Our hero is idling her car out of the driveway when she accidentally bumps into a stranger. "Ow, my back!" the stranger exclaims. "The pain is immeasurable! I'll sue you! I'll sue!"
Someone—usually a stranger, sometimes a friend—has decided to sue our hero in the wake of some minor accident. The plaintiff suffered no real injury, but is suing out of greed or perhaps a desire for revenge, often with the help of an Ambulance Chaser
or otherwise Amoral Attorney
. If the judge doesn't laugh the guy out of court, though, our hero must often resort to some variety of Courtroom Antic
to discredit her adversary.
The classic sitcom lawsuit is almost always a tort action: the plaintiff is claiming the defendant's negligence harmed them in some way, and is demanding monetary compensation. The actual injury sustained is always minuscule and the amount of damages claimed has to be at least five times what the hero earns in a year. The complaint itself is often just plain silly, such as suing Pizza Hut because the X-Treme Meatsa-Treatsaria did not truly deliver "gut-busting meat flavor" as promisednote
Technically, a frivolous lawsuit is one brought in bad faith—i.e., brought with no intention, expectation, or chance
of success. Within the legal system, calling an action frivolous is like calling the lawyer who brought it a certified loon, the legal equivalent of "not even wrong". Much more common are frivolous claims in otherwise reasonable lawsuits and frivolous courtroom motions that only serve to prolong the legal process and harass participants. Another common instance is the lawsuit that, while it is technically
not frivolous because it is based on actionable legal fact, said actionable legal fact is
hair-splitting, petty, and a Violation of Common Sense
(e.g. a ten million dollar suit filed against a restaurant for not putting ketchup on a burger advertised as having ketchup on it - it is
technically false advertisingnote
and therefore legally factual and actionable,note
but is the lack of a free packet of ketchup you could apply yourself worth ten million dollars?). The majority of the truly outrageous examples you might have heard of are filed pro se
, without an attorney. That's because none want to touch the craziness with a ten foot pole. If there's an actual attorney involved who isn't also their own clientnote
the case might not be so frivolous as it first appears.
Finally, yet another common lawsuit confused with the Frivolous Lawsuit
that may or may not be technically
frivolous is the SLAPP - Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation
, used to censor or intimidate people into withdrawing truthful accusations/statements, not releasing proof of corruption/wrongdoing, or otherwise silencing people. The Church of Happyology
is absolutely notorious
for this practice (to the point that almost all parodies of it include it), and it's often a favored tactic of the Corrupt Corporate Executive
and the occasional celebrity caught in major wrongdoing.
In real life, actual frivolous lawsuits will be over long before they get near an actual jury. Repeated filing of frivolous lawsuits, frivolous claims, and frivolous motions will often be met with "contempt of court" charges; and attorneys have been disbarred for excessive frivolous filings (granted, it takes a long
history of accepting worthless cases, making pointless and abusive appeals, and generally pissing everyone off to make them even consider it; bar associations are fairly reluctant to go that far and will never
jump straight to disbarment before making use of letters of reprimand, sanctions, and suspensions first). Likewise, litigants known for repeatedly bringing them can be labeled by the courts as "vexatious" and enjoined from ever filing another without getting court approval first (like disbarment, you really
have to fuck up before they'll even consider labeling you as vexatious due to a general reluctance to keep someone from having their day in court; it takes a whole lot of abusive, ridiculous claims, worthless appeals, bad courtroom behavior, unpaid fines, and general egregious misbehavior to get them to even think about forcing you to permanently leave them alone). Even if none of this happens, the case (and others like it) can be banned from itself ever being filed again, at least in both the US and Japanese court systems, if it is dismissed "with prejudice," which may or may not go as far as the judge calling it frivolous, but is a strong warning to the parties and lawyers involved that trying it or a similar case again will
put them at risk of the more severe consequences such as contempt charges, disbarring for attorneys involved, and the like.
Often this trope is invoked to make an argument about Tort Reform, i.e. limiting the ability to file claims or capping the liable amount of damages. On the one hand, everyone can agree that there sure seem to be a lot of unnecessary cases brought to court which takes up both time and money that can be better spent. On the other hand, it's hard to argue that the mere fact that someone with an illegitimate claim asks for a ludicrous amount of money means that someone with a legitimate claim should have their legal recourse limited. Particularly since — in the United States at least — most defendants in tort cases insist on a jury trial, and the jury
is responsible both for determining fault and deciding the amount of damages to award (if any).
Subtrope of Hilarity Sues
. A lawyer who goes after tort claims is called an Ambulance Chaser
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- Scrooge McDuck once crashed a plane and a man who had nothing to do with this threw himself at the wreckage and sued Scrooge for one "maximajillion" dollars. This is so large that it exceeds what Scrooge, who at one point had three cubic money bins each over 20 stories tall, expected to make over his lifetime. Scrooge himself is portrayed in many stories as being the richest person in the world, which makes the amount appear even more ludicrous.
- Played with in Ultimate Spider-Man. After Peter Parker is bitten and receives his powers, he begins to stand up for himself more, eventually refusing to take crap from Jerk Jock Flash Thompson. Flash responds by challenging Peter to a fight and, not knowing his own strength, Peter easily breaks his hand. Flash's family demand the Parkers pay his medical bills for the incident or they'll sue, ignoring the fact that Flash had been beating up Peter for years and he was the one who instigated the fight.
- For added bitterness, earlier in the volume, the spider bite made Peter ill enough to go to a hospital, and Oscorp wound up sending the Parkers a gift basket and footed the bill out of fear that they'd sue the company. Uncle Ben later explains he knew it was an accident and Peter wound up fine a few days later, so he'd never consider suing.
- Later still, Norman Osborn, once he discovers what the spider bite did to Peter, toys with the idea of suing his family. His reasoning: The spider was Oscorp property, along with everything the spider produced. Peter has the spider's venom in his blood. Ergo, Peter has stolen Oscorp property.
- One issue of the Archie Comics had a man intentionally get rear-ended by Veronica so he could sue her. It took Archie, Chuck, and a Zany Scheme to prove that the man had orchestrated the entire thing.
Films — Animated
- A string of these set off the plot of The Incredibles. After one man wins a lawsuit blaming Mr. Incredible for injuries incurred while saving his life, so many people follow that all superheroes are forced into retirement and hiding.
Films — Live-Action
- In the Babylon 5 Made-for-TV Movie River of Souls, a holographic entertainment operator attempts to sue the station with the help of an Ambulance Chaser who Captain Lochley refers to in those exact terms. At the end she takes great pleasure at informing him that, since the business in question was destroyed in the course of the film's events, the grievance was now a moot point and he'd be going home empty-handed. Add to that, part of the lease agreement the owner signed waived rights to sue if damage is done to his property during the course of protecting the station itself, which Lochley has a dozen affidavits attesting to this fact.
- Older Than They Think entry: The Three Stooges try their hands at this once they hear of someone slipping in a hotel lobby and suing for thousands (this is before 1950, folks). Naturally, they find ways to fail at pratfalling before they find the owner of the hotel is herself impoverished.
- The plot of the film The Man Who Sued God. The main character is a fisherman whose boat is destroyed by lightning, but he isn't allowed to claim damages from his insurance company because the lightning was "an act of God." So he sues God. (God is represented in court by clergymen.) In the end, the main character drops his lawsuit, but his efforts aren't in vain since he's won a moral victory. The clergymen then announce that they'll be suing the insurance companies for unauthorised use of their Lord's name.
- In Liar Liar, Jim Carrey plays Fletcher Reede, an unscrupulous lawyer who, it is implied, specializes in these sorts of cases. One scene also references the famous Urban Legend of the burglar who injures himself trying to break into a house and successfully sues the homeowner (in the film, it really happened — to a friend/relative of Fletcher's secretary).
- In My Sister's Keeper, one thing that attracts Anna to come to the Attorney Campbell to sue for bodily emancipation is Campbell's involvement in a case where a boy sued God for his injury.
- This is the background to the toad in the Discworld novel The Wee Free Men. He was a lawyer who was employed by a woman to sue her fairy godmother, on the grounds she was promised health, wealth and happiness, and didn't feel particularly happy one day. The godmother's response was to turn him into a toad, and his client into a small hand mirror. The worst part, he says, was when the judge applauded.
- This seems to be a common thing for magic-users, according to Going Postal:
Archchancellor Ridcully: Oh, please sue the University. We've got a whole pond full of people who tried to sue the University!
- Mr. Frankland, a minor character in The Hound Of The Baskervilles, liked to sue people as a way of showing off his knowledge of law, including the more obscure points. He was particularly proud of getting one man convicted of trespassing on his own property.
