Ask The Tropers

open

Designated Heroes in fantasy books Literature

I must contest the use of Designated Hero in The Chronicles of Narnia and Harry Potter.

The main Designated Hero page says Aslan qualifies for the trope because:

• In The Magician's Nephew he grants all the animals the ability to speak, but he makes it so that if they continue to behave like natural animals, they will lose that gift. He also decrees that non-speaking animals will be the lowest class in the Narnian hierarchy, while humans will rule over everyone else. In hindsight he is making it so that animals who chose to follow their instincts and nature are the lowest of the low, while humans, who in reality don't have the best track record for living with natural things they can't control, get to rule all. Additionally, the morality of Narnia could be summed up like this: you're either with Aslan and you're "good", or you're with someone else or independent and you're evil.
• In The Horse and His Boy, he wounds Princess Aravis in the back because her handmaiden had helped Aravis escape her arranged marriage and was punished for it. Aslan intended that Aravis know the handmaiden's suffering, even though she didn't really deserve it and had gone through enough hell already.
• In Prince Caspian it's implied he turned a group of fat boys into pigs for no reason than that they were fat.
• In The Last Battle he does something that every other designated hero ever written would call him on, he outright destroys Narnia.

Since C. S. Lewis was a devoted Christian and Aslan was meant to be a fantastic version of Jesus Christ, I think this has more to do with religious differences than anything else.

As for Harry Potter, the YMMV page says that Harry and Hermione qualify for the trope because:

• Hermione is often accused of being this, as she usually painted as being in the right whenever she does something morally questionable, like jinxing the D.A. sign-up sheet to permanently disfigure traitors, knowingly leaving Umbridge with the centaurs so that they could do something traumatizing to her, and abusing Ron whether he deserved it or not.
• Harry Potter through the course of his adventures, despite the great demands of fighting a Dark Wizard, never stops slacking off his studies, breaks countless school rules, displays poor sportsmanship and rarely considering the interests of his team or how it could affect them and their standing when he goes off on his own, and in Book 6, via the Potions book, indulges in what is more or less academic plagiarism. Likewise, while painted as an All-Loving Hero he is shown using two of the Unforgivable Curses (Imperio and Crucio) without any reprimand from his peers and elders even if both are considered taboo In-Universe, and one of them is a curse that tortures people (which he used before the highly moral McGonagall).

J. K. Rowling said that Harry and his friends were never meant to be saints, they are fallible human beings that make mistakes, get angry and are forced into extreme circumstances, not to mention, the Harry Potter fandom is one of the most notorious and controversial fandoms in recent memory.

What do you say?