Sometimes writers will, for reasons of convenience, extrapolate an entire race's "hat"
from the behavior of one or two characters.
Typically, this goes as follows:
- A character in an Ensemble Cast has exotic, quirky traits.
- That character is the sole example of their culture seen for a significant period (an entire movie, a season of a series, etc.).
- When we finally see the character's home culture, their distinctive set of exotic, quirky traits turn out to be their planetary hat.
of Planet of Hats
is known as Planet of Copyhats
If the original quirky character manages to stand out from the rest of their people at all, it will often be because they've toned down
their culture's hat to bring their behavior more in line with the ensemble, possibly citing that their species doth protest too much
and thus turning out to be wearing a lampshade
for a hat. Conversely, the trope may be partly psychologically justified
when a Fish out of Water
wears their hat proudly to uphold their cultural identity while living in a different culture.
If the culture is conceived from the start as having some specific distinguishing trait, and then characters are presented as specific examples of that culture, that's a standard Planet of Hats
. See also A Kind of One
for cases where there's some ambiguity concerning whether the quirky character is just a character who is quirky or a perfectly average specimen of a quirky species.
Bonus points if it isn't even established until later on that an individual is part of some broader "race"
as opposed to some unique entity.
open/close all folders
Star Wars Expanded Universe
- The Star Wars Expanded Universe uses this aggressively. With only three movies worth of content to start off with, writers had to create entire races based on minor extras that happened to have unique make-up.
- The most Egregious example? The Bothans. Their only appearance in the movies is Mon Mothma's line in Return of the Jedi: "Many Bothans died to bring us this information." From that single, offhand mention, EU writers whipped up an entire species whose entire society is based around spying and espionage.
- Star Wars has another Egregious example in Corellians, which is Han Solo's home culture. During the scene in the asteroid field in The Empire Strikes Back, Han says "Never Tell Me the Odds", and from this some EU writer extrapolated that all Corellians hate statistics with a passion.
- Ben Kenobi wears nondescript desert robes in A New Hope; in the prequels, this becomes the Jedi uniform (great way to hide out, Ben).
- This is less of an example, since simple robes fit the Jedi lifestyle of few material possessions and practicality, while they also protect Tatooine-dwellers from sun, heat, and sand.
- Jabba the Hutt was a crime boss, so the Hutts became an entire species of crime bosses.
- The females are all Beautiful Slave Girls because of Oola from Return of the Jedi.
- Males are all criminals because of Bib Fortuna, Jabba's majordomo. Also created the dichotomy that while Female Twi'leks tend to be more seductive and beautiful, male ones tend to be rather ugly. Especially if they are evil.
- The fact that Bib Fortuna fell victim to Luke's mind trick (nothing to be ashamed of, because at this point Luke is quite powerful) has many things classify Twi'leks as being Weak-Willed, due to Obi-wan's earlier line about it working better on the feeble minded.
- Then the X-Wing Series comes along and turns it inside-out. Nawara Ven of Rogue Squadron started as a defense attorney rather than a criminal. And The Krytos Trap reveals that the Twi'leks have a little-known warrior subculture that understandably doesn't appreciate the stereotype given them by the galaxy at large. That said one of those same warriors is brainwashed by Zsinj in Solo Command - maybe Twi'lek's, regardless of individual willpower just have less defense against mental tampering than other species.
- Sullustans becoming a race of navigator copilots after Lando's Millennium Falcon copilot (also Return of the Jedi).
- Farmers from Tatooine developing a reputation for improbable piloting skills as a result of Luke and Biggs. Gavin Darklighter is used to illustrate this in the X-Wing Series.
- Boba Fett's armor and style became the inspiration for Mandalorians being a Proud Warrior Race full of Badasses.
- Plo Koon, being a Jedi Master, was the inspiration to make his entire race scholarly, with a strong belief in justice and naturally gifted with the force. In short: Jedi-like.
- The bounty hunter Leia disguised herself as? Turns out he was Ubese. And guess what? Turns out the entire race has a thing for bounty hunting, mercenary work, and wearing helmets all the time. They wear the helmets because their planet got nuked into a post-apocalyptic wasteland and they need a poisonous atmosphere to live.
- A few Quarren were seen in Jabba's palace. Thus, the Expanded Universe features plenty of Quarren mobsters. As they come from the same planet as the Mon Calamari (Admiral Ackbar's people), their people always tend to come off as the more "evil" of the two. Ackbar is a good guy, so his people will tend towards being the good guys in a story. Take Star Wars Legacy: Mon Cals are at the forefront of the resistance against the Sith (and pay a heavy price for it), while we have seen at least two Quarren Sith Lords.
- One of the bounty hunters in the line-up on Vader's ship is Bossk, his species, the Trandoshans, got a hat as slavers, mercenaries, bounty hunters, and mortal enemies of the Wookiees. (See, cause he's hunting Chewie, get it?)
- Dantooine is weirdly a literal planet that conforms to its trope, its only apperance is in episode 4 and it's said that the rebels have an abandoned base there. So in the expanded universe its history is rife with abandoned colonies and buildings.
- However, many Star Wars fans sadly do not get the memo that the Gungans are not an example, and Jar Jar isn't typical, and was in fact exiled largely because the rest of his species thought he was an obnoxious screw-up too.
