These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
The announcements of Doomsday and Raven. Both characters have received both praise and criticism for their appearance, moveset, and especially their voices (particularly Raven for the latter, whose demonically deepened voice doesn't sound like the expected Tara Strong). Even after Tara herself revealed that she still is Raven, the camp of "We want Teen/Non-Demonized Raven voice back" is still not destroyed... yet.
Killer Frost. Some are fine with her inclusion, others are upset that she was chosen over Captain Cold, and others still decry her as just filling out the "ice character/Sub-Zero/Frost" archetype instead of giving it to a more deserving non-archetype character.
Damian's role in the story has set off quite a few fans, especially since the game was released after his Heroic Sacrifice in the comics around the same time. The death itself - There are those who are glad, considering some of the other deaths that have been seen in the game and comics, that it's not Damian brutally killing Dick; and those who think the death was incredibly anti-climatic.
The three DLC characters after Lobo (who avoids this, being generally popular) found by datamining all generate praise and controversy to some degree.
Batgirl for being yet another Bat-character, and for being Barbara Gordon instead of Cassandra Cain or Stephanie Brown.
Scorpion, because he's not even a DC character and is clearly only included because of NetherRealm's previous work.
General Zod, out of initial fear that, as he has the exact same powers as Superman, he would play too closely to Superman, and the stigma that he's only included in the game because of his role in Man of Steel.
And the same person who made the initial leak is claiming that they have found data implying Martian Manhunter, Power Girl, Red Hood, and Sub Zero will be added as DLC later. So the entire Broken Base is starting all over again, and for the exact same reasons.
The sheer number of costumes for Superman, Wonder Woman and Batman. Aside from the Teen Titans, Killing Joke and Earth 2 packs, every DLC pack includes a costume for at least one of the three.
General Zod getting his battle armor from Man of Steel as a DLC skin, when the majority of the characters on the disc haven't received one (and in fact is the only DLC character to have an alternate skin thus far).
The "Bat-Cast"/"Everyone Else" ratio. Catwoman - the fourth Batman character after Batman himself, Harley Quinn, and Nightwing - was announced prior to major heroes like Green Lantern and Shazam. With Joker's inevitable inclusion, that brought the ratio up to five of a presumed 24, which became six after Bane's inclusion, and seven after Batgirl's. As it stands, an approximate fourth of the overall roster is Batman-centric. Fans are split on whether even more should be included or if the "Bat-Cast" has more than its fair share, some even feeling that there should just be a Batman-focused fighting game at this rate.
The cameos in Arkham Asylum have their own split, some content to have them appear at all and others bemoaning that Killer Croc isn't playable.
This even extends into arenas. Of a total fifteen stages, six are related to Batman and two of them are variations of another: day/night versions of Wayne Manor, and Arkham/Joker's Asylum. Not helping matters is how the day version of Wayne Manor is never used in the story.
This is brought even further in the game's story mode, where Batman is the only character to get two chapters (one as the main Batman and one as his Insurgency counterpart)—not to mention a quick fight sandwiched in between Wonder Woman's and Superman's chapters Batman vs Batman.
The costumes more or less fall into this. The Darker and Edgier armored look is either awesome or awful. Flash and Harley are the most divisive.
Female faces. General consensus accepts that they could be better (NetherRealm Studios doesn't have the best track record in this regard), with some even denouncing them as the ugliest, most mannish butterfaces to ever grace the gaming world. Others, however, consider them as acceptably realistic and view such denouncement as Fan Dumb/Hate Dumb.
He says similar things about Green Lantern, stating that he's pretty easy to use.
Superman also gets a lot of online players who do nothing but spam Eye Beams all day. Never mind that Superman has ridiculously damaging close range combos.
Complete Monster: The Joker, as usual, but to explain why - he's the entire reason Superman adopts a zero tolerance policy on crime, as he places a detonator in the pregnant Lois Lane, set to trigger a nuke in Metropolis the moment her heart stops, and then uses a Kryptonite-laced version of Scarecrow's fear toxin to trick Superman into seeing Doomsday, so that the deaths of Lois and the millions in Metropolis are on Superman's hands. And the reason why he does all of this? Because he was tired of losing to Batman and wanted to go after an easier target. The real kicker, before Superman ended him is that he was planning on a way to top that.
