Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / Perdido Street Station

Go To

  • Alternative Character Interpretation: The Construct Council is a great example of this. Is the AI A Crapshoot? Is it a Spock who operates entirely on logic and let Isaac cut off its control of the slake moth trap because it knew it needed his help still? Is it more attached to New Crobuzon and information collecting than it lets on? Since it factors into the ending of the story only indirectly, the answer is left to the reader's imagination. The Weaver gets this too because of its state of mind...
  • Advertisement:
  • Captain Obvious Reveal: What "choice-theft in the second degree" turns out to be. Possibly deliberate, as a way to show that Isaac, for all his intellect, isn't worldly enough to catch on that it's rape.
  • Complete Monster: Even in the hellish setting of New Crobuzon, this duo manages to stand out:
    • Mr. Motley is a powerful crime lord in New Crobuzon whose name befits his grotesque, multi-faced appearance. Mr. Motley regularly presides over assassinations, murders, and torture, with a knack for awful retribution to those who slight him — he's noted to send letters to those whose loved ones he holds ransom, having almost always killed them before he can be paid back. Obsessed with his own image, Motley commissions the Khepri artist Lin to create a statue in his exact likeness, and when he finds out Lin's lover Isaac is responsible for the escape of Motley's slake-moths, Motley kidnaps Lin and tortures her for weeks, possibly even raping her, and sending Lin's severed head-legs in an enclosed envelope to Isaac. Not even Motley's cheerful farce masks the fact that he's one of the most vicious characters even in New Crobuzon.
    • Advertisement:
    • Mayor Bentham Rudgutter is the corrupt head of New Crobuzon, who inflicts horrific punishments on those he deems criminals, having them "Remade" into twisted forms, while also having them tortured or murdered in huge numbers. Secretly behind the murders attributed to the "Eyespy Killer", Rudgutter has dissidents killed, then their eyes harvested to replace his own pair. During the Slake Moth outbreak, he shows no compunction in having many people rounded up and killed, continuing these activities well after, even for rebel leader Jack Half-a-Prayer, with no amount of bloodshed too high to keep his hold on power. Oh, and the nearest thing he has to a "friend" is the handlinger-infested carcass that was once his second-in-command, until Rudgutter had his body usurped for plotting behind his back.
Advertisement:
  • Ho Yay Shadrach and Tansell, the two men in the adventuring party hired by Isaac.
  • Idiot Ball: The first two times characters go up against the slake moths, their otherwise competent plans succeed in getting into position, but fail in in panic and disarray solely because no one thinks to Kill Him Already!.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Yagharek turns out to be a rapist. He is also one of the most decent people in the story, deeply remorseful and has had a pretty terrible life after his (admittedly deserved) punishment. It doesn't get better... it gets far worse. Even though he saved Isaac's lover and helped destroy the slake moths, when Isaac realizes his crime, he abandons poor Yag. He's so broken by Isaac's betrayal that he ends up mutilating his avian body out of shame, tearing out all his feathers, and commits to living in New Crobuzon for the remainder of his life as a man.
  • Moral Event Horizon: Kidnapping an elderly terminal patient and using him as bait to attract the slake-moths is an In-Universe MEH for Derkhan and Isaac. Derkhan comes up with several ways to justify the act, but rejects all of them because she knows there is nothing that can truly excuse what they're doing.
  • Squick: Dear God, anytime they mention Remaking. Especially the woman who has her baby's arms grafted to her face.
  • Tear Jerker: Lin's state by the end. Her human body is half-emaciated, bruised, and broken while her head beetle has had its eye crushed, legs broken, and wings ripped off, with which she used to show her trust to Isaac in the beginning of the novel. Even then, she is still happy to see Isaac after he had forsaken her. Also, Yagharek by the end.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: Meet Lin, hard-working, talented, bitter, dysfunctional, trying to come to terms with her abandonment of her society and culture. Stuffed into a fridge halfway through the story.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: Honestly, the Malignant Plot Tumor that is the slake moths can be seen to have taken away from the perfectly workable story of a scientist and his artist girlfriend trying to make their way in a poor and hostile fantasy world.
  • The Woobie: Nearly everyone will end up this way by the end of the story. This is a law of China Miéville writing.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report