The Bottomless Coin Sack intentionally fails economics
Shortly after obtaining it, the owner realizes how utterly worthless it is due to basic economics.
The reason why the game doesn't really "end" after beating it and why it has multiple branching paths is because Wario is stuck in a "Groundhog Day" Loop
. This is hinted at in the ending of the "Uncanny Mansion" story, where the adventure up to this point seems like it's pulling an All Just a Dream
, but we see the Brown Sugar Pirates arriving at Wario's castle, much like in the opening
. How the loop is caused is still a bit cloudy, but considering collecting the treasures and map pieces reveals an Eldritch Location where Captain Syrup's treasure is kept,
one could argue that Syrup somehow caused this. Maybe Syrup found the Eldritch Location
by accident and thought it might have been the perfect place to hide her stash, not knowing what kind of effect it would've had on the fabric of space-time. So, only by removing the treasure from that location
could the "Groundhog Day" Loop
be broken and would Wario no longer be pestered by the Brown Sugar Pirates, hence why they don't appear in the following games (until Wario Land: Shake It!, that is).
Think about it. When Wario was defeated at the end of Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
, he had given up his hat in favor of Mario's powerups, probably with the intent to mock him, but this backfired greatly. Wario Land 1
was for a long while the only game in which he could run out of lives and face a Game Over
. Wario loses/discards his cap in the file select screen, then picks up the Explorer Hat as a poor replacement. He later recovers his hat and uses it to its full effect through the rest of the series. The game over from Wario Land 3
could be explained as having been trapped by Rudy in the magic box
; note that Wario is sleeping in that scene. And in Wario Land 4
he doesn't really die; he is warped back to the entrance of the level. He dons Silver Zephyr's disguise in Master Of Disguise
, which gives him powers, again, at the cost of his invincibility by not wearing his cap. As a side note, Mario takes doubled damage
wherever he isn't wearing his cap.
From the normal ending, where Wario defeats Captain Syrup and gets his treasure back, he doesn't really change his ways and heads on to Wario World
and Wario Land: Shake It!
. From the Invade Wario Castle ending, Wario begins to learn that greed is not enough and goes on to Wario Land 3
where money is much less of an object. From the temple ending, Wario finds out that ruins are great sources of treasure and heads for Wario Land 4
. From the ghost house ending, Wario begins to have bad luck with treasure and fantasizes about getting it, which eventually leads him into Wario: Master of Disguise
. And from the factory ending, Wario gains skills in operating machines which lead him into WarioWare
At the end of Super Mario Land 3, Wario also wished for immortality.
After all, what self-respecting megalomaniac would want a castle if they'll have to die and give it up eventually? This also explains why the genie wanted money in exchange for giving Wario a castle; it was actually a fee for additional wishes.
At the end of Wario Land 3, Rudy sensed that Wario was immortal, and somehow undid the genie's magic in order to kill Wario. Not only did this leave Wario mortal in his fight with Rudy and every future installment of the series, but it also stripped him of his castle. Notice how we never see his castle in Wario Land 4, and from WarioWare Inc.: Mega Microgame$ onward, he lives in a house, possibly bought with the treasure that he got from the music box in Wario Land 3. His castle is never mentioned again, because Rudy erased it from existence.
Yes, he is also quite mortal in Virtual Boy Wario Land, but there are two possibilities for that. Either VBWL was a prequel, or Wario's immortality wish didn't take effect immediately. Immortality is a rather powerful wish, after all, so the genie may have needed some time to gather the magic necessary to grant it.