Regime!Superman. When he finds out that maybe people don't like living in an oppressive dictatorship, he interprets this as them preferring chaos and plans to wipe out Gotham and Metropolis (i.e. the exact same plan the Joker had, albeit with a different motive), and then invade the universe the duplicates came from and conquer that, too. And when Shazam speaks out against this, Superman murders him in cold blood without blinking.
Creator's Pet: Scorpion by default, due to Netherrealm apparently stating that there'd only be DC characters in Injustice before adding in their mascot. Fans are not pleased.
Continuing the trend that started in Batman: The Brave and the Bold, Aquaman looks to be one in this game, being a fan favorite according to the official facebook page, being chosen as a main character by Mortal Kombat veteran Tom Brady, and being the subject of a TV spot featuring Kevin Smith and Jason Mewes arguing if he could beat Wonder Woman in a fight. He can thanks to his "mad sharks."
Martian Manhunter, if the frequent mentions of him in the Broken Base entry above are any indication. He is one of the most consistently requested characters for DLC, culminating in his eventual announcement as a future playable character.
Zatanna was also consistently requested, and in fact, won the fan poll Ed Boon put out on Twitter. Eventually, Ed revealed she was indeed a DLC character.
After the Season Pass was datamined and appeared to confirm Batgirl, Scorpion and General Zod as the DLC characters to follow Lobo, a large number of fans have become convinced that the 3 characters were officially confirmed by NetherRealm - whilst the leak wound up being accurate, NetherRealm never officially confirmed who was in the Season Pass until each character's release was imminent.
The Season Pass was always advertised as giving the buyer the 4 DLC characters and Flashpoint skins for the price of 3 characters. Hasn't stopped some fans from claiming that NetherRealm are thieves for releasing other costume packs which aren't included in the Season Pass.
Some assume Sub-Zero to be confirmed even though Ed Boon posted on twiter that only 1 guest character would be in Injustice.
Many younger fans don't seem to understand that the "Teen Titans" skin pack has nothing to do with the animated series but rather the comics from the 80's. Those same fans are also whining about the lack of Starfire & Beast Boy, not realizing that there have been many, many members of the Titans. Of course, this is nothing new, considering that the animate series is an Adaptation Displacement for some.
Despite episodes of The Batman & Teen Titans, the second season of Young Justice, and The New Batman Adventures making it clear that the original Robin grows up to become Nightwing, there are still plenty of fans unfamiliar with the comics demanding Robin as DLC. There are a number who would happily settle for (Or would actually prefer) a Robin skin for Nightwing, however.
Before he was added as a reskin, there were plenty of Justice League fans demanding John Stewart as DLC, convinced he was the first Green Lantern. But then, this is nothing new for the franchise, as the same thing happened with the 2011 film.
"Funny Aneurysm" Moment: A Running Gag recurring goal in the S.T.A.R. Labs missions is hitting Nightwing in the head a certain number of times when fighting him. It becomes a lot less funny when you realize that's how he died.
Superman disapproved of the methods of The Elite (killing criminals, going for a Might Makes Right approach, and generally threatening the populace to decrease crime). He is voiced by George Newbern, and acts upon many of the same methods in this game. Or at least, his evil counterpart does.
Quite a few fans dislike Damian's characterization in the game, especially in light of his recent Heroic Sacrifice in the comics. May die down a little as issue #16 of the prequel comic reveals his killing of Dick Grayson was an accident.
Batman being called a Scorpion clone after being one of his designated rivals (Superman and Sub-Zero aside) to the latter in Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe. Made noticeable with Batman's Grappling Hook and Slide Kick being very similar to Scorpion's Spear and Leg Takedown. Plus the fact Batman has insanely similar Clash dialogue with Insurgency Deathstroke (with Slade in Bats' place and Bats in Scorps' place).
Batman: I know your moves. Scorpion: As if that matters.
