Charity Motivation Song
There are some big problems in the world, and this song is here to remind you that you really ought to be doing something about them, with vivid descriptions of the problem and a call to action. Often the recourse of artists who feel like they should be using their worldwide fame to make a positive impact on the big problems faced by charitable organizations — or in other cases, just a powerful subject for a good song.
A more cynical potential motivation that's often suggested/joked about is that the performers don't care as much (if at all) about the cause in question as they are about the goodwill this can engender with the public and press.
Don't be surprised if the music video has a number you can call to donate today, or if the publisher elects to donate a portion of all album proceeds to a relevant charity. Also a popular choice for commercials soliciting charitable donations. This type of song was particularly popular in The '80s
, when it was common to round up whole choruses of name musicians to sing one song in support of a cause; the hammy, earnest performances that often result can be Snark Bait
. In fact, it may be on the verge of becoming a Discredited Trope
: Todd in the Shadows
pointed out in his review of the 2010 "We Are the World" remake that it was hard to take the whole production seriously since the original had been so often parodied after its release in 1985.
Compare Protest Song
, which is generally a specific protest against some specific event or practice and is more about social or political change than encouraging participation in existing charity work.
- Michael Jackson has "Heal the World", "Man In The Mirror", and (to some extent) "Earth Song".
- Phil Collins: "Another Day in Paradise", "Colors", and "Long Long Way to Go"
- Genesis: "Land of Confusion" (the climax of the video, which features Spitting Image puppets, parodies the "all-star choir" concept with one made up of celebrity caricatures).
- Expose: "Tell Me Why".
- Declan Galbraith: "Tell Me Why" (different song from Expose's).
- Black Eyed Peas' "Where Is The Love?" and its Flight of the Conchords parody "Think About It".
- "Charity" from Peter Schickele's Go For Broke.
- "Do They Know It's Christmas?", co-written by Bob Geldof (of Boomtown Rats) and Midge Ure (of Ultravox) and originally performed by Band Aid, was the first of the "Charity Supergroup" songs. Two remakes, though less popular than the original, both took the Christmas #1 slots for 1989 and 2004 (the latter was the last non-X-Factor Christmas #1 until 2009), while a third in 2014 may prove that there's still a little life left in the charity supergroup.
- "We Are The World", which followed on from Band Aid's success, and likewise sought to help.
- "Hands Across America" came from the same writers as "We Are the World".
- Elvis Presley: "In the Ghetto".
- Bruce Hornsby and the Range: "The Way It Is".
- In France, the charity Les Restaurants du Coeur, which gives food to the needy, is indissociable of the song and concerts from the sort-of band Les Enfoirés (lit. "The Bastards").
- The Onion's A.V. Club took a snarky look at these with the Inventory list "14 Overblown Charity/Advocacy Songs Besides 'We Are the World'".
- "Room In Your Heart" is a song performed by Beaker and Dr Honeydew as they try to get Scrooge to donate to charity in The Muppet Christmas Carol. It was cut from the actual movie (and wasn't even filmed), but does appear on the soundtrack album.
- At the first Comic Relief USA benefit show in 1986, "Weird Al" Yankovic and Richard Belzer performed an original rap song, "Cut the Grief with Comic Relief", that humorously approached the topic of helping the homeless.
- Loreena McKennitt's "Breaking the Silence" for Amnesty International.
- "Tears are Not Enough", by Northern Lights, Canada's response to "We Are The World".
- "Stars", by Hear 'n Aid, Heavy Metal's response to "We Are The World" (which didn't enlist metal performers for its all-star chorus).
- "Doctor in Distress", by Who Cares?, a supergroup of mid-level celebrities unsuccessfully trying to save the original run of Doctor Who. (The profits actually went to cancer research.)
- There are several notable examples in Country Music:
- "Tomorrow's World" (1990), a multi-artist single honoring the 20th anniversary of Earth Day. Notable for being co-written by Kix Brooks before he gained fame as one-half of Brooks & Dunn. The artists on the song were Lynn Anderson, Butch Baker, Shane Barmby, Billy Hill, Suzy Bogguss, Kix Brooks, T. Graham Brown, the Burch Sisters, Holly Dunn, Foster & Lloyd, Vince Gill, William Lee Golden (then-recently fired from The Oak Ridge Boys), Highway 101, Shelby Lynne, Johnny Rodriguez, Dan Seals, Les Taylor, Pam Tillis, Mac Wiseman, and Kevin Welch.
