troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
What Do You Mean Its For Kids: Literature

  • The Alex Rider series by Anthony Horowitz. So, you think this is a fun-for-young-teens novel series? Not quite, the titular character is just a fourteen-year-old manipulated to work for MI6. He then endures many horrific things over a single year. This series can be considered the Neon Genesis Evangelion of Spy Fiction.
    • They have a large amount of violence, horror, some swearing, and one use of the word "balls".
  • Alfie's Home, an attack on homosexuals thinly disguised as a story about a boy who was molested by his uncle. It includes the sentences "Some [kids] called me names like 'Sissy', 'Faggot', 'Queer' and 'Homo'" and "Now, I realize I'm not gay". And it's a picture book, so it was aimed at toddlers. But don't take our word for it: That Guy with the Glasses will fill you in, along with the entire book's contents.
  • Animorphs features a lot more violence and horror than you would expect, despite being for kids.
    • To elaborate: Much of the series is a brutal deconstruction of Wake Up, Go to School, Save the World, and it's one of the clearest and most prevalent examples of War Is Hell in children's literature. By the start of the last book, The Beginning, they've spent three years fighting a horrific war, just trying to Hold the Line until the Andalites show up and bring enough of a fighting force to stop the Yeerks. None of the main characters are in anything even close to a healthy mental or emotional state. One of them sent his cousin to kill his brother, knowing she'd die too. And she agrees with his decision because she doesn't think she'd be able to function in normal life without the war anymore. Another spearheaded a plot to kill his own mother because she was the host for one of the Yeerks' leaders. A third was trapped in a body—and a species—not his own in the first book. It's much darker than its market would suggest.
  • Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events. A story about a man who murders just about every character in the series trying to kill three orphans to get their inheritance. This includes characters being eaten alive, death by harpoon gun, and the untold unmentionables who didn't escape the hospital fire. Completely justified, since it comes with the Snicket Warning Label.
  • The Chronicles of Prydain contains death, zombies, human sacrifice and much more.
  • Coraline. Full of distinctly Freudian terror, but the true creepiness of the book isn't always apparent to kids, who might see it as just a book about scary monsters.
  • Author Roald Dahl could be one of this trope's patron saints, with several of his children's novels serving as near-fixtures on challenged book lists for years. (His adult-aimed fiction falls under this trope's inverted counterpart.) Particularly controversial works include:
    • Charlie and the Chocolate Factory: Perhaps kidlit's defining Black Comedy, as naughty children are subjected to a variety of dreadful consequences ranging from near-drowning to falling down a garbage chute that leads to an incinerator. While the novel has the kids survive, they're very much changed for their experiences, and adaptations have played with their fates — they're ambiguous in the 1971 film, and the 2013 stage musical goes with Death by Adaptation (if they're lucky, they'll get a Disney Death, but only offstage). Making matters worse, the factory proprietor has No Sympathy for them! This doesn't even get into adaptation-specific twists and references: the 1971 film has the notorious boat ride and the line "I am now telling the computer exactly what it can do with a bar of chocolate!" The 2013 musical has multiple jokes about alcohol and/or drinking problems amongst the adult characters, while the lyrics are rife with references to classical composers, modern art, the Tao Te Ching, etc. — witty, but likely to be lost on kids.
    • Esio Trot: Mr. Hoppy, a Shrinking Violet who is in love with the woman below his balcony, Mrs. Silver, impresses her by buying many tortoises and using a mechanical gadget to take Mrs. Silver's tortoise Alfie up to his floor and send a larger tortoise down, to make it look like Alfie is growing bigger (Mrs. Silver was complaining that Alfie had only grown three ounces in the eleven years she had owned him; she once tells Mr. Hoppy that if he can make Alfie grow bigger, she'll be his slave for life. This alone raises quite a few eyebrows). This impresses Mrs. Silver enough to give Mr. Hoppy the courage to ask her to marry him, and she accepts. In short, a man gets what he wants through lies and deception!
    • The Witches: The very nature of the witches — a race of child-hating hags who live only to rid the world of them by any means neccessary, the crueler the better — is disturbing enough to put off sensitive adults.
  • Darkest Powers series is essentially the same as its dark, adult oriented The Otherworld sister series. It's somewhat toned down, basically just the sex and profanity taken out. Thus we have a series about teenagers trying to escape getting killed and one of them doesn't.
