Oswald: Forget it. I don't wanna talk about this.A character's assumed actual romantic preference or even sexual orientation is made moot because of the setting or limitation of the plot. This frequently occurs with characters stuck in a gender-biased population. (see: Bishoujo Series and Cast Full of Pretty Boys). Even if there's a theoretical pool of candidates off-screen, savvy writers know the audience likely doesn't care. This arises when writers apply standard romantic tropes to quirkier settings without major modification and without the explicit intent to make a plot point about it. If the situation developed after the plot is well underway, this may also be Suddenly Sexuality, or at least played as such. Some writers are fully aware of the implication and the fandom it produces and might cater to both sides of the topic, making one character very enthusiastic about the idea, while one is humorously much more hesitant. A common by-product of this trope is the rejection of a newly introduced "common" romantic prospect, not because of a strong pre-existing fanship, but simply that they never reach the popularity of the existing cohort. Not to be confused with If It's You, It's Okay. For particularly cliched situations where this may occur, see Schoolgirl Lesbians, Girls Behind Bars, and Hello, Sailor!. In a much darker context, this is often associated with Prison Rape; in an isolated agrarian setting with Vulgar Humor, the targets of Situational Sexuality often walk on four legs.
Lewis: No, no, I'm curious. Let's say you're in prison, and you're not getting out for a very long time. Plus, your parents? Very understanding. Who's your cellmate?
Oswald: ...Liam Neeson.
Drew: (wrapping an arm around Oswald's shoulders) Aye, laddie!
Lewis: No, no, I'm curious. Let's say you're in prison, and you're not getting out for a very long time. Plus, your parents? Very understanding. Who's your cellmate?
Oswald: ...Liam Neeson.
Drew: (wrapping an arm around Oswald's shoulders) Aye, laddie!
— The Drew Carey Show, first episode
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Maria-sama ga Miteru is the famous all-girls example. Though it has a nearby all-boy's school, that's mostly used as a plot device rather than any real threat to the shippers. Its male-oriented demographic twin Strawberry Panic! pretty much abandons that idea.
- And the two lead characters avert the trope entirely: they are quite thoroughly lesbian, as illustrated by the manga's epilogue that takes place after high school.
- Gakuen Heaven, Sukisho and Hana-Kimi for BL versions.
- Everyone in Simoun's world is female until age 17, which makes all teenage romance Schoolgirl Lesbians by default.
- Vandread reverses it. The two cultures start off unfamiliar with the idea of gender at all, but when encountering each other for the first time, some of the women and all three of the captured men turn out to be straight (or at least bi). Not that they have any idea why they find the "aliens" more attractive than their own kind...
- Saber Marionette J, where the world is all male because the only survivors of the spaceship crash were male, and since not-so-logically everyone is a clone from the DNA of those six, there aren't any women. If they can do cloning, why can't they do X-chromosome duplication? Never mind. Oddly enough Robot Girls in the series are mostly treated as impressive machines, but Hanagata is the only real obviously gay character. It is shonen, after all. The manga states outright that lack of women is the reason for most of the homosexual relationships on Terra 2.
- Indirectly affects Yu-Gi-Oh!; no doubt one of the main reasons there's so much Yaoi Fic in this fandom is the dearth of female characters and overabundance of Bishōnen.
- One storyline in the manga Gohou Drug involves the characters infiltrating an all male boarding school, where almost all the guys are gay simply because there are no girls around. One student even explains this trope directly to the main character.
- The Arume in Blue Drop form a race that only consist of women, but they manage to produce offspring with the aid of technology. After conquering the earth they still appear to be mostly interested in the women though.
- Also happens with Earth's people in the manga, Tenshi no Bokura. The Arume keep the humans segregated by gender, so the girls grow up lesbian due to Arume... influence. Males resort to homosexuality out of necessity, although one of a pair often crossdresses.
- There is absolutely no appearance or mention of any female in Boys Love anime Sukisho, and the Valentine's Day episode shows many gay couples walking around. There is no explanation for this, females simply seem to not exist. The lead character's reaction to gayness still goes from absolutely-unbothered to completely-freaked-out (and oblivious-to-his-roommate-in-denial).
