I was about to pop in to confirm that Irrose removed an example that was properly You Monster!
instead. I also thought that something sounded fishy and familiar about the edit Irrose removed, and found that it's the same guy who made the questionable edit before that I removed from Tales of Vesperia
. I think I have to report him to Ask The Tropers
; he's done quite a few other questionable edits involving this and other YMMV tropes.
@3597 That's a bit rambling and incoherent. But at least I can tell what character you mean and from where. That said, you don't really say why they would belong.
@3598 Okay, then it seems the two Vagners qualify. Upon research, it appears that most of Telebornian's crimes are offscreen, so he should be cut.
@3600 I would cut anyone from Rocky
and its sequels. The deaths were all accidental, unless you want to make commentary on the barbarism of boxing (and I personally would rather not).
@3601 Hmm... The song "The Torture Never Stops" is much mroe vague than I remember. The evil prince involved, the only thing he does is... carve up a pig to eat (and then eat the feet and snout). Yeah, I think we can cut that. "Such Horrible Things" does deserve to stay, though - it's not about success, it's about the attempt. It's clear that he tries to kill both siblings (he clearly failed with the brother, the sister's fate is unclear), plus it sounds like he at least attempted to mutilate the mailman. Also, it's unclear if the arson attempt was when nobody was around or when there were no potential witnesses who'd survive. I'm inclined to keep.
@3602 No; the Internet tells me that it's the book series that The Rescuers
was based upon (specifically, the second of nine in the series). For all that it matters, info I've found suggests that Madame Medusa from The Rescuers
was based on the Diamond Duchess of Miss Bianca
. Between how little is described and the fact that I said the Disney version didn't count in @1556, I say cut unless someone can offer a good reason to keep.
@3603 Hmm... I believe we could include the example. Any appropriate lyrics to include as well?