- "Hope" (1996), honoring the T.J. Martell Foundation for cancer research. It featured John Berry, Terri Clark, Vince Gill, Faith Hill, Tracy Lawrence, Little Texas, Neal McCoy, Tim McGraw, Lorrie Morgan, Marty Stuart, Travis Tritt, and Trisha Yearwood.
- "What If", by Reba McEntire in 1997. Money made by the single went to the Salvation Army.
- "One Heart at a Time" (1998), a charity single for cystic fibrosis. It featured Garth Brooks, Billy Dean, Faith Hill, Neal McCoy, Michael McDonald, Olivia Newton-John, the song's composer Victoria Shaw, and Bryan White.
- Garth's own "We Shall Be Free" is also an example. It's also a benevolent Protest Song.
- "Self Destruction" by the Stop The Violence Movement. Headed by KRS-One, the song featured many New York-based rappers addressing rampant black-on-black violence in big cities.
- West Coast rappers responded with their own multi-rapper collaboration "We're All In The Same Gang", which had the same premise only it centered on gang violence.
- Artists United Against Apartheid's "Sun City", organized by Steve Van Zant of The E Street Band, combines the charity supergroup style of Band-Aid and USA for Africa with a Protest Song; the assembled rock and rap stars pledged, via the song's lyrics, not to perform at segregationist South African resorts like Sun City, as they believed that doing so would be tantamount to accepting what the apartheid regime was doing.
- "Voices That Care", organized by record producer David Foster, featured a group of actors, singers and athletes supporting the American troops fighting in the 1991 Gulf War, which happened to end on the very day the song's video released. The profits were given to the International Red Cross.
- Subverted: the 1997 all-star remake of Lou Reed's "Perfect Day" wasn't originally intended as a charity single, but it was well-received enough to be released as one anyway. Proceeds went to Children in Need.
- Kirk Franklin's Nu Nation Project is a Charity Motivation Album, created to benefit the congregations of churches lost in fires. Its lead single "Lean On Me" (an original composition, not the Bill Withers song) featured solos by Bono, Mary J. Blige, R. Kelly and Crystal Lewis; a remix included as a Hidden Track added the voices of En Vogue, New Edition, K-Ci and Jojo, Divine, Boyz II Men, Dru Hill, Xscape and Destiny's Child.
- Bob Dylan's Christmas in the Heart isn't directly about a charity cause, but the earnings of the album went directly to charity.
- The Glee cover of "Last Christmas" has similar origins, as it was originally released as a benefit for the Grammy Awards' music education programs (and a year before their Christmas Episode, no less).
- The entire album Diana, Princess of Wales: Tribute counts as this as it was assembled and released mere months after Diana's sudden death, and proceeds went to a fund established in her memory. Curiously absent from the release is Elton John's "Candle In The Wind 1997/Something About The Way You Look Tonight", also released to benefit the fund, which is the last charity single ever to top the American singles chart (the 2010 "We Are The World" came close, peaking at #2).
- Being a fictional 1980s pop band Jem And The Holograms has a few of these. "People Who Care" is their most popular. Their rival band, The Misfits, avidly hates these types of songs and generally hates how Jem always sings about romance and The Power of Friendship.
- Echo Der Mädchen by the Swiss Artists for Unicef is unique in that it is not at all schmaltzy or glurgy in any form and diminishes any call-to-action in its lyrics. It's mainly just a Tear Jerker.
- Chumbawamba released a filk of "Let It Be" under the pseudonym of "Scab Aid," a parody of The Beatles's work with Ferry Aid. It featured such lyrics as:
This manufactured sympathy, drowing in hypocrisy
Smiles to clinch the deals to boost the sales
All the owners of the printing presses
And popstars crying phony tears
Nothing bleeds like the hearts of the millionaires
For the charts and the state machine
Consumers of the world agree
Nothing sells like disaster, let it be
- "We're Sending Our Love Down the Well" from The Simpsons's episode "Radio Bart", which featured Krusty the Clown, his good friend Sting, and a host of Springfield-associated luminaries such as Sideshow Mel and the Capital City Goofball.