- In Ooku, the titular Inner Chambers of the female Shogun's palace are rife with male homosexual behavior; from late night "hazing" of newcomers to Bishōnen sleeping their way into better positions to rather ordinary romances and crushes. This is all the more surprising to newcomers to the Shogun's service because the gender ratio outside the Royal Harem is severely skewed in favor of women and the lack of men makes sperm worth its weight in gold, impossible to imagine wasting on coupling that will never produce a child. Meanwhile, many merchant and peasant women lust after male-impersonator kabuki actresses because men that attractive are completely out of their price range, and noblewomen often have lesbian romantic and sexual relationships because their arranged marriages are purely for conceiving female heirs.
- Axis Powers Hetalia. Female countries exist and will often get attention or give attention to the male characters, but they're few and far in between.
- Togainu no Chi
- Jyu-Oh-Sei: Women are very scarce on Chimera, and tend to live separately from men. As a result, a lot of otherwise straight men aren't against going for the next best thing (read: Thor).
- An example of either this or Bi the Way appears in Black Lagoon, Revy states that she had sex with women in prison, however, her love interest is a guy. Fans debate whether her interest in women extends outside of prison, since in context she was referencing being with women as a threat to make another woman her bitch for making a pass at said male love interest.
- Ai no Kusabi has homosexual relationships being very common because women are rare.
- In Neon Genesis Evangelion, Shinji has some Homoerotic Subtext with Kaworu. Although Shinji's sexuality is never stated, one possibility is that he's straight but too lonely to care that the only person to show him some affection happens to be an Ambiguously Gay boy.
- In Y: The Last Man, a lot of women are with other women as a substitute, but a lot simply go without, as many of them had before the "Gendercide". There are also some women who make a decent living as escorts who dress up like and pretend to be men for their clients.
- Writers of Wonder Woman throw around hints that Themyscira has embraced this sort of mindset: some of the women are chaste, some of them are seeing Rosie Palms, and the rest pair up.
- The more juvenile writers, usually the ones who get a chance to briefly play with the character in another title, throw around hints. The main series itself has straightforwardly confirmed it multiple times, though quietly.
- Diana does some traditional courtship rituals with her boyfriend Nemesis, he asks how a society of only women has such things.
- A throwaway line a while ago basically said Queen Hippolyta is in a relationship with General Phillipus, and Word of God confirmed it (as well as the fact that they intended to do a storyline where they got married before the editorial axed it).
- The Wonder Woman: Earth One Alternate Universe graphic novel by Grant Morrison (which basically retells the Golden Age Marston/Peters origin story in contemporary times with more explicit sexuality) makes it explicit (in dialogue, and to a PG-13 level visually) that most or all of the Amazons are lesbians and that Diana has a girlfriend at the beginning.
- The Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season Eight comics:
- Buffy, who is surrounded by fellow slayers (all women) and Xander, hooks up with fellow Slayer Satsu. It is shown as a result of Buffy feeling emotionally isolated (not to mention sexually-deprived), so she latches on to Satsu (who is genuinely in love with Buffy). This is similar to her relationship with Spike, where she also chose a unusual partner (a soulless corpse in that case) who was genuinely in love with her, in order to satisfy her (purely physical) needs (though at least Satsu she liked and respected, while she frequently professed outright disgust and rage at Spike during season six).
- Hilariously, it was Satsu who broke off the relationship with Buffy... and then spent an entire issue wangsting about Buffy rejecting her, despite this never having actually happened. Although, each time they slept together, Buffy kept saying that it was a mistake that should never have happened and it was dangerous for her to get romantically involved with anyone.
- Buffy also realized that she was starting to have feelings for Xander, who had been a Hopeless Suitor to her in the past. Unfortunately, he was already dating her younger sister Dawn by that point.
- Invoked in an issue of Adventures In The Rifle Brigade, where the brigade is captured and held in a Nazi prison camp. The female commandant accuses Captain Darcy (who definitely isn't gay) and Lieutenant Milk (who almost certainly is) of being lovers, since they both went to public school. Darcy dismissively and without a hint of shame replies "Everyone knows it doesn't count if it happens at school".
