alan's appearance) meet each other; Darling says Zane looks familiar, while Zane says Darling sounds familiar.
• Legend Fades to Myth: Turns out that Barbara Jagger's tenure as the Dark Presence's avatar is more well-known to the people of Bright Falls than originally implied, as she's become an urban legend in the area as "the Witch with No Heart." This can be considered foreshadowing about the Cult of the Tree's intentions, as the board detailing this piece of folklore can be found not to far from the sight where Nightingale was ritualistically murdered.
• Life Drain: One of the upgrades for Saga's sawed-off shotgun allows her to regain health when she kills an enemy with it; the amount recovered is proportional to the strength of the enemy.
• Lightswitch Surprise: Exaggerated. Alan is guided to an old desk lamp known as the "Angel Light" that the Clicker (a supernaturally-charged light switch) originally came from. The lamp has the power to suck the light out of certain lightbulbs that are on and transfer it into certain lightbulbs that are off. The areas covered by these lightbulbs will often radically change depending on whether they are on or off. Surprise.
• Limited Wardrobe: Played for Laughs. Harold, one of the elderly residents of the Valhalla Nursing Home, is first encountered at the sauna in Watery, wearing nothing but a Modesty Towel. When you encounter him again later at the nursing home itself, he's still in nothing but a towel, adamantly refusing all demands to Please Put Some Clothes On, because he wanted to stay longer in the sauna and is pissed that they made him leave before he had his fill. He, as well as several nameless NPCs from the sauna, appear again during Scratch's eternal Deerfest, still wearing only towels without any explanation.
• Living Shadow: In addition to the standard Taken Alan must contend with, the Dark Place has also conjured living shadows as decoys. They look like a Taken with full darkness shields, only to dissipate into nothing when shining light on their shield, wasting Alan's limited battery power.
• Malevolent Masked Men: Anderson and Casey are summoned to Bright Falls to investigate a series of ritualistic murders being committed by a secretive cult, with part of their appearance include deer masks.
• Malicious Misnaming: The revived Nightingale still misnames Wake after other authors as a pejorative; his favorite one this time around seems to be 'Hemingway'.
• Meaningful Echo:
  • Unintentionally on his part, but Agent Casey accidentally quotes his counterpart from the Dark Place while in the same situation with Alan; both men in danger, Alan begging for a gun:
  Casey: No chance.
  • Alan ends up shooting both Tom Zane and an earlier version of himself directly in the forehead. In both cases, he is deceived. In the first instance, Tom merely wipes the blood away afterwards and reveals it was a staged scene, and in the latter Alan realizes too late that it was himself and not Scratch.
• Medium Blending: Live-action segments are overlaid atop standard game graphics, much like Control. Saga sees glimpses of live-action characters while profiling, Alan sees live-action silhouettes of Casey as he narrates, and all televisions show real actors across the game.
• Memory Palace: Both Alan and Saga have one of these where they can look over collectibles and information they gained during the game on a conspiracy board.
  • Saga's case board lets her process information gained during the case and connect it together, this will allow her to ask townsfolk new questions or do new actions to progress her story.
  • Alan's writing board lets him outright change reality in the dark place in small ways, by finding "echoes" of events in the dark place he gains inspiration to change things elsewhere; one gameplay video shows Alan needing to get through a crashed subway car and using a story thread about a fire on it, the subway car becomes a burnt out husk that he can get through.
• Mind Screw:
  • The original Alan Wake heavily emphasized that Thomas Zane was a poet who erased himself from reality, but when Zane appears in this game, he claims to be a director/actor, and the diver he appeared as in the previous game was a character he played in a film — a film which you can find a poster form in Suomi Hall in Watery, with Zane and Barbara Jagger as cast members, and it's said to be based on a novel written by Wake himself, despite Alan being born after the film was made.
  • There are several moments in the Dark Place where Alan needs to interact with TVs or projectors that show a video of him. The camera zooms in on the on-screen Alan, only for that Alan to suddenly be the actual Alan and gameplay replaced with live-action footage. And during "We Sing", the Alan singing in the video footage appears to be just as much the real deal as the gameplay Alan walking through the set.
  • Don't think too hard about how the events Alan writes about in the Dark Place segments relate to the real world. There's evidence to suggest that something very much like them may have happened with the real Alex Casey's investigation of a murder cult in New York, but it can't have happened entirely as written.
• Mirror Monster: One new monster is the Taken Diver, a unique Taken conjoined with its own water reflection horizontally, as if it was standing waist deep in water, giving it an upside down torso, head and arms where its legs should be with a water surface-like distortion in the middle, the creature can become invisible by having both halves "dive beneath" the water surface leaving only the water distortion as it moves around until it emerges.
• Mood Whiplash: When Alan meets Zane in the Oceanview Hotel, he's clearly put off by the... poet? Filmmaker? Entity that's confronting him. Then it cuts to a montage of them drinking and doing coke.
• More Diverse Sequel: In addition to having a black female deuteragonist, there are more female characters in the game overall, including female Taken, which were absent in the original game.
• Multiarmed And Dangerous: One of the Taken that Saga encounters in the Gameplay trailer is shown to have at least 5-6 arms with the lighting make them look like tentacles.
