These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Fallout 3
Accidental Aesop: By using the GECK to reactivate Project Purity instead of using it to terraform the region as in Fallout 2, "It's better to work hard to change things over time than to change them entirely at once."
Alternative Character Interpretation: There's a mod that can make your player into a child. With this installed Moira's upbeat perky attitude that's so amusing and bizarre comes off as her talking to the player like he's actually a child. Compared to other NPCs who cuss and scream and try to kill this kid, she almost seems to become the mother figure they never had. Considering the fact that they share the same VA one has to wonder. And then when you consider her quest theme in that light, and she's suddenly a magnitude more crazy. Ask a 12-year old to get beaten up within an inch of its life, would you? Crawl into monster lairs, get irradiated, walk a minefield. Hell of a mother figure. The moment you're done giving her what she needs for her book she tosses the kid aside. And even with that she's still a hell of a lot more maternal than most people in the wasteland.
The appearance of Mr.Burke in the Lone Wanderer's drug induced hallucination can be taken to mean a variety of things depending the on the player's actions, specifically whether you destroyed Megaton or not.
Autumn, despite being the Final Boss, can be killed with one clean critical to the head, and the two bodyguards nearby are just the same Enclave troopers you've been gunning down all game.
You can convince President Eden to kill himself with just two lines of dialogue. The argument you make isn't even particularly impressive, either.
Sibley has only slightly more health than a normal Power Armor wearing minigun wielding mook. The only real problem in fighting him is that he's supported by a squad of elite mooks.
Eulogy Jones and the other slaver bosses have the same health as any other mook.
Ashur has excellent armor, but isn't that much tougher than a normal Mook. Ironically he can't survive as much damage as his unarmored rival Wernher, due to the later having Companion-level health.
Author's Saving Throw: The new ending for Fallout 3, provided by DLC for the widely unpopular ending.
Some of the random encounters might fall under this, but they are, by nature, a bit out-of-the-blue.
Broken Aesop: The Pitt DLC was touted for its Gray and Gray Morality, presenting a scenario where neither side was necessarily in the right and the player would have to make a difficult choice with no obviously "correct" outcome. The problem is, while neither Wernher nor Ashur are saints, Ashur comes off as a Well-Intentioned Extremist at worst, while Wernher turns out to be a psychopathic, scheming megalomaniac who would bring nothing but grief if he was put into power. As a result, the DLC's "difficult choice" ultimately comes off as just another good-evil scenario where it takes a bit more effort to learn which is which.
Not entirely, though. Wernher's still very concerned for the people of the Pitt and liberating them, even if he wanted to use the Cure for personal profit.
Ashur seems to have a large amount of Misaimed Fandom. He is fairly eloquent, but he is an extremely violent, brutal dictator that is pretty much supporting the majority of slavers along the east coast. His excuse was that he was stuck there because the Brotherhood of Steel abandoned him is flawed when you factor in that his followers could easily have reconnected with the Brotherhood of Steel. In fact, subjugating the entire area around the Pitt, repairing the steel mill, and abducting wave upon wave of slaves was actually much, much more difficult a task.
It doesn't really seem like such a "black and white" or "good and bad" choice- you have a psychotic leader fighting for a good cause and a rational level headed leader fighting for a group of bastards. If you think that's a black & white choice— you're over simplifying.
On one side, we have the lecherous Ronald Laren, who at worst is a Chivalrous Pervert who is at least trying to woo the clueless Sierra Petrovita into... erm... "opening up" instead of just making like a savage raider and raping her. He even will readily gun down raiders who threaten the little shanties in which they live. Helping him along with his quest to get in Sierra's pants is somehow karmically evil. On the other side, we have Angela Staley and Diego. Angela wants to woo the religiously chaste Diego who otherwise still has a liking to her. Finding some ant queen pheromones for Sierra to cause Diego's sexual instinct to overwhelm his inhibitions in an act that borders on Double Standard Rape: Female on Male is somehow karmically good.
Character Tiers: Hirable followers definitely come in tiers.
With Broken Steel, Dogmeat, Fawkes, and RL-3 are subject to a glitch that turns them into bullet sponges.*
They gain HP every time the player levels up: Dogmeat and Fawkes have 30,000 HP when the player hits level 30 with RL-3 not far behind.
Charon and Cross are fairly tough compared to other followers*
Charon is good at Sneak while Cross is above average with all weapons.
. Butch, Clover, and Jericho are fairly frail but remain usable as pack mules.
Without Broken Steel, Dogmeat is the weakest follower, Fawkes remains high-tier(albeit with MUCH less health), and RL-3 is mediocre.