- With a setting that includes only two canonical male characters (and only one of them is even given a name!), this trope grows like kudzu in the Touhou fandom.
- That being said, ''Perfect Memento in Strict Sense'' illustrates (literally) that there are males in the human village. Whether or not any of the youkai girls would be interested (although the presence of Rinnosuke would indicate it's possible), the human characters should have their pick of straight options. However...
- Lord of the Flies fanfiction is often subject to this, since there are no female characters...period.
- The Team Fortress 2 characters are seen (and promptly used) as such. As best said by Kytri, author of Cuanta Vida, "I think of most of the characters as being straight, you just wouldn't notice since there's no women around for them to be straight with."
- ISHBAL! The Musical!: Desperate Times is just full of this.
- 90% of the Glee fic set in Dalton Academy makes use of the Warblers' Cast Full of Pretty Boys.
- South Park fanfiction basically has an entire subgenre of the boys aged up in high school (to avoid the creepiness of slashing children), where the entire male cast is paired up like Noah's Ark. It's so prevalent that the series essentially has a "slash canon" in terms of pairings.
- Referenced in The Longest Yard (2005).
Caretaker (On the Camp Gay prisoners) - "Oh, they ugly now, but in eight months, he gonna look like Beyoncé."
- Referenced in In & Out:
Jack: There's only two times when that kind of thing's okay: In prison where it's a substitute and guys in space.Mike: Guys in space?Jack: Well, not on purpose. They just float into each other.
- There is evidence that both Jangle Leg and Biscuit in the movie Life are only together due to long prison terms and this trope. Jangle Leg is shown to be attracted to women (when they're around) and Biscuit can't bear to go home to his mom "like this", implying that he wasn't always gay (and flamboyant).
- The Decadents in Sexmission don't really have a choice. Once the Pill wears off, their sexual drive returns and there aren't any men around to hook up with. Come to think of it, if they were aware of Max and Albert, they still wouldn't know what to do with them, since there haven't been any men around for generations.
- The film Kiss of the Spider Woman follows two cellmates in an unidentified South American country. Since they spend all day locked up together, they become friends and eventually lovers. Played with in that one of them is openly and flamboyantly gay.
- Mädchen in Uniform takes place in a Prussian all-girls boarding school. The enclosed environment of the One-Gender School makes quite a sum of the girls express interest in their pretty teacher, Fräulein von Bernburg.
- In A Brother's Price, men are very rare. A group of sisters will marry one man together, but premarital sex is had with women, exclusively, if the woman in question is a decent person, as it just wouldn't do to defile someone's precious brother. (There is also the option to go to a "crib" to get pregnant, but this carries the danger of STD, and is avoided if at all possible.) While some women might actually be bisexual, it is implied that most would prefer men. There are female prostitutes part of whose job is to pretend to be men - their customers know they aren't, but some apparently like the illusion.
- In the Discworld series of books, dwarves embody this through most of the series. Both male and female dwarves wear the same clothes, have beards and so forth. Therefore, courtship for dwarves is described as delicately finding out the sex of a fellow dwarf. This starts to change through one female dwarf taking on Tertiary Sexual Characteristics and identifying as female, causing a large uproar in the dwarven community. While it does catch on, Unseen Academicals shows us there's also nothing stopping biologically male dwarves from doing the same thing.
- The Draka have no moral qualms with having sex with slaves, but it is very much more than a free woman's life is worth to wind up pregnant that way. Consequently, if straight Draka women fancy a bit of strange, it will have to be with a female slave; no-one thinks this at all shameful and a free woman is at liberty to have all the fun she likes with her own property. Men don't face the same problem.
- Rather baselessly averted in John Wyndham's Consider Her Ways. In the aftermath of a virus wiping out all men, a basically sexless society emerges. Wyndham seems to have utterly dismissed the possibility that women could form romantic relationships with each other, despite making a reference to Sappho at one point. He admitted that he put plot ahead of common sense in that one and seemed to regret it. Happens to the best of us.