• Musical Episode: The Chapter "We Sing" is basically "Alan Wake, the Musical"
• Must Have Caffeine:
  • Casey and Saga are both seen drinking coffee frequently; coffee thermoses actually serve as save points in both reality, and in the Dark Place.
  • The Koskela brothers apparently loved coffee so much that they opened Coffee World, a theme park that Saga calls the Most Caffeinated Place on Earth.
• Mythology Gag:
  • In the first game, Alan's character Alex Casey was a Self-Parody of Remedy's own Max Payne, complete with a shared voice actor. This time around, a real version of Casey is revealed to be Anderson's FBI partner, and along with James McCaffrey again returning for the voice, Casey's appearance is directly modeled after Remedy's creative director Sam Lake, as Max's was in the first Max Payne, and Casey's outfit in his appearances within the Dark Place (which in II takes on the form of Max's old stomping grounds, New York City) is highly reminiscent of Max's iconic Hardboiled Detective ensemble. During his inner monologue, Casey also sports Payne's infamous smirk.
  • The number 665 (the "neighbor of the beast"), a reoccurring number in all Remedy games since the first Max Payne, shows up on a neon sign in the Anderson's waiting room and as an important room in the Oceanview Hotel.
  • Ahti from Control appears throughout the game to help both Alan in the Dark Place, and Saga in Bright Falls.
  • Mr. Door, first mentioned in Control has his own talkshow in the Dark Place. Mr. Door's name also recalls the equally mysterious Martin Hatch from Quantum Break.
  • Several of the posters in the Dark Place actually use direct quotes from the first game, see Subliminal Seduction below.
  • Near the end of the game Saga ends up in the Dark Place in a nightmarish version of her Memory Palace full of demoralizing messages and has to use the case board to snap out of it, similar to what happened to Jesse at the end of Control, as well as Alan himself in the original game's DLCs.
  • Tim Breaker, played by Shawn Ashmore, apparently has dreamed of alternate versions of himself; looking at his 'board of crazy' reveals that he encountered a 'red-haired woman' in one of the alternate realities, recalling Jack Joyce and Beth Wilder from Quantum Break. The character's name is even one letter off from "Time Breaker", a nod to Jack's time manipulation abilities. Additionally, when Tim Breaker disappears from the morgue prior to Nightingale's awakening, the percussion that plays is sourced from a synth patch that composer Petri Alanko created for Quantum Break.
  • In the Dark Place, Tim is always humming the same tune (which Alan recognizes as the theme to Night Springs), which is helpful in locating his safe rooms. When questioned about it, he says he can't get it out of his head, that it's a real Ear Worm (his words), and that he first heard it in a dream he had once. Not to mention that the Dark Place is kind of a dream dimension itself, or at least runs on dream logic. This calls back to the phrase "An ear worm is a tune you can't stop humming in a dream" from the Hiss Incantation.
  • En route to Cauldron Lake, the Anderson Brothers crash their van into several of the Taken. Ramming Taken with vehicles is a gameplay mechanic from the first game.
  • The street address for the Oceanview Hotel in the Dark Place is 3 Cord St. In Control, the way to enter/exit the Oceanview Motel was by pulling a light switch cord three times.
  • One of the more memorable Altered Items from Control is a haunted Rubber Duck which will follow Jesse around the Oldest House. An identical rubber duck appears at many points throughout Saga's campaign.
  • The New Game Plus mode changes the ending, confirming that Logan and Alan Wake survive the events of the game. In remedy's previous effort Max Payne 2, beating the game a second time on an unlocked difficulty level revealed an alternate ending where his doomed love interest Mona Sax survives. Unfortunately, that was made non-canon when the series shifted to Rockstar.
• Naked People Are Funny: Norman, one of the elderly at Valhalla Nursing Home, spends all his appearances in the game wearing nothing but a Modesty Towel, whether it is outside the sauna in Watery or in the living room of the nursing home, much to the disgust of fellow residents Mandy-May and Rose. Later, when the Dark Presence attacks the nursing home and the residents have to relocate to a brightly lit area on the porch, Norman is still in his towel. And even in Scratch's alternate Bright Falls, he's still in his towel.
• Narrative Backpedaling: Saga's Game Over screen has a message that reads "That's Not How The Story Goes", implying a variation of this. Similarly, Alan's screen shows him lying in a pool of blood before he's jolted back to the Writer's Room, takes a moment to collect himself, and starts writing again.
• New Game Plus: One known as "The Final Draft" was added to the game on December 11, 2023. It repeats the game from the beginning with all weapons, upgrades, and charms left unlocked for both campaigns. It also includes small narrative alterations from the base game, including new manuscript pages, additional videos in the Dark Place, and an expanded ending sequence.
• No Ending: Downplayed, in that this was an Invoked Trope on Alan's side. The game ends with none of its main plotlines being definitively resolved. It's unknown if Alan was able to successfully rewrite "Return" to have a Golden Ending for Saga and Alex and whether he was able to escape the Dark Place or not — entirely by design, as Alan realized the only ending that asserted enough control that allowed him to escape would take Saga's own agency from her and leave her trapped in the Dark Place and likely with her daughter dead; he very intentionally chose the ending that leaves him, and thus the player, out of her life. The New Game Plus mode (entitled "The Final Draft") removes all ambiguity, being far closer to the Golden Ending that Alan proposed in content and tone.
