Main Tropes Index

Troperville

Editing Help

Tools

Toys

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

Custom Search

alt title(s): Butterfly Effect
Here is the real Butterfly Effect.

Martha: But are we safe? Can we move around and stuff?
The Doctor: Of course we can. Why do you ask?
Martha: It's like in the films! You step on a butterfly, you change the future of the human race!
The Doctor: I'll tell you what then, don't step on any butterflies. What have butterflies ever done to you?
-Doctor Who, The Shakespeare Code

Cyborg: Don't do anything, don't touch anything, Sci-fi rule number 1: you start messing with the past, you end up with monkeys ruling the future.

Want to go back in time to stop your parents from losing their retirement money in the Dotcom crash? Save a loved one from a fatal accident? Nudge a closet a little to the left to avoid hitting your toe? In some universes, you're not just going to run into You Cant Fight Fate, but into Finagle's Law on a grand scale: the Butterfly Of Doom. Any and every change made in the past will always have an unintended and horrible side effect. Much like a temporal Monkey's Paw, the initial effect might come to pass, but at a terrible cost. Telling your parents to move their money elsewhere gets you arrested for inciting a financial panic and insider trading, the loved one you saved develops a wasting terminal cancer, the closet you moved is now on a weak floorboard and crashes through it, and because of termite damage collapses the rest of the house.

Generally part of an Anvilicious story about accepting things as they are, this is the sword held over the heads of repeat offenders of Hitlers Time Travel Exemption Act, those who insist on changing the past. The resultant world can range from a dark Alternate Universe to a full-blown Mirror Universe. Heroes can usually Set Right What Once Went Wrong, by undoing the original change with a bit of Rubber Band History. Curiously, these changes are never positive, suggesting in all cases shit happens for a reason.

Intuition dictates that big changes have big causes, and small causes equal small changes. This trope is named partly for the Butterfly Effect, an observation made in meteorology. In the large-scale computer simulation of weather systems, a minuscule change in temperature or the wind's direction (about the bat of a butterfly's wings) will drastically alter the weather (sunshine instead of hurricanes) simulated at a later point. Even if the models used work, it is impossible to achieve sufficient accuracy when entering the data. Thus computer-assisted long term weather forecasting is considered a joke even by meteorologists. The Of Doom is appended because the image of a single frail, pretty, delicate-as-a-sheet-of-glass butterfly causing the world to turn itself inside out is amusing.

This alone may be a bad reason to argue for an universal butterfly effect. Edward Lorenz's Chaos Theory is based on the idea that an unstable system is unpredictable and a small change can have a large impact in the long term. Not all systems are unstable, though. This is why there is no scientific reason to claim that the whole universal system is unstable as well. Further, "Chaotic" does not mean entirely random. Systems defined as "Chaotic" may be unpredictable, but they still are deterministic.

The butterfly effect also refers to Ray Bradbury's seminal time travel story "A Sound of Thunder", which centered on the disastrous consequences of a butterfly's death. By marvelous coincidence, the story was written ten years before Lorenz began pondering the inaccuracies of his forecasting computer.

In theoretical discussions of Time Travel, this phenomena is sometimes referred to as "Avalanche Time", evoking an image of cascading changes that race forward through the timeline exponentially, obliterating everything familiar to the time traveler who set it off.

There is a philosophical history regarding this trope as well. Leibniz theorized that God made this the best of all possible realities. Ergo, any change would be tampering with perfection. Therefore in Western Media the Butterfly Of Doom is God being sort of a dick. (Leibniz's philosophy was parodied in Voltaire's Candide, with Doctor Pangloss who, no matter what horrendous atrocity he beheld, would exclaim that every thing was for the best in the best of all possible worlds).

The most common aversion of this trope is based on the idea that large scale historical processes happen for large scale reasons. The Butterfly Of Doom may alter the course of a hurricane, it can't stop winter from changing into spring.

See also the Aesop of Wonderful Life. See also Finagle's Law, Hitlers Time Travel Exemption Act, You Cant Fight Fate. A subtrope of For Want Of A Nail. Make A Better World is the opposite scenario. Godwins Law Of Time Travel is a subtrope of this.

Has been known to team up with Schrodinger's Butterfly to cause mind breaking havoc. See also Save This Person Save The World for when the Butterfly Of Doom is a person.


Examples

    open/close all folders 

     Anime/Manga  

     Comics  

     Films  

     Literature  

     Live Action TV  

     Tabletop Games  

     Video Games  

     Web Comics  

     Web Original  

     Western Animation  

For Want Of A NailOtherworld TropesWonderful Life
Born In The Wrong CenturyTime Travel TropesNecessary Fail
Blessed With SuckSour Grapes TropesCame Back Wrong
Artifact Of DoomDoomy Dooms Of DoomConveyor Belt O Doom
But I DigressNarrative DevicesCall Forward