Cliché Storm: The Aliens. They are little green men who ride around in a death ray using flying saucer and abduct humans for anal probing and other such things.
Colbert Bump: Sales of Roy Brown's music on iTunes quadrupled shortly after the release of the game, which features his songs "Butcher Pete" and "Mighty, Mighty Man".
Complete Monster: This game has a truckload of them. They include:
Mr. Burke, arguably the worst one in the game. His back story isn't explained much, all we know about him is that he is Mr.Tenpenny's right hand, and Mr.Tenpenny wants Megaton (a peaceful town) nuked, because it ruins the view from his tower. He assigns Mr.Burke to detonate the atomic bomb in the middle if Megaton, under the condition that he evacuate the town first. Burke, however, completely ignores this, and goes out of his way to make sure that when the town is nuked, as many people as possible are caught in the blast. If you get Lucas Simms to arrest him, he shoots Simms dead (unless you are very quick on the draw) and assigns mercenaries to track you down. You get positive karma for killing him. However, if you don't kill him and help Roy Phillips (see below) break into Tenpenny tower, Roy (who is scared to death of Burke), will make Burke his right hand man. Not only that, Burke will go ahead and nuke Megaton, even though Tenpenny is dead and there is absolutely no reason to nuke the town.
Roy Phillips. He leads a ghoul gang who live in the horrible slums outside of the luxurious Tenpenny tower. He has tried repeatedly to get in, and when you meet him you can help get into the tower either peacefully or violently (by unleashing a horde of feral ghouls into the tower). Either way, even if he gets in and is allowed to live there peacefully, he and his gang still slaughter everyone there. But for some reason, you get bad karma if you kill him (although you can kill him without karma loss if he attacks first).
Most slavers, for obvious reasons.
You can be this if you choose to go that way. The pure Video Game Cruelty Potential is outstanding. Murdering innocent people, participating in human trafficking and slavery, nuking an entire town, and that's just the tip of the iceberg.
Not to mention the Raiders, who seem to have absolutely no purpose what-so-ever other than existing to gun anyone who isn't one of them down. Even The Family and The Slavers can be talked to, the Raiders just kill and die. As a result, you will never lose karma for killing them, even if they try to run away.
The Enclave.
The Talon Company. They don't really seem to have any purpose beyond killing people for being too nice, or just whenever it will make them a quick buck.
Wernher even has shades of this, towards the end of The Pitt's quests you learn that he's willing (but fortunately prevented from) harming the infant Marie to acquire the cure. The number of surgical tools in his hideout seems to confirm what he has in mind for her.
Contested Sequel: Points of debate include the shift in gameplay from turn-based to real-time (among numerous other changes), the quality of writing, both in the main quest and in secondary quests and locations, and the change of location resulting in almost nothing carrying over from the first two games aside from the Enclave and Brotherhood of Steel.
Cool Versus Awesome: Mothership Zeta. A samurai, a cowboy, a wastelander, a soldier two centuries out of place, a Plucky Girl, and you versus hundreds of little green aliens.
Liberty Prime. He has backpack full of nukes he throws like footballs.
General Jingwei's main weapon, an electrified Jian sword.
Crowning Moment of Awesome: The ending, with Broken Steel. You highjack an Enclave Kill Sat and blow up their gigantic mobile base, almost certainly ending the threat of the Enclave forever. It's especially awesome when you think about it: It took an atomic war and two centuries for the Wasteland to throw off the shackles of the past. The Enclave, the remains of the United States government, had plans to control the Wasteland, and the protagonists of the Fallout trilogy flipped them off and nuked them. Three times.
Liberty Prime is online. All systems nominal. Weapons hot. Mission:the destruction of any and all Chinese communists.[1]
If you buy Charon's contract from Ahzrukal, this happens:
Charon: (upon being informed about you purchasing his contract) This is good news. Please wait here, while I go take care of something. (walks up to Ahzrukal) Excuse me, I am informed that I am no longer in your service?
Ahzrukal: That's right Charon, come to say goodbye?
Charon: Yes. (pulls out his shotgun and blows Ahzrukal's head off)
Consider this Foreshadowing if you happen to be an evil character yourself...
Crowning Moment of Heartwarming: Merely one example of many: Randomly encountering three slaves being escorted by a slaver, rescuing them, and successfully defusing all three slaves' explosive slave collars.
The "Agatha's Violin" question. From Three Dog:
Three Dog: Now, the Lone Wanderer, aka that kid from Vault 101, has done some pretty interesting things, but this one takes the cake. My contacts report that he/she recently went on a highly dangerous excursion to recover -drum roll please- a violin. Oh, but not just any ol' violin, children... We're talking Stradivarius here. That's one top o' the line fiddle, you dig? Here's the best part. The violin was for an old woman named Agatha, who has taken to the airwaves herself to share some truly beautiful music. Agatha, we love ya. Keep playin', sister. And Vault kid? You've helped make the Capital Wasteland a better place. Hats off, my friend.