• No-Gear Level: Return 4 has a brief playable section where the player has no access to any gear they may have accumulated prior. The only supplies available for the entire (thankfully short) level are two flashlight batteries and four shotgun rounds, against enemies that will continually spawn if the end isn't reached in time, forcing the player to just flee most of the enemies. The goal of the section is to find Alex and help him despite the barrage of enemies, and the lack of gear underlines a feeling of desperation and the player character's deep-seated desire to do what's right, even at great risk to oneself.
• Nostalgia Level: While playing as Alan towards the endgame, he comes across a section in which he needs to make his way through the forest surrounding Cauldron Lake. This section, one of only two in which we play as him in the real world, uses musical cues (specifically "On the Run"), sounds, and other atmospheric tricks straight from the first game calling to mind large sections that saw Wake traipse through the forest around Bright Falls.
• Notice This:
  • In every Alan level you can find Sheriff Breaker hanging out in an isolated room, trying to piece together what's happening in the Dark Place — he and Alan can amicably chat and trade theories, and there's usually some helpful gear for Alan in the room. The sheriff's room is always marked with yellow police tape. There's usually some sort of additional exploration required to access the room, which is frequently locked or otherwise inaccessible. The path to access the room is also helpfully marked with the same police tape.
  • Chapter 4 of "Initiation" (the musical level) takes place on a gigantic TV studio set that's nearly pitch-black with the exception of gigantic glowing screens showing the actors singing and dancing. At several points throughout the level, yellow tape is used to mark out paths and arrows pointing the way through the level, and a few screens are dedicated to looping footage of the characters pointing and waving the player through the level.
• The Nothing After Death: Briefly alluded to by Alan, right before Saga shoots him with the Bullet of Light.
  I pray nothing comes after this. Nothing but sleep.
• Nothing Is Scarier: The basement of the Valhalla Nursing Home is dark, claustrophobic, flooded and has a dead body. The route through it is winding and creates lots of blind corners. It's the perfect spot for an ambush. It contains no enemies, just water and suspicious sounds.
  • At the hotel where Saga and Casey have set up their headquarters, if you walk down the hallway where their rooms are, you'll find a woman knocking on a door apparently trying to contact someone inside. Later on, after the Cult of the Tree assaults the hotel, if you go back to that hallways, you find the same woman banging on the same door, but this time she is extremely agitated and desperate to get in. You never find out why she is banging on that door.
• Number of the Beast: The actor who took the role of the Devil in the performance of The Cult at the Oceanview, implied to be Scratch, specifically requested to stay in room 666.
  Casey: The devil had a sense of humor, or he really didn't. It was funny either way.
• One Dialogue, Two Conversations: Whenever they briefly meet in the Overlaps, Alan and Saga try to communicate with each other as best they can, but the connection between the two is...shaky at best, causing much of what they say to each other to be unheard by the other, which leads to both of them believing the other is saying things that they aren't.
• One-Steve Limit: Subverted as Agent Saga Anderson shares the same last name as Odin and Tor, the brothers from the first game. Double Subverted as according to the townsfolk's (apparent) False Memories, Saga is a former resident of Watery who is related to the Anderson brothers, She dismisses this oddity as Alan's story messing with the townspeople's memories but due to how things in this universe work both possibilities could be equally true. And triple subverted; Saga is Tor's granddaughter through an ex-wife, though she really hasn't met anyone before; she's just Immune to Fate.
• Ooh, Me Accent's Slipping: British actress Melanie Liburd portrays the American Saga with an appropriate generic American accent, but it wavers sometimes, especially on the American rhotic "R" sound- she usually pronounces her own surname in a distinctly British way as "An-dah-son" rather than "An-der-son".
• Painfully Slow Projectile: One of the Dark Presence's new tricks is creating hovering balls of darkness that float toward a target and explode, luckily using your flashlight on them makes them fade without exploding.
• Painting the Medium: Attempting to put the newspaper clipping about Saga's daughter drowning up on her crime board results in her scribbling it out and denying it as a fact.
• Paradox Person: Downplayed, as time travel is not involved. Saga was written by Alan to be a Tragic Hero seeking restitution for her daughter's death after leaving Watery... except Saga was already established as a person in Night Spring's story due to her being actually Tor's granddaughter, so while everyone reacts to her as if she was her character (and she communes with Other Saga a couple times), Saga is completely unaffected, since Mr. Scratch is unable to retcon her actual past. This is part of why Alan is so desperate to get in contact with her, as this makes her The Unchosen One which the story can't trap into the narrative of how Mr. Scratch broke free.
• Personal Space Invader: Every standard Taken can grab Saga or Alan and begin attacking them. They either need to Press X to Not Die or use a flare to instantly force them back.
• Point of No Return: After Saga's return to the Sheriff Station, and making a plan to free Alan, talking to Estevez will have her ask if Saga is ready to head out. A notification will then warn that the player is entering the endgame and their exploration will be limited once they agree to continue, though as much time as needed is given for any side quests to be finished on the player's terms.
• The Power of Rock: Saga has the Old Gods of Asgard write a new song, "Dark Ocean Summoning", to exploit Cauldron Lake's power and rescue Alan from the Dark Place.
