- Jerkass Woobie: Dana Palmer from the Seniors. A slight Beta Bitch in the books that didn't have her as the main character, she had the unfortunate luck to discover Danielle Cortez's corpse on the first day of school, and throughout the years watches as most of the cheerleading squad is picked off, and also loses her twin sister.
- Les Yay: The girls comforting each other in the locker room in Cheerleaders: The First Evil, and the friendship between Stacey Malcolm and Mary O'Connor from Seniors. Stacey was visibly angry that people were defending Trisha Conrad for going out with Gary Fresno even though everyone knew Gary was dating Mary first.
- Narm: Plenty of moments.
- From The Thirst: "GOOOOOOD DOGGGGG!!"
- Serial Numbers Filed Off: A small, coastal town in the northern US built around a lumber mill with more than its fair share of secrets, including both real and supernatural evil, largely centered on the sordid lives of teenagers. It also features a queen bee whose father owns a department store named after himself and has a recurring fire motif. Now, am I describing Shadyside or Twin Peaks?
- Tear Jerker: The second half of the first book in the 99 Fear Street: The House of Evil trilogy. It's the scene where Cally Fraiser is reading a picture book to her nine year old brother, James. Basically, James suffers a great deal of emotional stress due to the house. His dog, Cubby, goes missing a few days after receiving him, and the house taunts him by letting the dog's barking be heard CONSTANTLY throughout the halls, always making it seem like it's in the next room, only for them to arrive in said room and the barking shifts to another area of the house. He's also had to watch his parents suffer an equal amount of stress caused by the house. Cally notes that her brother has regressed to the emotional state of a baby, fearful of everything, when he asks her to read him a picture book he stopped reading years ago. Cally does indeed read the book to him, and wishes him goodnight, on the verge of tears from seeing her little brother in this state. And then the house takes James in the same way it did his dog. His family can hear James crying for his parents to help him, but they can't find him. It isn't until the next book that James and Cubby, or rather, their corpses, are discovered by the new residents of the house. At least the house hadn't turned him into a vengeful ghost as it did his sister, Cally, who also died in the first book.
- Unfortunate Implications: Many.
- The Cheater finds the rich characters all being painted in a sympathetic light - even cheater Carter and her killer boyfriend, Dan; the poor guy, Adam, is a creepy, abusive blackmailer and winds up dead. His equally-poor girlfriend is also a blackmailer and is portrayed as a jealous, contemptuous extortionist.
- The entire subplot of Ty Sullivan's womanizing in Fear Street Seniors and the messed up love triangle between Gary Fresno and Trisha Conrad. Trisha has dated Gary while he was still with Mary O'Connor, and then began cheating on Gary with Ty Sullivan even though she knew Ty was with Jennifer Fear, one of her best friends, and Greta Bradley. Yet Trisha still participated in the Amy prank alongside Marla Newman and Phoebe Yamura even though she is the least sympathetic of the three. The only people who really call Trisha on her actions are Gary, who is far from innocent, and Stacy Malcolm, Mary O'Connor's best friend who gets vilified for being against Trisha.
- Debra Lake vilifies Mira Block simply because she goes out with a lot of guys. Her distrust of Mira turns out to be justified when it's revealed Mira killed Clarissa Turner's older sister Justine, then Debra, and attempted to kill Clarissa and her adopted brother Aaron. Why? So she could get Clarissa's boyfriend Will Reynolds.
- The Woobie: Hope Mathis from Fear Hall. Growing up, her mother would constantly deride her for her weight. In one instance, when Hope had friends over for ice cream, her mom made her eat all the ice cream in the bowls, then forced her face into the carton. Right in front of her guests. She gave her the nickname "Buttertubs", which is how she addressed letters to Hope when she went to camp. In high school it got worse, she actually handcuffed herself to Hope to stop her from seeing a boy. Is it any wonder she snapped and developed four split personalities as a way to cope?
- Holly Flynn in Lights Out.