These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
In his review of Anaconda, Phelous theorizes that the reason the anaconda is attacking isn't because it's hungry, but because Jon Voight has been strangling people with his legs and framing the snake and because Jennifer Lopez and Ice Cube were the heroes.
Benzaie and Phelous both believe the Professor in Humains drags his son along on the expedition because he hates him and just hopes he'll die at some point.
In his Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde review he states that Lanyon died not because of the maddening revelation but of the fact that he sniffed the poison he found in Jekyll's cabinet. He also portrays the Nanny as a psycho who nonchalantly tells horrifying tales of murder to children.
In his review of the Mortal Kombat Conquest episode "Thicker than Blood", he believes that Scorpion is in love with Siro's brother Cassar, and the reason why he kills said brother by the end of the episode is because he broke his heart by leaving him for the good guys.
In Pulse 3, suggests that Justine's bad attitude towards everyone, being a Zombie Advocate, destroying the cure for the internet ghosts because one guy was a dick to her, simply proves that she's her mother's daughter. Her mother being an unstable, neglectful parent who tried to murder her.
In his "Beauty and the Beast" review he sees the Bumbling Dad who's dim but ultimately loves his daughter as a selfish, entitled, stupid and emotionally manipulative Jerkass who guilts his daughter into a possible deadly situation and reaps the benefits of poor business dealings and incompetent parenthood.
In The Real Ghostbusters Christmas Carol, Phelous remarks that the real monster is the butcher who gave Cratchit and his family the smallest bird possible, since it's so tiny that it could have been a baby pidgeon. And it was an accomplishment to being even more evil with the actual Scrooge in the episode.
Phelous killing the hooker in his basement and burping afterwards in the Mortal Komedy review.
Crosses the Line Twice: The end of his Pulse 3 review. After reviewing 5 films that have the name "Pulse" he manages to resurrect a dead Angry Joe...Only for Joe to laugh manically as he shoots Phelous over and over and over again.
The entirety of the Titanic Bot review.
Phelous: How big of an asshole would I be to put ice cubes in there? I'm already doing a Titanic Bot review, too late for dignity!
Harsher in Hindsight: The ending skit to his review of Pulse (2006) involves Jew Wario asking Phelous "want to see a ghost?" and then proceeding to perform the "face downloading" that the ghosts in the movie did to their victims. With Jew Wario's passing in 2014, a joke about him being a "ghost" doesn't seem quite so funny anymore.
He Panned It, Now He Sucks: He's gotten quite a bit of backlash for giving a negative review of Turtles Forever stating that it glorified the 2003 incarnation of the turtles and dumbed-down the 1980s incarnation of the turtles.
Hilarious in Hindsight: In the end credits of one of his early reviews, he added a note at the end stating that he was going for The Nostalgia Critic's record for dying in his reviews. Probably safe to say that he's succeeded by now.
The gag has apparently been retired, as he doesn't die nearly as much after adopting the Doctor Who intro. To Phelous's chagrin after reviewing the 30th Anniversary edition of Night of the Living Dead (which featured a new score and new scenes badly spliced into it).
Phelous(crying): I remember when I used to die. Those were good times.
"Actually, I'm glad this is dead snow, because I'd sure hate to see living snow!"
Hype Backlash: Phelous reviews The Human Centipede in his bathroom - not because he finds the movie disgusting, but because he finds it a piece of shit, largely due to people making it a big deal.
Idiot Plot: A lot of the movies he reviews have one. Special mention goes to Incubus, which he describes as the "Anti-Logic Movie", and later on refers to extreme stupidity displayed in other movies as "Incubus logic".
It's the Same, Now It Sucks: A lot of his critics say that he hasn't really changed his style at all during his run and as a result, appears to be suffering from burnout.
Never Live It Down: The whole Running Gag of Phelous dying and coming back to life over and over. It's arguably his best-known joke, repeatedly pointed out on this very page, and was the main hook for his character in To Boldly Flee, but Phelous himself abandoned the joke after about fifty episodes and has consciously avoided it ever since.
Nightmare Fuel: The Lion and the King style Phelous that shows up at the end of that review.
Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Responses to his early videos ranged from "Shows promise" to "Painfully bad" since then he's become one of the most consistently entertaining producers on the site, and certainly tied with Spoony for most visually inventive reviews. Additionally, his role in Kickassia helped win over some new fans.
Special Effects Phailure: Phelous's own effects are actually pretty good for a lone guy doing them on his own. He'll often mock those of the movie, though.
An entirely needless special effects failure occurred throughout much of Pulse 2, where actors were green-screened into scenes that they didn't even need to be, such as in front of houses and such. Phelous mocks this by screening himself in front of his own normal background (it's actually good enough that you might not have noticed unless he pointed it out, complete with his image doing a 180).