• Pronoun Trouble: Mocha the Moose is referred to with female pronouns in the Coffee World commercial, but male pronouns in some of the documents you find there. Possibly because Ilmo's first language is Finnish, which only has one gender-neutral pronoun, resulting in him mixing the two English ones up occasionally, or more likely, because the original Mocha died of a heart attack after consuming too much coffee, so Ilmo had to hastily replace him with another moose before the kids started asking why his "vacation" was taking so long, and he could only get a female one on such short notice. The commercial was most likely filmed after this, since Ilmo briefly breaks character to insist that customers stop feeding the park's goats coffee, presumably so the same thing doesn't happen to them.
• Psychic Powers: Saga, in her Memory Palace, seems to have some form of clairvoyance or telepathy; she asks a question about a person she's profiling, and she hears their voices answer. This comes from her grandpa, Tor Anderson.
• Psychological Horror: After dabbling with the genre in the previous, more Action Horror-oriented entry, this sequel fully embraces it. Alan's opening mission, for example, has a surreal scene where a talk show host brings Alan on to discuss his latest book... about a fictional author named Alan Wake trying to find the pages of a book he doesn't remember writing, in a clear attempt by the Dark Presence to play on Alan's crumbling psyche.
• Race Lift: In the "Return" Easter Egg in Quantum Break, Saga Anderson was played by a Caucasian actress. She has been reimagined here as a woman of colour.
• "Ray of Hope" Ending: By the end of the game, Alan still hasn't escaped the Dark Place, and is even denied death by the bullet of light he has Saga shoot him with, waking up in the writer's room once again. However, upon waking, he has a revelation: it's not a loop, it's a spiral, implying that each loop is not in vain. This combined with Alice's final video imply that Alan will be able to eventually escape the Dark place through "ascension" not "destruction" as he's repeatedly tried.
• Recurring Traveller: Tim Breaker takes this role in the Dark Place. Alan can always find him one step ahead in small safe zones. He exchanges information with Alan about his independent endeavors to find Mr. Door, and has a map nearby with the general location of collectibles marked down for Alan.
• Red Herring:
  • The Cult of the Tree for most of the game are played up as a sinister religious cult that appears to be trying to summon the Dark Presence. However, as Saga investigates them further, it's revealed that the Cult is more like a loosely organized gang of locals who are actually trying to prevent the Dark Presence's return. However, their varying levels of competence and limited understanding of what they're actually dealing with means their efforts are ineffectual at best, actively detrimental at worst.
• Religion of Evil: The Cult of the Tree, a group of deer mask-wearing maniacs who are behind the murders Saga is investigating, worshiping the Dark Place and Taken to some degree. Downplayed, however, in that they are enemies of the Dark Presence. They're are still murderers, but ultimately a self-limiting threat of Knight Templars than the primary threat as they restrict themselves to people who escape from Cauldron lake, aka people already "infected" by the Dark Presence and ripe targets to become Taken. In fact, it's because they were unable to finish their murder ritual on Nightingale that he came back to life as a Taken.
• Retirony: Saga references this trope when joking around with Casey about the Bright Falls murders potentially being his last case. Despite being put into life-threatening danger on several occasions, Alex makes it through the game alive.
• The Reveal:
  • Return 1: Invitation — Agent Nightingale was discharged by the FBI long before arriving at Bright Falls.
  • Return 3: Local Girl — Thornton & Mulligan are members of the Cult of the Tree.
  • Return 4: No Chance — Ilmo and Jakko are members of the Cult of the Tree. And the cult wants to kill Alan.
  • Return 5: Old Gods:
    • Tor and Odin are Saga’s maternal grandfather and great-uncle. And her Mind Place is really a form of Telepathy that all Anderson are blessed with.
    • Rose was the one who delivered the Angel Lamp to Alan; as well as left the Alex Casey lunchboxes and knitwork for Saga with Mandy May’s help.
  • Return 7: Summoning:
    • The Cult of the Tree isn't a cult at all. It was organized by the Koskela brothers to eliminate Taken and try to undo what Alan or Scratch started. They killed Agent Nightingale because they mistook him for a Taken.
    • The Clicker is an Object Of Power as categorized by the Federal Bureau of Control.
    • The Summoning Ritual was successful, however, Alan wasn’t summoned at the present time and place; instead, Alan was summoned to the point of time he emerged at the end of Return 2 - The Heart.
• Rewriting Reality:
  • A key gameplay mechanic on Alan's side is using "plot threads" gleaned from learning more about the events of the game to alter the Dark Place in accordance with Alan's story in order to make progress. Unfortunately, since Alan's writing a horror story, the things it creates aren't exactly pleasant. For example, halfway through Caldera Station, a plot thread creates a way through a blocked subway tunnel by turning the crashed train into a burnt-out husk filled with charred corpses.
  • Both Saga and Alan's various upgrades are the result of Alan doing this; in the case of Saga, manuscript fragments have to be found and assembled to upgrade her weapons, and you get a short cutscene of Alan narrating the change he's made to her weapons. In the Dark Place, Alan finds "Words of Power" that he can use to increase his damage, survivability, and inventory.
