"Game recognize game, and you lookin' kinda unfamiliar right now!"
Pushing a new character into the spotlight via Character Derailment
of the character that they're replacing. Dying to Be Replaced
seems merciful and dignified by comparison. At least that way you're dead, or comfortably converted to The Dark Side
, before someone starts messing around with your job.
The "victim" who was Dying to Be Replaced
is moved out of the way, but the victim who is Not as You Know Them
is expected to stick around and suffer. Not only have they lost their old title, it's usually through circumstance rather than their own fault. Unfortunately, whatever happened to them has transformed their personality - generally into something more jaded
. They're still there in the story, they're still (usually) on the side of good... but for all intents and purposes, it may as well be a different character
. They often become a cynical version of The Obi-Wan
to the new hero, who, of course, is much better at their job than they ever were
It's a trick that writers use to keep people tuned in to the show/playing the video game/reading the books when they decide to switch protagonists. Rather than risk starting all over again with a new character, the writers use the old hero as a hook to lure in the "old faithfuls" in the audience. Unfortunately, many fans have become wise to this ploy and view such sequels with some trepidation. It's a bit of a Catch-22 - do you avoid knowing your favorite character's fate, or find out what happened to him, at the risk of realizing that you don't particularly like
what's happened to him?
So why do a character assassination on an old favorite? Well, if the returning character was as lovable as (s)he originally was, the viewers' familiarity with them means that audience allegiance would remain firmly on their side... even when they're going against the new hero. That's not what the writer wants — they want you to follow the new
guy, so the returnee is demoralized to alienate them from the viewers/readers. However, this can backfire if the viewers resent the newcomer already, just for being a "usurper"
, and then find insult added to injury when they find their original, amiable hero has become grumpy and surly in the gap between series.
The quickest way to figure out if a character has become Not as You Know Them
is to ask yourself "if their physical appearance was completely different, and I wasn't told
exactly who they were, would I have figured it out or assumed they were a new character?"
If another character is not benefiting from this character's change in personality, it's a case of Same Character, but Different, NOT this trope.
As is always the case with Character Derailment
tropes, Not as You Know Them
can be fairly subjective; there will be those who hate the changes and declare Fanon Discontinuity
, and those who like them and cite Character Development
(albeit Character Development
that happened "off screen").
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- In Tokyo Mew Mew a la mode, the de-powered Ichigo becomes a sidekick to the new member and temporary leader Shirayuki Berii. Actually, "sidekick" is too strong of a word — she's her Mid-Season Upgrade that just happens to be able to talk.
- The most excessive (and infamously so) case may be the prologue to Kyle Rayner's term as Green Lantern, which required a Face-Heel Turn from signature GL Hal Jordan, who in turn either killed or depowered every other member of the Green Lantern Corps. They were careful not to do this when Hal was redeemed and returned as Green Lantern. Kyle got upgraded to "Ion" and was promoted out of the way.
- New Aquaman is in. Old Aquaman gets to be turned into a squid-faced being called the Dweller, whom DC keeps around to keep his fans reading... until he is Killed Off for Real.
- The original Aquaman returns to defend Atlantis in Final Crisis #7... with no explanation given about his death and whatnot.
- Ryan Choi is the New Atom. Old Atom ran off after his ex-wife (whom he still loved) went crazy/evil. After a "Search for Ray Palmer", the old Atom has been found, but he is now portrayed as cowardly, and eventually this is revealed to be the result of a complicated plot from his nemesis Chronos to discredit him. Then Ryan gets Stuffed into the Fridge and the Justice League: Cry for Justice mini has Ray Palmer torturing a supervillain by shrinking down and stepping on the bad guy's brain. Take note: that's exactly how his ex-wife Jean Loring accidentally murdered Sue Dibny. And this is the same Ray Palmer who in Blackest Night was chosen to be temporarily a member of the Indigo Tribe to help battle Nekron. Each of the Corps are based on a particular emotion, which is how they recruit potential members i.e Scarecrow was made into a Sinestro Corps member due to his obsession with fear. Want to know what the Indigo Tribe's emotion is? Compassion. Possible Fridge Brilliance as Indigo Tribe seems to be made up of brainwashed individuals devoid of compassion, who are infected with it by the rings. People already overly-compassionate wouldn't be able to handle all the extra compassion that the ring comes with.
- Jim Phelps in the Mission: Impossible movies. The original actor wisely refused to return to play the original character as he turns evil so the new guy can kick his ass on the way to becoming the new main character.
