troperville
tools
toys
5th Feb: Echo Chamber Season 1 blooper reel on Youtube here
SubpagesLaconic Main
|
|
|
|
Uncanny Family Resemblance
|
Family members tend to look like each other. Normally, this follows bloodline - you tend to look a lot more like your parents than you do your second cousin, for example. Generally, only identical twins can pass for each other, and even then developmental influences can make noticeable differences.
Television, on the other hand, is a little loose with the rules. Especially when it gives the chance to put an actor into a totally new role.
While the Identical Grandson can marginally argue that it is not unknown for direct descendants to bear uncanny resemblance to a forebear, the idea gets very shaky for other relations. When a show tries to pass off a male actor in drag as their visiting aunt, or when somehow a character resembles the man who adopted their great-great-grandfather, it gets flat out weird (and hence is usually played up for comedic value).
The trope is pushed further if the actor is put into playing nearly all members of his family, by blood or marriage.
See also: Acting for Two, Inexplicably Identical Individuals. Not to be confused with Strong Family Resemblance, where an animated character looks like one of their parents. Or with You ALL Look Familiar, which is more of an enforced trope.
Examples:
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- In Vampire Knight Yuuki is nearly identical to her mother Juuri to the point that Rido wants to use her as a replacement for Juuri, his sister who he was in psychotic love with and Kaname looks almost exactly like Haruka, their father. But then again, This is actually more a case of Haruka being an Identical Grandson, because Kaname is really The Ancestor and Haruka his great-grandson. This is somewhat justified in the fact that their parents were siblings as well, and given that their family tree doesn't fork for many generations, genetic traits would be passed down far more obviously.
- In Bleach, Rukia is nearly identical to her older sister Hisana Kuchiki, to the extent where they have extremely similar hair-styles. This stands out because Hisana abandoned Rukia as an infant and then died before the pair could ever be reunited. The uncany resemblance is lampshaded in the manga itself when it's revealed Byakuya's original lie for adopting Rukia was her resemblance to his dead wife.
- In Katekyo Hitman Reborn!, there's an example that gets into the flat out weird category (and isn't played for laughs). Xanxus, who isn't actually supposed to be blood related to the Ninth is almost a clone of the Second Vongola Boss. Lampshaded by other characters here
. As they say, his temperament, abilities, and even looks are the same. Makes you wonder if he really isn't the Ninth's love child...
- Mizuho from Otome wa Boku ni Koishiteru looks exactly like his mother, in spite of being her son.
- Joey Jones from Heroman has pretty much the same thing going for him, except it's not lampshaded.
- In Asatte no Houkou, Adult!Karada looks just like her mother Youko.
- Eyeshield 21 plays with this. Munakata looks nearly identical to his parents but his parents also look nearly identical to each other.
- In Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS, Subaru and Ginga both greatly resemble their deceased mother, Quint. All the more notable because they were adopted. It is later revealed that they were produced through cloning based on Quint's genetic information.
- The Tomokane siblings in GA Geijutsuka Art Design Class do not only look alike— Nodamiki one said the older Tomokane as a "bleached Tomokane-kun" in episode 12
◊— but both were voiced by Miyuki Sawashiro, hence upgrading from Strong Family Resemblance to this. Even so, they are also quite different...
- In To Aru Majutsu no Index, Mikoto Misaka not only already has her sisters, but she's also a splitting image of her Hot Mom Misuzu.
- All of the Nurse Joys and Officer Jennys resemble each other in Pokémon. The only way you can distinguish them is by the symbol on their hats.
- The two Nitori siblings from Wandering Son look almost exactly like each other, especially when Shuuichi grew his hair into a Bob Haircut like his sister. At several points once Shu grows his hair out, you can mistake him for his sister (or the other way around). Shu's body has started to look different from his sister's due to puberty though, he's taller than her and more square.
- Usopp and Nico Robin of One Piece look very much like their parents when they got older. Usopp a combination of his mother and father's traits (long nose, tan skin, hair) and Robin a spitting image of her mother save for the black hair (her mother's is white).
- Due to having Only Six Faces, Goku's sons Gohan and Goten look exactly the same as he did at their respective ages. This is even Lampshaded in the first episode of Dragon Ball Z. When the characters first meet Gohan, Bulma comments that he looks just like Goku.
Comicbooks
- Inverted: Spider-Man and his clone Ben Reilly pretended to be cousins with an uncanny resemblance. Peter's wife Mary Jane came up with the explanation for their resemblance, specifically referring to The Patty Duke Show.
