YMMV / Family Guy S10 E3: "Screams of Silence: The Story of Brenda Q."

• Alternative Character Interpretation: It's never really explained why Brenda tolerates Jeff's abuse. Is she afraid of what he'll do to her if she tries to leave him? Is she a sadomasochist? (Brian did initially mistake her for one of Quagmire's dates who liked S&M) Has the abuse been going on for so long that Brenda considers it normal for her? It could be combination of one or all of these.
• Anvilicious: The core theme of the episode is about how horrifying domestic violence is and how abusers are evil to their core for abusing their victim.
• Bizarro Episode: The series' signature Comedic Sociopathy is considerably toned down in this episode in favour of a Darker and Edgier tone, making it particularly jarring to see the show attempting to seriously handle subjects that it usually uses for comedy.
• Captain Obvious Aesop: The show presents a black and white take on domestic violence, with Jeff beating Brenda for any excuse he can come up with and Brenda being in deep denial about the reality of their relationship. Since Brenda is emotionally incapable of recognising Jeff as a threat: Quagmire, Peter, and Joe decide the best option is to murder Jeff before he can do any more harm. Making the lesson as clear as day; domestic violence is no laughing matter and every measure should be taken to save the victim.
• Esoteric Happy Ending: The ending is meant to be seen a good thing since the gang were able to get rid of Jeff and free Brenda from his wrath. However, she is likely suffering from Stockholm Syndrome, meaning she will never move on from Jeff and eventually hook up with another abuser. Not helping is that "Coma Guy" reveals she died at some point after this episode.
• Fridge Horror: Brenda was never seen again after this episode, leaving it unknown if she learned anything from her experience, turned her life around, or ended up even worse with a child she was too mentally-feeble to take care of alone. In many real-life situations, the life of an abuse victim is not solved by the murder of their abuser, and they're more likely to end up with someone just as bad, if not worse. She finally appears again in Season 18 — in the afterlife, alongside every other character that has died over the length of the series. Hence, it is left ambiguous of what happened to get her there...
• Harsher in Hindsight: The ending becomes a lot harsher when it's implied in Season 18's "Coma Guy" that Brenda died some time between this episode and the latter.
• He Really Can Act: Seth MacFarlane sounds on the verge of tears when Quagmire reads his letter to Brenda.
• Inferred Holocaust: Since Brenda never developed the courage to defend herself from Jeff, nor even accept the reality of their relationship, her cycle of abuse will never end. Even though she and the baby are safe because of Jeff's death, there's nothing stopping her from looking for someone identical to him or searching for a dead man for closure or a reunion. The future of the baby also comes to mind; will Brenda teach it domestic violence because of her romanticized delusion of Jeff, or will she lose her delusion of him over time and provide it with a good future? The Season 18 episode "Coma Guy" seems to have provided answer: she died as she was seen on the boat full of dead characters, which also leads to how she died.
• Jerks Are Worse Than Villains: Even though Jeff is a cruel Hate Sink who repeatedly assaults his girlfriend, people actually despise the main characters more than Jeff himself for the rather callous way they respond to Brenda's situation. Lois (who is in a relationship with someone who abuses her and her kids) criticizes her for dating Jeff; Quagmire tells her that she doesn't deserve to be called a woman for refusing to leave him; and Joe, a police officer, outright calls her garbage at the end of the episode.
• Moment of Awesome: As much of a Flat Character as Jeff is and how wrong so much of the information on Domestic Abuse is in this episode, it's immensely satisfying to see Quagmire both surviving getting strangled by Jeff (as he's sexually asphyxiated himself so much that it doesn't bother him anymore), then running down the bastard with Peter's car and slamming him into a tree.
• Narm: Despite Jeff being taken more seriously as a domestic abuser than every other villain in the show, his hamminess and some of his reasons for abusing Brenda (beating her just because she switched from The Tonight Show to The Late Show) are way too ridiculous to take seriously in a show like Family Guy, which often makes jokes about these kinds of situations.
• Nightmare Fuel: Jeff in general. None of his actions are presented as amusing, but his brutal strangling of Quagmire particularly stands out. It's only thanks to Quagmire's own habit of Erotic Asphyxiation that he survives and is able to take down Jeff.
• Uncertain Audience: Big time. This episode cannot decide whether it's supposed to be a Very Special Episode or a satire of one, bouncing back and forth between the two throughout its runtime, thus making it feel very inconsistent, hollow, and hypocritical at best. Considering this show stars a Dysfunctional Family who constantly abuse each other (especially Meg), making a Very Special Episode about domestic abuse and violence against women of all things and having Quagmire (a rapist sex maniac who always objectifies women) of all characters be the hero of the story feels very counterintuitive, to say the least. Not helped by the fact that, although Brenda and her situation are taken somewhat seriously, the one-note nature of Jeff, herself, and their relationship, along with the episode feeling the need to play it for laughs half of the time, like the Running Gag of Jeff yelling at and/or assaulting Brenda for dumbest of reasons (like not getting a joke on tv), in the style of Family Guy's usual Black Comedy, makes the serious moments involving them...well.... hard to take seriously.
• Unintentionally Unsympathetic:
  • Throughout the entirety of the show, Quagmire has treated women like objects and raped far too many of them to count. In this episode, the viewer is supposed to be touched when he tells his sister that women are "strong, vibrant and beautiful creatures", but his past actions make him look hypocritical at best and manipulative at worst, and when he tells Brenda she doesn't deserve to be called a woman, he only comes across as a prick.
  • Joe's strong commitment to the law is showcased when he explains that he can't arrest Jeff unless Brenda files a report, as well as when he threatens to arrest Quagmire himself when the latter comes up with a plan to murder Jeff. However, Joe had personally witnessed Jeff's abuse many times and did nothing to prevent it from happening, making him look incompetent and uncaring.

---