Follow TV Tropes


Literature / Where Angels Fear to Tread

Go To

"She looked at him with great friendliness, for he had made her life endurable. At that moment the train entered the St Gotthard tunnel. They hurried back to the carriage to close the windows lest the smuts should get into Harriet's eyes."
Final words

Debut novel by E. M. Forster first published in 1905. It is a dark comedy about a clash of cultures between the staid English middle class and the more ebullient Italians.

Lilia Herriton, an impulsive young English widow, travels to Italy with her companion, Caroline Abbott. Her mother-in-law, anxious to preserve the good name of the family, hopes that the trip will civilise her become concerned when she decides to stay in Italy, and send her brother-in-law Philip to fetch her home. Unfortunately by the time he arrives Lilia is already married to Gino, the 21-year-old son of a provincial dentist, and Philip and Caroline return to England.

When news comes through that Lilia has died in childbirth, Mrs Herriton goes to great lengths to keep news of her baby from Irma, Lilia's young daughter who has remained at home. However, Irma finds out from a postcard that Mrs Herriton wasn't able to get to in time, and becomes curious about her new brother. Mrs Herriton dispatches Philip and Caroline and her priggish daughter Harriet to gain control of the baby and bring it home to be raised as English. Chaos and tragedy ensue.

A film version, directed by Charles Sturridge and starring several well-known, mostly British actors (Rupert Graves, Helen Mirren, Helena Bonham Carter, Judy Davis, Giovanni Guidelli), was released in 1991. Apart from adding a slight hopeful note to the ending, it was quite faithful to the book, to the point that some viewers considered this a fault. It received a somewhat mixed reception overall; the Washington Post's review seems to have summed it up fairly well, remarking, "On the whole, it's rather like reading without the effort of holding the book. For many, this will do quite nicely, thank you. Others will find it all too stranglingly Anglophilic, which is perhaps the point."

Where Angels Fear To Tread contains examples of:

  • At the Opera Tonight: Philip, Caroline and Harriet attend a performance of Lucia Di Lammermoor at a provincial opera house. Harriet, who has only been persuaded because it's Walter Scott, is not impressed with the boisterous audience and makes her feelings known. Hilarity Ensues.
  • Black Comedy: Very much so.
  • British Stuffiness: Lots of it from Mrs Herriton and especially Harriet. Philip and Caroline lose theirs under the influence of Italy.
  • Culture Of Italy: Philip positively wallows in it.
  • Death by Childbirth: Lilia.
  • Defrosting Ice Queen: Caroline Abbott, who starts out as a suitably prim companion for Mrs Herriot to trust with Lilia, but who herself falls in love with Gino in the end.
  • Doting Parent: Gino is indifferent to his wife while she's alive, but he genuinely adores his son.
  • Evil Matriarch: Mrs Herriton has few if any redeeming features.
  • The Film of the Book: Released in 1991, as mentioned above in the description.
  • Homoerotic Subtext: Philip and Gino get on remarkably well, to the point where Philip sheds his British Stuffiness and becomes surprisingly intimate with Gino.
  • Jerkass: Harriet, who has no social skills and no empathy whatsoever.
  • Likes Older Women: Lilia is a good ten years older than Gino.
  • Literary Allusion Title: The title comes from Alexander Pope in his Essay on Criticism ("Fools rush in where angels fear to tread").
  • Love Triangle: By the end, Philip realises he is falling in love with Caroline, but realises that he can't have her because Caroline is now openly in love with Gino. Of course Philip is also in love with Gino.
  • Manipulative Bitch: Mrs Herriton will stop at nothing to prevent her daughter-in-law besmirching the name of her dead son.
  • Raised by Grandparents: Lilia's young daughter, Irma, has her upbringing carefully supervised by her grandmother.
  • The Edwardian Era: Published in 1905 and set in the recent past.