• Ruder and Cruder: Downplayed, but the normally reserved Alan dropping F-bombs at danger is certainly new for him. The game's Mature rating means almost every major character drops at least one Precision F-Strike at some point.
• Running Gag: Thrice throughout the game, a small visual gag will occur with Agents Anderson and Casey where they both take perfectly synchronized sips of their coffee.
• Savage Wolf: One of the new enemies encountered by Saga in the forest are Taken Wolves.
• Sequel Escalation: In the first game, a major set piece was the battle at the Anderson farm. Alan fought Taken on a stage while music and lights blared all around him. This game features two comparable sequences, one for each campaign. The entirety of "We Sing" in Initiation is a full musical recap of the first game with puzzles, fights, and a live-action dance climax. Later on in "Summoning", the climax of Return, Saga fights off waves of Taken while the Old Gods rock out to their latest hit on the edge of Cauldron Lake.
  • In the original game, Taken could only come out at night when it's completely dark. In 2, perhaps showing how much more powerful the Dark Presence has become in the intervening years, Taken are out and about even at twilight when the sun is still out but low in the sky. Indeed, most of Saga's gameplay segments take place in the evening rather than outright at night. Taken to it's logical conclusion at the end when the Dark Place begins to spread out into the world at large. The eternal Deerfest happens during mid day with the sun completely out. This in no way impacts the Dark Presence's hold on the majority of Bright Falls' citizens.
• Scatterbrained Senior:
  • A subplot in this game involves Pat Maine, the radio announcer from the first game, slowly going senile over the radio broadcasts; he claims that one of the murder victims that Saga and Casey are investigating, Wendy Davis, is alive and has set up a beef jerky business, which draws confusion from most of the townsfolk, and ire from Wendy's widowed husband.
  • Odin and Tor are shown to be even more detached from reality than before, as they are getting older and less capable of resisting the Dark Presence's influence on them.
  • It's partly the reason why Cynthia Weaver became a Taken, as she was getting too tired and one of her lapses had her forgetting to replace the lightbulb of her lantern, allowing the Dark Presence to drown her in her bathtub.
• Scenery Dissonance: Unlike in previous installments, Taken can appear in broad daylight.
• Sean Connery Is About to Shoot You: One of the billboards in the Dark Place shows Alex Casey looking down the barrel of his revolver, which is pointed at the audience.
• Sequel Hook: Alan willingly lets himself be shot to pay the price needed to allow Saga and Casey escape the Dark Place, dropping back into the loop he's spent ages trapped in. Then one last video from Alice reveals that she returned to the Dark Place and set up her exhibitions to slowly nudge Alan out of the loop permanently... and based on some of the changes, it seems to be working. Alan realizes, "It's not a loop. It's a spiral."
  • Beyond that, there's no specific indication that Saga and Casey actually got out of the Dark Place, they are still in Alan's writing room when the credits start. Also, Tor and Odin followed Saga into the Dark Place to try to help her, but they are not seen before the ending. ALSO, there is the matter of Mr. Door; aside from the heavy implication that he is Saga's father, Saga profiles Mr. Door near the end, but notes that anything she comes up with right now is irrelevant and she'll have to come back to him later.
  • If one meets the right conditions, they can find the normally unflappable Ahti tense and afraid of... something else coming.
• Sequel Non-Entity:
  • Sarah Breaker apparently went on to join the FBI in between games, hence why she's not present in the sequel.
  • Barry Wheeler, Alan's agent and best friend from the first game, is completely absent here. A plaque in the Valhalla Nursing Home corroborates with Control in the fact that he set it up for the Old Gods of Asgard and emails in Parliament Tower indicate he's kept in touch with Alice, but he's not acknowledged beyond that.
• Serial Escalation: While in the first game, Taken could only appear during the dead of night, by the time of 2, the Dark Presence's power has apparently grown enough that Taken are capable of manifesting at dusk as well where the sun casts a red haze across the country.
• Seriously Scruffy: Alan starts out in the Initiation chapters looking very well-groomed. While he stays this way in the Writer's Room, his hair and demeanor grow more and more frazzled traveling throughout New York City.
• "Shaggy Dog" Story: Partway through Initiation, Alan finds the script for Return in the "real" writer's room only to realize that it has been completely written by Mr. Scratch and if left unchecked would lead to the Dark Presence escaping. As he is unable to just throw it out, Alan begins to edit the story to create a version with a better ending than what the Dark Presence has in mind, but before he can finish, Mr. Scratch breaks into the room and shoots him in the head. Alan spends much of the rest of the story attempting to get back to that room to stop Mr. Scratch from undoing his edits. When he finally reaches his apartment, he sees a film that reveals that Alice killed herself after over a decade of being tormented by Mr. Scratch. In anger, he manages to break into the Writer's Room and shoots Mr. Scratch in the head, only to realize that he had really shot himself in the head, creating a Stable Time Loop of sorts moments before the Dark Presence showed up to possess him, making all his efforts seemingly pointless. However, this is subverted post credits when we see that Alice only faked her suicide as part of a plan with the Federal Bureau of Control to ultimately help Alan finally escape the Dark Place with zero strings attached. As the whole experience makes Alan realize, it's not a loop, it's a spiral.