  • The Demonata, also by the real Darren Shan, is another ultra-violent horror series involving demons. And just like the Saga, it's meant for kids. Among the not-so-kid-friendly elements:
    • The Protagonist advocating smoking.
    • The same protagonist later witnessing the graphic (and well-described) aftermath of a demon summoning gone wrong.
    • The twelve-year-old protagonist fantasizing about his uncle's sexy best friend.
    • Said uncle's sexy best friend also, at one point "accidentally" spills milk all over her shirt, and calls the narrator in to help her out of it.
    • And, by book five, it all starts to go downhill.
  • Most of the people getting up in arms over the blunt descriptions of puberty and other "naughty" things found in The Diary of Anne Frank are forgetting the fact that the book was written by, you know, a 12-year-old girl dealing with things every 12-year-old girl goes through (well, minus the whole Nazi thing).
    • Except for the vast majority of people, who remember what the word "diary" means.
  • The Discworld kids' books.
    • The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents is deep (the rats are inventing their own morality as they go), terrifying (the rats face vicious terriers, powerful traps and a Mind Controling villain), and squicky (the "inventing their own morality" includes the idea that maybe they shouldn't eat other rats, or at least not the wobbly green bit, but the eyes are fine).
    • The Tiffany Aching novels have a preteen (to start with) witch facing various inhuman creatures, including the Queen of The Fair Folk (one of Pterry's nastier villains) and a being of pure hatred towards witches. The last book begins with an abusive father beating his pregnant daughter into a miscarriage, and nearly being lynched by his disgusted neighbors. All the books also feature references to sex, which become steadily less coded as they go on. Interestingly, Wintersmith and I Shall Wear Midnight don't use the "smaller hardback" format of Maurice and the first two Tiffany books, although they're still listed as "for younger readers". Terry's view is that all Discworld novels are aimed at anyone who understands the jokes.
  • The Stephen King book The Eyes of The Dragon was written at the request of one of King's children, who wanted him to write a children's book. However, that didn't stop King from including, among other things, a Sex Scene. While for the most part it is tamer than King's other books, there's still a lot in there to scar a child for life.
  • The entire point of the Star Wars Expanded Universe series Galaxy of Fear was to be a horror series for kids, a la Goosebumps. Body Horror and Mind Screws abounded to the point where the book that revolved around ghosts was the least scary of the twelve. Hell, they introduced a planet that eats people alive in the very first book. Other lovely highlights include worms that suck the marrow out of your bones so that the empty space can be filled with a serum that makes you an unwitting zombie, a machine that traps you in your own nightmares, forcible conversion into a B'omarr brain spider, swarms of beetles that eat you from the inside out, other humans who also think your flesh is tasty, and some of the sickest Mad Scientists in the Star Wars universe. Good God, everywhere these kids go people die like flies! Special mention goes to the psychological trauma that goes with the question "If clones made of you have all your memories and think they are you, how do you know you yourself aren't a clone?
    • Special mention to the constant Adult Fear of having lost your entire family but one, and having that one constantly in danger.
  • The Gone series by Michael Grant was made with teenagers in mind, but the books contain such extreme violence that a warning is actually required. Features such characters as a sadist with a whip hand, evil talking coyotes who want to end all human life, a girl who can make people see all sorts of unholy terrors, and so on. The fourth book contains people coughing up their organs, and bugs eating people from the inside out. The less said about the last book, the better. It's easy to see why there aren't movies of these books...
  • Also from Neil Gaiman, the first page of The Graveyard Book involves a family being murdered, and the killer then going after the baby that crawled away. Other loveliness includes The Protagonist threatening to mentally torture school bullies, a man being hit by a police car, hangings, and a Fate Worse than Death.
    • For those not familiar with his work, Neil Gaiman does not believe in talking down to kids. He has also reached the conclusion that children often enjoy horrific stories more than adults, which dovetails with his observation that, unlike adults, many children know no mercy when it comes to what happens to villains (cf. the deaths of many of the villains in beloved fairy tales).
