ITT: Rate the above Troper's Casting Choices

A snowclone/merge of Rate the Above Troper's "X" and Cast the Above Troper's Gallery in Works.

So basically, we will start by casting avatars of our gallery in works, then the below troper's rates our choices from 1 to 10 and some side comment.

Note: Try to make the works you choose as broad as possible, and if you don't know enough about a work to rate the casting choices, refrain from rating it.

The Advertisement Server has some good and bad choices there 7/10, could use some polishing.

Aladdin

• Aladdin◊

• Jasmine◊

• Abu◊

• Genie◊

• Carpet◊

• Jafar◊

• Iago◊

• The Sultan◊

Now let's get started!

Edited by VengefulBale on Dec 10th 2018 at 9:52:31 AM

8/10. Pretty funny casting choices

Little Shop of Horrors

• Seymour Krelborn:
• Audrey:
• Mr. Mushnik:
• Orin Scrivello:
• Audrey II:

9/10, it seems to work pretty well.

The Avengers- Only genderbent because reasons.

Captain America:

Bruce Banner:

The Hulk:

Hawkeye: (as a human)

Black Widow:

Iron Man:

Thor:

Loki:

Nick Fury: (as a human)

Edited by Spottedleaf on Dec 12th 2018 at 6:30:24 AM

Bumped and edited.

10/10: The genderbent casting is a really good idea. Eris as Loki is the best choice, but they're all good.

Sonic Forces (With non-Sonic characters. Based more on personality than species.)

• Modern Sonic: The protagonist of Brush: A Fox Tale◊
• Classic Sonic: This fox◊
• "Rookie": Whiskers◊
• Tails: Lemmy Koopa◊
• Knuckles the Echidna: Dromarch◊
• Amy Rose: The girl fox from Brush: A Fox Tale◊
• Rouge the Bat: Ms. Fortune◊
• Vector the Crocodile: Tamatoa◊
• Dr. Eggman: The Coachman◊
• Infinite: Nightmare Klonoa◊
• Shadow the Hedgehog: Wolf O'Donnell◊
• Metal Sonic: Lolbit◊
• Zavok: Pete◊

Edited by DrNoPuma on Dec 13th 2018 at 11:43:44 AM

10/10- All good casting; I especially like Tamatoa as Vector and the Coachman as Eggman.

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic

Twilight Sparkle:

Spike:

Pinkie Pie:

Applejack:

Rarity: (Post Heel-Face-Turn; to avoid casting her as herself)

Rainbow Dash:

Fluttershy:

Celestia:

Nightmare Moon:

Luna:

Starlight Glimmer:

Trixie:

9/10 I know almost nothing about MLPFIM, but this looks pretty good. I like how all of them (except the last one) are live action. This makes me want to believe that this is a reboot of the show as a Darker and Edgier drama, and that's pretty amusing to imagine. :P

Kirby: Triple Deluxe

• Kirby: Surprised Pikachu◊
• King Dedede: Pete◊
• Bandanna Waddle Dee: Popplio◊
• Taranza: Joka◊
• Queen Sectonia: Maleficent◊
• People of the Sky: This◊ and the other moths from The Moth and the Flame.
• Flowery Woods: Brain-Eating Meteor◊
• Paintra: Mangle◊
• Kracko: The Old North Wind◊
• Coily Rattler: Lizard from Face Like a Frog◊
• Pyribbit: Harlequin◊
• Dark Meta Knight: Symbiote Rocket Raccoon◊
• Shadow Dedede: Shadow Blot◊

Edited by DrNoPuma on Dec 21st 2018 at 4:04:38 AM

10/10 Overall, your characters all fit the archetypes and personalities of the originals and pretty much fit in the context of the original game's story

The Princess And The Frog

• Tiana◊ (Lord Dominator)

• Prince Naveen◊ (Jamie)

• Dr. Facilier◊ (Sincline)

• Ray◊ (Ludo Avarius)

• Louis◊ (Yatsudenwani)

• Mama Odie◊ (Candelila)

• Charlotte LaBeouf◊ (Mega Gardevoir)

• Lawrence◊ (Charles Muntz)

• Big Daddy LaBeouf◊ (Scrooge Mc Duck)

• Evangeline◊ (Pink Diamond)

• Friends On The Other Side◊ (Alastor)

8-9/10. A couple of them I'm having trouble seeing, but overall pretty good.

• Kuzco: Pupper◊
• Pacha: Buttercup Cottonwood◊
• Yzma: Dawn Lycanroc◊ (Spinx◊ near the end)
• Kronk: Average Joe◊
• The crocodile ("Why do we even have that lever?"): UB-Blossom◊
• The squirrel: Pyxis◊

10/10- pretty funny, I'm especially loving Average Joe as Kronk.

Frozen (you knew it was going to happen eventually)

Elsa

Anna

Kristoff

Hans

Olaf

Sven

The Duke of Wesselton

7.5/10 Pretty good.