Fallout: New Vegas gives us one retroactively. You can find the Wasteland Survival Guide as a skill book. Moira dared to dream, and it came true. It is possible to come across a woman who tells you that thanks to your book her family is no longer starving.
Crowning Music of Awesome: The music playing in the main menu and while it loads. It practically booms POST-APOCALYPTIC. Works even better when doubled with The Ink Spots' I Don't Wanna Set The World On Fire in the opening sequence.
So cool that the London Philharmonic Orchestra included it in their album of The Greatest Video Game Music.
The Enclave Hellfire Troopers, who have more health than any other human enemies in the game, carry either a hard hitting, very accurate plasma rifle or an extremely high damage Heavy Incinerator, and wear the best armor in the game. Thankfully, they are a pretty rare encounter, and when you encounter a large number of them, you get the Tesla Cannon, which can make short work of them.
The Tribals. They are ridiculously powerful and hard to kill for no reason at all. Getting beaten by a bunch of tribals with hunting rifles and axes that barley wear clothes after curb-stomping the Power Armor wearing, Gatling Laser wielding Elite Mooks of the Enclave is rather jarring.
Radscorpions in general due to their lack of a weak point. At least the Mirelurks have a head to snipe for a potential One-Hit KO.
Draco in Leather Pants: Many people who played the game thought Colonel Autumn was a super nice guy, even though he's a Jerkass racist who only betrayed the Big Bad because he wanted absolute control over the water supply, and Eden was going to poison it. Some even wanted him as a companion.
The Player Character can play himself this way: a bloodthirsty killer with no morals what-so-ever, but who has maxed out their charisma and intelligence to the point where no one would dare argue. Except Three Dog, of course.
Alistair Tenpenny seems to have a bit of this treatment going on as well; while he's perhaps not quite the Complete Monster his minion Mr. Burke is, he still shoots people from the top of a skyscraper for fun, he's still a complete bigot, and the fact that killing him nets the player a karma boost (one of the few occasions where this happens) suggests that even if he's now just a slightly senile old man (which is how he's generally viewed in this treatment), he's been responsible for some pretty nasty stuff in his life.
Ear Worm: The Enclave Radio, and Galaxy News Radio station. Most memorable ones:
Or let's be practical: it could also be that he's a bright yellow, eight-foot-tall walking tank. With a GatlingLaser.
Fan Dumb: Try reading an argument about the "Meaning" of Butcher Pete and keeping your sanity.
Fridge Brilliance: The names of the weapons in Mothership Zeta are incredibly generic and dull, "alien atomizer", "alien disintegrator", "drone cannon", etc. Then you realize these aren't their actual names, they're just the names your character has given them in-universe to tell them apart, they probably have proper names but there's no way you could ask the aliens to tell you.
East Coast super mutants getting Stronger With Age neatly justifies Fawkes being such a Game Breaker with Broken Steel: He's an original super mutant, nearly 200 years old, making him potentially much older than the muties you and he chew through. And he still has all his faculties.
Fridge Logic: Pretty much everything to do with Little Lamplight. The town has been around since the bombs hit, but where do the citizens come from since it is only populated by children and the adults are sent away? It also lies right next to the Vault the super mutants come from, and in fact a door in the town connects right to the Vault, so how is it they haven't been wiped out? And when you grow older you're sent to Big Town—it's halfway across the wasteland, why is it so far away and how did anyone survive the journey there when from what you see they're sent off with nothing but the clothes on their backs?
Assuming contemporary real-life standards, puberty generally occurs somewhere between 9 to 14 years of age. The Little Lamplight exile age is 16, so there's enough time for reproduction.
For starters, every single add-on gives you at least one weapon that would be considered an Eleventh Hour Superpower before the eleventh hour.
Broken Steel gives you the Tesla Cannon, which can kill most enemies with one hit and all but the strongest enemies with two, and it runs on one of the most common ammunition in the game.
Almost every item you can find in Mothership Zeta is a Game Breaker. Of particular note is the Captain's Sidearm, a better version of the Infinity Plus One Gun of the base game. The other items are almost as powerful.
Operation Anchorage gives you an indestructible suit of Power Armor (although the indestructible bit is a mistake in the code) and a suit that will basically give you the effect of a Stealth Boy permanently, thus giving you the ability to have perfect invisibility and be undetectable to all enemies in the game, as long as you're using a silenced or melee weapon.