- Albert Haddock sometimes started these in AP Herbert's Misleading Cases in the Common Law. The intent was for Herbert to demonstrate how preposterous the law was, and it was sometimes suggested that that was why Haddock was doing it as well.
- In Adrian Mole: The Cappuccino Years, Adrian's mother sues a shoe shop because the stilettos she bought there fell apart while she was climbing a mountain in them. To Adrian's surprise, she wins the case, when her lawyer successfully argues that the shop ("Shoe Mania!") should have removed the exclamation mark from its name so as not to excite hormonal middle-aged women into making rash purchases.
- The Bible
Isaiah 59:4: No one enters suit justly; no one goes to law honestly; they rely on empty pleas, they speak lies, they conceive mischief and give birth to iniquity.
- Deconstructed in the Diogenes Club short story "Clubland Heroes", which first portrays the meaningfully named Peeter Blame as a petty man, constantly threatening legal action for trivial reasons, and by the end shows him as someone who was absolutely justified in many of his complaints, and was driven to despair by increasing evidence that while the law was on his side, the legal system wasn't.
- The trial in Annie on My Mind is this through and through. The entire reason Liza and the two teachers are brought to trial is because a homophobic teacher catches Liza and Annie in Ms. Winthrop and Ms. Stevenson's house. The teachers lose their jobs, but the school trustees call the trial ludicrous and fire the corrupt principal.
- The protagonist of The Dresden Files spent years dealing with harassing lawsuits from Larry Fowler after blowing out most of his talk show's electronics. Given that the only way to find him guilty was for a judge to accept the existence of magic, this mainly served to drain Dresden's bank accounts.
- This is possibly an inversion of the usual way this trope is played, since the lawsuit is legally frivolous but morally quite sound; Harry's magic really did blow out all the electronics and cause some very expensive damage, and Harry went into the talk show knowing the risk of this but decided to go in anyway, and he (obviously) didn't give Fowler due warning that he was a real-life wizard who carried a high risk of accidentally destroying all the electronics. Based on this, Fowler actually seems quite justified in wanting compensation.
- However, in a further complication, Fowler himself presumably doesn't believe in magic, so to the best of his knowledge he is launching a Frivolous Lawsuit against Harry, and his accusations just happen to be true.
- One minor character in the Carl Hiassen novel Striptease spends the entire book trying to arrange things so he can start one with some wealthy person/organization just so he can be given a large cash settlement to shut up. In the last chapter, he gets into a minor car accident on land owned by a sugar company and sues the property owners, claiming wildly exaggerated injuries.
Live Action TV
- The Golden Girls: Blanche gets in a minor accident driving Rose's car and the man she rear ended sues Rose.
- The Brady Bunch was once sued by a man who claimed whiplash in the wake of a collision with the Brady family car. His case was discredited in court when Mike deliberately dropped his briefcase on the floor behind the guy, whose prompt and obviously painless spin in place to face the noise demonstrated just how real his injuries were.
- In a possible case of a Recycled Script, a similar episode appeared on The Partridge Family, which ran on the same network in the following timeslot.
- The second season of Joan of Arcadia featured the title character's family being sued for "emotional damages" by the boy who caused the accident that paralyzed Joan's older brother. The lawsuit was dropped abruptly after an extended arc, and the character in question was never seen again.
- Malcolm in the Middle's evil grandma does this after slipping on a leaf on the main character's front porch. She is forced to back down when her lawyer meets the family and decides that even if they took the family for everything his cut of the profits wouldn't be as much as he wanted.
- In an episode of Coach, Luther sues Hayden after burning his mouth on a hot-off-the-grill bratwurst at Hayden's barbecue. He nearly wins the lawsuit; however, the judge eventually decides that, as Hayden is merely a tenant, he is not liable; the owner of the property is. Since the owner is Luther's girlfriend and both men's boss, he immediately drops the suit before the verdict is officially announced.
- Played with a bit on Married... with Children. After Bud and Kelly get into a fender bender with a Mercedes, Al bemoans society's litigiousness. But when Bud tells Al that the other guy was at fault, he immediately decides to sue, and has the children play up the severity (read: existence) of their injuries in court.
- In another episode, a burglar broke into the Bundy family home while Al was asleep on the couch. As Al woke up, he accidentally touched the burglar on the behind, before realizing what was going on and pummeling the burglar. He was later sued by the burglar for "sexual harassment" and being unable to "work", claiming that Al's punch ruined his career as a burglar, greatly exaggerating his injuries, this along with obvious signs that the burglar's attorney was having a relationship with the judge, and even tried to shake Al's hand with the one in said sling after he won. However, Al got the last laugh when he decked the burglar again, and won a Frivolous Lawsuit of his own by claiming he hurt his hand on the burglar's face.
- In another episode, a thief entered the shoe store where Al works and Jefferson suggested Al could sue the mall for four million dollars, claiming the incident made him afraid of shoes. The mall sent an investigator who kept an eye on Al. To make matters worse, Al's bowling team were finalists in a tournament and the bowling hall wouldn't let him play barefoot because the last one to do so there sued the place for three million dollars. Eventually, Al decided the championship was more important than money.
- In another episode, Peggy watched a tv ad about a lawyer who helped a woman to get 2.5 million dollars from her husband for asking her to cook. Peggy tried it with Al by volunteering to cook but Al was so focused on some idea he refused the offer and the lawsuit idea went unmentioned for the rest of the episode.
- Jefferson once fell inside Al's workplace when a wall gave in. Jefferson's claims of injury ended as soon as Al stated they had no insurance.
- An episode of CSI: New York revolved around the murder of a woman who made a living from multi-million dollar Frivolous Lawsuits (for reasons many of which are implied to have been set up by herself). The murderer turns out to be a chef whose life she had completely destroyed and had recently gotten back on his feet... only for him to see her getting ready to pull the same stunt again at his new place of business. You almost feel bad for the guy.
- Seinfeld had the Ambulance Chaser Jackie Chiles (an obvious parody of Johnnie Cochran) in at least three cases of this. Every time, he wound up humiliated due to Kramer acting stupid and ignoring his legal advice.
- In "The Postponement", Kramer sues a coffee chain for burning himself with hot coffee. In the next episode "The Maestro", we meet Jackie Chiles for the first time as Kramer settles the case for free coffee for life, passing up a large cash award in his stupidity.
Company Representative: We're prepared to offer you free coffee for life, and-
Kramer: I'll take it!
- In "The Caddy", Kramer and Elaine sue a woman for "distracting" Kramer while he was driving because she was wearing only a bra top. Jackie Chiles' remark that a bra has to fit "like a glove" is a reference to the O.J. Simpson trial. Kramer's stupidity was again the cause of losing this case, since Jackie had it in the bag when he insisted on checking to see if the bra would fit her.
- In another episode, Kramer turns his apartment into a cigar bar/smoking room, and the cumulative effects of hours upon hours of concentrated smoke make his skin pallid. They sue the tobacco companies and settle for making Kramer the new Marlboro Man.
- Archie Bunker tries to cook up a whiplash suit in "Oh My Aching Back", a first season episode of All in the Family. Because of his unambiguous prejudices, he also insists on having a Jewish lawyer. He gets one, but said lawyer senses the case isn't kosher, and bails.
- An episode of Babylon 5 has a short skit where a man sues a Vree (aliens that look like Greys and whose ships are flying saucers) because the Vree's great-grandfather abducted the man's great-grandfather and conducted experiments on him. The judge laments under his breath that he always seems to get these sort of cases.
- Even more amusingly (from the things the judge says), it seems that there's actually a treaty between the Vree government and the Earth Alliance that governs exactly such cases, meaning that these cases must happen all the time in the B5 universe.
- According to fluff, the Vree aren't the ones doing the abducting. It was most likely the Vorlons and the Streib (who look similar to the Vree but don't have flying saucers).
- In this specific case, the man claimed to have found records proving it was the ancestor of the specific Vree he was suing.
- Steve Bosell from The Phil Hendrie Show regularly sues anyone and anything for any slight, no matter how minor. For example when his oh so hated neighbor cracks a joke at Steve's expense (often warranted), Steve not only sues him, but his son for laughing at the joke. If he was only in the presence of his neighbor because his wife asked him to, say, pick up groceries or trim the hedges, he will sue her for putting him in a dangerous position. The number of lawsuits Steve filed over the course of the show are innumerable, and every one as inane as the last.
- Parodied by Saturday Night Live ads for the law firm of Green & Fazio ("Call 1-800-HARASSS. The extra "S" is for extra harassment!").