Deltarune:

Kris:

Susie:

Ralsei:

Lancer:

Rouxles Kaard:

Spades King:

Jevil:

Gaster:

9/10. Overall pretty good. I especially like... whatever that is as Jevil. :P I don't understand Obama as Ralsei, but it's good overall.

Spider-Man Trilogy

• Peter Parker/Spider-Man: Zeraora◊
• Mary Jane Watson: Nessie◊
• Harry Osborn: Thebestmaster◊
• Dennis Carradine: Count Olaf◊
• Norman Osborn/Green Goblin: Dr. Nefarious◊
• Otto Octavius/Dr. Octopus: Dr. Eggman◊
• Eddie Brock/Venom: Infinite◊
• Flint Marko/Sandman: Necross◊
• Aunt May Parker: "Nightmare Ned" dragon◊
• Uncle Ben Parker: Noel Harrison◊
• J. Jonah Jameson: Skeletor◊
• Betty Brant: Harriet◊
• Gwen Stacy: Rose Tico◊
• Bonesaw McGraw: Bowser powered up◊
• Henry Balkan: B. L. Zebubb◊
• Rahi Aziz (pizza time): Waluigi◊
• Radioactive spider: Skid◊

9/10. These are some really great choices.

Spyro: Year of the Dragon

• Spyro: UB Nightmare◊
• Sparx: Feather Fluff◊
• Hunter: Clever Comet◊
• Bianca: Azure Glory◊
• The Sorceress: Dawn Lycanroc◊
• Buzz: UB Blossom◊
• Spike: [REDACTED] with the gun◊
• Scorch: Mysticore◊

Edited by AgentKirin on Dec 31st 2018 at 6:31:45 AM

9/10- this looks really cool, actually!

Mulan

Mulan

Mushu

Ling

Chien Po

Yao

Shang

Chi Fu

Shan Yu

Edited by Spottedleaf on Jan 1st 2019 at 9:11:42 AM

Detective Pikachu as Mushu makes this a 10/10 casting choice.

The Star Wars Movies

• Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader◊

• Padme Amidala◊

• Luke Skywalker◊

• Princess Leia Skywalker◊

• Han Solo◊

• Chewbacca◊

• Yoda◊

• Emperor Sheev Palpatine◊

• General Bail Organa◊

• Death Star◊

• The Saarlaac◊

• Jabba the Hutt◊

• R2-D2◊

• C-3PO◊

• Supreme Leader Snoke◊

• Kylo Ren◊

• Rey◊

• Finn◊

• Poe Dameron◊

• Obi Wan Kenobi◊

• Qui Gon Jinn◊

• Darth Maul◊

• Count Dooku◊

• Jar Jar Binks◊

• Commander Cody◊

• Darth Plagueis◊

• General Grievous◊

Edited by VengefulBale on Jan 2nd 2019 at 12:42:28 PM

9/10. I think it's especially cool that you chose Meta Knight as Anakin and Kirby as Luke.

The Avengers (2012)

• Tony: Sky Song◊ (Mysticore◊ when suited up)
• Steve: Galaxy Star◊
• Bruce: Spinx◊ (I don't have one for the Hulk)
• Thor: Buttercup Cottonwood◊
• Clint: Average Joe◊
• Natasha: [REDACTED]◊
• Nick Fury: Princess Luna◊
• Loki: Negatavity◊

8/10. I like it, some good casting choices.

The Lady and the Tramp

Lady:

Tramp:

Jock:

Trusty:

Jim Dear:

Darling:

Aunt Sarah:

Si:

Am:

Tony: (i don't even know)

Joe:

Peg:

9/10 Good overall. For Si and Am, I think you could have gotten away with casting Vitani for both of them, but it's cool that you made them separate anyway. It's a shame that you didn't know who to do for Tony, but I know that feel.

Toy Story 3 (may expand later)

• Woody: Gideon Grey◊
• Buzz Lightyear: Batman◊
• Jessie: Squirrel Girl◊
• Mr. Potato Head: Yosh◊
• Mrs. Potato Head: Birdo◊
• Slinky Dog: Staya◊
• Rex: Grim Matchstick◊
• Hamm: Tom Nook◊
• Sarge: Wolf O'Donnell◊
• Barbie: X-6◊
• Lotso: B. L. Zebubb◊
• Big Baby: Mangle◊
• Ken: Lionel Hutz◊
• Chuckles: Seam◊
• Trixie: Nessie◊
• Buttercup: Marcel◊
• Andy Davis: Barry Allen◊

Edited by DrNoPuma on Jan 13th 2019 at 6:28:53 AM

9/10, Pretty good overall, some casting choices aren't my cup of tea tho.

Spiderman Into The Spider Verse

• Miles Davis Morales/Spiderman II◊

• [[ Peter Parker/Spiderman I]]

• [[ Peter B. Parker]]

• [[ Gwen Stacy/Spider-Gwen]]

• [[ Peter Porker/Spider-Ham]]

• [[ Peter Parker Noir/Spider-Man Noir]]

• [[ Peni Parker]]
  • [[ SP//dr]]

• [[ Wilson Fisk/The Kingpin]]

• [[ Norman Osborn/The Green Goblin]]

• [[ Dr. Octopus]]

• [[ Tombstone]]

• [[ Scorpion]]

• [[ Aaron Davis/The Prowler]]

• [[ Aunt May]]

• [[ Spoiler Character]] : Migel O' Hara/Spider-Man 2099.

