Follow TV Tropes

Following

Sandbox / The Bus Came Back Wick Check

Go To

The Bus Came Back is an old and much wicked trope that is misused every time I see it. Whenever a new big blockbuster movie or another season of a TV show comes out, someone adds an entry that says, "X character surprisingly returns after being absent for Y amount of time." They almost never mention if said character was written out of the show in a way that sets up their return, the entire point of the trope and the reason it is a sub-trope of Put on a Bus.

Most examples of this trope on the site are like this. Per the wick check I started months back and finished a few weeks ago, only a few examples mentioned the trope Put on a Bus or anything that could be construed to fit that trope's definition. Only 19 links out of 102 matched the trope's definition as is, while there were 81 wicks (including the 18 ZCEs and sinkholes) that made no mention of being a character being written out/Put on a Bus.

So, with this in mind, I think there are two clear options for what to do.

  1. We can just change the trope definition to match the misuse. This requires the least amount of work and is most likely to be effective. The issue is that I'm not sure how to re-write this in a tropeworthy way to match the misuse and not make this a duplicate of stuff like Long Bus Trip or Role Reprise.
  2. We can change the name, delete all the misuse, and hope that people on and off site catch on to all this. This is the best way to preserve the original meaning of the trope, but it requires us to remove this trope from 10000 pages, won't clear anything up for casual visitors to the wiki unfamiliar with forums like these, and also requires the deletion of a lot of writing from earnest tropers.

There might be other avenues (scrapping the page entirely, making the trope a disambiguation, splitting the misuse into a separate trope, etc.), but I think these are the best two options. I'm leaning much more towards the first option, because this trope has fewer zero-context and just poorly-written examples than I'm used to seeing through wick checks, so I don't think the Wiki gains anything from deleting 60% of its examples from the site.

Here are 102 distinct entries of Put on a Bus (from 96 pages, with two entries from the Super Mario Logan page, two entries from Big Time Rush's character sheet, and three from a Glee page, each under different sub-sections).

    open/close all folders 
    LEGIT 19/ 102 
  1. Characters.Champions Marvel Comics: The time travel nonsense makes this consuming, but what it is basically saying is that Kids!Cyclops was a member the time, was written out by going into the past, and was written back in as Adult!Cyclops for a few guest spots.note 
  2. Characters.Timothy Goes To School: The character in question was written as leaving the show to go on vacation, so he was brought back in a way related to how they were Put on a Bus.note 
  3. Characters.Genesis Of Aquarion: His hospitalization kept him from the show, but he returns because spoiler spoiler, which all checks out.note 
  4. YMMV.The RWBY Loops: The gist is a character was put on probation from the main org. the series is about and because they don't work there, they don't appear again until they come back with a vengeance. That's all legit.note 
  5. Characters.Super Mario Logan Main Characters: Jail was used to get him out of the series, although I'm not sure it applies if his return makes zero reference to his bus trip.note 
  6. Velvet Sky: Hey, it doesn't take much. The example specifies how they left both times (left the organization, got fired in-universe) and when they came back.note 
  7. Characters.A Series Of Unfortunate Events: This one also gets it right in a simple way, this time putting more focus on the circumstances of their return.note 
  8. Halo: Envoy: Long-winded, but it gets the point across.note 
  9. VideoSource.Thomas And Friends: Nothing wrong here, since this is just an index noting that a video from this work is used as an example on another page. The video itself seems fine enough too.
  10. Show by Rock!!: Written in context of a Put on a Bus entry.note 
  11. Characters.Murdoch Mysteries: This example actually mentions how each character left the show (sent into hiding / disappeared In-Universe) and mentions they escaped.note 
  12. Literature.The Three Investigators: This is indented under Put on a Bus incorrectly, but besides that, this is a well-detailed (if long-winded) example. If incorporated into the Put on a Bus, example it would be perfectly legit.note 
  13. Characters.Glee New Directions Later Additions: The first example is perfectly okay, while the second would be fine if indented correctly. Either way, both detail how and why the character left and when they came back.note 
  14. Characters.Big Time Rush: Okay, the show is about musicians, makes sense she wouldn't appear after being rejected from auditions. And hey, they mentioned how she was brought back into the fold.note 
  15. PlayingWith.Important Haircut: Seems appropriate enough for such a minor link.note 
  16. Recap.Buffy The Vampire Slayer S 6 E 9 Smashed: This doesn't give all the details, but it gives the minimum to get the idea and that at least makes it a little funnier.note 
  17. Characters.Bomb Girls: This doesn't go into detail on how The Bus Came Back, but this is a Put on a Bus entry, so it doesn't need to. It at least highlights the connection between the two.note 
  18. Recap.Star Trek The Next Generation S 3 E 1 Evolution: Crusher is a textbook example of this trope and this entry succintly gets that across.note 
  19. Characters.Gundam Seed Destiny Project R: There's a pothole to this trope in a character description about someone returning that doesn't seem to be misused.

