Follow TV Tropes

Following

Recap / Law & Order: Special Victims Unit S11 E16 "Witness"

Go To

Written By Christine M Torres and Dawn De Noon

Directed By David Platt

A woman (Diora Baird) is raped (by a man played by Eric Lange) in the stairwell of her apartment building, but the only witness (Saidah Arrika Ekulona) to the attack is in fear of being deported back to Africa. When the rape victim later succumbs to a Staph infection due to an injury inflicted on her during the attack, it becomes imperative to convince the witness to testify in order to get the victim justice. Alex Cabot also features in her last appearance on the show.


This episode provides examples of:

  • Attention Whore: The main cast accuse Lainie McCallum to be one. Despite being generally portrayed as sympathetic, the main cast wasn't portrayed to be in the wrong. Dr. Huang raises the possibility that she has Histrionic Personality Disorder.
  • Big Damn Heroes: Nardalee Ula stops Bryce Kelton from raping Lainie McCallum.
  • Bittersweet Ending: While Lainie McCallum gets justice for her rape, she didn't live to see it happen and he was not found guilty of her later death. Nardalee Ula also declines a chance to be a proper U.S. citizen and decides to help the women in Kongo. Finally, Alex was inspired by Nardalee and resigns as an A.D.A. to be an international lawyer, leaving the cast for the second time.
  • Book Ends: Alex returned to the series walking towards Elliot and Olivia wearing her white coat. She exists the series walking away from Elliot and Olivia wearing her white coat.
  • But Now I Must Go: Alex was inspired by Nardalee Ula's bravery and resolve that she resigns as an A.D.A. to become an international lawyer.
  • Crying Wolf: Discussed with Lanie. Dr. Huang suggests that she has Histrionic Personality Disorder, causing her to be overdramatic and an Attention Whore, which made it more difficult to believe when something genuinely horrible happened to her. She didn't mention Nardalee coming to her rescue until the third time she told the story, changing everything with the possibility of a witness.
  • A Day in the Limelight: As this is her last episode as a regular (for the second time), Alex gets the focus of all the main cast.
  • Deadly Scratch: Lainie had a nasty gash on her hand from the knife used by the rapist. Several weeks later she was giving a deposition and collapsed while hyperventilating. The cut ended up having a staph infection that was not caught in time and she died later that day.
  • Decoy Protagonist: While Lainie McCallum is the Victim of the Week, she dies halfway through the episode leaving the witness and hero to her rape, Nardalee Ula, as the central guest character.
  • Defiled Forever: Nardalee's husband rejected her after she was raped the first time.
  • Doomed Hurt Guy: Lainie McCallum gets her hand sliced during a sexual assault and dies about halfway through the episode when the wound gets infected with Staph.
  • End of an Age: This is Alex Cabot's final episode as a series regular (for the second time).
  • History Repeats:
    • Alex departs the cast for the second time.
    • Much like last season (which was ironically Alex's return episode), the A.D.A main character departs third quarter into the season.
  • The Illegal: Nardalee Ula immigrated from Kongo illegally. This was the main reason why she didn't want to testify against Bryce Kelton as doing so would expose her to the immigration department.
  • Irony: Alex's first departure is her being sent to witness protection. Here she leaves because she was inspired by her witness.
  • Let Them Die Happy: Benson ended up being the only one likely to be with Lainie during her last moments, when she asks if Jason is coming Benson lies and says he is, as telling the truth would be needlessly hurtful.
  • Killed Offscreen: Lainie McCallum succumbs to her hand infection, but her actual demise wasn't shown.
  • Ms. Fanservice: Lainie McCallum is a Shameless Fanservice Girl who has No Nudity Taboo, provided two Lingerie Scenes, Toplessness from the Back, and wears off-shoulders and mini-skirt during a trial that forces Alex to borrow a blazer from a court staff just to cover her up a little.
  • Offscreen Moment of Awesome: Nardalee Ula's Big Damn Heroes moment above is only told by her rescuee Lainie McCallum.
  • Outliving One's Offspring: Nardalee's six year-old daughter died from internal injuries she sustained when she and her mother were raped.
  • Put on a Bus: Alex departs as a series regular for the second time.
  • Rape as Drama: Bryce Kelton forcing his way on Lainie McCallum is the entire plot of the episode.
  • Rape as Backstory: Nardalee Ula was repeatedly raped by African Terrorists. This was the reason she came to the U.S.
  • Rape Is a Special Kind of Evil: The episode's theme.
  • Secondary Character Title: The title refers to Nardalee Ula.
  • Shameless Fanservice Girl: Lainie McCallum has no qualms if people see her in her underwear or dressing in front of them. She's also fond of wearing revealing clothes.
  • Slut-Shaming: Lainie brings up how everyone treats her as though she Really Gets Around because of the way she dresses and her flirtatious personality, but she had only been with three men she genuinely loved.
  • Stalker with a Crush:
    • Lainie McCallum is this towards a man named Jason. She claims that they were Childhood Friends, but Jason's dialogue suggests that they're really not.
    • Bryce Kelton is this for Lainie herself, with his eventual rape kick-starting the entire episode.
  • Wham Line:
    • Lainie collapses during a deposition and doctors reveal the cut on her hand had a staph infection that spread to her chest, she only had hours to live.
    • Nardalee casually telling Olivia that Alex is coming with her to Congo.


Top