Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help.
It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here. You can also go to this Directory thread
for ongoing cleanup projects.
Ask the Tropers is for:
- • General questions about the wiki, how it works, and how to do things.
- • Reports of problems with wiki articles, or requests for help with wiki articles.
- • Reports of misbehavior or abuse by other tropers.
Ask the Tropers is not for:
- • Help identifying a trope. See TropeFinder.
- • Help identifying a work. See MediaFinder.
- • Asking if a trope example is valid. See the Trope Talk forum.
- • Proposing new tropes. See TropeLaunchPad.
- • Making bug reports. See QueryBugs.
- • Asking for new wiki features. See QueryWishlist.
- • Chatting with other tropers. See our forums.
- • Reporting problems with advertisements. See this forum topic.
- • Reporting issues on the forums. Send a Holler instead.
Ask the Tropers:
resolved Are these examples correct? Videogame
Found this on FireEmblemThreeHouses.Tropes A To D
- All Lesbians Want Kids: If a female Byleth gets a paired ending with Mercedes it is stated that they ended up opening an orphanage and raising many kids together. Byleth also ends up adopting children in her paired ending with Dorothea but only in the Japanese version of the game.
Looking at the trope page, the trope is about various lesbian women who wants to have a kid. This entry simply states that Female Byleth and Mercedes opened an orphanage and becoming mothers to many orphaned children. No mention of them wanting kids. Any other thoughts?
Characters.Fire Emblem Three Houses Adrestian Empire
- Psycho Lesbian: She doesn't express any sort of romantic interest in any of the male characters and has an extreme obsession with Edelgard which goes to the point that she keeps track of every meal that Edelgard has eaten, the amount of times she's sighed, the amount of times she's said Monica's name, or to her chagrin, the names of others compared to her own. Downplayed, as while Monica's obsession with Edelgard is clearly unhealthy she doesn't actually physically hurt anyone over it.
The trope is about a woman is psychotically obsessed with another woman, to the point of actively harming others. As written, Monica sounds more like a lesbian Clingy Jealous Girl than anything.
Edit: The examples are misuse per here and here. Locking as resolved
Edited by Ayumi-chanresolved Specificity of Release Windows for Upcoming Works? Videogame
How specific does a release window for an upcoming game that only has a cutscene trailer need to be? Is a year enough, or do we need the quarter/season/month?
openTrying to recreate a CSP a bit too quickly Videogame
For context: Characters.Trails Series Crow Armbrust was recently merged with Characters.Trails Series Erebonia Thors Class VII Original Part Two ( a page I launched since the main OG Class VII page was getting two long) since Crow's page is not 250k characters long, as per the new CSP policy.
So troper salvadorfranz, has been editing the Characters.Trails Series Erebonia Thors Class VII Original Part Two page (as seen here) to add more things to Crow's folder to make it even longer (the edit reasons stating that the goal is to reach 250k characters). This is kind of sudden, since Crow's page was moved yesterday. Additionally, they are both misusing a few tropes (like Child Prodigy being listed even though Crow is now an adult) and using tropes that more narrative based than character based.
What should we do?
resolved The Elder Scrolls Character Page Splitting Videogame
The character page for The Elder Scrolls: Divine Beings is getting quite large, so I'm looking to split it into "Pre-Creation Entities", "Aedra", "The Tribunal and Dagoth Ur" and "Other Deities".
Additionally, I'm looking to soft-split The Elder Scrolls: Historical Figures into different sections for better categorisation.
I'd just like to know if I need to discuss with others before splitting any character pages, or if I can go right ahead with the edits. How to Split a Page doesn't specify if I need prior permission, but I just want to be sure.
For reference:
The Elder Scrolls: Divine Beings (including pre-existing Daedra sub-pages)
- Pre-Creation Entities
- The Aedra (Nine Divines)
- Daedra
- Daedric Princes
- Lesser Daedra
- The Tribunal and Dagoth Ur
- Other Deities
The Elder Scrolls: Historical Figures
- Cyrodilic Emperors and Regents:
- First Empire:
- Alessia the Slave Queen
- Second Empire:
- Reman Cyrodiil
- The Akaviri Potentates
- Third Empire:
- Tiber Septim
- Pelagius Septim III "the Mad"
- Uriel Septim V
- First Empire:
- Other Historical Figures:
- Merethic Era:
- The Snow Prince
- Topal the Pilot
- Veloth the Pilgrim
- Ysgramor
- First Era:
- Arch-Mage Shalidor
- Dumac Dwarfking
- Frandar Hunding
- Gaiden Shinji
- Indoril Nerevar
- Jurgen Windcaller
- Kagrenac
- Morihaus
- Pelinal Whitestrake
- Second Era:
- Ada'Soom Dir-Kamal
- Vanus Galerion
- Third Era:
- Potema Septim
- Multiple Eras / Unknown Era:
- Iachesis
- Lamae Beolfag
- Orgnum
- Rajhin
- Umaril the Unfeathered
- Wulfharth Ash-King
- Zurin Arctus / The Underking
- Merethic Era:
resolved Can I cut this page if the only entry no longer applies? Videogame
- Keep Circulating the Tapes: As Sarcastic Pasta Games have taken down the DLC in 2020 citing the need to replace multiple assets, this DLC is currently unplayable unless you already have a copy of it.
