#2: Sep 30th 2018 at 10:43:57 PM
This sounds more like a task for a Short Term Projects thread than TRS.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman
Total posts: 2
A discussion on this trope was made here, but that kinda stalled so here goes.
The problem with Obvious Beta is that there is a bit of YMMV on this. According to the other wiki Beta testing is supposed to be for games that are "feature complete", ie it has all the things developers wanted in the game and just needs bug testing. Unfortunately time has caused the phrase to shift slightly in meaning and I myself would classify a game as Obvious Beta only when it is nigh-impossible to play mainly due to poor optimisation, being unstable and Game-Breaking Bugs. Also, some folks seem to think that this is for any game that is in beta, even if they don't try to hide the fact at all (which this trope is).
The page image probably isn't helping, showing an image (missing textures) that according to the strict definition isn't in beta.
Wick check:
In summary: Due to a shift in semantics, as well as being slightly ambiguous in the first place what Obvious Beta means has a lot of YMMV. You reading this might disagree with my analysis / wick check, which is exactly the problem. My suggestions for this trope would be
A. An example cleanup of those that clearly don't fit, as well as ZCEs;
B. Rename the trope to something like Unfinished Release, and perhaps
C. Start a YMMV TLP for works that people feel are unfinished and should not be published, but is.
Edited by BreadBull on Sep 30th 2018 at 6:34:08 PM