Troy Baker voiced Robin in Batman: Arkham City, and voices Nightwing here, mirroring Dick Grayson doing the same thing in his backstory. Becomes a "Funny Aneurysm" Moment when you realize Damian Wayne does the same thing in the Injustice storyline, by killing Dick.
Scorpion deriding Batman as being "no Sub-Zero" in their Clash confrontation, with Batman's response that "[He's] Batman" - in Sub-Zero's Arcade mode ending in Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe, he began emulating Batman's methods.
From the tournament scene: Joker is banned! Explanation The given reasons range from how he's dead in the story, how he has a one button infinite combo, or how his keepaway game is too unbeatable. None of these are true (including the Joker ban, because he isn't) and anyone saying this is most likely just having fun.
From the tournament scene: Two frames, son! Two frames! Explanation Superman's super move. If Superman has full meter, and the opponent has less than 40% life, they are as good as dead, as almost anything the opponent does (except walk forward and block) is punishable by Superman's super move because it's just that fast. See That One Attack for more details.
The Joker of the Injustice universe tricking Superman into killing his wife and unborn child and destroying Metropolis.
Damian Wayne's Klingon Promotion. Insurgency Batman even mentions that he is dead to him for killing Dick. It's revealed in issue #16 that he accidentally killed Dick, though.
For many fans who still felt sorry or sympathy for Injustice Superman's grief or actions, he finally crossed this line in Issue #33 of the prequels comics when he killed Oliver Queen, in front of his own parents, no less, and despite Martha's pleas.
After the subject is trying to talk him out of a different one in the form of sending his armies after Metropolis, Gotham City, and then the main universe as an example to those who would oppose his rule, the cold-blooded murder of Regime Shazam, a teenager at oldest, by Regime Superman is so cruel that it causes a Heel-Face Turn in one member of the Regime (The Flash), shows that one of the more villainous members (Solomon Grundy) has some standards, and shakes the resolve of a third member (Yellow Lantern).
Superman's face when he discovers the body of Jimmy in the comics.
At the end of Classic Battle, Regime Superman has flashbacks to his downfall as he's being sucked into the Phantom Zone. The final flashback is of him before the graves of his wife and unborn son, who in a display that's simultaneously too much and too little, gets a completely separate tombstone yet not a proper name, the engraving reading "Baby Kent."
Superman's scream is up there with Dante's in terms of narm.
Yellow Lantern's outro consists of him trying his damn hardest to sound threatening, but it's ruined with the line "yellow is power." - In fact, a major problem some people have with the character in the game is that he just doesn't sound threatening at all. But perhaps that's the point, since Yellow Lantern is beaten handily by Green Lantern; and is actually very cowardly, immediately surrendering when faced by Heroic Superman.
The death of Dick Grayson, let's just say it wasn't what fans were expecting.
The artist in the comic has problems with drawing faces. But the crowner has to be Batman's face when Catwoman finds him after Dick Grayson died.
Which is perhaps topped by Black Adam making this◊ face. Made even better/worse in context, since he's supposed to be attacking in that scene.
The way characters bounce between buildings in the Gotham City street-to-rooftop transition looks kind of goofy.
The Scrappy: Scorpion, because he's a Guest Fighter included in the Season Pass. People have said they wouldn't have a problem if Scorpion was stand-alone DLC, but they feel they were misled into purchasing the Season Pass under the impression they would be getting 4 more DC Comic characters, not 3 DC characters and the Mortal Kombat mascot. Saying that, there are people who are adamant that he shouldn't be in the game at all.
Special Effects Failure: In Green Lantern's victory cutscene, he stands among a host of fellow Green Lanterns, all of which are very obviously static images hovering back and forth. Hammeroon, the humanoid immediately to Hal Jordan's left, is particularly conspicuous due to how dynamic his pose is.
Raven's psychokinetic grabs have ludicrous range: Only from the far side of the screen is her opponent safe without having to block.
The AI tends to use Green Lantern's "Lantern's Might" grab and Sinestro's "Final Impact" attack very frequently.
Superman's super move. It's got super armor, goes all the way across the screen, and executes in only 2 frames. (For reference, most normal standing light attacks take 10 frames to execute.) None of the other super moves are anywhere as good as it.
