In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Grim, God of Loser Grim Reapers (Reaper, Grimmy, G, Skeleton Man, Big Dummy, Bone Head) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Afterlife Entities (House of Death and Postmortem)
- Billy, God of Negative Intelligence as a Lesser God in the Hall of Mindsets (House of Knowledge)
- Mandy, Goddess of Tiny Tyrannical Girls as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Child Archetypes (House of Childhood and Adolescence)
- Jack O'Lantern, Damned Soul of Halloween as a Lesser God in the Hall of Festivities and Holidays (House of Celebration)
- Hoss Delgado, God of Prejudice Towards Monsters as a Lesser God in the Hall of Categorism (House of Hatred and Rancor)
- Irwin Dracula, God of Being Dumber Than They Look (Nerd, Freak, Urkel) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Mindsets (House of Knowledge)
- Grim's Scythe (Jodie) can be found in The Great Treasury, under the Artifacts Library
- The Left-Hand of Horror can be found in The Great Treasury, under Maximum Security