- In Only Fools and Horses episode "Hole in One", Del Boy decides to sue the Nag's Head after Uncle Albert falls into its cellar, despite the fact that he incurred no injury (they base the suit on emotional damages) and the Nag's Head offered Del a large settlement. The suit ends up being thrown out when the defense points out that Albert is a trained paratrooper (thus having knowledge of how to fall without injuring himself) and that he has "accidentally" fallen down pub cellars numerous times in the past, and taken the settlements.
- On Becker, Becker is sued by his patient, when Becker takes him to the gym for rehab-purposes, and the patient suffers a heart-attack as a result— even though Becker saves his life, and Becker was rehabilitating him in order to prevent an inevitable heart-attack, and accompanied him there for safety-purposes. Becker's insurance company wants to settle, and agrees to clear Becker of all liability and expense; however Becker refuses on principle, even though it costs him considerable time, money and harassment. He ends up managing to get the suit dismissed after a lengthy rant on the stand; however, his behaviour and personality has so antagonised the trial judge that she ends up throwing him in the slammer for contempt.
- A very mild example from Doctor Who — in "The Runaway Bride", Donna threatens to sue a cab driver who refuses to take her to her wedding in Chiswick... because neither she nor The Doctor are carrying any means of paying the fare.
- Happens in an episode of The Beverly Hillbillies. During the trial, the unwitting hillbillies do very little to help their case until they accidentally divulge the fact that the guy suing them has a girlfriend on the side, at which point, his accomplice lets the cat out of the bag.note
- In an episode of Lois and Clark, a man pretends to be injured after Supes saves his life, helped by an Ambulance Chaser who thinks successfully suing Superman will make him famous. He even pretends to get further injury when Supes takes a bomb out of the court (through the roof), but then his girlfriend snaps and spills the truth.
- In an episode of Smallville, Clark beats up a guy for attempting to sexually assault Lana, but the man sues him for his injuries. Clark's X-Ray Vision shows him that the jerk isn't even injured, but he can't tell anybody that. (Apparently Clark's lawyer didn't think of asking for doctor's records, including more conventional X-rays.)
- In one episode of Frasier, a man in the coffeehouse takes Frasier's seat and acts very rudely to him. Frasier, who has been on the receiving end of much rudeness all day, finally snaps, lifts the man up by his armpits and throws him out of the shop. The next day he goes back to the man to apologise, only for the man to sue for assault. Niles however starts insulting the man, goading him until he very lightly pokes Niles in the chest. Niles immediately throws himself into the nearest table and threatens to counter sue. Frasier is quickly persuaded to play along:
Man: I barely touched him!
- Interestingly, Niles is spot on here. In common law, battery is any offensive touching. Assault can be either an attempted battery or placing someone in reasonable fear of imminent bodily harm. You don't even need to touch someone to complete an assault and the guy poking Niles is a textbook definition of battery.
- For added humour / irony value, Niles seems to convincingly fake pain as a result of this... only for him to privately admit to Frasier than in his exaggerated fall, he accidentally landed on a fork.
- JAG: Harmon Rabb is subjected to a traffic accident scam with an Ambulance Chaser in "Standards of Conduct".
- M*A*S*H has several examples of frivolous court martial attempts. In The Trial of Henry Blake, Henry has to defend himself against gurney races, and Radar selling shoes and other things. General Steele brings in several charges against Hawkeye, including impersonating a civilian (The General Flipped at Dawn). In The Novocaine Mutiny, Frank charges Hawkeye with mutiny for disobeying some idiotic orders. In all cases, all the charges are dropped. note
- Oddly, in MASH, the episodes containing legal issues only come about when key characters usually aren't guilty. For example, when Hawkeye is tried for mutiny, it's a case where he was doing what was best for the patients. He's never tried for the many mutinies he actually commits or the times he fails to obey lawful orders.
- The West Wing has the President getting sued over his comments regarding car seatbelts.
- Batman: This is the plot of the pilot episode; the Riddler invokes this when he cleverly tricks the dynamic duo into falsely arresting him and then he sues Batman for a million dollars (in the sixties!). The point is not only the money (Bruce Wayne can afford it) but the fact that Batman must reveal his Secret Identity, which would ruin his Super Hero career.
- Penn & Teller: Bullshit!: An episode arguing against requirements for handicapped access uses as evidence the example of a handicapped man who would sue commercial shops en masse for not providing him with handicapped access. It would cost more to fight him than to pay the low damages he requested, netting him quite a hefty amount of money. He apparently hadn't even visited many of the stores he claimed to have attempted to enter, because some of them did have handicapped access.
- In the Sanford and Son episode "Whiplash", Fred ends up getting rear-ended by a white man in Cadillac. He isn't injured, but when his friend Bubba tells him that a friend of his sued for injuries from whiplash injuries, he decides to fake being injured to the point of filing a false police report, getting "advice" from an Ambulance Chaser and finally confronting the hit-and-run driver himself. It all comes crashing down when the driver turns out to be a car thief who stole the Cadillac.
- Spitting Image portrayed media tycoon Robert Maxwell this way, in a spoof where he sings his own riff on "Puttin' on the Ritz".
When I'm feeling in the mood / Someone out there will be sued / I'll nail those gits! / I'm putting out the writs!
When writers try to criticize / In bios I've not authorized / I'll axe those crits / By putting out the writs!
Of taking legal action I am weary / So I've only served six writs since January!
When they put these tales about / I just have to squeeze them out / like little zits / I'm putting out the writs!
- Probable Ur Example: an Egyptian myth about a thief who breaks into a house via a window, but breaks his leg because of the window's shoddy construction. The homeowner blames the carpenter who put the window together, the carpenter blames a beautiful woman who distracted him, and the woman blames the fellow who dyed her dress red. That dress-dyer doesn't fit in a cell, so a shorter dress-dyer is hauled in, and he can't come up with an excuse to get out. The focus, incidentally, is not on the burglar, but on how crazy the judge authorizing it all is.
- A variation exists where the last man recommends to hang the thief, the thief is too tall to hang, so a shorter man is brought. The man recommends to dig a hole below the thief's feet. The thief urges them to hurry so that he'll be able to get to heaven soon because a king is needed there... So the local king (who's also the crazy judge) orders himself hanged.
- In Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines, several of the adverts you can hear on the radio are political broadcasts for a fictional Republican senator. The first two imply his Democratic opponent has committed vehicular homicide (on the basis he owns a car of the type responsible for one in the area) and child pornography (on the basis he has not yet stated his opinion on the subject). When he sues the Republican, a third ad notes the Democrat had previously claimed to be against clogging up the courts with frivolous lawsuits, and implies he is a hypocrite ("Would you want your children to become hypocrites? Vote Republican candidate Robert Thorne, the candidate not accused of being a murderous child pornographer!")
- The old flash series Attention Deficit Disorder Man featured Lawsuit Larry, a supervillain who took control over hundreds of organizations by injuring himself on their premises and suing them into oblivion. In the end, he managed to sue and control entire countries; the only way ADD Man was able to defeat him was by making him injure himself from his own products, giving him nobody to sue but himself.
- Most of the cases in The Sonic Amigos sub-series Retard Court starring Homer Simpson end up being this.
- The New Batman Adventures parodied this with an unnamed Johnnie Cochran lookalike popping up to say a catchy line to support a lawsuit. In the commentary for one such episode, the creators note how dated the joke wound up being.
- In "Over the Edge," Batman's identity is exposed. Minor villains launch a billion dollar lawsuit against Wayne Enterprises. JC pops in: "If the bat's on a spree, Wayne must pay the fee!"
- When the Joker somehow acquired vast wealth, he used high-powered lawyers to get acquitted of his various crimes (clearly referencing Cochran's most famous case): "If a man's filled with glee, that man must go free!"
- Subverted in Clerks: The Animated Series. Jay slips on a wet mess that Randall left on the floor, and Randall taunts him about it. "What are you going to do, sue?" Right on cue, a lawyer walks in to buy some conveniences- but when Randall (yes, Randall) asks him to take on the case, he refuses and leaves. Randall then begins a concerted campaign of harassment until the lawyer finally gives in and agrees to take on the case- against Dante, since he was the store manager at the time.
- At trial, the lawyer doesn't even show any significant effort, presenting the bare facts of the case without any grandstanding. Unfortunately, Dante still ends up looking really bad because his boss hired Randall (yes, Randall), who presents an incompetent defense.
- In an episode of The Boondocks, Riley and his grandpa sue the school after Revered Rollo Goodlove vocally expresses his N-Word Privileges; with fantasies of getting a large sum of money.
- Happens in an early Simpsons episode "Bart Gets Hit by a Car" (1991). Mr. Burns accidentally hits Bart with his limo; the family attorney "tricks" Homer into exaggerating the resulting injuries to squeeze more money from Burns.
Lionel Hutz: Doctor, are you sure there isn't a little soft tissue trauma in the facial area?
