Recommendations for Perusal by 5P

Lucky Dog 1: Explicitly pornographic BL game, again.

Sugar Shooter: Porn Without Plot bara SHMUP with rather young-looking characters.

Shojokyuu Kurige No Shiofuki Shoujotachi: Pornographic Yuri game involving sex between underage ("third year of middle school") girls.

Training with Hinako: A series of exercise videos, interspersed with Fanservice as motivation. Not explicitly pornographic, but apparently consists of literally nothing but fanservice.

I'm talking about the fighting games that bear the Variable Geo title, not the OVA based on those games.

They're pretty different.

That's why I think 5P should look into it, actually, to see where something that sticky falls under the new guidelines.

edited 21st Apr '12 8:47:04 PM by Raidouthe21st

We Are Our Avatars Forever (Now on Discord by invitation, PM)

Edited for arguing when sleeping should be happening.

edited 21st Apr '12 8:50:19 PM by BlackDove

Gore Screaming Show: Heavily pornographic (and violent) H-Game. Also I think some characters look pretty childlike, but it should really be looked over even if their ages aren't a problem.

Youju Senki AD 2048: Explicitly pornographic tentacle-monster strategy game.

edited 21st Apr '12 9:01:39 PM by Neuchadjinys

Thank you for putting up reasonable petitions (so far.) You're a life saver! I thought my SAN points would go into the negatives.

Ahem, despite the absurdity of some of Glider guy's petitions, I'm leaving them in since someone's bound to find out about it and report it anyways. That person just so happened to be Glider guy. I hate to say it, but I actually do think he's being sincere.

For the record, the -_- faces were courtesy of me. Some other petitions do seem somewhat ridiculous to me, but those two take the bakery.

Full Battle Mode

I believe you should check out FanFic.Sonic In The Search For Love. Basically, it's some really raunchy fanfiction, set in the Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog or Sonic SatAM universe, that some of the goons at Something Awful found and started narrating aloud, typoes and all.

The actual plot is incredibly threadbare. The focus of the work is blatantly on the sex acts, which are depicted in fairly intimate detail. Characters can be in the middle of an important, time-sensitive mission, but because their partner accidentally touches them in the wrong way they'll immediately drop what they're doing and go down on them, plot be damned (seriously, we're talking heavy doses of Idiot Ball here). This covers some extreme fetishes, too - the author seems to be very fond of urolagnia, for instance.

For that matter, the Sonic characters are underaged. Sonic is only 16 or so, going off of memory (might be 17 as of Sonic Generations, but that's neither here nor there - it's still < 18). And even if they're considered okay for some reason or another, later on in the fanfic*

the Sonic characters wind up in the universe of the furry porn comic School Days... which itself focuses on the lives of elementary school children in various sex acts and states of undress. You can imagine the level we're working with here.

Yes, it was absolutely hilarious to see the Something Awful goons tear into this merely by reading it verbatim. No, I don't think it should be on TV Tropes.

(Forgive me if I'm going about this the wrong way; this is the first time I've even seen this particular forum.)

edited 21st Apr '12 10:04:31 PM by ShadowHog

Moon◊

• Neo Armageddon Evangelist Looks to be a porn fic centered around rape as a Deus Sex Machina, plus it seems some characters are under 16 when raped. Also has Naughty Tentacles involved.

• Ouropornos: Porn Without Plot based on Tiger And Bunny. Work description screams Excuse Plot and the trope list is a ton of sex tropes with nothing else. Took a look around the site and one out of two fics I read so far was porn.

• Comics Nix: Trollfic writer, described as "quite possibly the most disgusting, disturbing, and insane smutfic writer out there." And some of his "hits."
  • Batman In the Bowels of Hell: Porn with bare threads of plot
  • Doomsday Womb: Gorny porn with lolicon. I read it, it's there. May be over the top Crosses the Line Twice black humor like South Park or such - but needs a look anyway.
  • Love In The Smudge: Gross-Out Show meets Porn Without Plot.
  • Roots Of Life A Cradle To Love: Underage boy (originally from Fairly Oddparents) having sex with a flower after jamming a toothbrush up his ass.
  • Scooby Doo And The Trip Of Lust: "Lemon: The majority of the story involves the gang boinking each other."
  • Severus Snape Professor And Lover: The Snape fucks a Teletubby fic. No coherent plot exists.
  • The Day The Men Found Love: Possibly milder than some of the above entries in that both characters are adults, but it is being Troll Fic porn with no coherent plot.

?

Series like Shuffle are likely to be limited in scope to their Bleached Underpants versions. We may need some special efforts project with people who are familiar with the source materials.

I haven't seen He Is My Master, but it's important to note that many of these harem series are serialised in boys' magazines, meaning people doing the lusting over 14 years olds are 14 years olds themselves. This doesn't mean HIMM will necessarily pass, since I've not seen it, but it's an important thing to have in mind when assessing these works. Otherwise we'll find ourselves in a weird situation where something is sold at Borders (or whatever you have there) but it's banned here.

edited 21st Apr '12 10:40:16 PM by Catalogue

The words above are to be read as if they are narrated by Morgan Freeman.

