All speculation about important artifacts go here.
- The books seem to be about different things. So far Book 3 has been about the natural phenomena surrounding Gravity Falls, and Book 2 seems to be about curses and magic spells. So it might just be that it ends because that's all the writer put into that book. So it doesn't have to be that he lost it, or stopped writing for some reason.
- Continuing on, from what we've seen of Book 1, it seems to be solely dedicated to how to operate the Portal.
- Jossed.
- The six-fingered hand is a fairly common sigil for indicating weirdness. Given that Dipper's book (3) ends abruptly in the middle, implying that the author was forced to abandon it, the existence of further volumes seems unlikely.
- Unless, as stated lower on the page, it merely marks the point where the author jumped from visible to invisible ink. Dipper hasn't gotten an on-screen chance to check the rest of the pages under black light.
- Jossed.
- Then why does volume three cut off in the middle, as though something happened to the journal writer?
- They could be numbered thematically (with each volume covering a different topic), or belong to different people.
- It might not be cut off in the middle, especially now that we have proof that some parts of the journals are written in invisible ink.
- Jossed.
So far:
- Dipper (tree symbol(confirmed)) has the third volume.
- Stan (glasses(confirmed)) most likely has the first volume.
- Gideon (pentagram) has the second volume.
- Robbie (broken heart or ice bag) has a volume.
- Mabel (shooting star(confirmed)) will receive a volume.
- Soos (question mark(confirmed))has or will receive a volume.
- Grenda (llama) has or will receive a volume.
- Author (original owner of the fez) wrote a volume.
- The Pyramid Man is the controller/author/owner of all the volumes.
- Am I the only one who remembers that volume 3 cuts off in the middle, implying that something happened to the author before he/she could complete it?
- No, no you're not. There are only three books. The real question is, who has the first?
- Who says there's only three?
- Eh,or each book could be about something different. The third book seems to be about the natural phenomena surrounding Gravity Falls, while the second book seems to be about curses and magic. The third book might end abruptly as that's all the author actually found out while writing the others, if they all have the same author.
- There is some merit to this idea. If there is more than one author for the books, a theory posed multiple times already, then it's very possible that there are more than three. Also notice in the title sequence Easter egg that Dipper and Gideon's symbols are next to each other. If the symbols are sequential and match up with the numbers of the books, then:
- 6-fingered-hand symbol has book 1.
- Stan has 4.
- Ice Bag symbol has 5.
- Soos has 6.
- Etc. etc. From here, it looks like Mabel and Stan will have 2 books each. Unless the llama and glasses stand for characters we aren't aware of yet.
- Maybe Candy (glasses) and Grenda (llama).
- Am I the only one who remembers that volume 3 cuts off in the middle, implying that something happened to the author before he/she could complete it?
- Jossed. "Journals come in threes".
- Jossed.
- Jossed.
- Confirmed in as much that the three together have instructions on the portal.
- One thing about Dippers copy though. It doesn't just have creatures in it, one page covers a "Cursed Door"... although may the door itself is a creature, who knows.
- Not to mention that each entry on each creature makes a point on how to defeat it, indicating that the book was at least partially intended to help the reader defend himself.
- Adding to this, Book 2 has the instructions on how to summon Bill Cipher, while Book 3 has the warning "DO NOT SUMMON AT ALL COSTS" and explains how to go into a person's mind to chase him out.
- Jossed.
- Confirmed.
- Stan and Dipper both have possession of journals, and have noses that are a different color from the rest of their face. Old Man McGucket is also implied to be involved somehow, and he also has a red nose (all the bizarre crap he builds? got the designs from a journal. And Bill could've driven him insane). The exception is Gideon, and he loses his journal; the journal saw he had a regular nose and decided to escape.
- Stan's definitely part of a secret society (Remember the boys from the lodge who don't "like" or "trust" him?) But where did the contempt originate?
- Jossed.
- Jossed.
