Film / Carlito's Way

"Favor gonna kill you faster than a bullet."
Carlito Brigante

Carlito's Way is a Brian De Palma film in which Al Pacino plays a Puerto Rican gangster hoping to reconcile and start a new life after his five year stint in jail. It's a far cry from being another Scarface (1983), though Carlito's Way may be seen as its spiritual successor. The two films are nearly inversions of each other; where Tony Montana rises from a nobody to a prominent drug lord, Carlito Brigante attempts to reform after a life of notoriety. Both films however, go their way to show that gangster life is not all it's cracked up to be.

In 1975, Carlito Brigante is released from prison with help from his lawyer and friend David Kleinfeld (Sean Penn), after discovering that the prosecutor's evidence has been gathered through questionable means. From this second chance at life, Carlito decides to reform himself for good, vowing to stay legitimate and out of crime's way. He manages to buy a nightclub and rekindle his relationship with Gail (Penelope Ann Miller), a beautiful dancer.

Unfortunately, Carlito's criminal past catches up with him - his former associates, along with an up and coming gangster Benny Blanco from the Bronx, attempt to cajole him back into the gangster life. Further complicating things, the FBI wishes to see Carlito Brigante put back in jail. But the biggest obstacle is David Kleinfeld's dilemma with a mafioso boss 'Tony T.' who is locked up inside Rikers Island; Tony T. wants Kleinfield to spring him out, and Kleinfeld isn't sure of what other plans Tony T. has in mind for him afterwards..

The film was an adaptation of two novels by Edwin Torres: Carlito's Way (1975) and its sequel After Hours (1979). It left out several events of the first novel. Said events were eventually filmed for a prequel. Carlito's Way: Rise To Power was released straight to video in 2005. It covers the criminal activities of Carlito in the 1960s. The prequel was directed by Michael Bregman. The titular character was played by Jay Hernandez. The film remains relatively obscure, failing to gain much attention.

This film has examples of:

  • Action Prologue: The delivery that Carlito accompanies his cousin on is this, given that it takes place a month before the main action of the film. It isn't specifically framed as a prologue, however, only being subtly disconnected from the main body of the film.
  • Added Alliterative Appeal:
    • Benny Blanco from the Bronx.
    • And Tony T.
  • Asshole Victim: Carlito decides to let his lawyer, Kleinfeld, get killed by Vinnie T. for killing his father. Then there's also Pachanga, who was killed after betraying Carlito at the end.
  • Big Bad Friend: Kleinfeld has already sold out Carlito to the FBI with trying to frame him of cocaine dealing, even having offered to testify against him. Though interestingly, the FBI believe Carlito's attempt to go straight is genuine, and try to use him to instead bust Kleinfeld.
  • Bittersweet Ending: Though Carlito dies in the end, Gail makes it out to the Bahamas with their unborn child.
  • Bottomless Magazines: Averted. After firing a Colt .45 seven times, Carlito runs out of ammo and has to pretend to reload to scare some thugs.
  • Chekhov's Gunman: Literally.
    "Remember me? Benny Blanco from the Bronx?" * BLAM BLAM BLAM*
  • Chronic Villainy: Subverted. Carlito is unwittingly involved in several crimes, but he never directly perpetrates any himself. Unfortunately, the FBI and others suspect him of this.
  • Determinator: Vinnie T takes at least two or three to the chest, drags himself covered in his own blood across Grand Central Station, and still keeps shooting.
  • Dutch Angle: Used pragmatically - whenever the camera tilts, it's leveling two or three faces which are at different heights. As it happens, this positioning occurs in especially tense moments.
  • Face–Heel Turn: Carlito's best buddy Pachanga sells him out to a rival gangster, in the very end.
  • Fatal Flaw:
    • Either Carlito's past, his code of loyalty even to those who put him back In Harm's Way, or his determination to stay straight.
    • Kleinfeld's stemming inferiority complex, which leads to putting Carlito into deep trouble after he botches the Rikers Island breakout.
  • Foil: Contrast Carlito's determination to stay straight with Kleinfeld's efforts to dig himself into a hole of his own corruption and stupidity.
  • Foreshadowing: Pachanga is mentioned early on to be interested in selling Carlito out.
  • The Hero Dies: Carlito was killed before he could escape on the train with Gail.
  • Hidden Wire: Lalín, one of Carlito's past friends comes by for a visit, to have Carlito find Lalín hooked up to a listening bug courtesy of Norwalk. Lalín claims he turned it off beforehand.
  • Hope Spot: Carlito gets away from the Italian mobsters chasing him and it looks like he's going to make it to the train, but then Benny Blanco from the Bronx does Carlito in from petty revenge...
  • How We Got Here: The movie starts with Carlito on the gurney.
  • I Just Want to Be Badass: Gaujiro, Carlito's wannabe Gang Banger cousin, looks up to him but gets killed for his efforts during a drug deal.
    You said they were your friends, but there ain't no friends in this shit business''.
  • Jerkass Has a Point: Tony Taglialucci is quite rude and aggresive towards Dave Kleinfeld because he's convinced the lawyer kept some bribery money (one million dollars) for himself. And as we find out later, he was right.
  • Karma Houdini: Benny Blanco from the Bronx not only escapes his karma, but defies Carlito's as well.
  • Kick the Dog: After all the trouble Carlito went through to help him, Kleinfeld has already betrayed him to the FBI anyway.
  • The Millstone: Kleinfeld gets Carlito out of jail. After that, he only gets in the way of Carlito's goal to clean up his act.
  • The Mole: Carlito's friend Lalín is wearing a wire as part of the FBI's attempt to bust Carlito, but he's found out quickly. Also Kleinfeld and Pachanga.
  • Narrator: Carlito narrates throughout the movie, stream-of-consciousness.
  • No Good Deed Goes Unpunished: Carlito chooses to spare Benny Blanco's life. Benny kills him in return.
  • Noodle Incident: Characters would often talk about incidents and people from the past that aren't in the movie. Example:
    Oh, Carlito! I heard of you, man. You used to run smack with Rolando.
  • Off on a Technicality: Carlito got out of jail because of a prosecutor's mistake.
  • Pay Evil unto Evil: Kleinfeld uses Carlito to murder a prominent criminal because of his own egotism and gets Carlito a mark on his back from the Maffia. Carlito lets him have what is coming to him by arranging his death.
  • Pillow Pistol: Kleinfeld keeps one while he is recovering in the hospital. Carlito tells him to keep it in plain sight and unloads it. Cue Oh Crap! from Kleinfeld before he is shot by Vinnie T..
  • Pretender Diss: Carlito does not like gangster wannabes. At all. The problem is the guy he directed the comment to, Benny Blanco, wasn't a gangster wannabe. He was a young modern version of Carlito himself. It's even pointed out in the film.
    "Maybe I don't give a shit! Maybe I don't remember the last time I blew my nose either.. Who the fuck are you? I should remember you? What, you think you like me? You ain't like me motherfucker, you a punk. I've been with made people, connected people. Who've you been with? Chain snatching, jive-ass, maricón motherfuckers. Why don't you get out of here and go snatch a purse."
  • P.O.V. Cam: Carlito on the gurney.
  • Rewarded as a Traitor Deserves: Benny Blanco is smart enough to dispose of Pachanga after the latter betrays his former boss Carlito.
  • Roaring Rampage of Revenge: Vinnie T., after his father Tony T. is killed in the botched Rikers Island breakout. Unfortunately, Carlito gets mixed up in it.
  • Shadow Archetype:
    • Benny Blanco is an unpleasant reminder of how nasty Carlito used to be.
    • In a meta-example, Carlito is this to Tony Montana from Scarface (1983).
  • Someone to Remember Him By: Carlito himself finds out that Gail had an unborn child before dying.
  • Time Skip: Lampshaded. After the murder of Carlito's cousin, Pachanga offers his condolences. Carlito is annoyed that he's only saying this now, when a month has passed. Other than Carlito having made a bit of money in the club, there are no obvious signs that any real time has passed besides this line.
  • Too Dumb to Live: Kleinfeld makes many mistakes in his constant paranoia and feelings of inferiority, leading to the majority of the trouble for Carlito after the breakout and his own Karmic Death in the end.
  • Tragedy: Carlito's Way is a tragedy of character in the backdrop of high-risk, stark gangster life.
  • A Tragedy of Impulsiveness: Carlito Brigate himself is pretty level-headed, but his lawyer friend David Kleinfeld dooms the entire cast by impulsively killing his mob boss client during a jailbreak. This might be a subversion, though, as Carlito suspects that Kleinfeld planned to kill the mob boss all along and played Carlito himself for a fool.
  • Tragic Mistake:
    • Carlito probably would have avoided all his troubles with Tony T. had he'd told his friend Kleinfeld to take a hike.
    • Carlito's death at the hands of Benny Blanco from the Bronx would have been all avoided had he left Benny Blanco from the Bronx alone in the nightclub, killed him like Pachanga wanted to, or just gotten rid of Pachanga who everyone knows can't be trusted.
    • Simply tipping his hand about leaving town, especially to Pachanga, would have made for a happy ending.
  • What an Idiot: In-universe example. Carlito is pissed that Kleinfeld would be so stupid as to kill a mafia boss and his son. And this is the same boss who Kleinfeld had already ripped a million bucks off from, too!
  • White Collar Crime: Kleinfeld is implied to participate in some of these.
  • You Have Out Lived Your Usefulness: Pachanga to Benny Blanco from the Bronx.
    "Naw, you stay here!" * BLAM*