Superman Eye Lasers as well. Full Screen, builds meter, and does solid damage and chips, and its even better when meter burned.
So does Superman's F23 Breath Blockstring. Or his traits. Lets just say Superman in general and leave it at that.
Nightwing in Staff stance. Almost all of his attacks in this are safe on block and most of those moves give him frame advantage. Combine that with long reaching attacks and good mixups you got pressure monster.
Scorpion retains his Mortal Kombat 9 moveset, including his Hellfire attack, which teleports him behind an opponent to set up damaging combos. This is problematic here because Injustice lacks a block button, instead players must hold the opposite direction button from their opponent to block.
Cyborg's air projectile can be done again and again so quickly, it's the best zoning move in the game. (It used to be mid-hitting, which resulted in opponents being unable to crouch under it, making it a block-stun infinite—before it was patched to be a high attack. Even after that nerf, it's still the best zoning move in the game.)
Lobo is considered by many as one of the worst characters in the game.
From the other end of the scale, Raven is building something of a hatedom for being too overpowered. Her new design doesn't help either.
Superman. So much that the Grand Final of Evolution 2013 consists of booing at Superman.
That One Level: The S.T.A.R. Labs missions certainly don't lack for challenge, but some, such as The Flash's last mission (Mission 40: Go Boom!, where you have to defeat Lex Luthor—who comes with a shield ability that reflects all damage for a few seconds—under a time limit), are ludicrously hard.
They Changed It, Now It Sucks: Inverted with Batman's Supermove. Many people were underwhelmed with Batman's original Supermove (a short beatdown before stringing the opponent upside-down and dropkicking them), and Netherrealm responded by completely changing it (keeping the opponent stunlocked with smoke, tasers, and explosives before the Batmobile rams them). The response has been very positive, though some speculated that there would be multiple Supermoves (there aren't).
Also inverted with Red Son Superman's intro. While his "de-Clark Kenting" didn't look horrible, it did look rather silly with his conspicuous black gloves clashing with his civilian clothes (which the Red Son Superman never wore). In the final release, he flies in from the Fortress of Solitude like most of his alternate costumes.
They Wasted Perfectly Good Characters: Some characters have such small parts in the plot when they could have greatly expanded the overall story. Notable examples include the heroic Nightwing, who could have had very interesting interactions with the Regime world's Bat Family, and both versions of Catwoman, as her brief appearances in each setting unfortunately result in her seem unwitting at best and idiotic at worst.
Additionally, the main universe versions of Shazam, Hawkgirl, Black Adam, and Raven (i.e., the one not possessed by Trigon) are all but an afterthought in the story, with Raven getting little more than a line in the opening cutscene.
What an Idiot: Hey, Bane? Since you're shooting at Wonder Woman, you want to try shifting your aim and not hitting her indestructible bracelets? No? Okay, whatever.
What the Hell, Casting Agency?: Zatanna's voice actress uses the same voice used in Young Justice. It's fine in that show...where she's a teenager. Here, it sounds a little too young for what appears to be a more adult physique. If she's meant to be a fairly young adult (say, early twenties), it would be understandable, but as it is, it can be somewhat jarring.
Player 2 alternative colours occasionally fall into this. While some looks great, like "mostly black" Batman or "Blue 52" Nightwing, we also have stuff like "sky-blue Domino Mask" Nightwing and "mustard yellow shirt" Aquaman.
The fact that almost all Player 2 colors look exactly the same to the Player 1 costumes makes it very difficult to differentiate between the two on screen. They were probably expecting players to use alternate costumes, but that doesn't excuse it for people that prefer the default costumes or haven't gotten any alternates. Scorpion is the probably most egregious example. His normal Player 2 is only slightly darker than his Player 1 outfit.
Scorpion's Jim Lee designed costume draws this from some of his fans.
Zatanna, being a performer, doesn't have a set uniform in the comics— just a general aesthetic of feminine pantsless tuxedo, top hat, and fishnets. Her Injustice costume suffers from the character designers wanting to have their cake and eat it, too— she has a bow tie, cleavage, and a ruffly thing on her neck to suggest a doublet. Any two of these would be fine, but all three just looks awkward.