    No Mention of Being Put On A Bus 63/ 102 
  1. Characters.The Legend Of Korra Allies: This entry never even tries to establish that the character in question left the show, which is fair since he didn't. Kai was never written out of the show, he appeared in a major role earlier that season and traveled alongside Opal, who has a speaking role in like every episode.note 
  2. ComicBook.Extreme Carnage: Neither example applies their subject was written out, and it mainly seems like they were just obscure and unpopular among writers.note 
  3. Recap.South Park S 6 E 17 Red Sleigh Down: Kenny was not Put on a Bus, he was Killed Off for Real.note 
  4. Series.Moesha: The example is straight up saying the character wasn't Put on a Bus.note 
  5. Recap.Doctor Who S 35 Short Prologue: Ohila's fate wasn't addressed at the end of the special, so this is just a character returning after no special fanfare.note 
  6. BetterThanItSounds.Video Games S To Z: These characters never had a written departure from the story and thus, there is no bus from which they may return.note 
  7. Characters.Knots Landing: The one of these the remotely lines up with The Bus Came Back is the third, but even then, it relies on context in another example and is indented incorrectly, so the whole thing is a wash.note 
  8. Recap.The Secret Show S 1 E 22 When Good Food Goes Bad: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  9. WebAnimation.Minilife TV: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  10. YMMV.Street Fighter EX: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  11. Characters.Super Mario Logan Main Characters: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  12. Characters.One Piece Marines: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus. It's worth noting that this is a pretty, organized page with commented out warnings on the top about editing rules that the page largely follows. Misuse of this trope is common even on pages of good quality.note 
  13. Characters.Star Wars Planets And Races: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  14. Recap.Homestar Runner Halloween Hijinks: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  15. ComicBook.Ms Marvel 1977: "Sort of vanished" isn't the sort of deliberate exit that we all associate with buses.note 
  16. Donkey Kong Barrel Blast: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  17. Defenders (2021): Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  18. Recap.The Walking Dead S 08 E 15 Worth: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  19. Characters.Ennui Go: There are 15 examples of this trope on the page. None of them mention anything about being Put on a Bus.note 
  20. Getter Robo: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  21. Recap.Criminal Case Mysteries Of The Past Case 48 Unsafe Haven: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  22. Characters.Violinist Of Hameln: There's a write-up for Put on a Bus on a page, but nothing in this example indicates that.note 
  23. Recap.Criminal Case Mysteries Of The Past Case 30 How The East Was Won: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  24. Heartwarming.Pokemon The Shadow Of Nemesis: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus and is more about a performer returning to a show than the character.note 
  25. The Book of Pooh: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  26. Characters.Casi Angeles: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  27. YMMV.World Of Warcraft: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  28. Green Arrow (Rebirth): Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus. The ;ast example isn't even about anything.note 
  29. Fanfic.Anchor Foal: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  30. Recap.The 7 DS 2 E 13 B What Are You Five: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  31. Recap.Re Boot S 3 E 1 To Mend And Defend: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  32. Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  33. La que se avecina: The first example is fine but sparse, but the second two just don't mention the characters appearing earlier in the series or how they departed from it at all.note 
  34. The Camera Eye Series: This example doesn't even make it clear if Korrina is returning from the series proper or from earlier in the fic. Who is this person and what does her returning mean? I don't know!note 
  35. Recap.Bosch S 7 E 06: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  36. Recap.Arrow S 4 E 22 Lost In The Flood: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  37. Characters.Detentionaire: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  38. Total Drama Return Of The Stars: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  39. Recap.Doctor Who S 33 E 12 Nightmare In Silver: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus, just that they last appeared in a prior entry.note 
  40. Characters.Azur Lane Sirens: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  41. Doom Patrol: This is more of a Retcon or Canon Welding entry. This doesn't even focus on a particular character, so it has nothing to do with Put on a Bus.note 
  42. Characters.Sonic The Hedgehog Modern Era Antagonists 1: Nothing mentioned in any of these examples of being Put on a Bus.note 
  43. Characters.The Dresden Files The Vampires: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  44. Characters.The Walking Dead 2010 Atlanta Survivor Camp: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  45. DarthWiki.Pokemon Peace Squad: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus, and most of these seem to be referring to reappearances from different franchises and continuities anyway.note 
  46. ChuckCunninghamSyndrome.Film: General Ross wasn't written out of the movies, he just didn't appear. Again, nothing here is mentioned about him being written out and it seems the troper here Put on a Bus just means "a character ceases to appear."note 
  47. Characters.Glee New Directions Later Additions: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  48. ComicBook.Venom Space Knight: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  49. Characters.Miss Peregrines Home For Peculiar Children: This entry mentions that the character was specifically not Pot On A Bus.note 
  50. Digimon Adventure: Last Evolution Kizuna: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  51. Recap.Game Of Thrones S 4 E 4 Oathkeeper: Just another mundane re-appearance of characters with no reference to an intentional absence.note 
  52. Cinderjuice: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note  is summoned out of retirement to aid the heroes."[[/note]]
  53. Klonoa: Dream Crusaders: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  54. The Sacred Quest: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  55. HFIL: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus, just it being awhile since the characters last appeared. Most of these guys were just killed off.note 
  56. Muppets Now: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus, just more long absences.note 
  57. Characters.Pokemon The Series Diamond And Pearl Ashs Pokemon: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  58. Characters.K On: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  59. Recap.Odd Squad S 3 E 19 Sixteen And A Half Blocks Follow The Leader: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  60. Credits Gag: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  61. Civilization: This is about content being removed from a game sans story explanation, which isn't literally being metaphorically put on the metaphorical bus.note 
  62. Recap.Gotham S 4 E 7 A Day In The Narrows: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 
  63. Characters.Baywatching: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus.note 