• Shout-Out:
  • One of the subway signs in New York repurposes the "are you sure the only you is you?" message from the P.T. demo as an anti-identity theft slogan.
  • One of the clips of Nightless Night has a similar color scheme to Panos Cosmatos' movie Mandy.
• Show Within a Show: Several different forms of in-universe media are given attention throughout the game.
  • The second and last film of the imposter Thomas Zane, "Nightless Night" can be watched in full in his theatre.
  • Night Springs returns from the first game with a reboot on the way, like its direct inspiration, and posters and ads by Mr. Door advertise this throughout the Dark Place. The Andersons also mention enjoying watching it together.
  • A documentary by Alice Wake about her journey following Alan's disappearance, titled "The Dark Place", is found in pieces by Alan whenever he visits Parliament Tower.
• Shows Damage: At critically low health, both Alan and Saga will begin to move in a much more labored fashion, while the screen turns a shade of red.
• Significant Double Casting: A meta-example. The game heavily implies that a lot of Alan's ideas for characters are taken from psychic visions he has about existing people. This is most obvious with Alex Casey, as there is the real Casey, a gruff but ultimately affable FBI agent and the fictional Casey, a grizzled and bitter detective who Alan wrote multiple stories about. But as Alan creates stories to move around the Dark Place, he seems to use his psychic powers to create characters using various people in Bright Falls as initial guidelines. Specifically, he uses Tammy who in both real life and the Dark Place is a true crime author, her husband Ed who is an experimental theater director in both versions of himself, Mulligan and Thorton, who are both corrupt cops who want to be part of a cult, and Ilmo, who is a cultist in both reality and Alan's story (though the real life "cult" wasn't really a cult).
• Single-Use Shield: The Coffee Charms Saga can put on her bracelet, which saves her from a fatal blow but breaks afterward. They are the most common reward for the various Nursery Rhymes scattered around Bright Falls.
• Sir Swears-a-Lot: Alan drops almost a dozen F-bombs when you first play him, particularly when the Dark Presence makes itself known.
• Snuff Film:
  • Nightless Night is claimed to be a snuff film, with Casey noting that the ritualistic murder in the film might actually be a real murder.
  • The end of Alice's documentary about her experiences photographing Scratch is a final speech where she says despite everything she's tried, she can't go on and a short burst of photos showing her stepping off a cliff. Subverted later on, when she reveals it was all a ploy to fool Scratch while keeping to his story and she really jumped back into Cauldron Lake to come back and help Alan escape.
• Stable Time Loop: Alan crawls onto the shore of Cauldron Lake, unknowingly carrying Mr. Scratch. In his quest for the Clicker, Scratch takes over Alan. Saga thinks Alan was Scratch all along and only Scratch. She enlists the Old Gods of Asgard to write a new song for a ritual to summon the real Alan back. The ritual works, but due to the time-bending nature of the Dark Place, it leads to Alan escaping before it was even performed. Alan crawls onto the shore of Cauldron Lake, unknowingly carrying Mr. Scratch...
• The Stinger: Halfway through the credits, a final scene plays. In it, a final message from Alice plays, where she reveals her exhibit and eventual "suicide" were all a trick to play along with Scratch's story and enter the Dark Place. She mentions they've been through the events of the game several times, but she is hopeful Alan is learning how to break the loop with everything he's learned. Cue him springing back to life in the Writer's Room, exclaiming "It's not a loop... it's a spiral".
• Stalker Shrine: In Rose's office in the Valhalla Nursing Home, a collection of pictures, books, interviews, and her cutout of Alan are gathered around a shelf. It shows her obsession with Alan is as strong as ever.
• Story Difficulty Setting: The easiest difficulty mode is called "Story" and its description says it focuses on the mystery.
• String Theory: The murder board in Saga's "mind place" takes this form. Alan has his own plot board, but it doesn't involve any string.
• Stylistic Suck: On top of the Bad "Bad Acting" in the Ahma Beer commercials, the brothers are also obviously poorly greenscreened onto backgrounds with clashing graphical fidelity and a green haze at the edges.
• Subliminal Seduction:
  • Throughout the Dark Place almost every bit of signage and readable text in some way subtly disparages Wake from writing or make a reference to one of the other denizens of the Dark Place (Scratch and Thomas Zane). Notably, a set of posters nominally advertising bus passes bluntly says "It's not like your stories are any good", which is actually quoting the Hitchhiker Taken from the prologue of the first game. Other signs quote Alan's internal monologues or the manuscript pages from the first game and American Nightmare.
  • It wouldn't be a Remedy game without some backmasked messages hidden in songs:
    • Take Control gave us the origin for the Cult of the Tree's logo years ago, a drunken doodle on a stolen FBC document resulting in a "spruce tree" made up of two triangles stacked one upon the other, which you can find in their base. Curiously, the Cult of the Word uses the same triangles, but inverted and side by side — like an eclectic W, for Word (or Wake?).
      "In their drunken fever state, seeing double, profoundly. The pyramid in the stolen file becomes a spruce tree."
    • Anger's Remorse has two versions in the game, one without backmasking (chapter end, it is also the one in the official Youtube video which seems to address Saga) and one with, addressed more to Freya. It thus features a different second and third verse even as the subtitles go with the official version.