  • Harry Potter. The Harry Potter example is so prevalent that some editions of the books have plain covers in dingy earth-tones (as opposed to the colorful fantasy illustrations that the "main" editions have) so that adult readers don't have to feel so embarrassed when they read it on the train. Considering most children's books are written by adults, you think adults wouldn't feel they needed to justify reading a children's book in the first place... After all, if the author isn't embarrassed at having written, why should an adult feel embarrassed at reading it?
    • One of the best example of this trope is the Deathly Hallows film, which has a scene that caused major uproar (among Moral Guardians and parts of the fandom): Naked Harry and Hermione making out — a vision which Ron sees as the locket shows his worst nightmares. Another is Bellatrix writing on Hermione's arm with a knife. Sure, we all know that Cruciatus is worse, but it is perceived as unreal. When Umbridge forced Harry to carve words into the back of his hand, it was also done with a magic medium, and therefore less visceral.
    • Harry also grows into the world of moral ambiguity increasingly as the books progress and he ages, until a large part of the seventh reads more as a Deconstruction of the Kid Hero trope and associated character tropes than a straight fantasy climax. Especially the Dumbledore material.
    • The very nature of the one book = one school year ratio forces this. Even if there were no magical elements at all, 18-year-old graduating high school seniors face very different issues than 11-year-old sixth graders.
    • Though Rowling's The Casual Vacancy makes all her previous books look like fluffy bunnies, even the darker ones.
    • She's also had to point out to those that say the first book was much lighter than the others that it does open with a double homicide and the attempted murder of a defenseless infant.
  • 1997 children's adventure book Haunted Castle definitely fits this trope. Due in part to the amazing art of artist/writer Leo Hartas, complete child-friendly scenes such as demented, crumbling paper-mache clones of the protagonists, a man being crushed feet-first by a garden roller while still alive and swimming through the guts of a gigantic fish are all brought to your children's nightmares!
  • The Hobbit, due to Tolkien's natural propensity for large volumes of text.
    • The book is hardly all that wordy book. However, it can't be common for a children's book to feature a 50-year old bachelor as the main protagonist.
  • The Horrible Histories series, which is filled with Black Humor, Black Comedy-style jokes, and generally focuses on the grisly parts of history.
  • The Hunger Games: The age recommendation for these books - 11, 12, 13 - is surprising to some parents, reviewers, and even older teen readers. Maybe it's the inclusion of decapitation, suicide, torture, mutilation, child prostitution; death by fire or venom, being buried alive, and other psychologically and emotionally disturbing content that raises their eyebrows, or maybe it's the fact that Katniss, the viewpoint character and protagonist, is sixteen and the book appears to focus on the fears and themes most relevant to that age group.
    • Descriptions of the author's next book are interesting too: Year of the Jungle — about her childhood during The Vietnam War — is picture book for four-year-olds.
  • This is a large part of the reason why In the Night Kitchen by the late Maurice Sendak was banned from various school libraries and children's book shops, alongside Unfortunate Implications: The child protagonist Mickey loses his pajamas for some reason and ends up naked for a substantial chunk of the story, with his nudity uncensored.
  • The Last Dragon Chronicles, with a side order of Mood Whiplash. The first book in the series plays out like a traditional kid's story, with squirrels and magic clay dragons, and would appear to leave no doubt as to who the target audience of the series is. The later books, however, run on Getting Crap Past the Radar (specifically, G-Rated Sex), with violence up the wazoo (including one horrifyingly dark Downer Ending), existential crises, and a great deal of speculation on the nature of the universe, which leads to some very messed-up stuff. However, the spinoff wears its kiddie-colors proudly.
  • Phenomena: While the main series is dark enough already it is with it's strangely 9+, is Azur's spin-offs said to be for younger children. The first 4 books are filled with suspense, he's banned from his home and he's kidnapped and tortured, in the 5th book his brother is seen covered in the blood of innocent people, in the 6th he, himself, is seen covered in blood of innocents eating of an uncensored torn off leg complete with a Slasher Smile, on the cover! Worse still, the books are illustrated so you can see his suffering on every page.
    • The Jolsah's spin-offs meant for the same age group, aren't much better, it even features a mad man that wants to cut things of Jolsah while alive and an evil man wearing an elf's scalp which the other guy cut off so if they do something bad the elves are blamed. It's not even an horror series!