- The Thin Red Line (the James Jones book that Terrence Malick's famous film is based on) discusses this notion and has several examples among its cast of characters.
- The Wheel of Time has what are euphemistically referred to as "pillow friends", especially among initiates in the White Tower, where girls are isolated from men (and the world altogether) and would have problems anyway due to their powers and extended lifespan. Treated as a very private matter and not looked down upon, most of these relationships dissolve upon completing the long training process, anyway, though not always. See also Schoolgirl Lesbians. All of the all-female organizations have some mention of this. Complicated by the fact that "pillow friends" can refer to a platonic friendship, since sharing a bed isn't always sexual - it's just as often that one of the friends has been punished and wants to cry herself to sleep on a friend's shoulder.
- A comparably extremely brief allusion to a male equivalent in The Empire's military companies occurs in Knife of Dreams during Tuon's point-of-view. Enough to get the idea that it exists, but the author isn't as interested in writing about it.
- In Tanya Huff's The Enchantment Emporium the Gale clan usually keeps things in the family and there are more female Gales than male so they tend, in the words of one of them, to be "enthusiastically undiscriminating".
- The implications of this going on for generations are considered as a minor theme in Robert A. Heinlein's The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress.
- This has been a problem in the past at the main character's boarding school in The Confusions of Young Törless, initially part of why he doesn't intervene in the mistreatment of his classmate Basini.
- Possible case with Daenerys Targaryen of A Song of Ice and Fire, who becomes intimate with her handmaiden Irri. She wasn't exactly short on men at the time, but rather men who she trusted.
- Cersei ends up bedding (to some degree) one of her female friends, but she finds no pleasure in the act.
- The planet Athos in Ethan of Athos. Originally founded as a "monastery planet" by a religious cult who believed that women were the cause of all male sin, it has since evolved into a society where most men pursue non-religious professions. Reproduction is accomplished via Uterine Replicator technology. However, their religious culture forbids even depictions of women and censors all Galactic media. Thus most Athosian men will never even see a woman, nor have their ancestors going back generations. Homosexual relationships are therefore the norm, although some men, implied to be strongly heterosexual (and who are though of on Athos as holding a very strict view of the Founding Fathers intent,) remain celibate instead.
- This is implied to happen a lot in the society of the Masters in The Stone Dance of the Chameleon. The Masters place a tremendously high value on blood purity, so much so that their women are not allowed to leave their house, except when they get married off and are instead kept at their husband's house. As such, males often form very intense emotional and sexual relationships with each other.
- Sword at Sunset: A Battle Couple of cavalry captains tried it out while on campaign and never looked back.
- In the Against the Tide of Years, Kat Hollard has a short-lived fling with a Babylonian girl, because she's horny and the other girl has a bit of a crush on her. Nothing really comes of it; Kat ends up getting married soon after.
Live Action TV
- One character attempted to use this as an excuse in Kröd Mändoon and the Flaming Sword of Fire.
General: "Do you have any idea how long I've been in that dungeon?"Krod: "Yeah. Two weeks. And it's co-ed, so..."
- The prison variant is discussed on The Sopranos.
Tony: Well, what are you gonna do? There's no women there! You're there five, ten years! (Beat) Just for the record, my incarceration was very short term, so I never had any need for any anal— you know. (...) You think I'm lying, don't you?
- T-Bag on Prison Break was very interested in his fellow male prisoners while behind bars, but as soon as he got out he seemed far more interested in women. The actor has described him as being an Anything That Moves kinda guy.
- Oz, being an HBO show set in a men's prison, was just as chock full of this trope as you'd imagine. Possibly more. Usually it's just pent-up sexual frustration, but in Tobias Beecher's case he actually fell in love with his cellmate Chris Keller after Beecher's wife committed suicide.
- Curtis/Melissa on Misfits. Curtis is straight. Melissa's a lesbian. They're the same person.
- Orange Is the New Black plays around with this trope:
- Protagonist Piper Chapman is definitely bisexual, and was involved with another woman in the past, but is engaged to a man at the time she goes to prison. In prison, however, she gets involved again with her old lover (also in prison).
