To-do list:
- Move wicks related to evil rather than the sea from Prongs of Poseidon to Devil's Pitchfork, and remove examples unrelated to either evil or the sea.
Feel free to use Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon Wick Cleaning to keep track of which namespaces have been cleaned.
Original post
Prongs of Poseidon is in a bit of a situation right now, because it's very explicitly trying to be several tropes at once.Counting the on-page examples is relatively straightforward, since they're already sorted by folder on the page itself:
- Poseidon/marine tridents have 61 distinct works linked, not counting one ZCE ("BIONICLE: Kiina and Turaga Nokama have these"). This accounts for 52.14% of examples.
- Satan tridents have 28 distinct works linked, not counting one ZCE ("Touhou Project: Nue Houjuu from the 12th game wields one, however she is a subversion"). This accounts for 23.93% of examples.
- Random tridents have 21 distinct works linked. This accounts for 17.95% of examples.
- Gladiator/disarming tridents have seven distinct works linked. This accounts for 5.98% of examples.
Regarding inbound links, I opted to focus on dedicated examples over miscellaneous links and potholes, as these would be the most relevant to deciding the viability of a page split by showing how many examples each potential "offspring" would have. Consequently, I checked only character and work pages, looking at every fifth example.
- Characters.A Batalha Do Apocalipse: The king of Atlantis uses trident.
- Characters.Age Of Mythology Campaign: A descendant of Poseidon uses a trident.
- Characters.Aquaman: A bunch of water-themed superheroes use tridents.
- Characters.Azure Striker Gunvolt Antagonists: A sea-themed villain uses a trident.
- Characters.Bionicle Adventures: ZCE
- Characters.Blood Blockade Battlefront: A fishman can make his blood into a trident.
- Characters.Brave Frontier Units Part 2: A pirate uses a trident.
- Characters.Canaanite Mythology: A god of water and earthquakes uses a trident.
- Characters.Core Line Avengers Infinity: Nonspecific trident.
- Characters.DCEU Knightmare: A sea-themed superhero uses a trident.
- Characters.Darkwing Duck Allies: A fish person uses a trident.
- Characters.Digimon Adventure 02 Major Villains: ZCE.
- Characters.Digimon Ultimate Digimon M To Z: A fallen angel uses a pitchfork.
- Characters.Dissidia Final Fantasy NT Champions From I To V: Just a trident.
- Characters.Dragon Ball Supporting Cast: Devil uses a pitchfork.
- Characters.Drawn To Life: Just a trident.
- Characters.Dungeons And Dragons Fiends: Daemons use pitchforks.
- Characters.Earth Twenty Seven DEO: A demon uses a trident.
- Characters.Ennea Series: A water-themed hero uses a trident.
- Characters.Fairy Tail Celestial Spirits: A giant fish uses a trident.
- Characters.Final Fantasy XII: Fish-themed person uses a trident.
- Characters.Final Fantasy XV Kingdom Of Lucis: Just a trident.
- Characters.Friday The13th The Game Jason Voorhees: Lucifer's pitchfork
- Characters.God Of War Series Greek Gods: Poseidon's trident.
- Characters.Greyhawk Deities: A sea god uses a trident.
- Characters.Harley Quinn 2019 Superheroes: A sea-themed superhero uses a trident.
- Characters.Homestuck Pre Scratch Trolls: A sea-themed character uses a trident.
- Characters.Hunter X Hunter Chimera Ants: Just a trident.
- Characters.Hyrule Warriors Age Of Calamity Hyrulean Forces: A fish person uses a trident.
- Characters.Hyrule Warriors Hyrulean Forces: Just a trident.
- Characters.Iron Widow: Just a trident.
- Characters.Kaizoku Sentai Gokaiger Mecha: Just a trident.
- Characters.Kid Icarus Protagonists And Allies: Poseidon's trident.
- Characters.Kingdom Rush Towers: A sea god uses a trident.
- Characters.Kyukyu Sentai Go Go V: A water-themed character uses a trident.
- Characters.Lego Marvel Super Heroes 2: A sea-themed superhero uses a trident.
- Characters.MFU Champions Of Hyrule: A fish person uses a trident.