Dr. Nick: Oh yeah, tons of it! [wrapping Bart's head with bandages] Just say when!
- The irony being they would have gotten something, at least covering Bart's hospital bill as Marge wanted, if they had just told the truth at trial rather than make up false claims.
- Or if Homer had just taken the half million Burns had offered him and went home. They ended up with nothing because Homer was greedy.
- There is also Homer vs. an "all you can eat" seafood restaurant. If they kick Homer out before he has had "all he can eat," does this make it fraudulent publicity?
- He stayed hours past closing time, forced them to make run's to the grocery store and ate far more than any thoughtful person would eat. All you can eat does not mean you can eat it all.
- They actually settled that one out-of-court; they invited him back, but set Homer up in a glass display and let all the people gawk at him pigging-out! It draws boatloads of customers who came to watch, but they decide to try some food- because this restaurant has to be pretty good if he's eating like that. Well, Homer was happier, owner of restaurant was happiest, Marge... not so much!
- Hutz also mentioned in that episode that he sued The Never Ending Story for false advertising.
- Selma has claimed that she has a lucrative hobby filing 'nuisance lawsuits'.
- Deconstructed in one of the frequent "future episodes", Bart is an unemployed loser who frequently files these to make a quick buck, but it's deconstructed in that none of his ridiculous cases; which include suing a restaurant for an over-salted french fry; Disneyland for a spider bite received on the premises; and a messenger company for refusing to pay him for his first two weeks of employment, ever go to court, and it's implied Bart can't find a lawyer to take them all...
- One time Moe was able to sue a rope company when the rope that he was using to hang himself was weak, he won the case, got a good sum out of it, and a brand new rope to hang himself with.
- Once, Homer tripped over a hole in the ground next to the church and so sued the church. There was no way that Rev. Lovejoy could afford the sum he wanted so he won the church in court.
- In "They Saved Lisa's Brain", one of the dozen or so of Homer's relatives that he gathers claims he makes a living by insurance fraud lawsuits.
- The Blue Haired Lawyer who works for Mr. Burns is usually smart enough to avoid something like this, but when he became too immoral and threatened to sue Skinner for copyright violation (his elementary school carnival used Disney's catchphrase, "The Happiest Place on Earth" - just consider that for a minute) Skinner showed them what happened when you make a former Green Beret mad. "Copyright expired," he mumbled, after he beat the crud out of the lawyer and his two goons.
- South Park
- In "Sexual Harassment Panda", Kyle's dad (a lawyer) encourages a string of frivolous sexual harassment suits that culminates in a suit called "Everyone vs. Everyone". In which he represented both sides.
- In "200", Tom Cruise sues the town for mocking him, and recruits the help of every celebrity who has ever been portrayed on the show, all because Stan called him a fudge packer when that is what he was doing.
- As in he was working at a candy factory, packing fudge into boxes, while wearing the uniform of an employee of that company.
- An episode of Spongebob Squarepants had Plankton feign serious injury from slipping and falling in the Krusty Krab just so he could sue Mr. Krabs for everything he owned (including the secret recipe for Krabby Patties).
- Happened both ways on Wait Till Your Father Gets Home. Harry slips on a dropped piece of butter in a restaurant and falls down. The restaurant owners are heavily insured, and out of fear of Harry filing a lawsuit, they offer him a settlement. Harry doesn't want to take it citing the fact he didn't injure himself, but his honesty is not respected by his family and neighbors who try to pressure him into taking the easy cash being offered. Later on, Harry becomes the defendant when a bicyclist crashes into his stopped car and decides to sue him. His lawyer (Special Guest Don Adams) is particularly inept and Harry is only saved from a losing judgment when the plaintiff suddenly decides to drop the case.
- On My Gym Partner's A Monkey, Principal Pixiefrog's fear of lawsuits often either drove or exacerbated the wacky hijinks of the episode.
- In the original Grand Finale of King of the Hill, Lucky accidentally gets injured in Dale's house note so he can sue him so he can have an expensive wedding with Luanne. It turns out that Dale built the railing himself—without a permit, makes his own poison (he's an exterminator), is his own boss, and made up a fake liability insurance carrier just to shut Hank up. Lucky's lawyer tries to sue Strickland Propane because Hank suggested that Dale hire Lucky.
- A trait that made him The Scrappy to fans was that Lucky entirely sustained himself on frivolous lawsuits and refused to get a job. When we first meet him, he's just bought himself a new truck with money taken from "slippin' on pee-pee on th' Costco." When picked up by an ambulance, he even knows the exact amount of morphine to be given that will dull his pain without damaging his ability to testify.
- Lucky later manages to turn this around. After the lawyer refuses to drop the case due to "malpractice reasons", Lucky fakes a video of him playing golf, thus making his suit void. The lawyer tried to "unfake" it to get the suit through, but Lucky manages to get "injured" again in the lawyer's office. Turns out the lawyer's colleagues are just as unscrupulous as him, since Hank's threat of taking the case to any other man in the building was fairly credible.
- In another episode, Dale sues the tobacco companies, lying to claim that years of second-hand smoke have made his wife unattractive and destroyed his marriage. When he discovers that the company has (electronic) bugs planted in his house, he tries to exploit it by insulting Nancy at every opportunity, which completely destroys her self-esteem and nearly does destroy the marriage. When Dale finally figures out what he's doing, he cross-examines himself and convinces everyone that he still finds Nancy gorgeous.
- Ironically, he was suing to get money for Nancy so she could get cosmetic surgery.
- The Gravedale High episode "Monster on Trial" featured old lady Fresno, who cried whiplash after her car was slightly nudged by Reggie during driving lessons, and sued Max Schneider for a million dollars. Turns out she did that 8 times already, but always wins anyway. She wins the case this time too (entering in a wheelchair), but the case finally gets overturned when she tries the same trick in a minor collision with the judge. Yeah, so when a plaintiff gets into an accident involving the judge of a previous case, that judge is allowed to declare the lawsuit against himself and his old court ruling void.
- Fresno also ran a red light when Reggie and Frankentyke chase her through Midtown, so karma nipped her in the bud.
- On Rocko's Modern Life, Rocko swats a fly while cooking burgers. The fly sees an ad on TV saying how he can make money by suing someone... and he sues Rocko. Rocko is sentenced to 30 days... as a fly. (Until the judge sees him at a fancy restaurant, completely uninjured, and turns Rocko back.)
- In the Futurama "movie" Beast With a Billion Backs'', Bender is caught in an explosion on Zapp Branigan's ship, and screams that he can't feel his legs and will never walk again. Kif tells him in a bored voice that you can't sue the military, and Bender gets up.
- Courtney from Total Drama Island. Her first lawsuit wasn't so unjustified (fellow competitor Harold rigged the votes against her, sending her home instead, and the host of the show didn't care), but she also bargained for unfair advantages (most notably contact with the outside world via her PDA) along with reentry into the second season. Once she was back in the game, she threatened to sue the producers again every time something didn't go her way.
- The band The Romantics vs. Activision because "the cover band in Guitar Hero Encore: Rocks the 80s sounds too good". The case got thrown out by the judge.
- Nancy Stouffer, author of The Legend of Rah and the Muggles, who sued J. K. Rowling in 1999 for "plagiarism", because among other things, Rowling used her "Muggles", even though Stouffer's alien Teletubby-like goblins had nothing to do with Rowling's normal humans (and weren't actually called muggles; that was something Stouffer made up to increase her chances of winning) and the word 'muggle' already existed as a somewhat antiquated term for 'dullard'. Once the judges saw Stouffer's book was a terribly written piece of wall fragment, they dropped the case as fast as it came. Hoping to cash in on No Such Thing as Bad Publicity, a small-time publisher picked the vanity published original (because no respectable publisher would dare touch it) and did a small printing run of Stouffer's book in 2001. The next year, the publisher folded.
- In the music world, the incident of Versailles (a US solo act) vs. Versailles (a Japanese band that pre-dated her by years). Both are, of course, named after a French city that predates them by centuries. The US artist freaked at the thought that the Japanese band was "stealing" Google searches from her, didn't trademark the name until after she'd found out about their existence, and tried to sue them to keep them from ever playing in the United States. The band eventually changed their name to "Versailles Philharmonic Quintet" for their US releases and performances, although they continue to go by simply "Versailles" everywhere else.
- Before that, the LA punk rock band X sued X Japan when they first tried to perform in the US around 1990-1991, because at the time they too were called X. The lawsuit was judged in favor of the LA band despite the ridiculousness of the argument that somehow fans couldn't tell the difference between a Japanese thrash metal Visual Kei act and an American punk band, and the Japanese band was forced to rename itself to X Japan and not perform in the US for a few years. Other issues hit, and it wouldn't be until 2010 that X Japan would have a full live performance in the US.