To follow that up, The Pitt has the Infiltrator, a silenced machine gun with a scope, and it's not a unique weapon. It has an even more powerful version of itself called the Perforator. With this and the stealth suit, you can breeze through the game without ever being seen.
Point Lookout gives us the Microwave Emitter, which ignores armor. All armor.
Fawkes, who can take on any enemy with almost complete impunity. Good once you hit level 20/30, since you won't have to use your own weapons any more.
Unless you go to one of the DLC zones. Your Wasteland companions can't follow you there.
The Chinese Stealth Armor from the Operation Anchorage DLC. Allows you to kill anything without ever being detected.
The Grim Reaper's Sprint perk, restoring your action points once you leave V.A.T.S. if you killed someone in it. And you will kill someone, unless that someone is an Albino Radscorpion, Overlord or Behemoth.
Remember how in Fallout 1 and 2, healing while resting was a function of time and only restored hitpoints? In Fallout 3, one hour of sleep will restore you completely.
With Broken Steel, RL-3 levels up with the player at 10 times the rate he should, giving him absolutely ridiculous health. That, combined with the fact that he can be obtained very early provided the player knows where to look (and where to get 500-1000 caps) makes pretty much every other companion useless (except Fawkes, but that is pretty late in the game).
The same can be said for Dogmeat, who receives the same Broken Steel benefits as Fawkes and RL-3. Go right to the Scrapyard at the beginning of the game and you have a nigh-invincible (Dog)Meat Shield right off the bat! Oh, and unlike RL-3 and Fawkes, Dogmeat can be recruited regardless of your Karma.
And of course, there are plenty of glitches in the game that will give you a huge advantage. The ones above are by design.
The Dart Gun has a very high chance of crippling the legs of whatever it hits, turning melee enemies into a joke, including Deathclaws.
Genre Savvy: Officer Herman Gomez knows all too well that he doesn't stand a chance against the Wanderer, when he or she enters the vault. Rather let that one go.
The repair shop merchant in Point Lookout has continually increasing repair skill. He is eventually the merchant capable of repairing everything to pristine condition.
The developers mistakenly placed the simulation version of The Winterized T-51-b Power Armor as the reward after completing Operation Anchorage, which results in it becoming almost totally indestructible since it has nearly 10 million item HP (i.e., it doesn't ever have to be repaired).
In vanilla Fallout 3, Dogmeat, Fawkes, and Sergeant RL-3 are fixed-level characters, due to being creatures rather than human NPCs. The Broken Steel DLC upgrades them to allow them to level up with the player, in order to stay competitive against the super-powerful new enemies introduced in the expansion. The Good Bad Bug is that their health and damage increase 10 times more than what the designers intended... making them pretty much indestructible killing machines (For example, Dogmeat has 2,500 health at player level 1 and 15,000 health at player level 30!!! For comparison, a Super Mutant Behemoth, by far the toughest monster in the game, has 2000 health). Note that this only occurs if Broken Steel is installed before you actually meet and recruit those characters... otherwise they receive no upgrade, and get curbstomped by the new Demonic Spiders.
The inventory system has a small bug where, if there are two or more of the same equip with different conditions and the more damaged equip is below the less damaged equip, moving the more damaged equip will instead move the less damaged equip. The same bug applies to equipment shops, only now you can buy the item that is less damaged for the price of the more heavily damaged one, then sell it back for it's real price. Repeat the process as many times as you want and you will have quite literally robbed the shop blind of all it's stock and money.
The game applies perk based skill bonuses upon selecting them, rather than after confirmation. During the level up screen, you can select a perk that gives skill bonuses, then go back to the skill distribution and see the game has added them already. But if you go select another perk and return to the skill screen, the added points remain. Repeat for more points.
Grey and Gray Morality: At the end of the Pitt, you're faced with a real kicker of a choice. You can aid the slave rebellion, which wants to destroy the raider army oppressing them (who really are evil jerks) and kidnap the boss' baby daughter so they can try to create a cure for a massively degenerative disease from her. However, the raider army's the only thing bringing food into the Pitt other than the meat of 'Trogs', the degenerated semi-humans created by the disease, and they have no scientific or medical knowledge and won't treat that baby well. Or you can side with the genuinely good intentioned Lord Ashur, who leads the slaves and raiders so that he can create an industrial powerhouse that'll be free of disease so he can conquer the surrounding area to provide food, shelter and medicine for everyone.
Harsher in Hindsight: Liam Neeson plays the main character's father and a widower. Less than a year after the game's release, Neeson's real life wife, Natasha Richardson, tragically passed away. The scenes where he sadly talks about his dead wife in the game felt very strange after that.