      "I've been forever sinking..."
• Sudden Sequel Death Syndrome:
  • One of the murder victims of the investigation that FBI agents Saga Anderson and Alex Casey are involved in was Special Agent Robert Nightingale, who was implied to have become the new avatar for the Dark Presence at the end of the original game.
  • Cynthia Weaver becomes a Taken after the Dark Presence drowns her in the bathtub at the Valhalla Nursing Home.
• Surprisingly Realistic Outcome:
  • In the endgame, a small moment of levity is given amid the insanity when, right before the ritual at Cauldron Lake, Odin screws up the opening riff to "Dark Ocean Summoning" and has to start over. While he has been a professional rocker for over 50 years, he is out of practice, extremely elderly, and about to play a song he wrote half an hour ago for the first time. The fact neither of the Andersons screw up again is remarkable itself.
  • Cult stashes are sometimes locked behind math puzzles that have to be solved with algebraic systems of equations. The notes you find in them indicate the cultists are extremely annoyed at being forced to Solve the Soup Cans to access their gear.
• Survival Horror: Unlike the first game, resources are extremely limited, especially since batteries no longer magically recharge.
• Switching P.O.V.: Bizarrely, when he is speaking to Casey in the Dark Place, Alan's usual narration is spontaneously replaced by Casey giving a Private Eye Monologue until the scene ends.
• Telepathy:
  • Alan can apparently hear Alex Casey's internal monologue upon meeting him as seen here.
  • Saga has a limited form of this, being able to hear people's thoughts when she profiles them. This is revealed to be actual telepathy she inherited from her grandfather Tor.
• They Killed Kenny Again: The Alex Casey in the Dark Place is killed at the end of each of his own appearances, but always continues to show up alive and well later.
• This Is My Name on Foreign: The "Yötön Yö" short film was supposedly based on a novel by "Veikko Alén", who is also a character in the film played by Thomas Seine. The in-game closed captions also name "Veikko" as "Alan", confirming beyond the name similarity that this is intended to be some version of Alan Wake who swapped his given name and surname, and then Anglicized it (or maybe the other way around). Even more curiously, as a Finnish given name, "Veikko" means "brother" and was traditionally given to the second son, further fuelling the notion that "Veikko" is perhaps a copy of or otherwise connected to Alan in some way. Beyond that, this connection has thus far not been elaborated on.
• Timey-Wimey Ball: The concept of time is completely meaningless in the Dark Place, meaning seemingly paradoxical situations can occur. It also doesn't help that Alan is currently trapped in a Stable Time Loop.
  • For example, near the end of the game when Saga attempts to create a ritual to summon Alan from the Dark Place, it seemingly fails. However, Saga comes to the realization that the ritual did succeed, but not in the present. Instead, the ritual summoned Alan from the Dark Place several days prior, when Saga first discovered him washed up on the shore of Cauldron Lake...and this also leads Saga to realize that Mr. Scratch wasn't pretending to be Alan, he is Alan; or rather, that as long as Alan exists, Scratch, who is a version of him serving as a vessel for the Dark Presence, can just directly possess him in the real world.
  • On top of this, Alan and Saga experience their "conversations" in the overlap in different orders from each other. Specifically, they experience their second and third conversations in opposite order from each other, Alan's second conversation with Saga is Saga's third conversation with Alan and vice versa.
  • Also, it's implied that the Odin and Tor Alan witnesses playing a concert for him while he is trapped in the Dark Place are the real Odin and Tor after they drove their van into the Dark Place near the end of the game.
• Trailers Always Lie: Downplayed. One early bit of gameplay footage has Saga ambushed by a Giant Mook at the ruined general store looking for Nightingale's heart. In the game proper she's instead startled by a deer... and then the giant shows up. Thus, the scene happened, but slightly longer than it did in the trailer.
• Trespassing Hero:
  • With a screwdriver and later bolt cutters, Saga can break into several locked houses and lots throughout Bright Falls and Watery. She notes it isn't even near proper procedure, but feels the situation warrants it.
  • More mundanely, she can walk into any of the occupied rooms in the Valhalla Nursing Home and loot everything in them to her heart's content. One residents, Donna, even calls her out on it, but only on how rude it is to come in without even knocking.
• Uncertain Doom: You find a manuscript page in the Bookers' hotel room stating that Ed Booker went back to the lake the day after their encounter with the Cult of the Tree only get get captured by mysterious people. Your first assumption would be that the Cult of the Tree got him, and that's the last reference to him in the game so it leaves his fate as seemingly pretty bleak. Except it is revealed the Cult of the Tree only kill Taken who have risen from Cauldron Lake, so Ed would be safe from them. It's possible the Federal Bureau of Control captured him, but given that we later learn their entire local installation got taken out by the Dark Presence aside from a few members (most of whom die during the events at the police station), it all leaves Ed's fate up in the air, but not looking great.
• Unnaturally Looping Location: Whenever she's in an Overlap, Saga keeps pressing forward only to wind up back at the start of the location until she encounters the Taken within it. There is also a similar looping location that Alan has to deal with when in the Poet's Cinema.
• Vanity License Plate: License plates on the cars in the Dark Place are things like "DIEH3RE", "CULT-WRD", and "DNT-WRTE".