- Characters.Magi Reim Empire: ZCE.
- Characters.Magical Girl Raising Project Recurring: A water-themed superhero uses a trident.
- Characters.Marvel Comics Olympians: Poseidon's trident.
- Characters.Mashin Sentai Kiramager Mashins: Just a trident.
- Characters.Memoirs: ZCE
- Characters.Minecraft Overworld Hostile Mobs: Aquatic enemies use tridents.
- Characters.Monster Rancher Species: Just a pitchfork.
- Characters.Namco X Capcom: ZCE
- Characters.Neverwinter Nights: A devil with a pitchfork.
- Characters.Oceanfalls: ZCE
- Characters.One Piece Impel Down: Tridents used to reinforce a place's similarity to Hell.
- Characters.One Piece Sun Pirates: A merman uses a trident.
- Characters.Pathfinder Celestials: Sea-dwelling beings use tridents.
- Characters.Pathfinder Playable Races: Tritons use tridents.
- Characters.Power Rangers Dino Charge Villains: ZCE
- Characters.Queens Blade Grimoire Characters: Mermaid uses a trident.
- Characters.Reborn 2004 Protagonists: ZCE
- Characters.Rick And Morty One Off Characters: The ruler of the ocean uses a trident.
- Characters.SD Gundam World Sangoku Soketsuden: ZCE
- Characters.Salt And Sanctuary: A storm-controlling character uses a trident.
- Characters.Seraph Of The End Moon Demon Company: Just a trident.
- Characters.Shin Megami Tensei: ZCE
- Characters.Slightly Damned: A water demon uses a trident.
- Characters.Soul Nomad And The World Eaters: ZCE
- Characters.Sponge Bob Square Pants Recurring Characters: Neptune's trident
- Characters.Suikoden V Sol Falena: A fisherwoman uses a trident.
- Characters.Sword Art Online Alfheim Online: The ruler of the ocean uses a trident.
- Characters.The 100 Grounders: A member of a marine people uses a trident.
- Characters.The Demon Girl Next Door: ZCE
- Characters.The Hunger Games Literature Past Tributes: Just tridents.
- Characters.The Legend Of Zelda Breath Of The Wild Other Races: Just tridents.
- Characters.The Legend Of Zelda Ocarina Of Time: Demonic boss enemy uses a trident.
- Characters.The Miniavengers: ZCE
- Characters.The Secret World Egypt NP Cs: Just a trident.
- Characters.Toy Story Other Toys: Mermaid uses a trident.
- Characters.Ultra Series O 50: Just a trident.
- Characters.Ultraman Taro: A fisherman uses a trident.
- Characters.Vietnamese Mythology: A water god uses a trident.
- Characters.We Are All Pokemon Trainers Main 1: Water-type trainer uses a trident.
- Characters.With This Ring The Light: Atlantean villain uses a trident.
- Characters.Yggdra Union: ZCE
- Characters.Yu Gi Oh Card Game T To U: ZCE
- ComicBook.Aquaman: A sea-themed superhero uses a trident.
- ComicBook.The Kingdom DC: Just a trident.
- Fanfic.Equestria Girls Friendship Souls: A siren uses a trident.
- Fanfic.Queens Of Mewni: ZCE
- Film.Aquaman 2018: A sea-themed superhero uses a trident.
- Film.Na Cha: A water demon uses a trident.
- Franchise.Pirates Of The Caribbean: ZCE
- Literature.Horns: Just a pitchfork.
- Literature.The Citadel Of Chaos: Just a trident.
- Minecraft.Tropes M To R: Aquatic enemies use tridents.
- Recap.Big Finish Doctor Who 012 The Fires Of Vulcan: Gladiator tridents.
- Recap.The Great North S 2 E 09 From Tusk Til Dawn Adventure: Just tridents.
- Roleplay.Henshin Heroes: Just a trident.
- Series.Ultraman Mebius Gaiden: Just a trident.
- TabletopGame.The Gates Of Hell: ZCE
- VideoGame.Aquapazza: ZCE
- VideoGame.Crypt Killer: Fish people use tridents.
- VideoGame.God Hand: Demons use tridents.
- VideoGame.Mega Man 9: Water-themed boss gives a trident on defeat.