- Saturday Night Live had two cold openings spoof these. Recurring characters of the period, led by Frankenstein's Monster (Phil Hartman), sang "Fire Bad!" in response to the Rodney King riots of 1992. When Michael Jordan first retired from basketball in 1993, the cast spoofed such acts as the B-52s and The Proclaimers with a medley of their hits rewritten to beg him to return to the sport; the real Aerosmith pitched in with a "Dream On" rewrite.
- They also did a parody of the new version of We Are The World and its overproduction: Amongst the group were Rihanna, Lady Gaga, Adam Lambert, and Willie Nelson with others
- Another parody used the format (one of the singers was Jerry Garcia, played by Chris Farley), but the subject of the song was explaining the intricacies of Clinton's Whitewater scandal, so it was less charity-driven and more Public Service Announcement-driven.
- And ANOTHER one, but this time with Michael Bolton and cast for a special cause, Musicians for Free-Range Chickens, produced in part by "Whoopi Goldberg" (played by Chris Rock).
- An In Living Color! parody of "We Are the World" featured the cast as musicians who were either has-beens (i.e. Yoko Ono) or struggling with financial problems at the time (Willie Nelson); the song was asking the listeners to support them.
- The video for Pulp's "Bad Cover Version" is a parody of the "Do They Know It's Christmas" video, featuring celebrity impersonators of noted musicians performing the song.
- "Do They Know It's Hallowe'en" by North American Hallowe'en Prevention Initiative, a one-off Super Group featuring Win Butler and Régine Chassagne, Feist, Beck, Karen O, Russell Mael, and Thurston Moore, among many others. Oddly enough, it's both a parody of charity singles and an actual charity single itself: All proceeds went to UNICEF.
- On 30 Rock, Jack has a brilliant idea to record a generic charity song to have in readiness for the next natural disaster to scoop the other networks. Jenna touchingly sings "That thing that happened/was so sad/we can't believe it was so bad/when the stuff we know occurred..." Unfortunately they air it hurriedly on news of the devastation of a small island that turns out to be Mel Gibson's vacation compound.
- "We Are the Children of the World" from Terry Gilliam's The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus. It's the theme tune of a charity that supports children in third world countries; after all, their organs are ripe for harvesting for the benefit of wealthy Westerners.
- "Sue All the World" from Napster Bad, featuring Metallica, Eminem, Dr. Dre, Madonna, Elton John, Nutty McShithead and Sheryl Crow.
- "Radi-Aid" is a Norwegian parody of this, mocking simplistic and patronising charity appeals for "pathetic Africans" by urging Africans to donate radiators to help freezing children in Norway.
- Wag The Dog features a brief USA For Africa parody called "American Dream", staged by the White House spin-doctor to drum up support for a non-existent war against Albania, just before the election.
- Brüno ends with the titular Camp Gay organizing an all-star charity song for...well, any worthy cause will suit his needs; the song is really about how awesome Bruno is. Features appearances by Elton John, Snoop Dogg, Bono, Slash, and Chris Martin!
- "Weird Al" Yankovic's "Don't Download This Song", mocking Digital Piracy Is Evil.
- Garnet and Gure: This animated short ends with a "We Are the World" parody, entreating listeners to help wipe out the zombie virus.
- The Film Renegado ended his fourth anniversary special with "Don't You Know It's Ad-Blocker?"
- Spitting Image spoofed "We Are The World" and "Do They Know Its Christmas" in 1985 with "We're Scared Of Geldof", where it is implied that most of the people gathered to sing for charity are only there because they are terrified of saying no to Bob Geldof.
We're scared of Bob, we're really frightened
And every time we hear that Irish voice our sphincters all get tightened!
- The music video of The Ramones "I Want Something To Believe In" also spoofs charity singles.
- Sonny with a Chance once had a "We Are The World"-esque ensemble number about skinny pants syndrome (i.e. loss of blood flow in the legs due to wearing ridiculously tight pants).
- Straddling the line between parody and an actual Charity Motivation Song is Brett Dommino's "How to Make a Hit Charity Single." While it makes fun of the tropes in these types of songs forwards and backwards, it actually was used to raise money for Comic Relief.
Brett Domino: So we need the lyrics to say "donate your money to Comic Relief" without literally saying those words.
Steven Peavis: Unless...we do literally say those words.