• Waking Up at the Morgue: One of the first clues Saga and Casey find that something supernatural is going on is them doing an autopsy of Nightingale only for the lights to go out and him getting up and busting his way out of the morgue.
• Wham Episode:
  • Return 5 — Old Gods:
    • The Anderson brothers are Saga's grandfather and great-uncle.
    • The Reality Warper properties of the Dark Place modify Logan’s existence to be dead via drowning.
    • Saga's Mind Place is Telepathy that is innate within the Anderson bloodline — allowing her to see the original version of the "story", past all its revisions.
    • Blum is a member of the Cult of the Tree.
    • Rose has had an active role in the battle against the Dark Presence.
    • Overlaps are created via a piece of art, music, or literature and infused with the user’s passion.
    • Cynthia Weaver suffers a Despair Event Horizon and transforms into a Taken.
  • Everything from Initiation 5 — Room 665 to Initiation 9 — Gone:
    • Alan is still trapped in the Dark Place despite his emergence in Return 2. Many of his interactions with Saga in the Overlaps occurred in nonlinear sequence.
    • Thomas Zane/Seine is a sort of counterpart to Alan himself; with the strong indication that Alan is a creation of Thomas’s. And they wrote the manuscript of the whole Return narrative while on a drug binge.
    • Mr. Scratch stole the Return manuscript and modified it, hoping to organize a way to gain the Clicker and reshape the world. Alan has been combatting against Scratch’s revisions with his own edit’s and modifications before he is killed by Mr. Scratch in the Dark Writer’s room, resetting a loop where he wakes up in the TV studio’s green room.
    • Mr. Door has personal beef with Alan regarding the latter’s constant looping and revising of Return’s manuscript; as it disrupts Mr. Doors affairs and agendas.
    • Mr. Scratch and Alan are one and the same. The former is just Alan under the influence of the Dark Presence with his insecurities and fears being accentuated. It wasn’t Scratch who killed Alan before the loops restarted; it was Alan himself. In between Alan’s deaths and the loops’ beginnings, Scratch/Dark Presence would use Alan as a vessel.
    • The first three chapters of Initiation already introduced a share of Mind Screw, metatextual weirdness, but the buildup to and showing of the 15-minute short film Yötön Yö (Nightless Nights) amps it up even further.
    • Alice’s encounters with Mr. Scratch/Alan took such a toll on her that she (allegedly) committed suicide.
• Wham Line:
  • In the Dark Place trailer, "It's my fault he got out!" This, and Saga's following line about Alan's double, confirms that Mr. Scratch is once again out and about as an active threat to Alan after American Nightmare.
  • At the beginning of Initiation 7: Masks, during the exchange between Alan and Mr. Door.
    Alan Wake: I need to get to [Alice]. She’s in danger.
    Mr. Door: She is. Because of you. And so is someone important to me. Someone you pulled into this.
  • From Alice Wake, the character we assumed had a Bus Crash between games:
    Alice: After the haunting got started, I got in touch with an organization that was still looking into what happened in Bright Falls [...] After I got home, I could suddenly remember everything.
    Alice: I chose to come back to the Dark Place. That is why I put on this exhibition. I had to mislead you, so that I could get you where you needed to be.
  • The final line of the game spoken by Alan.
    Alan: It's not a loop. It's a spiral.
• Wham Shot:
  • In "Return 3: Local Girl", Saga finds a trailer in her name. In a bedroom that looks like it's meant for her daughter, she finds an article about her daughter drowning at the age of nine, causing her to seriously question her sanity.
  • While looking for the Clicker, Saga finds Odin bedridden from a hangover and in no shape to talk. She decides to profile him. Odin starts talking to her directly, then the scene shifts so that Odin is sitting in the chair. Odin soon reveals that all Andersons, Saga included, have some form of psychic power.
• What Happened to the Mouse?:
  • After their second trip to Cauldron Lake, Saga and Casey call the FBI for backup for the case, feeling (given the blatantly supernatural elements of it) that it will likely need more than 2 agents to handle. FBI back up never arrives or is even referred to after that conversation.
  • By the end of the game, Tim Breaker remains trapped in the Dark Place as he continues his search for Warlin Door.
  • Odin and Tor dive into the Dark Place to help Saga, but aren't seen again afterwards. "The Final Draft" has them show up in New York near Tim to talk with Saga, having joined up with Door in the Dark Place but promising they will be seeing and helping out Saga again.
  • Tammy and Ed are interviewed by Saga early on and never appear again in person, though they are seen in echoes by Alan during the train station and hotel portions. A manuscript page implies Ed was attacked at Cauldron Lake after an argument with Tammy, but this is never followed up on. The only thing we know is that they were using lights so they were not Taken, but whether they were the Cult of the Tree or perhaps the FBC or even something else is never clarified.
• You All Look Familiar: While Taken are far more varied in appearance in this game compared to the first, there are still only about a dozen different facial models. Seeing doubles throughout Saga's campaign is not uncommon, even without the presence of Splitters.

---

"Aaaand cut! Now that is drama."

"It's not a loop. It's a spiral!"

"And so I return. I bear with me the torch of knowledge — the light. The miracle illuminated. The master of two worlds. No. The master of MANY worlds."

---