- Hiroshi Matsumoto, brother of the late hide filing one of these against Yoshiki Hayashi of X Japan for using hide's image in X Japan, never mind that X Japan had been the band hide had been with the longest (from 1987 to 1997) and where he had first earned widespread fame. The judge threw out the lawsuit around a month after its filing, actually calling it a frivolous lawsuit in the brief doing so and prohibiting Hiroshi or his lawyers from filing suit again over that particular use of hide's image.
- A shining example. In retaliation for bad customer service, as delivered by a "Spanish woman", a man attempted to sue the Bank of America for "1,784 billion, trillion dollars". (Read: More money than actually exists.)
- Due to a clerical error, Bank of America once tried to foreclose on a home owned by a family who had paid for it in full up front, and had no mortgage or account with them. Despite the fact that they had no legal right to the house whatsoever, the Bank still took it to court. The judge immediately threw it out and ordered the Bank to pay the family's legal fees. When they didn't, the family foreclosed on the Bank branch that sued them. Since the foreclosure meant that everything in the Bank belonged to the family, including all of the money in the safe, the Bank finally acknowledged it was a mistake and immediately paid.
- The Church of Scientology, every time you say anything at all that may be criticizing them. Seriously. If what you say is (according to them) false, it's libel or slander (depending on the medium of dissemination). If it's true, and about any of their doctrine, dogma or practices, it's copyright infringement. Other cases, they just dig around until they find something to pick at. No matter how little the chance of you being a threat. They don't do it for the money, they do it to bankrupt their victims with legal fees, thus shutting them up, plus the potential intimidation factor against people who might want to criticize the Church but would rather not risk getting sued to oblivion for doing so (given that they fought the U.S. Government and won).
- Senator Ernie Chambers, tired of hearing about frivolous lawsuits, decided to make a point and file one of his own... against God. The kicker? Chambers is atheist.
- On the other end of the aisle in almost every way: your life sucks? Sue Satan! The "unofficial account" comes from a fictional story and the whole thing reads with such a Deadpan Snarker tone that it's impossible not to laugh. Good luck getting that subpoena served, as it requires Satan be a resident of the state of Pennsylvania. While not binding precedent in Pennsylvania, the record of Stone v. Scratch may provide some guidance on that count. The judge also notes that the plaintiff neglected to give the court directions on how to serve Satan the complaint. Even if you get past all that, Satan is a lawyer.
- Jonathan Lee Riches. He's filed thousands of these suits against various celebrities and political figures for questionable reasons, but that's not what pushes him over the edge. No, what pushes him past the Refuge in Audacity line is that his lawsuit against George W. Bush names 783 other defendants, including Marco Polo, "various Buddhist Monks", Google, The Da Vinci Code, Norse Gods, Adolf Hitler's National Socialist Party, the Gambino crime family and the Taliban, Mein Kampf, the Leaning Tower of Pisa, the Garden of Eden, the Ming Dynasty and former planet Pluto. The Guinness Book of Records has an entry for him as "The world's most litigious man". He then sued the Guinness Book of Records for understating the number of lawsuits he's filed.
- Leo Stoller, a self-styled "intellectual property entrepreneur" (read: con-artist), trademarked such words and phrases as Stealth, Sentra, Dark Star, Air Frame, Stradivarius, Havoc, Chestnut, Trillium, White Line Fever, Fire Power, Love Your Body, Terminator, and many, many more. Once he trademarked a word or phrase, he immediately launched million-dollar lawsuits against people and companies who were casually using those words. His lawsuits have consistently been laughed out of court.
- Moral Guardian Jack Thompson was infamous for his lawsuits and legal threats directed at companies ranging from Take-Two Interactive to Nintendo to Wendy's to Penny Arcade to Wikipedia to Facebook. He was eventually permanently disbarred by the Florida Bar Association, for including gay pornography in one of his court filings.
- Administrative law judge Roy Pearson sued a small, family-owned laundromat for fifty-four million dollars in damages after they misplaced a pair of his trousers for a day or two. It was finally settled once and for all after roughly four years. He lost, but not before making the life of the laundromat owners thoroughly miserable, even after they made repeated offers to settle for $3000, $4600, and $12000. He's also no longer a judge, thanks in part to this suit.
- Valery Fabrikant is a man who walked into Concordia University in Montreal and shot many of his colleagues. During his life sentence he's become famous for filing these. So many that in 2000, the Quebec Superior Court declared him a vexatious litigant (meaning he needs the approval of a judge to take any legal proceedings against someone else). A bid to clear that status was dismissed by the Court in 2007.
- In his book Somebody's Gotta Say It, talk show host Neal Boortz related a story from his legal days where a man entered his office and tried to start a lawsuit over a mislabeled beverage can. Boortz's response was "Get the hell out of my office."
- Disney Theme Parks:
- Cast Members were filming a training film at Disneyland on what to do if there's been an accident. As soon as the actor fell down, a lawyer appeared from among the bystanders encouraging the "injured" man to sue Disneyland and continued to do so after they walked past the camera.
- Also at Disneyland, a guest jumped out of his Skyway cabin in an attempt to injure himself and sue the park. Originally claiming that the door on the cabin was faulty and that he fell out, the court became suspicious of the fact that the man conveniently landed in the only tree below the ride that could have broken his fall and saved his life. Although he continued on with his story, after the cabin door was inspected and revealed to be in working order the guest admitted that he had jumped out of the attraction and was goaded into filing a lawsuit by his family. Nevertheless, the park removed the Skyway shortly after the lawsuit was dismissed in case someone decided to try it again.
- One other humorous example is someone claiming that one of the three little pigs sexually harassed her and caused her to gain weight. She was laughed out of court because the costumes were shown as having inoperable stub-arms.
- One of the more odd and, frankly, amusing lawsuits against Disney was when hyena researchers sued Disney for defamation of character for their portrayal of the hyena trio in The Lion King. Now, if ANY researchers should have a beef with Disney, it's herpetologists for the constant use of Reptiles Are Abhorrent.
Disney was asked by some of these researchers not to portray the hyenas as evil. Disney responded by portraying the main trio as Ineffectual Sympathetic Villains, who also became three major Ensemble Darkhorses.
- "Dr." Tim Langdell, CEO of Edge Games, claims to own the video game trademark for the word "Edge." The man hasn't made a video game since the 80's, but whenever a video game with the word "Edge" in its name is announced, he jumps on the developer and publisher with a trademark infringement lawsuit. His downfall came when he announced "MIRRORS a game from EDGE", well after Mirrors Edge came out, and promptly sued Electronic Arts over it. EA managed to get Langdell's trademarks pulled and set him and his company up for some serious fraud charges.
- Westboro Baptist Church does this to its critics. Its most often-used defense is that its right to free speech is being violated. These are the people who picket military funerals because they see the deaths of soldiers as divine punishment for serving a country that tolerates gay people. They even picketed Heath Ledger's funeral. Why? For playing the role of a gay cowboy in Brokeback Mountain. The general opinion of many people (even in the American Civil Liberties Union) is that they're doing it for money. One theory is that they are deliberately antagonizing people so that they will be assaulted, only to sue for damages, since their protests are, well, deliberately antagonizing, but always in public places where they can legally sue anyone who attacks them over it.
- Fred Phelps, Sr. (the leader of this church) was an attorney until he filed a frivolous lawsuit of his own against a court reporter, which ultimately led to his disbarment. The suit was because the court reporter had not given him a report on time as he had asked. He sued her for $22,000. The thing that got him disbarred was the fact that he falsified eight sworn statements which he claimed to have obtained, but he had never contacted any of the people.
- There is now a class action lawsuit in progress against Apple because some older iTunes gift cards advertised that "songs are 99 cents" (there are now some songs that cost $1.20).
- In an instance nicely averted by a cry of "Have your attorney talk to my attorney", self-proclaimed psychic Sylvia Browne threatened to sue Robert Lancaster, manager of a website devoted to debunking Browne's claims. Her — or her lawyers' — argument was that by (back then) calling his site "Stop Sylvia Browne", Lancaster was infringing trademark: his use of her name, the claim went, "misleads the consumer as to the source or affiliation". They were arguing that someone reading his site, on which nearly every word criticized Sylvia Browne, might mistake it for Browne's own website. Mr. Lancaster had his own lawyers reply to this blatant attempt at a SLAPP; Ms. Browne's lawyers have not to date followed up.
- A similar story revolves around Glenn Beck and the memetic website, "Did Glenn Beck Rape and Murder A Young Girl in 1990?"
