Screw the Rules, I'm Doing What's Right
What I am about to do is a direct violation of our orders. If anyone objects, please do so now. It will be noted in my log. Data:
Captain, I believe I speak for everyone here, sir, when I say... to hell with our orders
So the Big Damn Heroes
are about to set off to Save The World
. Not so fast, red tape and bureaucracy
are standing in the way of the world's last hope. Well, there's only one thing to do. Ignore the orders of the Obstructive Bureaucrat
and/or Corrupt Bureaucrat
, then go Save The World
anyway. This is, after all, a Matter of Life and Death
Other, less dramatic examples are usually helping someone out when the rules say that you shouldn't. Or obeying your Curious Qualms of Conscience
rather than your careful instruction in right and wrong.
However, when a Lawful Good
character has to choose between order and what's right
, they may break Lawful rather than Good and end up on this path. Some particularly scrupulous types will even willingly accept punishment afterward; this is called "civil disobedience". More often, though, they're Saved by the Awesome
Applying this trope does not
mean that the ends justify the means
, but rather that the person acts compassionate and follows his conscience even when the rules would forbid it (or to put it another way, they do
justify the means, but the means usually aren't very terrible). When a Knight Templar
attempts this, they are likely to go Jumping Off the Slippery Slope Doing What They Had To Do
instead — see Tautological Templar
A good aligned Cowboy Cop
will almost certainly invoke this trope at least once. Doing this is often the way to pass a Secret Test of Character
Can be the cause of Awakening the Sleeping Giant
if a group's new leaders decide to break with tradition. If the rules are such that the character is already on the run from the law, see Dudley Do-Right Stops to Help
. If it involves directly disobeying a direct order of a superior officer in the armed forces, it's The Mutiny
. This trope is the primary drive behind Chaotic Good
Compare Sudden Principled Stand
and Frequently-Broken Unbreakable Vow
open/close all folders
- In Devil's Due's G.I. Joe vs the Transformers, the Joes defy orders to capture Wheeljack and Bumblebee, who were already working with them, and take them to Area 51 for study when they find out that the nukes the government plans to hit the Cobra base with are going to have an adverse effect when combined with the Energon that Cobra is trying to produce.
- Heck, under Larry Hama's pen, the Joes regularly went against orders from more corrupt organizations like the Jugglers in order to do the right thing instead. One story arc even featured Destro saving the Joes after they were framed by a corrupt General.
- The Animated Adaptation had Destro do so during the "Synthoid Conspiracy" two-parter when Cobra Commander had the Synthoids impersonate Duke and other military figures, as well as Congressional Budget Committee members (in an effort to undercut G.I. Joe and disband it). It failed miserably when the Commander tried to make a Synthoid of Destro and made the real Destro believe the Commander went that one step too far.
- Despite his "Big Blue Boyscout" reputation, Superman is willing to tear straight through any laws in his way if lives are on the line. He'll also willingly turn himself in afterward.
- This is Batman's thing. The point of him dressing up like a giant bat and haunting the night is because he would never get anything done playing by the rules. Especially when the rules are made by corrupt officials who are connected to criminals.
- Captain America:
Doesn't matter what the press says. Doesn't matter what the politicians or the mobs say. Doesn't matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all else: the requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world — "No, YOU move."
- Most of the anti-registration superheroes in Civil War.
- The dawn of the Bronze Age pretty much happened when Hal Jordan, following a lecture from Green Arrow, disobeyed the Guardians' orders and set out to stop a crooked businessman who was putting poor families out on the streets.
- This is a fairly common theme in Green Lantern, period. The four human lanterns, and often a number of the alien ones, will go against a direct order from the Guardians or their Justice League teammates if they believe it will serve a greater purpose. Kyle Rayner sends a prisoner to Zamaron instead of Oa, John Stewart tells Batman to shove it when Bats disrespects Hal, the aforementioned Hal Jordan example, and Guy Gardner...well, he's freaking Guy Gardner.
- Uatu, the Watcher is an observer sworn not to interfere in the affairs of Earth, but there's just something about humans-- (Note that Uatu has frequently gotten in trouble for this from the other members of his species, and is apparently currently on some form of probation.)
- This trope is pretty much the reason that Nick Fury made Secret War happen.
