Seeking for Light
Correct. Whether a work is Trope Overdosed is completely unrelated to its content, except inasmuch as certain works are going to be more attractive to most tropers.
Never trust a laconic on anything. They are usually wrong about such things. In fact, I'll go fix that. eta: Did it, although it may use a stronger rewrite.
edited 8th Jun '13 8:56:02 AM by SeptimusHeap
No, the other one.
I want to write "Complete. Tropal. Saturation," but I don't think it would be a good idea...
edited 8th Jun '13 10:17:30 AM by AnotherDuck
Check out my fanfiction!
In uffish thought
Can I come here to say that I don't think Painful Rhyme should be YMMV? The idea that you cringe because of a rhyme is YMMV. The idea that a rhyme doesn't work, particularly in spoken English where you know what accent is being used, is not. Spür/mir, from Elisabeth, does not rhyme although it is clearly used as a rhyme. The description could be edited to focus on the latter — I've no clue why it doesn't do so at the moment — and there we have a perfectly objective trope. Whether or not it is removed from the YMMV list, can I remove the Love Never Dies example? That one tries to say that creep/sleep and floor/door/core/for/more are painful, but those are perfect rhymes and not stretched at all.
That looks like a redefinition/split thing, which would take a TRS (not that I am warming up to the prospect of another 300+ wicks TRS thread...)
Seeking for Light
Agreed with this. Hm... Does the usage of the words also flow naturally within the lyrics/poem? Because there's two types of forced rhyme: one which uses slant rhyme or mispronunciation, and one which mangles the text itself to make the rhyme fit. Not being familiar with the work in question, I have no idea if it falls under the latter.
I am nominating Jerkass Dissonance. This is about the reaction of the audience to a jerkass character, after all.
It's a trope.
Bumping to votes.
This is Rain. Isn't she pretty? :)
I've remade Too Good to Last into a disambiguation index. It should get the banner.
Making Too Good to Last a disambig may have been a better idea, but I think it should become a deliberate redlink.
edited 19th Jun '13 7:38:55 PM by MikuruFan
Note that disambig and YMMV are not mutually exclusive. We do that on discontinuity after all.
Using the YMMV banner gives messages that the example should be moved to the YMMV page, when really it should be fixed or removed.
I did some segregation on these indexes back in the day. Basically, if it's all on the audience side it goes on Audience Reactions.
Page Action: YMMV Banner 4
17th Aug '14 8:08:24 AM