- When David Letterman left NBC for CBS, NBC threatened to sue him if he used intellectual property from Late Night such as "Stupid Pet Tricks" and the Top Ten list. The problems with this include top ten lists preceding Letterman's show, and the fact that Stupid Pet Tricks actually came from a show which Letterman legally owned the intellectual property of. When both Letterman and Jay Leno mocked them for it, the issue was dropped.
- Orly Taitz. Despite her numerous lawsuits (all claiming that Barack Obama is not a US citizen and therefore ineligible to be president) being tossed out of court left, right and center; being fined $20,000 effectively for wasting the court's time and a public perception that she is completely barking mad, she keeps right on filing them. She has only been granted a hearing once (in 2012, to challenge the Georgia primary), and the President - named as the defendant - did not even send a lawyer; Taitz's testimony clearly only worsened the judge's opinion, as he still ruled against her. The Drudge Report described the hearing as, "Empty Table 1, Orly Taitz 0".
- Universal Studios once tried to sue Nintendo and several other companies selling Donkey Kong merchandise over allegations that it infringed on the King Kong copyright. What makes this frivolous is that not only was King Kong a Public Domain Character, but Universal themselves had proven he was such in an earlier lawsuit. Furthermore, the judge ruled that even if there had been a copyright, Universal still wouldn't have had a case, saying that, at best, Donkey Kong was a parody of King Kong. Needless to say, they lost, and were forced to pay back every bit of money they had gotten plus damages. Nintendo was so grateful to the lawyer who defended them in the lawsuit that they gave him exclusive rights to name his yachts "Donkey Kong" and later named a successful video game franchise after him. The lawyer's name was John Kirby. To make it even sweet, Nintendo later (successfully) sued Universal for their King King video game, which was itself a blatant ripoff of Donkey Kong.
- In a joke/urban legend somebody insured his cigars against fire; after smoking them all, he tried to collect the insurance. The insurance company turned the table on him by charging him with arson.
- Spike Lee's attempt to sue the then-newly-renamed Spike TV. The common joke at the time quickly became wondering if he was going to sue railroad spikes next.
- There are a couple of lawsuits pending against Casey Anthony, the Florida woman who was tried and acquitted of murdering her daughter, but one complaint filed in October of 2012 was pretty absurd. A Pennsylvania woman sought $3 billion in damages for psychological and emotional distress, claiming that Anthony was a member of the Illuminati who told the plaintiff that she would poison her water and that the plaintiff had secret cameras lodged behind her eyes watching her every move. (A full copy of the complaint can be found here.) The lawsuit was thrown out before a judge could even consider it.
- Singer Lady Miss Kier, of the former group Deee-Lite (of "Groove Is In The Heart" fame) sued Sega, claiming that popular space reporter Ulala of the Space Channel 5 dance game series was created based on her likeness. She promptly lost the lawsuit, as Sega claimed that the creators of Ulala did not even know who Lady Miss Kier or Deee-Lite were when they created her.
- Monster Cable Products will threaten to sue (and has occasionally filed suit against) anyone who uses the word "Monster" to sell anything. Monster Energy Drink, Monsters, Inc.., Monster Mini Golf, and Monster.com have all been pressured by the company.
- A woman is suing P. Diddy for $1 trillion for causing 9/11 and also for allegedly date-raping her and impregnating her 24 years ago. $900 billion is for child support and $100 billion is for loss of income. This is roughly the GDP of a decent-sized country (2010, Mozambique). Diddy himself is one of the most successful entrepreneurs in hip hop, and he's worth only about half a billion.
- Record labels want $75 trillion for copyright-related damages. That's five times the US national debt in 2011, and more money than exists on the planet (global GDP is somewhere on the order of US$61 Trillion).
- The fact that Private Eye do actually lose a lot of libel cases means that anyone who gets criticized in the magazine thinks it's worth a shot. Most of them receive "the reply given in Arkell v. Pressdram". In one recent example, the owners of The Daily Telegraph threatened to sue over a spoof Telegraph front page treating their own financial arrangements like the MP expenses scandal the paper broke. The Eye pointed out that this was clearly in the "joke" section of the magazine, and could no more be mistaken for a real Telegraph headline than The New Coalition Academy could be mistaken for a real school newsletter. Allegedly it is considered a mark of seniority amongst the relevant section of the English Bar, much like the first time one buys a round for their old man, or first drives a car, to have represented Pressdram Inc. (the Eye's publisher) in a court case. Of course, this may simply be the Memetic Badass-ery of Private Eye as a maniacal offending machine.
- The Room director Tommy Wiseau made a laughingstock of himself when he threatened lawsuits to various negative video reviews of the film, claiming that their use of clips from the film violated copyright (the use of short excerpts for the purpose of criticism is protected by the Fair Use section of the U.S. Copyright Act and backed up by extensive court precedent). Most notably, among his targets were two videos on That Guy with the Glasses, whose massive fanbase put Wiseau on the end of an Internet Counterattack of epic proportions. They eventually got him to back down, and the reviews are now back up.
- A famous Pepsi ad showed a series of goodies a kid could get for turning in Pepsi points, culminating in a Harrier jet with the caption "7,000,000 POINTS." Some kid actually tried to purchase one with a $700,000 check at ten cents a point (actual unit price of an AV-8B Harrier II is $30 million), and sued Pepsi when they declined.note Among other things, he demanded a jury composed of "The Pepsi Generation" to hear his claim. The judge threw the case out, noting that any reasonable person would get the joke. Although, just to be safe, this made any company who uses a similar gag in their ads start including some "prize not actually available" legalese.
- Katy Perry (stage name) tried to sue an Australian fashion designer named Katie Perry (birth name) to stop Katie from using her real name for her label. Katy Perry eventually dropped the suit because it was ridiculous.
- Al Franken was sued by the Fox News Channel for his book Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them: A Fair and Balanced Look at the Right for using Fox News's motto: "Fair and Balanced". The judge heard both sides' arguments and told them he needed a moment to consider. He stepped out of the courtroom for two seconds before returning and saying, "Your (Fox's) claim is completely without merit, both legally and factually."
- A man named Leroy Greer bought flowers from 1-800 Flowers with a love note. That wasn't a big deal...until a "Thank you for doing business with us" letter came in the mail to his home and was found by his wife. She had not received any flowers, nor had she any knowledge of a recent floral purchase, so she called the company to see what was up. Turns out some flowers had been purchased...for another woman he was seeing on the side.note So he decided to sue the florist's ass off for delivering the thank-you note, even though that's their standard business procedure and they had sent it to his (and his soon-to-be-ex-wife's) house... because now that there was proof of adultery, he was going to have to pay his soon-to-be-ex-wife a higher settlement.
- While this is definitely the "will be laughed out of court ten seconds later" version, a guy in late 2007 who drove under the influence of booze, Xanax, and cocaine and killed three people (a couple and the wife's mom) on Christmas Day (a fourth, the wife's stepfather, died a few years later, and injuries from that accident did play some part) decided that wasn't bad enough and added epic douchebaggery to his rap sheet: Why not countersue the victims (which means the victims' families, since the victims are slightly dead) for "pain and suffering," "mental anguish," and the "loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life" (y'know, 'cause you can't enjoy life while in prison for driving while hammered and stoned and killing three, now four, innocent people.)
- The drunk driver lost his countersuit in 2012 when a jury found that he and he alone was responsible for the crash. Relatives of the victims settled their civil suit against the driver for $1 million.
- The Babylonian Code of Hammurabi actually had specific rules set in place to prevent these. If no evidence could be found to support a claim or the plantiff was found to be using false witness, the plantiff could be executed. Bear in mind this wasn't put in place as a preventative measure. The Code of Hammurabi wasn't a codified set of laws, so much as a list of legal decisions Hammurabi had made in the past, meaning he actually had put at least one person to death for a frivolous lawsuit.
- Häagen-Dazs, an American ice cream company who designed their name to sound Scandinavian, once brought the American ice cream company Frusen Glädjé (whose name means "Frozen Joy" in Swedish if you remove the accent that was put there to help Americans pronounce it right) to court. Why? Because the Häagen-Dazs people considered it false advertising that Frusen Glädjé were using a Scandinavian-sounding name despite being American. Since Häagen-Dazs were doing the exact same thing with their name (which actually sounds German to most Scandinavians), the court found that by the doctrine of "unclean hands" (you cannot sue someone else for doing something when you yourself are doing the exact same thing), Häagen-Dazs was barred from suing Frusen Glädjé or indeed anyone else over using faux-Scandinavian names to market ice cream. If you're wondering who could bring such a suit: Only an actual Scandinavian company marketing ice cream with a "We're Scandinavian!" schtick would have grounds, but even then they wouldn't be particularly likely to prevail.