    ZCE/Sinkholes 18/ 102 
  1. Funny.Ravages Of Time: Not even worth copy-pasting, the wick is just a sinkhole over a character's name with no context.
  2. Shocking.Western Animation: Just a sinkhole.note 
  3. Characters.Lego Marvel Super Heroes 2: A character's comic book getting cancelled just has nothing to do with this trope.note 
  4. Recap.Arrow S 7 E 13 Star City Slayer: This isn't even a complete sentence and doesn't even end with proper punctuation.note 
  5. Characters.Sam And Cat: There are two entries on this page that just list "The Bus Came Back" with nothing else.
  6. Adamant Ditto:Commented out zero-context example.note 
  7. YMMV.Mortal Kombat 11: This whole entry is just littered with unnecessary hyperlinks, but The Bus Came Back link is especially bad since this entry mentions that Johnny appeared in the previous game. If that's the case, there's no bus for him to come back from!note 
  8. Characters.Kiwi Blitz: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus or even being absent in the show previously.note 
  9. Characters.Defenders Of The Universe: Nothing mentioned about being Put on a Bus, or even about them previously having been absent from the show.note 
  10. Characters.Beelzebub Other Characters: One entry just name-drops a different character besides the one the entry was for returning and another just mentioned the name of an arc.
  11. Characters.Glee New Directions Later Additions: No mention of how he was Put on a Bus. This is indented under another trope, but that one is also a Zero-Context Example.note 
  12. Series.The Day Of The Triffids 1981: This isn't as bad as the other ones here, but since nothing here really indicates Coker wasn't in the story beforehand, this isn't a super helpful pothole.note 
  13. Characters.The Mystic Knights Of Tir Na Nog: Not even a zero-context example for the right trope.note 
  14. Characters.Big Time Rush: What even needs to be said here, there's just nothing in this example.note 
  15. Quotes.Delayed Reaction: A Steven Universe quote on this page has a character's name spoilered out with a hyperlink to The Bus Came Back, even though that trope has nothing to do with the quote itself.
  16. Recap.Game Of Thrones S 6 E 8 No One: This isn't even a complete sentence.note 
  17. CreditsGag.Gravity Falls: This is just a quote with a sinkhole.note 
  18. Gunnerkrigg Court: This is a spoiler-tagged sinkhole that I'm pretty sure is also a misuse of Wham Shot.note 

    Misc. 2/ 102 
  1. Characters.Corrin Reacts: These are two weird examples, the first may be a legitimate example if being Put on a Bus can apply retroactively and the second might be too, but it doesn't actually mention what chapters they missed so they went mountain climbing. This is more like a three-quarters-context example than a ZCE.note 
  2. WebVideo.Twitch Plays Pokemon Rising Ruby: I have no idea how narrative tropes like this apply to Twitch Plays Pokemon and I'm not gonna figure that out today.note 

Top