Except, now that I've checked the creator's page, the DLC is available to download again, by about note (coincidentally, since I just came across this news because of this entry) half a day ago. It's the only entry, can I cut the page?
EDIT: 5 days late, but I just updated the entry per the last reply. Going to lock without bumping. Edited by BlackFaithStar
open(The sort of maybe) Harsher In Hindsight misuse... again Videogame
/TW: abuse/SA mention/
It took me a lot longer to realize, and something I last expected to be misused, but back in December of last, this Genshin Impact example was added to the Video Game sub-page of Harsher:
- Tighnari’s voice lines (at least the original ones done by Elliot Gindi, Tighnari’s original voice actor) in Genshin Impact(specifically, “What are they gonna do, lock me up?”) sting very badly knowing that Gindi had been abusing minors with his status as a voice actor.
Ignoring the fact that this is the only example of Genshin being added to that page at the (the game's YMMV page has a lot of In-Universe Harsher examples), this feels like misuse. While it's true that the line has been memed to death for darkly humorous purposes, if you take the line in context, it's more about him doing courses for the Forest Rangers without permission from the Akademiya and doing such would be considered "dissemination of information" according to Nari - while Gindi was fired for something similar ("breach of contract" according to MiHoYo), nothing from that line implied or insinuated that Tighnari used his power as a teacher to abuse his students (and hypothetically, it will be Out-of-Character for Nari since one of his patients and fellow comrades is a victim of abuse themselves). Furthermore, fans of the character have learned to separate the art from the artist and hate it when you associate that character with their now-disgraced voice actor. Seemingly the closest connection to Nari and his old VA is that the Dramatic Irony between their situations (Nari takes care of abused and disabled child who views him as a brother to her, while Gindi used his fame to abuse minors, some of whom had mental disabilities). I apologize if I may come off as a bit to insensitive in this post, I spent the majority of the day editing the character pages for Black★Rock Shooter.
Edited by ToonAbbyopenPotential LEGO City: Undercover ActorAllusion? Videogame
In LEGO City Undercover, the character Vinnie Pappalardo is voiced by John Guerrasio, who also did voicework as the Brickster in Island Xtreme Stunts. Since both are characters of criminal intent featured in LEGO games, would Guerrasio's role as Vinnie in LCU qualify as an Actor Allusion to his role as the Brickster in IES, or would there need to be a more clear cut Brickster reference in LCU for it to count?
resolved Character folder for Eiko from Street Fighter 2 Pocky Edition Videogame
So I want to make a character page for Eiko from the Advertising game Street Fighter 2 Pocky Edition. And I want to know if it's okay to do so.
Edited by AFanopenShould I crop repeat info from character photo? Videogame
I'm working on the character page for upcoming Edmund McMillen roguelike Mewgenics and I'm finally getting around adding images for the human NPCs, but there's a small problem: The images I'm using came from a pre-release blog post on steam, and in said images, character bios I've already transcribed into the page. Since I'm adding the images now, should i crop the bios out, erase the transcription I've already written there, or just put in the virgin images with repeat information in there?
Edited by ClicketyWhinnyresolved something wrong with the Baldur's gate 3 Origin Characters page? Videogame
Specifically this one. Checking the history of the page or the edit page, i can clearly see there is content here. But when i try to look at the page itself... it's blank.
resolved Very Questionable Troping Videogame
The one-month-old account TNO Enjoyer has been displaying a pattern of bizarre behaviour. I don't have the time to catalogue it all in detail, but it includes and is not limited to:
- Creating the subpage Characters.TNO Legacy Denmark, and an invalid Analysis page for it. The former was cut for duplicating content already on TNO Europe.
- Adding an entry on FanWorks.Hearts Of Iron for "Chronicles Of Elementa", which is described only as an "upcoming mod". This was later removed by another Troper.
- Creating the page "Chronicles Elementa", which was cut as a stub.
- Creating a Characters page for "Elementa Chronicles'', and several sub-pages for it, without a corresponding work page.
- Creating then abandoning the misspelled page "Characters.Chroniclesof Elementa".
- Adding a blank folder to Characters.TNO Misc.
- Creating two more troll stubs, Characters.Revolutionaries, and Revolutionaries.Characters containing only the word "Bruh".