- One (most likely a hoax) example in China centered around a man who sued his wife just because she gave birth to an ugly baby, under the reasoning that they were both so beautiful that there was no possible way that they could have produced an ugly baby and therefore she must have been cheating on him. Even more galling was the fact that he won, getting 120,000 dollars.
- A similar case happened in South Korea, where the man instead ordered a paternity test to find out if his wife had cheated on him; when it came out she did not, he found out she had a lot of facial operations in the past. It's said he apologized to her for mistrust and she accepted the apology. The child will probably get similar operations later.
- John Fogerty, of Creedence Clearwater Revival fame, was once sued for $140 million for plagiarizing himself. Saul Zaentz of Fantasy Records alleged that Fogerty's song "The Old Man Down the Road," from his solo 1985 album "Centerfield," was a remake of CCR's "Run Through the Jungle," to which Zaentz owned the copyright. Fogerty won; although the case ended up in the U.S. Supreme Court, it was over a technical matter (namely, whether Fantasy Records would have to pay Fogerty's attorney's fees after Fantasy's appeal was smacked down by the Ninth Circuit; the Supreme Court, evidently CCR fans, granted Fogerty's motion).
- Country music star Tim McGraw was sued for delivering a contractually obligated album too early. Curb Records alleged that McGraw's recordings had to be "topical and new," and delivered within a specific window of time after his last album. McGraw countersued and, as in the Fogerty case, the label lost. McGraw now records for Big Machine Records. Curb released the "too early" album, "Emotional Traffic," in 2012.
- Yoko Ono filed a lawsuit against singer Lennon Murphy to keep her from performing under the name "Lennon". That's right, Yoko tried to keep someone from using their own name for musical purposes. Ono eventually lost the case.
- Scenario: You're attending a prestigious university for free because your father is a professor there. You don't attend/participate in class. You get a C+, and as a result you don't get the career you wanted. Logical solution: Sue the university for 1.3 million dollars, accusing your (female) professor of sexual discrimination.
- In December 2012, Sega filed a lawsuit against Level-5 for 900 million yen (US $11 million) alleging that Inazuma Eleven infringes on 2 of Sega's patents by using drag-and-drop and tap commands on a touchscreen to control multiple characters at once, i.e. using the Nintendo DS touchscreen as a freaking touchscreen. In quite possibly the most epic pwning ever to happen via corporate public statement, Level-5 responded by calmly pointing out that Sega's 2 patents in question are dated 2009 and 2011, whereas Inazuma Eleven was released in 2008, then proceeding to basically call out Sega for patent trolling.
- Silicon Knights' example led to their termination. A year before the release of Too Human, Silicon Knights sued Epic Games over selling them a version of the Unreal Engine 3 that was allegedly glitchy and flawed. However, in a twist of fate, Epic counter-sued them, citing unauthorized modifications to the engine and the lack of credit or royalties Epic was given. After five years of arguing, the court ruled in favor of Epic, and Silicon Knights was fined $13 million for damages as a direct result. In addition, they were ordered by the court to recall and eradicate all unsold copies of Too Human, their later project, X-Men: Destiny, the game codes using the modified engine, and any other future projects planned.
- Games Workshop apparently has attempted to copyright the term Space Marine (which needless to say is older than the Mega Corp. itself) so it is in the position to sue any fiction or people using it which they certainly will if their frequent use of copyright infringement lawsuits is any indications. Bungie and Blizzard are said to be prepared.
- They did use it to take Spots The Space Marine off Amazon, but a few months later the e-book was reinstated after massive Internet Backlash. And the revelation that their trademark is only for gaming material.
- Oddly enough, Games Workshop only started doing things like that after they got the The Lord of the Rings license and their lawyers had to start dealing with Saul Zaentz, who, as mentioned above, sued John Fogerty for plagiarizing himself.
- The 1976 swine flu vaccination campaign was followed by a wave of lawsuits claiming that the vaccine was responsible for a couple thousand cases of Guillain–Barré syndrome that occurred shortly after the patient received a shot, despite over 40 million people being vaccinated and numerous studies showing that the odds of developing the disorder were no higher after immunization than before.
- In late 2004, Colt Defense LLC (the military/law enforcement/security forces, separate from the civilian-oriented parent company) sued both Bushmaster Firearms and Heckler & Koch for trademark infringement due to them releasing "M4-branded" weapons (in particular H&K's "HKM4" and Bushmaster's "M4 type weapons"), but also that the visual look of the weapons was recognized as an indicator of the brand (trade dress). H&K settled out of court and changed their weapon's name to HK416, but Bushmaster separated their suit from H&K's, got the case moved to a court in their home state and moved for a summary judgment that in fact Colt's federal trademark on the term M4 should be cancelled because the term M4 was itself generic, arguing that "relevant" customers and trade publications were treating the term as genericnote , while at least fifteen different manufacturers had previously been allowednote to market their similar-looking weapons with the M4 name. Not only was the judgment granted based in part on the above arguments and evidence, but the district court opinion and the subsequent U.S. appeals court opinion both pointed out that there was however-limited evidence that Colt itself had used the term M4 in a generic manner, and the term M4 referring to a particular 'style' of weapon was a military-issued designation, not a term originated by Colt. And when Colt was pressed to offer an appropriate generic name besides M4 for this style of weapon:
Finally, Colt contends that evidence that there are words other than M4 to designate the product at issue was ignored. According to Colt, such evidence is probative of non-generic use because the existence of other suitable identifiers suggest that M4 is not a name for a type of gun but rather is an identifier of the brand of gun. Colt argues that the words carbine, rifle, and firearm are adequate alternative descriptors of the M4.
- The Russian government did this in 2012, believe it or not, suing Madonna for "propagandizing homosexual behavior" during a concert, in a hearing that bordered on the absurd. During the hearing, the prosecutor - who sought $10.7 million - claimed that the singer's so-called "propaganda of perversion" would negatively affect Russia's birthrate and erode the nation's defense capability by depriving the country of future soldiers. The judge almost had to tell court reporters to leave because they were laughing so much, and he eventually threw the case out. As you might expect, Madonna neither attended the hearing nor commented on the result.
- FunnyJunk vs. The Oatmeal. In short:
- Matthew Inman (creator of The Oatmeal) finds out FunnyJunk hosts copies of his comics without his permission, and posts an annoyed rant about it on his own website.
FunnyJunk hires a lawyer who claims Inman's post constitutes defamation of their site, and demands $20,000 in damages.
Inman refuses, and instead starts an Indiegogo campaign to raise $20,000 for the National Wildlife Foundation and the American Cancer Society (he ends up raising more than ten times that amount).
FunnyJunk's lawyer sues Inman, Indiegogo, the American Cancer Society, the National Wildlife Federation and a hundred anonymous Internet users, claiming they might commit charity fraud.
Finally, Inman proves he has donated all the money he had raised to charity, and FunnyJunk drops their lawsuit.
- Yes, you just read that correctly: FunnyJunk stole something and then tried to sue the rightful owner for complaining about it.
- It gets even more bizarre. The laywer that FunnyJunk hired? He proceeded to go completely insane and started suing everyone under the sun. He tried to sue a satire site about him for libel, however by doing so he managed to make himself into a public figure, and so the site was protected by parody laws. His wife started to rant about how anyone that criticized them were Nazis, etc. Net result was that he had to pay $46,100 to the satire site.
- Jesse Dimmick, who was running from a murder charge in Colorado, sued a couple he took hostage in Kansas for breach of contract after they broke their promise to hide him from the police. Thankfully the ridiculous lawsuit was dismissed and Dimmick was sentenced to 11 years for the kidnapping and 37 years for second-degree murder.
- In Italian law, every lawsuit must go to a judge before being possibly dismissed, with no punishment whatsoever for it. Thus Italian courts have an enormous backlog for things like a woman suing her daughter in law for not following the family (of the mother in law) recipe for a particular dish, or a stupid crook getting sued for attempting a bank robbery by the same people who foiled and beat him up.
- Filing a lot of these against a single person is in and of itself a crime, called "Litigious Harrassment".
- The Tetris Company owns the chiptune rendition of the Russian folk song Korobenieinki (Tetris track "A"), and files SLAPP suits against any game company that uses it, along with descending tetrominoes (those domino-like shapes the game is famous for). They'll even sue over things it's impossible to copyright for.
- The video game Zodas Revenge on the NES has the player tracking down magic Tetrads, which are in the shape of the classic Tetris blocks. Well aware of the Tetris company's history of the above lawsuits, the Tetrads were renamed "blocks" in the game's Virtual Console re-release on the Wii.