- Played with in The Sandman: Robert Gadling covers up his immortality by exploiting this. Since he doesn't age, he can pretend to be his own grandson or nephew and leave his property to himself.
- He actually mentions that this has gotten more difficult since the invention of photography. He has to conceal old family photographs to make sure nobody notices that he looks EXACTLY like his uncle or grandfather did fifty years ago.
- Tweedledum and Tweedledee
of Batman lore are identical cousins.
- Zippy The Pinhead, his wife Zerbina, kids, Evil Twin Lippy, and other members of his extended family are all microcephalics who wear muu-muus.
- Denise the Menace and Dennis the Menace in the Britsh Anthology Comic The Beano
- There was a Superman-related mini-series in the 90s called The Kents, which examined the lives of the ancestors of the Kent family. One story showed how one of Jonathan Kent's ancestors, Abraham Kent, was a pioneer who was largely responsible for turning the state of Kansas into the breadbasket it is today. A fine story, but the artist bizarrely chose to make Abraham Kent be a dead ringer for Superman, even though Superman has no blood relation to the Kent family (or any human being) whatsoever. Being, you know, an alien and all.
- Goofy has a huge extended family. Just about every single family member, male and female, looks almost exactly like him, only with one or two minor visual details to set them apart.
Film
- * One of the greatest and most successful examples of this trope is the black and white comedy film Kind Hearts and Coronets Alec Guiness plays all 8 members of the D'Ascoyne family.
- The Eddie Murphy remake of The Nutty Professor, where Murphy plays every member of the title character's family. Though at least in this case he's wearing fat suits to disguise pretty much all his features for the different roles.
- This aspect of the movie has become the default parody for cheesy comedians who specialise in broad humour. In 30 Rock, Tracy Jordan is the star of The Chunks, and Tropic Thunder features a fake trailer for The Fatties 2, starring Jack Black's character.
- In the Back to the Future movies, Michael J. Fox played not only hero Marty McFly, but Marty's two future children (Marty Jr. and Marlene), and his great-great-grandfather Seamus from Ireland. He also posed as Marty's great-grandfather William in a photograph. And Lea Thompson played both his mother and his paternal great-great-grandmother. The producers have since joked that McFly men are just genetically predisposed to be attracted to women who look like Lea Thompson.
- Strange Brew briefly does this half-way through the movie. Dave Thomas didn't just play Doug, but his father (with Mel Blanc dubbing over his voice), and Rick Moranis didn't just play Bob, but his mother (with a woman dubbing over his voice)!
- A variation appears in The Mouse That Roared. In the opening sequence, we're introduced to the Grand Duchess, Prime Minister, and Tully Bascombe, all played by Peter Sellers. The narration explains that these disparate residents of the Duchy of Grand Fenwick look like each other because they are all descendants of the country's founder, who was literally the father of his country (the statue we see of him is clearly a likeness of Sellers).
- The Prisoner of Zenda.
- In the sex comedy Live Nude Shakespeare, the same actress plays two identical sisters, one a sophisticated socialite, the other a backwoods bumpkin.
- After playing Dante Hicks in Clerks, Brian O'Halloran also played characters with the surname Hicks in Mallrats and Dogma. It's not explicitly stated that they're related, though, so the Continuity Nod might just be a way to Hand Wave the uncanny resemblance.
- In most of Tyler Perry's movies, Perry dresses in drag to play Madea, Madea's brother (not in drag but with a lot of makeup and a wig) and another character (no makeup), who is usually related to Madea.
- Rupert Everett as Carnaby Fritton and his sister Camilla, in the recent ReBoot of the St. Trinian's movie series.
- Tia and Tamera Mowry as Sydney Donovan and Sydney's grandmother de-aged to seventeen in the Disney Channel movie 17 Again.
- Jim Dale as Eli, Wild Billy, AND Jasper Bloodshy in Hot Lead And Cold Feet.
- Adam Sandler plays both Jack and his twin sister Jill in Jack And Jill.
Literature
- In the fifth book in L. M. Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables series, Anne's House of Dreams, a woman who hates her husband is left caring for him for years after he suffers brain damage. Later he has an operation and recovers his memory—and turns out not to be her husband at all but her husband's cousin. The book explains that the cousins were double cousins, and one set of parents (either their mothers or fathers) were actually identical twins. The cousins looked very much alike, but were easy to tell apart if they were seen together. The wife had never met the cousin, however, and had only heard her husband mention him once. The book also admits that he had changed a lot after his accident and didn't look much like either he or his cousin used to.