- VideoGame.Rayman Legends: Just a trident.
- VideoGame.The Last Stand: Lucifer's trident.
- VideoGame.Total War Rome II: Gladiator tridents.
- WebVideo.Best Pal Brigade: Just a bident.
- Webcomic.Athena Complex: ZCE
- Western Animation/Wishfart: Neptune's trident.
Ratios:
- Sea/Poseidon tridents: 51/104 = 49%
- Demonic tridents: 9/104 = 8.7%
- Gladiator tridents: 2/104 = 1.9%
- Tridents/pitchforks with no narrative significance: 22/104 = 21.2%
- ZCEs: 20/104 = 19.2%
My conclusions are:
Firstly, this page is very under-crosswicked. There are 117 works linked on-page, versus 644 inbounds. The majority of the works I checked were not listed on the page.
As for the examples themselves, notice that both lists are largely dominated by sea/Poseidon/mermaid/fish-associated tridents, the inbound list more so. Normally this would be the opposite of a problem, since it shows concept cohesion — but this trope is currently supposed to cover the other uses of tridents as well, which means that the fact that people are not using or linking for those definitions is a problem. The page's title and presentation absolutely contribute to this, I feel — logically, who would look at a trope called Prongs of Poseidon, with a page picture of a big merman in the ocean, and think that this is also supposed to cover, say, Satan's pitchfork? Folding those other tropes into this one is very clearly hurting them.
My proposal is as follows:
- "Pitchforks associated with infernal figures" is the most obviously viable trope to extract here. It has plenty of examples and is very clearly a strong trend in fiction. Carve out its folder and send it to the launch pad.
- "Pitchforks associated with gladiator figures/used for disarming opponents" could also be viable, but I feel it lacks enough material to work with. We could try to extract it too, but I'm not too confident that that would yield results.
- The third type is by its own definition tridents that have nothing to do with any specific theme. That's chairs by definition and should just be cut.
- Having decided what to cut and what the send to TLP for separation, comb through the inbound wicks list, keep examples of the sea-themed type and crosswick them to the main page, move any applicable ones to the new draft/s, and cut everything else.
Thoughts?
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 17th 2022 at 8:12:39 AM
Satan◊ from Animaniacs? Could use a quality upgrade, but it's obviously a Big Red Devil and I like how the pitchfork is front and centre.
Erm... this trope is about evil characters who use tridents/pitchforks. Examples don't have to literally involve Satan.
I'm not going to stop anyone from replacing the image if anyone thinks it's necessary (I wasn't the one who added it; I didn't check who did either). I just wanted to point out that the image that was chosen is still an example.
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 10th 2022 at 6:12:31 AM
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.- Well, I was in error about my proposed name then.
I would've wanted Evils Pitchfork instead of Devil's Pitchfork then.
Disambig Needed: Help with those issues! tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13324299140A37493800&page=24#comment-576Well, obviously evil goes with Satan and pitchforks are associated with evil because of Satan so I don't see the problem.
Macron's notesIt ain’t that deep, but it shows the codifier. Just how Prongs of Poseidon’s wielder doesn’t literally have to be Poseidon.
Edited by Synchronicity on May 10th 2022 at 7:37:38 AM
Speaking of POP, should we change its Laconic now? And its Analysis and such too?
Edited by Malady on May 10th 2022 at 6:14:57 AM
Disambig Needed: Help with those issues! tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13324299140A37493800&page=24#comment-576I'd rather move Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon into place before changing the subpages of Main.Prongs Of Poseidon, and ideally we'd move Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon into place at the same time as Sandbox.Devils Pitchfork (and we'd transplant the redirects I made for that trope to point to it; I made them as well as Main.Devils Pitchfork into redirects to Prongs of Poseidon so mod intervention isn't needed to edit them).
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 10th 2022 at 7:47:48 AM
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.Expanded the Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon description some.
So these tropes are just for actual weapon wielders, right? Because I had been thinking of The Devil Wears Prada's film poster (stiletto heel that ends in a pitchfork) but that's just devil's pitchfork imagery.
Edited by Yindee on May 11th 2022 at 10:24:23 AM
Vehicle-Based Characterization | Grief-Induced Split | Locker MailAlso, that would be a duplicate of the image on Film.The Devil Wears Prada.