- The magnifying glass part seems incredibly likely; if you're paying attention, the writing in the jacket of the book ("Property of") is clearly visible through the "gem" part of the charm/pendant/whatever. As to what it does, well, there is a trope for that.
- More specifically, Soos and Wendy will both find Journal 1 (or 2), Pacifica will find Journal 2 (or 1), and Robbie will find Journal 3 (the one with the page about the Undead).
- The irl Journal 3 reveals that all the Journals were thrown into the Bottomless Pit. Therefore they could end up anywhere, in anyone's hands.
- As for why specifically those four characters: they're the ones that, despite being on the Cipher Wheel, hadn't been as important to the plot as the Pines family, Gideon, or McGucket. Perhaps obtaining the Journals will give them more importance...?
- Jossed
- Jossed in the Season 1 finale. It seems that the object in the bunker is searching for something that Grunkle Stan plans to let out willingly.
- Stan could just end up telling everybody in a later episode, or time travel could be involved, or go into Stan's memories again, or anything of that nature. This doesn't disprove your theory but it's "not now or never"
- (Original poster) I guess I just don't think those other options will have as strong of a dramatic effect.
- Confirmed
- A portal to another dimension
- A time machine
- Access to some powerful being
- A cipher reveals this passage "THE PORTAL WHEN COMPLETED WILL OPEN A GATEWAY TO INFINITE NEW WORLDS AND HERALD A NEW ERA IN MANKIND'S UNDERSTANDING OF THE UNIVERSE. PLUS, IT WILL PROBABLY GET GIRLS TO START TALKING TO ME FINALLY."
- Hmmm... I seem to recall someone else in the show creating a massive technological wonder to get attention...
- Didn't Dipper say that it seemed to be some sort of super weapon?
- A cipher reveals this passage "THE PORTAL WHEN COMPLETED WILL OPEN A GATEWAY TO INFINITE NEW WORLDS AND HERALD A NEW ERA IN MANKIND'S UNDERSTANDING OF THE UNIVERSE. PLUS, IT WILL PROBABLY GET GIRLS TO START TALKING TO ME FINALLY."
- Maybe its a portal to the dimension where Bill Cipher resides
- It's a portal to the world of hot old ladies and gold chains for old men where Stan's twin resides.
- The machine in the basement is strongly implied to be some kind of portal. Where it leads to is still unknown.
- Stan's twin theory confirmed, but Bill Cipher's home theory unfortunately also confirmed.
- Alternatively, someone he loves got trapped on the other side.
- Confirmed
- Alternatively, someone he loves got trapped on the other side.
- ... Find something that will stop Bill Cipher. A cryptogram in Dipper's book suggests that the device at the end of season 1 is some kind of portal. Stan wants to open in so he can go into other worlds and get a way to stop Bill Cipher.
- Things have become more interesting with the reveal of the author's first intial, F. Whose's name comes to mind from the town? Fiddleford H. McGucket. Not to mention according to a clue from the game, it says that he knows. it doesn't elaborate, but it does make the mystery more intriguing.
- Part Confirmed and part Jossed. McGucket didn't write the books, but he was an ally to whomever did.
- Jossed: The creatures do come from another dimension, but they were coming out of a naturally occurring rift long before Ford and McGucket built the more stable portal.
- To add some weight to this theory - Double Dipper featured cloning machine (well, copying machine) that recreated anything, except the tree from Dipper's hat. Which probably means symbol is indeed special.
- Actually, Dipper was wearing a bow tie when he copied himself, which didn't transfer to any of the copies either.
- Well, couldn't it mean that the bow tie is somehow some sort of symbol?
- Mabel wore the sweater with the star in the opening sequence and pilot, so she would have obtained it before coming to Gravity Falls.
- In Dreamscapers, Bill specifically refers to Dipper, Mable and Soos as Pine Tree, shooting star and question mark.
- Possibly jossed in Sock Opera, as Bill refers to Dipper as Pine Tree in a statement clearly directed to Dipper himself.
- The AMA by Alex Hirsch as Bill implies he has (or had) a family whom we may have caught a glimpse of in "The Last Mabelcorn".