Film - Animated
- In Mulan, by law, Shang should have executed Mulan once he discovered she was a girl disguising as a soldier. But because she had earlier saved his life, he let her live.
- In Disney's The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Frollo orders Captain Phoebus to burn down a windmill — with a couple and their two children locked inside of it. Phoebus objects, saying that he was not trained to murder innocent civilians, to which Frollo replies, "But you were trained to follow orders.". Phoebus then put out the torch that he was given by dunking it into a barrel of water. After that happens, Frollo starts the fire himself. Phoebus promptly breaks into the windmill to get the family out safely, and is arrested immediately afterward. Frollo comments on how he expected better from such a decorated officer.
- The protagonist in the Parable of the Good Samaritan as told in The Bible (Luke 10:29�37) could be considered the Ur Example, although Jesus probably didn't base the character on a real person.
- Jesus himself fits this trope in many respects, blatantly altering or disregarding then-common interpretations of Mosaic law when he felt the rules had gotten in the way of doing what was right.
Tabletop RP Gs
- Lord Shojo of The Order of the Stick felt the restrictions on the Oaths that prevented them from seeking out the other Gates were too restrictive, especially since two Gates were destroyed within the last 20 years. However, his plans all involved disregarding his Oaths, going behind the backs of his paladins, and contacting foreign mercenaries. While Shojo is portrayed sympathetically, Rich points out that Shojo never considered trying to convince the paladins that the Oaths were outdated (plus, one of the locations was heavily booby trapped in case Soon or his followers decided to do this, the trapper believing this trope in the hands of paladins would only be a self-righteous justification).
- Miko actually said the phrase "The laws have no meaning... Only honor and the will of the gods matter now". Granted, it turned out that she was doing the wrong, incredibly stupid thing, but she was convinced that killing Lord Shojo was the right and necessary thing to do.
- Domain Tnemrot has Angel helping Dae after his fight, even though she's not allowed in the ring and is almost killed for it.
- The Mayor's assistant in Freefall deliberately goes against the Mayor's decisions to help Florence stop Gardener in the Dark, noting that there are some things worth risking your internship for.
- Also in Free Fall, Florence notes that some people are criminals because they're bad, others are criminals because they're out of legal options.
- Iron Man: Armored Adventures: In the episode "Fun with Laser", Iron Man goes against Nick Fury's order to stop the Living Laser and save the SHIELD space station after Nick's first plan fails spectacularly.
- Pretty much Pepper's reason for every plan of hers, despite some plans including destroying the enemy's entire company.
- In the Star Wars: The Clone Wars episode, "Cat and Mouse", Anakin decides to engage Admiral Trench after he sends bombers to bomb the command center where Bail Organa is, because Anakin wants to not have Obi-Wan risk his fleet by engaging Trench, because he has less resources, and would be walking into a deathtrap.
- In one episode of Popeye And Son, Popeye and his son are in a father/son contest, and one of the rules forbids the use of spinach. They end up breaking this rule when they have to save Wimpy and his nephew.
- In the Family Guy episode "Screams of Silence: The Story of Brenda Q.", police officer Joe was initially against Quagmire's suggestion that they kill his sister's abusive boyfriend, since it would be murder. But when he witnesses the abuse for himself, his response is...
- And in "Thanksgiving", a flashback shows Joe chasing a homeless man who stole some food, but he lets the guy off the hook when he sees he stole it to feed his starving family.
- In The Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes, Captain America suspected something was mind-controlling the Hulk to go berserk, who was currently captured by SHIELD and General Ross. When nothing could be done to convince them to let the Hulk go, he then proceeded to break into the underwater base and broke all sorts of rules to rescue Hulk, which was against his otherwise extremely lawful persona.
- Hal tends to do this in Green Lantern: The Animated Series, much to the annoyance of his bosses, the Guardians (save Ganthet, who seems to follow in Hal's belief in this). Lampshaded by Kilowog when Hals shows annoyance at Aya for doing the same after learning it from his example.
- Korra from The Legend of Korra has this attitude with a mix of Screw the Rules, I Have Supernatural Powers!.
- Her mentor Katara from Avatar: The Last Airbender also shows this attitude when she wants to save a village from a Fire Nation troop (whose factory polluting the river was destroyed by her).