- Another inmate, Lorna Morello, was also engaged to a man prior to her incarceration, but got involved with fellow prisoner Nicky Nichols, but breaks up with her out of guilt at being unfaithful. It was implied, however, that Morello is kidding herself that her engagement is still on, as her fiance has not visited or otherwise contacted her since her third week in prison (actually, later revealed that he wasn't her fiance but stalkee), and it's possible that her real reason for the break up is her issues over her sexuality; that is, that she's telling herself that she's not really gay.
- It is implied by one prisoner, Carrie "Big Boo" Black, that her former lover, Mercy, was not really gay, although whether that was true or was only an expression of jealousy over the fact that Mercy had left her for another prisoner, Tricia Miller, is debatable; Mercy quickly lost contact with Tricia following the former's release.
- Downplayed with Maritza and Flaca, who attempt a one-time drunken kiss on the Christmas episode. They quickly let the experiment go, resuming their mostly platonic Romantic Two-Girl Friendship.
- Finally, discussed by the second season's Big Bad, Vee, who calls it 'gay for stay' and warns her surrogate daughter Taystee that it's a stain on one's reputation in her mind.
- During the Prison Arc of My Name Is Earl, this is a major plot point. The leaders of two rival prison gangs were placed in "the hole" together, in an attempt to resolve the conflict. After they wore themselves out fighting, they started talking to one another and found they had a lot in common. Soon, this grew into a friendship...and shortly after that, it was a full-on romantic relationship. Unfortunately, they felt they couldn't be together because their gangs wouldn't approve...so they would purposely start fights in the prison yard just to get a few moments together. Earl has to figure out how to help them be together without the gang fights.
- Played for laughs in the Married... with Children episode "Live Nude Peg", when Peggy hasn't had sex for such a long time that she starts finding Marcy attractive:
Peggy: It's been so long since someone touched me.Marcy: (puts her arm around Peggy) Poor Peggy. I'm so sorry.Peggy: You know, Marcy, that boyish cut really becomes you.Marcy: (takes her arm away) Well, Peggy, there must be something you can do. With Al.
- Possibly Hilarious in Hindsight after Amanda Bearce came out.
- If this isn't what Elvis Presley's "Jailhouse Rock" is about, then what the hell is it about?
Number forty-seven said to number three:"You're the cutest jailbird I ever did see.I sure would be delighted with your company,come on and do the Jailhouse Rock with me."
- The writers (and by their account Elvis himself) knew this was a gay line and thought it would be funny to put it in and see what happened. They said they put in lots of stuff like that, because they knew Elvis wouldn't have a problem with it.
- Played with in T-Pain's "Up Down":
- "She don't even like girls but a stack'll make her kiss her."
- Referenced in Mitch Benn is the 37th Beatle, when Mitch is talking about the criminalization of homosexuality "because as we all know, the way to stop people being gay is to put them in prison."
- World of Warcraft and indeed the entire Warcraft lore makes it fairly clear that all male Night Elves went into the Emerald Dream, while the females stayed in the material world. For several thousand years. Even after the awakening of the males, and the destruction of the world tree stripping the Night Elves of their immortality, there are hints and fluff pointing to this trope being in effect for the females at the very least.
- This, with a side order of Prison Rape, is how Enzai justifies its sheer number of possible homosexual encounters. What makes it all the more cruel is that the protagonist is genuinely gay.
- Morrigi in Sword of the Stars live their entire lives in a gender-separated society where the females live on planets and the males operate the starfleet, the two only rarely meeting for mating contracts. The game mentions off-handedly that the only 'stable' Morrigi relationships are homosexual ones.
- Toyed with in 1/0. Marcus, existing in a world consisting of only male characters, has no concept of women and tries to flirt with the guys instead. Tailsteak clarifies that Marcus isn't gay, "he's just settling for second best," then introduces a female character to clear things up for Marcus. (Said female character is gay, just to annoy the cast.)
- More or less the same situation as Y: The Last Man exists in the webcomic Angels 2200.
- Word of God is that all Erogenians in The Challenges of Zona are "situationally bisexual".