- In The Prisoner of Zenda, one of the kings of Ruritania has an affair with an English noblewoman, who bears his child. Several generations later, one of that child's descendants bears an uncanny resemblance to the current King of Ruritania, leading to an Emergency Impersonation.
- In the 1979 comic film version with Peter Sellers, he plays King Rudolf IV in the opening sequence; once that character dies, he plays both Rudolf V and Syd, the working-class chap who bears the uncanny resemblance. It is implied that Syd was the result of an affair Rudolf IV had.
- In The Secret History, narrator Richard Papen is in love with Camilla, one half of a fraternal pair of twins. She and her twin, Charles, look virtually identical ... and when Richard finds out they're a little too close, he's titillated by the thought. Eew.
- The post-finale Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Relaunch novels reveal that Gul Macet, played by Marc Alaimo in Star Trek: The Next Generation, is a cousin of Alaimo's Deep Space Nine character Gul Dukat.
- In Mort, Princess Keli closely resembles her great-great-grandfather, despite being a pampered princess rather than a yurt-dwelling horse barbarian.
- In The Last Hero, Paul Kidby's painting of High Priest Hughnon Ridcully is basically Archchancellor Mustrum Ridcully with a better-trimmed beard and a bishop's hat.
- Possibly justified, as their mannerisms and attitudes are so clearly parallel that there's a good chance they really are identical twins.
- In Sharper Than A Serpent's Tooth, John Taylor resembles his older male relatives, so much so that John's late father, resurrected to meet his grown son for the first time, points out John's resemblence to his father.
- In The Hound of the Baskervilles, the late Sir Charles' wayward brother is said to have resembled a family portrait of Lord Hugo, a distant ancestor, to an uncanny degree. Could be considered a Chekhov's Gun, as the brother's secret son is the villain of the story, and both shared Lord Hugo's inclination toward evil.
- Harry and James Potter of the Harry Potter series.
- And Harry is rather disturbed when he learns that the resemblance was purely physical, as James was a Jerk Jock, more like Malfoy than Harry, despite being on the good side.
- In the Honor Harrington books, Michael Oversteegen greatly resembles his relative, the infamous Baron High Ridge. Their personalities could not be more different, though.
- Emmanuel from Malevil describes his Uncle Samuel, noting that in doing so he also describes himself.
- In the Ghosts of Fear Street book Horror Hotel Part 1, the protagonist discovers that he looks almost identical to a distant relative who's been dead for years. This is bad news, because it turns out that relative was a murderer and his victim's ghost is out for revenge.
- An Uncanny Semi-Family Resemblence: The ancient Greek story Aethiopica, King Hydaspes and Queen Persinna of Ethiopia cast out their infant daughter Chariclea because she is white. After many adventures, it is revealed that she is, in fact, the perfect image of a picture of Andromeda that her mother had looked at while she conceived, and so Chariclea really is their daughter with "maternal impression" explaining her looks.
Live-Action TV
Puppet Shows
Theater
- Viola passing for her twin ''brother'' Sebastian in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, making this Older Than Steam.
- There have been productions of Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street in which the same person who plays Johanna also plays her mother Lucy in the flashbacks.
- In the Japanese tokusatsu series Sazer X, a flashback scene depicts the main character's grandfather as a young man. In flashback, the younger version of grandpa is played by the same actor who plays the main character.
- In the stage version of "Rocky Horror", Eddie and Dr. Scott are played by the same actor
- In Book-It Repertory Theatre's play of Sense and Sensibility, (non-twin) brothers Edward and Robert Ferrars were played by the same actor.
Webcomics
Western Animation
- Played for Drama with Ty Lee from Avatar: The Last Airbender. She has six sisters who look identical to her, and she ran away from home to avoid becoming part of a "matching set".
- Played with on The Simpsons. As noted in the DVD commentaries, many children characters wound up greatly resembling their parents. The most noteworthy example is Milhouse, who looks very much like both parents, who in turn look very much like each other. On the other hand, Ralph Wiggum differs in appearance from Chief Wiggum (oweing to the fact that their relationship came years after they were created). The main family characters (Lisa and Maggie aside) also greatly difference in appearance from each other, but Marge's mother looks like an older version of her. Grampa could also be taken as an older version of Homer, though flashbacks show he wasn't a look-alike.