I think they are just asking if it would be an example. But I think it is flexible enough to count.
Sandbox.Devils Pitchfork already has an image and I'm not sure if it's good enough or not.
Edited by Amonimus on May 12th 2022 at 7:09:36 PM
TroperWall / WikiMagic CleanupI think The Devil Wears Prada counts. It's using the pitchfork to evoke Satan.
Currently Working On: Incorruptible Pure PurenessI feel like we should focus less on the image and more on getting the descriptions into a state where they can be moved into Main/, followed by cleaning up the wicks, because I'd prefer if this thread didn't get derailed by discussion regarding the fact that Ganondorf isn't Satan despite still being an example of a trope about evil trident wielders. Image Pickin could still be used while wick cleanup is taking place after the split is complete.
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 12th 2022 at 12:21:17 PM
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.So, I don't see anything wrong with the descriptions of Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon and Sandbox.Devils Pitchfork, so I'm going to move them to Main.Prongs Of Poseidon and Main.Devils Pitchfork in three days if nobody objects. Alternatively, they could be moved now if anyone chimes in saying they think the descriptions are fine and if the image for the latter is the only thing being objected to, and image discussion could be deferred to Image Pickin.
Edit: For the record, I mean I'll transplant the sandboxes in three days if nobody objects to the descriptions. I still don't think this is the right place to discuss image changes, so I'd still rather defer that discussion to Image Pickin.
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 14th 2022 at 9:33:31 AM
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.Alright so if Satanic imagery/references that involve the pitchfork count then I can rustle up a couple more just from digging through google. Most are just quotes referring to devils carrying pitchforks though (like not wanting to end up on the end of the devil's pitchfork), but I think one is referring to some sort of b-movie involving a satanic pitchfork dude.
Vehicle-Based Characterization | Grief-Induced Split | Locker MailI should probably clarify that when I said I was prioritizing the descriptions with the plan to move the sandboxes to Main/, I wasn't saying that image changes can't be done at all before the move. My reason for prioritizing the descriptions is partially because the descriptions and examples are more important than images and page quotes, and partially because images for trope pages are subject to change to a greater extent than descriptions (plus they're easier to change, since Image Pickin changes tend to go through more quickly and easily than Trope Description Improvement Drive changes), hence why I referenced Image Pickin.
Edited by GastonRabbit on May 13th 2022 at 11:54:09 AM
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.The sandboxes have been moved to Main.Prongs Of Poseidon and Main.Devils Pitchfork.
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.Alright since Devil's is the new trope, I tried to page through a bunch of google results in hopes of finding more examples. Tedious and nigh fruitless work, but eh. Is what it is.
Vehicle-Based Characterization | Grief-Induced Split | Locker MailTo avoid people accidentally checking an already checked section, it'd probs be good for people to say which namespaces they've looked through so others can know they don't need to
for example, Evil Counterpart wicks are
Edited by amathieu13 on May 16th 2022 at 1:11:16 PM
Usually we just make sandboxes for that; it's easier to help us keep track.
Currently Working On: Incorruptible Pure PurenessPoseidon only has 650 wicks. We're just moving the Devil-s, right? No need to Google things?
Or are there not enough examples?
Edited by Malady on May 16th 2022 at 10:16:53 AM
Disambig Needed: Help with those issues! tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13324299140A37493800&page=24#comment-576We're also completely removing examples that don't have have anything to do with the sea (Prongs of Poseidon) or evil (Devil's Pitchfork) instead of moving them.
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.Double posting because I made Sandbox.Prongs Of Poseidon Wick Cleaning. I'll add a link to the opening post.
Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
Crown Description:
Consensus was originally to split Prongs Of Poseidon between Poseidon-influenced tridents, Satan-influenced tridents, and gladiator-influenced tridents. However, on the second page of this thread, the tropeworthiness of gladiator-influenced tridents has been questioned. Should the creation of a trope for gladiator-influenced tridents be skipped?
- Yeah, that's more Evils Pitchfork...
Maybe try Sinfest?
Disambig Needed: Help with those issues! tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13324299140A37493800&page=24#comment-576