- Exclusive to the Star Wars Expanded Universe, a notable inversion. Nom Anor was introduced well before any other Yuuzhan Vong in an obscure comic series as a shadowy political manipulator. When the New Jedi Order saga got underway, the rest of the Vong showed up, and Anor turned out to be highly atypical of his species, a scheming Dirty Coward among Knight Templar Proud Warrior Race Guys, tolerated (barely) because he got results. Anor's conflict with Vong society at large would be the impetus for several plot points across the series.
Anime and Manga
- In Terminator 2: Judgment Day, the T-800 wields a minigun in one scene because it is most effective in achieving a particular goal (namely, scaring off the police). Rise of the Machines and Salvation, in contrast, show the T-800s using the minigun as their preferred weapon of choice.
- In Elmo in Grouchland, we learn that 1) Grouches are a distinct species of monster, 2) they all have exactly the same preferences as Oscar toward trash and snarkiness, and 3) they all have a hidden Heart Of Gold as well.
- The character M3 Green, from Star Trek: The Animated Series, was an overly cautious coward. His race features in the Starfleet Corps of Engineers novels, having been named the Nasat, and their hat is indeed "being overly cautious". However, the lead Nasat character, P8 Blue, is a straight-forward case of My Species Doth Protest Too Much, as she loves shaking things up and taking risks.
- The first book in the Redwall series is primarily about mice fighting rats, but there's a single goofy, bard-like Hare, a single brewmaster Hedgehog, and a single tough, warrior-like Badger. In later books of the series with more varying races, almost all hares are goofy bards, almost all hedgehogs are defined by making alcoholic beverages, and the badgers are a Proud Warrior Race.
- BIONICLE had Roodaka, a treacherous and cruel female Vortixx, and possible the only toy whose gender you could guess simply by her looks. When we learn of the Vortixx culture, it turns out that every female of her race is as mean, but not only that, as it's also revealed that the whole species looks exactly like her... including the males.
Live Action Television
- Star Trek:
- Averted by the Vulcans of the original series. Vulcans were defined as a logical species early on, and that gave the writers a hook to develop Spock's personality. (Watch "The Cage", "Where No Man Has Gone Before", and "The Man Trap"; Spock is a very different character before he dons the Vulcan logic hat.)
- While not the first Bajoran seen on screen, Ro Laren was the first with any real amount of screen time. In an episode she shows a more religious side (compared to Geordi). Come Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, religion became the Bajorans' hat. A rather mild example, though, but conspicuous because of Star Trek: The Next Generation's atheist tenor. They also acquired the hat that the Bajorans who weren't saintly calm spiritual leaders were generally short-tempered ex-terrorists (it didn't help that the main Bajoran character in DS9 was a Suspiciously Similar Substitute for Ensign Ro when Michelle Forbes wouldn't commit to being a regular character.)
- The Klingons in TNG famously follow this trope— but only to a point. In the Original Series, they were conniving bastards and Soviet standins. Enter Proud Warrior Race Guy Worf, and ever after Klingon culture is all about honor and the warrior tradition. However, there's a degree of subversion to it. In one episode, Riker serves on a Klingon ship as part of an exchange program. He assumes that they'll all be stoic Proud Warrior Race Guys just like Worf, but instead he sees them telling jokes and being casual around each-other. Then in later episodes, it turns out that their warrior code is something they often don't live up to, with a lot of conniving and even craven bastardry still going on. It turns out that Worf was representing his own very highly idealized, even downright inaccurate, vision of his race with lines like "A Klingon does not laugh."
- Also, in Star Trek: The Next Generation, There is Guinan the Barkeep, who was always eager to listen to people and offer advice. We later learn she is not human, and even later that she is from a race whose hat is "listening".
- On the Lois and Clark show, Clark decided to wait for marriage. A cute gesture? When the New Kryptonians show up, they tell him it's a racial quirk.
- In Stargate, Ra is an evil alien overlord (and sole member of his race seen on screen). Come Stargate SG-1, Ra's race, the Goa'uld, has a Hat of being evil overlords posing as deities.
- Averted in Farscape with Chiana. She is hunted by her people (the Nebari) because she insists on being a wild individualist, while the rest of her species values conformity and order. When we do meet other Nebari, they're usually the polar opposite of Chiana.
- In the Ronald McDonald cartoon movies, Grimace travels to the island of his people, the Grimaces.
- In Futurama Dr. Zoidberg's Yiddish accent became the standard one of his entire race.
- The Nibblonians take Nibbler's defining characteristic (that he's an Extreme Omnivore who consumes things much larger than him) and make it one of the fundemental concepts of their culture. Let the Feast of a Thousand Hams begin!
- World Of Quest inverts this. The techno-organic Way is a living direction finder, and for most of the series is assumed to be representative of her people. Then we meet her people, most of whom have senses of direction on par with Ryoga Hibiki.
- One episode of Wakfu has Sadlygrove, the "lovable goof" of the series, doing a butt-slapping dance to playfully mock the other team during a sporting event. It's fairly typical conduct for an athlete in the middle of a game, and it lasts for about second and a half. Later on, we meet Sadlygrove's people, the Iops, and they have an entire butt-slapping dance ceremony.
- In American Dad!, when other aliens of Roger's race appear, they share his campiness and snarky sense of humor.