Live Action TV
- In the 1988 series War of the Worlds, mercenary John Kincaid joined the cast in the second season to fight alien invaders, and the cast changed as a result. The character he was replacing (Lt. Paul Ironhorse) was kidnapped, replaced with a doppelganger, and then shot himself in the head. Kincaid got more depressed as the series went on, especially when his brother (who he thought was dead) came back - and then died for real. Even the main cast was affected. The lead, Harrison Blackwood, lost his quirky nature, and started carrying weapons, when he refused to do so in the first season, and his accomplice, Suzanne, became so stupid that she didn't know how to bake a cake!
- Chloe Sullivan suffered from this during the 7th season of Smallville, once Lois Lane was hired at the Daily Planet in a chain of events that led to Chloe being fired by Lex Luthor for protecting Clark. This came a few episodes after she had gleefully handed over all her info she had compiled through investigation on the Luthors to Lois.
- From Merlin: After several years of being terrorized at the hands of Uther and being poisoned by Merlin in a somewhat misguided attempt to save Camelot from a sleeping spell, Morgana leaves the show under the protection of her half-sister Morgause. At some point the writers must have felt that all she'd suffered through made her too sympathetic, and so went out of her way to make her a sneering, smirking super-villain in series 3.
- Andy Bernard suffered this in the 9th season of The Office (US) as part of a writer attempt to shill two new characters - Nellie and Pete. Andy had perfectly legitimate reasons to hate Nellie (who had stolen his job the previous season) but the writers apparently forgot this and consistently portray her as The Woobie and him as a bully. Pete meanwhile simply steals Andy's girlfriend Erin and is portrayed as a much better partner, Andy having suddenly lost all sensitivity towards Erin when as recently as the 8th season he had broken off an engagement with another woman to be with her.
- Kes of Star Trek: Voyager was written out of the show early in the fourth season as having Ascended to a Higher Plane of Existence. But then in season 6, she's back in her physical body and out for Revenge on Voyager thanks to not remembering she'd left on her own, killing B'Elanna, not listening to anyone, and trying to abduct her younger self. Quite the opposite of the entirely good-natured person she was while on the crew.
- In Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney, the main character of the first three games has been disbarred and become a piano player since we last saw him. His sense of justice takes a battering after this, and he is no longer the upright, optimistic lawyer of the first three games. Stepping up to bat is novice lawyer Apollo Justice.
- On the flip side, borderline Idiot Hero Phoenix has become something of The Chessmaster in the intervening years, working to reinstitute trial by jury in order to collar Kristoph Gavin, the man who destroyed Phoenix's reputation and plotted multiple murders to keep his own spotless. Considering the way he shrugs off getting hit by a car, one could argue he's been upgraded into a full-blown Determinator.
- Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World supposedly features Lloyd as an antagonist. The opening has him killing people in the burning ruins of what had been Palmacosta. Your first few encounters place him as either crazy or evil. it is later shown that this was an impostor. You then meet up with the real Lloyd who, while changed, is clearly not with the bad guys.
- In Mega Man X7, the reluctant warrior X is suddenly an obstructionist pacifist so that Axl can steal the show.
- Subverted in Mega Man Zero when X appears to be the antagonist, but it turns out to be an impostor, and the real X is a cyber elf.
- In Deus Ex: Invisible War, the hero of the original Deus Ex has been converted from a badass secret agent with a practical take on geopolitics, to an intellectual super-being with a god complex who wants to reshape the world in his image. He's also the Final Boss in every ending EXCEPT for the one where you side with his faction.
- Justified, he had his mind merged with an AI programmed to reshape the world in its image. It's also complicated by the fact that players were able to determine his character in the first game — playing him as an intellectual super-being with a god complex was entirely possible.
- Dreamfall, the sequel to The Longest Journey, brought back the heroine of the previous game, about thirty years older and absurdly cynical and bitter. She was still the most appealing main character in the game.
- Contra: Shattered Soldier plays this straight: Lance Bean, player 2 in the early Contra games, was apparently killed off between games (causing him to be replaced by Lucia, a female protagonist), only to be revealed that he still alive and is in fact the terrorist leader (the game attempts to justify by this by revealing that Lance is a Well-Intentioned Extremist who was fighting against the evil masterminds actually responsible for the Alien Wars). Neo Contra lampshades by having Lucia, Lance's replacement, do a Face-Heel Turn herself.
- In Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal, you play as a new character. However, deep inside the final dungeon of the game, you find the player character from the original Pokémon Red, Blue and Yellow, who elsewhere in the game is stated to have been missing for years, simply standing there in an empty cave staring towards the wall and not speaking to you before or after he battles you (with what are far and away the most powerful Pokémon owned by any trainer in the game). Some would argue that the lack of speech is simply because he is a Silent Protagonist in the original games, though in fact the dialogue of other characters frequently implies that your character actually spoke but you simply didn't see it directly. Either way the experience of finding the familiar character there living alone in a cave is remarkably unsettling.
