These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Alas, Poor Scrappy: The same fans who spent the last two years referring to TOM 4 as "Tom-ass the Toonami Engine" cried when he left. It was because a simple word ("Bang...") reminded the older audience - the ones who had watched Toonami through all eleven years - that they weren't forgotten. Sure, we thought they had when they started milking Naruto for all it was worth, (practically) changed hosts, and got rid of all the credible shows and original series. But what Tom said - what Steven Jay Blum said - just meant so much more. The fact that a certain imageboard practically broke down during the last hour or so of the final run, overwhelmed with nostalgia and begging each other to do something to stop Toonami from shutting down simply adds to the heartbreak. In short, Toonami with a crappy looking host is still better than no Toonami at all.
If this can be applied to a show, Tenchi Muyo GXP fits the bill. Some enjoyed it for being an overall fun show following in the footsteps ofitspredecessors, while others hated it for being a non-action show airing on Toonami, an action-oriented block (despite the fact that the Tenchi Muyo! series in general isn't an action-oriented series). Unfortunately, the latter side seems to have more prevalence, as the show tanked in ratings to the point of being moved down to 3:00 AM (though in all fairness, GXP did manage to finish its run and air all 26 of its episodes without getting taken off the lineup), and it's unlikely if any other shows that put less emphasis on action will air on the block.
ThunderCats and Sym-Bionic Titan... or rather, the fact that they were added to the lineup in the first place. Anime fans insist that Toonami should stick exclusively to anime. Others are either happy about or don't really mind the addition of western animation.
When Toonami came back on May 26th, Cowboy Bebop was one of the shows that was previously airing on [adult swim] and carried over to Toonami. When it's run ended, it was taken off along with Deadman Wonderland and replaced by Samurai 7 and Eureka Seven. However, when the block expanded to 6 hours, it was brought back to the lineup, and it has been a part of the block since. While some fans don't really mind, other fans are sick of seeing the show to the point where they actually want it to be taken off, and are getting their wish on Oct 19th. Unfortunately, the removal of Cowboy Bebop has flipped the tables, satisfying the people who wanted the show off, but also pissing off the fans who were perfectly fine with Bebop.
Likewise are debates if Panty And Stocking should join the block, considering it's parody of western shows (especially those on CN) developed by Gainax (the same creators behind FLCL), but contains large amounts of "mature" content, either making massive Bowdlerization inevitable or destroying the show's chances of even airing. (Toonami Tumblr Jossing it entirely probably helped)
Kick-Heart, a kickstarter-funded 15-minute short produced by Production I.G. that was aired on August 31st, airing right afterEvangelion 2.22, and again on November 2nd along with King Star King and Korgoth of Barbaria as Daylight Savings Time filler. Reception has so far been mixed, with some liking the surreal artstyle and quality which greatly contrasts that of the shows in Toonami's lineup and resembles the type of shows that air on regular [adult swim], while others despised it for the very same reasons.
King Star King suffered a brutal backlash when it was played during the 2013 Daylight Savings Hour alongside Korgoth of Barbaria and Kick-Heart, to the point where Toonami's showrunner ran a Twitter poll asking whether they should replay the DST Hour again the next year or do something experimental. The verdict? "Experimental by a huge margin. As long as it's NOT King Star King!" There were a few people here and there who did like King Star King, but they were greatly outnumbered by those who didn't.
There are those who want to see the original 291-episode uncut and uncensored Dragon Ball Z with the FUNimation english dub, and there are those who would rather see the 98-episode Dragon Ball Z Kai recut with improved voice actors and much of the filler removed. Oddly enough, the 53-episode Ocean dub that aired unsuccessfully in syndication before finding success on Toonami is almost never brought up.
Another main problem with the block during the TOM 4.0 era was that it was hastily cut down from four hours to three, and then from three hours to two, and they still insisted on showing two new episodes of their hit show Naruto back-to-back, even though it was in the "endless year of filler" saga and effectively took up half the block. Not only that, but when they began airing the FUNimation dub of One Piece, considered a vast improvement from 4Kids' dub, and the ratings started to climb, the show was unceremoniously canceled in the middle of the Skypiea story arc, right before the arc was going to kick into high gear, and replaced with Blue Dragon which didn't even make it past a few episodes! What's worse, future episodes of the Skypiea arc did air on the Australian Cartoon Network, and all the episodes that they aired starting with episode 175 were completely uncensored. And if that weren't bad enough, the well-received reruns of Dragon Ball Z were also cut short not too long after One Piece was bumped off the block. To make matters worse, it, too, was also taken off right before the story arc it was in was about to shift into high gear. It's no wonder people don't like the TOM 4.0 era.
A lot of fans who claim that Toonami sucks without Dragon Ball Z seem to forget that A) it wasn't the first show to ever air on Toonami (that would be ThunderCats), B) it wasn't the first anime show to air on Toonami (that honor belongs to Sailor Moon... or Voltron, if one considers that show to be an anime), C) Dragon Ball Z wasn't even remotely popular in the states until it started airing on Toonami, and D) Nick Toons as of this writing has exclusive cable broadcast rights to anything Dragonball, meaning that DBZ can't return to Toonami anytime soon.
Also, contrary to semi-popular opinion, Toonami is an action-animation block, meaning that anime under the Slice of Life and Romantic Comedy genres (barring a few exceptions such as Tenchi Muyo! and Patlabor, which do contain some action) are notacceptable choices. Granted, Toonami has aired non-action shows before (Hamtaro comes to mind), but those are very few in number.