- An Alternate Timeline of Ben 10 had the main character fully grown in a now futurized Earth having a son named Kenny, who looks like a carbon copy of his 10 year old self. In addition, Ben's Evil Counterpart also has a son named Devlin Levin who looks like his younger self before the mutations with no mention as to whom he conceived him from.
- On All Dogs Go to Heaven: The Series, we're introduced to Annabelle's evil cousin Belladonna, who may as well be Annabelle's Evil Twin — they look exactly alike, with the only real difference being the color of their fur (and the fact that Belladonna has bat wings, due to being a devil).
- Back to the Future: The Animated Series took this to ridiculous levels by having a Tannen in every timeline they go to, no matter what country. Taken Up to Eleven when they even encounter a T-rex Tannen in a timeline where the dinosaurs weren't wiped out.
- In South Park, most of Cartman's relatives look a lot like him. The one slim person in his extended family is a young girl who resembles Liane
.
Other
- In the comic strip Blondie, Dagwood and his son Alexander look very much alike, as do Blondie and daughter Cookie.
- A common Fan Fic trope in crossovers is to have a two different characters in different continuities played by the same actors 'turn out' to be related to each other. There is one where James Bond (Connery version) is the illegitimate son of Henry Jones Jr and thus the grandson of Henry Jones Snr... who was played by Sean Connery.
- There is also one used in fan fiction with MacGyver (of MacGyver) and Colonel Jack O'Neill (of Stargate SG-1), both played by Richard Dean Anderson, being cousins.
- Although they were only cousin, King George V of England and the Czar Nicolas II looked like twins. See for yourself.
◊ George has blue eyes but that probably won't be much help.
- And George's grandson Prince Michael of Kent, who's still around today, has the same uncanny resemblance to the Tsar, to the extent that he's very popular among royalists in Russia. It helps that he grew the Russian-style beard to hide a scar.
- In Big Finish's Doctor Who audio dramas, India Fisher plays Eighth and Sixth Doctor companion Charley Pollard. Fisher also voiced Charley's sister Cissy in the Gallifrey spin-off series.
- In the video game Day of the Tentacle, you travel into the future and meet people who look suspiciously like Nurse Edna, Doctor Fred and Weird Ed, but they call themselves "Nurse Zedna," "Doctor Zed" and "Weird Zed." They're the descendants of the original Maniac Mansion characters.
- In Peanuts Linus and his little brother Rerun look almost exactly the same. The only way they can be told apart is height, hair (Rerun's is a bit flatter) or outfit (Linus wears red and black stripes while Rerun wears overalls).
- Outside of their trademark costumes, Groucho, Harpo, Chico, and Zeppo Marx bore an incredible resemblance to each other. They would even occasionally play each other's parts in their stage shows with no one the wiser.
- Actors Alan Hale (Senior) and Alan Hale (Junior). One played Little John in The Adventures of Robin Hood, the other is famed as the Skipper on Gilligan's Island. Without looking at the date of their films there is no way to tell them apart.
- In the sprite comic 194X, Kalinka and Ran strongly resemble their WWII-era ancestors. It's hard to decide whether the fact that Ran is a robot makes this better or worse.
- In what is part this trope and part Strong Family Resemblance, in Back to the Future: The Video Game, Marty runs into his grandfather, Artie McFly, who looks and sounds just like George McFly (both being based on Crispin Glover's performance in the film). Artie's father, William, is once again played by Michael J. Fox, who had previously portrayed him in a photo shown in the third film (even though Marty himself is actually voiced by AJ LoCascio). This leads one to believe that if the pattern continues, since Marty's son will end up looking like Michael J. Fox, his grandson and great-grandson will look like Crispin Glover, and so on. Also, Kid Tannen is basically just Biff with a moustache and zoot suit.
- Back in The Nineties, a running joke was that the public appearances of Michael Jackson were actually his sister LaToya Jackson.
- In Suikoden V, Dragon Cavalry commander Rahal and his Cloud Cuckoolander sister Rania look virtually identical, to the point that they'd fall under Half-Identical Twins if not for Rania being a year older. Not immediately obvious for most of the game, due to Rahal wearing battle armor and Rania being in civilian dress, but when the plot calls for Rahal to dress as a woman the only visible difference from his sister is that she wears glasses and he doesn't. Apparently they have a history of exploiting this for pranks.
|
|