- Pine tree - Dipper; Confirmed
- Shooting star - Mabel; Confirmed
- Question mark - Soos; Confirmed
- Pac-man symbol - Stan; It is on his hat after all.
- Pentagram - Gideon; This is the symbol that's on his Tent of Telepathy.
- Bag of ice - Wendy; She does have a cool personality and her first major episode took place in a convenience store.
- Don't forget the ice at the fair and the cooler on the roof!
- Stitched heart - Robbie; This symbol does appear on his sweat shirt.
- Six fingered hand - The author of the books; It's obviously him, since the symbol is on the books, we just don't know who he is.
- Llama - Wendy's dad or some one equally tough; Larry King's head did say llamas were nature's greatest warriors, so it would have to be someone powerful.
- Maybe Grenda could be the llama...
- It could be Gompers the goat. See theories below.
- Wax Larry King is a strong candidate for this one. The llama on the wheel is mirror-reversed from the one on Mabel's sweater. Mabel was holding the sweater up to the mirror when Wax Larry endorsed it, thus identifying himself with that version of the image. Expect to see more of Larry in the next season.
- Lebam, a mirror doppelganger of Mabel created by Gideon from a sample of her hair (and her llama hair sweater). There is considerable evidence for the existence of this character. See theories by "The Sqoou" on You Tube.
- Pacifica. We've only seen the sweater, but not anyone wearing it. If Mabel and Pacifica do eventually become friends, maybe Mabel will reward her with the sweater for doing something brave?
- As of Northwest Mansion Mystery this is looking more plausible, especially with the picture of a llama hidden in one of the paintings in the manor. Link
- Pacifica's boots from "Irrational Treasure" look like they may be made from llama fur.
- Glasses - I dunno, maybe Blubs; He's the only character with sunglasses. Blendin could also be an option since his goggles cover his eyes.
- ...and Candy could be the glasses.
- I'd like to point out that when Gideon summoned Bill to go into Stan's mind, there was a little arrow pointing at the glasses.
- That was a big X over his eyes, basically symbolizing "Kill Stan."
- Well yes, on the picture in the middle of the summoning circle the glasses on Stan's face where crossed out, but what the other troper was referring to is probably the fact that Gideon's book on summoning Bill had an arrow pointing to the glasses symbol in the circle.
- There is currently a popular fan theory (with a surprising amount of evidence) that Grunkle Stan has a twin brother, and that the glasses represent said brother.
- The glasses look like they have a frame line on top but not the bottom, like the Stan they disturbed when time-traveling (and the glasses in the secret room with the carpet). It could be the hypothetical twin of Stan.
- Since Stan wears the glasses when younger, the glasses could mean him and the symbol on the fez could mean someone else. Stan does mention "other people" from the lodge.
- It could be McGucket. He had glasses when he was younger, and now he has those green ones from the Society of the Blind Eye.
- Or alternatively:
- Tree: Dipper (on his cap)
- Shooting Star: Mabel (on one of her sweaters and the bubble Bill imprisoned her in)
- Question Mark: Soos (on his shirt)
- Fish/Pac-Man/whatever: Stan (on his fez)
- Bag of ice: Wendy (see above)
- Six-fingered Hand: Ford - well, it is his hand.
- Pentagram: Gideon - the symbol on his Tent of Telepathy
- Stitched Heart: Robbie (on his sweat shirt)
- Llama: Pacifica (see above) - also, seeing that Mabel has a sweater with a llama on it looking in the opposite reaction than the one on the wheel, I'm guessing, Pacifica is going to wear it - considering that the wardrobe in her size in the Mystery Shack during Weirdmageddon is limited to Mabel's stuff, it's possible that she'd put it on - probably inside-out for whatever reason- when she needs a wardrobe change, hence the llama looks in the opposite direction.