Iron Woobie: Gob. He seems to keep a stiff upper lip, (well, if he had lips) but the fact that his normal way of saying goodbye is crying "Don't hit me!" shows that Moriarty's done a number on him.
Irony: The Brotherhood of Steel's original mission in the Capital Wasteland was to recover lost technology and the Outcasts left because Elder Lyons made the decision that helping the local Wastelanders was more important than their original goal. By the end of the game (especially with the add-ons) the Brotherhood of Steel has made entirely new weapon systems, reactivated a super robot from the Pre-War period that single handily curb stomped the Enclave, and have recovered so much of the Enclave's advanced technology that they are practically swimming in it. No good deed goes unrewarded, eh?
Jerkass Woobie: Scribe Bigsley in Broken Steel is a smug, snarky, arrogant jerk who shows you nothing but disdain until you offer to help make his workload easier, and yells at his subordinates. However, he's stuck working around the clock in a dimly-lit room with no windows, has little support from the Brotherhood because their resources are still focused on the Enclave war, and has to oversee the distribution of the water to the various cities of the wasteland, which he does with limited manpower and limited money to hire more.
Jump Scare: You're deep in the tunnels of the Marigold Station. You've got the constant chitter of ants in your ears, you don't know if something worse is down here, it's dark and you're looking around every corner for enemies. Bonus points if you're low on ammo and/or health so you're even more on edge. You open what appears to be just another door, and are immediately yelled at by a human scientist working in a secret lab. And he's complaining because you startled him!
Moral Event Horizon: As the player, you can if you want: Nuking Megaton, following Eden's orders and poisoning the Wasteland with the virus, and aiming the Enclave's Kill Sat at the Citadel in Broken Steel.
Charon in particular has a personal moral code despite coming off as True Neutral, and certain acts (such as murdering innocent Ghouls, robbing Underworld blind, or killing female slaves) get an audibly horrified reaction from him, and he'll try to blow you away if you dismiss him immediately afterward. The same can happen with Fawkes, though you have to be much more of a bastard to get on his bad side, and if you do then you'll be facing off against someone with a Gatling Laser and skin tougher than two Vault doors welded together. Good luck!
Most Annoying Sound: "You appear to be wounded sir/madam, may I suggest you seek attention treatment as soon as possible?"
The tone that plays every time you lose karma.
Doc Church if you rely on him for stimpaks and other meds early in the game: "You best have cancer, because from the look of it your breaking rule number one right now."
The Dunwich building is bad mojo. Stay away from there.
The Radscorpions are pretty terrifying. The Giant Radscorpions even more so.
Compounded by their seemingly uncanny ability to sneak up on you. You can just be trotting along, minding your own business, you hear something and turn around just in time to see a scorpion the size of a small car bearing down on you.
Super Mutants can be pretty scary sometimes, especially if one is barreling down on you in a confined space waving a nailed board or a sledgehammer in the air, not even flinching as you run backwards firing your gun in his face. The first Super Mutant Behemoth you're likely to meet is introduced by exploding two buses after a Scare Chord hits, and then out from the smoke comes a Super Mutant twice as big as the rest so far swinging around a piece of sewage pipe like a baseball bat.
Very often you stumble into tableau-like scenes of skeletons that were killed doing things when the bombs hit. For example, you can frequently find "Pulowski preservation shelters", phone booth-like pods designed to protect people. However, almost every single time you open them a skeleton falls out. On occasion you'll find two skeletons in a shelter, or a skeleton with a handgun clutched in its hand with a blood spatter on the wall. While wandering around pick up a radio broadcast of a couple with a critically injured son child taking shelter in a nearby drainage pipe, but when you get there you find a ham radio broadcasting the messages and two adult skeletons. Stop and take a moment to think about what happened to these people that you find their skeletons in these conditions...
Listen to Keller Family Transcript 3 of 5. "Mom, it's Candace. Oh my God, it's really happening. I can see the cloud... it's so big... Mom, I'm so scared." The background noises on the tape just make it all the worse.
In Mothership Zeta, the screeching of the Abominations as they run at you pointing with their Black Eyes of Evil wide can be pretty creepy.
All the Vaults are pretty bad in this regard, but possibly the worst is Vault 92. What makes it the worst is that the game builds up a hugely creepy atmosphere all the way through it, with plenty of detail provided about exactly what was going down and what went wrong, expecting you to find the worst things around every corner, until you find... Nothing. There's nothing down there. Just the ghosts of the dead and the ruins they left behind...
Only The Creator Does It Right: The game is hated by some of the more die-hard fans of the first two games because it was created by Bethesda Softworks and not Black Isle Software. Especially noticeable when you consider that Fallout: New Vegas was given a more accepting reception and that some of the old employees of Black Isle incidentally worked on it.
