Main Tropes Index

Troperville

Editing Help

Tools

Toys

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

Custom Search

redirected from Main.TheXanatosRoulette

alt title(s): Improbable Scheming; Just As Planned; Exactly As Planned; Yagami Gambit; Single Xanatos Pileup
In a Xanatos or Batman Gambit, an especially cunning villain is able to trick the heroes into giving him what he wants. The Xanatos Roulette takes this one step too far. The villain is upgraded from "cunning" to "seemingly omniscient". The plan is ridiculously convoluted, often relying on events that are completely within the realm of chance - yet it comes off without a single hitch (or so we're told; it's only in retrospect that we find out that pretty much everything that's happened in the series up to this point was part of one huge, overarching plot).

Basically, an attempt to make a villain seem impressive, stretched to the point where Willing Suspension Of Disbelief is broken. In rare cases, a Xanatos Roulette can be successfully executed, but you really have to establish a character as The Chessmaster for them to be able to pull it off without arousing your audience's skepticism. Genuine precognition also helps.

Often part of retconning in a new Big Bad, as it turns out everything up to then (including the supposed successes of the heroes against the old villains) is all part of their scheme. Also often the justification of the Omniscient Morality License; their control over events is supposedly total. Additionally, if a character messes with their own mind, getting their memories back almost inevitably becomes a Xanatos Roulette at some point.

May be parodied by having events obviously (and blatantly) be out of the character's control, and yet still have them take credit for it. Or, y'know, have the Spanner In The Works topple their Rube Goldberg plot with a poke.

In a litmus test distinguishing a Gambit from a Roulette, the Gambit has a basic cause and effect to to the linchpin; there is no more than a few steps to achieve the goal and it is achieved by expecting the most likely outcome. If the steps grow in number, the timing is far too perfect and the outcome emerges from a pool that has far more likely possibilities left behind, it is a Xanatos Roulette.

Even shorter litmus test. If your first reaction to seeing the plan unfold is "Dear God, that's brilliant!", it's a gambit. If, on the other hand, your first thought is "There is no fucking way that you planned that!", then it's a roulette.

Note that some plans may be complicated; however, that does not automatically make them a Xanatos Roulette. There might be a few seperate plans to achieve a greater goal, but the individual gambits may still make logical sense. As well this is about having omniscient knowledge of the outcome without incident. If there are active and emergency adjustments because of deviations to the original blueprint, it is a Xanatos Speed Chess.

The author risks accidentally using a Xanatos Roulette if someone's plan becomes too complex, as well as the aforementioned Ret Con to make seemingly seperated events to be part of that big plan. Add in several Xanatos Roulettes or Gambits unfolding simultaneously and you have a Thirty Xanatos Pileup.


Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Anime/Manga 

    Comic Books 

    Fanfiction 

    Film 

    Literature 

    Live Action TV 

    Mythology 

    Tabletop Games 

    Video Games 

    Web Animation 

    Web Comics 

    Western Animation 

    Other 


Xanatos GambitXanatos Planned This IndexXanatos Speed Chess
Wrong Guy FirstOlder Than RadioYour Costume Needs Work
Xanatos GambitTropes Of LegendX Meets Y
Xanatos GambitSpoilered Rotten        
Xanatos GambitPlotsXanatos Speed Chess
Xanatos GambitNarrative DevicesYellow Sash Of Power