- Thief and Red Mage have a little discussion about this and elven prisons in 8-Bit Theater. Dumb Fighter then asks what "Situational Homosexuality" means, almost exactly referencing this trope by name..
- The presence of romance in most Transformers continuities combined with the fact that about 90% or more of the Transformer population is male leads to the insinuation that many Transformer romantic relationships must be male/male by default. The canon doesn't help. At all.
- And on the other gender of that age demographic, most My Little Pony shipping is between females, because of similar logic.note
- Present to a lesser extent in Friendship is Magic...where there ARE at least a decent amount of male/female shipping in fanfics.
- Subverted in the Family Guy episode "Perfect Castaway". Peter is stranded on an island with Quagmire, Joe, and Cleveland. Noting that there are no women and men have needs, he says they need to have an orgy. Cut to a shot of them piled on top of each other... and no one is horny.
- Atlantis in Ugly Americans turns out to be an entire Underwater City of this. Women don't have enough testosterone to survive the pressure down there, so they make do.
- Avery Bullock of American Dad! when he attended an all-boys boarding school as a kid. According to Bullock, every boy there did it.
"It was nothing sordid, just some boyish night poundings."
- The old Royal Navy was famously rife with "rum, sodomy, and the lash", and not all prison sex is Prison Rape. Until anti-sodomy laws were struck down in Britain, the only time that "buggery" was legal was "after ninety days at sea," at which point it was no longer a crime.
- One ex-prisoner writing about time inside said it's a mistake to think it's only about sex and a bigger mistake to think it's always rape. His words were
Until you've been there for over a year, you would not believe how starved you become of ordinary human affection and, to put it bluntly, love.
- As The Onion blurb in Our Dumb Century for August 15th, 1954 put it: "Let's Work Together to Pretend Our War-Time Homosexual Experiences Never Happened".
- Old joke about life on submarines, "150 people go down, 75 couples come up"
- Hence the phrase "Prison Gay", with the con asserting, despite the evidence, "I'm not gay"
- The ruggedly heterosexual Christopher Hitchens wrote about his gay experiences at boarding school, and maintained that everyone was at it, and anyone who said otherwise was lying.
- As also noted in Everyone Is Bi, many non-Western societies do not have much concept of "sexual orientation" as an immutable personal attribute and/or as a category distinct from gender. If such societies place high value on gender segregation or same-gender romantic friendships, they also often have a lot of situational homosexual behavior by people who otherwise appear to be purely heterosexual.
- Since China instituted its "One Child Policy", there has been a decline in female births, since male children are traditionally more desirable in Chinese culture, leading to a much larger number of men than women among the younger generations. Not coincidentally there has also been a marked increase in male homosexual behavior.
- Parthenogenesis: essentially, the female's eggs contain both X chromosomes. There are several species of lizards that ONLY produce offspring this way (no males). In fact, one female will mount another, which increases fertility.
- Others, due to the way that reptilian genetics can work, produce only males through this method.
- Plus bison and other animals with sex-segregated herds. You can only go so long without!
- Male gorillas too old to stay with their mother but too weak to claim their own troop of females will often form troops with each other on the fringe of another troop's territory. They have been observed to practice mating with each other.
- For that matter, homosexual behavior is much more common among zoo animals than among the same species in the wild, and is even displayed in captive species that in the wild are rarely or never homosexual (such as koalas). The same article briefly discusses this trope as applied to humans—40% of high school football players admit to having engaged in same-sex kissing or similar acts.
- While in heat, female rats and mice will often start humping each other in the absence of males. Ahem...
- Apparently cows have been known to mount each other while in heat, so much so that someone once invented a device which was glued to a cow's hind quarters and which popped up a little flag when such mating had taken place, as a sign to the farmer that it was time to fetch the bull.
- Birds tend to pair-bond (for the season, if not for life), and will bond with a same-sex partner if there are no opposite-sex partners available. However, the introduction of an opposite-sex individual usually breaks up the couple (apparently birds don't care much for the OT3). Needless to say, the member left in the lurch is usually not happy.