- The infamous "Superheated McDonald's Coffee" suit often held high up as the epitome of this, is actually an aversion. The facts of the case:
- The plaintiff, Stella Liebeck, was a 79-year-old Albuquerque, New Mexico resident who purchased coffee from the drive-through of a local Mickey D's. She was riding in her grandson's car at the time, which had no cup holders, so she had to hold the coffee cup in her lap while attempting to add cream and sugar. She accidentally spilled the entire cup of coffee in her lap while attempting to undo the lid and happened to be wearing cotton sweatpants. Since cotton clothing absorbs liquids very easily, the hot coffee was held very close to her skin for several seconds, which produced a mix of second and third degree burns over roughly 22% of her skin in total (6% of her skin, including her buttocks and groin, suffered the third degree burns and required skin grafting to mend; 16% of her skin in surrounding areas suffered second degree burns).
- McDonald's refused several pre-trial attempts to settle for something closer to the projected total damages of twenty thousand dollars, calculated from the cost of medical expenses and lost income. They insisted upon settling for a measly eight hundred dollars, which would have been insufficient to cover Liebeck's losses.
- It was revealed in evidence examination that McDonald's made serving its coffee at 180-190 degrees Fahrenheit mandatory, which meant the coffee was capable of causing serious burns in as little as seven to twelve seconds of continuous exposure, which is very possible if a plaintiff happened to be wearing cotton sweatpants. McDonald's had actually compensated several hundred other individuals for burns sustained by their coffee before Liebeck, yet found that number to be too small to consider altering company policy. Several other restaurants had no such policy, and instead served their coffee at temperatures ranging from 140-160 degrees. It was also revealed that while the coffee cups did have a warning attached, the warning was not sufficiently visible. Subsequent to the damage award, McDonald's increased the size of the warnings, made the cups sturdier, and started keeping its coffee at a lower temperature.
- Finally, Liebeck was awarded around $2.7 million by trial jury and was, in fact, deemed partially at fault, but the brunt of the initial award was in punitive damages. Following an appeal, the total amount awarded was projected to be around $610,000, and Liebeck and McDonald's reached an undisclosed settlement out of court.
- One P.S.: because Liebeck's troubles were caused by the fact that she had to hold her coffee between her thighs, many car companies realized that she could have easily sued the auto manufacturer (in that case, Ford) for failure to include cup holders. Thus, starting in the late 1990s, Cup Holders have become standard equipment for most cars.
- This hasn't stopped others from trying to cash in on it too though, as seen when one woman tried to sue McDonalds for hot coffee burns and was found to have copied the burn photos she attempted to use as proof off the internet. She's now facing 21 counts of felony insurance and workers' compensation fraud.
- UK-based broadcasting company British Sky Broadcasting sued Microsoft over the name of their SkyDrive service, which they claimed was copyright infringement. Despite the questionable legality of the suit (BSkyB isn't in the cloud storage business and has no plans to enter it), Microsoft ended up having to change the name of their service to OneDrive to shut them up.
- Scenario: You order a Quarter Pounder at McDonald's and they only give you one napkin. Solution: Sue McDonald's for $1.5 million, alleging that the incident has left you unable to work due to "undue mental anguish".
- In a case still under consideration (but which will obviously be thrown out), Manhattan resident Anton Purisima is suing New York City, the Au Bon Pain bakery, two local hospitals, Kmart and a "Latina" dog owner (apparently he tried to sue everyone he could think of) for two undecillion dollars (That's a two followed by thirty-six zeroes. As What If? points out, that's more than the entirety of everything every produced in the history of mankind plus the estimated worth of every animal, vegetable and mineral on the planet.) He seeks damages for "civil rights violations, personal injury, discrimination on national origin, retaliation, harassment, fraud, attempted murder, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and conspiracy to defraud", making numerous absurd claims. The full story is here.
- A man fell asleep in the midst of a Yankees-Red Sox baseball game, during which the announcers noticed and commented on. A video of this was then published on the MLB's website, and the Internet, being the Internet, began making fun of him for it. The man decided to sue the MLB and ESPN over this, apparently believing they are the ones throwing the insults around. The lawsuit even calls out an apparent attempt to imply he's gay, completely oblivious to the fact that this is from a parody website and not the MLB's site.
- Recently, a nurse by the name of Sara Hellwege applied for a position at a family-planning clinic in Tampa, Florida. She did not get the position. Why? She mentioned during the application process that she had moral objections to administering certain types of birth control, even though doing so would have explicitly been part of her duty. She claims that hormonal contraceptive methods (such as the Pill) are abortifacients.note (There were no positions available that would allow her to work there without having to administer birth control, or the methods she objected to.) That's right; she essentially told HR that she wouldn't be able to work if she were hired! She's now suing the clinic for religious discrimination.
- The maker of Candy Crush Saga sued the Banner Saga because of the word "saga", claiming that it could cause confusion and that the two games are closely related. See for yourself how closely this◊ is related to this◊. One is a viking strategy-rpg with a lot of blood and pillaging, the other is a causal game of clicking on glittering candies. Also, the word "saga" actually means a "viking heroic story", much more befitting a game about vikings. Still, the makers of Candy Crush Saga basically believe they own the words "candy" and "saga", and sue anyone who uses them even in completely unrelated games.
- Narrowly averted in the spat between games journalist Jim Sterling and Imminent Uprising. Sterling posted a first impressions video of the Slaughtering Grounds and was very critical of the game. After personally insulting Sterling for about a week, the game's developer- Imminent Uprising- issued a copyright takedown of Sterling's video. This page could go on forever for how often this has happened to critics and Let's Players whose videos were actually protected by Fair Use, but Imminent Uprising believed that Sterling's video was not covered under Fair Use because his comments were not fair.note Imminent Uprising threatened to follow through with their claim and take Sterling to court. Sterling filed a counter-claim, Imminent Uprising never followed through with their threat, and after two weeks of inaction the video was put back on Youtube. Imminent Uprising will still argue with anyone who will listen on their forums that they're in the right, that Sterling is personally responsible for the game's financial failure, but that they just don't have time to bother with the legal proceedings.
- Red Bull recently settled a class-action lawsuit out of court. The reason the lawsuit came about in the first place? According to Benjamin Careathers, the man who led the charge in filing suit, "consumers of the drink did not benefit from any mental or physical enhancements, though the product states in its advertisement that it 'gives you wings'." Yeah. They sued Red Bull because, shocker of shockers, it doesn't actually give you wings. And this is ignoring that "actually, Red Bull [what energy drinks are supposed to do]" could be construed as a disclaimer.
- Three recent examples from Poland.
- A local Polish company named a.pl was sued by Apple because of similarity in names; the Apple lawyers argued that the two companies are "easy to get confused". That's right - it's hard to distinguish a local company specializing in delivering fresh fruits and vegetables to stores from an internationally-known megacorporation dabbling in electronics. The case never made it to the court.
- Similarly, Red Bull threatened to sue a charity organization, because it is named "Give the Children Wings", while Red Bull's slogan is "Gives You Wings". Someone in the company must have noticed that suing a charity organization that operates on a strictly non-profit basis and helps poor children is not necessarily the smartest PR move, because Red Bull withdrew their suit.
- A truly stunning 2011 case. When a movie called Kac Wawa was released, it was completely reviled by the critics note , and as a result, the audiences stayed away and the movie flopped severely note . As a result, the producers tried to sue one of the movie's major detractors, the famed critic Tomasz Raczek, to compensate for their financial losses. No attorney was crazy enough to pick up the case.
- A woman in Seattle was sued by her neighbor for for several hundred thousand dollars because her dog's barking caused him mental anguish and also caused him hearing damage as the barking reached volumes of 120 decibels. (That's louder than an ambulance siren and only slightly softer than a jet engine during takeoff). The woman ignored the lawsuit- since it was obviously frivolous and would never stand up in court- and the neighbor won the suit by default because she didn't respond. Now she's at risk of losing her home and it's going to take some serious legal fees for lawyers to overturn the lawsuit.
- A company that produced prefabricated steel buildings was investigated by California and Colorado authorities for deceptive sales practices (the buildings were fine, but the company misrepresented some important characteristics) under their respective states' consumer protection laws after receiving complaints from dissatisfied customers; these authorities sue. What does the company do? Sue the authorities, the consumers, the Better Business Bureau (which had taken complaints and directed consumers to the authorities), a competitor founded by a disgruntled former employee, and several media outlets for "conspiracy"note to make it appear that the company was violating consumer protection laws. The funny thing is that because the conspiracy laws are so complicated, this technically wasn't a frivolous suit—it's too hard to prove that they didn't have a chance. That said, when the judge in the case brought by the Colorado authorities made his ruling, he said it was "obvious" that the company had violated the law—something judges don't say lightly when there's parallel litigation on the issue, basically amounting to saying "I could say that the other suit is frivolous, but I won't because that wouldn't be quite right."