• [[ Mary Jane]]

Edited by VengefulBale on Jan 13th 2019 at 10:17:52 AM

9/10- I still haven't seen the movie, but from what I have gleaned the casting is pretty accurate.

The Lego Movie

Emmett◊

Wyldstyle◊

Vtruvius◊

Batman◊

Metalbeard◊

Unikitty◊

Benny◊

Lord Business◊

Good Cop/Bad Cop◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on Jan 26th 2019 at 8:53:37 AM

Bumped and edited.

Ehh… I guess it’s 6/10. Still good, though.

Ben 10 (2016) (had no idea what to do so have this).

Ben:

The one in the middle.

Gwen:

Grandpa Max:

The aliens:

Four Arms:

Upgrade and eventual Glitch (best thing, he looks like him):

XRL8:

Diamondhead:

Grey Matter: or

Cannonbolt:

Heatblast:

Overflow:

Wildvine:

And, last of all, Stinkfly:

9/10. I've never watched any version of Ben 10, but these seem like they all fit, based on the Characters page. I like your choices for the aliens, especially Stinkfly. :P

Batman Returns

• Bruce Wayne/Batman: Seam◊
• Oswald Cobblepot/Penguin: Arnold Hugh◊
• Selina Kyle/Catwoman: Ms. Fortune◊
• Max Shreck: Prince John◊
• Chip Shreck: Marx◊
• Alfred Pennyworth: Gentleman Snorlax◊
• Commissioner Gordon: Sir Roderic Murgatroyd◊
• Red Triangle Circus Gang:
  • Organ Grinder: Slagar the Cruel◊
  • Poodle Lady: Stella◊
  • Poodle: Broodle◊
  • Thin Clown: Umlaut◊
  • Fat Clown: Harlequin◊
  • Knifethrower Dame: Rarebit◊
  • Tattooed Strongman: Dark Crafter◊
  • Sword Swallower: Jack o' Lantern◊
  • Snake Woman: Maleficent◊
• Ice Princess: Vividria◊
• Mr. Cobblepot: Count Olaf◊
• Mrs. Cobblepot: Ursula◊ (I thought I had an avatar of Esme Squalor, but now I can't find it... had to make do with something else. :P)

Edited by DrNoPuma on Mar 17th 2019 at 11:45:26 AM

7/10 It's pretty okay.

A Series of Unfortunate Events

• • Violet:Ichigo◊
  • Klaus:Jeff◊
  • Sunny:Bean◊
  • Beatrice II:Paula◊
• • Lemony Snicket:Lemon Cookie◊
  • Kit Snicket:Squigly◊
  • Jacques Snicket:Claus◊

• • Count Olaf:Thanos◊
  • Esme Squalor:Harumi◊
  • The Hooked Hand Man/Fernald:Magolor◊
  • The Bald Man:Sims 4 Pidgeon◊
  • The White Faced Women:Peach and Daisy◊
  • The Person of Indeterminate Gender:Lime Cat◊
  • The Carnival Freaks:Splash Mountain Melee Players◊
• • Uncle Monty:Gingerbrave◊
  • Aunt Josephine:Lil' Miss Marshmallow◊
  • Sir and Charles:Skitty And Delcatty◊
  • Jerome Squalor:Lloyd◊
  • Council of Elders:Breadroll Cats◊
• • Larry Your-Waiter:Will Smith◊
  • Beatrice and Bertram:Francisca◊Taranza◊
  • Mr. Poe:Winter◊
  • Ms. Poe:Autumn◊
  • Justice Strauss:White Choco Cookie◊
  • The Denouement Twins (Ernest & Frank:Spidermen◊
  • Dewey Denouemnent:A Mood Spiderman◊
  • Phil:Kirby◊
  • Vice Principal Nero:Fire Spirit Cookie◊
  • Olivia:Marie◊
• • Duncan:Ron◊
  • Isadora:Luna◊
  • Quigley:Lucas◊
• • Fiona:Kumatora◊
• • Principal Ishmael:Big Chungus◊
• • Dr. Georgina Orwell:Palutena◊
  • Carmelita Spats:Susie◊
  • The Man with a Beard but no Hair and the Woman with Hair but no Beard:Aeon & Venus◊

As someone who's been meaning to get into ASOUE, this is AWESOME. 10/10.

Aladdin

Aladdin: Cisco Ramon◊

Abu: Goose◊

Jafar: Voldemort◊

Iago: Mapleshade◊

Raziel (captain of the guard): Javert◊

Genie: The Flash◊

Jasmine: Caitlin Snow◊

Rajah: Spottedleaf◊

Sultan: Uncle Iroh◊

The Merchant from the beginning of the movie: Barry Allen◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on May 10th 2019 at 7:07:32 AM