    • The 1st book might be a Cliché Storm to some, and then the 2nd book comes. There the Chosen Ones are drawn down into the sand by some beings eating everything! When Azur protects them and they are "free" to go, are the other terraqus'es mad at him, so they eat their OWN elder instead. When they are accending to the surface are they passing by some terraqus'es eating something, it's mentioned that it looks familiar and quite fresh looking although almost eaten up, and it's heavily implied that it's one of the children's ahmel...
  • The Power of Five books are fairly scary and deal with some fairly adult themes.
  • Redwall. Cute furry creatures killing each other with swords, bows and arrows, spears, poison, and whatever else comes to 'paw'. Multiple instances of murder and torture, not all of it off-screen. Slavery, cruelty, major battles, and almost anyone can die.
  • The Saga of Darren Shan is a kid's book series, but the author himself says that he knows people both above and below the series' age demographics read them. And he gets a LOT past the radar:
    • Book two mentions marijuana (or some other herbal drug; it's not mentioned by name) and 'shrooms.
    • Book eight has a character who, though appearing to be fifteen (and probably around the same stage of puberty as any real teen), is really about 27, first outright saying that he wants to date said real teens ("That's the thing I love about high school girls: I keep getting older, they stay the same age") and then trying to do... something to his much-older teacher (who is very likely younger than him.)
    • Plus, the books are so violent and gory, it's not even funny.
  • Skulduggery Pleasant is marketed to preteens. It features the charming adventures of Skulduggery and his young apprentice Valkyrie who spend their time searching for clues and engaging in witty repartee and—Oh Crap, did the Grotesquery just rip off someone's head? And, um...Darquesse? This is a kids book. You can't go playing football with people's brains.
  • Someone Else's War is about child soldiers trying to escape the Lord's Resistance Army, erstwhile enduring unspeakable horrors no child should have to read about, let alone endure. Truth in Television, though, as there really are children going through this in certain parts of the world, even today.
  • Yeah, The Underland Chronicles is still a book series aimed at older children, even though it contains a massive ammount of extreme violence such as decapitation. Wounds are even sometimes described in explicit detail. Maybe the fact that it's written media and not shown as actual pictures keeps the Moral Guardians away.
  • The Varjak Paw books are marketed for kids, but are full of inhuman viewpoints, death, mutilation, starvation, general creepiness, and the implication that the Big Bad is taking cats and turning them into walking, talking toys, or silent, deadly killing machines, somehow. Being illustrated by Dave McKean (as is Coraline, above) probably doesn't help much, either.
  • Wagstaffe the Wind-up Boy is a textbook example of What Do You Mean, It's for Kids?? The amount of anger and nihilism that permeates this supposedly funny story is notable; nowadays you'd call it Black Comedy. Everyone is unsympathetic. This book was not written by happy humans. Furthermore, some of the scenes... well... The main character is pancaked by getting run over by a truck. There's illustrations. Amazingly he's still alive when two workmen try to scrape him into a bin bag. Later, after he's been rushed to hospital and the renegade doctor's team turns him into the wind-up boy, they discuss what to do with the left-over organs. "It'd be a shame to waste them on the dog - he's so young and tender." They eat his heart and pancreas. "And very nice it was too", she tells Wagstaffe.
  • Warrior Cats. It's a series about a bunch of cats living in a forest which is marketed to ages 9-12 and decorated with colourful covers. But as for what's under the covers? As the title implies, there is a lot of fighting in these books, accompanied by pseudo-realistic (and often very graphic) violence. Pretty much every fight ends with every character involved bleeding from at least one gash, and on a few occasions cats have had their throats slit or torn open and bleed to death. And those are some of the average moments. The series goes on to feature cats having their eyes clawed out, getting run over by cars, being crippled, bleeding to death while giving birth, getting mauled by dogs, being ripped open and left to bleed to death nine times, being slaughtered by an Ax-Crazy mountain lion, impaling a mountain lion with a stalactite, falling off cliffs and breaking their necks, getting crushed by trees, having their tails removed, having a wooden stake driven into their throat, drowning in a series of dark tunnels which they are forced to wander for all eternity, bleeding heavily from gashes in their stomachs, being tortured by extremely bloody nightmares, slowly bleeding to death after being severely wounded by a beaver's teeth, hearing another cat screaming in agony as his stomach is ripped open offscreen, etc. How these books being considered child-friendly has never been challenged by parents or bookstores for all these years is a mystery. Not to mention the fact that it covers themes like racism (although towards fictional races, which technically makes it okay), genocide, moral ambiguity, organized religion, insanity, and war. Also, see the series' entry for Getting Crap Past The Radar.