Which is ironic, considering how one DLC of the sequel and a lot of Continuity Nods in the stock game and the other DLC confirm it exists, it uses over 75% of this games assets and code, and even uses every core mechanic Fallout3 does (including the hated ones), even expanding on some of them. And, as bonus irony, the player WAS invincible when using the first two games interpretation of VATS, so the Fallout: New Vegas version that removes this is technically LESS in line with the first two Fallout games.
Railroading: Grievous. Notably how choosing not to protect the code to Project Purity gets you insta-killed, or how you can every be extremely selfish or extremely generous at the final "morality choice"
Rooting for the Empire: It's easy to want to side with the Enclave in this game. As a sharp contrast to Fallout 2 where they were fascist, genocidal monsters, in this game they're just looking to take control of the Capital Wasteland with intent to begin rebuilding "true" America. The only one of them who seems to be prejudice against outsiders and want to eradicate them is President Eden, Colonel Autumn seems to actually want to rule over the people. Granted they're still Jerkasses and are hostile towards you, but they don't really do anything evil and actually act like a more extreme version of the Brotherhood of Steel. Imagine if Autumn and James had been more reasonable to the other during negotiations—the project is peacefully turned over to the Enclave, they raid Vault 87 and get the G.E.C.K., the purifier is started and the Enclave begins using their vertibirds to fly clean water across the wasteland. Also keep in mind they have the manpower, resources and willingness to take out the raiders, super mutants and Talon Company mercenaries that make the wasteland such a nasty place to live. The only downside is that the local humans live under Enclave rule, but considering the abundant anarchy that threatens them, how much worse could it be?
Only if you never visit an Enclave wilderness outpost. The computers note they're experimenting on the denizens of the wasteland, then killing them. Of course, a Villain Protagonist LW probably wouldn't care.
Dr.Zimmer in the Replicated Man quest actually makes a very good point. He's out to capture an android that escaped, and the player is either given the option of locating and bringing back the android or helping the android avoid Zimmer. The first option gives negative karma, the second gets positive karma. However, Zimmer repeatedly points out that the android is his property that he created himself, and that you couldn't enslave an android anymore than you can enslave a water purifier or a computer.
The obvious flaw in his reasoning is that water purifiers cannot decide they want to be free. Androids can - that is the point of the quest!
(Admittedly) obvious flaw aside - and his ignoring it is supposed to show why Zimmer is the "wrong" choice - the android is still a significant financial investment that took time and caps to build and activate.
The Overseer's reason for being such an extreme isolationist is actually pretty sound. He thinks that the dangers of the outside will result in the deaths of everyone in the vault, particularly if a large group of raiders finds them. Considering what happened to Vault 3...
Vault 34 and Vault 11 also show what can happen if an Overseer allows his people to get too much out of hand. Totalitarian authoritarianism seems more nuanced when balanced by the fact that all it takes is one asshole to get careless in the engineering area to doom the entire vault (something Butch was dangerously close to doing himself in 101's case).
Vault 34 failed because the overseer was too totalitarian and refused to left them leave the Vault. If they did they would never had a food problem which was a major reason for the unrest, and Vault 11 had a Lottery of Doom.
Tear Jerker: "If anyone can hear this, this is Bob Anderstein. [My] family and I have taken refuge in a drainage chamber not too far from a radio relay tower outside of D.C. My boy is very sick, needs medical assistance. Please help if you can. We're listening for your response. 3950 kilohertz."
For those who are curious, there's a drainage chamber nearby, with the long-dead skeletons of Anderstein and his wife, surrounded by toddler toys and a lunchbox. Their son's corpse is nowhere to be found.
There's just a lot of little things that get you down. A skeleton behind a sealed door with a pistol in its hand, a note from a nurse dying of radiation sickness who laments that she'd prefer to die last so she could take care of her patients, a corpse in the wilderness with a note about a man who killed his kids in front of him... who doesn't exist in-game, denying you the satisfaction of enacting some justice in this sick sad world.
Also, the story of Little Lamplight and Vault 87. Little Lamplight began as a series of caverns that a troupe of children happened to be taking a field trip in during Armageddon. Vault 87 was in an adjacent cave complex. The kids pounded and pounded on the door begging to be let in, but a man inside said that they were "already dead" and should go away. That man was one kid's father, who believed his son killed in the holocaust, and his voice a hallucination.
And, right outside Vault 101, there are a couple of skeletons. And a picket sign saying, "We're DYING,assholes!"
At one of the Drive-in theaters, there are two skeletons embracing on the hood of an old car. And if you check the mailboxes in the various small towns, you'll eventually find rejection letters from the Vault program.