TOM claiming to be a vampire hunter "way back" is a subtle reference to when Cartoon Network aired Vampire Hunter D for Night of the Vampire Robotsnote A special event on January 29, 1995 (before Toonami was even conceived), where Cartoon Network aired Robot Carnival, Vampire Hunter D, and Twilight of the Cockroaches during the network's after hours, starting at midnight.
TOM 4.0's speech "Eleven years and counting! Raise your hand if you were alive during Toonami's launch" wasn't as celebratory when it eventually turned out to be the final year of the original Toonami's existence.
A commercial advertising Gundam Wing DVDs. "Gundam Wing. Pick up the DVDs wherever you can find them." This commercial and line spoken one day after Bandai Entertainment announced that they were halting production and distribution of all their DVDs for good.
However, though Bandai Entertainment halted production, Sunrise, the company who produced the Gundam series and many other shows that Bandai licensed, has opted to sell their formerly Bandai-licensed shows to other companies, meaning that picking up DVDs for Gundam Wing (as well as The 08th MS Team, Gundam 0080, G Gundam, etc.) might not seem impossible anymore once someone decides to pick up the licenses.
At the end of each Tenchi promo, you hear the narrator say, "Love Stinks", keep in mind that that narrator was the voice of the original Optimus Prime! Mr. "Freedom is the right of all sentient beings"! A character who is known for being serious and almost entirely lacking in a sense of humor (at least in later Transformers shows and movies)!
Back at the height of the 2000s anime boom, some ads mistakenly labelled Cowboy Bebop as part of the Toonami block. It took a while, but it did finally happen in 2012.
There was once a obscure [adult swim] bump in the past, making fun of the fact that Toonami claimed to be cooler than Adult Swim, and had a pretty comical in-house rivalry (both being run by Williams Street). Cut to 2012, where Toonami has been Uncancelled and now runs on Adult Swim hours.
One of D's quotes, "Glad to see you stayed with us. Toonami loves you", could easily describe the revival.
In 2002, the Toonami review of The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind had SARA praise it while TOM act completely dismissive towards it. Flash forward 10 years later, where TOM looks at Skyrim and not only showers it with praise, but gives it a rating of 100/10 (Dawnguard got an 8/10)
The Haters speech could count as both this and a Hypocrisy Nod. Back in the TOM 3 era, there were promos for Naruto where TOM talked smack about the "haters", "false heroes", "pretenders", and American Dragon Jake Long (going so far as to claim Naruto could beat Jake Long in a fight, and even toss away a video tape with the latter show's logo on it). Come TOM 3.5's speech about Haters in the 2012 revival, and...
TOM 3.5: "Ole TOM learned his lesson a while ago."
Some fans believe that Naruto (more specifically, Naruto fillers) was responsible for Toonami’s original demise, when it was in fact Cartoon Network’s fault for refusing to make or acquire more action cartoons and anime for the block. A lot of it had to do with the Network Decay Cartoon Network was undergoing at the time as they were heavily pushing a retool of the network with live action shows instead of cartoons, which evidently did worse for the network than whatever Naruto did. Plus, if Naruto did prove to be a block killer, it would not have been a part of the block’s revival, much less be one of the headlining shows. That being said, whether they will air the infamous pre-Shippudden filler arc or not when the time comes is yet to be determined (ironically enough, the show was actually nearing the end of the filler arc before Toonami got cancelled).
A lot of viewers don't like that the intros and outros of shows get trimmed down or cut entirely and will usually blame Toonami for that. However, it's actually the distributors themselves who do that, due to TV time constraints. They even addressed this on an on air Q & A session.
Nostalgia Filter: Some say a lot of love for Toonami in the current day comes from this. Fans insist however that they love the block because of how high-quality and influential it was.
Most of the revamps got this, but the 4.0 revamp was the worst, no doubt thanks to the block being cut down to two hours a week (Toonami started out with fifteen), TOM 4, SARA's disappearance, and (finally) the cancellation of the block.
The 2012 revival has caused a Broken Base. Opposers complain about the Darker and Edgier elements, the later time slot, the poor launch lineup, and the fact it's near indistinguishable from [adult swim]'s normal anime block. Supporters are just happy that [adult swim] is (showing interest of) returning to its roots after the whole Network Decay fiasco that ravaged Cartoon Network during the late 2000's, and say that it'll get better shows and an expanded timeslot if it gets support. Whether or not its lineup of shows improved is debatable, but it did get an expanded timeslot after a few months (and there's still support to get the timeslot to expand even further).
Hypocritical Hatedom: Those who use the rebuttal "ALL TOONAMI IS IS ADULT SWIM WITH TOM!" tend to be oblivious to the fact that the original Midnight Run eventually lead to the creation of Adult Swim. Then again, [adult swim] wasn’t a poster example of Network Decay back then.
Uncanny Valley: The TOM 4-era Robot Buddies had movable facial features and gave the distinct impression that they would eat your face if you changed the channel. Or didn't change the channel.
Visual Effects of Awesome: If there's one thing Toonami has a reputation for outside of stellar programming and a kickass host, it's the CG effects. Ever since the early days with Moltar and TOM 1.0, Toonami has been provided with some of the best-looking CG this side of PIXAR, with the CG work getting better and better with each successive retool.