- It's possible that he just happened to be passing through that particular cave at a time when you walked in, the same way all the NPCs in the games just stay in one place but are presumed not to be there for their whole lives. It's highly unlikely that he actually stayed in that one spot forever.
- In ObsCure II, Shannon went from a fairly upbeat Hollywood Nerd to a jerkass goth girl, Stan went from a pot-smoking slacker to an ex-convict, and former varsity athlete Kenny literally turned into a monster halfway through the game. This was presumably done to make room for Amy, Corey, and Sven, who have similar character traits to those that the characters listed above had in the first game.
- Prototype 2 replaces protagonist Alex Mercer with new character James Heller, a move the developers made to avert Bag of Spilling and in the hopes Heller would gain more audience sympathy. In the process, they decided to make Alex the villain - by completely inverting his personality and ignoring most of the last game's plot developments. Where Alex once went on a vicious Roaring Rampage of Revenge against those he perceived as responsible for New York's hellish state, killed Greene to stop the infection, and blew himself to pieces preventing New York being nuked, he's now deliberately spreading the infection (including to Heller), making rambling speeches about humanity's worthlessness, working with plants in GENTEK to make the virus more powerful, planning to infect a pre-pubescent girl to create a new "Greene"... Even reading the bridging comics makes it only slightly less difficult to believe they're supposed to be the same person.
- Both Anders and Justice in Dragon Age II. When introduced in Dragon Age: Origins – Awakening, Anders was a free-spirited and carefree mage while the Spirit of Justice was, true to his name, a Knight in Shining Armor inhabiting a decaying corpse. Between the events of both games, Anders takes Justice into him and becomes an Abomination and both of them change incredibly. Vengeance is no longer concerned with doing general goodwill, but on avenging the mages that it feels are oppressed, while Anders loses most of his humor and concerns himself entirely with the plight of mages. Over time, the two become increasingly more obsessed with bringing down the Circle of Mages and the Templars, culminating in blowing up the Chantry to invoke a war between them.
- Peculiar example: Egon in Extreme Ghostbusters couldn't really be said to be "not as you know him" - he always was an absent-minded genius, and doesn't change in the sequel series - he's just Older and Wiser. Janine, too, remains much the same personality-wise. However, when the other three original Ghostbusters turn up, their circumstances have changed drastically Maybe Peter's new role as a Hollywood agent was believable, but idealistic, paranormal-obsessed Ray as a salesman qualified as a "huh?" moment. In this case, it's not so much the characters' personalities that have changed so much as their role in life... but since ghostbusting was so central to their character make-up, it's still a culture shock for anyone who watched the original series. It's just as much of a culture shock to the new generation of Ghostbusters as it is to the viewers.
- In Transformers: Beast Wars, Optimus Primal was a competent, down-to-earth commander with a tendency to make somewhat sappy speeches. In Beast Machines, Optimus became some kind of spiritual teacher/fanatical terrorist, and the "down-to-earth commander" role got passed to Cheetor, probably the only returning character in the series who didn't get shafted by his personality change.
- Not that Cheetor didn't suffer any. First, he reacted to everything Optimus said as if it was the dumbest thing in the world, even when Optimus wasn't being fanatical, to the point that he reminded you of a certain jet-bot. However, he got better.
- From Around the World in 80 Days we have Fix. Where in the original novel Fix was a Scotland Yard detective who chased Phileas Fogg because he believed him guilty of bank robbery, here he's a thug hired by the malicious Lord Maze to stop Fogg from going around the world in 80 days so Fogg could marry Lord Maze's niece.
- Anyone familiar with The Get Along Gang who watches this pilot for an aborted revival of the series will probably find themselves planting some Epileptic Trees regarding how little Portia Porcupine may have possibly betrayed the original Gang sometime in the past 60 years and is now organizing a new Get Along Gang either to atone for her previous sins or to facilitate a plan against the "common foe" the theme song speaks of...or both.
- In Wolverine and the X-Men, Cyclops is turned into basically the sum of all the bad qualities Wolverine used to have before they made him a Canon Sue (right down to being easily pushed to Ax-Crazy, causing a lot of collateral damage in one episode while raving like a madman.) When he can be bothered to do something other than angst over Jean being missing, his role is "the one who's always wrong so Wolverine can be right." Alternate explanation: the writers were simply taking in all of the Flanderization Cyclops has gone through over the years (the nigh-constant Wangst over Jean and his disconnection from the team) and leaving out a fair portion of his honest Character Development that has made him a proper team leader.
- In Ben 10: Omniverse, Gwen and Kevin are much different when they return than they were when they left in the first episode, making Rook look like a more compatible sidekick to Ben in the process.