- Glasses: Ghost-Eyes: no, seriously. First, the glasses in the wheel only match with the ones worn by Pa Duskerton (from the Dusk 2 Dawn convenience store way back in Season 1); though, since he passed on, the glasses in the wheel probably don't refer to him directly; second, notice how of the 5 characters we actually see going inside one of Bill's madness bubbles, he is one of the 4 to emerge from them without being driven completely insane - and the other 3 Dipper, Wendy, Gideon are already on this list. And no, I have no idea where he could have gotten them from (probably raided the convenience store or whatever).
SO PATIENTLY I WATCH THIS TOWN
ABNORMAL SOON WILL BE THE NORM
ENJOY THE CALM BEFORE THE STORM
Why is this important? The first three episodes of Season 2 had combined ciphers told in a rhyming couplet once translated. This, however, is doubled in length into one four-line stanza.After Sock Opera, the next episode is Soos and the Real Girl, which is mostly monster of the week. Then comes the next episode, Little Gift Shop of Horrors, a three shorts-styled episode. Two episodes with no big impact..."the calm before the storm". What is the next episode? Society of the Blind Eye.
The cipher was doubled in length to signify two episodes serving as breathers before the next big event.
- Question Mark: Soos - When Grunkle Stan handed Soos the question mark staff shirt, Soos made the decision to move on from disappointment his Disappeared Dad left him and take Stan on as his new father figure.
- Ice Bag: Wendy - Wendy is initially shown with a habit of making fun of her friends. But when Dipper fesses up about only being 12 and performing the "lamby lamb dance," she resists the temptation to blurt out his embarrassing secrets, and instead plays it cool.
- Fez symbol: Unknown - It's clear from "A Tale of Two Stans" that the fez was just a prop Stan used and may have belonged to someone else. Douglas makes the WMG that the symbol is connected to Shermy Pines, "but what do YOU think?"
- Pine Tree: Dipper - Already confirmed to be this, the symbol may have been connected to him when he and Mabel expected a boring summer in Gravity Falls, got more than they bargained for, and decided to stick around despite the sudden reveal of the town's weirdness.
- Star: Bud Gleeful - The star may not represent Gideon himself—who showed no character growth whatseover—but Bud, who may have been connected to the symbol when he wished on a star for a child—and got Gideon, but still.
- Six-fingered Hand: Ford - Ford is connected to the symbol based on his own six-fingered hand when he creates it himself, because it's the moment he finally decides what to dedicate the rest of his life to—a huge decision to make.
- Llama: Pacifica - The llama motif appears during "Northwest Mansion Mystery" in the very room where Pacifica discovers what horrible people her whole family has been. It was there that she made the very mature decision not to let her family's legacy dictate who she is.
- Shooting Star: Mabel - See Pine Tree: Dipper
- Stitched Heart: Robbie - After spending a large portion of the series mourning his break-up with Wendy, Robbie finally moves on (with a little "help" from Mabel) and begins dating Tambry instead. At the end of the episode, he symbolically shows Mabel the stitched heart symbol on his shirt as he thanks her for helping to mend his heart.
- Glasses: Stan - After making years of rash and/or selfish decisions, Stan winds up accidentally sending Ford into another dimension through his machine. Stan doesn't have his brother's brains and has no idea how to work the portal. But as he clutches the spare glasses his brother dropped, he made a very selfless decision to bring his brother back whatever it took.
- Seemingly confirmed by the events of "Weirdmageddon": Gideon does seem to turn against Bill when he realizes his desperation to "claim" her is what drove her away in the first place. Furthermore, none of the characters agreed to be represented on the wheel (including Dipper, Stanley, Stanford, Soos, and Wendy) are seen being affected by the "weirdness waves", which seems to suggest some resistance to Bill's powers. Bill was able to turn Ford into a statue, but it required direct application of his reality-warping powers. And given Bill put Mabel in a Tailor-Made Prison on the far side of town, he doesn't want her in particular getting out...
- Confirmed in "Weirdmageddon 3: Take Back the Falls": The symbols are part of a prophecy/magic ritual that can potentially banish/destroy Bill Cipher. Unfortunately, Stanford and Stanley's bickering breaks the circle before they can finish, and they're forced to come up with another way to stop Bill when he interrupts the ceremony.
- The pine tree: Manly Dan, as a lumberjack he works with trees and the woods in Gravity Falls are full of pines.
- The Tent of Telepathy star: Bud Gleeful, if he isn't the legal owner of the place, then at least a good part of his income comes from it.
- The lama: Wax Larry King. After all, two of his limited number of lines mention lama's and he reappeared during Weirdmaggedon.
- The glasses: Most of the other symbols point to some artikel of clothing or physical attribute. Ford as the obvious representatieve of the six fingered hand is out, same with Grunkle Stan and the symbol on his fez. That leaves two glasses wearing characters who played a somewhat important role in the series, namely Candy and Quentin. There is also Toby Determined who wears that style of glasses, making him plausibile as well.
- Jossed.
- It will be how Dipper gets into Stan's secret vending machine bunker.
- Jossed.
- Let's face it: this wouldn't be the first time Stan bought (or "bought") a bunch of cursed objects out of cheapness. In this case, the baseballs had a sentient desire to cause as much injury as possible when thrown, and could adjust their own ricochets accordingly. Dipper's super-complicated ploy at the end basically worked because it confused the hell out of the curse, forcing it to change trajectories so many times it could no longer keep up with who was the most "ideal" target.
- Maybe it meant that the world as we know it would end in 3012. Some kind of apocalyptic event might happen which will end civilization, but life on the planet will continue, until it eventually evolves into the world we saw in 207012.
- Maybe the mailbox is right due to the Earth being older. The year 207012 happened in the past due to true chronology, then after that Atlantis-esque-futuristic society collapsed time recording started again making both the 207012 and the 3012 predictions true. (See also Library of Alexandria.)
- But I thought that 207012 was stated to be a future year in the show?
- it could be a Star Wars Future/past situation.
- In The Inconveniencing Mable's dream that mentions not to trust Grunkle Stan gives another clue she says 'The future's in the past! Onwards Aoshima!' who's to say the trance the candy put her in didn't impart on her some 5th dimensional wisdom?
- But I thought that 207012 was stated to be a future year in the show?
- Or she's a fan of Sev'ral Times, and her catch phrase is just a Shout-Out to them.
- But if that were so, how could Soos talk while in a pig body?
- It was either that or pig subtitles.
- Obviously, Waddles is just that special. He is a Gravity Falls pig, after all.
- But that doesn't bridge the issue of the password-induced data erasure.
- Confirmed, at the end of Northwest Mansion Mystery It is shown that Old Man McGucket fixed the laptop
- It was BLINDEYE. Think about it... Search for the Blind Eye and we know its an order of some sort hinted to appear in the show...
- The password entry field is eight characters long, too.
- Lending extra credence to this theory The laptop and the secret organization known as "The Blind Eye" were made by the same man. One Fiddleford McGucket
- It was STANOWAR. We know the laptop was found in Ford's bunker. When he had nowhere and no one else to turn to, he chose to call Stan. If he still cared about him enough to trust him, he could possibly have set the password after the boat of their childhood dream.
From Northwest Mansion Noir we see a tapestry depicting a burning tree and Bill, and during the Bill AMA he says something along the lines of having to "make like a pine tree and burn to the ground" when he's about to leave. While this can be interpreted as Bill planning on doing something really bad to Dipper or using him as a sacrifice, the burning of the tree can be entirely symbolic.The pine tree symbol is on Dipper's hat, which is used to hide the birthmark on his forehead. The same birthmark that spawned his nickname. We don't know Dipper's real name; his real name is hidden behind his nickname. Therefore, his birthmark could symbolize his secrets or things he's hiding, and he's using his hat (the pine tree) to cover (hide) his secrets.Meaning that the burning of the pine tree could mean not a literal burning of a "tree" but a removal of cover to expose the secrets or true nature of something.
- That would be especially challenging since Bill doesn't have a mouth.