In one house, the player can find the undisturbed skeletons of a couple spooning on a bed, apparently sleeping peacefully when the bombs fell. There's a child's skeleton in another bedroom. The child's room has a crutch and medical brace nearby. Yeah, basically they killed Tiny Tim.
In another random house, you can find a skeleton in a bathtub. Also, a toaster.
When some characters are killed, they'll cry/mutter the name of a loved one as their last words. Even for gamers who enjoy playing evil characters, it can be heart wrenching to be reminded the man you just shot had a wife or kid.
One drawn-out side quest involves trying to gain entry to a vault in the National Guard armory where a family had taken shelter. Once you get in, you find four skeletons and a feral ghoul.
There is one house in Georgetown where a robot sits silently in a room, untouched for the two hundred years since the bombs fell. When activated on a certain command, the robot will drolly float to the child's room where a small charred skeleton lays where the child died sleeping, with its teddy bear still cradled in its hands. The robot, not realizing this, will read its designated bedtime story...There will come soft rains.
This one is especially tragic if you think of it as the parents possibly preparing their children for what the war will bring...
Going to Arlington Cemetery invoked this feeling in me. It seems so sad that all the sacrifices and suffering of the ages experienced by all these soldiers was in vain because the world that they fought to protect and uphold was all destroyed in the nuclear fires of the Great War. Even after the apocalypse all it brought was a sad new chapter in humanity's long history. It got me to thinking if perhaps the men in those graves were luckier then we for the dead have seen the end of war, the survivors of the war have not because war never changes.
That One Boss: Defender Sibley in Anchorage, mainly because he has a bunch of heavily armed mooks backing him up and it doubles as an Escort Mission of sorts.
And General Jingwei in Anchorage. He has a massive amount of health and an oversight in programming causes the American Powered Armor troops to turn hostile to the player without provocation.
The Computer Is a Cheating Bastard: Certain weapons have a special effect of dealing additional damage per hit that ignores damage resistance. The catch? This only activates when an enemy NPC is using it against you.
Ugly Cute: Take Animal Friend, and the normally vicious mole rats will trundle harmlessly along the Wasteland. Sometimes they sit up to sniff the air, then drop back down to yawn and shake themselves.
You get a Karma boost for killing certain evil characters in the game.
Another point is the rather small range of -1000 to 1000 karma points. Nuked Megaton (-1000)? No problem, just pay 2000 to the local cult and you are the shining beacon of goodness again. Since the game is nice enough to send mercenaries after you if you are too evil or too good, this pays off in no time!
Note that once you EVER hit evil karma, Regulators will come hunting for your head. In fact, going back to good karma from evil karma means that BOTH the Regulators and the Talon Company mercs are gunning for you, your call to decide that is good or bad.
And then there's the ending:
Possible ending 1: Activate purifier, + 1000 Karma. Understandable, so far.
Possible ending 2: Poison purifier and activate it: no karma change (the game docks 1000 for the poison, but you also get the 1000 boost for activating it), unless you were on the evil side, in which case you will be neutral after that. Oh, and you just doomed the whole Wasteland to a long and painful death.
Possible ending 3: Poison purifier and then walk away, leading to its destruction. -1000 karma, and the Wasteland is no better or worse off than before.
There's a possible ending 4: Poison the purifier, then have Sarah Lyons sacrifice herself to activate it instead of you. This grants -1000 karma and, upon reflect, is the most logical choice for an evil, non-idiotic character.
The quest Tenpenny Tower has this. If you convince Tenpenny that ghouls are not all mindless, cannibalistic murderers, he allows them to move in to the tower. A few days after this occurs, the ghouls murder every resident, strip their bodies, and unceremoniously dump their corpses with feral ghouls around to presumably eat them. This includes the one resident who is extremely tolerant of ghouls. The major bigoted stereotype is actually justified by this quest.
Reverse-pickpocketing a grenade onto a swamplurk (Point Lookout) is somehow bad karma. What.
Swift Learner: +10% experience for each level, but there's an infinite amount of experience available.
Lead Belly: -50% radiation from drinking water, radiation-free healing is easy to come by.
Fortune Finder: More caps found in random containers, there is an infinite amount of caps available.
Rad Resistance: +25% radiation resistance, clothing and RadX make it moot.
Impartial Mediation: +30 to Speech skill at neutral karma, but remaining at neutral is tedious. Speech challenges can be exploited for a 100% chance of success, either through save scumming or maxing out the speech stat.
Animal Friend: Normally-hostile mammals become non-hostile. You can go for a second rank to get them to help you in combat, but they aren't usually that tough or annoying enough to be worth getting the perk (except if you encounter yao guai.)