I know absolutely nothing about Hearts of Iron and its clearly extensive fan-work community, but there are no results for "Elementa Chronicles" on Google whosoever, unless you count misspellings of a Minecraft fanwork series named the Elementia Chronicles. I can't tell if this Troper is a troll or vandal, or simply trying to trope their own unpublished mod, in which case it should be on Darth Wiki. In any case, they've made an awful lot of stubs.
Update: I have sent Characters.Chroniclesof Elementa, Characters.Revolutionaries, Revolutionaries.Characters, and Analysis.TNO Legacy Denmark to the Cut List, the former three for being stubs, the latter for namespace misuse. Edited by Azorius24
openVisualNovel/VideoGame split on trope pages. Videogame
If I want to crosswick/add a Visual Novel example in a trope page and it doesn't have a Visual Novels folder or subpage, should I create it myself, or should I put the VN under Video Games?
In the case that the Video Games folder already contains some VNs, is it better to move them to a new Visual Novels folder, or to leave it like that and add my example there?
Edited by animuacidopenDeleting YMMV Videogame
Alley Oop has a tendency to delete YMMV tropes from Xenoblade Chronicles 3 and Xenoblade Chronicles 3: Future Redeemed if they personally disagree with them. I'd hash it out elsewhere but they gave an edit reason that raised an eyebrow.
I don't remember there being a rule about not troping audience reactions allegedly from a specific part of a fanbase. Am I right in thinking that's not the case?
Edited by PresidentBritopenFemale protagonist from P3P Videogame
So I was on the Persona 3 YMMV section and came across this entry, edited by Key Will Jay:
- The female main character herself is rather divisive. Some love her inclusion for providing an interesting "what if" scenario (and with the main theme of Portable being the butterfly effect, this also fits) and for her personality contrasting with the male main character while still keeping the "masking feelings" theme. They may also like how some of the less interesting Social Links get replaced with S.E.E.S. members. Others see her as unnecessary and believe she ruins the game's themes of overcoming despair and accepting death with said alternate scenario and personality, and dislike how SEES is made obviously friendlier in her route (a criticism fans of older titles sometimes level at newer titles in general). The memes and exposure surrounding her also induce Hype Backlash for non-fans and those that have played the console version but do not try Portable, calling her overrated. It was bad enough that when an alleged lead regarding a theoretical remake mentioned cutting out Portable content (which turned to be reality per the reveal of Reload), the fanbase split between those calling it a worst-case scenario and those celebrating the removal.
I’m not as active in the fandom but do people really fight over the female protagonist? Because I’ve never seen much divide over her. In fact, I’ve only seen people express their disappointment of her being excluded from Reload.
Edited by Superdude96openCookie Clicker Characters Videogame
there is at least two characters in cookie clicker that are not NPC,and those are the Baker (it has no name or face...maybe)and the Grandmatriarchs. should i make a characters tag for them?
openEdit War Videogame
Back in January I touched up Extremis Ultimis, including commenting out a ZCE. Today, Infamous Empire uncommented the ZCE without expanding it. I sent them a ZCE notifier, but I cannot comment out the ZCE again (because that would be an Edit War) nor can I expand it (I am not familiar with the mod in question).
openWhy Vivienne from Dragon Age Inquisition doesn´t count as a Defrosting Ice Queen? Videogame
Even as a downplayed version, since we can be her friend. Also, I found interesting that Sugar and Ice personality was added in that trope page and with Vivienne as a exemple. Do you think writting that trope on her page in DAI makes sense?
Edited by TabsopenAssPull example re-added without discussion Videogame
I originally had brought the example of Ass Pull on YMMV.Star Wars Jedi Survivor regarding Bode being a traitor and his true nature up on the "Is This An Example" thread, pointing out that it had extensive foreshadowing listed on the main page. So it was decided to be removed.
Now, Chris116 is has re-added it without discussion, saying that only his identity as a former Jedi is the Ass Pull, when the foreshadowing entries also mentioned the hints in the story for this as well.
I don't want to incur in an edit war so I'm bringing this in here.
Edited by matruz
Context: Shin Megami Tensei V`s Updated Re-release, Vengeance, was originally planned to release on June 21, 2024 before being moved up to June 14. This lead to people speculating that it was intentionally moved as to avoid competing with Elden Ring`s highly anticipated Shadow of the Erdtree DLC.
With that in mind, SMTV's Trivia page mentions this speculation twice (along the line of "leading fans to speculate"). I'm not sure this is allowed, but I want to make sure.
Here are the entries in question:
- Dueling Games: Shin Megami Tensei V: Vengeance was originally to be released on the same day as Elden Ring's highly anticipated Shadow of the Erdtree DLC expansion. When Atlus announced that Vengeance would release a week earlier, people speculated that Atlus wanted to avoid this.
- Release Date Change: Vengeance was meant to be released Worldwide on June 21st of 2024, but nearly a month after its announcement, Atlus announced that it would release a week earlier, with fans speculating that this was to avoid competition from Elden Ring's expansion.
Edited by Ayumi-chan