Country Music: Dived into after leaving WWE, her theme "hardcore country" being self done.
Cute Bruiser: Especially as her childish face character in BBOW
Dirty Coward: For her 2013 Heel turn, she started doing everything she could to avoid getting into a rematch with Velvet Sky for the Knockouts Title, when she had previously treated Velvet as a Worthy Opponent.
Emotional Bruiser: She cried more than any of the other WWE divas, which was mocked by Beth Phoenix and a source of entertainment for Laycool. Neither was without consequence as they both had title reigns ended by Mickie.
Expy: Has one in Psycho!AJ Lee. The only real difference is that AJ's character has actually managed to get over as heel, in comparison to Mickie who was never booed in WWE.
Face-Heel Turn: In TNA it was teased a few times but it was ages before she finally turned.
Five Moves of Doom: Jumping clothesline, Thesz press, back elbow, corner canrana, implant DDT. Initially most of these moves, among some others, were occasionally used or at least recently at the time used by Trish and Mickie made them her signature moves, to show she was borrowing from her idol but adapting her own style. She later chose the ones listed for her sequence.
Genki Girl: Fans are convinced her blood is made of caffeine.
Girl on Girl Is Hot: When she kissed Trish under the mistletoe, gaining an Earth-shattering pop from the audience.
Groin Attack: Did this to Trish Stratus at WrestleMania 22. However, unlike every time this had been done before in pro wrestling, this was meant as sexual, topped off by her licking in between her fingers to a huge pop from the crowd. It was edited out of the DVD release because Vince McMahon just didn't like it.
She took a few bumps that had or would have put others out, such as a fall on her neck from the ring she took in a falls count anywhere match that lead to a rushed finish with Melina as the champion...but Mickie proved to be not too injured to continue.
At TNA Lockdown 2011, April 17, 2011, she Squashed Madison Rayne for the TNA Knockouts Title in a Hair vs. Hair Cage Match in 34 SECONDS with her arm in a sling!
Mini Dress Of Power: Much like Melina, she debuted in a skirt and continued to wear skirts for a little while into her WWE career before decided she'd be taken more seriously in shorts or tights.
Ms. Fanservice: Well conditioned, flexible, strong and willing to wear very little clothing. That's before one looks at some of her character specific antics.
Nice Cap: Added one on her entrance outfit around 2008-2010.
Put on a Bus: To TNA, following an incident on an overseas tour. Ironically the incident in question involved a bus.note She caused several tour buses to be late to the arena WWE.com eventually came up with an explanation for Mickie's departure months later in an article where they said LayCool and their taunting caused her to have a breakdown and eventually leave.
The Rival: Melina Perez in WWE. The two were enemies from the start, there were times Mickie would try to be civil but Melina was unreceptive up until Mickie put her health on the line to protect Melina from Victoria and Natalya. Then they were the best of friends but that did not keep them from ending up as opponents every so often. Prior to WWE Mickie was rivals with Jillain Hall ever since Mickie won a $1000 prize match in OVW and post WWE it continued in the NWA as Hall goes out of her way to show up Mickie and undermine her music career.
Shout-Out: Frequently kips up after doing moves, something her idol Lita did often as well. In her feud with Trish Stratus, using the Stratusfaction and the "Mick Kick" were intentional examples.
She seems to do this at least once everywhere she goes. Along with the TNA example under Made of Iron, at Royal Rumble 2010, January 31, 2010, she flattened Alpha BitchMichelle McCool for the WWE Women's Title in 20 seconds! This was followed by Mickie and the other Divas joining forces to shove Michelle's face into a cake.
At ROH Epic Encounter, April 12, 2003, she defeated Ariel (Ana Otero) in 35 seconds.
Tweener: To Draco in Leather Pants levels, this was the worst she ever got. Mickie was never able to get lasting heel heat, not even after she abducted Trish's protegee, busted Trish open when Trish tried to make the save, then licked the blood off her hands. Not even during the ECW vs WWE Head to Head TV special when the rest of the WWE side was booed. Her gimmick as Alexis Laree did manage to get over as a heel though