Mister Sandman: Adds prompt to instantly and stealthily kill sleeping people for maximum experience, but it often glitches up and causes entire settlements to go hostile on you.
Mysterious Stranger: He'll occasionally show up in VATS to provide a One-Hit Kill to any enemy, but he can glitch up, anything he kills doesn't provide you perk or quest-related benefits, and he has a low chance of appearing at all.
Night Person: +2 Intelligence and Perception between 6:00 PM and 6:00 AM, which can be done with drugs or clothing.
Here and Now: Level up again instantly. Wasted perk slot due to the fact that infinite experience is available, the perk only functions at level up when you take it.
Cannibal: Can devour human corpses for +25 HP / +8 rads / -1 Karma, but the animation is lengthy and getting caught turns settlements hostile.
Computer Whiz: Can try to hack a terminal you get locked out of. Only use three attempts when hacking and the problem will never show itself.
Infiltrator: Can try to pick a lock you broke once more. Save and reload instead. Even worse than Computer Whiz, as locks don't break unless you try to force them (as opposed to picking them. By contrast, locking a terminal happens by botching a hack).
Nerd Rage!: Descended from an equally terrible Perk (Adrenaline Rush) in the previous Fallout games, you gain a bonus to strength and damage resistance, but only when you're on death's door (Health < 20%), making it far too tedious and fragile for actual use.
Concentrated Fire: +5% accuracy for each action in VATS targeting the same part of the same enemy. Only useful for guns with low AP costs.
It's worth noting that Concentrated Fire can actually be a Gamebreaker used properly, giving multiple headshots at maximum range for a pistol.
Solar Powered: +2 Strength, +1 HP every 20 seconds while outside between 6:00 AM and 6:00 PM. Moot with drugs, health is easily replenished, and the HP recovery is incredibly slow.
Explorer: All map markers are revealed, but not counted as "discovered." The Pip-Boy has a compass that directs you to all nearby map markers as soon as you exit the Forced Tutorial.
Deep Sleep: Sleeping anywhere gives you the +10% "Well Rested" experience bonus, normally available only at your house or from a hotel. Swift Learner is terrible at level 2 with it's constant 10% that stacks with Well Rested; if Deep Sleep weren't bad enough, it becomes available at level 22...out of a maximum of 30!
Puppies!: If Dogmeat(or Dogmeat's Puppy) dies, Dogmeat's Puppy appears outside Vault 101 after a few days. Only available in Broken Steel, which causes Dogmeat('s Puppy) to become a bullet sponge. Useful only for the follower exploits.
Devil's Highway / Escalator to Heaven / Karmic Rebalance: Instantly sets your Karma to very evil, very good, or neutral. Karma is easily adjusted by theft, murdering respawning NPCs, and donating to churches.
No Weaknesses: All SPECIAL stats below 5 increase to 5. Made moot with the Almost Perfect which raises all SPECIAL stats below 9 to 9.
Rad Tolerance: Nullifies the debuff of minor radiation poisoning. RadAway is easy to get and minor rad poisoning is...minor.
Warmonger: Instantly get all weapon schematics to level 3. Most are pretty easy to get to level 3 anyways and only Nuka Grenade and Bottlecap mine really gain much from being level 3.
Nerves of Steel: Effectively boosts your AP recovery...by 1 point every 10 seconds (for comparison, firing a pistol costs 17)`. Someone programmed it wrong.
Rad Absorption: -1 rad every 20 seconds. Radiation is easy to get rid of and the rate of reduction is incredibly slow.
Nuclear Anomaly: At 20 HP or less, you lose all your radiation, your health rises to 20 HP exactly, and you create a small nuclear blasts where you're standing. Although it's an amusing gimmick, anything that could drive you to under 20 HP at level 30 is probably going to be dealing MORE than 20 damage per hit, the blast re-irradiates you, damages your clothing, often cripples your limbs, damages any friendly NPC in it's radius, and occasionally it glitches up and fails to provide the healing; causing you to kill yourself.
Punga Power!: Boosts healing and radiation removing effects of normal and refined punga fruit considerably. Stimpaks and RadAway are weightless and much more effective at their respective purposes than punga fruit. At least it's a perk given to you for free.
They're not weightless on Hardcore, mind.
Except that Hardcore is only available in Fallout: New Vegas...and Stimpaks and RadAway are still weightless when it's turned on.
If you decide to be a terrible person, you can make Amata's life hell growing up. Teaching bullies to mock her weight, killing her dad, destroying her home, and causing her to be captured by the enclave and shot to death for not revealing where Vault 101 is.