  • Watership Down. Despite what one may think of the movie, author Adams wrote the original book as a bedtime story for his daughters, and has always maintained it was for children. In one edition's foreword, he even talked about how happy it made him to see kids enjoying it.
  • A lot of books by Astrid Lindgren. Including, but not limited to, children and beloved elderly people dying, Nightmare Fuel monsters, and very realistic and heartbreaking descriptions of the problems with alcoholism and poverty.
  • Despite being fairly new to the kid's book scene, Brandon Mull is pretty good at this.
    • The Fablehaven series starts off very tame, like most other YA fiction, but when you get to, say, the extreme violence at the end of Book 2, the death-by-dissolving in Book 3, and Naverog's eventual fate (chomped in half, with his bleeding torso stump slumping to the ground), you start to wonder.
    • The Candy Shop War features the surprisingly vicious John Dart, who has no qualms about binding and gagging ten-year-olds or shooting people's legs almost clean off. Not to mention both books running on twice their allotted helping of Paranoia Fuel.
    • And as for The Beyonders? Well, it begins with a mass Suicide Pact and accidental mauling. From there, it's pretty much all downhill.
  • The Choose Your Own Adventure books were sold to kids as offering the ability to play the title role in a kid's adventure book. They are, however, remembered for the terrifying endings that arise when incorrect choices are made, with some books even giving detailed descriptions of being eaten, shot, stabbed, poisoned, torn to bits, electrocuted, immured, trapped in tortuous time-loops forever, and so on. These older books are generally no longer considered suitable for children, although the creator of the series - Edward Packard - said in an interview in 1981 that in his experience children enjoyed the exaggerated deaths.
  • Fairy tales, and pre-20th century bed-time stories. Maybe some of them were designed to Scare 'Em Straight, but still, some push it Up to Eleven, with both psychological and Body Horror many snuff films don't get even close to. An example for the psychological horror story: a tale by Andersen consists of nothing else than a lengthy description of the hypothermia-induced delirium a little girl suffers while she slowly freezes to death. About tales with Body Horror... too many to list.

    Fairy Tales were written for peasant children who grew up in rather a Crapsack World. What would be considered fit for them would be different then what is considered fit for modern suburban kids. Although it might be argued that even these generally have a stronger stomach then many adults realize. Some of them were originally written for adults. In these cases, it's What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids?. Indeed, a lot of what we now consider to be for kids ("Little Red Riding Hood", for example) were originally tavern stories adults told each other. They weren't told to children until much later.
  • Pretty much any book by Garth Nix that's labeled as "young adult" (as in, the stuff usually found in the kid's section). For example, there's the series that has living (often unfriendly) shadows, Mind Rape as capital punishment (even for minors!), Body Horror, and some rather intense war scenes. Then there's the one with Mind Screw galore, Body Horror monsters, mandatory brainwashing (more literally than the word is usually used) for children, and plenty of death. Oh, and the ending involves the destruction of everything everywhere everywhen. For those of you asking how this can possibly be meant for children, go and read the Old Kingdom books. You know, his teen series.
  • John Bellairs wrote gothic horror novels intended for children full of all sorts of subtle Nightmare Fuel.
  • Anything written by the late Robert Cormier would count here, especially The Chocolate War and Fade (two books that frequently make it to "frequently banned books" lists) but not limited to those two books. His novels were specifically written for older children and preteens but are about anything from (terminally ill) children being used as live guinea pigs to a young boy with amnesia who's being marked for death as soon as he regains his memory.
  • Much Victorian literature is like this. While Victorians are stereotyped as a whole century of Moral Guardians, one can find more then a few surprises along the way. Including occasionally things that it would be hard to imagine in a modern children's story.
    • For example, while Christina Rossetti insisted Goblin Market was a children's poem, it's kind of difficult to ignore the Les Yay, to say nothing of the incest.

FilmWhat Do You Mean, It's for Kids?Live-Action TV

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
56270
36