Strike Witches

Despite the fact that I'm a fan for non-sexual reasons, it's going to be nominated for a look sooner or later, so I might as put it up myself. Problem is sexualization of young girls - copious panty shots, and the DV Ds have gratuitous nudity in around half of the episodes. This covers all main characters, around half of whom are below 16. No underage sex, but it possibly falls under point four of what's being looked for here: "Fanservice intended to cater to pedophiles (lolicon and shotacon count)." It's fanservice, and it includes underage characters, but I'm not sure it's intended to cater to pedophiles. But that's a judgment for P5 to make.

(Note that this series wouldn't qualify as porn alone; it has more than enough plot and action in it to give it another point. It's just the underage characters that present a problem.)

Note: Strike Witches is in the Military science fiction genre, licensed in the US by funi and you can watch it on Zune and other places with no age restrictions even on an Xbox. (so even microsoft has no problems with the content.) The Artstyle is heavily Puni Plush and the outfits are include bathing suit bottoms (due to the fact that they wear airplane like engines on their feet.).

Ages... Not sure on everyone but the ones stated that I can find are all 16-19.

EDIT: it has aired on TV before on the Funi channel.

*

edited 22nd Apr '12 10:09:23 AM by Raso

Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!

Aki Sora - Is this porn? It was banned in Japan, but it could be an innocent work.

It's Porn with Plot, but it's a controversial plot. There's some squicky stuff in it even if you disregard the incest. I'm not going to say it out loud unless some one specifically asks.

edited 21st Apr '12 11:14:15 PM by encrypted12345

Full Battle Mode

In a similar vein to Strike Witches, someone is bound to find Dance In The Vampire Bund eventually. I only got through about half of the first volume of the manga series, but the TV Tropes page mentions the anime adaptation being NSFW, with a link, and there was definitely a fair bit of sexualization/nudity in the half-volume I read of the manga. On the other hand, it's licensed in the US and has seen a release, but I seem to recall it being shrink-wrapped.

@animeg - Aki Sora is no good. It's incest underage porn. Encrypted, you don't have to say anything out loud. I already researched it and it's awful.

"Did anybody invent this stuff on purpose?" - Phillip Marlowe on tequila, Finger Man by Raymond Chandler.

It's censored and technically Ecchi has a plot and everyone is in high school.... The plot itself is the issue, it's mainly about an Angsty Incestious romance between a guy, his older sister, his twin sister, the sister's best friend and more. there are other characters like an exhibitionist but the main story is about the family... Yeah.

It was banned in Tokyo because of the Incest plot and sex in school with it lacking an 18+ label... (yes sex in school was a cited reason... And only one tank was banned but the publishers killed the whole series.)

It's not underage anything.... It has other issues....

edited 21st Apr '12 11:24:03 PM by Raso

Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!

I can confirm that they are in high school, but like Raso said, there are other reasons why this manga would be suspicious.

...There are flat-chested girls at worst. I don't think any girl or boy looks younger than maybe 14.

Full Battle Mode

I'm under the impression that Strike Witches is quite popular and quite rich in its non-sexual aspects, although whether it's more known for the military themes or the lack of pants I do not know.

Should we find it to be unsuitable, that's perhaps one of the definitive grey-area decision I've seen so far, especially if it's sold in mainstream markets. But I don't know much about the series, never read/watched/played(?) any of its releases.

If some fans here want to try to salvage it in case it will be removed, I suggest finding a relatively clean version of it (a comic or something) as a start.

The words above are to be read as if they are narrated by Morgan Freeman.

Well the TV version used Censor Steam and beams which was removed in the DVD release, Funi used the DVD version I think. And that is available to buy in the US and the original TV versions were aired on youtube for 10 hours the day the episode aired.

Their ages are old enough (that I can find), there is no sex, hell there isn't even a guy in the series iirc as its part of the famous all girl cast trend that people claim is destroying anime (K On, A Channel etc.)

Just their combat uniforms lack pants.

Anyway big on the if its licensed in the US it should be very much ok for TV Tropes. (although for some reason Sky Girls by the same artist did not get licensed in the US even though the Fanservice is a lot less than Strike Witches... ages are all appropriate too.)

edited 22nd Apr '12 12:58:44 AM by Raso

Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!

@encrypted: So the question is whether there's a plot to it. (Haven't read, obviously; no intention to.)

Have we put Legal Jailbait up for review yet? At the very least, de-creepification is probably in order.

What's precedent ever done for us?

lu127 said that she would keep it clean. I think so at least.

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman

I've kept the damn thing clean for months, ever since it was in TRS. No pedo-gushing.

I'll rewrite the description in a while.

"If you aren't him, then you apparently got your brain from the same discount retailer, so..." - Fighteer

RE Strike Witches: Would it have killed you to specify what action you are asking for? The 5P isn't just about cutting pages; clean-ups, close watchlisting, and locking are well within their options, too.

Fiat iustitia, et pereat mundus.

I already posted this in the about thread, but perhaps we should make a rule based on ratings to keep out the ridiculous stuff? For example, only +PG 13 or +R for movies, and only +TV 14 +TVMA for Television? I don't know about other ratings systems, but the genres/things without ratings systems are usually the least mainstream, and therefore least likely to be raged about when someone puts them on the list.

Go play Kentucky Route Zero. Now.

I think that topic is for the content policy thread. Holler for an unlock there.

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman